In an underworld where every debt is paid in blood, the only thing more dangerous than surviving the cage is surrendering to the man who owns it.
BrookGrief cost Brook everything, forcing her to rebuild her shattered life behind the velvet curtains of Halo. Guarded and fiercely independent, she swore no man would ever control her again. But when her best friend tricks her into self-defence lessons with a man who can't even look at her, it becomes a game of who will break first. As his violent world bleeds into hers, wanting him becomes a dangerous addiction she cannot escape.
RhysFor over a decade, Rhys has bled in illegal cages, used as a weapon bound to the Reaper to keep his best friend alive. Survival meant staying cold and untouched. That is until he meets Brook. Sharp-tongued, defiant, and intoxicating, training her shatters his control and sparks a ruthless obsession. With one final, brutal fight standing between Rhys and freedom, the stakes turn deadly and the odds change. Reaper owns his blood, but Rhys will burn the underworld to the ground before he lets anyone touch her.
💌 ੭﹕ ❝ there's a difference between doing something because you want to and doing it because you have no other choice. Not every bad decision makes you a bad person. Sometimes, what looks like a choice from the outside is nothing more than survival from the inside, and the hardest part isn't living with what you've done. It's learning to live with who you had to become to do❞
I am not exaggerating when I say 'this book changed the trajectory of my life.' After I finished this book, I looked at the wall and thought now what? Louise Steel did such a good job with Rhys and Brook. I love both of them with my whole heart. This book made me feel like I am now another person after reading it. Every character is so dear to me and I am officially their defence attorney. Rhys is my top man and Brook is my top woman. I am going to protect them with my whole life. Louise's writing style captured the vulnerabilities of both the mcs so well that i felt like I am with them especially Rhys. I am glad to announce Louise is my go to author for new releases. The book was long with 600+ pages and it was worth every word, every page, every second of my life. Every chapter was able to capture the rawness, vulnerabilities, weakness of mcs and I felt so heartbroken reading them. I was able to feel every emotion which I never felt before. I was able to get reality hit on most of the emotions I felt like never existed in me. This book made me feel everything. I am not mad about the cliffhanger but I am mad that I have to wait for next book. Now onto the characters.
Rhys Holloway 𓂃 ࣪˖ ִֶ♱ I would like to thank Louise for bringing Rhys to life. She did a great job with Rhys. I felt like the book was more driven towards Rhys and I am not complaining I loved every part of him. He was vulnerable and helpless and I was able to feel it through the book. His every decision, choice to stay with Theo and not giving up on him was not settling up with me but when I got more into the book I was able to understand it. He had no choice, no one to turn to, no one to protect him. His friendship with Logan was so touching and moving that I fell in love with Logan too. Their relationship started with stubbornness and from then on it got stronger with time. Rhys' backstory was tragic and I just wanted to protect him throughout the book. He lost his mom at a young age and did everything a good son was supposed to do. He tried his best. He had every reason to turn in a bad person but he never did and turned out to be the best friend and best person for his dear ones. The walls he created around himself, needing to protect everyone, trying to fix everyone around him and not depending on anyone resonated with me because that's how I am. The way he fought for everyone with his life was impressive and I have immense respect for Rhys.
Brook Hale . ݁⋆ ꫂ᭪ ݁˖ . ݁ Brook was strong, independent, fiery, stubborn and I loved every part of her. She taught me thar people not telling us know anything for our sake is also a form of control and it is our choice to stay away or stay with people after listening to it. I never thought of it in this way. She suffered a lot and used it as her shield by taking control of her life and making every decision. I resonated with her because she was also afraid of trying new things. I felt like I am reading about myself. She never backed up and stood strong and also never let a man dictate her life. She created clear boundaries by saying she has the right to take her own decisions. Her friendship with libby was admirable and I want to see more of it. If libby and Logan get their own separate book, I will be on cloud nine. I was impressed when she stood by Rhys without a second thought and helped him with whatever it takes.
Rhys and Brook ₊˚⊹ ᢉ𐭩 They are the perfect couple who are made for each other. The burn was perfect in the book. I hate it when the relationship starts with them lusting towards each other and they start growing feelings after having their first time. That is a relationship based on lust. But here it was not that. Their relationship was based on their vulnerabilities, stubbornness and fire. They cared for each other and understood the other person while noticing things everyone misses. They both were so sharp and observant and It made me love them more. Rhys doing anything to protect Brook and Brook doing everything to make Rhys a human. They were perfect for each other. Brook knew what Rhys wanted and she made it possible for him every time. I loved how the book was not only about the mcs but about side characters also. When Rhys felt like he was dying, he thought about every person starting from his mom, theo, logan and then brook. He didn't miss a single person and this was the detail louise added which made me love the book more. There are two I can't take out of my mind. 1) The date Rhys planned for Brook in the old gym. It was so sweet and a break from everything in their lives. It was perfect along with the slow dance. 2) Brook coming to meet Rhys before the big fight when he needed her the most especially the red thread she gave him. It was the reason Rhys stood up even after injuries and won.
The book ended on a happy yet sad note with Rhys winning the fight but ending up with major injuries which might be life threatening but I am not complaining because if book would have ended with Rhys winning the match and everything going normal, it would have felt rushed. I got an excuse to read more about them in the book two. I want book two now!!!!!
I hope we get to see more of Libby and Logan and infact I need their separate books.
Thanks Louise for bringing this masterpiece to life. XO
﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌﹌ ── .✦ 𝒑𝒓𝒆-𝒓𝒆𝒂𝒅 Finally got the arc!!!! This is a long one with 600+ pages. I am a big fan of reading about vulnerable characters. I got so bored of reading about rich x poor. This book is such a breath of fresh air with cage fighter mmc and dancer fmc. I hope I like it so much that they become one of my favs.
Two weeks after finishing this Book, I’m still emotionally devastated. That’s a sign of the compelling impact Louise’s writing, and her ability to show genuine, gut wrenching, beautiful and lasting emotion.
Rhys & Brook have found their way into the very core of my being, and though this isn’t the end of their story, I can’t help but feel like I’m grieving two people I actually know. I felt everything they went through, the pain, the love, the laughter.
I can’t bring myself to listen to “The Night We Met” or “Work Song”. When a writer tells you to listen to certain songs when reading a particular chapter… do it. They really were nothing but perfection, granted the tears and sobs came. Again, that just shows the choices Louise made, were so well thought out.
The way Louise left me feeling afterwards, even now, weeks on, has me both terrified and eager for Part Two.
I feel incredibly lucky to have been given the opportunity to ARC read this unbelievably, beautiful, piece of work. Trust me when I say, you will want to devour ‘Beneath The Surface’ when it releases on the 27th November 🖤.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Had the opportunity to ARC read this and it didn’t disappoint! From the first chapter i HAD to know what was going to happen. I need book two RIGHT NOW
I genuinely cannot put into words how much this book has impacted me. Saying that it changed the course of my life might sound dramatic, but I mean every single word. The moment I finished reading, I found myself staring at the wall, wondering what I was supposed to do with myself now that their story had temporarily come to an end. Louise you have done something incredibly special with Rhys and Brook, and I don’t think I will ever be able to stop loving these two. They have found such a permanent place in my heart that I am officially their biggest supporter and, if necessary, their defence attorney. Rhys is my favourite man, Brook is my favourite woman, and I will defend both of them with literally everything I have.
Louise’s ability to portray the emotional depth and fragility of her characters is something I deeply admire. Her writing made me feel as though I was experiencing everything alongside them, especially when it came to Rhys (my baby omg) 😭 I didn’t just read about their pain, fears, struggles and happiness, I felt them. By the time I reached the end, I genuinely felt like a different person. This was more than just a reading experience. It made me reflect on emotions, experiences and parts of myself that I had never really acknowledged before.
Now, let me talk about the characters who completely stole my heart.🥹🥹
Rhys Holloway
First of all, a huge thank you to Louise for creating Rhys Holloway. I don’t think I have ever wanted to protect a fictional character as desperately as I wanted to protect him. (No joke) The story gave considerable attention to his perspective, and honestly, I wouldn’t have wanted it any other way. I loved getting to know every layer of him, including the parts he desperately tried to hide, I just wanna give him a big hug and tell him everything will be okay 😭😭
Rhys was someone who carried far more than he should have had to. He was vulnerable, lost, emotionally exhausted and constantly trying to find a way to keep everything and everyone around him from falling apart. Some of his decisions, particularly his choice to remain with Theo and never give up on him, initially frustrated me. I couldn’t understand why he continued putting himself through so much. But as his story unfolded, everything started making sense….. He wasn’t someone who had the luxury of choosing freely. He had very few options, nowhere safe to turn and nobody he could rely on to protect him.
His friendship with Logan was another highlight for me. I ABSOLUTELY loved the two of them. What began with stubbornness gradually developed into something incredibly meaningful. Watching their bond grow stronger throughout the story was heartwarming, and I ended up becoming just as attached to Logan. Their friendship was one of those relationships that reminded me how important it is to have someone who genuinely stands beside you.
Rhys’s past really broke me. Losing his mother at such a young age and having to grow up carrying responsibilities that no child should have to bear was heartbreaking. Despite everything life put him through, he never allowed his circumstances to turn him into a cruel or bitter person. He kept trying, kept caring and kept showing up for the people he loved. He had every reason to become someone completely different, yet he remained one of the most selfless and genuine people in the story.
What I really liked was his constant need to protect everyone. He built walls around himself, convinced that he had to handle everything alone. He wanted to fix the people around him, carry their burdens and make sure they were okay, even when he was barely holding himself together. He struggled to depend on anyone because he was so accustomed to being the person everyone else depended on. I saw so much of myself in that part of him, and perhaps that is why his character affected me as deeply as it did.
Brook Hale is the kind of female character I will happily admire forever. Strong-willed, independent, outspoken, fiery and wonderfully stubborn, she was everything I wanted her to be and so much more. I loved how she refused to let her circumstances define her or allow anyone else to make decisions on her behalf.
One of the biggest things I took away from her character was the realisation that withholding information from someone under the excuse of protecting them can also be a form of control. Just because someone claims to have your best interests at heart doesn’t mean they get to decide what you should know or what choices you should make. Ultimately, it is your decision whether to stay or walk away once you know the truth. I had never looked at things quite that way before, and Brook’s perspective genuinely made me reconsider a lot.
She had endured so much, yet she found a way to turn her pain into strength. Taking control of her own life and making her own choices became her way of protecting herself. At the same time, I loved that she wasn’t portrayed as someone without fears or insecurities. Her hesitation towards unfamiliar experiences and her fear of stepping into the unknown made her feel incredibly human. There were so many moments when I felt as though I was reading about myself rather than a fictional character.
Her friendship with Libby was literally everything I absolutely adore their bond and it deserves so much more attention, and I would genuinely love to see it explored further. In fact, if Louise decides to give Libby and Logan their own separate stories, I will be the happiest reader alive.
And I cannot possibly finish this review without mentioning the song Louise used during the last chapter…. The night we met by Lord Huron?! Because WHAT WAS THAT?! That was the final blow. I was sitting on the train, listening to it, and suddenly found myself crying my eyes out. I genuinely wasn’t prepared for how much that song would affect me, especially after everything these characters had been through. I am not someone who cries easily while reading, but this book managed to break that part of me. In fact, this is only the second book that has ever made me cry like that. The song, the memories of their journey and the emotions attached to that particular moment were simply too much. I don’t think Louise understands what she has done to me with this book. I will never be able to hear that song without thinking about Rhys and Brook again. 😭
Thank you Louise for writing such a beautiful story😭🥹 and thank you for letting me be apart of it. I can’t wait to read what you’ve got next 🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Louise Steel, what the actual fuck was that ending?!
I genuinely don’t know what to do with myself after finishing this book. I was hooked from start to finish and that cliffhanger had me immediately messaging Louise practically begging her to tell me if there was more to come.
Rhys absolutely broke my heart. He’s a cage fighter being forced to work for an absolutely vile man, all while carrying so much trauma and grief from losing his mum to addiction when he was younger. There’s so much more to him than his tough exterior and I just wanted to give the man a bloody hug. He’s spent so long carrying everything on his own and my heart genuinely hurt for him.
And Brook?! WHAT A WOMAN. Honestly, one of my favourite FMCs. She’s feisty, fiery, stubborn and gives as good as she gets. I absolutely loved her character development, especially watching her go from fighting with her words to learning how to fight with her fists as Rhys teaches her self-defence. She never loses that fire and I loved her for it.
Now, the slow burn between these two. MY GOD.
The banter, the back and forth, the TENSION. They bounce off each other so well and I was eating up every interaction. But fucking hell, I needed them to JUST KISS ALREADY. The chemistry was unreal and I loved how their connection developed.
Libby is quite literally the best friend we all need. I adored her. And LOGAN?! THAT IS A GOOD MAN. His friendship with Rhys was one of my favourite parts. Rhys deserves someone like him in his corner.
Also, can someone please tell me how Theo is doing?! Because I am DESPERATE to know.
What really got me with this book was how much I cared about everyone. Their friendships, their pasts, everything they were going through. There was so much more to the story than just the romance, and I was just as invested in the plot as I was in Rhys and Brook. I genuinely didn’t want to put it down.
The characters, the slow burn, the friendships, the tension. I loved every bloody minute of it.
Louise, I hope you know what you’ve done to me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
First things first - thank you so much to Louise for allowing me to ARC read this book. I had an absolutely brilliant time with this!
This was a PHENOMENAL read. A big 5-star from me! The characters, the pacing, the plot, the tension - it was so well executed that I didn't want to put this book down. Right from the start, I fell in love with the characters and really got a good feel for who they were. The way that Louise tells a story feels so incredibly cinematic; it's like there was a movie playing in my head while I was reading each line - I could see it all playing out like I was fully immersed in their world.
I know it's quite a long book, yet I found the pacing on point. There was so much suspense, great build-up, and where do I even begin with the tension between Rhys and Brook?! The plot was insane, and I don't think I've ever read a book quite like it. It was so well thought out; every little detail was leading up to this incredible crescendo. There was never a dull moment in this book - something was always happening.
Louise also added some songs to accompany certain chapters, letting the reader know exactly when they're being played - incorporating them into the storyline. I know listening to music and reading is not for everyone, but I genuinely think it elevated my experience for those particular chapters. I loved that it was only specific chapters too; the songs were carefully picked for the maximum emotional damage or suspense build-up.
This was an absolutely fantastic book, and I genuinely cannot rave about it enough - I am so grateful I got to experience this, and I think I'm going to have a minor book hangover for a while after this.
ARC review This review is 100% my own thoughts and feelings and is not impacted by the author.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️
This book completely stole my heart! 🥹 Rhys and Brook are what dreams are made of! ❤️
First off — huge thank you to Louise for bringing this story to life, this book has consumed my thoughts even after I turned the last page.
🩷 hate to love 💚 forced proximity ❤️ grumpy x sunshine 🩵 he falls first 🧡 touch her and die
Rhys Holloway — oh my poor heart! He was so vulnerable, and I truly felt every bit of it right through the pages. Choosing to stay with Theo, refusing to give up on him — the deeper I read, the more I understood him. His friendship with Logan? Absolute perfection — it started with stubbornness and just grew stronger, it was so touching. His backstory broke me — losing his mum so young, doing everything right… he had every reason to turn bitter, but he never did. Those walls he built around himself, always protecting everyone else?
Brook Hale — strong, fiery, stubborn and completely unforgettable. She definitely brought us a new meaning to keeping things from people "for their own good" is still a form of control, and it's our choice what we do next. She turned all her pain into strength and never let anyone dictate her life — especially not a man! Her friendship with Libby was wonderful, and when she stood by Rhys without a second thought? Chef's kiss. 🙌
I also loved that the side characters got just as much depth too — Libby, Logan, Theo — they all felt like people I actually know. The moment Rhys thought of everyone he loved when he thought he was dying?
Theos fact Brook gave him something very special before he went into that last fight and that's what kept him going even when he was broken. I cried. 😭 what an absolutely heartbreaking ending I need to know what happens!
“You’re not here to fix what was broken” “you are the life I was trying to survive long enough to find”
Another AMAZING book from the wonderful Louise Steel💜
I was lucky enough to be selected to receive an ARC copy of this book.
All comments and ratings are my own honest opinions.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 🌶️🌶️🌶️
This is a slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers, forced-proximity story following Brook, a badass dancer, and Rhys, an equally badass cage fighter.
I absolutely LOVED their dynamic from the very beginning and watching how their relationship developed throughout the story. I was completely hooked! The plot was PLOTTING! I loved the drama, the tension and all the moral dilemmas woven throughout.
The themes explored in this book really intrigued me. The romance isn’t the only focus, which I absolutely loved. You’re given the opportunity to fall in love with multiple characters, follow several different storylines and get to know the side characters just as much as the main ones. It adds so much depth to the story!
As most of you know, I do love to dabble in a good ol’ spicy book, and I was NOT disappointed! 🌶️ Most of the spice happens in the second half of the book, but the build-up and tension between Rhys and Brook are absolutely captivating.
It was actually really refreshing to read a book that didn’t dive straight into the spice. I usually find myself getting a little impatient with slow burns, but this one had me completely invested from start to finish. The anticipation was SO worth it!
My heart HURTS after reading this! 😭 Definitely make sure you listen to the last song while reading the final chapter. Trust me, it adds a whole other level of tension and makes it hurt that little bit more! 😂😭
This is officially my favourite book Louise has written to date, and I cannot WAIT to see how book two continues the story! 💜
First, I want to thank Louise Steel and whimsy after dark pr for the gifted eARC of Beneath The Surface to read and provide my honest, spoiler free review.
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
My Thoughts: Oh my gosh….i literally just finished this story and trying to form my thoughts as I’m writing this review. I have been completely glued to my phone all day reading this book. Louise Steel managed to suck me into the world that was created centering around Rhys and Brook.
Brook was such a strong FMC to admire. Being through a really tough and brutal situation just made me feel for her in so many ways. I couldn’t help but get this overwhelming sense of pride with her, especially if she was willing to do what it takes to learn self defense to protect herself. Even when Rhys pushed her buttons and didn’t treat her like a fragile person, I loved her energy and her stubbornness that matched with Rhys.
Rhys was also another character that definitely pulled at my heartstrings. Everything that he carried on his shoulders by himself was insane and so heavy that I’m surprised he survived by himself for as long as he did. The epitome of doing whatever it takes to protect the people he cares about the most, even if it costs his life or his basic humanity. There was so much that I didn’t expect about his life but learning everything just broke my heart into pieces. His protective qualities were outstanding and I loved seeing him protect Brook the way he did.
I loved the found family dynamics in this book as well. Rhys, Brook, Logan, Libby and even Theo just made the ultimate family bond. It was beautiful seeing them together and the way they were willing to help Theo and also help Rhys with the mess that he was involved in. I enjoyed every single part of this book and I cannot wait for other readers to have a chance to experience this book for themselves.
Firstly, thank you SO much to Louise for writing this. For letting me ARC read it and for being you in general.
I was expecting to like this book, I wasn’t expecting it to consume me the way it did. I laughed, I cried, I didn’t want it to end. This is the kind of all consuming read I was really craving and dare I say, touched a little space in me that hadn’t been touched since reading Edge of Darkness. There’s really similar vibes here. 🖤
She’s a dancer, he’s a fighter. She’s confident and makes her presence known, his presence is lurking and powerful. And? He’s really just not into it…yet. What’s not to love.
Our MMC is complex, difficult at times, and has a delicious bad boy persona. However, he has the weight of the world on his shoulders, responsibilities nobody should have to bare, and his pain is so palpable it was heart breaking. Something so real and raw. He’s not JUST the “bad boy”. His development was amazing.
Our FMC is a blast. Sassy, witty, confident but the ability to see and soothe the pain in others. Honestly, I’d want to be her friend. She had me actually laughing out loud. (I had to message Louise mid giggle session) She’s the calm to his storm.
Their development from annoyance, through the tension, the loathing to the pure want and need for each other was a journey I loved. And the way this was written was beautiful. I LOVE a good slow burn and this was done OH SO FKIN RIGHT.
The ending of this had me screaming, crying, throwing up. The build up to it too was great, you learn you’re never TRULY safe.
This was honestly one of my higher rated reads of this year. So well done Louise. And thank you a million times over for writing something so amazing. 🖤
There’s so much banter, and it had me laughing. Brooks is THAT girl. I love an FMC who’s strong, fierce, spicy, full of attitude and isn’t afraid to stand her ground, and she gives exactly that.
And Rhys… UGH. I feel for this man. Yes, he’s grumpy and has his walls up, but once you get past them, he’s so incredibly sweet. The protective, touch-her-and-die energy? I absolutely loved it.
One thing I really enjoyed was the found family aspect with Libby and her brother Logan. Those two are genuinely the sweetest. The way they take care of each other and how Logan looks out for Rhys made me love them even more. They’re all just magnificent together.
Now, let’s talk about the slow burn because when I say SLOWWWW, I mean SLOW. We’re talking over halfway through the book and they’ve barely almost kissed. 😂 But I promise you, the wait is worth it. And when the spice finally comes? It’s THERE. Trust me.
And THAT ending?! I was curling my toes, holding my breath and genuinely struggling to breathe. I was not prepared for that.
Everything about this book was worth the wait. I loved the characters, the banter, the found family, the tension and the slow burn. Louise Steel, you have me counting down the days until book two because I NEED MORE OF RHYS AND BROOKS.
But I’m also genuinely scared. I know book two is a non-HEA, and after getting so attached to these characters, I don’t know how I’m supposed to handle what’s coming. I’ve fallen in love with Rhys and Brooks, and the thought of what they might have to go through already hurts my heart. Louise, please be gentle with them… and with us, because I don’t think I’m ready. 😭🖤
5 stars, and I’m already emotionally preparing myself for book two.
Okay I have almost 24 hours to process reading Beneath the Surface and OMG I don’t even know where to begin.
Firstly, I would like to say a massive thank you to Louise for giving me the opportunity to ARC read. This has been one of my most anticipated reads for the year and it did not disappoint (side note - I am so proud of Louise for writing such an amazing story).
Reading this book was a rollercoaster ride of emotions, I cried on the bus, I stared at the walls, I giggled and laughed all before bursting into tears. The amount of times I had to stop reading because I was unable to see due to the amount of crying just made the book have even more of an impact on me.
Trust me when I say, you will want to read more and never stop straight after chapter 1.
The characters: Beneath the Surface follows Brook & Rhys. Brook is an ex nurse (really don’t blame her there) who is currently working at club, and living with her best friend. Rhys is a fighter, he has been dealt many shitty cards and is now trying to repay the debts of a friend. The way their relationship builds throughout the book is just heart warming and heart breaking at the same time. It gave enemies to lovers vibes, grumpy x sunshine vibes and whole lot of slow burn.
The side characters really stuck with me throughout this book, Libby (Brooks best friend) who in my opinion was sassy and I loved her for it. Logan (Libby’s brother and one of Rhys’s best friend?) who was always there no matter what the situation, and Theo (Rhys’s best friend) his story broke me.
I truly adored this book and I can’t wait for book 2!!
Book 2 required immediately!!! That ending … i still haven’t processed my feelings for that yet 🫠
Firstly, i would like to say a massive thank you to Louise for allowing me to read this book as an ARC 🤍
The first thing i really enjoyed about this book as the simple fact that it was set in Manchester, UK! Sounds daft i know, but when places were being referenced, it was nice to actually know where they were for once 😂
Rhys was a very troubled MMC that has built his life around survival, and learning how to carry everyone’s problems on his shoulders. He seems very grumpy and unapproachable, but he’s built his walls so high that no one else has the chance to leave. My heart bled for him at times, because no one should ever have to carry all of that alone.
Brook was a feisty redhead, who’s been through her own share of trauma & heartbreak, and still came out swinging! She takes one look at Rhys and refuses to back down, even though everyone else usually does.
The story progressed perfectly and i loved seeing the walls crumble and the tension build in real time. They both learnt it’s okay to lean on someone else, and seeing them become each other’s important person was incredible.
The book went through so many twists & turns that i genuinely couldn’t even anticipate what was going to happen next. The plot, the tension, the chemistry, the found family… all of it made this a perfect read!!
Theo, Logan & Libby were also the perfect side characters, and i cannot wait to see more of them in the next book!
A perfect hate to love, forced proximity, grumpy x sunshine dark romance read 🖤
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I adored Brook, Rhys, Logan, and Libby. Their found-family friendship, ride-or-die attitude, and sheer loyalty to one another are everything. Rhys is a truly complex and incredible MMC, with ultimate sexy bad-boy vibes (that one chapter 👻🥵🥵🥵 hunnnaiii), but his trauma and the invisible collar around his neck are heartbreaking. The side jobs had me shook. And Brook is astounding! Grounded and strong, I love a stubborn lil FMC.
Theo! I was so caught off guard by how much I ended up caring about him, purely because of Rhys. The character development and likability are unreal because, despite feeling like Theo wasn’t really there, Steel still had me feeling so emotional! 😭
The first half... the tension, the yearning, the drama, the intensity. Holy sh*t. And then the story takes an even harder turn, leaving you with nothing but uncertainty and ALL the emotions. The plot development and the way the darker, heavier themes were handled were so well written.
I was just not ready. Recovery time is needed.
Devoured within 24 hrs *goddammit work* and kept me awake until 3am.
Good work Steel! 👌
Thank you WhimsyWordsPr for an eARC in exchange for an honest review
I was addicted to this from start to finish. One of them books you just don’t want to put down. The build up of tension between Rhys and Brooke made me want to crawl out of my skin but in the best way. It was a living being I could feel growing chapter by chapter.
Rhys had so much to carry and he was trying to do it all alone for all those years. I genuinely don’t know how he was functioning day to day. Brooke was such a strong and independent FMC. I’m itching to know what happened between her and Joe, why do I have a feeling that wont be the last we hear from him.
Libby.. everyone needs a best friend like Libby! She was there for everything and asked all the right questions.
I absolutely loved the writing style of the author. Everything felt so immersive and that I was right there inside these characters. Addictive from start to finish.
I cant wait for Reaper to have his smug little face rearranged. He’s far too cocky and confident for my liking.
THE ENDING. I was on the verge of tears falling. My eyes held them and didn’t let them fall but believe me they was there. Internally I was screaming NO! I need book 2 yesterday. The second i finished the book I had to contact the author to demand answers and tell her I wont survive it.
I was very lucky to receive this read as an ARC read and all opinions are given voluntarily and are my own.
I don't even know where to start... Every chapter, every moment, I was totally obsessed and it was so hard to put down the book for sleep, for work...... I always keep notes when I read.. I didn't have time for that shit reading this book. It paralyzed me completely.
The storytelling is amazing. The pacing is smooth and solid with events, with the past, with the characters. Every detail I want and need is there.
Rhys, Brooke, Logan and Libby - what a fucking crew, the love they share for each other, still with the bickering makes me love them even more.
From the beginning there is definitely no love between Rhys and Brook though.. but the hostility slowly unravels and OMG... This is real. The emotions and the feelings. This is written by someone who knows. Louise makes me believe so. It's deep and unfiltered and it's raw.
This is literally taking me beneath the surface of the world she built. Beneath the skin and bones of the characters. I can se the damage, the mental states, the walls they built, the hurt, the spiraling... I wish I could be there to help them up, from the deep black hole, to let them breathe over the surface...
But as my fingers are bleeding from the anxious biting of how the fuck this is going to end, my tears are falling as I stare at the last sentence.... I feel so utterly fucked.
The ratings above are at this point in time and may not be applicable depending on changes made prior to publication.
Louise does an incredible job of writing a beautiful story about substance misuse and how it affects everyone in relation to the abuser.
Not only that, but Louise does a stunning job of writing an enemies-to-lover romance that is different to the majority of dark romance themed books on the market today.
The dynamics between all of characters is perfection with found family and sisterhood really hitting home. Thai is the type of book that sets a precedence for people you should surround yourself with.
Louise could not change a thing in this book and not take on any of my suggestions and it would still be a resounding 5-star read. I laughed hard, I cried harder. I cannot wait for part two!
It was an honour to alpha read this. Thank you so much for trusting me with your work and for giving me the opportunity to scream at you via google docs 🤣❤️
WOW! What can I say?! 🤭🔥 I was absolutely hooked from the moment I started and ended up finishing it within 24 hours!
Miss Steel, your writing has come such a long way, and the growth is genuinely incredible to see. From the character development and attention to detail to the pacing and the way the entire story builds, everything was just chef’s kiss! 🤌🏻❤️
The way you’ve brought this story to life and portrayed everything was absolutely spot on. Your creativity, imagination and technical ability have truly shone through in this book, and you should be so proud of what you’ve created. It’s amazing to see how much your writing has developed, and this book really showcases just how far you’ve come.
I honestly couldn’t be prouder of you! 🥹❤️ You’ve absolutely smashed it with this one, and I can’t wait to see what you come up with next.
A massive well done, Miss Steel! You deserve every bit of praise for this one! 👏🏻🔥❤️
BRING ON BOOK 2!! 👀🔥 And P.S… HURRRYYY UP!! 🤣🫣❤️ I NEED MORE! 😭📚
Some books pull you in, some completely consume you, and then there’s Beneath the Surface… the kind of book that grabs you by the heart, puts you through every emotion possible and leaves you staring at the pages afterwards wondering how you’re supposed to move on. 🥹🖤
Louise, what the hell have you done to me?! This book had me hooked, emotionally invested and feeling ALL the things. The characters, the tension, the emotions and the moments that hit harder than I was prepared for made this such an unforgettable read.
I wasn’t just reading their story; I was feeling every moment alongside them. There were moments that broke my heart, moments that had me smiling and moments that reminded me exactly why I adore getting lost in a good book.
Louise, you’ve absolutely smashed it. A well-deserved five stars from me! ❤️
Some stories don’t just get read… they get felt. And this one? I felt every single bit of it and I even went as far as to message Louise my thoughts on the ending which I won’t repeat but it’s very rare that I cry as I’m soulless and this brought tears to my eyes!😭
Brook and Rhys completely stole my heart. Their chemistry, the tension, the banter and the slow development of their relationship had me hooked. I loved watching two people that carry so much hurt slowly let their walls down and find something special in each other.
Rhys especially had my heart. Beneath that tough exterior is someone who feels everything so deeply and would do absolutely anything for the people he loves. Brook is such a strong, fiery character, and I loved that she never lost herself along the way. I also loved how much depth was given to the supporting characters. The friendships, loyalty, found family and the difficult themes throughout the story made it so much more than just a romance.
The emotional rollercoaster, the tension and the twists kept me invested, and that ending... HOW could you leave us like that?!
Louise darling, you should be so proud of this one. Now please I need book two because I am NOT ready to say goodbye to Brook and Rhys! 🤍
This book has sooo much grit and depth, I don't know how I'm going to write a short review here, because I have SO much I need to unpack 😅
Rhys as an MMC is just 🤌🏻 cage fighter who's been wrapped up in a criminal enterprise for too long to get out safely. The only way to keep his loved ones safe is to continue doing whatever Reaper asks of him...
Brook is an exotic dancer who needs some self defense lessons... I bet you can see what happens here 👀
The characters are so well written you can just feel every moment and the plot just got thicker the more I read! This whole story is thought out so thoroughly that I genuinely don't think I can pick out ANYTHING I didn't like!
This will genuinely have you riding an emotional rollercoaster though so trust me, make sure you're ready to cry 🥺
✨This is a DARK romance, so check your trigger warnings!✨
First of all, a huge thank you to Louise Steel for letting me both alpha read and arc read this book.
And let me tell you: Beneath The Surface has become my comfort read. I never get tired of reading this masterpiece of a book. I’ve lost count on how many times I’ve read it already, and I’m not tired of it one bit.
I love the characters, all the emotions, the setting. Well I love it all, well not Reaper and his gang, but you get what I mean.
Brook is this strong woman, with a past. But she is so strong and badass, I love her.
Rhys I think is this misunderstood guy, that cares more than you know. He’s just tired.
I don’t want to spoil anything, but you will smile, and you will definitely cry. It’s THAT good.
The book started off kind of slow for me. I’m fully aware it’s a slow burner before people come at me. I just felt the pace was a tad too slow for my liking. I got interested later on in the book, then it was gone again. At that point it was time to DNF. It’s written really well and I’m sure there are a lot more readers who love this story. Unfortunately, I didn’t make that team.
If you are into the slow burners, witty banter (which I loved), and a lot of emotional trauma? This book is for you and I recommended you do give it a go.
I want to thanks the author for sending me an advanced readers copy.
This book honestly shocked the hell out of me! I knew I would enjoy it, however I didn’t think I would enjoy it as much as I did. I was grateful to receive this as an Arc and I would 100% recommend everyone to read it.
Louise is so incredibly talented and she definitely smashed it out of the park with this one! The writing was so beautifully done it had me staring at the wall in silence for 30 minutes after finishing.
I honestly don’t think there is even one small thing I would change about this book which says a lot in itself considering the size.
OMG!! Louise, why did you have to break me like that? This is one of the best enemies to lovers I've ever read, she did this perfectly and really left you wanting more. As someone who has an addict in her family, this really hit home on how it affects others, not just the addict, and you did this amazingly Louise. The chemistry that builds between Rhys and Brook is just amazing. I need more and absolutely cannot wait for the second part.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book! Rhys was by far my favourite character! I loved seeing him develop from beginning to end! The way he went from hard as nails and moody to really opening up was phenomenal! Louise can for sure write an mmc!! I can’t wait for book two (which will hopefully heal me from book one’s trauma) I absolutely recommend ♥️
You wanna know how this book for me is a 6 star book? I finished it over a week ago and I still think about it often. It’s the first book I’ve ever read by Louise and her writing is fantastic. It’s gripping, it’s emotional , it’s definitely going to linger with you long after you finish it.
Beneath the surface was an incredible rollercoaster of a journey. Rhys stole the show for him, my heart bled and ahem… raced whenever he was there on page. I think Louise has done an amazing job when writing about very hard topics (Theo’s story). I cannot wait for the second and I will devour it as I have devoured this!