1871, Eagle Harbor, Michigan
Tessa had been the daughter of a lighthouse keeper. She saw too many shipwrecks and family deaths due to this dangerous occupation, and if she never set foot in another lighthouse it would be too soon. Escaping her past poor choices and ruined reputation, Tessa finds a teaching position in a mining village on the shore of upper Michigan.
Alex Bjorklund was the most handsome man Tessa had ever seen, saving her three times in the space of a few minutes. First he rescues her from several crude ship crewmen who accosted her wanting a kiss, then the next moment he pulled her out of the water she just fell in. Then, as he's helping her find room and board, he saves her from the lecherous Mr. Updegraff who insisted she stay at his home which he shares with his housekeeper, who, rumor has it, is his mistress.
As a single female teacher in a mining town, she had to guard her reputation by staying clear of even the appearance of anything inappropriate, which meant staying away from men. But Alex had the most beautiful, mesmerizing, captivating eyes she was drowning in... (all her adjectives). Plus she couldn't keep from "staring at the muscles of his bronze chest", "perfectly chiseled"..."a beautiful specimen of manhood"... ogling in front of children...(yes, again, all this coming from her).
But for someone cautious of impropriety, we read that she and Alex took an evening stroll up by the mines and...
"He angled so that his lips brushed against her cheek"....
"he pressed a kiss against the hollow part of her ear"....
"tilting her head and giving him access to more of her neck."
With flashbacks later of how good his touch felt.
They were interrupted by a 15 year old girl and a boy coming out of a mine building right next to them...
"Their faces were flushed, their hair and clothes askew. The boy had been doing a lot more than kissing Josie."
Josie (the 15 year old) threatened that if Tessa told on her, she would spill about how their teacher and Alex were kissing in the woods.
Ugh
Again she was threatened by Mr. Updegraff (the man who hired her, who acted like king of the town) that she must be above reproach. However...
"Halfway through town she stopped abruptly at the sight of Percival Updegraff exiting one of the miner cabins in the process of buttoning his pants. His coat and vest were askew, his shirt only half tucked in."....
"Was she, (Hannah) a married woman, having an affair with Percival behind her husband’s back?"... Seeing her class assistant (Hannah) the next day she asks...
“Does he force himself on you?” ...
"Finally she said, “If I don’t do what he wants, he’ll not only fire my husband but he’ll make sure Mr. Nance never gets another mining job.”
Tessa decides to keep these incidents to herself. Mind you, the 15 year old girl was her landlady's daughter, and Percival Updegraff was apparently using his power to take advantage of any woman he wanted.
But she says nothing!
Ugh.
At this point (at about 40%) I was so disillusioned I nearly quit reading this book. But I kept on, hoping it would redeem itself.
There were about 4 tragedies to keep the story interesting I suppose. But much of the book was a love triangle (Tessa/Alex/Michael, his brother), including flirting and ridiculous arguments about which one she really loved...then the wretched Perceval Updegraff pressured her for her "favors". The the final blow came when Alex and Michael are framed for setting fire to the town's food supply warehouse, and Tessa's past being found out, consequently getting fired.
Ugh.
Although I liked the fun banter between Alex and Tessa, and she seemed to be a fairly upright and caring young woman who was determined to keep her reputation pure, she kept ping-ponging back and forth, mooning over Alex, then denying her feelings saying she can't love him and she would never spend her life with a lighthouse keeper (which he and his brother both were). For someone careful with inappropriate appearances, she kept putting herself in compromising situations knowing full well she was being spied on and reported daily.
As much as so many people loved this book, I could not see it, and can't give it more than three stars...and I'm really not sure why I'm giving it even that high of a rating. This was simply not Jody-Hedlund-worthy, in my estimation. I've enjoyed so many of her books, but this? Sadly this was not my favorite.