What do you think?
Rate this book
Family Fletcher #2
The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island
Love the TV show Modern Family ? Wait until you meet the family Fletcher! With two dads, four adopted brothers, two cats, and one pug, the Fletchers will have you laughing out loud!
Welcome to Rock Island, Where Time Stands Still!
The Fletchers are back on Rock Island, home of all their best summer memories. But from the first day they arrive, it’s clear that this year, things have changed. FIRST, a giant fence is blocking their beloved lighthouse. SECOND, they have new neighbors. THIRD, who the heck is the weird artist guy who's never actually painting? And FOURTH, there's now an ice cream truck! Can the island stay the same even with these crazy transformations?
Over the course of the summer, the Fletchers will learn that sometimes, even in a place where time stands still, the wildest, weirdest, and most wonderful surprises await.
A JLG Selection!
"There is constant action and delightful humor, but there are also realistic present-day problems and happy solutions. An old-fashioned summer adventure set in a very modern world, this lively family tale will leave readers impatient for more. "-- Kirkus, Starred
"While the other story lines reach satisfying resolutions, this one— about a young African American male struggling to figure out his identity in the largely white landscape of Rock Island—leaves room for thought-provoking, timely discussion.-- Horn Book
"A must-have middle grade family story with contemporary sensibilities."-- SLJ, Starred
"Lots of kids will want to take this along on their summer vacations."-- Booklist
Welcome to Rock Island, Where Time Stands Still!
The Fletchers are back on Rock Island, home of all their best summer memories. But from the first day they arrive, it’s clear that this year, things have changed. FIRST, a giant fence is blocking their beloved lighthouse. SECOND, they have new neighbors. THIRD, who the heck is the weird artist guy who's never actually painting? And FOURTH, there's now an ice cream truck! Can the island stay the same even with these crazy transformations?
Over the course of the summer, the Fletchers will learn that sometimes, even in a place where time stands still, the wildest, weirdest, and most wonderful surprises await.
A JLG Selection!
"There is constant action and delightful humor, but there are also realistic present-day problems and happy solutions. An old-fashioned summer adventure set in a very modern world, this lively family tale will leave readers impatient for more. "-- Kirkus, Starred
"While the other story lines reach satisfying resolutions, this one— about a young African American male struggling to figure out his identity in the largely white landscape of Rock Island—leaves room for thought-provoking, timely discussion.-- Horn Book
"A must-have middle grade family story with contemporary sensibilities."-- SLJ, Starred
"Lots of kids will want to take this along on their summer vacations."-- Booklist
259 pages, Hardcover
First published May 10, 2016
21 people are currently reading
359 people want to read
About the author
Dana Alison Levy
10 books116 followersDana Alison Levy was raised by pirates but escaped at a young age and went on to earn a degree in aeronautics and puppetry. Actually, that’s not true—she just likes to make things up. That’s why she always wanted to write books. She was born and raised in New England and studied English literature before going to graduate school for business. While there is value in all learning, had she known she would end up writing for a living, she might not have struggled through all those statistics and finance classes. The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher is her first published novel, but she has a trunk full of other attempts, which vary in degrees of awfulness.
Her first book for young adults, Above All Else, comes out in October 2020. In addition to The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher, she has also written The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island, This Would Make a Good Story, and It Wasn't me. All her books have garnered starred reviews, multiple Best Of lists and state reading lists, and are Junior Library Guild selections. Also her kids like them.
Her first book for young adults, Above All Else, comes out in October 2020. In addition to The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher, she has also written The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island, This Would Make a Good Story, and It Wasn't me. All her books have garnered starred reviews, multiple Best Of lists and state reading lists, and are Junior Library Guild selections. Also her kids like them.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews
Read
April 5, 2016Well, as with The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher, I wrote this book, which either makes me a very good person to review it, or a terribly bad one.
But here's the thing: I loved writing this book. I've heard horror stories from authors struggling to find their path in a sequel, and I was nervous. Nervous that Sam, Jax, Eli, and Frog wouldn't let me in, that Rock Island would somehow refuse to share its secrets with me, that newcomers Alex and Val would be dull and boring. But oh, was it fun to write! (Mostly. In all honesty it gave me a few struggles along the way, but that's to be expected with four boys, two dads, and a boatload of shenanigans.)
Anyway, I wanted to write a story about what summers can be, what we dream them to be, and what, sometimes, if we are really lucky, they are. The Fletchers are really lucky...they have Rock Island, a magical haven in a busy world. But even there, time can't stand still. And I knew the boys would have to face new realities, because the truth is, even when we are lucky, even when summer is magical and perfect, life shifts and moves along. Sometimes these changes are for the better. Sometimes they're not. But to me, the joy of telling a story includes the ability to write, in my mind at least, "and they all lived happily ever after," and (SPOILER ALERT), the Fletchers do.
I hope you enjoy reading The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island as much as I enjoyed writing it. I hope your summer includes some perfect days, whether they are sandy and salt-licked on a beach, or all jazz and dripping ice cream on a lively street corner, or chlorine and blue popsicle tongue and cannonballs off the diving board at the local pool. Enjoy every minute...because as much as we may want it to, time never really stands still.
But here's the thing: I loved writing this book. I've heard horror stories from authors struggling to find their path in a sequel, and I was nervous. Nervous that Sam, Jax, Eli, and Frog wouldn't let me in, that Rock Island would somehow refuse to share its secrets with me, that newcomers Alex and Val would be dull and boring. But oh, was it fun to write! (Mostly. In all honesty it gave me a few struggles along the way, but that's to be expected with four boys, two dads, and a boatload of shenanigans.)
Anyway, I wanted to write a story about what summers can be, what we dream them to be, and what, sometimes, if we are really lucky, they are. The Fletchers are really lucky...they have Rock Island, a magical haven in a busy world. But even there, time can't stand still. And I knew the boys would have to face new realities, because the truth is, even when we are lucky, even when summer is magical and perfect, life shifts and moves along. Sometimes these changes are for the better. Sometimes they're not. But to me, the joy of telling a story includes the ability to write, in my mind at least, "and they all lived happily ever after," and (SPOILER ALERT), the Fletchers do.
I hope you enjoy reading The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island as much as I enjoyed writing it. I hope your summer includes some perfect days, whether they are sandy and salt-licked on a beach, or all jazz and dripping ice cream on a lively street corner, or chlorine and blue popsicle tongue and cannonballs off the diving board at the local pool. Enjoy every minute...because as much as we may want it to, time never really stands still.
December 1, 2015
Full disclosure: I am a HUGE fan of The Fletchers!!! Finding it impossible to wait for May 2016, I managed to snag an advance readers copy which I devoured in one sitting.
And... THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND did not disappoint! This sequel is every bit as endearing and crazy and funny and uplifting as the first book - maybe even more so. The Fletchers have packed up the whole family and most of the assorted pets for their annual summer vacation on Rock Island, a place where time stands still. Only this year, changes abound, and most of them are not happy ones.
Like the first Fletcher book, fabulous details make this story come alive with brilliant family chaos. Each boy's voice and story is completely distinct and compelling, and each has his own goals and challenges during their month on Rock Island. Though they also set out on a common goal - to save their beloved lighthouse - and after being thwarted by obstacle after obstacle, they find the help they need in a very surprising way.
As wonderful as it is to spend time with beloved characters, THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND is much more than "The Fletcher Family, continued." In this story, Dana Alison Levy shows us not only how much they've each matured and grown, but she also digs deeper, particularly around issues that were introduced in the first book, such as gender and race.
I wholeheartedly recommend THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND to anyone and everyone. Long live the Fletchers!
And... THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND did not disappoint! This sequel is every bit as endearing and crazy and funny and uplifting as the first book - maybe even more so. The Fletchers have packed up the whole family and most of the assorted pets for their annual summer vacation on Rock Island, a place where time stands still. Only this year, changes abound, and most of them are not happy ones.
Like the first Fletcher book, fabulous details make this story come alive with brilliant family chaos. Each boy's voice and story is completely distinct and compelling, and each has his own goals and challenges during their month on Rock Island. Though they also set out on a common goal - to save their beloved lighthouse - and after being thwarted by obstacle after obstacle, they find the help they need in a very surprising way.
As wonderful as it is to spend time with beloved characters, THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND is much more than "The Fletcher Family, continued." In this story, Dana Alison Levy shows us not only how much they've each matured and grown, but she also digs deeper, particularly around issues that were introduced in the first book, such as gender and race.
I wholeheartedly recommend THE FAMILY FLETCHER TAKES ROCK ISLAND to anyone and everyone. Long live the Fletchers!
March 26, 2022
The Fletcher family - Dad, Papa, Sam, Jax, Eli, and Frog... as well as pet cats and dog - return in this second middle-grade novel devoted to their adventures. Heading to Rock Island, where they have always spent their Augusts swimming and surfing, the Fletcher brothers are dismayed to discover that this summer holiday will be a little different than that of previous years. To begin with, the lighthouse right next to their cottage, where they are used to playing, has been fenced off, and might be in danger of being demolished. Then there's the Galindo children, who are spending some time at the nearest cottage to the Fletcher's own, and who at first seem rather annoying. Fortunately the Fletcher boys soon discover that their neighbors are good friends, whilst also realizing that the artist intent on buying (and possibly destroying) the lighthouse is not. Can the Fletchers and Galindos do anything to stop him...?
A lighthearted summer read with some serious moments as well, The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island is an engaging follow-up to its predecessor, The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher . Levy delivers an amusing and believable family story here, revisiting all of the main characters from her first book (save neighbor Mr. Nelson), and adding a few new ones. I continue to think that she ably captures the different perspectives of her four boy protagonists, and appreciate the fact that the Fletchers' status as a family with same-sex parents is not the narrative focus, but just one characteristic of this non-traditional but nevertheless perfectly normal family. I also appreciate that the realities of racism, something not addressed in the first novel, do intrude in this story, as Jax (who is African-American) and his friend Alex (Latino) are misjudged because of the color of their skin. Given that the Fletchers are a multiracial family, it stands to reason that the prejudice of the wider society will eventually be a factor in their lives. Levy does a good job emphasizing the damaging aftereffects of being treated poorly by a bigot - Jax continues to feel terrible about the incident - but doesn't let that one element of the story take over. All in all, this was a very readable sequel, and more than enough to convince me to read the next Family Fletcher story, should one be forthcoming.
A lighthearted summer read with some serious moments as well, The Family Fletcher Takes Rock Island is an engaging follow-up to its predecessor, The Misadventures of the Family Fletcher . Levy delivers an amusing and believable family story here, revisiting all of the main characters from her first book (save neighbor Mr. Nelson), and adding a few new ones. I continue to think that she ably captures the different perspectives of her four boy protagonists, and appreciate the fact that the Fletchers' status as a family with same-sex parents is not the narrative focus, but just one characteristic of this non-traditional but nevertheless perfectly normal family. I also appreciate that the realities of racism, something not addressed in the first novel, do intrude in this story, as Jax (who is African-American) and his friend Alex (Latino) are misjudged because of the color of their skin. Given that the Fletchers are a multiracial family, it stands to reason that the prejudice of the wider society will eventually be a factor in their lives. Levy does a good job emphasizing the damaging aftereffects of being treated poorly by a bigot - Jax continues to feel terrible about the incident - but doesn't let that one element of the story take over. All in all, this was a very readable sequel, and more than enough to convince me to read the next Family Fletcher story, should one be forthcoming.
May 29, 2016
A really solid sequel about a loveable family. In this volume, the Family Fletcher spends August at their beloved vacation home on Rock Island, Maine. Although the boys look forward to doing the same summer things they always do, some things have changed on the island. Notably, the abandoned lighthouse next door has been fenced off and is being sold to a suspicious artist who claims that he was injured while inside the lighthouse. Can the Fletchers figure out what's going on and save the lighthouse they love so much?
Frog tries to teach their cats to swim, Eli faces his fear of kayaking, Jax makes a new friend to play soccer with, and Sam joins the cast of A Midsummer Night's Dream in this pitch perfect summer romp.
Shove this into the hands of every Penderwicks fan you know!
Frog tries to teach their cats to swim, Eli faces his fear of kayaking, Jax makes a new friend to play soccer with, and Sam joins the cast of A Midsummer Night's Dream in this pitch perfect summer romp.
Shove this into the hands of every Penderwicks fan you know!
June 17, 2016
The family Fletcher is charming, and their diversity is great. Summer mysteries always have appeal. I appreciated a family dealing forthrightly with the homogenous nature of an east coast seaside resort. I didn't even mind the slightly clunky introduction of issues. Not that I don't think discrimination is real, just that in this case I thought the racial bias incident didn't feel natural. I think the youngest Fletcher, Frog, is adorable and am a fan of the Garcia sisters, especially Alex. For all that the book deserves four stars. What I didn't love was the stereotypes of the bad businessman. In many ways the character development of the 'bad' characters reminded me of the crude villains that used to appear in Nancy Drew or the Hardy Boys. I feel at this point in time all you have to say in a children's book is 'white male businessman' and a thrill of fear will run through the crowd as a hiss of opprobrium escapes the reader's lips. Can we think of any adult male character who works in 'business' who isn't a two dimensional bad guy? Also what makes it ok to rightly castigate a bad (white male businessman) for making assumptions based on appearance, but it is totally fine for Sam to decide someone isn't worthy because they wear stupid boat shoes and bright green shorts? (Btw I personally hate boat shoes and do acknowledge that one character is an adult and another is a child, but still.)
February 25, 2018
Sure it's got a message about families coming in all sorts of flavors, but more importantly, it's a fun story. I do wish there were occasional drawings to help us remember which character was which, or that my library system had the first book so I could have read that first, but by the end I definitely knew who was who and I loved them all.
Except the two fathers... somehow it's harder, at least for me, to keep track of Papa and Dad instead of Mom and Dad, because we're (I was) wired/raised to put that gender tag on people as a clue to their identity. Enlightening experience to read this, even for me, a queer feminist myself.
Except the two fathers... somehow it's harder, at least for me, to keep track of Papa and Dad instead of Mom and Dad, because we're (I was) wired/raised to put that gender tag on people as a clue to their identity. Enlightening experience to read this, even for me, a queer feminist myself.
July 27, 2015
The Fletcher family is back and spending the summer on a New England island where each boy has his own conflict to work through in typical fun Fletcher fashion. I adored book one so, so much and I may have loved this one even a smidgen more!!
July 25, 2021
This one didn’t hold my interest as well as the first one. I preferred their everyday school-year lives to this save-the-lighthouse plot. But it was still nice to spend time with this family again. And still a great book for young readers.
May 17, 2016
This is the second book in the Family Fletcher series and once again it is a treat to spend time with this dynamic family. This time they head to Rock Island, a place where Papa has been coming since he was a child. Rock Island is a small place where things are always the same. There is the same lighthouse, the same flavors of ice cream, and the same tiny house where all of the boys share a loft filled with beds. This year though, some things have changed. There is a fence around the lighthouse, so no one can visit it. A new family has moved in next door too, though they seem to be very annoying. The brothers themselves are also changing and heading in different directions for the first time on the island. Though one thing unites them all, the question of what is really happening to their beloved lighthouse.
Levy has once again written such a readable book. The Fletcher family is made up of gay parents and four adopted siblings of different races. Yet this series is not about growing up in a diverse and gay family, rather it is about a merry and very human family that is a joy to spend time with. The brothers all treat one another like siblings, meaning they fight, they apologize, they inadvertently hurt one another’s feelings. This series is about a real family, one that comes to life on the page.
Levy does deal very sensitively about race in this book. The scene is handled beautifully where at first readers will not realize what is going on, so their own understanding progresses at the same rate as the young characters who soon realize they are dealing with a bigoted bully. The issue is not minimized, but the family comes together to support their brother as he discovers the harshness of direct racism for the first time.
Smart and very funny, this novel for young people adds a winning second book to a series I hope continues for some time. Appropriate for ages 8-11.
Levy has once again written such a readable book. The Fletcher family is made up of gay parents and four adopted siblings of different races. Yet this series is not about growing up in a diverse and gay family, rather it is about a merry and very human family that is a joy to spend time with. The brothers all treat one another like siblings, meaning they fight, they apologize, they inadvertently hurt one another’s feelings. This series is about a real family, one that comes to life on the page.
Levy does deal very sensitively about race in this book. The scene is handled beautifully where at first readers will not realize what is going on, so their own understanding progresses at the same rate as the young characters who soon realize they are dealing with a bigoted bully. The issue is not minimized, but the family comes together to support their brother as he discovers the harshness of direct racism for the first time.
Smart and very funny, this novel for young people adds a winning second book to a series I hope continues for some time. Appropriate for ages 8-11.
August 17, 2016
Sam, Eli, Jax, Frog and their two dads are back for another rollicking adventure. This time they're on their way to the family's summer cottage on Rock Island. The boys have been coming here as long as they can remember, and they are looking forward to the usual beach time, exploring the lighthouse next door, and feasting on chowder at their favorite local restaurant. But from the very beginning, things are different. Their beloved lighthouse is fenced in, with a "no trespassing" sign, and no one seems to want to give them a straight answer about what's going on. And for the first time, there are neighbors next door, when the boys are used to having the beach to themselves. Even worse, there are annoying girls among them - girls who keep giggling about how cute Sam is and making a scene everywhere they go. Will the Fletchers be able to save their summer - and the lighthouse? A follow up that isn't quite as strong as the first one, but this book is still filled with love, laughter and a wonderful family.
September 8, 2016
Fun, if a bit slower and less engaging than the first (though I will note that this actually perfectly captures the feel of summer during childhood. It seems to stretch on forever, and then suddenly without warning, it's done). Primary quality of this series seems to be authenticity: the characters not all being cishet/white never feels like its pushing an agenda, it just is natural and totally normal. Now this is obviously done purposefully, but I'm all for the message of diversity here and Levy pulls it off in a very positive and organic way; the method of delivery with the Fletcher parents being different from their kids goes a long way in making this not feel forced. It's never preachy even if it does preach - and if you throw out all the political stuff (which you know the target audience is going to), then this is just a cute and fun family story.
Long live the Family Fletcher.
Long live the Family Fletcher.
August 29, 2016
The fabulous Fletchers are back, this time spending the month of August at their family summer home on Rock Island. The boys have been looking forward to the summer, but as soon as they get there they find that there are many changes. The lighthouse next door, which they think of as their own, has a fence around it with a Do Not Enter sign. The usually empty house next door has a family living in it. Nothing feels quite right. As the summer progresses, they find their way, each with changes of their own. A perfect book for summer -- or in the middle of the winter when the summer feels so far away... Recommended for fans of the first book and the Penderwicks, grades 3 & up.
Kudos to Ms. Levy for the way she tackles issues of race and racism in the book! It is not a major plot point, but an important one that was worth addressing.
Kudos to Ms. Levy for the way she tackles issues of race and racism in the book! It is not a major plot point, but an important one that was worth addressing.
October 4, 2023
The Fletcher family can't wait to visit Rock Island for their summer vacation. Rock Island is a paradise where nothing ever changes. Frog wants to teach their cat how to swim, Eli is eager to see seals but not so keen on learning to kayak out to the island where they live. Sam and Jax just want to play soccer, and hang out at the beach. Woohoo! Summer on Rock Island. Where everything stays the same! Until this year, that is. First they discover the abandoned lighthouse where they love to play has been chained off! Reportedly an artist wants to buy it and was injured while setting up to paint inside. What will happen to the lighthouse? The Fletcher boys are determined to save it and keep it open for everyone. Then, they meet some new neighbors. The Galindo kids live nearby, in their family's summer home they've never been to. The younger Galindo, Alex, is cool. Alex is around Jax's age and loves soccer, snakes and other creepy crawlies. Alex's older sister, Val, however, is totally annoying, especially when she's with her friend Janie! Girls. Mysterious and gross. Without Janie, however, Val is kind of cool even if she's always recording their most embarrassing moments. With the Galindos around, the Fletcher boys start to drift apart but the one thing all 6 children agree on is that the artist, Kark, is up to no good. Can they prove it in time to save the lighthouse?
This is another adorable entry in the canon of plausible kidlit. I still dislike the excessive use of the slang word "sick" because it dates the story a lot but their summer adventures are timeless. What New England kid didn't grow up exploring tidepools, catching hermit crabs and horseshoe crabs, collecting shells and swimming in the ocean? Rock Island felt very old-fashioned Cape Cod, without tourists. We never saw seals when I was a kid but I hear they've come back and that's why we have sharks in our waters now. No sharks at Rock Island though, at least not the animal variety. Adult readers can guess what Kark is up to but even so, I couldn't put the book down. I had to know if the kids figured it out, how and when and whether this would be the ultimate kid fantasy where the kids save the day or more realistic. It ended up being a blend of both and the lighthouse plot offers up a commentary on how historical buildings are treated in this country.
The Fletchers are mostly a charming family. Dad and Papa are still confusing but they're more a part of the story. Papa is more strict while Dad is the fun one but together they're on the same page when it comes to rules and punishments. Sam's angsty teen personality didn't appeal to me. He's growing up and drifting away from his little brothers, yet he's still a boy, longing for those childhood days when his brothers were the only playmates he needed. He's grouchy because he's missing out on community theater back in Shipton. He's grouchy because Janie thinks he's cute and Sam isn't ready for girls yet. Janie is super annoying and silly so I don't blame him. Eli is grouchy too at times. He's afraid of the kayak because he's not a strong swimmer. Eli is still nerdy but now he can learn things for his own sake but kayaking is not something he's interested in learning. I could have done without the angst.
I admit that Frog's story was my favorite. ARE cats natural swimmers? He was trying a science experiment, even though it was bound to NOT go well. I don't know why he has to try it out with Zeus first though. Lili seems like she would be the easier cat to train. Poor Frog is very earnest and takes himself seriously. I feel bad that everyone keeps ignoring him and dismissing him. Ladybug is away for the summer so he doesn't have anyone his own age to play with. Frog was so so sweet helping Eli with his phobia! I would never have thought of that at all.
Jax is boring for most of the book. He just plays soccer with Alex, gets dirty hunting snakes and playing outside. There is one amusing moment when Jax discovers something shocking and then one dramatic moment when Jax and Alex, who is Hispanic, are racially profiled and labeled as thieves and hoodlums - an "urban" problem. That part didn't fit the light tone of the rest of the novel. Alex is a cool kid. I don't have anything in common with Alex and can't relate but Alex has traveled around the world and still behaves like a feral child when let loose on Rock Island! Val is weird. I don't understand why she greeted the Fletcher boys in Spanish without first checking to see if they understood Spanish.
Aunt Lucy finally makes an appearance. She's smart and knows the way the world works, being from New York. Her relationship with her brother is cute and funny. I like their memories and inside jokes. Lucy's boyfriend, Elon, is a magician and sometimes he uses his powers for bad instead of good. I really liked Captain Jim, an old salt, who knows just how to deal with tween boys who are eager and earnest about their adventures. What he does for Eli is lovely and I am very jealous! Like Eli, I want to see seals but I do not want to go in a kayak to do it! Captain Jim is very patient and kind when the kids just assume he'll go along with their schemes to save the lighthouse. I'm surprised the other fishermen allowed lobster races!
Obviously, Kark is not a likable person. He's smarmy, all smiles and flash but no substance. Their first encounter with him angers the dads! He doesn't think about anything except himself. Is he really an artist? Funny how no one seems to see him painting or has seen a finished painting. The adults in town are either gullible or naïve and I find it hard to believe no one checked into this guy! His friend Sheldon is even worse. A racist bigot and a bully, he is a truly horrible person. He doesn't come right out and SAY anything racist but he implies it.
This is a fun series and I would happily read more about the Fletchers if Sam holds back with the "sick" and the texting.
This is another adorable entry in the canon of plausible kidlit. I still dislike the excessive use of the slang word "sick" because it dates the story a lot but their summer adventures are timeless. What New England kid didn't grow up exploring tidepools, catching hermit crabs and horseshoe crabs, collecting shells and swimming in the ocean? Rock Island felt very old-fashioned Cape Cod, without tourists. We never saw seals when I was a kid but I hear they've come back and that's why we have sharks in our waters now. No sharks at Rock Island though, at least not the animal variety. Adult readers can guess what Kark is up to but even so, I couldn't put the book down. I had to know if the kids figured it out, how and when and whether this would be the ultimate kid fantasy where the kids save the day or more realistic. It ended up being a blend of both and the lighthouse plot offers up a commentary on how historical buildings are treated in this country.
The Fletchers are mostly a charming family. Dad and Papa are still confusing but they're more a part of the story. Papa is more strict while Dad is the fun one but together they're on the same page when it comes to rules and punishments. Sam's angsty teen personality didn't appeal to me. He's growing up and drifting away from his little brothers, yet he's still a boy, longing for those childhood days when his brothers were the only playmates he needed. He's grouchy because he's missing out on community theater back in Shipton. He's grouchy because Janie thinks he's cute and Sam isn't ready for girls yet. Janie is super annoying and silly so I don't blame him. Eli is grouchy too at times. He's afraid of the kayak because he's not a strong swimmer. Eli is still nerdy but now he can learn things for his own sake but kayaking is not something he's interested in learning. I could have done without the angst.
I admit that Frog's story was my favorite. ARE cats natural swimmers? He was trying a science experiment, even though it was bound to NOT go well. I don't know why he has to try it out with Zeus first though. Lili seems like she would be the easier cat to train. Poor Frog is very earnest and takes himself seriously. I feel bad that everyone keeps ignoring him and dismissing him. Ladybug is away for the summer so he doesn't have anyone his own age to play with. Frog was so so sweet helping Eli with his phobia! I would never have thought of that at all.
Jax is boring for most of the book. He just plays soccer with Alex, gets dirty hunting snakes and playing outside. There is one amusing moment when Jax discovers something shocking and then one dramatic moment when Jax and Alex, who is Hispanic, are racially profiled and labeled as thieves and hoodlums - an "urban" problem. That part didn't fit the light tone of the rest of the novel. Alex is a cool kid. I don't have anything in common with Alex and can't relate but Alex has traveled around the world and still behaves like a feral child when let loose on Rock Island! Val is weird. I don't understand why she greeted the Fletcher boys in Spanish without first checking to see if they understood Spanish.
Aunt Lucy finally makes an appearance. She's smart and knows the way the world works, being from New York. Her relationship with her brother is cute and funny. I like their memories and inside jokes. Lucy's boyfriend, Elon, is a magician and sometimes he uses his powers for bad instead of good. I really liked Captain Jim, an old salt, who knows just how to deal with tween boys who are eager and earnest about their adventures. What he does for Eli is lovely and I am very jealous! Like Eli, I want to see seals but I do not want to go in a kayak to do it! Captain Jim is very patient and kind when the kids just assume he'll go along with their schemes to save the lighthouse. I'm surprised the other fishermen allowed lobster races!
Obviously, Kark is not a likable person. He's smarmy, all smiles and flash but no substance. Their first encounter with him angers the dads! He doesn't think about anything except himself. Is he really an artist? Funny how no one seems to see him painting or has seen a finished painting. The adults in town are either gullible or naïve and I find it hard to believe no one checked into this guy! His friend Sheldon is even worse. A racist bigot and a bully, he is a truly horrible person. He doesn't come right out and SAY anything racist but he implies it.
This is a fun series and I would happily read more about the Fletchers if Sam holds back with the "sick" and the texting.
June 6, 2018
I enjoyed this series. It was nice to read about same sex parents bringing up a diverse family, with all the normal problems associated with parenting, plus the additional difficulties that can sometimes happen when the adopted children come from different ethnic backgrounds. It's all handled calmly and sensitively, without any over-the-top angst, but no real sugar coating either. **** 4 stars
August 25, 2017
Better than the first, and the first was fantastic. Includes the mystery of What Is Going To Happen To Our Fave Beach, and new friends, and a Cat the youngest Fletcher is determined to teach how to swim. (It goes surprisingly better than you'd think, and then amazing.)
April 2, 2018
Content Note:
unquestioned use of racist terms, (criticised) racist behaviour by white characters, sexism
You'll find the entire review (in German) on my blog.
The Fletcher boys are funny bunch, whose story, sadly, can't be exactly recommended - thanks to the author (and/or the German translation). Racist words should not be used in books without any criticism (not even once), especially not in children's books and certainly not in a story that deals with racism to some degree.
unquestioned use of racist terms, (criticised) racist behaviour by white characters, sexism
You'll find the entire review (in German) on my blog.
The Fletcher boys are funny bunch, whose story, sadly, can't be exactly recommended - thanks to the author (and/or the German translation). Racist words should not be used in books without any criticism (not even once), especially not in children's books and certainly not in a story that deals with racism to some degree.
July 13, 2016
Another great family story starring the Fletchers. I love how the author touches on some tough subjects opening up some thoughtful conversations if you're family is ready to have them. I also love that it takes place on an island, kinda reminds me of a place I love.
I hope the author continues to write about this loving family.
I hope the author continues to write about this loving family.
Read
January 1, 2021Cross-posted from my blog where there's more information on where I got my copy and links and everything.
This is a really good sequel that also would work just fine as a standalone. There’s definitely some continuity, and it’s cool if you read both, but this is a book where a kid can grab it and not have to seek out the one before it to understand what’s going on. I think that’s a strength in MG, because kids can’t always control what books they have access to, or have the patience to wait for a previous book.
This series really reminds me of Judy Bloom’s Fudge series, which I adored growing up. Especially the one where they went on vacation. (One of my favourite Baby-sitter’s Club books was also a vacation book… perhaps I have a thing!) I also really think it’s cool how the book manages a balance between being realistic about technology (Sam tries to get his phone to work a lot, despite the island’s bad signal, a Go-Pro becomes a plot point) while still feeling timeless, and letting the kids just play and go to the beach and chase the ice cream truck. It feels like you could read this in twenty years and the inclusion of technology wouldn’t feel dated or gimmicky, you know?
I also appreciate that the book did actually address some racism. This is a series that is aimed at slightly younger kids, even for middle grade, but I think it’s very true that many of the readers of it are going to have experiences like the kids have, where someone assumes they’re a criminal or a bad kid because of their skin colour, and the book saying no, that’s not true, and explicitly calling it racist is a good thing. Now, I think the representation of their friends who were Latinx was a little clunky at times, especially with the handling of them being bilingual, but I can’t say for sure because, you know, white, and I can’t find reviews mentioning that. In all of this, obviously, take me with a grain of salt, and feel free to completely ignore me.
I also thought there was a really unfunny line at one point that was transmisic and not necessary. At one point one of the kids thinks about their (presumed male) friend having to wear a dress and thinks that’s hilarious. Boys can wear dresses. It’s not funny. And that was incredibly unnecessary and kind of mean.
So I did have a couple problems with this, but in general I liked it, and I thought it was a lot of fun. There’s a ton of humour in it, and I think it’s got big appeal. I also do appreciate the cover and back copy. I know it’s kind of a bummer not to see the parents on the cover, but that also makes it a safer cover, as well as the back not mentioning their dads. A kid who needs this might be able to read it, who otherwise might not have been able to. That’s something important to consider in MG, sadly.
I really do hope for more middle grade with both queer main characters and queer families. Imagine being a little kid and reading this and seeing your family, or seeing the kind of family you want to have when you grow up. That’s powerful. Plus, this is just a series that’s ridiculously fun.
This is a really good sequel that also would work just fine as a standalone. There’s definitely some continuity, and it’s cool if you read both, but this is a book where a kid can grab it and not have to seek out the one before it to understand what’s going on. I think that’s a strength in MG, because kids can’t always control what books they have access to, or have the patience to wait for a previous book.
This series really reminds me of Judy Bloom’s Fudge series, which I adored growing up. Especially the one where they went on vacation. (One of my favourite Baby-sitter’s Club books was also a vacation book… perhaps I have a thing!) I also really think it’s cool how the book manages a balance between being realistic about technology (Sam tries to get his phone to work a lot, despite the island’s bad signal, a Go-Pro becomes a plot point) while still feeling timeless, and letting the kids just play and go to the beach and chase the ice cream truck. It feels like you could read this in twenty years and the inclusion of technology wouldn’t feel dated or gimmicky, you know?
I also appreciate that the book did actually address some racism. This is a series that is aimed at slightly younger kids, even for middle grade, but I think it’s very true that many of the readers of it are going to have experiences like the kids have, where someone assumes they’re a criminal or a bad kid because of their skin colour, and the book saying no, that’s not true, and explicitly calling it racist is a good thing. Now, I think the representation of their friends who were Latinx was a little clunky at times, especially with the handling of them being bilingual, but I can’t say for sure because, you know, white, and I can’t find reviews mentioning that. In all of this, obviously, take me with a grain of salt, and feel free to completely ignore me.
I also thought there was a really unfunny line at one point that was transmisic and not necessary. At one point one of the kids thinks about their (presumed male) friend having to wear a dress and thinks that’s hilarious. Boys can wear dresses. It’s not funny. And that was incredibly unnecessary and kind of mean.
So I did have a couple problems with this, but in general I liked it, and I thought it was a lot of fun. There’s a ton of humour in it, and I think it’s got big appeal. I also do appreciate the cover and back copy. I know it’s kind of a bummer not to see the parents on the cover, but that also makes it a safer cover, as well as the back not mentioning their dads. A kid who needs this might be able to read it, who otherwise might not have been able to. That’s something important to consider in MG, sadly.
I really do hope for more middle grade with both queer main characters and queer families. Imagine being a little kid and reading this and seeing your family, or seeing the kind of family you want to have when you grow up. That’s powerful. Plus, this is just a series that’s ridiculously fun.
July 9, 2018
I really enjoy the idea of the rollicking Family Fletcher: the two daddies, the multiracial kids, etc. But the plot was weak (scam artist tries to take over local monument with little effective local opposition or even recognition) and there was a really lame plot twist that involved the black son being racially profiled and the cops called on him, much to everyone's shock. The kid is 11 and lives in in a city. There is no way that he could have first encountered prejudice at age 11. If that were the case somehow, I think it would have affected him more strongly, made him question his place in his multi-ethnic family. He does get a little guidance from his aunt's black boyfriend. But apparently no one has given this kid "The Talk" that Ta-Nehisi Coats describes so movingly in "Between the World and Me," (how to deal with the cops so you will not be killed as a black man in white America) and they don't do it now. The series issues at hand are so sugar-coated and after school special in treatment, I was disappointed and a bit disgusted.
October 1, 2022
The Fletcher's have been vacationing on Rock Island for years. They have a small cottage that sits right next to a lighthouse. The view from the top of the lighthouse is one of the best experiences, one they look forward to and one they aren't able to do this year. Something's going on with the lighthouse that has the Fletcher's feeling horrible. In fact a lot of changes are happening at Rock Island. They used to know what to expect and every year was the same....until this year. Their hideaway has been infiltrated, they aren't alone anymore. A family is staying in the deserted cottage next door for the first time. But there are a few good things like the ice cream truck, the play that Sam gets into and Jax makes a new friend. The kids take it upon themselves to raise money and to secretly spy hoping to save the lighthouse. But in the process Jax learns about prejudice.which he doesn't have to deal with at home. It makes him see the island a little differently. Eli faces kayaking. And Frog has a good accident.
January 11, 2017
I received a copy free of charge in exchange for an honest review to be posted on my blog later. I came into this book not knowing the Fletchers (didn't realize there was a first book) so it took me a few chapters to really get to know the characters. Once I did, the book became a fun read, complete with coming of age issues, mystery (I figured it out immediately as I've read this plot many times before), friendship, even racial tension. I thought the characters were very likeable and just the right amount of family crazy. One point I didn't like was the adult interjection of explaining racism (seemed too preachy to me, as if the author was speaking to the reader directly on her own beliefs) as well as how the issue felt tossed in and not a natural part of the story. Overall, I enjoyed this book and may go back and read the first adventures to gain a better understanding as well as just have fun reading.
September 8, 2021
It’s been years since I read the first book, but I remember it as riotously funny. This book did crack me up at a few points, but I don’t think it had quite the punch of the original. Still, it was funny, and charming, and extremely evocative of that late-summer why-can’t-things-just-stay-the-same feeling I’m sure we all remember from childhood. Of course it had great representation of a family with two dads, totally normalizing and not the focus of this book. It also addressed racism, with an incident that was deeply upsetting yet nonviolent and totally age-appropriate. I would strongly recommend both books for anyone 8+. Although I would urge readers to experience the first book first, I don’t think it’s critical to read it in order for this to make sense. (Would definitely add to the sense of depth of characters and family and friend dynamics, though.)
January 12, 2019
I adore the Family Fletcher - the dads, the boys, and the pets. While this book is mostly a gentle, very funny story of the misadventures of a family with four adopted boys, the author doesn't shy away from some of the issues that may arise when two white dads adopt nonwhite kids. These issues are by no means the focus of the book. They are just one part of the Fletchers' story, which is a story filled with love, laughter, occasional grumpiness, and the wacky misadventures of a very close family. I find myself hoping for more Fletcher books because I would gladly spend more time with this delightful family.
July 15, 2018
Another audiobook for the whole family. We listened to this as part of our vacation driving. The chaos of a big family on vacation, all with expectations of the same vacation experience they have always had, starts to go wrong immediately. I really like how the kids all have their own issues, so there is almost always both things worth celebrating and mourning at the same time. It's funny at times, but also touching.
I'd really like to see another book in this series, but I'm not sure it can be done without repetition of what we have already read.
I'd really like to see another book in this series, but I'm not sure it can be done without repetition of what we have already read.
August 3, 2018
Perfect late elementary/early tween read. Levy is clearly aiming for an "old fashioned family story" tone with updated details. In this case, those details include gay dads, 4 adopted sons of various ethnicities, cell phones, and racism, all gently explored along with a core of kids' scrapes that would fit in any classic novel. I loved the first book about this family and was delighted to realize there was a sequel.
April 4, 2019
For the 2019 Read Harder Challenge category of a children’s or middle grade book that has won a diversity award since 2009. In this case, the book was one selected for ALA's 2017 Rainbow Project. It has two dads, four adopted sons, an aunt who has a cupcake store and a magician boyfriend, AND a bad guy to outwit. So much fun.
October 21, 2019
One of my favorite books the kids and I have read together this year--better than the first in the series.
If you're looking for a family story a la the Penderwicks but with boys, the book is for you. It's both funny (I had to put it down and catch my breath at one point) and thought provoking. Highly recommended by all 4 of us, which is a rarity these days.
If you're looking for a family story a la the Penderwicks but with boys, the book is for you. It's both funny (I had to put it down and catch my breath at one point) and thought provoking. Highly recommended by all 4 of us, which is a rarity these days.
February 16, 2020
The story of a same sex, multi racial family that goes on vacation to Rock Island. They have lots of adventures and meet up with a so called artist that actually has ulterior motives for being on the island that would destroy the island forever. A cute story for kids. A bit annoying in that everything has to be politically correct, shows racial bias and calling people losers.
October 18, 2023
This book is all about the Fletcher's family summer vacation. It's filled with adventure, laughter, and heartwarming moments. It beautifully portrays diverse family dynamics and explores themes of love, acceptance and identity. This is an inclusive story that celebrates the beauty of different experiences and relationships. I recommend this book for young adults.
May 25, 2018
The Family Fletcher returns for summer fun, while also solving the mystery of their beloved Rock Island lighthouse. Wonderful sequel to the first book, and I can't wait to read more of their yearly adventures.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 116 reviews