A fast, informative, insightful read, but not necessarily what you'd expect (unless you know the backstory). Whether or not you buy into the canonization of Shorter as the father of the modern distance running movement, there's no denying that Shorter ranks pretty high on the pantheon of great runners, and it's hard to argue with the conclusion that, at least in the U.S., he's one of the most influential runners ... ever.
Not really a spoiler alert (more of a trigger warning), but, while this book will be (extremely) attractive to runners of a certain age (think baby boomers, the over-50 set, whatever or ... I dunno, if you were running in the era before Nike popularized the iconic waffle trainer, or ... if you remember being blown away by the light, breathable, water repellent magic of Gore Tex), the story is heavily influenced, and frequently dwells upon
child abuse
(inflicted by the author's father). Shorter's life is complicated, and the book is as much about his life as it is about his running.
Still, the book is filled with gems for runners, running fans, and running readers. For me, one of the most gratifying bonuses was Shorter's relationship with John Parker, author of the sublime and iconic Once A Runner, (the cult classic, considered by many to be the finest piece of running-related fiction ever written) and its long-anticipated sequel Again to Carthage. For me, it was worth reading the book solely for the references to, and information regarding, Parker. Others, however, may be amused, for example, by the anecdote surrounding Shorter's move from Adidas to Nike (and why it mattered).
Another particular gem is that the book offers a gratifying alternative to sports success being the domain of the stereotypical dumb jock. Briefly, Shorter does Yale proud, but that's just the tip of the iceberg.
Like any biography, there are holes (OK, there are gaping holes, that may or may not be relevant to some readers). Shorter holds his cards pretty close to the chest when he talks about spouses and children (save for a little parental bragging, which is, in its own way, rather endearing).
Similarly, given how much has been written today about doping and the war against athletic doping, Shorter's discussion of the topic comes across as anecdotal and superficial. Heck, there's an entire shelf of Lance Armstrong-era related cycling/doping literature, much of which has gravitated from the non-fiction to the fiction shelf with time, including at least four (4) books by Armstrong's team-mates (which, in and of itself, is somewhat incredible, to the extent that Armstrong typically raced with a team consisting of ten or fewer other riders). So it's fascinating how little time or energy Shorter expends on the "cynical and diabolical" Armstrong, dismissing/disparaging him in less than a paragraph. Granted, cycling isn't running, but....
Finally, much of the book revolves around Shorter's frustration with, and attempts to break the stranglehold of, "the powers that be" whose idyllic, but hypocritical, morally flexible, and all-too-often condescending obsession with a naive vision of amateur athletics impoverished and disadvantaged and, directly or indirectly, arbitrarily punished serious athletes for no apparent purpose other than control and anachronistic idealism. Personally, I would have been interested in learning Shorter's perception of the modern-era NCAA-sanctioned exploitation of college football and basketball players for the benefit of coaches (with more than 50 universities paying their football coaches more than $2M annually, and more than 20 paying their basketball coaches $2M/year or more), university athletic directors, and, of course, television/cable companies.
I'm also a little dubious on Shorter's (or his editor's) German geography (placing Wiesbaden close to Munich - nah, it's much closer to Frankfurt), but that's a minor quibble. Unfortunately, it literally jumps off the page very early in the book, which makes one wonder how the error remained.
In the end, if you've ever run a marathon or a large distance event (half-marathon, ten-miler, 10k, or even a 5k), the book is well worth reading.