The websites and catalogs note that "Drums" was the most played "song" in the band's repertoire. I have to admit, it was never a favorite of mine. It was, for me, more of a prelude to "Space," which was often the high point. And I didn't have particularly high expectations for this book. So I was pleasantly surprised.
In general, I am not a big fan of drummers, and especially not of the drummers other people think of as virtuosos. I have little use for the Neal Pearts, the Keith Moons, or the Ginger Bakers (or the Buddy Rich's) for that matter. I prefer a more restrained approach, as with Ringo, or Levon Helm, or Jim Keltner.
So, for the most part, I either haven't paid much attention to Bill and Mickey. And when I have, its typically because their approach has tended to homogenize a bunch of the the band's stuff. There was a time when almost everything took on a slightly reggae/cajun feel, and I think that was mostly the doing of the drummers. But, I have to admit, there are other times when the drumming is astonishingly good. And it tends to be in the jams, the free sections, the exploratory parts of The Other One, or Dark Star, etc...
The first thing that impresses me about this book is how strongly Kreutzmann's commitment to the music comes through. He subtitles the book with "drumming, dreams, and drugs". I would say that the topics of importance in the book are not exactly these, but rather, in order, "music, drugs, and pranks." But always the music comes first. The same thing rang true in Lesh's book, but he seemed to think of the music as a vehicle for the "group mind," as a way to find something greater. Kreutzmann, on the contrary, gives the impression that there is nothing greater. The reason the group mind is important, for Kreutzmann is because it makes better music, not the other way around. It was also refreshing to hear his opinions about the musical abilities of other players (mostly keyboard players for some reason - there is hardly a word about Phil or Bobby's playing here).
As for drugs, Kreutzmann is brutally honest. Drugs made the band, and broke it. Pot and acid are good. Cocaine, prescription drugs, and heroin - not so much. It's clear that he probably did more drugs himself than all the people I have ever known, combined. And he is now remarkably clear-headed about things. But, there is also a repeated theme of him not remembering stuff, and its pretty clear that he doesn't remember large chunks of his life because he was simply too drugged out at the time. At no time in the book, did I get the feeling that he was either glorifying drugs, or telling the cliche tale of regret. Rather, he was simply being candid.
The tales of the pranks are fun. I suppose lots of them appear elsewhere. But even if I had heard some of the stories before, it was fun to get his take on them. And lots of them are new, and they were almost always enjoyable. Kreutzmann's voice comes through, and it sounds like he is casually telling stories, which suits a memoir of this sort quite well.
What's missing, for me, is anything particularly deep about the relationships between the band members. He discusses his relationship with Jerry at some length. And he describes how Mickey was first something of a mentor to him. And there's a fair bit about Pigpen. But he lived with Phil and Bob for years, and I get almost no impression at all about how they interact. And there's also almost nothing about his interactions with Keith, Donna, Brent, Vince, etc... I got a clearer impression of his relationship with John Belushi than I did of his relationship with Bobby, for example. Perhaps this is because his relationship with Bobby is ongoing, and he wants to be a little careful there. But it does come across as a bit of a whole in an otherwise candid memoir.
Some people have complained that this book is a bit scattered, and jumps all over the place. Others have complained that he is going over old material. But, that's what the Dead did. They played the same stuff again and again, and they did it in ways that were scattered at times, and seemed to jump around. But, when it worked it was magic. I wouldn't go that far with this book, but when it works, it is very good, and well worth reading.