Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Instant Classic: 'A heartfelt novel about queer love' Shelf Awareness

Not yet published
Expected 26 Jan 27
Rate this book
Instant Classic is a page-turning queer love story and perfect bookclub pick. It is set across two timelines and explores the world of Hollywood as well as women's basketball.

Marion May is in desperate need of a win. She's directed two films, both flops. And if she can't land the third, she may never get to make another. But she was put here to make movies, she knows it, she just needs to convince everyone else.

Fate or good fortune takes Marion to a Lakers game, where she is sat beside Jaz Jones. Graceful and magnetic, exactly as a WBNA player should be, Jaz is hard to ignore, and she has a pitch for Marion's next her coach's story.

Harper Kidd was a rising star of the women's basketball world in the 1950s until one night when everything unravelled and she was forced to leave the game and the team she so loved. It is not until a young, fiercely talented Jaz enters her world that Harper finds her way back to the court and to herself.

Marion is hooked. On Harper's story, on Jaz, on the way she feels when she's in their world. Inspired by these women who fought to play, to be seen and to love, Marion begins to see that making movies might be only one part of who she is…

Kate Fagan's Instant Classic is a love letter to women's sports and queer identity. It explores how the stories we tell can bridge decades, heal old wounds, and lead us back to who we truly are.

'A book about movies, romance, basketball, parents and parent-figures, and how a rich life can be lived even if the world is against you.' Booklist

Kindle Edition

Expected publication January 26, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kate Fagan

12 books851 followers
Kate Fagan is an Emmy Award–winning journalist and the #1 New York Times bestselling author of What Made Maddy Run, which was a semi-finalist for the PEN/ESPN Award for literary sports writing. She is also the author of three additional nonfiction titles, a former professional basketball player, and spent seven years as a journalist at ESPN. Kate lives in Bolton Landing, NY.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
39 (35%)
4 stars
43 (39%)
3 stars
23 (20%)
2 stars
5 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews
Profile Image for Angie Miale.
1,542 reviews239 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 12, 2026
“A story isn’t the what, it’s the why and the how.”

Kate Fagan’s Instant Classic is subtitled A Love Story, and I initially assumed I was picking up a romance. Instead, it’s something much more expansive. This is a story about the love of basketball, the bonds between women across generations, the friendships that shape our lives, and the power of telling stories that deserve to be told.

The novel weaves together several timelines centered on the legendary Hanes Hosiery women’s basketball program. Harper Kidd dreams of escaping her small-town life through basketball before eventually becoming both a coach and a mentor to future WNBA superstar Jaz Jones. As Jaz’s remarkable career attracts the attention of a filmmaker hoping to bring her story to the screen, the novel shifts beyond the court into a thoughtful exploration of legacy, representation, and whose stories Hollywood chooses to tell.

One of the themes that resonated with me most was Fagan’s commentary on women’s sports—both on and off the screen. She points out how few films center female athletes, and even fewer celebrate queer women. That absence gives this novel an added layer of purpose. One quote in particular stayed with me: “The number of men holding back women’s sports while telling themselves they were its protectors was infuriating.” Fagan makes a compelling case that these stories matter, not simply because they’re about sports, but because they’re about people whose lives have too often been overlooked.

You don’t need to know anything about basketball to appreciate this novel. While sports provide the backdrop, the emotional heart lies in the relationships, the mentorships, and the determination to preserve history before it’s forgotten.

For me, the book truly came alive in its third act as the characters fought the Hollywood machine to get this story made. Those chapters were deeply moving and highlighted the importance of authentic representation in film. I also appreciated how Fagan explored the many different ways love can manifest outside of traditional romance.

My biggest reservation was the structure. While I enjoyed each timeline individually, I found myself wishing for a stronger thread connecting them throughout the novel. I also would have loved a bit more time spent developing the characters, as I occasionally felt at a slight emotional distance from them.

Even so, Kate Fagan continues to be one of the strongest voices writing about women, sports, and identity today. I still prefer her memoirs to her fiction, but her compassion, insight, and passion for these subjects shine through on every page. If you enjoyed Carrie Soto Is Back but are looking for something less about competition and more about legacy, storytelling, friendship, and the enduring love of the game, Instant Classic is well worth picking up.

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for the advance electronic copy. Instant Classic publishes January 26, 2027.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
1,261 reviews1,050 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 4, 2026
Kate Fagan is a master of her craft and I inhaled this beautiful story - and learned so much about the history of women’s basketball in the process!! This is a love story to basketball and tenacity and the power of love.
Profile Image for Brooke!.
163 reviews7 followers
August 10, 2026
i am going to think about this book for the rest of my life. this STORY was fantastic and it ended perfectly and was just so good i don’t even have the words. this was so good that i WISH this movie was made in real life. these characters are just so perfect and this was just such a good book.
Profile Image for Alyssa.
958 reviews43 followers
November 6, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for inviting me to read this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

This one was an interesting read to me! I couldn’t quite get into it, but it was written well.

I will say, the beginning was pretty boring to me. I just had a hard time connecting to the characters and the story. As it went on, I started to enjoy it more. I think I liked the film side of it better than learning about Harper’s story.

I thought the concept of the novel was super cool! Usually I am big on sports romance. In this book I didn’t care for it as much, but as the book went on it wasn’t AS prevalent.

The way the filming and how the movie was described was so beautiful! It really tugged at my heart strings! I want to be able to watch this movie for myself!

There was a lot that was happening. There was the romance with Jaz and Marion, Harper and Ivy, Harper and Jaz’s friendship, Marion’s relationship with her dad, and so much more. Not that it was confusing to read, it was just a lot of jumping around. It felt like the novel had a lot of different parts. It’s not like it didn’t mesh together, but it didn’t fit as nicely as I would have wanted.

I think Harper and Jaz’s relationship was my favorite. You could tell how much love they had for each other and they really respected each other. They knew what each other needed without really even using words. It was beautiful to read. I liked the romance between the characters, but that wasn’t why I cared about the book. I liked them together because I knew we needed to, not because I felt very deeply for them if that makes sense.

I liked the addition of Cecilia! She was a great character.

The drama at the end of the book was so well done! I was stressing out, but it wasn’t dragged out, which I appreciated.

I really liked the last page of the book, I thought that was such a nice touch to wrap up the novel. (Pun somewhat intended)

I think there will be other people that will really love this book. There was just something about it I couldn’t quite get into, but I enjoyed it enough that I could see what other people could like about it.
Profile Image for Caitlin.
117 reviews206 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
October 14, 2026
uh this is the lesbian basketball story we need. like a cross between the decades-long lez yearning of the seven husbands of evelyn hugo and the sobbing historical goodness of a league of their own plus the feeling of watching yr favorite underdog wnba team win in a clutch upset (portland fire over the liberty iykyk). esp hits the spot when yr waiting the endless week before the championship series begins (go valks and go dream, idc who wins, let the season never end) ❤️🏀
Profile Image for cyd.
1,243 reviews60 followers
July 24, 2026
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review. I was pleasantly surprised by this book and I really enjoyed reading it. This book is definitely for fans of The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo. It almost feels like it was split into two separate books. The first half mostly took place in the last but the second half was present focused and covered a larger span of time. I preferred the first half to the second half but overall the book was very enjoyable. Some of the veins half felt a little bit unnecessary and it made the book feel a bit less cohesive. The pacing was the main problem that I had with the book but it wasn’t super distracting. I would definitely recommend this to women’s sports fans and fans of Taylor Jenkins Reid.
Profile Image for Ashlee.
316 reviews31 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 27, 2026
Instant Classic is an interesting look back in time and is a great book for those looking for more of what A League of Their Own offered. I liked this story of Jaz, Coach Harper and Marion all finding their place in the world. Their relationships were well developed and each of the main characters had a distinct feel. There was a bit of basketball but not a huge amount which makes it a fun read even for those not into sports. This took me back a bit to The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo as Coach Harper told her story. I liked it but have to say the timeline jumped around just a little too much for me. Some scenes/time periods left me wanting more and some of the time jumps were just a bit too long in between and less detailed than I would have liked. There was also some tension with the film production that I was just not as invested in as I was in Coach Harpers/Jaz' story. I see the draw of having some pushback in the current timeline but it felt a bit too much in my opinion and left too little time for the details I wanted to see from the past. Overall a fun read and would recommend, I am definitely due for a re-read of Seven Husbands soon though. This retrospective made me want more of the same.
Profile Image for Kelly.
1,124 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 13, 2026
Kate Fagan’s Instant Classic is full of slam dunks, missed shots, and too many different possessions. Having said that, I have used up the majority of my basketball references as I do not watch or follow the men’s or women’s games at the collegiate or professional level.

The cover of the book is definitely a missed shot, though this is more on the publisher than Fagan. The dust jacket design is light blues and pinks with palm trees, conveying the idea that the book is a fun, lighthearted romance, which does a disservice to the very not lighthearted primary storylines in this book. The romance part of the story, between Marion and Jaz is underwhelming and the second least interesting thing going on in the book. And there’s a lot going on.

The most interesting thing by far for me was the historical element of the book, which is about Harper Kidd, and how her love for basketball leads her to be a part of one of the early competitive women’s basketball teams, and later a many times over championship winning coach. In between, being a lesbian kills her chance at a playing career, makes her shy away from the game she loves, and leaves her feeling disappointed in love multiple times.

The second most interesting storyline is the fight to tell stories like Harper’s, instead of the established canon and guaranteed blockbusters, which is approached from the angle of Marion May trying to make a movie about it and get it released in an unfiltered form to the general public. This is a war with many, many battles. This is probably not unrealistic, but almost gets exhausting for the reader.

The next most interesting storyline is Marion. This character has by far the best development, and the reader gets to see her struggle what kind of director she wants to be, how important her dad’s acceptance of her matters to her, and most importantly, her comfort level with being publicly out with another woman, which is shaken by what she perceives as a less than enthusiastic response by her mother when she tells her she’s gay.

And then’s there Jaz. There will probably be readers who like her, but I did not. I appreciated that she felt like Harper’s story was important to tell and pushed for that to happen. I liked that she welcomed Coach Harper into her home after she had knee surgery and needed support. And good for her for being out and owning it without caring what people think.

But it felt like a lot of things became the Jaz show without a good reason like Harper breaking down barriers or Marion exploring her identity and relationships. The one storyline that could have explored her character, a recovery from a ruptured Achilles and whether her professional career was at an end was a whimper of a storyline.

Instead, she regularly jumps in to tell Harper’s story because “she’s heard it so many times she could tell it herself”, so she interrupts and just does. Then Harper’s story evolves to meeting Jaz as a young girl and Jaz learning to play from her. Then Jaz getting her interested in the game again. Then Jaz convincing her to be the coach for her team. Then Jaz going on to be a successful WNBA player.

This high degree of self focus also makes her a less than stellar partner professionally and romantically. As Marion faces barriers to getting the movie made, Jaz is more focused on pushing Marion to figure out a way to make it happen than she is willing to provide financial support to help grease the wheels or ask how she can use the clout she’s earned to help get things done. Romantically, she doesn’t understand Marion’s struggle with being out; she just distances herself from the relationship instead of seeking to understand why Marion doesn’t have the confidence she does.

Because of all the competing storylines, the books also starts feeling choppy. Not only does it jump back and forth between the past and the present, the past events don’t happen in consecutive order, as they will jump back to a certain time when Jaz decides she wants to reframe it differently for Marion, or as filming for a certain part of the movie takes place.

There were parts of this I thought were great, and parts I thought would have better served the book by being minimized or left out altogether to allow the story to focus on the stronger, more powerful parts of the book.

A complimentary copy of this book was provided by the publisher. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Michaela.
44 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 12, 2026
★★★★★

I was thrilled to receive an ARC of Instant Classic because I absolutely loved Kate Fagan’s The Three Lives of Kate Cay. This book did not disappoint—in fact, I think Instant Classic may be my favorite Fagan novel yet.

The story follows three women connected by basketball and by the complicated ways that love, sexuality, family, and societal expectations can shape a life. Marion is a former college basketball player hoping to become a filmmaker while struggling with her sexuality and difficult relationships with her parents. Harper is a former professional basketball player who sacrificed the sport she loved after she was discovered in a lesbian bar with Ivy, the woman she loved, at a time when being openly queer could carry serious professional consequences. Jaz is a current WNBA player whose career and life have been shaped by Harper, who became her mentor and surrogate mother after the death of Jaz’s mother.

When Marion, Harper, and Jaz come together to make a film about Harper and Jaz’s lives, their individual stories begin to illuminate one another.

Fagan explores the history of women’s sports and the particular challenges faced by queer women without ever making the story feel like a history lesson. Instead, those issues are woven naturally into the lives of the characters. The result is a deeply human story about the sacrifices people make for love, the cost of hiding who you are, and the ways that one generation can create opportunities for the next.

As someone who loves women’s basketball, I especially appreciated the sports elements, but this is ultimately a character-driven novel. The relationships between the three women—and the ways their pasts and presents intersect—are what kept me turning the pages.

I also loved the exploration of legacy. Harper gave up something she loved because of the world she lived in, while Jaz gets to pursue a career that women like Harper helped make possible. Marion sits somewhere between those generations, trying to understand both the history that came before her and what it means to live authentically in the present.

Instant Classic is thoughtful, emotional, beautifully character-driven, and deeply affirming without ever feeling overly sentimental. It made me think about how far women’s sports have come—and how much further there is still to go.

Five stars. Highly recommended for readers who enjoy women's sports fiction, queer romance/fiction, complicated family relationships, and emotionally rich character-driven stories.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Jenn.
5,256 reviews75 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 18, 2026
Fagan's newest novel about a movie director and a WNBA player has something for everyone! Marion has had small successes with her first two movies, but now it's time for her to complete the last of her three movie deal and she needs a killer idea. When injured WNBA player Jaz comes to her with an idea about her mentor's time in some of the first women's basketball leagues, she's unsure at first, but she hears the story, she's all in. But it will be an uphill battle all the way. Can she succeed?

I liked the story here. I'm not too sure about the cohesion of the writing. It felt kind of disjointed and didn't flow as well as it should have. Yet I did definitely enjoy it.
Profile Image for shan.
255 reviews
September 7, 2026
I absolutely adored this book! Such a beautiful story about women’s basketball, sapphic love, and self acceptance. The flashbacks and multiple timelines were well done which can be tricky. I was so invested in each of the characters and their stories and their relationships to each other. Very well done!

Instant Classic comes out on January 26th, 2027. Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for my honest review!
Profile Image for rachel.
433 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 27, 2026
This book is by a new-to-me author and follows Marion, a movie director, as she tells the story of a WBNA coach named Harper, which intertwines with one of her players’ stories, Jaz Jones. It takes place in multiple timelines, and switches between the three female POVs, giving the reader a well rounded storyline to follow. The book was interesting and it reminded me a lot of Daisy Jones and the Six, The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, and A Great Big Beautiful Life in the way the story was told. I appreciated getting to delve into Jaz and Harper’s individual stories but struggled at times with the pacing. I would suggest this book to anyone who is looking for an lgbtq+ romance featuring sports and history.

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read&review this arc!
Profile Image for Jamie P-Kretzschmar.
218 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 16, 2026
A Powerful Love Letter to Queer Legacy and Sports
Kate Fagan is well-known for her heavy-hitting, impactful narratives, so I will admit I was slightly intimidated to pick this one up. However, Instant Classic completely captivated me. The cover—with its retro typography, palm trees, and the "A Love Story" subtitle—gives off a breezy, contemporary romance vibe. But readers should know going in: this is a sweeping work of women's fiction rather than a traditional, trope-heavy romance.

Instead of a straightforward rom-com, the book delivers a profound dual-timeline story centered around the love of basketball, female mentorship, and the fight for authentic queer representation. We follow Marion May, a modern-day Hollywood director trying to salvage her career, alongside a 1950s timeline focusing on Harper Kidd, a rising star in women's basketball whose legacy was unjustly erased.

What makes this book shine:

The Nuanced "Love Story": While there is romance, the true love story here is about queer history, the love of the game, and the deeply forged bonds of female friendship. Fagan draws heavily on her own background in sports, making the basketball elements feel incredibly grounded and authentic.
The Thematic Depth: The book tackles the erasure of queer identity and the struggles of being a woman in the public eye. It treats queerness as an important, celebrated legacy to be uncovered rather than just a plot device.

A quick note on structure:

The only reason this is a 4-star read instead of a full 5 is the dual-timeline structure. I often struggle with back-and-forth narratives because I inevitably end up favoring one era over the other, which can make the reading experience feel a bit uneven as you rush to get back to your preferred storyline. While Fagan handles the transitions beautifully and the connective tissue between Marion and Harper is incredibly strong, the pacing occasionally dips when jumping between the decades.

Overall, if you are looking for an expansive, thoughtful piece of women's literature that honors queer history and sports legacy, this is an absolute must-read. It is a heavier, more contemplative story than the cover suggests, but the emotional payoff is entirely worth it.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing this ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Chelsea.
114 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 4, 2026
Thank you to Atria Books eGalley for this digital advanced copy and to Kate Fagan for the dopamine surge.
*inhales*
I love a novel I can savour. An arc that really wraps around you and holds you while you're reeling from the emotion. I, however, must also be humbled and reminded that you always should TRUST THE STORYTELLING OF YOUR FAVORITE AUTHORS.
*exhales*
Buckle up, because this book has 54 chapters, and each one is used systematically. This review is written within ten minutes of finishing this book, with my Kindle still on my chest as I hold my phone to write in my notes app the overwhelming sensations of this read. AND a warning that this novel has a cold open.

I don't say this lightly, as the mental journey I have just finished really did start off with what I would compare to drinking a lukewarm glass of water, and even made me think, had I misremembered Fagan's writing or my previous enjoyment of her work? In Ch. 2 we are given a saltine of a sentence with "She decided long ago not to be gay-" and while my throat felt thick with deception, as if this is a choice at all, I persevered.

Fagan expertly peels back the layers of fear, of standing at the base of a mountain, and the anxiety, still prevalent in 2026, that people across the globe feel as they realize who they know themselves to be. The act of looking at one's reflection is used several times, and it remains powerful to hold eye contact with oneself. It identifies the privilege of being surrounded by those who will accept and nurture you, and also highlights that this is not a given or the majority.

The timing of this book is perfect. The narration and multiple POV is handled and written flawlessly. It's inspirational, emotional, loud and PROUD AF! While I have mentioned above that the book starts with a saltine, by the crescendo of the plot, you are devouring warm focaccia with olive oil and licking rosemary and salt from your fingertips.

Your thirst for strong, authentic, female leads will be quenched. You will have all ten courses, and you will be satiated by the dessert presentation, and then you'll need to leave room for the digestif. Fagan calls out homophobia, societal discomfort, misogyny, and the weakness of men who are otherwise praised and uplifted by their peers. She speaks into the shadows and the spotlight. She is inclusive and welcoming. No one is left on the outskirts.

This is a stunning and heartfelt journey which was an honour to read.


Profile Image for Christin.
49 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
Kate Fagan has written something genuinely special with Instant Classic. This is a book about women's basketball and how dismissive the narrative around representation of women (especially the queer community) is in Hollywood. I have already told all my sports loving girlies to add this to their TBR pile!
The story starts withMarion May, a director desperate for a career win, when she meets Jaz Jones at a Lakers game and learns about Harper Kidd, a brilliant coach whose legacy was stolen when she was forced out of the game in the 1950s. The film project that follows becomes something far deeper than a career move. It becomes a reckoning with hidden selves and the lineage of women who fought to belong.
What works beautifully is how Fagan weaves the basketball through everything. This isn't a sports book that happens to have queer characters. The sport carries the emotional weight of the story. Harper's erasure from the court wasn't just a career loss; it was a loss of self. Jaz's presence brings Harper back to the game and, more importantly, back to herself. The basketball court becomes the space where healing happens.
The history here is vital. Fagan doesn't gloss over the 1950s or treat it as distant backdrop. That era shaped everything about what Harper could and couldn't be, and understanding it makes you understand why this story, this recovery of Harper's legacy, matters so much.
The characters feel fully alive. Marion confronting what she's kept hidden. Jaz's magnetism and genuine care. Harper's hard-earned wisdom. The dynamics between them create real emotional stakes beyond the surface plot.
What genuinely moved me was the queer joy running through this book. There's celebration alongside the struggle, brightness alongside the darkness. It's not a tragedy dressed up as triumph. It's a genuine love story about women claiming space and seeing each other fully.
This is the kind of book that will stay with me because it understands that the stories we tell matter, that visibility heals, that sometimes the most radical act is remembering the women we were told to forget.
Disclaimer: I received an advance reader copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Danna.
1,137 reviews31 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 1, 2026
Instant Classic by Kate Fagan earns four stars for storyline and five for execution overall, though the pacing wobbles early on, averaging 4.5 stars rounded down for me. The novel weaves between the early 1950:, following Harper Kidd, a player on the real life Hanes Hosiery women's team out of North Carolina, and the present day, where an older Harper lives with a WNBA star she once coached, named Jaz. Jaz pitches the story of Harper's playing days to Marion May, a Hollywood producer struggling to step out from under her blockbuster director father's shadow, and together the three women turn it into the instant classic the title promises.

The premise alone is a delight, but what makes the book sing is how fully realized its characters are. Harper, Jaz, and Marion each feel distinct and lived in, and the historical sections do lovely work bringing the early days of women's basketball to life, the grit, the stakes, the sense of a sport still fighting for legitimacy while its players struggle to balance what society expects of them with their love for the sport. Fagan's prose has the smart, sharp wit her readers have come to expect, and it carries the book even through its rougher patches.

Those rougher patches show up mostly in the first third to half of the novel, where the back and forth between timelines goes so deep into each thread that it gets hard to find your footing again after a switch. You settle into one storyline only to be yanked into the other just as it's picking up steam, which made we want to stay put rather than jump. The book also runs a touch long overall, and tighter editing with smoother transitions between eras would have made for an even stronger read. That said, once the story hits its stride around the midpoint, the back and forth smooths out and the pages fly.

Overall, this comes recommended. It's a rich, funny, tender story with a premise you don't see often, and I'll be first in line for whatever Fagan writes next.

Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Favorite quotes:

“I think what’s happening is that you’re conflating the universe with the world,” Jaz said. “In my experience, those places are run by two very different CEOs.”

quote—if you don’t have time to do it right, when will you have time to do it over?—and
Profile Image for Alexandra.
29 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 19, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon & Schuster for an eARC of Instant Classic by Kate Fagan in exchange for an honest review.

⭐2.5/5 stars⭐

It pains me to say how disappointing this book was considering how OVERJOYED I was to get access to an advance copy. The Three Lives of Cate Kay was my favorite read of 2025, so I was very eager to get my hands on Kate Fagan's latest novel. From the moment I read the first page of this story I was.... confused. I fell in love with Kate Fagan's voice in The Three Lives of Cate Cay, and what I was reading here was startlingly different. The first issue was that this book seemed to be written at a second grade reading level... Why? This is adult fiction. I also knew this book was supposed to be a "love story," but there were so many cringey sentences and phrases that I was overwhelmed with second hand embarrassment during the majority of my time reading. Another choice the author kept making was to constantly interrupt a character's statement or train of thought with a phone call, a dog barking, a server coming to take an order, etc. which took me out of the story every time. Fagan also regularly went into great detail describing items that did not matter to the story at hand. I don't need two full paragraphs about the Italian meal and drinks the main characters are eating before we get to their conversation, which is actually significant to the plot. Lastly, I was disappointed to find the whole plotline very predictable with none of the twists and surprises that were found in Fagan's previous novel. I am so sad and perplexed as to what happened to this author's writing style. Theoretically, I enjoyed the idea of the story - multiple timelines, forbidden queer love, good conquering evil, and fighting for gender equality. However, the execution was shockingly subpar compared to my previous read with this author. Overall, I would still encourage anyone who enjoys LGBTQ+ fiction or romance novels to give this book a try, but it unfortunately missed the mark for me.
Profile Image for Kristy.
1,492 reviews239 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 19, 2026
INSTANT CLASSIC is a love story, alright, a love story about basketball, women who love women, women's sports, and more.

Director Marion May needs a hit. Growing up in the shadow of her distant, famous father, she feels she has one last shot to make a film that matters. When she meets Jaz Jones, a star WNBA player, she feels sparks--both romantically and creatively. Jaz tells Marion the story of her coach, Harper Kidd, and her basketball legacy that goes back to the 1950s.

Marion has suppressed her own lesbian feelings for years, but spending time with Jaz and Harper opens up a whole new world. She learns about the one season Harper spent in the 1950s on the Hanes Hosiery women's basketball team, a pioneering team--and the devastating series of events that led her to leave the team (and basketball) behind. And how, many years later, she came to coach the spunky, irresistible Jaz.

The timeline in this story is slightly confusing; I was never fully sure if Marion had already heard a story from Harper and Jaz, or if she was adjusting something for her movie script, so I just went with it. No matter what, Harper's early years are absolutely fascinating and bringing in Jaz only adds more intrigue.

Fagan excels with the multiple POVs, letting us hear from these amazing talented women. It's an exercise in learning about early women's sports, but even if you aren't a basketball fan, you will love this story. It covers the pain and difficulty of feeling different, how often women were overlooked and mistreated--and how they persevered nonetheless. It's so easy to get lost in the narrative and Harper and Jaz's stories. I really enjoyed this one. 4.5 stars.

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and Atria Books in return for an unbiased review.
Profile Image for Beth Gordon.
2,974 reviews22 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
4.5 ⭐️

This was a fantastic story involving women’s basketball and filmmaking, and the characters really made this an amazing read. Marion May is a filmmaker, under contract to make her third movie after two not-so-well-received movies. When she meets Jaz Jones, a current basketball player, there’s a spark and an inspiration seeing Jaz talk about the interaction between her and her coach Harper. When Marion hears Harper’s story, she’s determined to make this movie despite all the obstacles in the way, especially when she knows Hollywood doesn’t want a lesbian basketball movie.

🩷Lots of filmmaking talk in this novel - while there are some scenes in front of the camera, there is much more behind the scenes in the producing realm, which was interesting. (Another novel released this year - Hollywood, Ending - was about movies as well, but it focused on filming and the press junket from the actor angle. I thought this novel complemented that one very well.)
🩷Window into the history of women’s basketball (two dribbles) and being a lesbian throughout the last 60ish years.
🩷 The author’s knowledge seared through the pages.

⚠️Some scenes to move a little too fast. It’s rare that I want a longer novel, but in this case I did.

While the subject matter may not appeal to all readers, this novel was a hit for me!

Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an Advance Reader Copy. My review is completely my own.

It will be published on January 26, 2027.
Profile Image for Nicole LC.
39 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 15, 2026
⭐️4/5

Marion has one more movie left to create in her contract, with the first two being less than impactful she’s really pushing to find the right story to tell. WNBA star, Jazz is losing her sense of self post injury and looking for purpose for her and best friend / coach, Harper. When she runs into Marion at a NBA game,she suggests telling Coach Harper’s story. After diving into Harper’s story playing for one of the first recognized women’s team, Marion is instantly enamored with her story. Feeling inspired again, the three embark on creating this Instant Classic.

I really enjoyed reading Coach Harper’s story, and seeing the impact both she and Jazz had on each other was so sweet. Fagan did a great job creating a deeply emotional story that you wanted to root for. While Marion wasn’t my favorite character, I did enjoy seeing the growth in her relationship with her mom. Seeing her shift to not needing her father’s approval was very satisfying.
I enjoyed the dual timelines but did feel this was a touch too long and that some of the current timeline could’ve been condensed. Overall, I enjoyed this book and would recommend it.

Extra half star for the pug representation in this book 🫶

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for liv.
96 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 13, 2026
One of my goals this year is to read more books with sapphic couples and more especially lesbian couples and this book hits that goalpost several times and beautiful so.

There so many elements here, Hollywood and women's basketball and what happens after the audience is not longer looking and how to be queer in both those spaces throughout history and how to survive it authentically to the best of your abilities.

Despite feeling like some chapters just ended a tad too abruptly for me, I overall loved how Kate Fagan constructed this story. We get to live it with Harper as she's telling it to Marion since we travel in time as the events unveil and I felt like that made a big difference in how we connect with those characters.

Instant Classic is one more instance where we can see how representation matters, not only queer but also female representation where we are repeatedly told it's not our place, sports is just one more prevalent occasion. Kate Fagan affirms and shows in an achingly beautiful way that we deserve to be where we want to be, when we went to be in and with who want to be with.

Thank you to Netgalley and Atria Books for providing me with this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Profile Image for Julia Gonsalves.
29 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 24, 2026

I loved this!!

Going into Instant Classic, I wasn’t sure how much I’d connect with a story centered around basketball, but it ended up being about so much more than sports. It’s really about legacy, identity, and making sure the stories of women who came before us don’t get forgotten. That was easily my favorite part of the book.

I also loved the friendships and the relationships throughout the story. Everything felt genuine, and I found myself rooting for the characters. The multiple timelines were a little confusing for me at first, and it took a while to really get into, but once everything started connecting, I was hooked. The ending especially pulled everything together so well.

The only reason this wasn’t a five-star read for me is that I wish I’d connected with some of the characters a little sooner. It felt like it took me a while to become emotionally invested, but once I did, I was really glad I stuck with it.

Overall, this was a thoughtful, unique read that shines a light on a part of sports history I didn’t know much about. I’d definitely recommend it, even if you’re not a basketball fan.

Thank you to Atria Books and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review..
Profile Image for Amanda.
260 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 31, 2026
See, this is the sapphic sports romance I've been looking for (and so much more... +hollywood+small town+coming out). I can't wait to get my hands on multiple copies and make everyone I know read this. If you liked HR for the love story, you have to read this one.

Jaz and Marion's love story is beautiful and is told intertwined with flashbacks to the 1950's with Harper's story which is absolutely amazing.

Stuffed with the history of women's basketball and how the game has changed and evolved from how it was played 70 years ago to today. (Including how class, race and sex were addressed.) I'm not sure how much of this is based on history but everything I looked up read true so I think this was highly researched and incredibly informative (without being dry.) This made me want to watch basketball and nothing makes me want to watch basketball...

There's sisterhood, found family, the importance of a good support system and also gay awakening, working through comp het and the YEARNING!!!!

This reminded me of Last Night at the Telegraph Club and A League of Their Own which I'm just going to go and rewatch until this gets made into a movie or TV show.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for my gifted EARC!
Profile Image for Rachael Fronduti.
75 reviews
October 20, 2026
“How did you know, and how long have you known, and how many more people like us exist? And the most important question: would it all be okay?”

As someone with a complicated relationship with sports in books, I wasn’t sure what to expect going into this. But I enjoyed The Three Lives of Cate Kay enough that it felt like it was worth a shot. And I was right!

I was not expecting to get so sucked into a gut wrenching queer coming of age story that really reminded me why representation - across the board - is so important. Why we are so lucky to have books, just like this one, to make you feel seen. It reminded me that so many generations before us didn’t even have the luxury of knowing they weren’t alone, whether that be in queerness, or anything else that might make someone feel like an “other.” The dual timelines, love story within a love story and found family came together SO beautifully. This book just *did something* to me, and I’ll be thinking about it for a long time.

Long story short: I love women. I love queer women and queer love. I only occasionally like sports, but I wholeheartedly loved this book.

—————
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review!
Profile Image for Micah.
338 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 28, 2026
3.5 -- Firstly, I want to thank netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I will be honest, I went into this book completely blind, I saw the cover, name, and author and I was immediately interested in whatever the story could be. Despite this, I was pleasantly surprised with how much I enjoyed this story. I thought it was very unique to be able to follow Harper's story not only through the flashbacks but also through her retellings and then alternatively Marion's adaptation. I also think in general that there needs to be more stories like this that put women athletes at the forefront and highlight the things they had to sacrifice to get women's sports where it is today. I also enjoyed the dynamics the author provided with having three different women that are all connected to basketball but in different stages because it allows you to gain a better perspective of the world. This book is not perfect, especially when it comes to some of the pacing, but I still would recommend this story to a friend.
Profile Image for Essie.
78 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 31, 2026
A feel-good story about a feel-good movie, this was an emotional tale of love, basketball, and fighting for what you believe in.

One of the most striking things to me about this book was how it covered three different age groups: young adult, middle-age (late thirties), and senior. I enjoyed what little there was in the historical timeline, especially queerness and lesbianism in that time period, as well as what it was like being a woman.

Fagan's writing, as always, was great. My issue was the pacing for the first half of the book. It was a very, very slow build up. Once I hit the fifty-percent mark, however, it finally picked up and closed out strong.

I'm not a huge fan of the romance genre, but after the pace picked up, I truly enjoyed this book. The chemistry and slow burn yearning between Marion and Jaz was great. I would recommend this to those who enjoy a good slow burn sapphic romance as well as moving expositions.

Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for an eARC.
Profile Image for Laura.
102 reviews2 followers
October 13, 2026
Thankyou to Netgalley and Bloomsbury Publishing for the advanced copy of this book.

Wow. An author is not read before and I went in blind, but Instant Classic felt both personal and bigger than itself.
The way Fagan she weaves the threads together is what impressed me most. Nothing feels random or tacked on, and by the end it all fits together.

One small touch I especially loved was Ivys choice of name for her shop; it took the story right back round to a part that had famished as the movie developed.

I'm always drawn to stories about women in sports and in fields that society has spent so long telling them they didn't belong in. This book honors that experience without turning it into a lecture. It's engaging and moving, and it left me thinking about how much of the story has gone untold.
I took off half a star only because I wanted more. I wasn't ready for it to end. Highly recommended for sports fans, and for anyone who loves a well-told story about women breaking through.
869 reviews21 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 12, 2026
I was asked by NetGalley to review this book- I read and reviewed The Three lives of Katie Cay so was intrigued to read this story.

This story is about three women who are connected by the sport basketball and complex lives, relationships, family and life in general.
Marion who played basketball in college and now hoping to get into the film industry whilst having difficulty with her sexuality as well as her difficult relationship with her parents. There is Harper who left the sport as at the time being gay was frowned upon and she was spotted in a lesbian bar with a woman she loved. Then there is Jaz a current basketball player who has been mentored by Harper after Jaz mother passed away.

The characters are real, emotional, showing how socirty and womens sports have come a long way and still have a journey to go.

Well written and from a great author so recommended.

Due for publication at the end of January 2027.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 71 reviews