Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow: Stories

Rate this book
Vivid stories of hard-partying Chicago trans women in the 2020s—right here, right now

AN ABA INDIE NEXT PICK FOR NOV 2026

"As refreshing as an ice-cold beer, and well worth savoring.”
—Kirkus (starred review)


"Delicious, fabulous writing—devoured this in one sitting."
—Kristen Arnett, New York Times-bestselling author of Stop Me If You've Heard This One


Agnes can’t deal with the coke and the whiskey. Joan’s been getting a little success, it’s not really working out for her. Sybil’s still insane, I saw her last week at the bars, she was screaming at Sara. Maybe actually someone screamed at her when she tried to make fun of Clara for not shaving her eyebrows correctly. It was just before she got hit by that car. Jenny and Joan had to pick her up from Thorek Memorial. Freddie’s still Freddie, but I heard her mom showed up at some point. Just on her doorstep. Orla and Kate finally got around to dating. They broke up though. Carolina? Well she got that job with the Sanitation department, and she hasn’t really been around since.

In this crackling collection of stories, Sloane Murphy shows a beautiful and wrecked scene of young Chicago trans women. With the clairvoyance of Michelle Tea and the precision of Raymond Carver, Shut Up, I Love You, I’ll Call You Tomorrow is a conduit of bleary electricity inside a stubborn, still-beating heart.

152 pages, Kindle Edition

Published November 10, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Sloane Murphy

1 book1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
28 (45%)
4 stars
24 (38%)
3 stars
9 (14%)
2 stars
1 (1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews
Profile Image for Chloe.
388 reviews822 followers
Review of advance copy
November 8, 2026
Probably my favorite thing that Little Puss has yet published. I started it last night and read it in a single sitting. Reminiscent of early Michelle Tea, like Valencia for trans women. I love party stories that feature all the good and bad about that lifestyle. An incredibly fast read but one I know I'll be coming back to again and again.
Profile Image for Demetri Papadimitropoulos.
1,090 reviews165 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 6, 2026
Knowing Someone Is Not the Same as Knowing How to Care for Them
Sloane Murphy's "Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow" Examines the Fault Lines Between Intimacy and Responsibility in a Crowded, Funny, Sometimes Painfully Inattentive Community
By Demetris Papadimitropoulos | November 5th, 2026

Difficult people are easy enough to catalogue, if you confuse gossip with acquaintance. In Sloane Murphy's "Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow," gossip travels faster than anyone can check it: who slept with whom, who quit her job, who said something unforgivable at a party, and which nickname belongs to which Carolina. Across nine linked stories about trans women in the early 2020s, Murphy draws an awkward distinction between knowing everyone's business and knowing whether anyone is all right. Her characters can reconstruct a breakup from three sources and a rumor, then fail to notice that the person who always answers the telephone is coming apart. A rumor can cross a crowded room in seconds; a warning may not make it across town.

Everyone arrives halfway through a conversation. Agnes, hungover for a second day and aware of what this says about her drinking, nevertheless goes to Lana's party because staying home would constitute an admission. Joan, a former lover, can joke with her now that their attempt at a relationship has ended; Edie, whom Agnes still wants, remains maddeningly available to other people. Everyone seems to know how the others got here, but their accounts have contradictory endings. You hear a scandal first, then ask the teller's name. After a while that order starts to matter.

Murphy names the opening story "In Control of the Situation," then lets each new drink test that boast. Agnes's blunt recognition – "Fuck. I've got a problem." – arrives before the story has gathered its full momentum. Her answer is to get dressed for Lana's party, where another drink will be easier to justify than another hour alone. She insists upon the distinction between sexualizing herself and being sexualized by somebody else: what matters is who controls the situation. She is right about the difference. That is the uncomfortable joke: she can defend her consent more articulately than she can defend the choices that follow. Her words insist on a clear border between choosing and being chosen; her evening makes the border look porous. Edie’s renewed affection arrives alongside another line of the drug Agnes meant to avoid. The kiss is consolation and, perhaps, one more reason to postpone going home.

Elsewhere the evenings belong to open mics and the mornings to restaurant shifts. Joan's comic aggression is partly aesthetic choice, partly armor. When she becomes an opening act for the established comedian Chris Panos, a hostile audience encounter circulates online, and her career abruptly begins to look viable. Joan wants the jokes to count; strangers want a symbol, a fantasy, an enemy, or a personal confidante. The heckler and the admirer can circulate the same clip while claiming opposite meanings for it. The attention pays, making it harder for Joan to refuse the terms on which it arrives. Joan is not foolish to suspect that the audience is already rewriting the contract under which she performs.

The bookings multiply. So do the people who believe Joan now owes them a reply. Joan becomes more visible to people who have never met her and less available to the people who have. She bristles at becoming a trans celebrity yet has exquisite contempt for the followers whose enthusiasm is helping her pay the bills. Joan needs an audience; what she cannot decide is how much of her it has bought. A sold-out room cannot distinguish admirers of her jokes from admirers of the spectacle. A comedian who can make a hostile room laugh may still find a private conversation intolerable.

Responsibility gets ugly on the train with Joan and Carolina. In "What Else Do I Have?," Joan and Carolina, formerly partners, undertake the practical errand of collecting a woman with an injured leg from the hospital. As they travel, Joan complains that admirers who pay for sexual content also expect advice, intimacy, even maternal reassurance. "I can't mother a country," she says. Carolina's telephone contains requests to fix a drain, offers and requests surrounding food, inquiries about informal resources, and messages arranging the movements of friends. Murphy places these messages against Joan's complaint, so that the reader has to keep both inventories open at once: the paid intimacies Joan wants to limit and the unpaid errands Carolina scarcely knows how to refuse. Carolina cannot issue an invoice for the hours those messages will take. Answering makes her necessary. It also leaves less of her to go around.

It would be easier to endorse Carolina's grievance if she did not so often teach others what to want. Her answer to Joan's protest is an accusation: "You don't mother anyone, Joan." The same verb turns accusatory in opposite directions. Joan hears strangers claiming ownership; Carolina hears somebody denying the simplest obligation to help. Carolina says it before she means to. Joan hears the old argument begin again; the narration declines to award either woman the last word. Yet Carolina has also been known to turn assistance into instruction, and Joan has been known to mistake a request for ordinary reciprocity for an attack on her autonomy. Joan was exhausted after long hours cooking for strangers; Carolina was exhausted by having to cook at home. Both remember the labor that belonged to them more vividly than the labor done by the other. Neither invents the hurt; each omits a little of the burden she laid upon the other. An argument about the duties of a public figure becomes, without changing its vocabulary, a quarrel about who cooked dinner when they lived together.

Perhaps their marriage was always going to end up back at the stove. Carolina once tried to teach Joan to cook although Joan worked professionally as a cook. Joan has meanwhile written a play about their history. Carolina objects to the figure she has become in somebody else's art, a mothering nuisance whose demands seem absurd once assigned lines and staged for an audience. Freddie, who saw the reading, reportedly admired the play while noticing that Joan had altered the history. Carolina tells Joan Freddie hated it. Even the verdict on the play arrives in a falsified version. The narration gives us Freddie's actual assessment, revealing how Carolina has sharpened an ambivalent verdict into an insult. The collection itself plays a subtler version of Joan's dangerous game: somebody has to decide which of the competing stories will be told.

A familiar name can arrive long before a person does. Murphy can introduce a friend through the remembered shape of her jaw, a strange outfit, a few seconds of gossip, or an ill-advised nickname. Chicago is not a decorative set of neighborhood references: a train determines when an argument must pause, a truck makes an emergency errand possible, and a former haunt can disappear when somebody loses a job. Joan's secondhand pickup is simultaneously a pleasure purchased with touring money and a means of doing something useful for someone else. Car keys, fare, groceries, steady hands: here care has an inventory, and somebody must pay for it.

Party politics grow suddenly less important when someone bleeds. "The Beer Drinkers Vs. The Puppy Mill" turns an argument about generations within the scene into a study of social rank. The labels North and South, invented to distinguish two Carolinas, are so ineffectual that they almost cease to distinguish anyone. Maggie cuts her hand, and the factions suddenly have tasks: find supplies, clear the table, hold still. The woman whose competence matters now is not the one who had the sharpest insult. These women may quarrel over who belongs, but they know how to help when a bottle breaks. The scene will look different after Carolina's last story, where no one can simply clean the wound and send everybody back to their beers.

A different kind of courage appears in "God, Please Let Us Go On This Way," where a sexually exuberant bathhouse visit leaves Orla face to face with Kate, whom she has been avoiding. Their argument turns on a particular indignity: Orla has taken Kate's possible rejection so seriously that she has denied Kate the opportunity to respond at all. Kate questions whether constant pleasure can replace the quieter demands of a relationship; Orla argues that the freedom to desire openly is itself beautiful. Orla apologizes, Kate receives the apology, and their former romance is not restored by verbal effort alone. For a few minutes Orla listens without preparing an exit. She finally gives Kate the choice her silence had denied her, even though the answer need not be yes.

Distance between generations changes the register, not the quarrel. "Hello Daughter" follows Lori visiting Freddie, her adult daughter, with whom years of arguments about transition, appearance, and parental authority have accumulated. Her conviction that a mother's history must count as knowledge becomes a claim upon Freddie's body. Freddie's answer, that being a daughter does not make her an extension of her mother, briefly jolts Lori: she recognizes her own younger voice, once directed at her mother Doris. The argument does not evaporate, but the discovery makes it impossible to cast one generation as the sole custodian of independence. They order another round. The disagreement is still on the table with the glasses. For one evening, they can be mother and daughter without winning the argument, or demanding that the other woman declare it settled.

In "Pretty Girls Get Treated Better," the narrative stays close to Sybil long enough to expose her without rescuing her. Sybil thinks about the advantage of being more conventionally attractive, fears becoming old in a scene that continually replenishes itself with younger people, and tries to keep Megan's attention while using the company around them as a mirror. When she is harassed online, she cannot bear being understood as masculine because, in her own taxonomy, that insult should belong to other women. Sybil hears common sense coming out of her mouth. Megan and the others hear cruelty, and the silence after her pronouncement lasts longer than the joke. When Megan moves a few paces ahead of her on the walk home, the physical distance makes visible what Sybil still refuses to understand.

Most jokes here come with years of permissions the reader has never witnessed being granted. Familiarity permits brutal candor but also makes it possible to evade tenderness through performance. The prose is profane and fast on its feet, thick with references inherited from years of shared talk. The distance between a joke and an accusation can be no longer than a breath. The close third person borrows the speaker's slang and impatience, often making us comfortable with her account just before somebody else punctures it. The missing fact may come from somebody scarcely noticed in the first telling. The second perspective is corrective but not omniscient. We have to revise our judgments while still knowing less than a person would need to act with certainty. When it falters, the same abundance of talk can make separate voices blur into the collective sound of a room.

In so crowded a book, recognition is sometimes mistaken for development. The Joan-Carolina stories return to shared experiences from opposing angles until the reader understands why neither account can be sufficient. "Circles," whose visitor Sue wants both new experiences and freedom from being known too well, is the clearest test. Agnes's drunken arrival, then illness, turns the promised sexual adventure into an absurd embarrassment. Through Sue's position the reader feels what it is to believe oneself central to an encounter and discover the other participants possess a history that will always outrank one's expectations. Sue has mistaken an invitation to a bed for admission to a history. Yet its revelation is comparatively narrow, and its anticlimax does not achieve the cumulative force of the book's more sustained relationships. Still, it is Maggie, not a new lover, who walks away with Sue laughing; the episode has the shape of a failed seduction and the aftertaste of an old friendship.

There are returns that alter a character, and returns that merely jog the memory. Murphy frequently asks readers to carry names, relationships, and references between stories, and sometimes the reward is an altered interpretation: the exuberant figure from an earlier party emerges as someone frightened or exhausted; the dependable helper acquires a history of resentment. The social world can become an end in itself, as though Murphy were reluctant to decide which encounters survive the cut. The problem arises when an episode introduces its tensions so persuasively that its conclusion seems content to confirm them. Remembering who was there cannot always justify the time spent with them.

Recording all these voices, however, is part of Murphy's stated ambition. In her June 2026 reporting for the Chicago Sun-Times, Violet Miller reported that Murphy wanted to preserve the everyday voices and social experience of trans women for those who might come afterward. The wish to leave such a record complicates any easy complaint about sprawl. Still, an overheard conversation does not become a finished story simply because it would be a shame to lose it. In the strongest pieces, the chatter is made to change meaning; in the weaker ones, we are only asked to remember that we heard it. The burden of selection is literary; it says nothing about whose life deserves remembering.

One can also become trapped by a successful act. Joan's comedy persona shields and markets her, Sue invents identities to avoid letting lovers know her, Sybil stages attractiveness as superiority, and Agnes's party jokes briefly conceal a desperate desire to be chosen. The act works beautifully until somebody wants to know who will show up after it ends. When Joan writes a play about her relationship with Carolina, the problem becomes literal: an artist's right to shape experience collides with another person's right to object to her own representation. Murphy cannot exempt her own fiction from the problem she makes Joan perform.

Precarity has no interest in a moving apology; rent is due on schedule. Orla's unemployment helps explain why she hides from Kate; Joan's paychecks change what she can imagine; Carolina cannot keep assisting everybody after losing the work that supported her. Friends can offer a ride, lend money, find a room, share food, or arrange a medical errand; they cannot always supply stability, and the distribution of such labor is neither neutral nor fair. The more reliably she answers, the easier it becomes for everyone to assume that she will go on answering. She can be controlling as well as generous; the women she advises are not automatically obliged to become better versions of her plans.

One objection to all this accounting is that the parties really are fun. Orla and Kate prove that an apology can have value without securing forgiveness in the form the apologizer wants. Orla has hurt Kate, then does something better than finding an excuse. It changes a conversation, not an entire life. The characters keep returning to bars and apartments for a little longer not because they are too foolish to leave a dysfunctional world but because this world is also theirs: funny, desired, inventive, hospitable, and full of people who remember the worst thing they ever did. It can also be the reason somebody comes looking when a familiar face disappears.

Under all that chatter, Carolina's departure from Chicago might be mistaken for one more change of address. In "Our Lady of Perpetual Help," Carolina has left Chicago for Missouri, lost the ordinary coordinates of her social life, and taken work at a go-kart track. Joan’s visit begins with jokes, including an absurd little beer-can figure in the trailer, and proceeds through the familiar dodge of discussing everyone except the people present. Then Carolina asks whether Agnes has died. Joan knows otherwise: Agnes is alive, attempting sobriety and a more stable life. Carolina, who once seemed to know everyone's needs, has been carrying an imagined death while Agnes has quietly moved beyond her sight.

Learning that Agnes lives resolves one dreadful uncertainty. It does nothing for Carolina's lost job or the money and food other people keep asking her to supply. Her days have narrowed until she can imagine a tornado destroying the trailer more readily than she can imagine growing old. Joan is angry because she was frightened, and frightened because she remains attached to someone she has spent considerable energy resenting. "I don't hate you," she tells Carolina, before interrupting the apparent generosity with the admission that Carolina makes friendship difficult. The insult and the affection occupy the same breath. The drive leaves Joan with a friend whose survival cannot be secured through a single intervention. She can, at least, refuse to make her fear a reason for staying away.

Once, Carolina pictured an old woman in a field and recognized herself. She could even pass that image along to younger women who struggled to imagine surviving into old age. She cannot make herself believe in the destination that once made the present bearable. In that earlier image the future seemed habitable. Here there are only boards beneath two pairs of feet. After the hardest admissions they return to the absurdly ordinary business of hormone injections, then sit together by the water. A syringe does not settle any argument, but the shared routine asks both women to remain in the same immediate hour, rather than bargain with an imagined future. Even the apparent stillness refuses to hold: after the sentence about waiting, the women begin teasing one another again. The conversation does not obediently end when the image has made its point. The difference between last July and now remains unspoken. Joan has nonetheless made the journey to ask.

Silence is hard to earn among people who can turn a confession into a bit before anybody has stopped crying. These women have invented a common language of interruption, flirtation, mockery, and extravagant affection, and that language has helped them make a home. At the dock the jokes survive, yet the women eventually have to say what frightened them without waiting for a punchline. Knowing a friend's nickname, a comedian's best bit, or a former lover's humiliating story is not the same as knowing what to do when the person stops answering. But that shared history is also what lets Joan find the trailer. Years of uneven affection have brought Joan where a perfect diagnosis could not: she came.

Despite the reckless evenings, the pettiness, and the competitive cruelty, "Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow" is finally more interested in the unfinished work that follows pleasure than in either celebration or punishment. The shorter stories sometimes sketch a mood and exit before it changes; elsewhere the accumulation of familiar faces becomes its own substitute for dramatic pressure. Yet a broken bottle, a grocery request, and a seven-hour drive each reveal a different price attached to the word friend. I rate it 81/100, corresponding mechanically to 4.00/5 on Goodreads. At the dock the sunset does not get the final speech. Carolina recalls last July; Joan asks what difference it would have made. The question remains between them, unanswerable and still worth asking.
Profile Image for anne.
243 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 11, 2026
in a few words ࿐
✧ transfem cast, dykes everywhere
✧ plethora of other queer identities and sexualities
✧ interconnected short stories about different trans women in a friendship group (+ freddie's mom)

stories ࿐
✧ in control of the situation ★★★★
✧ thank you, i've been an open wound ★★★★.5
✧ god, please let us go on this way ★★★★
✧ the beer drinkers vs. the puppy mill ★★★.75
✧ hello daughter ★★★★
✧ what else do i have? ★★★.75
✧ circles ★★★.75
✧ pretty girls get treated better ★★★.5
✧ our lady of perpetual help ★★★★.25
⤷ 3.94★ rounded up to 4★

“Big surprise. There’s literally no way to win. You’re either a whore or you’re mommy.”
“Siobhan, baby, I think we just invented feminism.”
Both of them smile.

thank you to netgalley and littlepuss press for giving me the opportunity to read this e-arc in exchange for my honest opinions!

📅 publication date: 10 nov 2026
Profile Image for Elizabeth Addison.
1,397 reviews24 followers
November 11, 2026
I received an eARC of this book from NetGalley and LittlePuss Press in exchange for an honest review.

I wish this was longer and had more cohesion— it mostly feels like a collection of ideas and the beginning of something more than a complete work. There are /so/ many characters, and many of them are indistinguishable from each other. I had a thought at one point that this would make a great movie or TV show because seeing their faces would really help the rotating cast make more sense and fit more seamlessly. All that being said, I did really enjoy this, and it’s very true to the Chicago experience. Very happy for all these girls fucking and sucking each other all over the city; never felt more hashtag blessed not to be a part of it.
Profile Image for Crystal Odelle.
Author 4 books66 followers
August 5, 2026
Sloane Murphy’s debut short story collection, Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow (LittlePuss Press, 2026), is a smart, brutally funny book about Chicago trans women who would roll their eyes if I called them a community. With terse prose and biting dialogue, Murphy centers big personalities and bigger emotions. Even while fighting each other when tired of fighting against the world, their inside jokes and lasting bonds made me feel apart, less alone. Maybe in reading this book you will, too.
Profile Image for Sam.
457 reviews40 followers
October 7, 2026
Disclaimer: I received an e-ARC from netgalley.

This short story collection features a rotating cast of trans women in Chicago, hanging out together in clubs, bars, house parties, dealing with a surprise visit from one’s mother, picking up a friend from the hospital to drive her home, trying to make it as a comedian, hooking up, gossiping about the girls that aren’t here right now, avoiding a complicated ex, reaching out when somebody goes into hiding or just getting really, really wasted.
Loving, but also bitingly honest about the clashes that can exist when big personalities meet each other, tender when it’s called for and very, very realistic. Many of the characters are flawed, many of them dislike each other in messy, sometimes unfair, sometimes completely understandable ways, but what really makes this collection stand out is how despite all this there is a lot of care among the characters. You wouldn’t need to gossip about her, if you didn’t care about her in some way, after all. Community is not shown as the healing beacon that protects you from transphobia or poverty, but it is still central to your identity and impacts your life and that’s what matters here. Care can exist alongside mockery and relationships (both platonic and romantic) can be ambiguous and still be incredibly important. As a reader I loved getting to know the various characters and I especially adored getting to see who turned up in another short story again, allowing us to see their story from a different perspective or to allow for some development to have occurred between the various short stories.
While there are certainly some short stories that I thought about longer as well as main characters, I found more interesting, I can’t really pick favorites, having enjoyed each short story for its own reasons. Instead, you need to just let these stories take you to the club, allow each woman and her own circumstances to become alive around you and immerse yourself in the various circles of friends, exes, lovers and haters that make up the regulars in a community. All in all, a really great collection that allowed me some interested looks in the lives of a few fascinating characters.

In Control of the Situation: One of the slower pieces in the collection, this short story follows Agnes, a woman who enjoys partying, trying to avoid her ex Edie when some guy keeps trying to chat her up. Thankfully there’s always a beer in her hand. I liked how it very quickly set the scene, filled with colorful characters outlined in gossipy overheard sentences, examined intercommunity trans discourses, while also showing how Agnes dealt with the situation at hand. Really interesting writing, but in comparison to the other pieces this one feels a bit less intriguing to me. It did a great job at making the guy really, utterly annoying.
TW: alcoholism/heavy drinking

Thank You, I’ve been an Open Wound: Joan, a comedian, tries her best to get an in with a semi-famous comedian, currently trying to replace his opener. When she gets the gig, she has to decide if his rightwing audience is something she is willing to put up with. A quite interesting piece, I liked getting to know the characters, I liked the conflict of the main character, I really liked the way being even slightly famous as a trans woman was examined here, all in all this was a really interesting short piece.
TW: queerphobia, transmisogyny

God, Please Let Us Go On This Way: After losing her job, Orla, a butch woman is dragged to the trans cruising event at the gay club by a friend. Avoiding the men and meeting exes, she might have to talk about her feelings after all. Bittersweet and beautiful, I liked how it examined how desirability can be tied to ideas of being financially stable and how you can get so in your head, you might miss out on a good thing right in front of you. I also really enjoyed Orla as the main character, it was interesting to follow her thought process through this evening.
TW: chasers, unwanted sexual advances

The Beer Drinkers Vs. The Puppy Mill: Carolina is spending her evening at a bar, which has recently become a hot spot for trans meetups, to hang out with a few of her friends (some of which, we have met in previous short stories), when a discussion starts about the generational divide between the new girls and the old ones.
TW: injury

Hello Daughter: After not receiving any answers to her texts for a bit, Lori, a concerned mother, shows up at her daughters’ apartment to spend the evening with her. I really liked the way this examined a complicated mother-daughter relationship and how past sentences can still haunt you years after they have been spoken. Really interesting and fraught, tense and loving.
TW: misgendering, suicidal thoughts (past)

What Else Do I Have?: Joan gets a call from Carolina asking her for help picking up an injured woman from the hospital. On the ride there they talk about everything that has changed in their lives since they broke up and Joan stopped really engaging in the local trans community after her comedy gig and online popularity blew up as she became paranoid of how people viewed her now. Really interesting look into a complicated relationship with community. It is also again quite interesting to see how the various people in this community view and talk about each other when you’ve gotten to know them from their own perspectives earlier.

Circles: Sue has to get out of Cleveland for a weekend, needing to get away from how small everything seems, her exes and embarrassing faked orgasms and hits up her old friend Maggie if she can stay with her in Chicago for a bit. She is quickly introduced to the party scene and gets to know a few of the women. I really liked how this one compared transfem party-focused communities in two different places and really illustrated this feeling of meeting people you may have heard one or two stories about, but not enough to know anything specific and then trying to match them up with the stories.
TW: vomit

Pretty Girls Get Treated Better: Sybil (a name I actually remembered from the very first short story for being mentioned in the sentence “Sybil has bypassed all transfeminist thought and basically started a religion where salvation is being one hundred twenty-five pounds and cissexual”) is bored of her girlfriend Megan complaining about their last threesome not going according to her plans and further unsettled by trolls on her social profiles and begins taking it out on her friends. Sybil is certainly one of the messier characters in here, her own pain hidden behind a layer of judgement on others and it was horrifying to watch her steadily pull the mood down.
TW: misgendering, sexual harassment, weight shaming

Our Lady of Perpetual Help: Carolina is in need of a place to stay after losing her job. Calling up her ex Joan, she manages to find one, even if it is in the Ozarks. Without local community, working a dead-end job, ignoring people asking her when she’ll be back, she drifts through the days until Joan shows up so she can finally talk about whatever is keeping her hiding here. A really touching story about how easy it can be to disappear inside your own head and get stuck somewhere.
TW: mention of death and suicide
Profile Image for brokebookmountain.
141 reviews10 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
July 15, 2026
the thing about short story collections is that oftentimes, it's a mixed bag. a huge chunk of short story collections (especially *groans* anthologies) feels like it was just a collection of the author's works over the years (which is the case, most of the time). slap a title of the best story in the collection, and boom, there you go, a collection of short stories. this means a lot of these books tend to be incohesive, with some of the stories being better than the others.

going into shut up, i love you, i'll call you tomorrow, i expected that it'll be probably be just like any other collections out there. i was pleasantly surprised that it's nothing at all like that. murphy writes stories about a cast of eclectic characters, all surrounding trans women in chicago. it's raw, honest, and surprisingly tender. i didn't expect it to be so full of heart, considering that a huge portion of the book talks about orgies and drugs. even with all the nonchalance and bleakness that the characters couldn't help but feel, they still come out of it hoping for something better.

these characters bicker, cry, lie, pretend, and judge each other, but despite it all, they care for each other with all of their heart could afford. and i think that's such a beautiful thing to write about. of course, these characters aren't flawless little angels; there were so many characters that i couldn't help but roll my eyes to. still, i couldn't help but love them. sloane murphy wrote these characters with so much love and care, it's no surprise that i ended up loving them too. shut up, i love you, i'll call you tomorrow sits in the ranks of short story collections that i will fondly keep in my memories, just like The Secret Lives of Church Ladies, With the Heart of a Ghost: Stories, and People Who Talk to Stuffed Animals Are Nice: Stories.

that being said, i do believe some of the stories are weaker than the other ones. my favorites are The Beer Drinkers Vs. The Puppy Mill, Thank You, I've Been An Open Wound, Hello Daughter (my favorite!!!!), What Else Do I Have?, and Our Lady of Perpetual Help. i think the other stories are interesting, but these favorites of mine are just *chef's kisses*.

thank you to littlepuss press and edelweiss for the e-arc. also: littlepuss press has some interesting books in their collection! definitely anticipating great stories from this publisher.
Profile Image for Kiera.
130 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 7, 2026
Shut up, I Love You, I’ll Call You Tomorrow by Sloane Murphy is a bold, reflective set of short stories. Telling the stories of trans women in 2020s Chicago, each chapter gives us a window into what feels like real people’s lives. These women’s stories feel so grounded in reality that they could be happening in Chicago while you’re reading. The reader takes on a spectator role in their messy, realistic lives, which all link together through their community with one another. I keep thinking about the short story Hello Daughter about Lori, who visits her daughter Freddie after not seeing her for a while after her transition. The mother’s perspective adds an interesting texture to the story, making the examination of their mother-daughter relationship tender and striking. I found it easy to read this book in one sitting if I wanted to, but I could also put it down and pick it back up without guilt or loss, since each story is different even when intertwined. Having this book centred around trans women as well was something that pulled me in, as there are not many books dedicated solely to trans women’s stories. Shut up, I Love You, I’ll Call You Tomorrow highlights that, like every other community, these women all have their own stories to tell which deserve to be heard, platformed and protected. If you’re looking for a read about the realistic, complex, beautiful mess that is life, I recommend this!

Thank you to NetGalley, LittlePuss Press, and the author, Sloane Murphy, for this ARC!!
Profile Image for Chloë Jackson.
398 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 28, 2026
Here is a blurb i wrote for this book:
“ What a beautiful ode to staying alive. I read Shut Up I Love You in Ubers in between lesbian parties and on the couch of my messy apartment and at the desk of my bookstore job. And between it all, i fell in love again and again with the Midwest — a place I’m not native to but has held me in a way nowhere else has. It is in the Chicago queer party scene that I found myself, terrified of the future and unsure about my present and nonetheless held by the flashing lights and the cigs between sets and saying hi to the same gay guys i always saw. Shut Up I Love You honors gay Chicago so damn eloquently, with heart and truth and all the scariness in between. What a beautiful archive of the ephemeral Sloane Murphy has created. Required reading.”

And here is a bit more. I mean every word of that. I also mean i have been terrified and alive and felt fearful and felt happy in chicago clubs. And I’ve found bits of myself in so many sections of them. What a beautiful exploration of queer life through interconnected stories. I felt lost in some places but found in others. The story was not all for me so there’s no way I’ll understand all of it. But i found myself in so many bits of it. And i found myself feeling so wonderfully alive despite it all. 4.75 stars
Profile Image for Max.
224 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 29, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Casey Plett for providing me a arc copy of Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow for an honest review. If you want to read a book about a strong LGBTQIA+ community, this is the one to go to. I liked how each mini story focused on one of the different characters that normally attends the parties and how their life entwines with the other characters, some more then others. I also liked the exploration on how minorities are pushed to focus on being the first blank ever in this feild. The example of Joan being good at comedy and being trans, and how being trans garners her attention rather then just being a good comedian really me understand the frustrations someone may face in said scenarios. As a gay person I feel as though my sexuality is a strong part of my identiy due to wanting to be represenation for my community, but i'm bigger then just what I prefer, i'm my own human. This book goes to show that while indiviuals may not what to be put in a box. They could potentially have to overcome the public forces that try to push them in said position. I would recommend this book to people that like books with strong communities, modern messages, and short story collections. Happy reading!
Profile Image for Siobhan.
Author 3 books124 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 21, 2026
Shut Up, I Love You, I'll Call You Tomorrow is a collection of short stories about a group of trans women in Chicago, following their parties and interpersonal dramas. Each story follows a particular character, but the women all appear in each others' stories too, and the stories move forward in time, meaning that you build up tiny pictures of the characters as you make your way through the collection.

This is like getting to live vicariously through someone else's friend group drama: you start to learn things about the major players, you can't always remember who everyone is, but you're interested nonetheless. My personal favourite parts were Joan's attempts to make it in her comedy career (which looks at the state of modern comedy and what you have to give of yourself for fame) and the final story in the collection, exploring trying to disappear (and the darkly comic failure of just hoping a tornado will do the work for you).

The collection consciously never quite gives you everything, refusing to fill in every gap or explain who people are. Instead, you have to let the tangled drama take over.
Profile Image for lyraand.
264 reviews64 followers
November 11, 2026
(This review is based on an advanced reader’s copy provided by Edelweiss.)

This is slice-of-life fiction set in mid-2020s Chicago (with a couple stories set in St. Louis, MO). All the stories are about a group of trans women who are friends with each other and date each other, with the same characters appearing in multiple stories. My reaction to the first two stories was “This is plenty readable, but not much happens, and then the stories just sort of end, at some arbitrary-feeling point,” but then I really liked the rest of them. My favorite, counterintuitively, was “hello daughter,” from the POV of the (cis) mom of a trans woman.

For some reason I want to say this book has kind of an autofiction-y feel, even though none of the characters share a name or profession with the author. Maybe I just associate slice-of-life contemporary litfic with autofiction.

If you liked this book, read Electra Mordinson!

Content notes: Suicidal ideation. Graphic description of vomiting. Recreational drug use.
Profile Image for Mint.
107 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 23, 2026
Have you ever been at a party where everyone kinda knows each other and it's getting a little late but it's fine because you know the people around you (mostly) have your back and it's too interesting to leave? No? Well, you'll feel it when you read this.
This isn't a book to read if you want a fast-paced plot, but there are good character moments and each individual story stands strongly within the wider narrative. I especially liked how this showed the relationships between the characters; that chaotic-ness of being in your twenties and figuring out a hundred things at once, very aware that everyone else is both better than you and in exactly the same place. And of figuring out who you are, on top of that - who you want to be, how you exist in a way you can live with in a space that can hold you.
I received an ARC from NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Rhys.
124 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Edelweiss+
July 25, 2026
This was really good. Authentic, funny, emotional, and complicated. There's a large cast and sometimes I had to flip back to try and piece together who all the characters were, but I still feel like all the women in this were so complex and well-written. There's so many issues and struggles explored without any characters feeling like mouthpieces anything. This is a short read but I feel like each story was just long enough. Several stories made me snort-laugh while reading and the last story made me tear up. Also, if you, too, are from Chicago (or the area) and/or have spent enough time in Chicago you'll love going "Yeah, I know where that is" as we all seem to do when we read stories taking place in Chicago and what's better than that?
Profile Image for Rachael.
527 reviews33 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 2, 2026
CW: transphobia, self-harm (mentioned), blood, drug use, alcohol, addiction, toxic relationship (recounted), domestic violence, vomit (mentioned), body shaming (mentioned), fatphobia (mentioned), alcoholism (recounted), emotional abuse

I would like to thank NetGalley and Little Puss Press for providing me with a free e-ARC of this book in exchange for a fair and honest review.

As a whole, this was a pretty solid short story collection. Murphy has a unique and distinctive voice as she weaves the lives of a group of trans women in Chicago together and the community they build together that extends throughout the Midwest. My only issue with the book was that it was hard to keep track of some of the characters and their backstories at times, but other than that I enjoyed the book.
Profile Image for Lori.
86 reviews
July 9, 2026
I loved the title of this book and was so excited to read it. I love getting the opportunity to read LGBTQIA+ books. Once I started, I didn’t quite know what was going on/felt like it was all over the place. I was thrilled there was a variety of characters included, but I just couldn’t get involved in the story enough to want to stick through the entire thing. This might be for some, but sadly wasn’t for me.
I was gift a copy of this book by #NetGalley for review. All opinions expressed are my own. #SUILY
Profile Image for The Queer Librarian.
38 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 22, 2026
I’m so excited for people to read this book. It’s a series of interconnected short stories that really brings a community of trans women in Chicago to life. I loved the little nuggets connecting the different stories, the cynicism and yet hope present throughout and the clarity of writing. There wasn’t really fluff here. Each story was important and surfaced something about the community. We need more stories like this — where trans people get to be whole, messy, imperfect people. What a great fucking book!!
Profile Image for Rhian.
35 reviews
August 30, 2026
Thank you to Netgalley for the advance copy

-4.5 stars-

I’m genuinely surprised by how such a short book managed to pull me so completely into these characters’ lives. At times, it felt less like reading about them and more like actually being there, catching glimpses of their conversations, relationships and at times, messy, lives.

The characters felt wonderfully real and the writing had such an intimate, conversational quality. Murphy somehow manages to pack so much life, humour and heart into so few pages. A little book that left a much bigger impression than I expected.
Profile Image for PT.
62 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 27, 2026
sisters are rly doing it 4 themselves

Lots of fabulous idiosyncratic characters make up the Greek chorus of SUILYICYT. I'm endeared by the true to life depiction of what it feels like to be ensnared in the quixotic web of a trans community.

Feels like I know these girls, and honestly, I might. I love Chicago(land) and I love transgender. Thank you Sloane Murphy for putting pen to paper and thank you littlepuss press for sending this message to the universe!
Profile Image for Viktor.
108 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 16, 2026
This story collection captures and depicts a wide range of experiences and beliefs in the transfeminine community and bares it all: the good, the bad, and every unimaginable thing in between. Every person knows that mess is a part of life, but these effervescent vignettes are a riot that will endear readers to all the very human characters. Fans of Torrey Peters and Maggie Nelson will enjoy this book!
Profile Image for Amanda.
259 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 2, 2026
An absolute fever dream of a book filled with a ton of characters each with their own interlocking part of the story. I feel like it went by so fast and yet, I got so much from it at the same time. I'm not usually a fan of short story collections but I loved this one because they show how connected we all are, even when we don't know it.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for my gifted EARC.
Profile Image for Dean.
26 reviews
September 4, 2026
Although it was a little hard to keep track of everyone in this book, I enjoyed it so much. All of the conversations felt so real and there's such a sense of a lived in community that has experienced so much together. Everything was interwoven nicely, as real life often is, that I could fully believe that these were women who had spent years going through thick and thin together.

Protect the dolls <3
Profile Image for em.
716 reviews107 followers
September 22, 2026
3.5
A great short story collection with interlinked characters and arcs. I enjoyed some more than others, in particular the stories that focused on Freddie and Joan. Some parts were a little overwhelming, with so much happening at once it was hard to understand what exactly had happened, but overall an enjoyable read. Protect the dolls!

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for kindly providing an ARC in exchange for an honest review. #SUILY #NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Rose.
240 reviews112 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 20, 2026
This was fun but I did find the characters all kind of blended together and I found them hard to picture. The most distinctive were definitely Joan and Freddie who I felt had the best stories. I would have liked a bit more plot, not very much happened, and it was all very slice of life. Overall though I enjoyed the depiction of trans dykes in chicago!

Thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the eARC.
862 reviews5 followers
Want to Read
November 14, 2026
Andover - Memorial Hall Library
XX(1739490.4) 1739490-4001
Being acquired by the library
Book
Dracut - Moses Greeley Parker Memorial Library
PB/MURPHY 31482003234971
Due 12/4/26
Book
Groton Public Library
XX(1739490.1) 1739490-1001
Being acquired by the library
Book
Ipswich Public Library
FIC MURPHY, SLOANE 32122003256546
Being cataloged
New books
Lowell - Pollard Memorial Library
FIC MURPHY 31481006184167
Due 12/4/26
Profile Image for Squash (Lex).
51 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy
June 29, 2026
This is such a wonderful collection of short stories. Because all the stories revolve around the same group of trans women in Chicago, by the end of the book you really feel like they're all your friends, too. I enjoyed getting so many different types of POVs: the girls who have been around the scene and their group of friends for years, newbies, girls who are visiting, a parent. Each new POV honed in on the details of one or two girls, but also gave new opinions and observations on others which fleshed everyone in the entire book out. The characters just felt so real! Also as someone living in Chicago I enjoyed reading it and being able to say "Oh I've been there, oh I know where that is!" about a lot of the locations mentioned in this book. This is a quick, fun, emotional read. These girls felt like I could run into them on the street, like I knew versions of them in real life.

Advance review copy received at American Library Association conference.
Profile Image for Chelsea.
114 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 10, 2026
I enjoyed this collection, but at times did find the cross over or naming confusing - a double carolina does seem like a challenge just to be challenged. Overall it was a nice peek into the curation and creation of found family. What you may or may not experience as you navigate life and love as a doll in this world.
Profile Image for inapileofyarnandbooks.
65 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
November 2, 2026
Really enjoyed these stories about trans women in Chicago (a place I've spent a lot of time.) Short story collections are always a bit of a mixed bag, and there were some I like more than others for sure, but the interconnected nature really held them together for me.

Thanks to the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Profile Image for Rozuva Phynix.
18 reviews1 follower
Did Not Finish
July 28, 2026
Thank you Netgalley for sending me a copy. I really appreciate it.

Unfortunately I could not get into the writing style so I have to put it down. I have other arcs I’m very excited to read and I don’t want to waste my time reading something I’m not enjoying.
Profile Image for Bridget Bell.
375 reviews25 followers
October 12, 2026
this is a collection of interconnected short stories about a community of trans women. I was invested in a few of the stories and characters, but overall I found myself drowning in the amount of dialogue. I would like to read a longer piece by this author!

thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the eARC.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 37 reviews