Read this because this is a path I'm beginning. It took me a while to get through so I don't remember the beginning parts as well.
It wasn't written recently, so there's a lot of stuff that doesn't carry over quite the same now that the internet exists. I didn't find the stories particularly relatable, particularly the majority who seem to feel favourably about Israel as a modern state or who don't mention it. The way they talk about devotion to G-d also doesn't resonate with me. I think some of it is that no one in there seemed to come from an atheist background specifically, just "no particular religion" and they didn't really talk about reconciling their relationship with religion in contrast with anything like queerness or past religious trauma. For the people in the book, it feels like they just kind of found Judaism and were good. They don't talk about specific aspects of the Jewish community they'd flourished in really — like to me, I could not manage to separate my concept of Judaism from queer Jewish anarchists I know.
I appreciate the concept of this book but it ended up with me feeling only more alienated.
I did like the parts where problematic relationships to Judaism were talked about, and how converts seem to end up being spokespeople for converts and how it isn't just a seamless transition. I wish I'd had more of that.