Normally, I love Sarah Morgan’s books, but this one, I’m afraid, was a real disappointment. I’d read the other book in the series, so I purchased this one in paperback (as it wasn’t available on Kindle), but I really wish I hadn’t bothered.
I’m guessing that’s partly because the book was written back in 2007, and it explains why it feels so dated. And also because I’m so used to the authors doing a much better job with both her characters and her plotting.
The story of Evanna (and where does that name come from?) and Logan, who work together, in a general practice on a Scottish island waswas too twee and unbelievable for me. The heroine is supposed to have been in love with the hero since she was five! 26 years of quietly loving him and doing nothing.
And despite the fact he married, and then was widowed, she has stayed on the island, loving him from afar, like a wet dishcloth instead of leaving a building a life for herself. No other men, no sex, nothing except making herself always available to help him out.she might just as well have laid herself on the ground and invited him to walk over her.
The scene at the barbecue when Logan ignored her new dress, told her she should wear in the ponytail and that flat shoes would be better than the high heels was excruciating. And she just accepted everything he said. Then asked her to look after his daughter on a Wednesday and she just said yes. I wanted to slap her and tell her to grow a backbone. I gave up at that point - I simply couldn’t read any more and skimmed. to the last two pages. And Logan? He has never been aware of her as anything but a good friend. Suddenly he sees her naked and then , only then does he realise he’s attracted to her? No, this did not work for me. I became increasingly annoyed with them both - but especially with her.
The heroine was simply absurd and I was simply annoyed at her. Why on earth had she not got a job on the mainland, and dated other men as a way of curing herself of this impossible infatuation?
I couldn’t believe that she’d put up with unrequited love for so many years and just accepted it without trying to move on. I thought she was unutterably pathetic, and I didn’t empathise with her at all.
Even at the end when Logan was declaring his love, she was refusing to believe him and insisting it had only been sex. So not into this trope never mind, Sarah went on to write, so many brilliant books. I’ll forgive her this one, but I simply wish I’d never read it.
You can see in this book that SM is a good writer but this was not for me.