Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #21

Miss Wolcott's Ghost: Exclusive audio edition read by Alfred Molina

Rate this book
'There's a body in Lost Nation.' But the line goes dead before Chief Inspector Armand Gamache can question the caller.

The head of homicide for the Sûreté du Québec has no idea where Lost Nation is, or who woke him in the small hours of the morning at his home in Three Pines. What he does know is that the man was terrified.

When he and his team of Jean-Guy Beauvoir and Isabelle Lacoste find both place and body, the situation only grows more bizarre. The unidentified dead man appears to be from an era more than a century old. He's lying in a long-abandoned cemetery, on top of a grave with a date, but no name.

Adding to the mystery, the early morning call appears to have come from Gamache's friend and neighbour, Clara Morrow. While she denies any knowledge of it, it becomes clear there is some connection between her, the Morrow family, and Lost Nation.

Soon, Gamache and his team are faced with tracking down not just the legend of Lost Nation, but a lost ship, lost documents belong to an eccentric Victorian botanist, and a mysterious plant not seen in a century, that might save, or take, countless lives.

As the ghosts begin to gather, Gamache realises that the body on the grave is far from the only death. To solve the crime and avert catastrophe he must look to rancid secrets and old lies no longer dead and buried.

Audible Audio

First published October 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Louise Penny

94 books27.7k followers
LOUISE PENNY is the author of the #1 New York Times and Globe and Mail bestselling series of Chief Inspector Armand Gamache novels. She has won numerous awards, including a CWA Dagger and the Agatha Award (seven times), and was a finalist for the Edgar Award for Best Novel. In 2017, she received the Order of Canada for her contributions to Canadian culture. Louise lives in a small village south of Montréal.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
6,372 (53%)
4 stars
4,101 (34%)
3 stars
1,114 (9%)
2 stars
181 (1%)
1 star
54 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 911 reviews
Profile Image for MarilynW.
2,156 reviews4,883 followers
October 25, 2026
Chief Inspector Armand Gamache #21
Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny

I know that Three Pines is not on any map so it's impossible to find for most. But since I began the series from the beginning, years ago, I'd felt like I knew the place, how to get there, and I knew the people. And then the stories got much darker and much more political, with Gamache being the only one who could save the world from the political big bad guys and he wasn't about to tell anyone what he was doing and what he was thinking, but things were so darkly dire because of the rottenness of human kind who didn't think like he thought and I was souring on the series during the latest books. We saw much less of Three Pines and the characters I'd grown to love in the books before this one.

Now I feel like it's been a huge homecoming with this book. To top it off, Alfred Molina, who played Gamache in the short TV series, is narrating this book. I can understand everything he says (except sometimes French words sound like mush to me but that's because of my lack of being able to speak French, that's a me problem). Listening to the story was effortless and fun, especially after seeing Molina as Gamache on TV. There is a slight mention of things maybe turning toward world destroying something or other but you'll have to read/hear the book to see how that works out.

The gang was all here, duck, dogs and humans, we spend a lot of time in Three Pines and I was thrilled. As usual the story is very complex, with lots of moving parts and misdirection, and it takes a team, including some of the citizens of Three Pines, to help to solve what is going on. DeAnn is my constant reading companion for these stories and is the one who got me hooked on Three Pines in the first place, so be sure to check out her thoughts on this latest book.

Published October 20, 2026 by Macmillan Audio

Thanks to my library and Libby for this audiobook.
Profile Image for Robin.
658 reviews91 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
July 10, 2026
It’s been a while. I wasn’t a huge fan of the last two Gamache books, or of the more recent thriller co-written with Melissa Fung, but with Miss Wolcott’s Ghost Louise Penny has returned to the form that has made me a giant supporter of her work. I’ll never forget the spell put on me by her first novel, Still Life, and that reading rapture was gifted to me again with this book. When I hit the three-quarter mark, I was glued to the pages and didn’t leave my chair.

Readers have come to expect many things from Penny’s novels – a complicated, thoughtful plot; wonderful characters; and a resolution that often leaves a lump in your throat (for this reader, in any case). This book does not disappoint on any of these fronts. Set again in Three Pines, the story focuses in on Gamache, Beauvoir, and another character who appears to be despised by both men. His story is teased out through the book, and I won’t provide a spoiler.

The basics: Gamache gets a panicked phone call in the middle of the night, with a caller saying merely “There’s a body in Lost Nation.” That of course is a sentence to launch a good story and it does. First Gamache has to find “Lost Nation” and when he does find it there is indeed a dead body on top of a grave, and the body has plants growing through it.

The plant is as big a mystery as the body itself. It appears to be a plant thought to be extinct, and with great care (and the help of a botanist) Armand transplants it to his own garden. The plant and the body are linked, but it takes the majority of the novel for Gamache and his team to discover exactly how they are connected. Along the way the team also discovers a marine disaster – worse than that of the Titanic – occurring just two years later. The investigation also involves this tragedy. It’s a real occurrence, and you’ll want to look it up as you read. It’s remarkable that it’s been so forgotten.

To tell much more would be to give away the delights of this plot. Always, the revelations are made via Gamache’s conversations with suspects and other people he encounters during his investigation. In this way, Penny very much reminds me of the great P.D. James, though Penny’s spirit is ultimately a more optimistic one than James’. These conversations and discoveries are the heart of this deeply complex and moving novel.

Penny also gifts the reader with some short visits with her series “regulars” – Reine-Marie, Ruth, Clara, Myrna, Gabri and Olivier, and even Rosa the duck. But for all it’s breadth of storytelling this is a focused book. It’s focused on Gamache’s and Beauvoir’s investigation, as well as their memories of the character despised by them both. This tighter focus makes the novel a very strong entry in this series, perhaps one of my favorites to date.

Profile Image for Teres.
296 reviews874 followers
November 10, 2026

Hail, Hail, the Gang's All Here! 🙌🏻 Back to Three Pines we go... 🌲🌲🌲
Profile Image for Liz.
3,087 reviews3,964 followers
November 5, 2026
How does Louise Penny do it? Miss Wolcott’s Ghost is the 21st in the Armand Gamache series and I was engaged from beginning to end.
I was thrilled that this book takes place in Three Pines and all of the residents are involved in this story.
The book begins when Armand receives a call at home about a dead body in Lost Nations. It takes a while to even figure out where that is. When he and Jean Guy get there, they find a body which would seem to be from 100 years ago.
The story delves into a little known historical event, the sinking of the Empress of Ireland, the worst Canadian maritime disaster, which took place in May, 1914. I loved the mix of mystery and history. And as always, there’s a lot of philosophical thought thrown in. I especially loved the interchange between Armand and the judge about the difference between belief, suspicion and a possibility.
The ending was poignant, a way for Penny to rewrite the history way too many of us have dealt with.
This would have been an easy five stars if not for Jean Guy’s nightmares and Gaston’s daydreams which did nothing to advance the story and actually distracted me. It’s obvious Penny was trying to provide a window into their personalities but it was like being hit over the head with a hammer. Too obvious.
And thank heavens the audiobook includes the Acknowledgements. Make sure to listen. I was thrilled to learn how much of the historical parts were based on real life.
I listened to this and enjoyed Alfred Molina as the narrator. I wasn’t sold on him as Armand in the tv series because he didn’t look the part. But just listening to his voice worked well.
Profile Image for Julie.
827 reviews
October 25, 2026
Hmm. I loved being back in Three Pines with characters who almost feel like friends after 21 books and many adventures shared together. And I was happy to mostly stay in Three Pines out on the terrace of the bistro, in Gamache's garden, in Clara's studio, and rooted in the Old Train Station of course. But being rooted in Three Pines wasn't enough to make up for some of the issues I have with this story.

First of all, better editing please! The repetition of phrases and flashback scenes was just plain annoying. How did her editor miss this?

And the story bordered on being too convoluted to enjoy. I usually appreciate the complexities and layering that is part of the mastery of Penny and her mysteries, but the excessive # of storylines that branched off the central murder mystery weakened this one.

Overall, it was still a delight to be back with these familiar and much loved characters, and I look forward to the next.
81 reviews3 followers
October 24, 2026
Between the flashbacks, dreams and daydreams of the various characters, I find this incredibly disjointed and almost annoying.
Profile Image for Marcie Reads.
318 reviews52 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 14, 2026
𝗔𝗴𝗮𝘁𝗵𝗮 𝗖𝗵𝗿𝗶𝘀𝘁𝗶𝗲 𝟮.𝟬 🔎

An intricate historical mystery with fascinating characters, multiple threads to untangle and some genuinely interesting insights into human psychology. Add a fantastic atmosphere and subtle, intelligent humour woven naturally into the dialogue, and I was completely sold.

Adam Sims's narration was brilliant, with distinct voices and accents that brought the diverse cast to life. And Ruth? Absolutely fantastic.

I never felt lost despite starting with book 21, and the ending tied everything together beautifully. A layered mystery that rewards your attention rather than relying on nonstop action.

Thank you to Louise Penny, Hodder & Stoughton Audio and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review this ARC. All opinions are my own.

🎉 𝗛𝗮𝗽𝗽𝘆 𝗣𝘂𝗯𝗹𝗶𝗰𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗗𝗮𝘆, 𝗟𝗼𝘂𝗶𝘀𝗲 𝗣𝗲𝗻𝗻𝘆! 𝗖𝗼𝗻𝗴𝗿𝗮𝘁𝘂𝗹𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻𝘀 𝘁𝗼 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗲𝘃𝗲𝗿𝘆𝗼𝗻𝗲 𝗮𝘁 𝗛𝗼𝗱𝗱𝗲𝗿 & 𝗦𝘁𝗼𝘂𝗴𝗵𝘁𝗼𝗻 𝗔𝘂𝗱𝗶𝗼 𝗼𝗻 𝘁𝗼𝗱𝗮𝘆'𝘀 𝗿𝗲𝗹𝗲𝗮𝘀𝗲! 𝗜 𝗵𝗼𝗽𝗲 𝗹𝗼𝘁𝘀 𝗼𝗳 𝗿𝗲𝗮𝗱𝗲𝗿𝘀 𝗱𝗶𝘀𝗰𝗼𝘃𝗲𝗿 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗹𝗼𝘃𝗲 𝘁𝗵𝗶𝘀 𝗼𝗻𝗲.
Profile Image for Victoria Grant.
Author 6 books83 followers
October 26, 2026
Having read every book in the Gamache series, more than once, I was sooo looking forward to this novel. After all, the Wolf saga was over, the title was intriguing, and I thought we could get back to enjoying a nice cozy mystery. Couldn't we? Nope. This story, while interesting in parts, included a tertiary plot line that, frankly, boggled my brain cells. It was certainly one we could've done without - so the character is a coward? Fine. Just tell us that and get back to the main story. All these mini fast food joint scenes that popped up willy-nilly were extremely annoying and didn't further the main plot.
I think the most disappointing thing for me was I felt the Three Pines character interactions were forced and convoluted...they didn't have the wit, the sparkle, or the warmth that earlier books had, sadly. With her last four or five novels not hitting the mark for me, this may be the last Gamache I read.
Profile Image for Kari Ann Sweeney.
1,518 reviews388 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 3, 2026
HEADLINE: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 𝗪𝗲’𝗿𝗲 𝗯𝗮𝗰𝗸 𝗯𝗮𝗯𝘆!

I’m an unapologetic Penny Pusher. #pennypusher I adore this series. Over 21 books, Three Pines and the characters who dwell there have started to feel like old friends.

But- I haven’t loved the last 3 books. I was missing the feelings I got from the early/middle books in the series.

I am thrilled to say 𝗠𝗜𝗦𝗦 𝗪𝗢𝗟𝗖𝗢𝗧𝗧’𝗦 𝗚𝗛𝗢𝗦𝗧 (pun 10.20) delivered on all the things I love about this series. We’re back baby! Ruth and Jean Guy bickering. Time at the Bistro. The characters we know and love getting time on the page. A well plotted and executed mystery with connections to actual events/places. Love love love.

𝗙𝗢𝗥𝗠𝗔𝗧: I listened to it on audio narrated by Alfred Molina. Once I got Marcellus the Octopus (RBCreatures) out of my head I was all in.
Profile Image for The Bookish Elf.
3,437 reviews551 followers
October 22, 2026
The phone rings in the Gamache bedroom at 3:17 on a Saturday morning, on the family's private line. A frightened young voice says there is a body in a place called Lost Nation, then the connection dies. When the call is traced, the phone turns out to be registered to Clara Morrow, the painter who lives across the village green, and within the hour her head of homicide neighbour is searching her attic and crawl space in his socks. Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny opens like that: small, local, and odd. After two books spent chasing a conspiracy against the whole country, the twenty-first Gamache novel is a murder in the woods behind home.

What Miss Wolcott's Ghost Adds

The body in the forest cemetery wears a tweed suit cut before the First World War, from a Savile Row tailor whose shop was bombed in the Second World War. The headstone it lies on carries no name, only a carved sprig and a date: 29 May 1914. And growing on that one grave, and through the dead man, is a spiky grey plant that no app can identify.

Readers who know Canadian history may recognise the date. Most of the characters do not. It is the night the Empress of Ireland sank in the St. Lawrence after a collision with the Norwegian collier Storstad, taking 1,012 people with her in about fourteen minutes. Penny makes the team's ignorance part of the story: one by one, every investigator and villager asks how they never knew. Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny turns that question into its real subject, which is what a country, a family or a scientific establishment chooses to forget.

What works
The historical braid. A genealogy company, a salvage official's suspicious records, a Victorian plant hunter and a lost settlement converge so neatly that the clues read better on a second pass than the first.
A return to the village at full strength. Ruth and her swearing duck, Gabri's running jokes and the bistro's endless sandwiches are back, and Gamache's hundred-year-old godfather in Ottawa gets the best scene of financial gossip in the series.
The team as a team. Lacoste, Beauvoir, a forensic accountant and an eager rookie each crack part of the case. Gamache listens more than he leads, which suits him.
Courage examined, not assumed. A disastrous raid from the past, told in fragments, gives the book a moral spine about fear, cowardice and second chances.
Where It Gives Ground
Refrains repeat past their welcome. A plea from that old raid, a line from the 1967 recording and Beauvoir's nightmares about the sinking each recur many times. The first few land hard; by the twentieth the effect has worn thin.
The solution is explained more than dramatised. In Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny the endgame is laid out in a long conversation with a prosecutor, re-covering ground the reader already holds, and the culprit gets little inner life.
The middle wanders. A chase through several archives on two continents depends on lucky finds and convenient timing.
The whimsy is thick. Readers who find Three Pines too cosy will find nothing here to change their minds.
Do You Need the Earlier Books?

Partly. Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny is a self-contained case, and the mystery needs no homework. But much of its feeling depends on history: Clara's late husband Peter and his difficult family, Beauvoir's sobriety and marriage into the Gamache family, Lacoste's near death in the bistro. Newcomers can follow it, but they will get far more from Still Life, The Long Way Home and The Grey Wolf first.

Worth Your Shelf

It is long, it repeats itself, and its final explanations arrive in conversation rather than action. Even so, Miss Wolcott's Ghost by Louise Penny is the most satisfying puzzle she has built in years, and the most moving, because every clue leads back to people the world agreed to forget.

Come for the body in the woods. Stay for the ship nobody remembered.
Profile Image for Jay Langer.
171 reviews
October 28, 2026
Rating: 2.25/5

This is both a return to form for the series and a continuation of what I've come to hate in Louise Penny's writing: the flanderization of the characters, the trite attempts at humor, the mysteries- while well executed- are overly complex to the point of being convoluted, and even I've started to notice how many unnecessary sentence fragments there are. Due to these problems and others, I've decided this will be the last Armand Gamache book I'll read. Godspeed to Penny, but I can’t deal with this shambling husk of a series anymore. I wouldn’t go so far as to say that it’s become a parody of itself, but it certainly feels like it’s getting closer and closer to that with each installment.
Profile Image for Darlene.
231 reviews2 followers
October 22, 2026
I had trouble with this novel; it just did not seem like one of Louise's better works. Quite different from 'The Grey Wolf' and 'The Black Wolf'. To me there seemed to be no intensity. It was ok, but overall disappointing, for instance: all these people repeatedly coming to the crime scenes....seriously?! You don't do that in police work.
Profile Image for Evelyn.
619 reviews17 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 21, 2026
I say this all the time- Louise Penny’s Three Pines series are the best mystery books of all time. Filled with wonderful characters that have depth, complex mysteries that are wrapped in a cloak of compassion and humanity, I can never get enough of them.They dealt with the mafia and that just doesn’t interest me. So I was thrilled that her upcoming book Miss Wolcott’s Ghost returns to the series roots.

The book opens with Chief Inspector Armand Gamache receiving an early morning phone call from an unidentified and terrified caller proclaiming, “there’s a body in lost nation”. The only problem is that Armand has never heard of Lost Nation. What follows is a scramble to find the body and the mysterious Lost Nation. What Armand and his team uncover is a cemetery located in the mysterious Quebec forest and the body of a man on top of a grave marked with a tombstone with a date but no name. And most puzzling of all is that the body is clad in clothing from another century, but this is most assuredly a recent murder.

This book is classic Penny. A mystery possibly involving one of the inhabitants of Three Pines with ties to the past. Add in a dose of little known Quebec history involving a ship wreck that rivals the tragedy of the Titanic, and the complex puzzle for Armand, Jean Guy and Isabelle to unravel and you have the perfect mystery to cozy up with on a rainy day. Yes, these books have a cozy factor, but they also have an edge and an underlying brutality that lets you know that you are in the hands of a master storyteller. You can read this book as a stand alone and not be disappointed, but if you want to have one of the best reading journeys of your life start at the beginning and read the series in order. But whatever you do please read at least one of these books!
I listened to this one on audio and it was sublime. Narrated by Alfred Molina, who portrayed Gamache in the series, the character is perfectly brought to life. I was transported and it was a magical experience that I highly recommend. Thanks to @netgalley for this audio arc
Profile Image for Dave Schaafsma.
Author 6 books32.3k followers
November 13, 2026
For those who dread horror there are no actual ghosts in this book; in typical literary fashion, all the ghosts are metaphorical!

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost (2026) is #21 in Louise Penny’s Chief Inspector Armand Gamache detective series. Penny may not always do things the same way, but she is always looking for the light, the hope. Her Gamache is so good, so much a model for responsible adult behavior and professional standards and family love, he is definitely romanticized, but tor fair, in the world of crime, mystery, and thrillers, the nearly perfect man or woman is standard; neither Perry Mason nor Poirot lost a case,Poirot never lost a case, Bond is supposedly a perfect lover and fighting hero, so so we might give Gamache a break. Penny would be quick to point out that he does make mistakes, but she would agree he’s morally perfect. “He’s just so good,” she admits! And then, this is Penny’s particular brand of cozy mystery, not a gritty gutter noir.

What are the ingredients of a Penny novel? The solid foundation of place (Three Pines, a small loving community); family, friends, good food (so good that people today still go up to Quebec to find Three Pines and Olivier and Gabri’s restaurant. A duck named Rosa that says Fuck instead of Quack (yes, in every book, multiple times, sight). Facing the reality of a racist, violent history of the world and Canada in particular. She tries to balance an acknowledgement of bad acts and actors with good people that stand up to this baddies and seek the truth.

In recent books she had been very angry and aggressively political about the sad state of the world, pushing Gamache and the team into more of a thriller mode, but in this book she regrounds herself inThree Pines, featuring family and friends--– Reine-Marie, Ruth, Clara, Myrna, Gabri and Olivier, and even Rosa the duck--as she did in the beginning. And this makes for a better mix of tones, I think. This book is historical fiction, or mystorical fiction, featuring an actual botanist whom Penny wants to get more credit for doing useful science that was unappreciated in her time, more than 100 years ago: Ellen Wilmott and a plant she is known for, Miss Willmott's Ghost, sown from the seeds of (the ghostly-appearing) Sea Holly.

Ghost plants have these things in common: They don’t need photosynthesis to survive, and are ghostly or pale-looking, often. They can thrive on fungi. They are also rare, sometimes not seen for years or decades, thus matching the second meaning of ghost. In the process of discovering the medicinal secrets of this plant that were ignored or uncredited to Wolcott, Penny also weaves in a plot of a maritime disaster from 1914 and an entity called Lost Nation that connects to Gamache neighbor Clara Morrow. We begin with a dead body dead body, and a plant that is "ghosted" for more than a century, but then we go into what i my opinion is too many threads, too long and hard to connect dots Not boring, just all over the place. There’s a genealogy company scamming people thread, too!

Okay: there’s a central theme worth supporting: We forget out history, our pioneers, a lost nation, a maritime disaster, and we need to keep this history alive to be fully functioning citizens (ok, this is Canadian history, directed to Canadians, but you get the point about history).

The cconlusion, after a long book, feels both a bit rushed, with a quick convenient discovery but mostly reporting the resolution rather than through action. I wasn’t a big fan of the dreams and nightmares and flashback sequences that didn’t advance the plot and felt a bit confusing in an already extremely complicated plot.

But I think if this is the only Penny you will ever read you will be impressed by her ambition, especially in a book so late in the series. You’ll like Gamache and the Three Pines crowd, but I’ll say you’d like them better in one of the first ten books.

PS: This is a story of more than 100 years ago. I wonder if Penny knows of another “ghost” plant only rarely seen in Chicago, where a botanist Norma Etta Pfeiffer, discovered Thiamine Americana in 1912 (around the same time as Wilmott.

PPS: Here’s a link to the real life Penny botanist story:

https://www.gardenhistorygirl.co.uk/p...
Profile Image for Jamie.
742 reviews33 followers
Review of advance copy
October 3, 2026
Louise Penny has returned to her roots, and I am so here for it! I struggled through the last few books, but I sailed through this one! Classic Louise Penny. Great story, excellent character development, and my beloved Three Pines.
Profile Image for Bookreporter.com Mystery & Thriller.
2,905 reviews64.9k followers
October 25, 2026
Welcome back to Three Pines, that charming, peaceful village (minus the occasional murder) nestled in the mountains of Québec.

Louise Penny's prior books, THE GREY WOLF and THE BLACK WOLF, took us into a far-reaching conspiracy that spoke of world politics and evil intentions. While our beloved Armand Gamache was still intrepid in his determination to protect people from dastardly plots and despicable deeds, we didn't get to spend much time in Three Pines. But even though MISS WOLCOTT’S GHOST returns us to that idyllic locale, there is still so much going on, so many threads to the plot, that trying to do justice to them all is a Sisyphean task.

One of the best parts of Penny's novels, and almost a character in its own right, is Three Pines. It's a magical place that doesn't appear on any map or GPS, and it's difficult to find, but the “right” sort of people end up there --- those who need to be there. And I daresay that most readers, certainly moi, long to move there as well. Gabriel “Gabri” Dubeau and Olivier Brulé are the charming couple who run the bistro, which serves mugs of café au lait and sandwiches with ham, brie and apples. Ruth Zardo is a well-known poet whose favorite word rhymes with her pet duck, Rosa. Myrna Landers owns the local bookstore, and Clara Morrow is the now world-famous artist. And Inspector Gamache and his wife, Reine-Marie, live in a cottage with a wide veranda and a lovely garden.

The story begins with a phone call in the middle of the night. Someone wakes up Gamache with information that there's a body in Lost Nation. The call is disconnected, and Gamache is flummoxed. He doesn't know who it was, and he has no idea where or what Lost Nation is. Muddling the matter even more, the call originated from a burner phone registered to Clara, who claims to know nothing about it. He and Reine-Marie ask their friends about Lost Nation and try to research it, but to no avail. Ruth mentions that perhaps the couple at Buzz, the bistro in nearby Knowlton, might know about it. They do, and it turns out that it's a real bistro (which I'm guessing will be getting a lot more traffic from fans of the series who flock to Knowlton, where Penny lives).

Lost Nation is a place that is uninhabited in the novel. The cemetery contains tombstones on which the dates stop in the late 1880s. And yes, when Gamache is led there by the bistro's chef and owner, there is indeed a body on top of one of the graves. But the tombstone has no name, just a date. It is made of a different material and faces in a different direction than the other markers. Growing out of and through the body is a strange plant --- one that turns out to be named Miss Wolcott's Ghost.

Penny brings to our attention historical events that otherwise might have passed us by. For example, in another novel, we learn about the shooting of the Canadian engineering students at the École Polytechnique. It led to the passing of gun control laws, and there is a national day of remembrance. Penny continues that tradition here by detailing a tragedy that I'm not going to name in this review as it needs to be discovered during the reading. But it's yet another obscure event that should be known.

In the Acknowledgments, which Penny (and I) advise you not to read until you have finished the book, Penny shares that Miss Daisy Wolcott is based on a very real, brilliant woman.

So this mystery wanders from the wealthy and eccentric Miss Wolcott and her roundabout connection to the tragic event, to the killings of two women over half a century ago, and the current murder that Gamache is investigating.

In this novel are tales of greed and unbridled avarice. But perhaps the most touching element is that Miss Wolcott, who exemplified the difference between male and female explorers, didn't explore simply to find riches. Rather she listened to indigenous people. She noted their stories and thought they were important. There is more that can't be shared, but she truly is one of Penny's most notable characters.

Along the way in this free-rambling mystery, we are treated to Penny's brilliant writing and wry commentary on the history of women. At one point she describes Clara, Ruth and Myrna as they arrive at the cemetery at Lost Nation after an arduous climb: “They looked for all the world like something Mother Nature had birthed. Like the three tall pines. Or the witches from Macbeth. Or the Three Graces. It came to the same thing, Isabelle knew. Witches. Graces. Same women. Just different interpretations.”

Penny mentions the perceived threats from history that certain governments feel and that they sometimes try to erase due to “toxic nationalism and unpleasant truths.” She also spends time studying opposites: bravery and cowardice. It's one thing for an officer to know what is expected in a planned raid, but she points out that we don't know how we'd behave in a crisis. Would we sacrifice our lives to help others escape, or would we succumb to that basic desire to run and live to see another day? She says that bravery isn't a lack of fear; it's how we deal with that fear. Do we run away? Do we face it?

One of the reasons that this series is so delightful and beloved is the sense of belonging, community, friendship and family as we read about Three Pines and its residents. Where one woman goes, the others show up. And after just a bit, Gabri appears with libations and treats. Lemonade and ginger cookies in the summer. Mugs of coffee and tea with hearty soups and sandwiches dripping with melted cheeses in the winter. Sitting in front of fireplaces enjoying the crackle of the logs burning, or sitting outside the bistro and taking in the sunny day, depending on the season. Three Pines is at the heart of these stories. The warm feelings and Inspector Gamache's kind, intelligent and understanding demeanor envelop us inside a sensation of protection. We know he'll keep us safe.

And then we have to close the book and step back into the real world. But at least for several hours or days, we get to live in Louise Penny's world, a better place (except for the murders, of course) and most definitely a more delicious experience through and through.

Reviewed by Pamela Kramer
Profile Image for Dara Tinius.
606 reviews45 followers
October 28, 2026
I will always ride or die for Gamache but this one was hard to follow with the flashbacks that slowed the momentum.
18 reviews1 follower
October 30, 2026
I’ve read all the Gamache books and this one doesn’t measure up. The plot is hard to follow and the numerous daydreams/nightmares related to a ship that sank 100 years ago were distracting. Towards the end, the book resorts to Gamache giving a lengthy explanation to a prosecutor so we can try to understand what’s going on. A lot of repetitious descriptions of the regular characters, which are more caricatures at this point. And enough of the stupid duck. It’s not cute anymore, if it ever was.
16 reviews
October 25, 2026
Not up to Louise Penny standards

I've read every one of Gamance

books. And loved every one of them, however this one was confusing. And mostly unbelievable.
Profile Image for Laurie.
638 reviews51 followers
November 9, 2026
Once again, the focus of this 21st novel in the Chief Inspector Gamache series is on the village of Three Pines, which must make it the murder capital of the world. Although it is an idyllic setting and a place I would love to live in, it seems to have a high crime rate.

When Armand Gamache's phone rings in the wee hours of the morning and he receives a cryptic message about a body in Lost Nation, Gamache, instantly awake, begins to trace the call, only to find it supposedly originated in his home village of Three Pines. Finding that not to be the case, his next task is to locate Lost Nation.

Through investigative work by his team, Lost Nation is found and, indeed, they find a long-dead body. In their efforts to identify the body, they discover a link to a presumed-extinct plant called Miss Wolcott's Ghost, an old shipwreck, and the missing papers of an amateur Victorian botanist. What ties them together is the challenge the team faces.

First, let me say that this book can be read as a standalone. There are few references to the earlier books, but for continuity, I recommend reading at least the two prior books. As usual, Penny's plot is compelling reading. She does an excellent job of tying together the various subplots and, although the pacing slows with repeated dream sequences, it is an engrossing story. I love the main characters and their interaction in Three Pines. Were it not for the unnecessary dream sequences and a plot summation near the end, this would have been a 5-star read for me. 4/5 stars.
Profile Image for Maine Colonial.
1,061 reviews225 followers
October 30, 2026
I haven’t been a fan of Louise Penny’s forays into international thrillers, so I was glad to be back in Three Pines. A trip to Europe is required for the investigation, but it’s all part of solving the local mystery. And what a strange mystery it is. Who called Armand Gamache in the middle of the night to say “There’s a body in Lost Nation”? What or where is Lost Nation? With the help of locals, Gamache and his seconds, Beauvoir and Lacoste, find an old abandoned settlement, deep in the woods, known as Lost Nation. Sure enough, in its graveyard, there is a grave with no name on it, but a date, and they find a corpse that has been there for some months, though dressed in hundred-year-old clothing.

Solving the meaning of the date on the grave, and finally identifying the corpse, lead the team on a fascinating historical journey involving botany, shipwrecks, and an eccentric heiress. Interspersed with the investigation, three characters recall a years-before violent incident that reverberates in their psyches today, bringing up issues of bravery and cowardice.

I found the mystery engaging, especially the historical aspects that were previously unknown to me. I could have used more participation by the Three Pines locals, but that’s something I’ve been saying for several books now. I’m just grateful that this book sticks with the usual themes of human faults and how they can lead to murder and other tragedies, while love and understanding can heal.

Alfred Molina makes a very good narrator.
Profile Image for Kyle.
24 reviews9 followers
October 24, 2026
It’s my fault for being gullible and reading glowing advance reviews. This started out as a much-needed improvement in the series and a solid mystery. Then, devolved into flashbacks, torturing the characters because the author has nothing else to do and then, about 3/4 through the books jumps the shark again. I am assuming the author and editors are getting comfortably paid by gullible readers for this to continue book after book.
Profile Image for Joe.
641 reviews
November 9, 2026
I have to wonder if there comes a point when an author has grown so successful that their editor simply stops editing their manuscripts and just sends them on to the printer. I’ve read a dozen or so of Penny’s Gamache novels, many with great pleasure, but this one is unusually poorly written. There are many problems, but the main one is repetitiveness. Penny repeats several dream or memory sequences, several times, and nearly word for word. She delays the revealing of key information in obvious and annoying ways, and she goes back frequently and needlessly over the details of a not particularly complex plot. And she can’t stop praising , time and time again, the brilliance and kindness of everyone in Three Pines. The overall impression is of someone trying to stretch a short story into a novel.

The story does refer to some interesting historical events: the remarkable and eccentric career of the 19th-century English botanist Ellen Willmott (the novel’s Miss Wolcott ), the catastrophic sinking of the Empress of Ireland ocean liner just off land in the St Lawrence Seaway in 1914, and the sad fading away of the ghost town of Lost Nation. I’m glad to have learned about all three.
Profile Image for DeAnn.
1,912 reviews
November 15, 2026
4.5 Chef's Kiss to Alfred Molina Stars

Narrated by the incomparable Alfred Molina, this one was a return to Louise Penny greatness.

A late-night call alerts Armand that a body has been found and the chase is on. The team has to discover what and where Lost Nation is and who the dead body is.

There's lots of activity in Three Pines in this installment, and Clara has a role. There are also lots of descriptions of a famous ship going down that most people have never heard of.

There's a deep dive into the past, featuring a Victorian botanist and the secrets of a plant thought to be extinct. It was not that the world was not ending in this one like in some of the more recent installments.

My good book buddy Marilyn and I have been buddy reading all of these, and we enjoyed this one!
Profile Image for Tanja Berg.
2,440 reviews613 followers
October 31, 2026
Finally a Gamache mystery actually set in the Three Pines and not involving police or government corruption! I thought I had read my last book by this author with the gawd-awful «Grey Wolf», but the blurb for this book made me reconsider.

I’m glad I did, because this is a return to what we love so much: familiar characters in a hidden village where everyone knows and cares about each other, despite characters flaws.

It starts with Gamache getting a call to his private phone from an unknown number in the middle of the night, yelling about a body in last nation or lost nation. Trouble is, no one really knows where that is.

When this first mystery has been solved and everyone is staring at the dead body, several more issues arise. Who is the dead man? And why is an extinct plant growing on him?

I found this quite delightful, entertaining and living up to Three Pines expectations.
Profile Image for Derby Jones.
49 reviews3 followers
November 7, 2026
Finished Miss Wolcott's Ghost, barely, if it had been by anyone but Louise Penny, I would have DNF'ed, such a disappointment. While we were back in Three Pines, and our beloved characters were there, they were very much background, none of the lovely character moments we used to have. The story is convoluted, Beauvoir for inexplicable reasons is having recurrent nightmares about the sinking of the Empress of Ireland, makes him seem like a basket case, way too many flashbacks, one whole chapter is flashbacks, nightmares and fantasies by various characters. I think Penny has just changed her writing style after writing all these political thrillers, and it's no longer the series that I have enjoyed for so long.
Profile Image for Ellen.
164 reviews
October 30, 2026
I enjoyed this book, especially as compared to the Wolf books. But enough with the flashbacks already!
Profile Image for Linden.
2,313 reviews1 follower
October 30, 2026
Gamache gets an anonymous call in the middle of the night, telling him there was a body in Lost Nation. He and the team find a body in the long-forgotten Lost Nation cemetery. Who is this person? Their search leads them to Reunion, a company that researches genealogy, and the mystery of the Empress of Ireland, a ship that sank and killed many people in the early 20th century, including Daisy Wolcott, a botanist who had made some remarkable discoveries which were dismissed because she was a woman and not affiliated with a university. Greed and dishonesty caused many lives to be lost, but Isabelle, John Guy, and Armand are determined to get justice, albeit belated, for the victims.
Profile Image for Erika.
11 reviews2 followers
October 29, 2026
I found this book really disappointing. It seemed like there wasn’t enough mystery to fill a book so we had a plot line of characters dreaming they were in a sinking ship, including the same dream repeated over and over. Then we also had a fragmented and repeated (so many times) story hinting at why someone was untrustworthy that in the end didn’t seem at all to support that conclusion. The repetition in both was really boring, especially as the investigation dragged on with little development. I was very invested in the outcome but ultimately this book felt like a ton of filler.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 911 reviews