Lady Frances Ffolkes has embarrassed her noble family by campaigning for women's suffrage, volunteering at a soup kitchen and moving to a hotel for ladies with only her maid for a chaperone. Conventional Lady Frances is not, but she IS a loyal friend and when a family friend, Kat Colcombe, comes crying for help finding her late brother Daniel's missing manuscript, Lady Frances is only too happy to help. She begins to have her suspicions that Danny, an ex-soldier, did not die in a gun cleaning accident nor did he commit suicide. The manuscript he was working on was a memoir of his service during the Boer War- a war that most people want to forget. Lady Frances vows to obtain justice for Danny and those who died a horrific death in South Africa. As Frances investigates, she attracts the attention of Scotland Yard, the Secret Service, two suitors and who knows how many villains!
This is a fabulous light mystery set in the early 20th century. It is similar to a cozy mystery, not having much violence and no gore with a light romance. Though not set in a small town, the story is similar to a cozy mystery because it features an amateur sleuth and focuses on solving the mystery behind the murder and largely on character development. At first I felt like the reader was dropped into a story in progress. I had questions about why Lady Frances knew the Superintendent and how and where she had been educated. The answers come out slowly as Frances fills other characters in on her backstory. Then I couldn't put it down! I didn't guess who the villain was but I did guess someone else would turn up dead halfway through and who and why. I only gave this 4 stars instead of 5 because of that slow reveal backstory and also because there were too many characters to keep track of and some of the history felt forced into the story and not part of the story. My only other quibble would be that Frances and Mallow spend a LOT of time discussing fashion yet the details are sketchy. What designers is Frances wearing? What exactly do her clothes look like? There are some great resources out there. Let Frances show off her designer gowns!
I love Lady Frances! She's intelligent, feisty, shrewd, with a touch of the naivety that comes from being a woman of her class in her time. She fights for what she wants and knows how to get it. I love how she handles the men who doubt her intelligence and how she is one step ahead of the police. She isn't too modern for her time. She wants to be bold and daring and claim the century as her own, but she is also sometimes really innocent and ignorant at times. I didn't get a sense that Frances was a modern woman plunked down into the Edwardian era. She does resemble women like the Pankhurts. Frances is so kind hearted without being generous to a fault. She wants to solve the world's problems and that may cause her some problems later on.
I also love Mallow! June Mallow is not your typical ladies' maid. She's learned a lot from watching Frances. Frances treats Mallow more like a sister than a servant. They have gotten into mischief together, experienced tragedy and now they are sleuthing partners. She's loyal to Frances but not in a subservient way. I think Mallow enjoys the sleuthing they are doing together in this book. It gives her a chance to use her brains.
Major Daniel Colcombe, the victim, sounds like he was a really great person. Though he was an adventuring type, he was kind, loyal and brave. He went through hell and survived only to get murdered. That is so unfair. Some parts of his story surprised me but others did not.
Frances has two suitors who could not be more different. Lord Gareth is a fun-loving, pleasure seeking second son whose kisses are divine. I did not like him or trust him from their first meeting. Frances seems to trust him but can he keep that trust? Hal is a nerdy solicitor but because of Frances, he has revised his beliefs about what women are capable of, which makes him wonderful in my eyes (Frances agrees). His mother is pushing him towards Frances, that much is obvious, but he kindly plays along with his mother's schemes. He's kind, caring and considerate. Too bad he's kind of nerdy and shy.
The other major characters are government and military men hiding dark secrets that could have led to Danny's missing manuscript and possible murder. None of them were all that appealing and I had a hard time keeping them all straight.
The Inspector on the case is a good foil for Frances. He's wry, observant and doesn't seem to doubt her intelligence. I was surprised by him. Could he be a potential suitor? Not in this book but I'm hoping in the future.
Read this if you love Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries TV series. Frances and Mallow reminded me of Phryne and Dot.
There are some scenes of wartime violence and one barroom brawl scene. There is also hints of men wanting improper things from ladies and a subplot revolving around a child born out of wedlock.