*I received a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.*
I will admit that crime thrillers are not exactly my genre of choice, so there's that lol. What intrigued me about this book was the fact that the MC went to prison and, if anyone knows anything about me, they know I LOVE a prison story. There's something about witnessing someone's transformation from upstanding citizen (or not) who made a mistake, to cold blooded, calculating and 'will do whatever it takes to survive.' It just intrigues me, and needless to say I jumped in with both feet.
The book opens with a bang, and draws you in right from the start. Frederick Starks is out driving around, working himself into a frenzy because his estranged wife is living in a house that he's still paying for, with their kids that he's forced to be away from, and he's finally made up his mind to confront her (married) lover at his home in front of his wife. Things go awry and he ends up beating the guy comatose with a bowl. At this point I was front and center, with refreshments.
The trial is riveting. I was literally up at 4am, following the testimony. The verdict is handed down, and while Starks is acquitted of attempted murder (?) he is convicted of the lesser charges and is sentenced to 15 years. (None of this is spoiler info; you know he goes to prison from the blurb). Anyhoo, just imagine, a multi-millionaire reduced to strip searches, cold showers and soap that doesn't lather. More refreshments made their way to my bedside table. Tears of excitement sprang to my eyes as Starks boarded the prison bus to his new life. Within a few days he'd already mouthed off and found himself on the wrong side of Bo, one of the toughest gang leaders in the prison, and was a marked man. I was all abuzz with excitement...and then I started to struggle.
To be fair, I think I might have to shoulder some of the blame here. It's partly a case of 'it's not you; it's me,' but only partly. As I said, when I read books where an MC goes to prison, I'm all about how the fish (new inmate) deals with his CURRENT situation, so I was unprepared for the constant, never ending conversations, thoughts and flashbacks about Starks' estranged wife, Kayla. In theory, it makes sense. Her affair is, after all, the catalyst for the events that land him in prison. Starks also now has a lot of time to think about it, and her, and his life. So, on paper it makes sense. But it was so constant and repetitive that every time her name was mentioned I felt like my brain was in a vice grip. He mentioned her at every opportunity, and just as the story was starting to move ahead, we had to hear, yet again, how hard he'd worked and how much she'd betrayed him, and how she was a serial cheater, and it wasn't just one guy. We had to go back to high school and college and before babies, and after the babies, and ugh. And by the way, did he tell us that her betrayal cut so deep? Yes!! Yes, you did. You already told us fiftyleven times. I had to put the book down a few times and read something else because I just couldn't take it. I hated Kayla, if only because I had to hear about her so much. I was ready to force feed her some nutraloaf my damn self.
The sessions with the prison psychologist made me want to dig my eyes out with a dull spoon. Not only were his theories really simplistic sounding (I'm not trained, but even I was like huh?), his deductions just seemed so off and served to always give Kayla a pass. In one of my updates I asked if we could check if he was sleeping with her, sirrusly! It just defied logic. Dr. Demory went away for a while to deal with some family business and the story FINALLY reverted to the prison and we had some progress. As soon as he came back, we were back to talking about Kayla, and forgiveness and Starks's pride. I was in complete agreement with Starks about those sessions. They annoyed me as much as they did him.
To be clear, I get what the author was going for. Starks was by no means a saint. He and Kayla were both wrong in the marriage, and Starks refused to accept any responsibility. He also had some very chauvinistic ideas about women and fidelity, and felt that the fact that he paid for everything and gave Kayla a comfortable life should have been enough to show her he loved her. Yes, he was a proud man and Dr. Demory was right that he had to accept his part in the demise of his relationship, and really examine exactly what he was mad about when he was out there doing dirt too. Starks had to learn certain things about himself in order to grow and move on; we get all that. But I felt that the arc should have been tighter. A book has a finite number of pages and the reader needs to feel like the MC is actually making progress. We were still talking about Kayla, literally having the same conversation about her, right down to the end!
An attempt is made, when Starks *cough* suffers an injury in prison *cough*, to present Kayla's side of the story. We get to see exactly what Starks was out there doing, what she had to endure and how alone and unappreciated she felt. The problem is that it comes so late in the book that it does little to redeem her character. Starks had already been bashing her for a good 50%. Instead of showing that neither of them was completely at fault, for me it just made both characters unlikeable.
I'm all for complex characters, but I wasn't exactly sure what I was supposed to feel for Kayla when the first words out her mouth after hearing Starks was hurt was 'is the money ok?' (referring to the company). Really, chick? I'm supposed to feel bad about how neglected you felt?? Apart from that, I have little sympathy for women who insist on having the best, and living a life of extravagance, but are upset by their husband's long hours. How exactly do you think success happens??
There was the same push and pull with Starks. I'd empathize with him for getting the short end of the stick in terms of his marriage, but then he'd say something like 'Kayla should have known her place.' 'Scuse me? So the middle of the book is pretty much me wanting to beat both their heads in with a shovel. Kayla more so, but still.
Then, 'the incident' happens and Starks stops focusing on that skank for five seconds, remembers the few seasons of Oz he watched, and gets with the doggone program. I.WAS.IN.HEAVEN! He steps up, realizes he's going to be in prison for a while and looks FORWARD. And like his grandfather always told him, If you don't like where you are, move up. And move up he does. With his slowly growing band of trusty sidekicks, he moves to cement his place and as one final betrayal is revealed, we finally see him shed the last vestiges of his former self, and embrace the dark side.
The ending feels like it's a prelude to a second book, and you know where I'll be. Right up front, baby! Despite my struggle with the middle of the book, Mr. Clerge is clearly a very talented storyteller. The start of the book, Starks's indoctrination into the prison system (complete with trusting the wrong people and paying dearly for it), and his bid for power at the end are superbly done. The flashbacks (though they focused on Kayla) are seamless and never really took me out the story. Very few authors can do this effectively, and I appreciated not feeling jerked around by shifting timelines. The characters are fleshed out and multi-faceted. Editing was well done, a few errors here and there, nothing to write home about. I love this dark side of Starks that I see emerging and want to see more. I have complete faith in the author to do him justice.
Re my problems with this book, clearly I am in the minority here and it may be my lack of 'crime thriller' background that I didn't understand right off the bat that it would be a character study. However, a few things would have helped me:
The blurb is very forward-thinking. It doesn't give the impression that we'd be (extensively) looking back. A simple line about Starks contemplating his past actions, while looking ahead to blah blah would have better prepared me.
Kayla's thoughts should have been introduced earlier. Dual view points might be a bit cliché, but someone could have visited her when Starks was first imprisoned for us to get her side. It was included way too late for us to balance our empathy.
I would say less should have been included about Kayla, but I'm thinking that this is a series, and Book 1 was about Starks's reluctant acceptance and eventual crossover to the dark side. If that IS the case, it should have been made clear that this is Book 1 of x number of books. This would have gone a long way to help me understand the pacing. As it stood, I just kept seeing the page count increasing and not much changing.
All in all, this is a solid, enjoyable and well written debut novel. I enjoyed the beginning and last third immensely, and though I struggled with the middle I did not regret reading it. Looking forward to much more by this author. 3.75*