Let me be clear: Jennifer Skutelsky is an amazing writer. Her style is phenomenal. She pulled at my emotions with damn near every passage.
Unfortunately, the plot needed a lot of work. The magical elements in this book were introduced way too late, at which point it seemed really hokey. One particular murder remains unresolved. It was pretty clear, to me, who did it, but someone else ends up taking the blame for everything, which doesn't make a whole lot of sense, given the facts. Everyone in the town being in love with the same woman got real irritating real fast, and Finn's thing with animals was eyeroll-worthy. Even the author's delicious prose couldn't take away from how silly it was.
The first dozen or so chapters were incredible. After that, though, I was unable to suspend my disbelief, and a lot of things seemed to happen for the sake of happening, rather than actually playing an important role. In my opinion, the author tried to jam too many things together at the end and none of it rang true.
I will, however, read more from this author, because I think she has potential and like I said, her technical ability is superb.