Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ballad of the Broken

Rate this book
THE KINGDOMS ARE DYING AND THE PRICE TO SAVE THEM WILL SHATTER LYRA'S HEART.

Dragged into the Seven Hells, Lyra is forced to marry the fallen god who betrayed her. But he is no ordinary captor, and in the Hells, nothing is as it seems.
Bound to a past she cannot remember, Lyra will do anything to find a cure for the curse consuming the Commander of Death. Even if it means surrendering herself to the very god who stole her.

Across the ocean, the Commander of Death is running out of time. Their bond torments him, forcing him to feel Lyra falling for another while the curse rots him from within.
Determined to hold her one last time before death claims him, he sails the Dead Sea in search of the only woman he has ever loved.

Caught between the monster made to kill her and the fallen god who refuses to let her go, Lyra must choose between saving the kingdoms and saving the med who have claimed her heart.

Because the throne demands more than blood.
It demands heartbreak.

465 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 22, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Nakita Kirwan

2 books86 followers
Hi, I’m Nakita. I love creating dark worlds filled with romance that hurts.
I am a mum of four, emergency nurse, and the author behind stories that will make you feel seen.

I write about broken girls who become powerful, men who would destroy the world for them, and love that will make you kick your feet at 2am.

If you love enemies to lovers, fated mates, tension, and just enough chaos that will keep you up at night… Step into the dark with me. I am so glad that you are here.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
60 (57%)
4 stars
37 (35%)
3 stars
7 (6%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews
Profile Image for Katerina Paus.
257 reviews54 followers
Did Not Finish
November 2, 2026
DNF at 5%

Disclaimer: I might get some details wrong and spoil things for anyone who hasn't read book one.

When I read book one, I noticed that it was PACKED with fantasy tropes: prophecies, gods and goddesses, Fae (who drink blood), an MMC with shadows, trials, curses, elemental powers… You name it. But at the time, it felt like the book was right on the edge of being too much without actually crossing that line.

Before starting book two, I went through my updates and highlights and even reread the last chapter. And yet, I still couldn't remember what was happening. Meanwhile, this book throws EVEN MORE fantasy elements at me. Apparently, we're in Hell now, and there are more trials to come. I already feel lost, and I know it would take me a while to get back into this world and wrap my head around all the new information.

And I would have tried. But then we get to my actual reason for DNF'ing, and SPOILERS ahead.

Let's go over the important bits of the story.

We have Lyra, who discovers that she's the reincarnated Sea Goddess. In her previous life, she was married to Helion, the King of Gods, but fell in love with a mortal, Rythos. When Helion found out, he cursed Rythos to kill Lyra in every lifetime. So, for thousands of years, Rythos has been doomed to kill the woman he loves whenever she's reincarnated.

Book one is a MF romance, while book two is tagged as Why Choose, meaning that both her husband and her lover are MMCs. And knowing what I know now, I just couldn't bring myself to continue.

In book one, Lyra undergoes a series of “treatments” administered by a priest. These include bloodletting and rape. Thankfully, she gets some revenge on him in the first book.

But then, in book two, I find out that the priest was actually sent by Helion. The bloodletting was meant to regenerate Helion's powers, and it also kept Lyra hidden from Rythos. AND THE RAPE WAS ALSO ORDERED BY THE MMC.
"I’d even had him fucking her to keep her from burnout."

Please, explain to me how rape was supposed to keep her from "burning out." And more importantly, how am I supposed to feel about an MMC who deliberately ordered the FMC to be repeatedly raped?

And now I'm supposed to entertain the possibility of these two falling in love again? What kind of emotional gymnastics am I expected to perform here? Because I genuinely cannot see how I'm supposed to root for this relationship after that revelation.

I just can't. I don't care how complicated his motivations are or how much the story wants me to understand him. At this point, I'm not interested in finding out.

Combine that with the already overwhelming worldbuilding, and whatever interest I had in this book is gone.
Profile Image for Sydney Wampler.
45 reviews1 follower
October 24, 2026
Review of advance copy
Thank you to the Author and Hawthorn & Aster for the opportunity to read the ARC. All thoughts and opinions are my own #hawthorn&aster.


After reading Melodies of the Damned and that cliffhanger… I figured the second book would be a fight of love and triumph for Lyra and Rythos. BUT I WAS WRONG, and it was beyond heartbreaking. Melodies of the Damned showcased Lyra’s want and need to be free of the cage she was in and death being a viable option was okay with her. Until she met people she began to trust and eventually The Commander of Death. The slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers plotline grew into an overwhelming and true love that I adored. I loved their love.

Enter Helion and book 2… I’m sorry but the ending of Ballad of the Broken simply broke me and I honestly hated it. I desperately wanted the perfect outcome for Lyra and Rythos. She deserved to be loved by the man she truly loved, and he deserved to finally love the woman he loved for thousands of years for a thousand more. I truly wish the ending had reflected that, but it was just grief of a crappy outcome. While I understand she broke the world to love him… that’s the depth that deserved a happier outcome.

The why choose and Helion, I just didn’t care for. I will firmly state that I am not a fan of why choose, and when book 2 went in this direction I was like, “…ok…” But I can acknowledge the aspects of ‘light’ and ‘dark’ in the plotline. I understand Helion’s love for Maraveth, but Lyra deserved more WITH Rythos, or at least an ending that showed them meeting again in some shape or form to be together for eternity. In my opinion, Helion made his bed and he should have slept in it ALONE. Love is enduring, however, Lyra and Maraveth found it in a different man and let it bloom and grow enough to destroy worlds for it.

I wish there had been a different ending, and truly I needed it after being immersed in the love story between Lyra and Rythos, but I assume that was not the purpose. Which is why book 2 did not register has higher than a 3-star read.

Profile Image for Elizabeth.
355 reviews43 followers
October 25, 2026
This book definitely had all the feels! It is an amazing duology. It is very dark though! I absolutely devoured the first one and this one also had me hooked all the way through. I actually came to love Helion in this one. It is such a heartbreaking story though. I normally won’t go for books that don’t have a HEA but this is extremely well written and even though parts hurt I am very glad I read it.

Thank you to both the author and Hawthorn & Aster for the advanced copy.
Profile Image for Sarah Berkowitz-Melton.
141 reviews14 followers
October 24, 2026
⭐ V&V RATING
Overall Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice Level: 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️
Emotional Damage: 💔︎💔︎💔︎💔︎
Tropes: Love triangle, Love you in any lifetime, Bonded Mates, Gods & Goddesses, Gothic vibes, Deadly trials (in Hell), Missing Memories, Sacrifice for Love, Found Family, Slow-Burn, Spice is Spicing!!!!

✨ VIBE CHECK
If you liked…
The Siren Mage duology or the Gothic Vibes of Rachel Gillig, but wanted to see a baddie FMC Siren Goddess of the Seas rule the hearts of both a God and a Monster.

💭 REVIEW THOUGHTS

This was the PERFECT way to close up this duology and that includes the way it ended. It is not what so many expect to see in Romantasies nowadays, but it felt real and cut deeply.

Watching these two MMCs - Rythos, her monster destined to ☠️ her lifetime after lifetime, and Helion, the God of the Sun and husband - both love her fiercely enough they would be willing to sacrifice not only their hearts and lives, but the entire world, was everything!

The spice is spicing in the most delicious way between these three and the love that flows along their bonds was palpable and definitely caused me to reach for the tissues more than once. I will be recommending this series until the seas drown the world.

Thank you to the author/publisher for providing an advance reader copy. This review reflects my honest opinion.
Profile Image for Barbara.
113 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 15, 2026
Nakita Kirwan, you did it again! I LOVED your first book, so naturally, I didn’t even hesitate to sign up for this ARC… and I’m SO happy I did!

Small disclaimer: I’m not a big fan of why-choose romances or books with two main love interests, regardless of the form they take. However, that didn’t stop me from enjoying Ballad of the Broken! Since it’s simply a matter of personal preference, I would never rate a book lower just because of this. And if you’re anything like me, please don’t let this put you off reading it, because this book will give you SO much and make you feel so many emotions. It definitely deserves a spot on your TBR!

There’s so much to highlight about this book!

First of all, the FMC, Lyra! She’s so strong and admirable. I loved her in the first book, and I love her even more in this one! Watching her deal with her trauma while growing into a badass woman was just so beautiful.

And the two MMCs…

I had a love-hate relationship with Helion in this book. Sometimes, he was an asshole, but I can forgive him because he’s hot and so cocky. He really grew on me by the end of the book!

But Rythos… Holy shadow-wielding gods, that man is PERFECTION! A man who’s been cursed to unalive his one and only love and is still strong enough to withstand it?! 10/10, without a doubt! The way he yearned for her, supported his woman, and protected his friends… He made me fall even harder for him than I did in the first book!

The story was once again incredibly entertaining and exciting. I loved the trials! I loved the side characters and how everything came together in the end. Nakita once again proved how good she is at playing with my emotions. The way she portrayed trauma and healing was so beautifully done!

And the ending?! It was NOTHING like I expected, and it absolutely destroyed me emotionally. 😭❤️
381 reviews20 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 7, 2026
"The melodies of the damned have become a ballad of the broken" indeed. My heart.

If you enjoyed book 1, Melodies of the Damned, then you'll for sure want to pick this up to see how this emotional, intense and spicy duet ends.

🖤Morally Grey
🌊Enemies to Lovers
🖤Captor x Captive
🌊Cursed Oceans
🖤Forced Proximity
🌊Sirens
🖤Dual POV
🌊Fated Mates
🖤Why Choose
🌶Spicy

"A choice must be made..."

"Would you blame a storm for following the wind?"

A captivating story of love, sacrifice and survival this story keeps you on the edge of your seat for this entire sequel. You start right where book 1 left off and Nakita's writing style will have you turning page after page long after you should be asleep. She knows just how to unravel her story, just which information to let loose and when. A lot happens in the last 25% so hold on to your heart because you're in for a deliciously spicy, emotional ride.

"The grief had hollowed me out so completely that even fear could no longer find a place to live. "

Thank you @nakita.writes.romantasy and @hawthorne.and.aster.services for the advanced read of this incredible debut duet.

As with any content, please check your own triggers prior to consuming.

##BalladoftheBroken #hawthorneandaster #fantasy #romantasy #darkfantasy
Profile Image for Jade.
88 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy
October 8, 2026
It was devastating, it was beautiful, it was BEAUTIFULLY DEVASTATING.
This was everything I didnt know I needed in a dark and twisted romantasy.
Book 2 picks up right where we left Lyra in book 1. There is multiple POVs in this book so we get to see and experience the broken world and what all our MCs doing to try fix it through their perspectives.
We have Gods, Monsters, Sirens and Fae. A FMC who will do ANYTHING for those she loves, consequences be damned.
Nakita takes us on an EPIC journey of how THIS world broke and the people trying to fix it. The last 15% of this book is so beautifully written I COULD NOT put it down. I laughed, I cried, I had my flabbers gahsted. It may not have ended how I wanted but it was done well and what happens when we ignore said consequences. EPIC, EPIC dark duology.
Please check your triggers as there is alot of darkness in this book, it's what in my opinion makes it so beautifully devastatingly written. Thank you Hawthorne and Aster for this ARC copy.
148 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 8, 2026
Oh my goodness, what a book.

I knew this was going to be heartbreaking, I knew it, and I still went in full of hope.

I loved the conclusion, loved how all the parts came together. I'm not sure if I was meant to fall in Helion, but boy did I. He is wrong in all the best ways, but by the end, I was just smitten with him.

Book 2 really focused on the consequences of the things our characters did for love, it's not your typical "burn the world down for them", in this story, if you burn the world down for love, then there are always repercussions for your actions. It is a beautiful and tragic love story, equal amounts epic and devastating.

I cannot recommend this duet enough, it will stay with me for a long time.
Profile Image for vampire•ink•drinker.
299 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 10, 2026
ALL THE STARS.
EVERY. LAST. ONE.

Book one left me adrift on a sea of sadness, but THIS? Broken indeed. 😭

The ugly crying I cried. Absolutely NOT cute. No grace. No dignity. Just emotional devastation in its purest form.

Thrown straight back into the events where book one left us, this story is awash in grief, impossible choices, and heartbreak.
My heart is STILL broken, and somehow, despite every tear, I wouldn't trade this experience for anything.

I genuinely don't know how to do this book justice without giving too much away, so I'll simply say this:
The writing is melodic and haunting, the story is heartbreakingly beautiful, and Nakita has written something that will stay with me long after the final page.

Nakita, thank you for such a poignant, soul crushingly beautiful story. You've officially got me ready to read absolutely anything you write.
49 reviews2 followers
October 24, 2026
I had to take a whole day to process what I had just read, because | was TOTALLY WRECKED IN THE FEELS! ( I loved the unique ending the author gave. Sad but tied the story together amazingly. Wow! The yearning, angst, the insane chemistry, and some of the most action-packed suspense I have read in awhile had me glued to the pages. I was frantically hunting for answers as the fantastic storyline delivered surprise after surprise. You add in a love triangle, shadow daddy vibes, gods, and cursed seas, and I AM SOLD - this book had me in an absolute chokehold, and I would MOST DEFINITELY RECOMMEND IT! This duo-logy was amazing!
Profile Image for Jenny.
234 reviews9 followers
October 13, 2026
Spoil Free Reviews

Stars: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Spice: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
Author: @nakita.writes.romantasy
POV: Multi 1st person
Gene: Romantasy
Triggers: Descriptive torture, captivity, forced marriage, manipulation, dubious consent, why choose (MFM), SA - in the past, grief, etc.
Read Time: 8 - 11 hours
Expected Publishing Date: October 24, 2026
I received an advance review copy from the author, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.

❤️ World Building: The world building was phenomenal! While in the last book we were in the one world, the story mostly takes place in “hell” and we got a good glimpse of the Nether. As you would imagine, these are darker places than the last book.

❤️ The Characters: How could you NOT love our trio? Helion was simply adorable in his roguish ways. I’m a sucker for a smirk! Rythos, oh Rythos, does he have to be so perfect? And then our heroine Lyra, stuck in the middle between the two. The feelings were so real to me, the pain, the grief, the love, all of it! They are written with such heart, you can really tell the author put their whole self into writing them.

❤️ The Story: The story was an absolute masterpiece, a Pièce de résistance if you will. I’m sad that the story has ended, but OH what a story it was! This one will be staying with me for a long long time.

❤️‍🔥Overall: If you love Romantasy, you just NEED to read this duology. If you like to listen to your books, these were just picked up for an audiobook deal! The first book is currently on KU, but for a limited time.

🦭Selkie fact Inspired by Selk: Some say that the origins of the selkie myth actually stem from Scottish and Irish ancient peoples coming into contact with Finnish and/or Sami travellers who were thought to be selkies for their use of sealskin coats and kayaks. As they became waterlogged, the boats would start to submerge, and so the Sami traveller would be required to stop and dry their sealskin clothing and boats out before continuing onwards. Take their “fishtails” away from them, and it’s true enough that the “selkie” cannot return to the sea. (source: https://www.wildernessireland.com/blo...)
Profile Image for Eirini.
35 reviews
October 24, 2026
ARC Review

This book had me going through so many different emotions, and honestly, i’m still recovering.

First of all, HELION. HELION, HELION, HELION. This man is infuriating, dangerously charming, and somehow manages to keep me intrigued even when i want to shake some sense into him. a walking red flag, and yet… here i am...

And then there’s Rythos, our tortured Commander, whose devotion and yearning had me feeling ALL the things. The angst, the desperation, the emotional damage…

Lyra? I have a complicated relationship with her. One minute i’m rooting for her, the next i’m questioning her decisions, but there’s never a dull moment with her around. That's for sure.

The dynamics between these three were easily one of my favorite parts of the book. The tension, the jealousy, the possessiveness, the complicated feelings… THE MESS OF IT ALL. I was seated.

Also, I really enjoyed exploring more of this dark, beautifully twisted world, with its mythology, magic, gods, and all the danger lurking around every corner. The story kept me curious, and i loved getting more insight into the characters and what makes them who they are.

While the pacing felt a little uneven in places, and there were moments when i wished certain things had been explored more deeply, i was still invested in the overall story and especially in these complicated characters.

Overall, Ballad of the Broken was an angsty, chaotic, emotionally charged romantasy that gave me plenty of reasons to keep turning the pages. It wasn’t perfect, but the characters, the tension, and the emotional roller coaster made it a very enjoyable read.

And HELION… i fear this is not the last time you’ll be hearing from me about this man... The name? The way he's built? Just... give me more... please... getting his POV was one of the things i was looking forward to the most. Morally questionable, dangerous, infuriating, and somehow still capable of making me understand him even when i wanted to throw fists.

Big thanks to Nikita Kirwan, Hawthorn & Aster and BookFunnel for the ARC Copy in exchange for my honest opinion.


Spoilers ahead!

AND THAT ENDING????? HELION CHOOSING TO BE IN THE DARK WITH HER RATHER THAN EXIST IN A WORLD WHERE SHE’S ALONE????? THE REDDEST GREEN FLAG (if thats a thing...)


Profile Image for Anchali Fahlstad.
32 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 10, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ SIX STARS!!!!

Thanks to Nakita Kirwan and Hawthorn & Aster for providing this ARC!

This book picks up right where the first one left off, and what a ride it is!

Lyra is with Helion, while Rythos desperately searches for her. The world surrounding them remains dark, eerie, and haunting. Lyra and Helion find themselves in the realm of the God of the Seven Hells, where they are forced to participate in his wicked games for his entertainment. Everyone seems to hold secrets about Lyra and her past, and she must learn to manipulate those around her to uncover the truth.

Meanwhile, the feelings between Lyra and Helion are becoming increasingly difficult to navigate. Despite hating him, she finds herself irresistibly drawn to him, and that tension? Absolutely delicious.

Lyra grows so much in this book! We get to see her become stronger while also witnessing her insecurities surrounding what truly happened when the Throne of the Gods was destroyed. The uncertainty surrounding her past and how it continues to affect her adds another layer to her character that I absolutely loved.

And Helion… this man is EVERYTHING in this book! The sexy smirk, the swagger, the confidence. I was completely sold. And Rythos? We get to see so many more sides of him, both his harder and softer sides, as well as the depth of his unwavering love for Lyra. My heart couldn’t handle it!

This book kept me on the edge of my seat, and the pages practically flew by. The plot is phenomenal, and Nakita Kirwan knows exactly how to keep you hooked while slowly revealing more of the secrets woven into this dark, haunting world.
An ending that left me emotionally wrecked and still wanting more.

Nakita Kirwan has created an utterly addictive world, and this series is absolutely top-tier. Six stars, without a doubt. 🖤
Profile Image for Bronwyn Wilton.
40 reviews5 followers
October 24, 2026
If you want an unexpected ending, then this is for you.
This the second and final book in the series and picks up where book 1, Melodies of the Damned, ended.
Lyra has been taken to the Seven Hells by Helion.
She is forced to marry Helion and a second bond forms inside her heart alongside Rythos’ bond.
Both Helion and Lyra are forced into trials for the entertainment of the God of Gods, Astaroth. Also, as punishment for their crimes against the realms. Not that Lyra has those memories of what happened. Everyone else seems to remember by her, though Rythos is unsure of how he was cursed. Helion refuses to tell her what happened, claiming it was all him.
I appreciate Helion’s arc in the book. His need to make amends and prove himself to Lyra, even though he is holding back so much.
In this book we get multiple POVs. We get Lyra and a couple of Helion. We also get Rythos as he fights his way back to Lyra. We even get a vague connection between Lyra and Rythos through their bond while she is with Helion. Which feels like torture to him, especially as his curse continues to consume him.
Like I said, this book will not end how you expect, but I think it is the perfect ending. Some may not like it, but it is almost how I see the ending for Violet and Xaden.
This book was absorbing, with enough twists to be unexpected and engaging. The best thing is it is something different. A different magic system and mythology. Although we have the weak human girl transform into a goddess who learns to fight back against the world. But we have unexpected choices, and unexpected ending and characters who do the unexpected for love.
‘Love is not stronger than death, though perhaps that was never the point. How could something so powerful, so consuming have an ending? But everything worth having is also worth losing in the end.’ – Rythos
‘Love was not only choosing to stay. Sometimes, love was sacrifice.’ - Lyra
Profile Image for Sadie.
16 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 12, 2026
Thanks for the ARC read Hawthorn & Aster!

I DEVOURED this book. Like I know it says it took me 3 days, but like 80% was done in one day.

This book had me feeling so many things. Excited, aroused, devastated, happy, anger.

Getting into the nitty gritty.... (spoilers)

I wasn't crazy about the multiple POVs, I enjoyed the first book being all from Lyra's perspective. I understand why this one needed it, due to being separated, but It still broke some of the magic the first one had.

Lyra was wonderful as always. Strong, fighting back and fighting for what she wants. Not being the broken little princess she was at the beginning of book 1 and becoming the strong goddess she truly is. I wish we had delved more into what she did with Cerilla other than the brief mentionings.

HELION. Literally give me this man on a silver platter. He's hot, he's bratty, he's kinky. Like I am here for it all. He loves her, he's forgiven her, he's done so much to make things right and help her. I loved their banter, their slow burn, when they finally consummated that marriage, YES.

Rythos was still pretty mid for me. Am I devastated at his ending, absolutely. My soul was breaking from the second she decided to sacrifice herself all through the ending. And his real backstory was wonderful and made so much sense. He's just never been a particularly strong character for me. His softness with Lyra never really felt like it fit him.

This book was an amazing continuation of the first book and such a great ending to the duology. I'm both devastated and thrilled that there wasn't really a HEA. Because life doesn't always work out.
Profile Image for Kasey.
433 reviews14 followers
October 23, 2026
Thank you to Hawthorn & Aster and the author for the gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

Ballad of the Broken is book 2 in the Crowns of Gods and Monsters series and it is just as amazing as book 1! I could not wait to immerse myself back into this world that has so much emotional depth and so many layers. It is so heartbreaking, but so beautiful at the same time. The world building continues to be beautifully written, dreary and immersive. The magic system is creative and so neat to read it develop more. The characters are complex and each have traumas and fears, making them relatable and humanized. I felt Lyra’s pain like it was my own and I learned to love both Rythos and Helion. I didn’t know who I could trust and I was waiting for the shoe to drop, but so much unfolds and is revealed in due time. You’ll have to find out for yourself who it is you can trust and who you can’t! The pacing is great in my opinion, and it is easy to follow and understand. It had me invested from the beginning all the way to the end. The plot twists are twisting, and I couldn’t get enough of it. The end had me sobbing and feeling every emotion. I still don’t want to admit to myself it was real and it happened. Overall, amazing series and will forever recommend it.

If you love dark romantasy, morally grey, enemies to lovers, spice, captor romance, forced proximity, cursed oceans, dual POV, fated mates, and why choose then I absolutely recommend this series!
Profile Image for Theresa G.
27 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 10, 2026
Review of advance copy received from Hawthorn & Aster
https://www.hawthornandaster.com/
Ballad of the Broken

An Emotional and Heartbreaking Conclusion

I really enjoyed Ballad of the Broken, but I wasn't prepared for how emotional the final chapters would be. I found myself tearful as the story unfolded, particularly because I had become so invested in Lyra, Rhythos, and Helion. The story picks up where the first book left off, providing some much-needed answers about the characters’ past lives, their relationships, and the consequences of decisions made over a thousand years ago.

I particularly appreciated the character development of the three main characters. Their relationships evolved in ways I hadn't anticipated, and I enjoyed seeing how love, forgiveness, acceptance, and sacrifice influenced their choices. The revelations about their shared history added another layer of complexity to the story, and the author did a wonderful job exploring the emotional consequences of their actions.

Although I understood the significance of the ending and appreciated how the storylines came together, I couldn't help wishing for a different outcome. I had grown attached to these characters and hoped they would finally find the happiness they deserved.

Overall, this was a beautiful emotional story that left me heartbroken. I thoroughly enjoyed the journey, even if the ending wasn't quite what I had hoped for.
Profile Image for E B .
11 reviews
October 24, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️’s


I’m so grateful to have received this as an arc thank you Nakita and Hawthorn & Aster for the copy🖤

oh my where do I even start…
I was so excited to get into book 2 because of the cliffhanger in book 1. I LOVED how book 2 started exactly where book 1 left off at. Usually, authors try to do “ a couple of months later” crap but not Nakita, so thank you!!

When I read Melodies of the damned I kind of pushed myself through it because it wasn’t dual pov and a real slow burn. However, in Ballad of the broken the plot picked up quickly plus we get everyone’s pov. I pulled an all-nighter because I was hookeddd. Like girl the plot twist was twisting!!! I lowkey forgot it was a why choose until I started reading and not going to lie I was a Hellion’s girl in book 1 & stayed a Hellion girl in book 2. ( sorry rythos )

Throughout the book I felt every emotion, sad because of what Rythos was going through, Lyra fighting her feelings and Hellion feeling like he’s not worthy of love. Happy because Lyra was finally getting answers to her questions, Rythos coming to terms with his fate and Hellion for realizing that he doesn’t have to pretend to be someone else.

I really loved this book I liked how both of the mmc’s were opposites, Riven the submissive but smart-talking man and Rythos the dominant, the “do what I say or I’ll beat you up”. But yet they were still perfect for my girl Lyra.

I will say the ending had me crying, I totally did not see that coming. I guess it’s a reminder that it’s okay to let go and not everything can be an easy fix.
381 reviews20 followers
October 25, 2026
Ballad of the Broken
(Crowns of Gods and Monsters - book 2)
By: @nakita.writes.romantasy

"The melodies of the damned have become a ballad of the broken" indeed. My heart.

If you enjoyed book 1, Melodies of the Damned, then you'll for sure want to pick this up to see how this emotional, intense and spicy duet ends.

🖤Morally Grey
🌊Enemies to Lovers
🖤Captor x Captive
🌊Cursed Oceans
🖤Forced Proximity
🌊Sirens
🖤Dual POV
🌊Fated Mates
🖤Why Choose
🌶Spicy

"A choice must be made..."

"Would you blame a storm for following the wind?"

A captivating story of love, sacrifice and survival this story keeps you on the edge of your seat for this entire sequel. You start right where book 1 left off and Nakita's writing style will have you turning page after page long after you should be asleep. She knows just how to unravel her story, just which information to let loose and when. A lot happens in the last 25% so hold on to your heart because you're in for a deliciously spicy, emotional ride.

"The grief had hollowed me out so completely that even fear could no longer find a place to live. "

Thank you @nakita.writes.romantasy and @hawthorne.and.aster.services for the advanced read of this incredible debut duet.

As with any content, please check your own triggers prior to consuming.

#BalladoftheBroken #hawthorneandaster #fantasy #romantasy #darkfantasy
2 reviews
Review of advance copy
October 6, 2026
Received this ARC from Hawthorn & Aster and was so grateful for it because Melodies of the Damned left me begging for more. After completing Ballad of the Broken this is what I have to say:
This whole duology really took me by surprise. I thought Melodies of the Damned was really well done, but even with those elevated expectations nothing could have prepared me for how beautifully Kirwan landed this sequel. She absolutely nailed it! Overall, I'd describe this duology as a (very) dark iteration of the Little Mermaid meets The Witcher meets the chaos of Greek mythology. The raw, visceral way Lyra's journey is captured, the plot twists and sub plots that bolster the intensity of the reading experience, the urgency brought into the story line by the Commander of Death, and the devastating, heart breaking loyalty of Helion had me in an absolute chokehold the entire time. Truly so very impressed by this author and I cannot wait to read more from her. Aaaand now it's time to go hydrate because the tears this author pulled from my body aren't going to replenish themselves.
Profile Image for Charlee Lock.
67 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 9, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive this ARC via Hawthorn & Aster.

This book picks up straight were book 1 ends, I was still reeling from the plot twist from book 1 - Riven was the bad guy?! And Cirella oh that witch!!!

I truly love the way Nakita weaves her stories, the layers upon layers of lore, world building and character development. I love the imagery she paints with her words. I was right there inside the pages with the characters.

I enjoyed the hate to love story between Lyra and Helion, the ever loving passion of a dying monster and his little drowning and of course the all consuming world destroying love of gods, goddesses and mortals that this story

The spice levels up for me in this story and I am all for it!

There were moments where I giggle aloud and sobbed woefully, this duology will forever have a pride of place in my heart and on my bookshelf.

Profile Image for Rebecca.
210 reviews48 followers
October 10, 2026
“Despite being the monster made to kill me, my soul ached to return to his side as if that was where I belonged.”

✨ Morally grey
✨ Why choose & Fated mates
✨ Epic worldbuilding
✨ Spicy 🔥🔥

This was a HIGHLY anticipated sequel for me, and it definitely delivered. Heartbreakingly beautiful, with complicated relationships, incredible worldbuilding and some very nice spice. I was so excited to return to this world, and it did not disappoint.

“I would marry him, though, I would be widowed the moment I had what I wanted.”

The romance growing between Lyra and Helion was something I really enjoyed. There’s so much going on beneath the surface of their relationship, and watching Lyra’s feelings develop when she’s still so deeply tied to someone else made everything that much more complicated.

“I was too broken to be worshipped. Too ruined to be admired. Too monstrous to be loved.”

And then there’s Rythos, who’s still searching for Lyra and loving her despite everything. Knowing what he’s going through while their bond lets him feel her falling for someone else adds another layer to their story. He’s running out of time, and that desperation to find her again really adds to the heartbreak.

“The day you fell in love with the Commander, I discovered that hearts don’t stop when they are broken. They simply learn to bleed forever.”

The mythology and worldbuilding were another huge highlight. I loved the depth of this world and how the story weaves together the gods, the curse and the fate of the kingdoms while keeping the characters and their relationships at the heart of it all.

“I was a princess who had died beneath the weight of expectation. A girl too sharp, too strange, too unhinged to fit inside the mould of perfection they had carved for me.”

Overall, this was a beautiful sequel that lived up to the anticipation. The relationships, the mythology, the worldbuilding, the heartbreak and the spice all came together so well. Definitely one that left me glad I picked it up! 🔥

Chaos, vibes and opinions are all my own ✨ please give credit if you share.
Profile Image for Natalie nataliescraftedcreations.
111 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 12, 2026
Ballad of the Broken is a dark fantasy romance intended for an 18+ audience. The Content warnings should be taken into account before reading.


What to expect

🌊 Morally Grey
🖤Enemies to Lovers
🌊 Spice
🖤 Captor Romance
🌊 Forced Proximity
🖤 Cursed Oceans
🌊 Dual POV
🖤 Fated Mates
🌊 Why Choose (MMF)


⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Spice included




Thoughts

Thank you to HAWTHORN & ASTER for this ARC.

After I finished this I was left lying on my bed, completely speechless, and with nothing but my thoughts to reflect on. I was laying there asking, how do I review a book when I don’t know what to say?

“Sometimes the most delicate things are the most lethal.”

Let me try, This was a beautifully chaotic, Broken love story! I think you should definitely read it but Please check the content warnings as some things maybe not be for all readers.

I legitimately have no more words!

“Would you blame a storm for following the wind?”

Thank you Nakita! The Duet Was told in a beautifully broken but great way!
Profile Image for Rebecca.
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
October 10, 2026
Dark fantasy romance isn’t typically my genre, but I’m really glad I gave this series a chance! I started with Melodies of the Damned, and I definitely recommend reading the books in order. The first ends on a cliffhanger, and I think knowing the characters and their relationships makes this one so much more meaningful.

What stood out to me most was the writing. I could easily picture the world and everything happening around the characters. As someone who enjoys D&D and fantasy video games, I especially loved the fantasy elements. I was constantly curious about what would happen next, and it was definitely a page-turner!

It’s a beautiful but tragic love story with some spice. I don’t typically read spicy romance, but those scenes felt natural and helped me better understand the relationships rather than feeling unnecessary.

Overall, I really enjoyed this book and am glad I stepped outside my usual reading preferences!

Thank you to Hawthorn & Aster for providing an advance reader copy (ARC) in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Samantha B.
25 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 9, 2026
Review of advanced readers copy received from author

What a beautifully tragic tale. Nakita Kirwan has once again created a story so consuming and immersive that I'm not sure where the characters' emotions end and mine begin. Did I accidentally bond these men too? 🥵🥵 Holy moly......but in all seriousness, my husband thanks you 😘 😂

Thank you to Hawthorne & Aster as well for marketing this ARC so I was lucky enough to find it and apply. 😊
Profile Image for Letitia Brooks.
68 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 10, 2026
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of Ballad of the Broken, words and review are my own.

Ballad of the Broken was my favourite of the duology, the pacing was great. My heart will forever be with our Monster, he stole the show in this book with his rawness and desperation to save Lyra and find some sembalance of peace. His exhaustion, devotion and at times devastation were heart-felt. I loved the relationships with Solas and Aldric - he became much more human in this book. The grief was real - tears in my eye Nakita.

I found the dynamic between Lyra & Helion conflicting, well it left me conflicted, I would have loved to explore their back-story a bit more to put it into context - maybe we need a novella!

The ending...what can I say. Heartfelt, devastating, inevitable...parts of it were expected but others...nope did not expect that.

Well done.

Please read the trigger warnings, this duology is very dark and some themes may make you uncomfortable.
Profile Image for Bookmarked Chaos.
35 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 14, 2026
My first book of the year that shared every emotion and made me want to scream, cry and laugh. I love a good book that makes me feel them all and Hawthorn & Aster supporting this story and putting it out in the world I am grateful for. I was lucky to be able to read this duo without having to wait and thankfully you don’t have much longer either as it is hitting the shelves the 24th of this month! Thank you Nakita for allowing us this amazing story with so many twists and turns. It is bound to make you feel something.
19 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 6, 2026
Totally invested. Ballad of the Broken picked up perfectly from the 1st book of the Duology Melodies of the Damned. I loved the different pov perspective. The Author has this amazing ability to drop crumbs for just one more chapter and she did it again. Once again she immersed me into another world. A roller coaster of emotions. Times where I laughed and omg I cried. Spicey, saucy and savage. Totally recommend 👌 👍 👏
Profile Image for Rachel Hellyer.
5 reviews
October 24, 2026
I had been eagerly awaiting the continuation of this story, and it did not disappoint. The second part was able to build and grow on the world, the mythology and history without being too much or a repetition of the first.

The tension, the yearning, the pain and emotional betrayal....it is everything a dark fantasy romance could promise. Just like the first book, I had to stop myself from putting the book down in those last fifty pages just because I didn't want it to end.
Profile Image for Jerry.
Author 1 book4 followers
October 25, 2026
This is a spoiler free ARC review. Thanks to the author and Hawthorn and Aster for the opportunity!

Book 2 of the Crowns of Gods and Monsters series picks up right where Melodies of the Damned ended. The epic world building continues in this book, and the twists, turns and trials they endure will keep you on the edge of your seat.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews