What do you think?
Rate this book


465 pages, Kindle Edition
Published October 22, 2026
After reading Melodies of the Damned and that cliffhanger… I figured the second book would be a fight of love and triumph for Lyra and Rythos. BUT I WAS WRONG, and it was beyond heartbreaking. Melodies of the Damned showcased Lyra’s want and need to be free of the cage she was in and death being a viable option was okay with her. Until she met people she began to trust and eventually The Commander of Death. The slow-burn, enemies-to-lovers plotline grew into an overwhelming and true love that I adored. I loved their love.
Enter Helion and book 2… I’m sorry but the ending of Ballad of the Broken simply broke me and I honestly hated it. I desperately wanted the perfect outcome for Lyra and Rythos. She deserved to be loved by the man she truly loved, and he deserved to finally love the woman he loved for thousands of years for a thousand more. I truly wish the ending had reflected that, but it was just grief of a crappy outcome. While I understand she broke the world to love him… that’s the depth that deserved a happier outcome.
The why choose and Helion, I just didn’t care for. I will firmly state that I am not a fan of why choose, and when book 2 went in this direction I was like, “…ok…” But I can acknowledge the aspects of ‘light’ and ‘dark’ in the plotline. I understand Helion’s love for Maraveth, but Lyra deserved more WITH Rythos, or at least an ending that showed them meeting again in some shape or form to be together for eternity. In my opinion, Helion made his bed and he should have slept in it ALONE. Love is enduring, however, Lyra and Maraveth found it in a different man and let it bloom and grow enough to destroy worlds for it.
I wish there had been a different ending, and truly I needed it after being immersed in the love story between Lyra and Rythos, but I assume that was not the purpose. Which is why book 2 did not register has higher than a 3-star read.