4.5 stars.
Absolutely fascinating. As a woman, I feel a little ashamed that I know so little about the actual history of the women's movement. I knew some names, knew (and appreciate) some of the rights the early suffragists fought for, but only vaguely understood what happened to the women's movement during the 1960s. I'm Christian, conservative and pro-life and I am extremely uncomfortable with many of the principles the current feminist movement espouses. I had a friend ask me the other day if I would call myself a feminist, and although I absolutely believe in the equality of women, I cannot bring myself to actually identify as a feminist as it is popularly defined. If there was more room for my voice as pro-life, pro-marriage, pro-children, pro-family (in places other than the church), I would climb right on that bandwagon. But as it is, those opinions are not often welcome.
Sue Ellen Browder takes you through the broader events of the sexual revolution and abortion rights becoming intertwined with the original women's rights movement (of which I knew nothing and I suspect most women have never studied in any great depth) while also chronicling how it affected her. She is extremely articulate, vulnerable, and honest. And also just a beautiful writer. Although she clearly believes that abortion and sexual freedom are harmful to women, she never disparages any of the key players - Betty Friedan, Helen Gurley Brown, Larry Lader, Margaret Sanger. Within the Christian community, some of these feminists often get painted as thoroughly evil so I appreciated her respectful disagreement. I had some assumptions corrected (such as that Betty Friedan was not initially pro-abortion and she eventually concluded that adding abortion rights to the women's movement was not helpful in the long run or that Margaret Sanger, despite all her other eccentricities and acceptance of eugenics, was vehemently anti-abortion) and I really appreciated that.
I'm not a huge fan of spiritual memoirs and this very much is one. At some parts, I was a little bored by the family's financial troubles and cross-country moves. I'm also not Catholic (which she is) and there's a very brief portion where she makes an odd (and slightly snarky) decision that she cannot convert to Protestantism because it is a terrible place for women's rights since Martin Luther and King Henry VIII were either corrupt or misogynistic. Which, ok, not debating those specific points, but I also don't think it discounts an entire belief system. There's been plenty of corruption within the Catholic church as well. However, I still appreciated her story of how she came to genuine faith and found hope and redemption through Christ.
I really kind of want to buy multiple copies of this and hand it out to friends simply because I think most of us have not spent time thinking about the history of abortion rights, whether casual sex is actually freeing for women, and logically forming beliefs either for or against abortion. It's way too easy to just accept the opinions of others or the slogans that are either present in our churches or the media. Whether or not you accept Sue Ellen's version of how abortion became such a central part of feminism or whether or not you agree with her perspective on abortion and casual sex, this is a worthwhile book to engage with the issue.