Well Balanced History
Having grown up in the age of Braveheart and always being aware of my significantly Scottish ancestry (3/8th at last attempted reckoning), you might be surprised at my positive review for a historical work about the King known as the Hammer of the Scots and the subduer of the Welsh; but if Tout does an incredible job of recounting the past in a non-judgmental manner, he also manages to not gloss over the grittier portions of the king's character and actions. While certainly not biographical history, Tout infuses just enough of the personal and personality to enable the modern reader to at least comprehend the disparities and occasional cruelties of the medieval king, if not accept or understand them. The author clearly believes that, when all factors are weighed and historical perspective is accounted for, Edward I can be deemed a successful and good king. At the least, his kingship certainly shines when compared to his two predecessors and his immediate successor, but the author's bias does not fully take into account the far-reaching consequences of Edward's Welsh and Scottish policies. In terms of England's history and the consequences of his domestic policies, Tout declares him a resounding success.
On the whole, the prose is concise and clear. Eminently readable for both the novice and the scholar.