What do you think?
Rate this book
The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster
Not yet published
Expected 4 Dec 26A Trial of the Century
Was Lizzie Guilty of Murder?In the Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother with a hatchet.
In 1893, Lizzie Borden stood trial for the brutal murders of her father, Andrew, and stepmother, Abby, in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. There were no eyewitnesses, no confession and no murder weapon that could conclusively be tied to the crime. Instead, the prosecution built its case from a disturbing collection of Lizzie's conflicting accounts of her movements, an alleged attempt to buy poison shortly before the killings, and a dress she burned in the kitchen stove three days afterwards. What followed became one of the most notorious murder trials in American a case of family tensions, missing evidence and reasonable doubt, played out before a public struggling to imagine that a respectable Victorian woman could have committed such a savage crime.
Drawn from the original trial transcripts and contemporary reporting, this edition recreates the key exchanges between prosecution and the discovery of the bodies inside the Borden home, the search for a weapon, Lizzie's behaviour before and after the murders, and the circumstantial evidence on which the prosecution attempted to build its case. The proceedings reveal not only the mystery at the heart of the Borden murders but the assumptions of Gilded Age America about class, respectability and what a woman was capable of doing.
The Trial of Lizzie Borden is the fourth title in the Trials of the Century series, following The Trial of Patty Hearst .
Was Lizzie Guilty of Murder?In the Lizzie Borden, accused of murdering her father and stepmother with a hatchet.
In 1893, Lizzie Borden stood trial for the brutal murders of her father, Andrew, and stepmother, Abby, in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. There were no eyewitnesses, no confession and no murder weapon that could conclusively be tied to the crime. Instead, the prosecution built its case from a disturbing collection of Lizzie's conflicting accounts of her movements, an alleged attempt to buy poison shortly before the killings, and a dress she burned in the kitchen stove three days afterwards. What followed became one of the most notorious murder trials in American a case of family tensions, missing evidence and reasonable doubt, played out before a public struggling to imagine that a respectable Victorian woman could have committed such a savage crime.
Drawn from the original trial transcripts and contemporary reporting, this edition recreates the key exchanges between prosecution and the discovery of the bodies inside the Borden home, the search for a weapon, Lizzie's behaviour before and after the murders, and the circumstantial evidence on which the prosecution attempted to build its case. The proceedings reveal not only the mystery at the heart of the Borden murders but the assumptions of Gilded Age America about class, respectability and what a woman was capable of doing.
The Trial of Lizzie Borden is the fourth title in the Trials of the Century series, following The Trial of Patty Hearst .
Audiobook
Expected publication December 4, 2026
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
November 6, 2026
3.5⭐️
I went into this audiobook knowing very little about Lizzie Borden, but I certainly came away with plenty to think about.
In 1892, 32-year-old Lizzie Borden stood trial for the brutal murders of her father and stepmother, who had suffered 41 and 40 blows respectively. But was she a grieving daughter caught up in a terrible tragedy, or a cold-blooded murderer?
We’re taken through the trial, hearing the evidence and arguments as the jury tries to piece together what really happened. After deliberation, they found Lizzie not guilty. However, with the murderer never identified, the case remains unsolved.
I found myself weighing up the evidence as I listened, and despite everything presented, I came away believing Lizzie was not guilty. Of course, we’ll probably never know what really happened, and that’s what makes this case so intriguing. There are still so many unanswered questions, and I found myself wanting to know more.
Sandra Parsons does a lovely job narrating, keeping the story engaging throughout.
At just 1 hour and 16 minutes, this was a really interesting listen and one that certainly got me thinking. Having heard all the evidence, I’m still firmly in the not guilty camp, but I suppose we’ll never know what really happened. And isn’t that the frustrating thing about an unsolved case?
Thank you to NetGalley, Roland O’Leary, narrator Sandra Parsons and Classic Crime Ltd for this ALC in exchange for my honest review.
Publishing date: 4th December 2026
I went into this audiobook knowing very little about Lizzie Borden, but I certainly came away with plenty to think about.
In 1892, 32-year-old Lizzie Borden stood trial for the brutal murders of her father and stepmother, who had suffered 41 and 40 blows respectively. But was she a grieving daughter caught up in a terrible tragedy, or a cold-blooded murderer?
We’re taken through the trial, hearing the evidence and arguments as the jury tries to piece together what really happened. After deliberation, they found Lizzie not guilty. However, with the murderer never identified, the case remains unsolved.
I found myself weighing up the evidence as I listened, and despite everything presented, I came away believing Lizzie was not guilty. Of course, we’ll probably never know what really happened, and that’s what makes this case so intriguing. There are still so many unanswered questions, and I found myself wanting to know more.
Sandra Parsons does a lovely job narrating, keeping the story engaging throughout.
At just 1 hour and 16 minutes, this was a really interesting listen and one that certainly got me thinking. Having heard all the evidence, I’m still firmly in the not guilty camp, but I suppose we’ll never know what really happened. And isn’t that the frustrating thing about an unsolved case?
Thank you to NetGalley, Roland O’Leary, narrator Sandra Parsons and Classic Crime Ltd for this ALC in exchange for my honest review.
Publishing date: 4th December 2026
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I’ve read numerous books in the past about Lizzie Borden, but after reading my GR friend Caz’s review, I was inspired to listen to this audio version, “The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster” by Roland O'Leary and narrated by Sandra Parsons.
I **absolutely** love the narrator’s British accent. For some reason—probably due to all of the BBC British mysteries I’ve watched—hearing a British accent just adds to the mystery. I also love that this is a full-cast audio using numerous actors. Full-cast audios make the story really come to life. Even the background noise (e.g., the murmuring in the courtroom) was 100% realistic.
Leary did an excellent job providing the essential evidence regarding this case. I particularly appreciate how the author took pains to ensure that readers/listeners weren’t “led” to a conclusion. This is an excellent recording and I absolutely recommend it.
I received an ARC of “The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster” by Roland O'Leary from NetGalley, Classic Crime, and Trials of the Century Audiobooks, in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
I **absolutely** love the narrator’s British accent. For some reason—probably due to all of the BBC British mysteries I’ve watched—hearing a British accent just adds to the mystery. I also love that this is a full-cast audio using numerous actors. Full-cast audios make the story really come to life. Even the background noise (e.g., the murmuring in the courtroom) was 100% realistic.
Leary did an excellent job providing the essential evidence regarding this case. I particularly appreciate how the author took pains to ensure that readers/listeners weren’t “led” to a conclusion. This is an excellent recording and I absolutely recommend it.
I received an ARC of “The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster” by Roland O'Leary from NetGalley, Classic Crime, and Trials of the Century Audiobooks, in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A 90-minute dramatization of one of the most buffling trials which presents the facts but leaves the interpretation to the listener ..
November 8, 2026
Got the audiobook for review on netgally.
I think I've listened to every Trials in this series and enjoyed them all a lot. This time I went into it a little differently as ive already heard podcasts/read by Lizzie Borden as its a puzzling but interesting case. The audiobook felt realistic and an very engaging read. I think its hard to listen to this and not develop your own opinions (or theories) about the case. I do feel like the police, media and public was so set it being Lizzie Borden they might not have been looking for evidence of it being someone else. But hard to know really.
I think I've listened to every Trials in this series and enjoyed them all a lot. This time I went into it a little differently as ive already heard podcasts/read by Lizzie Borden as its a puzzling but interesting case. The audiobook felt realistic and an very engaging read. I think its hard to listen to this and not develop your own opinions (or theories) about the case. I do feel like the police, media and public was so set it being Lizzie Borden they might not have been looking for evidence of it being someone else. But hard to know really.
November 3, 2026
I’d like to send a thank you to NetGalley and Classic Crime Ltd for the ARC
The fourth installment of Trials of the Century has been released and it’s the trial of the infamous Lizzie Borden, the woman who was convicted for murdering her father and step-mother.
130 years later have passed since the murder and the question of the trial remains: was Lizzie guilty? I have been familiar with this case for years and fascinated by it.
The format follows the other three books in the series. The full cast narration with the sound effects really brings the case more to life, especially with the courtroom scenes.
At the end of the day, nobody will know what happened - though the book does feature Lizzie’s testimony. While I did enjoy listening to this, I wish it was longer. The question to this day still remains whether Lizzie was the one who committed the crime. As always, the true-crime documentary style of the book made it more engaging for audiences, whether people are familiar with the case or not.
Pub date: December 4th, 2026
October 31, 2026
This recording is the latest in the Trials of the Century series, which Ive thoroughly enjoyed.
As usual I think I know a story but, again as usual, I'm entirely wrong.
For starters I had always believed that Lizzie Borden was a child when her parents were killed. It turns out that she was 32. I had also believed that Lizzie was found guilty - not so.
So I am oh for two at this stage.
The recording itself is made by an ensemble cast and works very well. We get some basic background before the trial itself begins. Obviously it isn't the whole trial but we do hear Lizzie's testimony on the stand.
You can make your own mind up about er guilt or innocence but I will say the testimony of the coroner makes for such grim reading it is hard to imagine anyonr having such rage, let alone a god-fearing daughter.
Thankyou to Netgalley and Trials of the Century Audiobooks for the advance audio review copy.
As usual I think I know a story but, again as usual, I'm entirely wrong.
For starters I had always believed that Lizzie Borden was a child when her parents were killed. It turns out that she was 32. I had also believed that Lizzie was found guilty - not so.
So I am oh for two at this stage.
The recording itself is made by an ensemble cast and works very well. We get some basic background before the trial itself begins. Obviously it isn't the whole trial but we do hear Lizzie's testimony on the stand.
You can make your own mind up about er guilt or innocence but I will say the testimony of the coroner makes for such grim reading it is hard to imagine anyonr having such rage, let alone a god-fearing daughter.
Thankyou to Netgalley and Trials of the Century Audiobooks for the advance audio review copy.
November 8, 2026
A fascinating and well-presented look at one of history’s most infamous murder mysteries. I really enjoyed how this audio drama brought the courtroom proceedings to life, using original trial transcripts and contemporary reporting to explore the evidence, conflicting testimonies, and family tensions surrounding Lizzie Borden. The narration and dramatic presentation kept me interested throughout, and I appreciated that it allowed the listener to consider both sides rather than simply jumping to conclusions. It was intriguing, thought-provoking, and full of historical detail. A little slow in places, but overall a very engaging listen for anyone interested in true crime, history, and unsolved mysteries.
November 7, 2026
This was intriguing, I wasn’t at all familiar with the story for some reason. At least I don’t think so. I feel like I should’ve heard about it somewhere. I don’t consume a lot of true crime media, books, podcasts, you know. But once in a while I do, and these Trials of the Century audiobooks really do it for me, I’m on my fourth I think, and they’re so interesting every time. Even when the story isn’t something you’ve heard before the full cast narration makes sure you’re involved. There’s a kind of rhyme, like a nursery rhyme, said and repeated by this little kid in this one, and it kind of sent chills down my spine! Anyway, onto the actual story.
Lizzie Borden is said to have murdered both her father and stepmother, to make it brief. Now, is she an actual murderer or caught up in some terrible tragedy? It’s interesting that even now there’s no concrete answer to it. The case remains unsolved. She was found not guilty by the end though. I’m not sure anyone knows how to feel about that. Conflicted, maybe.
Overall, this story was entrancing even for people like me, who aren’t familiar with almost anything about this particular case. For me, that changed today. I’d give this four stars, I really liked it.
Audiobook notes: I found the narration to be top tier, as usual. Again, the nursery rhyme was creepy, the whole atmosphere was so realistic. You always feel like you’re in the courtroom with them. All the different voices and accents really make the book for me. Another reason (the main one, in fact) why I would recommend this book and series.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Lizzie Borden is said to have murdered both her father and stepmother, to make it brief. Now, is she an actual murderer or caught up in some terrible tragedy? It’s interesting that even now there’s no concrete answer to it. The case remains unsolved. She was found not guilty by the end though. I’m not sure anyone knows how to feel about that. Conflicted, maybe.
Overall, this story was entrancing even for people like me, who aren’t familiar with almost anything about this particular case. For me, that changed today. I’d give this four stars, I really liked it.
Audiobook notes: I found the narration to be top tier, as usual. Again, the nursery rhyme was creepy, the whole atmosphere was so realistic. You always feel like you’re in the courtroom with them. All the different voices and accents really make the book for me. Another reason (the main one, in fact) why I would recommend this book and series.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing an ALC in exchange for an honest review.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This audio production features a full cast of narrators so that the story really comes alive. It is reminiscent of an old time radio show with sound effects. The script comes from trial transcripts and other primary sources so it is more accurate than some of the so called docu-dramas about this woman.
I enjoyed it and wish it had been longer. The crime has never really been solved definitively though I’m sure many have an opinion. It was just so long ago and forensics and evidence and trial procedure are much different now.
I enjoyed it and wish it had been longer. The crime has never really been solved definitively though I’m sure many have an opinion. It was just so long ago and forensics and evidence and trial procedure are much different now.
November 1, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and Classic Crime for providing me with an ALC.
As always, Classic Crime does a brilliant job of bringing the courtroom and investigation setting to the listener. I had never heard of this case before so it was interesting to read about. The sound effects and ordering of the different transcripts and interviews were done very well and kept the narration engaging. The multicast narration also played a part in that. I like that the book didn't really push their opinion/conclusion on the readers and just presented the facts/evidence. I will definitely be listening to any upcoming books in the Trials of the Century series. I would definitely recommend it to anyone who reads books or listens to podcasts in the true crime genre.
As always, Classic Crime does a brilliant job of bringing the courtroom and investigation setting to the listener. I had never heard of this case before so it was interesting to read about. The sound effects and ordering of the different transcripts and interviews were done very well and kept the narration engaging. The multicast narration also played a part in that. I like that the book didn't really push their opinion/conclusion on the readers and just presented the facts/evidence. I will definitely be listening to any upcoming books in the Trials of the Century series. I would definitely recommend it to anyone who reads books or listens to podcasts in the true crime genre.
October 28, 2026
I was so happy to see this new release coming - it's the fourth book in the Trials Of The Century series and you may remember that over this year, I've read the first three books - The Trial Of Leopold And Loeb - Dickie & Babe by Ben Devlin then The Trial Of Dr Crippen - A Drop Of Poison by Matt Richards and most recently The Trial Of Patty Hearst - The Captive Mind by Céline Fitzmaurice.
There are so many things I love about this series and I really hope I manage to catch them all along the way.
These are super quick read trials - just over an hour on audio and this means that I can easily binge read one over my lunchtime while I eat.
The audio format features a full recap of the whole trial and uses a multi narrator cast and sound effects which creates such an authentic feel to the production.
It really does feel like you're there in the room watching the trial play out.
I'm absolutely fascinated by true crime, but never seem to be able to fit any into my schedule so these books are the perfect solution to get my fix and learn about some of the famous names from the past.
Having said this, I'd never heard of Lizzie Borden and her case was certainly an intriguing one.
Did she murder her own father and stepmother or was she really innocent?
What fascinates me is that we will never really know in some of the cases - but to hear the statements from those called to trial - hear how the lawyers bombard with their questions and see the differences in evidence methods between them and now - it's amazing how much progress has been made - yet still we maybe don't always get it right?
Listening to these books has sent me down various rabbit holes after reading and I'm glad that they've prompted me to take more time on something I find really interesting.
If you haven't seen this series before or haven't read the books yet, I can't recommend this enough and am looking forward to seeing who will be next.
There are so many things I love about this series and I really hope I manage to catch them all along the way.
These are super quick read trials - just over an hour on audio and this means that I can easily binge read one over my lunchtime while I eat.
The audio format features a full recap of the whole trial and uses a multi narrator cast and sound effects which creates such an authentic feel to the production.
It really does feel like you're there in the room watching the trial play out.
I'm absolutely fascinated by true crime, but never seem to be able to fit any into my schedule so these books are the perfect solution to get my fix and learn about some of the famous names from the past.
Having said this, I'd never heard of Lizzie Borden and her case was certainly an intriguing one.
Did she murder her own father and stepmother or was she really innocent?
What fascinates me is that we will never really know in some of the cases - but to hear the statements from those called to trial - hear how the lawyers bombard with their questions and see the differences in evidence methods between them and now - it's amazing how much progress has been made - yet still we maybe don't always get it right?
Listening to these books has sent me down various rabbit holes after reading and I'm glad that they've prompted me to take more time on something I find really interesting.
If you haven't seen this series before or haven't read the books yet, I can't recommend this enough and am looking forward to seeing who will be next.
November 2, 2026
I really enjoy The Trials of the Century audiobook series (my thanks to NetGalley and the publisher who makes these so easily accessible on NetGalley). This is their fourth edition and I’ve listened to every one. Bringing sensational cases to life is exhilarating. It’s done in ninety minutes using real documents - newspaper, legal documents - assuring historical accuracy. This is perfect for people who don’t have a lot of free time and anyone who enjoys true crime.
Lizzie Borden’s trial has remained mired in history - even inheriting a nursery rhyme. The crime itself remains a mystery to this day. The evidence wasn’t there but the crime was brutal. The audiobook book brings this all to light and what happened to Lizzie after the trial.
I highly recommend this audiobook.
Lizzie Borden’s trial has remained mired in history - even inheriting a nursery rhyme. The crime itself remains a mystery to this day. The evidence wasn’t there but the crime was brutal. The audiobook book brings this all to light and what happened to Lizzie after the trial.
I highly recommend this audiobook.
October 29, 2026
Action packed. Short. Entertaining.
Another one in this series that I rather enjoyed very much. I especially enjoy audiobooks with a full cast, and this one did not disappoint. It was incredibly engaging—more like a 90-minute production than a traditional audiobook, with the feel of a well-paced movie.
As I have come to expect of this series, this one throughly kept in the lane of true crime, put me right in the heart of action and kept the courtroom proceedings front and center.
Thank you to Classic Crime, Trials of the Century Audiobooks and NetGalley for for gifting me this ALC. As always, this review contains my candid thoughts and opinions.
Another one in this series that I rather enjoyed very much. I especially enjoy audiobooks with a full cast, and this one did not disappoint. It was incredibly engaging—more like a 90-minute production than a traditional audiobook, with the feel of a well-paced movie.
As I have come to expect of this series, this one throughly kept in the lane of true crime, put me right in the heart of action and kept the courtroom proceedings front and center.
Thank you to Classic Crime, Trials of the Century Audiobooks and NetGalley for for gifting me this ALC. As always, this review contains my candid thoughts and opinions.
October 26, 2026
Thank you to Roland O’Leary, Classic Crime, and Trials of the Century Audiobooks for providing me with this complimentary ALC (audiobook) for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I am a true crime junkie, and I am pretty sure it all stemmed from that darn little rhyme we all know from elementary school about Lizzie Borden. This audiobook was intriguing because it used its narrator to make a performative piece that was reminiscent of old radio plays– which honestly worked given that this crime is over 130 years old. That old-timey feel fits the eerie vibe of this tale well. I loved the dramatized police interviews and court transcripts being read, and the narrator had a very melodic voice that was soothing to listen to— which is ironic given the content of this trial.
I’d recommend this book to anyone who wants to learn about the Lizzie Borden case in a way that comes to life without any biases. Think: “true crime podcast”.
I am a true crime junkie, and I am pretty sure it all stemmed from that darn little rhyme we all know from elementary school about Lizzie Borden. This audiobook was intriguing because it used its narrator to make a performative piece that was reminiscent of old radio plays– which honestly worked given that this crime is over 130 years old. That old-timey feel fits the eerie vibe of this tale well. I loved the dramatized police interviews and court transcripts being read, and the narrator had a very melodic voice that was soothing to listen to— which is ironic given the content of this trial.
I’d recommend this book to anyone who wants to learn about the Lizzie Borden case in a way that comes to life without any biases. Think: “true crime podcast”.
November 3, 2026
I’ve heard a lot about Lizzie Borden lately, especially with the documentary about her on Netflix, but before that I knew very little about her or the crimes she was accused of. Considering how much true crime I read, I was quite surprised that this case had passed me by. Perhaps it’s because it happened in America so long ago.
This audiobook features a full cast of narrators, which really brings the story to life. It begins with a brief history of the crime before moving on to Lizzie’s trial, presented in a way that makes you feel as though you’re sitting in the courtroom, listening to the evidence unfold.
At around 90 minutes, it’s a short but engaging production that leaves you to make up your own mind about whether she was guilty. I thought this was a very clever way of introducing listeners to the case, about the victims and Lizzie herself.
This audiobook features a full cast of narrators, which really brings the story to life. It begins with a brief history of the crime before moving on to Lizzie’s trial, presented in a way that makes you feel as though you’re sitting in the courtroom, listening to the evidence unfold.
At around 90 minutes, it’s a short but engaging production that leaves you to make up your own mind about whether she was guilty. I thought this was a very clever way of introducing listeners to the case, about the victims and Lizzie herself.
November 3, 2026
Book four in the Trials of the Century series does not disappoint. This time we look at Lizzie Borden the latest subject of the Monster Netflix tv series which I had just watched so it was nice to add this to some of the background in the case. This is still one of those that we don’t know if she killed her parents or not and there are still many questions that we will never have answered but I loved hearing the words and testimony from the actual case played out throughout the book. Fascinating and absorbing as always and I can’t wait for book five.
November 4, 2026
I have always been very interested in this case.
This was a nice refresher of the facts of the case V.S the speculations.
I enjoyed the dramatized audiobook, definitely made it more interesting.
This was a nice refresher of the facts of the case V.S the speculations.
I enjoyed the dramatized audiobook, definitely made it more interesting.
October 28, 2026
I have been eagerly awaiting this installment for months and I’m very happy to say it lived up to my expectations! Final Score: 5
My reviews tend to run long, so they’re a lot easier to read with proper formatting. You can find the full review on Pagebound here
What Worked Well For Me
Like many other “weird” girls (complimentary), I learned about Lizzie Borden early on and have consumed a lot of media about her and this case over the years. Some have been much better than others, after listening to the first 3 audiodramas in this series, I’m not surprised that this is one of the better versions of this story that I’ve come across!
So much of Borden’s case was sensationalized to sell papers at the time and those myths have made their way into a lot of media about her. I’ve seen claims that she committed the murders fully nude (with no evidence), that the dress she burned was drenched in blood, and some have even gone as far as accusing her of witchcraft! Because this series focuses on the trial itself, none of that showed up here. While I wasn’t worried that the other books in the series had gotten their facts wrong, it’s always nice to be reassured that the common pitfalls I’ve seen elsewhere didn’t come up!
I also really appreciated how gender and Victorian expectations and how that may have impacted Borden’s case - things that are often overlooked in other renditions of her story.
Where It Fell Short For Me
Nothing really fell short for me. The closest thing to a “complaint: is that the Foley artist almost did too good of a job when the hatchet was demonstrated in the court case - mostly kidding, but I did physically grimace at that one.
I’ll also say that I’m probably a little biased in saying this one is my favorite in the series since I already knew the case, the other three are just as good! .
Audiobook Experience
I’ve mentioned it in my other reviews for this series, but as someone who is easily overstimulated in graphic audiobooks, I’m always pleasantly surprised by the audio quality in this series!! The small additions of sound effects or gasps from the courtroom really make you feel immersed as if you are in the courthouse yourself.
I also really love that there is always a clear narrator that sounds distinctly different than the actors, so when any interjections are added I always clearly know that it’s a “in hindsight” addition not part of the actual case without them ever having to explain that.
Final Thoughts, Opinions & Recommendations
Even if you think you’ve heard and read everything about Lizzie Borden and this case, I would still recommend this one! Focusing on the story from the angle of the trial gave the story a different flavor. If you don’t know anything about Lizzie Borden or only know her from the rhyme, you don’t need to do any research before going into this one!
My thanks to NetGalley & Trials of the Century Audiobooks for the complimentary copy. The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster is set to publish on 12/04/2026. All opinions are my own.
TL;DR
Would I Recommend it? Yes!
Would I Reread it? Maybe
Would I Continue the Series? Yes! This was already a series I was keeping an eye on and that continues to be true!
Series Information: 4/4 of a (hopefully) Ongoing Series. Each are true standalones!
Links to Previous Reviews in this Series:
🔗 The Trial of Leopold & Loeb: Dickie & Babe - The trial that inspired The Secret History by Donna Tartt
🔗 The Trial of Dr. Crippen: A Drop of Poison - A trial that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle witnessed
🔗 The Trial of Patty Hearst: The Captive Mind
My reviews tend to run long, so they’re a lot easier to read with proper formatting. You can find the full review on Pagebound here
What Worked Well For Me
Like many other “weird” girls (complimentary), I learned about Lizzie Borden early on and have consumed a lot of media about her and this case over the years. Some have been much better than others, after listening to the first 3 audiodramas in this series, I’m not surprised that this is one of the better versions of this story that I’ve come across!
So much of Borden’s case was sensationalized to sell papers at the time and those myths have made their way into a lot of media about her. I’ve seen claims that she committed the murders fully nude (with no evidence), that the dress she burned was drenched in blood, and some have even gone as far as accusing her of witchcraft! Because this series focuses on the trial itself, none of that showed up here. While I wasn’t worried that the other books in the series had gotten their facts wrong, it’s always nice to be reassured that the common pitfalls I’ve seen elsewhere didn’t come up!
I also really appreciated how gender and Victorian expectations and how that may have impacted Borden’s case - things that are often overlooked in other renditions of her story.
Where It Fell Short For Me
Nothing really fell short for me. The closest thing to a “complaint: is that the Foley artist almost did too good of a job when the hatchet was demonstrated in the court case - mostly kidding, but I did physically grimace at that one.
I’ll also say that I’m probably a little biased in saying this one is my favorite in the series since I already knew the case, the other three are just as good! .
Audiobook Experience
I’ve mentioned it in my other reviews for this series, but as someone who is easily overstimulated in graphic audiobooks, I’m always pleasantly surprised by the audio quality in this series!! The small additions of sound effects or gasps from the courtroom really make you feel immersed as if you are in the courthouse yourself.
I also really love that there is always a clear narrator that sounds distinctly different than the actors, so when any interjections are added I always clearly know that it’s a “in hindsight” addition not part of the actual case without them ever having to explain that.
Final Thoughts, Opinions & Recommendations
Even if you think you’ve heard and read everything about Lizzie Borden and this case, I would still recommend this one! Focusing on the story from the angle of the trial gave the story a different flavor. If you don’t know anything about Lizzie Borden or only know her from the rhyme, you don’t need to do any research before going into this one!
My thanks to NetGalley & Trials of the Century Audiobooks for the complimentary copy. The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster is set to publish on 12/04/2026. All opinions are my own.
TL;DR
Would I Recommend it? Yes!
Would I Reread it? Maybe
Would I Continue the Series? Yes! This was already a series I was keeping an eye on and that continues to be true!
Series Information: 4/4 of a (hopefully) Ongoing Series. Each are true standalones!
Links to Previous Reviews in this Series:
🔗 The Trial of Leopold & Loeb: Dickie & Babe - The trial that inspired The Secret History by Donna Tartt
🔗 The Trial of Dr. Crippen: A Drop of Poison - A trial that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle witnessed
🔗 The Trial of Patty Hearst: The Captive Mind
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
ALC Review
Title: The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster
Author: Roland O'Leary
Narrator: Sandra Parsons
Genre: Non-Fiction, History, True Crime
Started: 10/28/26
Finished: 10/28/26
Length: 1h:44m
Expected Release Date: December 4th, 2026
Overall: 5/5 ⭐
Plot: 5/5⭐
Characters: 5/5 ⭐
World Building: 5/5 ⭐
Ending: 5/5 ⭐
📱__ 📚__ 🎧_✅
Favorite Character:
Lizzie Borden herself. She forever lives in infamy, with a variety of books, movies, and tv movies all about her! Prior to this audiobook, the most recent adaptation of her story is Season 4 of Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's Monster series, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story. Not only is she a childhood nursery rhyme and, a pop culture icon, but she was also acquitted of the murders of her father and stepmother! Not to condone a potential murderer but, she's an absolute legend!
Favorite Part:
The entire trial. The audiobook provided a multinarrative radio/talkie dramatization, however Sandra Parsons provided the proper Gilded Age voice and credibility that brought you back to the era of when the crimes actually occured. Yet, regardless of neighborhood testimony, badgering lawyers, and a jury of men, Lizzie Borden was acquitted of both murders. To this day, it remains unsolved. The unequivocal cold case. With her popularity, I'm surprised no one has tried to solve this case. Then again, maybe some people are cool with patricide since he killed her pets.
Thoughts:
I've listened to all of the Trial of the Century audiobooks, and before that, I wasn't a true crime fan. However, subjects like Lizzie Borden is so intriguing because the case was never solved. Her story remains popular, as I've mentioned earlier, there are many books and movies about her, giving their own interpretation of what may or may not have happened. Nevertheless, we will never know what truly happened. After 130 years, we could only assume. Was this retaliation for her father's murder of her pet pigeons? I know I'd feel enraged. For now, perhaps we can go back in time by just listening to this audiobook? Maybe make our own murder boards, now that we've been provided with accurate details. In the mean time, I'm truly appreciative that NetGalley, Classic Crime and this Trial of the Century audiobook was provided to me in reciprocity for my honest thoughts and opinions. Which I'm always happy to do. I get a bit of education, entertainment, and a first class seat to dramatized historical trials with precise descriptions. I'm really excited to see what Classic Crime has for us next!
Title: The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster
Author: Roland O'Leary
Narrator: Sandra Parsons
Genre: Non-Fiction, History, True Crime
Started: 10/28/26
Finished: 10/28/26
Length: 1h:44m
Expected Release Date: December 4th, 2026
Overall: 5/5 ⭐
Plot: 5/5⭐
Characters: 5/5 ⭐
World Building: 5/5 ⭐
Ending: 5/5 ⭐
📱__ 📚__ 🎧_✅
Favorite Character:
Lizzie Borden herself. She forever lives in infamy, with a variety of books, movies, and tv movies all about her! Prior to this audiobook, the most recent adaptation of her story is Season 4 of Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan's Monster series, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story. Not only is she a childhood nursery rhyme and, a pop culture icon, but she was also acquitted of the murders of her father and stepmother! Not to condone a potential murderer but, she's an absolute legend!
Favorite Part:
The entire trial. The audiobook provided a multinarrative radio/talkie dramatization, however Sandra Parsons provided the proper Gilded Age voice and credibility that brought you back to the era of when the crimes actually occured. Yet, regardless of neighborhood testimony, badgering lawyers, and a jury of men, Lizzie Borden was acquitted of both murders. To this day, it remains unsolved. The unequivocal cold case. With her popularity, I'm surprised no one has tried to solve this case. Then again, maybe some people are cool with patricide since he killed her pets.
Thoughts:
I've listened to all of the Trial of the Century audiobooks, and before that, I wasn't a true crime fan. However, subjects like Lizzie Borden is so intriguing because the case was never solved. Her story remains popular, as I've mentioned earlier, there are many books and movies about her, giving their own interpretation of what may or may not have happened. Nevertheless, we will never know what truly happened. After 130 years, we could only assume. Was this retaliation for her father's murder of her pet pigeons? I know I'd feel enraged. For now, perhaps we can go back in time by just listening to this audiobook? Maybe make our own murder boards, now that we've been provided with accurate details. In the mean time, I'm truly appreciative that NetGalley, Classic Crime and this Trial of the Century audiobook was provided to me in reciprocity for my honest thoughts and opinions. Which I'm always happy to do. I get a bit of education, entertainment, and a first class seat to dramatized historical trials with precise descriptions. I'm really excited to see what Classic Crime has for us next!
Read
November 6, 2026Thank you to Classic Crime and NetGalley for the audiobook ARC -
A story about the trial of Lizzie Borden, an incredibly famous whodunnit with questions remaining unanswered to this day. I was already familiar with the case, and I’m sure I’ve heard it covered in quite some depth before, but I do think it’s such a compelling story that it’s one worth revisiting. Again, I think the multi-narrator format really breathed life into the story and added to the intrigue.
I think I was probably more aware throughout this retelling of the limitations in our understanding of human psychology, and particularly neurodevelopmental differences, at the time of the trial. I read a lot of literature, particularly fiction, that either explicitly or implicitly features characters who are neuroatypical, and I can relate to some of those experiences myself. I felt there was quite a strong suggestion that neurodevelopmental differences might have played a part in how Lizzie presented and perhaps how she was perceived by others. I also got the impression that this was something the production intended to explore, and I thought they did that aspect justice. I found the narrator voicing Lizzie particularly believable in the way she conveyed her affect and presentation.
The one thing I would say is that, while I found the performance itself very convincing, I did feel that some of the voice actor’s strengths didn’t necessarily translate quite as well to audiobook narration. That is to say, the speed of her delivery, in combination with her intonation and occasional lack of clarity, meant that I was prone to missing the odd word or phrase of Lizzie’s when listening at a speed that was otherwise comfortable for enjoying the narration of all the other characters. Overall, though, I thought this was a good, enjoyable listen and would definitely recommend it to anyone with an interest in the case.
A story about the trial of Lizzie Borden, an incredibly famous whodunnit with questions remaining unanswered to this day. I was already familiar with the case, and I’m sure I’ve heard it covered in quite some depth before, but I do think it’s such a compelling story that it’s one worth revisiting. Again, I think the multi-narrator format really breathed life into the story and added to the intrigue.
I think I was probably more aware throughout this retelling of the limitations in our understanding of human psychology, and particularly neurodevelopmental differences, at the time of the trial. I read a lot of literature, particularly fiction, that either explicitly or implicitly features characters who are neuroatypical, and I can relate to some of those experiences myself. I felt there was quite a strong suggestion that neurodevelopmental differences might have played a part in how Lizzie presented and perhaps how she was perceived by others. I also got the impression that this was something the production intended to explore, and I thought they did that aspect justice. I found the narrator voicing Lizzie particularly believable in the way she conveyed her affect and presentation.
The one thing I would say is that, while I found the performance itself very convincing, I did feel that some of the voice actor’s strengths didn’t necessarily translate quite as well to audiobook narration. That is to say, the speed of her delivery, in combination with her intonation and occasional lack of clarity, meant that I was prone to missing the odd word or phrase of Lizzie’s when listening at a speed that was otherwise comfortable for enjoying the narration of all the other characters. Overall, though, I thought this was a good, enjoyable listen and would definitely recommend it to anyone with an interest in the case.
November 9, 2026
I received an ALC of from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
I only had brief knowledge of this case from a youtube ghost hunter show so the opportunity to learn more had me sitting up and hitting 'listen now' at speed.
The rhyme at the start and end is truly chilling (in a way only playground rhymes about murder can be), but also pays homage to the significance this case holds in public rhetoric. Listening to the trial was fascinating, especially when I started thinking about how they were responding to the possibility of a female murderer in a time when women were supposedly delicate. The not guilty verdict was also interesting; I'd love to know what the jury discussion was like.
I think the fact this remains unsolved makes the title really intruiging as well - was she a monster if she wasn't found guilty but if the case was not solved and all cirucmstantial evidence points to her, maybe she was as she benefited the most from the outcome of the deaths. It's really interesting to unpick and I think credit has to be given to the author - this audiobook doesn't sensationalise the trial, and enough time has passed that the recording of the case feels respectful and fair. I've heard a lot of rumours about this case, so to have it put out so eloquently in this audiobook really helped.
I was listening to this book while doing other things so having a huge cast of voices was really helpful for keeping pace and also keeping the book clearly distinct with each voice shifting and clear identifiers as to what I was listening to. As others have said I also really appreciate that this book leaves it to the reader / listener to make up their mind - one way or another the case remains unsolved but I like how no conclusion is forced and you can come to your own conclusions in a case we likely will never know the truth to.
I only had brief knowledge of this case from a youtube ghost hunter show so the opportunity to learn more had me sitting up and hitting 'listen now' at speed.
The rhyme at the start and end is truly chilling (in a way only playground rhymes about murder can be), but also pays homage to the significance this case holds in public rhetoric. Listening to the trial was fascinating, especially when I started thinking about how they were responding to the possibility of a female murderer in a time when women were supposedly delicate. The not guilty verdict was also interesting; I'd love to know what the jury discussion was like.
I think the fact this remains unsolved makes the title really intruiging as well - was she a monster if she wasn't found guilty but if the case was not solved and all cirucmstantial evidence points to her, maybe she was as she benefited the most from the outcome of the deaths. It's really interesting to unpick and I think credit has to be given to the author - this audiobook doesn't sensationalise the trial, and enough time has passed that the recording of the case feels respectful and fair. I've heard a lot of rumours about this case, so to have it put out so eloquently in this audiobook really helped.
I was listening to this book while doing other things so having a huge cast of voices was really helpful for keeping pace and also keeping the book clearly distinct with each voice shifting and clear identifiers as to what I was listening to. As others have said I also really appreciate that this book leaves it to the reader / listener to make up their mind - one way or another the case remains unsolved but I like how no conclusion is forced and you can come to your own conclusions in a case we likely will never know the truth to.
October 27, 2026
The Trial of Lizzie Borden is a 90 minute standalone in the series Trials of the Century. Each one of the books is highlighting individual court cases. The format is audiobook formatted as radio play, and it's highly effective for this genre. It feels like you’re present in the courtroom and the full audio cast gives it an immersive experience. The performance of the cast is outstanding.
In 1893, 32 year old churchgoer Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom accused of killing her father and stepmother that was found dead in their home in Fall River. They have been brutally hacked to death. There were no witnesses, no confession and no murder weapons were linked to Lizzy, but her behaviour before and after the murders raised suspicion. Was she innocent or was she a cold blooded murderer?
I haven’t heard anything about the case previously, and I found it interesting and the audiobook was highly engaging. I listened in one sitting, and there was no unnecessary information given in the book, nor too little information either to understand the case.
This book is suitable if you like true crime, historical crime, audiobooks with full casting, and short stories. I highly recommend listening to this, and also the rest of the series! I rate it 5 out of 5 stars.
Disclaimer: I received this audiobook from NetGalley. A grateful thanks to NetGalley, Roland O’Leary, and Classic Crime for this ALC. As always, all thoughts and opinions are my own, and I leave this unpaid review voluntarily.
In 1893, 32 year old churchgoer Lizzie Borden entered the courtroom accused of killing her father and stepmother that was found dead in their home in Fall River. They have been brutally hacked to death. There were no witnesses, no confession and no murder weapons were linked to Lizzy, but her behaviour before and after the murders raised suspicion. Was she innocent or was she a cold blooded murderer?
I haven’t heard anything about the case previously, and I found it interesting and the audiobook was highly engaging. I listened in one sitting, and there was no unnecessary information given in the book, nor too little information either to understand the case.
This book is suitable if you like true crime, historical crime, audiobooks with full casting, and short stories. I highly recommend listening to this, and also the rest of the series! I rate it 5 out of 5 stars.
Disclaimer: I received this audiobook from NetGalley. A grateful thanks to NetGalley, Roland O’Leary, and Classic Crime for this ALC. As always, all thoughts and opinions are my own, and I leave this unpaid review voluntarily.
October 30, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Classic Crime for the audiobook ARC, and to Classic Crime for reaching out to me directly to let me know it was available! You're the best!
The Narrative
The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster by Roland O’Leary is a full cast audiobook based on the criminal trial of Lizzie Borden. The bulk of the audio IS the trial, rather than all the stories surrounding it, which is what most true crime focuses on. Lizzie Borden is a gold mine for that kind of true crime format, so choosing to strip back the larger narrative is a real decision. Focusing ONLY on the trial helps you sort fact from sensation and get back to the heart of the crime, much like Classic Crime’s Patty Hearst audio. A narrator sets up the context before the trial begins, which is a really useful tool.
Production & Narration
The cast is brilliant, and the soundscaping really puts you in the courtroom. Lizzie’s own testimony made the biggest difference when voiced. These are interpretations, even though they’re based on the trial transcripts, but hearing the frustration (and haughtiness) in her voice made her a person rather than a folkloric monster. I’ve always been quite soft towards Lizzie, and this reminded me that she was a higher-class lady who definitely looked down on people, making her a complicated figure. That still doesn’t mean she did it, but it really humanised her.
Final Thoughts
At about 90 minutes total, this is a GREAT length for this kind of listen. I just love Classic Crime’s audios for this reason.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5 stars)
The Narrative
The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster by Roland O’Leary is a full cast audiobook based on the criminal trial of Lizzie Borden. The bulk of the audio IS the trial, rather than all the stories surrounding it, which is what most true crime focuses on. Lizzie Borden is a gold mine for that kind of true crime format, so choosing to strip back the larger narrative is a real decision. Focusing ONLY on the trial helps you sort fact from sensation and get back to the heart of the crime, much like Classic Crime’s Patty Hearst audio. A narrator sets up the context before the trial begins, which is a really useful tool.
Production & Narration
The cast is brilliant, and the soundscaping really puts you in the courtroom. Lizzie’s own testimony made the biggest difference when voiced. These are interpretations, even though they’re based on the trial transcripts, but hearing the frustration (and haughtiness) in her voice made her a person rather than a folkloric monster. I’ve always been quite soft towards Lizzie, and this reminded me that she was a higher-class lady who definitely looked down on people, making her a complicated figure. That still doesn’t mean she did it, but it really humanised her.
Final Thoughts
At about 90 minutes total, this is a GREAT length for this kind of listen. I just love Classic Crime’s audios for this reason.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5 stars)
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Trial of Lizzie Borden: The Making of a Monster by Roland O’Leary is another fantastic addition to the Trials of the Century series!
This installment tackles one of the most infamous true crime cases in history, a murder mystery that has fascinated people for generations thanks in part to that unforgettable nursery rhyme. Even today, the question of who killed Lizzie Borden’s father and stepmother with an axe continues to intrigue true crime fans.
What I really loved about this book is that it presents the actual questioning and trial transcripts without author interpretation. You get to experience the testimony and proceedings for yourself and draw your own conclusions based on the facts presented. There’s something especially fascinating about reading the words spoken during such a notorious trial and realizing that, even with all this information, the mystery remains.
And once again, the audiobook production is absolutely fantastic! The full-cast narration brings the courtroom to life and makes you feel as though you’re sitting right there as the trial unfolds. It’s such an immersive way to experience historical cases, and this series continues to deliver.
If you enjoy true crime, unsolved mysteries, and courtroom drama, this is another excellent listen! 🎧
This installment tackles one of the most infamous true crime cases in history, a murder mystery that has fascinated people for generations thanks in part to that unforgettable nursery rhyme. Even today, the question of who killed Lizzie Borden’s father and stepmother with an axe continues to intrigue true crime fans.
What I really loved about this book is that it presents the actual questioning and trial transcripts without author interpretation. You get to experience the testimony and proceedings for yourself and draw your own conclusions based on the facts presented. There’s something especially fascinating about reading the words spoken during such a notorious trial and realizing that, even with all this information, the mystery remains.
And once again, the audiobook production is absolutely fantastic! The full-cast narration brings the courtroom to life and makes you feel as though you’re sitting right there as the trial unfolds. It’s such an immersive way to experience historical cases, and this series continues to deliver.
If you enjoy true crime, unsolved mysteries, and courtroom drama, this is another excellent listen! 🎧
November 5, 2026
Lizzie Borden took an ax,
And gave her mother forty whacks;
When she saw what she had done,
She gave her father forty-one.
In 1893, Andrew and Abby Borden were slaughtered at their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. After inconsistencies in her story, suspicion fell on Andrew’s daughter from his first marriage, Lizzie, a respectable Sunday school teacher. There was no evidence and no eyewitnesses but a trial ensued. Did she do it?
This is the fourth in the Trials of the Century series and very timely thanks to the recent Netflix programme on the same case. Audiobooks are the perfect way to tell stories such as this as rather than just simply read the trial transcript, we are treated to a full reenactment of what actually occurred. The parts were acted superbly, taking you into the courtroom and helping you to get a real feel of how the trial played out.
The Lizzie Borden case is one that I only knew the bare facts of before listening to this book and I now feel as though I know a lot more. I liked how all sides are shown, the aim being to inform rather than try to sway your opinion. I am still none the wiser as to whether she committed this heinous crime or not but I do feel as though I know much more about the case.
This is a great series and I am looking forward to seeing what comes next.
And gave her mother forty whacks;
When she saw what she had done,
She gave her father forty-one.
In 1893, Andrew and Abby Borden were slaughtered at their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. After inconsistencies in her story, suspicion fell on Andrew’s daughter from his first marriage, Lizzie, a respectable Sunday school teacher. There was no evidence and no eyewitnesses but a trial ensued. Did she do it?
This is the fourth in the Trials of the Century series and very timely thanks to the recent Netflix programme on the same case. Audiobooks are the perfect way to tell stories such as this as rather than just simply read the trial transcript, we are treated to a full reenactment of what actually occurred. The parts were acted superbly, taking you into the courtroom and helping you to get a real feel of how the trial played out.
The Lizzie Borden case is one that I only knew the bare facts of before listening to this book and I now feel as though I know a lot more. I liked how all sides are shown, the aim being to inform rather than try to sway your opinion. I am still none the wiser as to whether she committed this heinous crime or not but I do feel as though I know much more about the case.
This is a great series and I am looking forward to seeing what comes next.
November 6, 2026
I really enjoyed this audiobook on the trial of Lizzie Borden from Trials of the Century, which offers a deeply immersive way to learn about one of America's most famous criminal cases. Rather than simply summarizing events, it draws on excerpts from the trial itself, so you hear how each witness was examined and what questions were asked. That approach gives a clear picture of what happened and makes the listener feel present in the courtroom.
The voice actors deserve real credit. Their performances bring the testimony to life, and you can hear the range of emotion coming from Lizzie, or the notable lack of it at times. That tension left me genuinely unsure whether she was guilty or not. I can see why she was acquitted, since I didn't feel the evidence proved beyond a reasonable doubt that she killed her parents. The ending was a highlight as well, following how she lived out the rest of her life and noting that nothing new has come to light since.
Overall, this audiobook was entertaining, engaging, and well produced, and I would happily recommend it to others. It's another great entry in the Trials of the Century series, and I'm looking forward to more.
The voice actors deserve real credit. Their performances bring the testimony to life, and you can hear the range of emotion coming from Lizzie, or the notable lack of it at times. That tension left me genuinely unsure whether she was guilty or not. I can see why she was acquitted, since I didn't feel the evidence proved beyond a reasonable doubt that she killed her parents. The ending was a highlight as well, following how she lived out the rest of her life and noting that nothing new has come to light since.
Overall, this audiobook was entertaining, engaging, and well produced, and I would happily recommend it to others. It's another great entry in the Trials of the Century series, and I'm looking forward to more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 7, 2026
Once again I was granted the privilege of receiving an audiobook from NetGalley so that I could provide my honest review. I absolutely adored and was so invested in the first three crime stories that I listened to. And while this seems to primarily be the same cast of voice as I recognized and it’s a story that I once was very intrigued by as a kid, I just don’t think it was presented as excitingly as the other stories in this series were. There is so much that we don’t know about what happened in that Borden Home a century and a half ago. It almost seemed that this story wanted to share or portray some of the disbelief and chaos that people of the time experienced, but it was more of the court procedurals this time that were very calm. Perhaps it’s that calmness which admittedly lost my attention a few times.
All in all though, still a wonderful entry in this series of court dramas. Once again it was such a treat to listen to a full cast present the story!!! thanks again NetGalley and the publisher!!
All in all though, still a wonderful entry in this series of court dramas. Once again it was such a treat to listen to a full cast present the story!!! thanks again NetGalley and the publisher!!
October 31, 2026
I've always found the Lizzie Borden case absolutely fascinating, so this was right up my street. This wonderfully intriguing dramatisation of the infamous 1892 double murder of Lizzie Borden's father and stepmother, and the subsequent trial that gripped the American public, made for a really enjoyable listen. A must for fellow true crime addicts!
I really liked the courtroom drama format, with the different voices bringing the prosecution, defence and witness testimonies to life. It made the whole thing feel much more immersive than your typical true crime audiobook, and I particularly enjoyed being able to weigh up the evidence and make my own mind up about Lizzie's guilt or innocence.
It's also interesting to look back at the attitudes towards women, class and respectability at the time, and how much these played into the trial and the way Lizzie was perceived.
At just under two hours, it's a relatively quick listen, but there's plenty to get stuck into. A really enjoyable production and a great choice for anyone with a love of true crime and a fascination with all things Borden.
If you enjoyed this review come follow me on Instagram @TravelsEatsReads for more
I really liked the courtroom drama format, with the different voices bringing the prosecution, defence and witness testimonies to life. It made the whole thing feel much more immersive than your typical true crime audiobook, and I particularly enjoyed being able to weigh up the evidence and make my own mind up about Lizzie's guilt or innocence.
It's also interesting to look back at the attitudes towards women, class and respectability at the time, and how much these played into the trial and the way Lizzie was perceived.
At just under two hours, it's a relatively quick listen, but there's plenty to get stuck into. A really enjoyable production and a great choice for anyone with a love of true crime and a fascination with all things Borden.
If you enjoyed this review come follow me on Instagram @TravelsEatsReads for more
November 7, 2026
Read this if… you enjoy true crime dramatizations that blur the lines between horror and thriller!
True crime has never felt so much like a horror story and a thriller at the same time!
I thoroughly enjoyed this dramatization of the Lizzie Borden trial, drawn from actual court transcripts. Going in with little knowledge of the case, I appreciated the attention to detail and the way the story unfolded.
The narration provided context and just enough detail to understand the events surrounding the trial and its aftermath without feeling overly editorialized. It allowed the facts, testimony, and unsettling circumstances to speak for themselves.
A short but compelling and informative listen that left me intrigued, questioning, and eager to explore the rest of the series.
After reading this, I am left thinking… Was justice truly served in this trial?
Thank you to Classic Crime for the ALC via NetGalley for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
True crime has never felt so much like a horror story and a thriller at the same time!
I thoroughly enjoyed this dramatization of the Lizzie Borden trial, drawn from actual court transcripts. Going in with little knowledge of the case, I appreciated the attention to detail and the way the story unfolded.
The narration provided context and just enough detail to understand the events surrounding the trial and its aftermath without feeling overly editorialized. It allowed the facts, testimony, and unsettling circumstances to speak for themselves.
A short but compelling and informative listen that left me intrigued, questioning, and eager to explore the rest of the series.
After reading this, I am left thinking… Was justice truly served in this trial?
Thank you to Classic Crime for the ALC via NetGalley for review consideration. All opinions are my own.
October 31, 2026
I've listened to a couple of podcasts about the Lizzie Borden case over the last few weeks. One seemed to lean towards the possibility that Lizzie was innocent, while the other seemed pretty determined to condemn her. So I was really happy to receive this short audiobook from Classic Crime through NetGalley, as I thought I'd be able to draw my own conclusions with the objective (though acted out) information provided in this immersive production that revisits the trial through the original courtroom exchanges.
It was a fascinating listen, and the full cast really brought the courtroom proceedings to life.
Five stars for the production and the storytelling, even if I'm still sitting here wondering what the heck to make of this case. Both sides make valid points, and after listening to this, I'm honestly no closer to deciding whether Lizzie was guilty or innocent (guilty, I think?).
It was a fascinating listen, and the full cast really brought the courtroom proceedings to life.
Five stars for the production and the storytelling, even if I'm still sitting here wondering what the heck to make of this case. Both sides make valid points, and after listening to this, I'm honestly no closer to deciding whether Lizzie was guilty or innocent (guilty, I think?).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews