I do not under any circumstances recommend this, as having read 8 Viking books and sat through 2 lecture series now, it became clear very quickly that this resources is biased, over-generalized, and over-dramatized. I am by no means an expert on Vikings, which means the discrepancies are clear and in your face. I didn’t go looking for them. They came to me.
What this book does is tell some half-truths about the Vikings, which are very misleading. I believe it does this so as to add “excitement,” for the target age, but I prefer accuracy. I couldn’t even get through the first chapter without lecturing the book four times on how it’s spreading misunderstanding with the bad jokes and Viking stereotypes. In fact, I had to take this book with a grain of salt and then just shake it off, to try and make sure none of the misinformation stuck to me.
When the book is not spreading half-truths, it’s busy wielding 5 adjectives per sentence, which are less than factual and rather exhausting. Basically, the attempt to be descriptive really missed the mark.
This is surface-level research presented in a way that is intended to be intriguing, dramatic, or interesting, but it has little care for accuracy. Now, that’s not to say that nothing is accurate. There’s some good stuff here, but I think most audiences would have trouble differentiating the 75% of truths from the 25% of half-truths, mistruth, personal judgment, bias, and stereotypes, which is why I’m opposed to this book.
Also, it’s definitely a biased, male perspective on the Vikings, with little regard or respect for the females of the society, despite how important they were to Viking culture. Ugh. Please save me from the overdose of testosterone. Heaven forbid we assume a girl may want to read a book about Vikings, or even that a boy may enjoy reading about Viking without any sexist language.
If you want a cheap laugh, at the cost of the full truth, then maybe this book is for you. As someone who served as a middle school librarian for 6 years, I would not have wanted this resource on my shelf, because students inherently trust nonfiction books to be truthful, as is evident by some of the reviews for this book.
This is too busy being cute to be truly accurate, and since it was only published in 2015, well past the point where some of this additional information and research on Vikings became standard knowledge, I don’t forgive it of its sins. I suspect the goal here is to push out as many “exciting” nonfiction offerings as quickly as possible, rather than to produce a good, accurate resource. Under the circumstances, I’m sure many people have purchased this without even realizing the issues.
Book 144 read in 2018
Pages: 320