What do you think?
Rate this book
Golden Gate Chronicles #3
Through the Shadows
The devastating earthquake is just two years past, but the city of San Francisco is still trying to recover. Destruction of this magnitude is not so easy to overcome-and neither are the past regrets shadowing Elizabeth King's hopeful future.
Hoping to right her wrongs, Elizabeth dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, even if it means putting her own life at risk to sneak through the gloomy alleys and rooftops where dangers lurk.
Putting her life on the line for a worthy cause is admirable. But opening her heart is even more terrifying. So when Elizabeth meets attorney, Charles McKinley--a man who dreams of reforming San Francisco's crooked politics--Elizabeth begins to doubt: Can she maintain her pretense and hide her past? Or will her secret jeopardize both their futures?
Hoping to right her wrongs, Elizabeth dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, even if it means putting her own life at risk to sneak through the gloomy alleys and rooftops where dangers lurk.
Putting her life on the line for a worthy cause is admirable. But opening her heart is even more terrifying. So when Elizabeth meets attorney, Charles McKinley--a man who dreams of reforming San Francisco's crooked politics--Elizabeth begins to doubt: Can she maintain her pretense and hide her past? Or will her secret jeopardize both their futures?
304 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2016
11 people are currently reading
351 people want to read
About the author
Karen Barnett
12 books624 followersKaren Barnett is the award-winning author of the Vintage National Parks Novels, the Golden Gate Chronicles (Out of the Ruins, Beyond the Ashes, Through the Shadows), and MISTAKEN. She lives in Oregon with her husband, two kids, and a bevy of furry friends. You can learn more about Karen's writing journey at http://www.KarenBarnettBooks.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews
May 4, 2016
Karen Barnett has done it again! Elizabeth and Charles are characters of depth and substance, struggling to find courage and redemption. The harrowing glimpse into human trafficking rings as true today as it did one hundred years ago. And the rich historical details plunge you into a city rising from the ruins, rife with both vile corruption and soaring altruism. Overall, Through the Shadows will stir your soul and satisfy your heart.
February 22, 2017
While written about the period in America just after the great San Francisco earthquake of 1906, several of the social issues covered in Karen Barnett’s Through the Shadows are just as timely today. Immigration, social justice, human trafficking, racial prejudice. Any one of these could be ripped from the headlines on any given day in our newscasts and social media feeds. Catching this glimpse from history of how there really is “nothing new under the sun” gives a fresh perspective on the world we presently call home.
It’s also a grace-filled perspective. A redemption-filled perspective. And therefore, a perspective filled with hope.
Courage, redemption, grace, and mercy permeate this novel! As the city of San Francisco rises out of the ruins, beyond the ashes, and through the shadows, so too does the King family. So too does Charles McKinley. And Elizabeth King. And the girls of the Mission Home. It’s why their stories will linger with you when you’ve closed this book and moved on to the next. It might even motivate you to dig further into history… and walk through the present a bit more open-eyed and open-hearted.
Along with the beauty of these intersecting stories, a sweet romance holds hands with intriguing (sometimes uncomfortable) historical detail and well-crafted writing to present a satisfying conclusion to the Golden Gate Chronicles trilogy.
Through the Shadows can be read as a standalone novel with no problems, but you will have a greater appreciation for the King family if you’ve been with the series from the first novel, Out of the Ruins.
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
Read my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
It’s also a grace-filled perspective. A redemption-filled perspective. And therefore, a perspective filled with hope.
Courage, redemption, grace, and mercy permeate this novel! As the city of San Francisco rises out of the ruins, beyond the ashes, and through the shadows, so too does the King family. So too does Charles McKinley. And Elizabeth King. And the girls of the Mission Home. It’s why their stories will linger with you when you’ve closed this book and moved on to the next. It might even motivate you to dig further into history… and walk through the present a bit more open-eyed and open-hearted.
Along with the beauty of these intersecting stories, a sweet romance holds hands with intriguing (sometimes uncomfortable) historical detail and well-crafted writing to present a satisfying conclusion to the Golden Gate Chronicles trilogy.
Through the Shadows can be read as a standalone novel with no problems, but you will have a greater appreciation for the King family if you’ve been with the series from the first novel, Out of the Ruins.
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
Read my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
May 30, 2016
Through the Shadows is a satisfying conclusion to the trilogy of San Francisco, by Karen Barnett. A healthy mix of history, romance, faith, and grit makes it a book to satisfy a broad range of readers. I especially appreciated how the author didn't shy away from the darker side of the sex trafficking of the Chinese in San Francisco's history while also exposing the mission that sought to free these treasured women. I can always applaud good historical fiction when it's a feel good romance mixed with realism and deep issues. I appreciated the non-fairy tale romance laced with bad choices, wounds from mistakes the heroine made, and also covered in the redemptive story of grace that is the only story of true love that lasts. A definite must read for any historical romance lover and a definite consideration for any reader who appreciates learning of the seedier sides of history.
May 4, 2016
A wonderful addition to this exciting series! Set in 1908 San Francisco, the third book continues on with the King family, focusing on younger sister Elizabeth, who moves to the city to begin a new chapter in her life. Hoping to redeem her past, she takes a position working as a teacher at the Mission house for rescued Chinese girls. Charles McKinley, a new attorney-at-law, also has high hopes as he starts work in his uncle's law firm. He and Elizabeth seem to be destined to bump into each other with their mutual interests, yet he makes her bristle no matter what he does, and sparks fly.
This was my favorite book in the series so far! Well-written with many meaningful interjections of faith, especially the concept of God's grace, illustrated so well in Elizabeth's character. She learns that grace can't be earned, and nothing we do can redeem our sin. Love the use of the hymn Amazing Grace, the words reflecting what she finally grasps. Delving into the underbelly of the city more with the sex trafficking, prejudice, corruption, and the rebuilding in the aftermath of the quake, gave a good picture of how God rescues and redeems us also. I liked seeing Elizabeth's transformation from prickly, guarded and shamed to open, loving, and grateful, as she embraces God's grace in her life.
Recommend reading the first two books in the series to get the full story, but it's fine as a stand alone too. Readers who enjoy historical Christian fiction with a romance, will enjoy this book.
(Book provided by NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.)
This was my favorite book in the series so far! Well-written with many meaningful interjections of faith, especially the concept of God's grace, illustrated so well in Elizabeth's character. She learns that grace can't be earned, and nothing we do can redeem our sin. Love the use of the hymn Amazing Grace, the words reflecting what she finally grasps. Delving into the underbelly of the city more with the sex trafficking, prejudice, corruption, and the rebuilding in the aftermath of the quake, gave a good picture of how God rescues and redeems us also. I liked seeing Elizabeth's transformation from prickly, guarded and shamed to open, loving, and grateful, as she embraces God's grace in her life.
Recommend reading the first two books in the series to get the full story, but it's fine as a stand alone too. Readers who enjoy historical Christian fiction with a romance, will enjoy this book.
(Book provided by NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for my honest review.)
May 11, 2016
This story brings us to San Francisco, California as it is rebuilding after the 1906 devastating earthquake. As the book opens Charles McKinley is bringing the sad news that the King families fortune has been lost in the fires that came after the quake, and the buildings their father had invested in are destroyed.
Elizabeth King had been staying with her mother when they learn the news, and at the same time she meets Miss Cameron and finds a calling for herself, and maybe a reason to go on. Charles was also at the meeting with Miss Cameron and is also feeling led to help her mission. Miss Cameron life’s work is rescuing children whom have been sold into slavery, and worse.
There are sparks flying between Elizabeth and Charles, but not always sweet ones. Elizabeth is hiding a horrible secret, and Charles is trying to make his uncle proud as he begins his career after graduating law school.
Poor Charles is really up against it at the law firm, will he play along, or will he stand up for himself and beliefs? When some of the findings would help people he cares about, will he give up all that is going to come his way?
You will be turning pages pretty fast, as you pursue answers to what is going on, and you may be surprised what it is all about, and will all the secrets be found out?
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Abingdon, and was not required to give a positive review.
Elizabeth King had been staying with her mother when they learn the news, and at the same time she meets Miss Cameron and finds a calling for herself, and maybe a reason to go on. Charles was also at the meeting with Miss Cameron and is also feeling led to help her mission. Miss Cameron life’s work is rescuing children whom have been sold into slavery, and worse.
There are sparks flying between Elizabeth and Charles, but not always sweet ones. Elizabeth is hiding a horrible secret, and Charles is trying to make his uncle proud as he begins his career after graduating law school.
Poor Charles is really up against it at the law firm, will he play along, or will he stand up for himself and beliefs? When some of the findings would help people he cares about, will he give up all that is going to come his way?
You will be turning pages pretty fast, as you pursue answers to what is going on, and you may be surprised what it is all about, and will all the secrets be found out?
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Abingdon, and was not required to give a positive review.
Read
May 19, 2016Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett is book three in The Golden Gates Chronicles series. I was captivated right from the start with this most wonderful book of historic fiction. Characters that you will surely love. There is always something happening in this wonderful story. This story is full of faith, love, heartache and pain. A powerful story that makes you feel that you are part of this story right along with the characters. Be sure to grab a few tissues and a glass of sweet tea as you kick back to enjoy this most wonderful read. Through the Shadows is one of the best books that I have read this year. Be sure to get your copy of Through the Shadows today. 5 stars! I received a copy of this book for my honest review.
May 27, 2016
"We all suffer our own chains. The Lord holds out the gift of new life, but many turn Him away, not trusting the offer." (pg 201).
In the latest and third novel in the Golden Gate Chronicles Series, Karen Barnett takes readers back into historical San Francisco just after the 1906 earthquake and fire that subsequently leveled most of the city, in Through the Shadows. Elizabeth King is the last and youngest daughter to leave home in order that she might get out from under her mother's controlling interest in her life. She is struggling to come to terms with all the property investments her father had made prior to his death, that has left them financially strapped. Now that the earthquake and fire leveled those investment holdings she can't understand why some insurance companies are offering to pay their claims on some, but interestingly enough not on any of her father's property. Without it, they will face financial ruin.
She involves herself in helping Donaldina Cameron with managing the Missions House, that takes in abandoned Chinese children that have found their way into prostitution and have no way out. She is hired to be their sewing teacher to enable them to learn a life skill that will offer them a future once they leave the home. She isn't sure she is ready to face her own shadowed past that caused her to leave behind her chance as a concert pianist. All she knows is that she must find a way to atone for her sins of the past in an effort to please God and sooth her own guilty conscience. No one must ever know.
Up and coming attorney Charles McKinley has a bright future ahead of him, working under his Uncle Silas' law firm. Unfortunately it will be starting at the bottom even though his name guarantees him a leg up in the firm. His first task is to bring the paperwork to the King family to ensure them that Silas has done everything but the insurance companies won't settle on the property claims Mr. King had purchased. He hopes to put an end to all their endless phone calls into the law firm for a meeting, something he has avoided doing. Now Charles hopes he can live up to the McKinley name. He just doesn't expect to fall for Elizabeth when she answers the door and the news he has to give her isn't something he is looking forward to doing. He only wishes he had better news for the King family.
I received Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett compliments of Abingdon Press and Litfuse Publicity for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation, aside from a free copy of the novel in exchange for my honest and personal evaluation. I have been waiting for this novel since starting the Golden Gate Chronicle series! I was not disappointed. The story surrounding Donaldina Cameron is based on fact and her mission to help the struggling Chinese orphans is admirable. Again it is something missing from our history books and one I delighted in learning more about through this novel. I love Elizabeth King who is afraid of dealing with her past, tries to work out salvation on her own through her good works, but she will discover, that is not what God intended when He offers true forgiveness. I'd rate this one a 4.5 out of 5 stars and Discussion Questions are included that are perfect for book clubs.
In the latest and third novel in the Golden Gate Chronicles Series, Karen Barnett takes readers back into historical San Francisco just after the 1906 earthquake and fire that subsequently leveled most of the city, in Through the Shadows. Elizabeth King is the last and youngest daughter to leave home in order that she might get out from under her mother's controlling interest in her life. She is struggling to come to terms with all the property investments her father had made prior to his death, that has left them financially strapped. Now that the earthquake and fire leveled those investment holdings she can't understand why some insurance companies are offering to pay their claims on some, but interestingly enough not on any of her father's property. Without it, they will face financial ruin.
She involves herself in helping Donaldina Cameron with managing the Missions House, that takes in abandoned Chinese children that have found their way into prostitution and have no way out. She is hired to be their sewing teacher to enable them to learn a life skill that will offer them a future once they leave the home. She isn't sure she is ready to face her own shadowed past that caused her to leave behind her chance as a concert pianist. All she knows is that she must find a way to atone for her sins of the past in an effort to please God and sooth her own guilty conscience. No one must ever know.
Up and coming attorney Charles McKinley has a bright future ahead of him, working under his Uncle Silas' law firm. Unfortunately it will be starting at the bottom even though his name guarantees him a leg up in the firm. His first task is to bring the paperwork to the King family to ensure them that Silas has done everything but the insurance companies won't settle on the property claims Mr. King had purchased. He hopes to put an end to all their endless phone calls into the law firm for a meeting, something he has avoided doing. Now Charles hopes he can live up to the McKinley name. He just doesn't expect to fall for Elizabeth when she answers the door and the news he has to give her isn't something he is looking forward to doing. He only wishes he had better news for the King family.
I received Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett compliments of Abingdon Press and Litfuse Publicity for my honest review. I did not receive any monetary compensation, aside from a free copy of the novel in exchange for my honest and personal evaluation. I have been waiting for this novel since starting the Golden Gate Chronicle series! I was not disappointed. The story surrounding Donaldina Cameron is based on fact and her mission to help the struggling Chinese orphans is admirable. Again it is something missing from our history books and one I delighted in learning more about through this novel. I love Elizabeth King who is afraid of dealing with her past, tries to work out salvation on her own through her good works, but she will discover, that is not what God intended when He offers true forgiveness. I'd rate this one a 4.5 out of 5 stars and Discussion Questions are included that are perfect for book clubs.
June 9, 2016
*My Thoughts*
Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett is the third book in the Golden Gate Chronicles series. I read book two without reading book one, and was not lost a bit, so these books can be read in any order needed!
My favorite thing about Karen's books is definitely the raw emotions the characters experience, and the places she uses! She has such a way about choosing the little talked about aspects of our history, and making it into a well-written gem! I love hearing about things not often talked about, and Karen always brings new things to my attention.
This series has been filled with emotional ups and downs, twists and turns, fabulous plot lines, and engaging characters...I cannot wait to see what's next for Karen Barnett!
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett is the third book in the Golden Gate Chronicles series. I read book two without reading book one, and was not lost a bit, so these books can be read in any order needed!
My favorite thing about Karen's books is definitely the raw emotions the characters experience, and the places she uses! She has such a way about choosing the little talked about aspects of our history, and making it into a well-written gem! I love hearing about things not often talked about, and Karen always brings new things to my attention.
This series has been filled with emotional ups and downs, twists and turns, fabulous plot lines, and engaging characters...I cannot wait to see what's next for Karen Barnett!
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give Through the Shadows by Karen Barnett...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
June 23, 2016
MY THOUGHTS ON THIS BOOK
The city of San Francisco is trying to rebuild after the devastating disaster of the earthquake two years before. Elizabeth King is also trying to forget about the dark dreaded places of her past, so she dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, and just maybe get in God’s good graces. And maybe Elizabeth’s new friend Charles McKinley can help with some on the paperwork side of helping these young girls.
The real life story and ministry of Donaldina Cameron is the inspiration for this story, Through the Shadows. Ms. Cameron served at San Francisco’s Presbyterian Mission and because of her ministry, 3000 young Chinese girls were rescued from slavery and prostitution. This made the story much more appealing, knowing these situations and issues acted out by these wonderful characters actually happened. Karen Barnette does a wonderful job weaving together this special story to not only tell of what happened in early history, as well as making us away of what is happening in the world.
I received this book from Litfuse to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55.
The city of San Francisco is trying to rebuild after the devastating disaster of the earthquake two years before. Elizabeth King is also trying to forget about the dark dreaded places of her past, so she dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, and just maybe get in God’s good graces. And maybe Elizabeth’s new friend Charles McKinley can help with some on the paperwork side of helping these young girls.
The real life story and ministry of Donaldina Cameron is the inspiration for this story, Through the Shadows. Ms. Cameron served at San Francisco’s Presbyterian Mission and because of her ministry, 3000 young Chinese girls were rescued from slavery and prostitution. This made the story much more appealing, knowing these situations and issues acted out by these wonderful characters actually happened. Karen Barnette does a wonderful job weaving together this special story to not only tell of what happened in early history, as well as making us away of what is happening in the world.
I received this book from Litfuse to read and review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 55.
May 20, 2016
FTC: I received a free copy of this book from Litfuse in exchange for my honest review. I received no other compensation and the opinions expressed in this review are one hundred percent true and my own.
Through The Shadows by Karen Barnett was another great book in The Golden Gate Chronicles series. This is the third book in the series, and I think it may be my favorite in the series. I loved these characters, and I felt like I could relate to them more than I could the other characters. I also loved the subject of this book because it reminded me of one of my favorite author’s and her books that take place in North and South Korea and even though that this book takes place in San Francisco it reminded me of those books and I know that made me fall even more in love with this book. I could see myself acting like Elizabeth and Charles because the things that they are fighting against are also things that I would be against and try to change. This is a fantastic historical fiction book that I know just about everyone will love just as much as I do.
Through The Shadows by Karen Barnett was another great book in The Golden Gate Chronicles series. This is the third book in the series, and I think it may be my favorite in the series. I loved these characters, and I felt like I could relate to them more than I could the other characters. I also loved the subject of this book because it reminded me of one of my favorite author’s and her books that take place in North and South Korea and even though that this book takes place in San Francisco it reminded me of those books and I know that made me fall even more in love with this book. I could see myself acting like Elizabeth and Charles because the things that they are fighting against are also things that I would be against and try to change. This is a fantastic historical fiction book that I know just about everyone will love just as much as I do.
May 23, 2016
As my first book from Karen Barnet, I was thoroughly impressed with Through the Shadows. Karen has a way of drawing her readers into her stories and falling in love with her characters from page one. I was drawn in and loved how Elizabeth King throws herself into the work of the mission of saving young girls from brothels in Chinatown. I also enjoyed how Elizabeth and Charles McKinley keep bumping into each other and how a romance forms. Although the third book in a series, this can be read as a standalone. I would recommend this book to readers that enjoy historical, romance novels.
Series: Golden Gate Chronicles
Genre: historical, romance, Christian
Publisher: Abingdon Press
Publication date: May 1, 2016
Number of pages: 320
Content Rating: PG, reference to prostitution
Book Rating: 5 stars
Other books in the series:
1-Out of the Ruins
2-Beyond the Ashes
A review copy of this book was provided by LitFuse.
Series: Golden Gate Chronicles
Genre: historical, romance, Christian
Publisher: Abingdon Press
Publication date: May 1, 2016
Number of pages: 320
Content Rating: PG, reference to prostitution
Book Rating: 5 stars
Other books in the series:
1-Out of the Ruins
2-Beyond the Ashes
A review copy of this book was provided by LitFuse.
May 17, 2016
Stepping into history with Karen Barnett is a treat as she develops very realist characters, scenes, and events.
As San Francisco continues to reconstruct after the historically catastrophic earthquake and fire that gutted the city, corruption and evil manipulate the lives of the populace. The evils of criminal politicians, human trafficking, and racism are rife.
The good folks still exist, though, and Elizabeth King and Charles McKinley muddle through discovering how God's grace and His strength can imbue one with wisdom and virtue to carry on.
This is an absolutely riveting read and a fine conclusion to the Gold Gate Chronicles.
I received a complimentary copy to facilitate this review. Opinions are my own. I was not compensated.
As San Francisco continues to reconstruct after the historically catastrophic earthquake and fire that gutted the city, corruption and evil manipulate the lives of the populace. The evils of criminal politicians, human trafficking, and racism are rife.
The good folks still exist, though, and Elizabeth King and Charles McKinley muddle through discovering how God's grace and His strength can imbue one with wisdom and virtue to carry on.
This is an absolutely riveting read and a fine conclusion to the Gold Gate Chronicles.
I received a complimentary copy to facilitate this review. Opinions are my own. I was not compensated.
January 8, 2017
Set 2 years after the earthquake of San Francisco in the early 1800s, Through the Shadows is a great read. Charles got into law to try to fix a broken system that hurt his sister. Elizabeth believes working at the mission teaching young Chinese girls rescued out of slavery will help not only my them, but to make up for her past mistakes. They along with the entire city are trying to rebuild their lives and homes.
The book takes a look into early San Francisco and the struggle of young Chinese and those who worked to help them. Ultimately, it's a story of redemption and grace.
The book takes a look into early San Francisco and the struggle of young Chinese and those who worked to help them. Ultimately, it's a story of redemption and grace.
June 29, 2016
Through the Shadows is a complex historical romance which explores the depths of God’s mercy and forgiveness. I found the characters compelling, and the problems they faced challenging. Often I sat on the edge of my seat, holding my breath, waiting for what I prayed would be a good outcome. Barnett did not disappoint and the story carried me to a satisfying end, a book I can highly recommend. A particularly thought-provoking tale—one of Barnett’s best, so far.
June 13, 2016
Karen Barnett is a strong historical writer. She researches and uses the results to flesh out the lives of her characters. Characters I cared about. You won't be disappointed.
I received this book for free in return for my honest opinion.
I received this book for free in return for my honest opinion.
June 4, 2016
I've long been interested in the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, so when I learned that Karen Barnett, whose Mistaken: First Impressions Are Never What They Seem I really enjoyed, had written a series centered around the earthquake, I knew I wanted to read it. The first two books, Out of the Ruins and Beyond the Ashes, were both enjoyable reads. I loved the plots, but I felt a bit ambivalent toward the heroines. Still, the strong writing was enough to keep me coming back for more.
Through the Shadows features the same vivid writing found in Barnett's previous novels, but I liked it even better for one reason: I loved the heroine! Elizabeth is a spunky young woman unafraid to stand up against evil but terrified that she can never be forgiven for her past mistakes. I really appreciate that Barnett chose to gave Elizabeth a real past—she's not feeling guilty about circumstances out of her control; rather, she's regretting her sin. She moves to San Francisco to help the girls at the Mission Home, but she also believes that maybe, just maybe, if she does enough good, that will get her back into God's good graces. As danger swirls around her, she finally understands that God's grace is freely offered, not something she must work to attain.
I also enjoyed Elizabeth's romance with Charles. When Elizabeth was tentative, Charles was patient and kind, and all the roadblocks to their happily ever after made sense. (One of my biggest pet peeves in romance is when the hero and heroine are kept apart due to ridiculous miscommunication.) In the beginning, I wasn't so sure that I'd like Charles, as he was quick to take his (obviously shady) uncle at his word. But Charles quickly grew on me, and just as I rooted for Elizabeth to accept God's grace, I rooted for Charles to stand up to his uncle and make his own way in the world. Also, I enjoyed the look into law office politics.
The bulk of the novel takes place at the Mission Home, a refuge for girls rescued from forced servitude and prostitution in Chinatown. I loved reading about Elizabeth's interactions with the girls, as well as the rescue missions—so to learn the Mission Home was a real place (that still exists today!) and mission director Donaldina Cameron was a real person was just the icing on the cake.
Through the Shadows is Barnett's best book yet. I loved every second I spent reading it, and I highly recommend it!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Litfuse Publicity Group. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
Through the Shadows features the same vivid writing found in Barnett's previous novels, but I liked it even better for one reason: I loved the heroine! Elizabeth is a spunky young woman unafraid to stand up against evil but terrified that she can never be forgiven for her past mistakes. I really appreciate that Barnett chose to gave Elizabeth a real past—she's not feeling guilty about circumstances out of her control; rather, she's regretting her sin. She moves to San Francisco to help the girls at the Mission Home, but she also believes that maybe, just maybe, if she does enough good, that will get her back into God's good graces. As danger swirls around her, she finally understands that God's grace is freely offered, not something she must work to attain.
I also enjoyed Elizabeth's romance with Charles. When Elizabeth was tentative, Charles was patient and kind, and all the roadblocks to their happily ever after made sense. (One of my biggest pet peeves in romance is when the hero and heroine are kept apart due to ridiculous miscommunication.) In the beginning, I wasn't so sure that I'd like Charles, as he was quick to take his (obviously shady) uncle at his word. But Charles quickly grew on me, and just as I rooted for Elizabeth to accept God's grace, I rooted for Charles to stand up to his uncle and make his own way in the world. Also, I enjoyed the look into law office politics.
The bulk of the novel takes place at the Mission Home, a refuge for girls rescued from forced servitude and prostitution in Chinatown. I loved reading about Elizabeth's interactions with the girls, as well as the rescue missions—so to learn the Mission Home was a real place (that still exists today!) and mission director Donaldina Cameron was a real person was just the icing on the cake.
Through the Shadows is Barnett's best book yet. I loved every second I spent reading it, and I highly recommend it!
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Litfuse Publicity Group. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
May 20, 2016
Through The Shadows by Karen Barnett is the third book in the Golden Gate Chronicles. It is a Christian historical novel set in 1908 in the aftermath of the 1906 San Francisco earthquake.
The novel is all about new beginnings. No-one is too far from the hand of God. "You're never beyond God's love." Whatever the past, God can take lives and redeem them. "All around you... you can see God bringing life from the ashes... And He's redeeming these girls from the ruin of their lives too." The story centres around a Chinese mission to rescue young girls and women from a life of slavery and/or prostitution. The centre is run by Miss Cameron who will stop at nothing to give the girls a new start in life.
Through The Shadows continues the theme of rescue throughout. One can be physically rescued or spiritually rescued. This all ties in with the theme of grace. Everyone has sinned but Jesus went to the cross for all our sins. We all need grace and we all need to dispense grace. If we close our eyes to suffering, it is as if we are turning our backs on Jesus.
Grace links in with the theme of forgiveness. Often it is easier to forgive others than to forgive ourselves. "If God had given her the gift of freedom, why did she live under the shadows of the past?" Our guilt can weigh us down, but Jesus dealt with our guilt on the cross. God forgives our sins and chooses not to remember them. We would be wise to do the same.
Elizabeth, a young teacher has a past. She bargains with God, intending to work her way to forgiveness. Elizabeth has missed the point - it is not about what we can do, it is about what Jesus has done.
The novel has an over-riding theme of love, beautifully put by lift operator Eugene "Career ups and downs- they don't matter none. It's all about loving the people God gives you." It is important to love people and not to judge them. There are instances in the story where people are prejudiced against the residents of China Town. They see the tongs rivalry, the opium dens and the prostitution but they do not see the individuals. "A patient is first and foremost a person. Treat them as such." We need to see people and not have generalisations.
I absolutely loved all three Golden Gate novels so far. Karen Barnett has created some wonderful storylines and characters. There is a serious underlying message to save people from others and themselves, as well as a gentle story of everyday life and friendships. There were some very touching moments with the young girls and some highly amusing scenes too.
A delightful series.
I received this book for free in exchange for a fair and honest review. No monetary compensation was received and all views expressed are my own.
The novel is all about new beginnings. No-one is too far from the hand of God. "You're never beyond God's love." Whatever the past, God can take lives and redeem them. "All around you... you can see God bringing life from the ashes... And He's redeeming these girls from the ruin of their lives too." The story centres around a Chinese mission to rescue young girls and women from a life of slavery and/or prostitution. The centre is run by Miss Cameron who will stop at nothing to give the girls a new start in life.
Through The Shadows continues the theme of rescue throughout. One can be physically rescued or spiritually rescued. This all ties in with the theme of grace. Everyone has sinned but Jesus went to the cross for all our sins. We all need grace and we all need to dispense grace. If we close our eyes to suffering, it is as if we are turning our backs on Jesus.
Grace links in with the theme of forgiveness. Often it is easier to forgive others than to forgive ourselves. "If God had given her the gift of freedom, why did she live under the shadows of the past?" Our guilt can weigh us down, but Jesus dealt with our guilt on the cross. God forgives our sins and chooses not to remember them. We would be wise to do the same.
Elizabeth, a young teacher has a past. She bargains with God, intending to work her way to forgiveness. Elizabeth has missed the point - it is not about what we can do, it is about what Jesus has done.
The novel has an over-riding theme of love, beautifully put by lift operator Eugene "Career ups and downs- they don't matter none. It's all about loving the people God gives you." It is important to love people and not to judge them. There are instances in the story where people are prejudiced against the residents of China Town. They see the tongs rivalry, the opium dens and the prostitution but they do not see the individuals. "A patient is first and foremost a person. Treat them as such." We need to see people and not have generalisations.
I absolutely loved all three Golden Gate novels so far. Karen Barnett has created some wonderful storylines and characters. There is a serious underlying message to save people from others and themselves, as well as a gentle story of everyday life and friendships. There were some very touching moments with the young girls and some highly amusing scenes too.
A delightful series.
I received this book for free in exchange for a fair and honest review. No monetary compensation was received and all views expressed are my own.
April 28, 2016
About the Book:
The devastating earthquake is just two years past, but the city of San Francisco is still trying to recover. Destruction of this magnitude is not so easy to overcome-and neither are the past regrets shadowing Elizabeth King's hopeful future.
Hoping to right her wrongs, Elizabeth dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, even if it means putting her own life at risk to sneak through the gloomy alleys and rooftops where dangers lurk.
Putting her life on the line for a worthy cause is admirable. But opening her heart is even more terrifying. So when Elizabeth meets attorney, Charles McKinley--a man who dreams of reforming San Francisco's crooked politics--Elizabeth begins to doubt: Can she maintain her pretense and hide her past? Or will her secret jeopardize both their futures?
My Review:
San Francisco, 1908
San Francisco was changed completely two years ago, by a devastating earthquake and fire. The city is hard at work trying to rebuild all that has been destroyed and so is Elizabeth King. Her past has so many dark twist and turns, things she never wants to tell anyone. In hopes of looking better in God’s eyes she decides to take a job as a teacher at the local mission. Maybe helping young girls escape some of Chinatown’s brothels will help redeem her in God’s eyes.
Charles McKinley wants to help people, why else would he one day wish to be someone prominate in the government. Working under his uncle, it seems he may never get any where. When his uncle gives him the King’s case to work on, he know maybe there is way he can help someone for once. Meeting Elizabeth King is like facing a tiger head on. But he is not going to let that stop him from getting her to realize how he feels.
When the mission at which Elizabeth works needs legal help, can Charles stand up for what’s right or will he continue to be under his uncle’s thumb? Elizabeth’s past soon comes to close for comfort, leaving her to wonder if she will ever be loved.
Through The Shadows is book three in the Golden Gate Chronicles. This series is by far one of the best series I have read. I love Karen Barnett’s books because they correspond wonderfully with history itself. I hope that there will be more in this series because I will be sure to read them.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author.
The devastating earthquake is just two years past, but the city of San Francisco is still trying to recover. Destruction of this magnitude is not so easy to overcome-and neither are the past regrets shadowing Elizabeth King's hopeful future.
Hoping to right her wrongs, Elizabeth dedicates herself to helping girls rescued from slavery in Chinatown brothels, even if it means putting her own life at risk to sneak through the gloomy alleys and rooftops where dangers lurk.
Putting her life on the line for a worthy cause is admirable. But opening her heart is even more terrifying. So when Elizabeth meets attorney, Charles McKinley--a man who dreams of reforming San Francisco's crooked politics--Elizabeth begins to doubt: Can she maintain her pretense and hide her past? Or will her secret jeopardize both their futures?
My Review:
San Francisco, 1908
San Francisco was changed completely two years ago, by a devastating earthquake and fire. The city is hard at work trying to rebuild all that has been destroyed and so is Elizabeth King. Her past has so many dark twist and turns, things she never wants to tell anyone. In hopes of looking better in God’s eyes she decides to take a job as a teacher at the local mission. Maybe helping young girls escape some of Chinatown’s brothels will help redeem her in God’s eyes.
Charles McKinley wants to help people, why else would he one day wish to be someone prominate in the government. Working under his uncle, it seems he may never get any where. When his uncle gives him the King’s case to work on, he know maybe there is way he can help someone for once. Meeting Elizabeth King is like facing a tiger head on. But he is not going to let that stop him from getting her to realize how he feels.
When the mission at which Elizabeth works needs legal help, can Charles stand up for what’s right or will he continue to be under his uncle’s thumb? Elizabeth’s past soon comes to close for comfort, leaving her to wonder if she will ever be loved.
Through The Shadows is book three in the Golden Gate Chronicles. This series is by far one of the best series I have read. I love Karen Barnett’s books because they correspond wonderfully with history itself. I hope that there will be more in this series because I will be sure to read them.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author.
May 26, 2016
Before I finished my very first novel by Karen Barnett, I knew I had found yet another author whose books I must have. I have been fortunate to have the opportunity to review them so far but I can assure you that if I happen to miss out on a blog tour, I will definitely purchase anything she pens. “Through the Shadows” met all my expectations and more.
The third book of Barnett’s Golden Gate Chronicles series, “Through the Shadows” takes place two years after the great San Francisco earthquake. The city is beginning to rebuild but many people have lost everything and the rich seem to get richer at their expense. Political corruption is rampant and an evil human slavery trade takes advantage of the innocents among the Asian community. It is to this volatile environment that young lawyer Charles McKinley comes to his uncle’s law practice because he wants to help others. Unfortunately his noble ambitions are squashed by the realities of his new job. Elizabeth King has also recently arrived in San Francisco hoping to atone for her mistakes by helping in a mission to the young rescued Chinese girls.
I loved this book! Elizabeth is just the kind of character I like – one who fights for the oppressed without a thought of her own danger, loving and loyal to those she cares for, yet fragile and wounded in spirit. Charles is the perfect hero also. He has such fine ambitions to help others and even when things do not go as planned, he always takes the high road. Working without sleep to prove himself worthy, he turned the other cheek time and again to those who wanted to undermine him and went out of his way to protect and serve those who needed him.
It was a joy to catch up with Elizabeth’s brother and sister as well as their spouses from the first two books of this series. Other familiar characters played important roles also. With plenty of drama, danger, misunderstandings, romance, and suspense, “Through the Shadows” held my attention through the end. It is a fine story of forgiveness and reconciliation plus learning to see ourselves the way the Lord sees us and accept his plans for us.
I am sorry to see this series end but I look forward to whatever Karen Barnett has in store for her readers next. I can’t wait!
A copy of this book was provided for review by LitFuse Publicity.
The third book of Barnett’s Golden Gate Chronicles series, “Through the Shadows” takes place two years after the great San Francisco earthquake. The city is beginning to rebuild but many people have lost everything and the rich seem to get richer at their expense. Political corruption is rampant and an evil human slavery trade takes advantage of the innocents among the Asian community. It is to this volatile environment that young lawyer Charles McKinley comes to his uncle’s law practice because he wants to help others. Unfortunately his noble ambitions are squashed by the realities of his new job. Elizabeth King has also recently arrived in San Francisco hoping to atone for her mistakes by helping in a mission to the young rescued Chinese girls.
I loved this book! Elizabeth is just the kind of character I like – one who fights for the oppressed without a thought of her own danger, loving and loyal to those she cares for, yet fragile and wounded in spirit. Charles is the perfect hero also. He has such fine ambitions to help others and even when things do not go as planned, he always takes the high road. Working without sleep to prove himself worthy, he turned the other cheek time and again to those who wanted to undermine him and went out of his way to protect and serve those who needed him.
It was a joy to catch up with Elizabeth’s brother and sister as well as their spouses from the first two books of this series. Other familiar characters played important roles also. With plenty of drama, danger, misunderstandings, romance, and suspense, “Through the Shadows” held my attention through the end. It is a fine story of forgiveness and reconciliation plus learning to see ourselves the way the Lord sees us and accept his plans for us.
I am sorry to see this series end but I look forward to whatever Karen Barnett has in store for her readers next. I can’t wait!
A copy of this book was provided for review by LitFuse Publicity.
August 11, 2016
Deb’s Dozen: Amazing Grace, How Sweet the Sound That Saved a Wretch Like Me
Through the Shadows is Book 3 in Karen Barnett’s The Golden Gate Chronicles. I have enjoyed each and every book in the series. This book follows Elizabeth King, a talented seamstress and concert pianist. Her family has been impoverished by the Great Earthquake where all their investments in property came crashing down. Or did they? Something nefarious seems to be going on. The young attorney, Charles McKinley, who comes to explain their standing, offends Elizabeth immediately by taking her for the maid.
Elizabeth has abandoned the piano to her mother’s dismay—but Elizabeth connects piano with her piano teacher, who seduced her and then informed her he was married. In her mind, she is ruined forever. What man would want an impure woman? After hearing about the plight of young Chinese girls who have been sold as sex slaves, she decides to volunteer at a home in San Francisco whose purpose is to rescue these waifs. Here the girls are housed after they escape or are rescued. They are taught skills such as sewing and music as well as other life skills. Also a talented seamstress, Elizabeth is hired to teach sewing.
Charles McKinley, working at his uncle’s law firm, is disillusioned quickly about the high calling of law. He is apprenticed to Attorney Spencer who views Charles as a threat to his own success. Charles soon learns his uncle is only concerned with acquiring wealth and power—not in seeing justice obtained. Charles is handed the King case to handle—and keeps running into Elizabeth.
How Elizabeth finds solace, comfort, and faith through her students, and how Charles discovers his true calling form the basis of the novel. You’ll care deeply for the characters and ache for the young Chinese girls. Through the Shadows will sadden, educate, and encourage you as you read the story. I look forward to more novels from Karen Barnett.
Karen lives in Oregon with her husband and two kids. The Golden Gate Chronicles is her first series.
Abingdon Press gave me a copy of Through the Shadows in exchange for my unbiased review.
Through the Shadows is Book 3 in Karen Barnett’s The Golden Gate Chronicles. I have enjoyed each and every book in the series. This book follows Elizabeth King, a talented seamstress and concert pianist. Her family has been impoverished by the Great Earthquake where all their investments in property came crashing down. Or did they? Something nefarious seems to be going on. The young attorney, Charles McKinley, who comes to explain their standing, offends Elizabeth immediately by taking her for the maid.
Elizabeth has abandoned the piano to her mother’s dismay—but Elizabeth connects piano with her piano teacher, who seduced her and then informed her he was married. In her mind, she is ruined forever. What man would want an impure woman? After hearing about the plight of young Chinese girls who have been sold as sex slaves, she decides to volunteer at a home in San Francisco whose purpose is to rescue these waifs. Here the girls are housed after they escape or are rescued. They are taught skills such as sewing and music as well as other life skills. Also a talented seamstress, Elizabeth is hired to teach sewing.
Charles McKinley, working at his uncle’s law firm, is disillusioned quickly about the high calling of law. He is apprenticed to Attorney Spencer who views Charles as a threat to his own success. Charles soon learns his uncle is only concerned with acquiring wealth and power—not in seeing justice obtained. Charles is handed the King case to handle—and keeps running into Elizabeth.
How Elizabeth finds solace, comfort, and faith through her students, and how Charles discovers his true calling form the basis of the novel. You’ll care deeply for the characters and ache for the young Chinese girls. Through the Shadows will sadden, educate, and encourage you as you read the story. I look forward to more novels from Karen Barnett.
Karen lives in Oregon with her husband and two kids. The Golden Gate Chronicles is her first series.
Abingdon Press gave me a copy of Through the Shadows in exchange for my unbiased review.
May 27, 2016
Through the Shadows- a story of grace
Through the Shadows takes the shadows and darkness lurking within the lives of its central characters, weaving them into the darkness of the sex slave trade in Sans Francisco and the brightness of courageous mission endeavours, to create a story of secrets and tensions, life and struggles. But it is also a story of grace. Good read!
Elizabeth King, an attractive, petite blonde with a definite mind of her own, struggles to move beyond the shadows of the past and her own painful secret. A teaching position at the Presbyterian Mission for Girls rescued from the sex-slave industry offers a salve for her conscience and the promise of a new beginning.
Elizabeth loves the work and grows fond of the girls at the mission but there is danger in the shadows of Chinatown. After forays into China Town for supplies, information and a daring rescue of an abducted girl Donaldina Cameron, the mission director, warns the girls, “The enemy crouches like a roaring lion. Keep prayers on your lips.”
Despite initial misunderstandings on both sides, Elizabeth finds herself increasingly drawn to the young attorney, Charles McKinley, who has been given the responsibility of managing her family’s estate. Elizabeth states with exasperation, “You might look like a handsome cowboy but you’ve the twisted heart of an attorney.”
But Charles has his own shadows of the past and feels a growing disquiet concerning the King family’s collapsed investments. Despite growing tension at the law firm office he helps and provides legal representation for the mission leading to even more friction.
‘How many times would he be forced to choose between his heart and his career?’
Through the Shadows is a fictional piece but set in a historical period with well-known personalities of the time mentioned or included in the story. Extra historical details can be found following the story and also group discussion questions, which is helpful for personal reflection or discussion within a reading group.
Through the Shadows takes the shadows and darkness lurking within the lives of its central characters, weaving them into the darkness of the sex slave trade in Sans Francisco and the brightness of courageous mission endeavours, to create a story of secrets and tensions, life and struggles. But it is also a story of grace. Good read!
Elizabeth King, an attractive, petite blonde with a definite mind of her own, struggles to move beyond the shadows of the past and her own painful secret. A teaching position at the Presbyterian Mission for Girls rescued from the sex-slave industry offers a salve for her conscience and the promise of a new beginning.
Elizabeth loves the work and grows fond of the girls at the mission but there is danger in the shadows of Chinatown. After forays into China Town for supplies, information and a daring rescue of an abducted girl Donaldina Cameron, the mission director, warns the girls, “The enemy crouches like a roaring lion. Keep prayers on your lips.”
Despite initial misunderstandings on both sides, Elizabeth finds herself increasingly drawn to the young attorney, Charles McKinley, who has been given the responsibility of managing her family’s estate. Elizabeth states with exasperation, “You might look like a handsome cowboy but you’ve the twisted heart of an attorney.”
But Charles has his own shadows of the past and feels a growing disquiet concerning the King family’s collapsed investments. Despite growing tension at the law firm office he helps and provides legal representation for the mission leading to even more friction.
‘How many times would he be forced to choose between his heart and his career?’
Through the Shadows is a fictional piece but set in a historical period with well-known personalities of the time mentioned or included in the story. Extra historical details can be found following the story and also group discussion questions, which is helpful for personal reflection or discussion within a reading group.
June 7, 2016
I am sorry to say it, but this book reminded me of why I almost always avoid so-called Christian fiction. From the first page, it was as preachy as all get-out -- and that's unfortunate.
Elizabeth King, the protagonist, goes to work for Donaldina Cameron in Cameron's Chinatown mission. Miss Cameron was a crusader against human trafficking of young girls (some as young as 8) in the Chinatown brothels, and worked very hard to get them out.
Why is Elizabeth doing this? Well, she's interested in social justice -- even in 1908 -- but mainly she thinks she needs to be punished for having been seduced by the promises of an older man who has a great deal of power over her. The book is rife with Elizabeth being told, indirectly (because she keeps her secret) that she is worthless and needs to repent for what amounts to having been raped (there, I said it). Even the young man she meets, Charles McKinley, tells her he could never love a woman who "surrenders her virtue."
This is the worst kind of preachiness, to me. The author is clearly blaming women for their own harassment or rape ... which is absurd. Sure, the book takes place in 1908 ... when society as a whole still talked about "ruined women." But that didn't mean it was necessary for the author to gas on throughout the entire book about how certain Elizabeth is that God won't love her anymore.
It really is unfortunate, as I said above. The story of Donaldina Cameron's work is an important one, and the book touches on other issues like the Chinese Exclusion Act. This information is generally glossed over in history courses, and it needs to be talked about. I just wish it hadn't been talked about in this context.
Elizabeth King, the protagonist, goes to work for Donaldina Cameron in Cameron's Chinatown mission. Miss Cameron was a crusader against human trafficking of young girls (some as young as 8) in the Chinatown brothels, and worked very hard to get them out.
Why is Elizabeth doing this? Well, she's interested in social justice -- even in 1908 -- but mainly she thinks she needs to be punished for having been seduced by the promises of an older man who has a great deal of power over her. The book is rife with Elizabeth being told, indirectly (because she keeps her secret) that she is worthless and needs to repent for what amounts to having been raped (there, I said it). Even the young man she meets, Charles McKinley, tells her he could never love a woman who "surrenders her virtue."
This is the worst kind of preachiness, to me. The author is clearly blaming women for their own harassment or rape ... which is absurd. Sure, the book takes place in 1908 ... when society as a whole still talked about "ruined women." But that didn't mean it was necessary for the author to gas on throughout the entire book about how certain Elizabeth is that God won't love her anymore.
It really is unfortunate, as I said above. The story of Donaldina Cameron's work is an important one, and the book touches on other issues like the Chinese Exclusion Act. This information is generally glossed over in history courses, and it needs to be talked about. I just wish it hadn't been talked about in this context.
May 23, 2016
Through the Shadows is the third in the Golden Gate Chronicles, which follow a family and their friends through the 1906 San Francisco earthquake and its aftermath. People are flocking to the city looking for opportunity, even as corrupt officials and well-connected businessmen want to remove those they see as undesirable. Enter Charles McKinley, whose wealthy uncle attorney prefers to represent in court those who can afford to pay well or provide the right social connections. Providing legal assistance to a city mission is not among the senior McKinley’s ambitious plans for his nephew. Nevertheless, Charles is drawn to the mission’s cause.
As with Karen Barnett’s previous titles, Through the Shadows is an entertaining read of life after the earthquake. Readers get an insight into the good, the bad, and the downright ugly of San Francisco in the early 20th century. Morality appears to have a sliding scale, with certain behaviors and people given a ‘free pass’ while others are treated with shame. All sides of society are featured, from wealthy politicians to young Chinese girls rescued from slavery. The story of the King family runs throughout the series, with each book building upon the previous one. For that reason, I do recommend reading them in consecutive order. This is a series I’ve enjoyed, and I feel a little sad now that it’s come to an end. I’ll miss the characters and will wonder how their lives could’ve progressed. Hopefully, everyone lived “happily ever after.”
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Abingdon Press for my complimentary copy of Through the Shadows, which I received in exchange for my honest review.
As with Karen Barnett’s previous titles, Through the Shadows is an entertaining read of life after the earthquake. Readers get an insight into the good, the bad, and the downright ugly of San Francisco in the early 20th century. Morality appears to have a sliding scale, with certain behaviors and people given a ‘free pass’ while others are treated with shame. All sides of society are featured, from wealthy politicians to young Chinese girls rescued from slavery. The story of the King family runs throughout the series, with each book building upon the previous one. For that reason, I do recommend reading them in consecutive order. This is a series I’ve enjoyed, and I feel a little sad now that it’s come to an end. I’ll miss the characters and will wonder how their lives could’ve progressed. Hopefully, everyone lived “happily ever after.”
Thank you to Litfuse Publicity and Abingdon Press for my complimentary copy of Through the Shadows, which I received in exchange for my honest review.
May 18, 2016
After having read Karen’s other two novels, Beyond the Ashes and Out of the Ruins, I could not wait to get started on Through the Shadows. In this novel, we meet two new characters who are tied to our familiar favourites from the previous two novels (I LOVE this the most – you get to see how their lives evolve while being introduced to two new characters you fall in love with).
The novel takes place two years after the devastating earthquake that destroys most of San Francisco. Many of the citizens have lost everything and are trying to just stay a float, this is true for Elizabeth. Her father’s investments were lost both in the earthquake and the fire that followed. It is this combined with her love of making a difference, that sees her travel to San Francisco. She wants to put her past behind her, join her siblings and make a difference in the lives of young girls who are sold into slavery. She meets up with Charles, a young man who wants to make a positive difference in politics and the lives of the people he meets.
Charles is a character of strong convictions. He senses something is not quite right at his Uncle’s firm and works hard to uncover the details. What he finds is unbelievable and heart breaking. What he does with this knowledge, is mind blowing.
Through the Shadows is an amazing tale of forgiveness, healing and love against all odds. Our characters fight against the social constraints of society towards women, men and even foreigners, corruption that goes unpunished and the societal norm. It leaves you with hope and understanding. A fantastic read from start to finish, that leaves you craving just a little bit more!
The novel takes place two years after the devastating earthquake that destroys most of San Francisco. Many of the citizens have lost everything and are trying to just stay a float, this is true for Elizabeth. Her father’s investments were lost both in the earthquake and the fire that followed. It is this combined with her love of making a difference, that sees her travel to San Francisco. She wants to put her past behind her, join her siblings and make a difference in the lives of young girls who are sold into slavery. She meets up with Charles, a young man who wants to make a positive difference in politics and the lives of the people he meets.
Charles is a character of strong convictions. He senses something is not quite right at his Uncle’s firm and works hard to uncover the details. What he finds is unbelievable and heart breaking. What he does with this knowledge, is mind blowing.
Through the Shadows is an amazing tale of forgiveness, healing and love against all odds. Our characters fight against the social constraints of society towards women, men and even foreigners, corruption that goes unpunished and the societal norm. It leaves you with hope and understanding. A fantastic read from start to finish, that leaves you craving just a little bit more!
July 22, 2016
"Through the Shadows" is a Christian historical romance set in 1908 in San Francisco. You don't need to read the previous books in the series to understand this novel, though the main characters from the past books do appear in this story.
The heroine has rejected a life as a concert pianist along with the sin that she committed while touring. She decides to teach the rescued girls at the mission how to sew. She hopes to earn God's forgiveness, though she also enjoys the work and even joins in on the rescues. She finds healing, learns to trust God, and comes to understand the song "Amazing Grace."
The hero became a lawyer so he could help people like the girls at the mission, but his uncle--who is also his boss--wants him to defend the big-money clients. He tries to please his uncle while staying true to his ideals, but he struggles with what he should do. The hero and heroine spend time together and fall in love, but the heroine knows her past sin--if exposed--would prevent him from gaining his dream of a political office.
The characters were well-developed. I sympathized with their struggles and cared about what happened to them. I also enjoyed the historical details that were woven into the story, like the rebuilding of the city and the work that the mission did. This is the type of historical that I love, where the historical setting actually influences the plot rather than just being a stage backdrop.
There were no sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable novel.
I received an Advanced Reader Copy of this book from the publisher through Amazon Vine.
The heroine has rejected a life as a concert pianist along with the sin that she committed while touring. She decides to teach the rescued girls at the mission how to sew. She hopes to earn God's forgiveness, though she also enjoys the work and even joins in on the rescues. She finds healing, learns to trust God, and comes to understand the song "Amazing Grace."
The hero became a lawyer so he could help people like the girls at the mission, but his uncle--who is also his boss--wants him to defend the big-money clients. He tries to please his uncle while staying true to his ideals, but he struggles with what he should do. The hero and heroine spend time together and fall in love, but the heroine knows her past sin--if exposed--would prevent him from gaining his dream of a political office.
The characters were well-developed. I sympathized with their struggles and cared about what happened to them. I also enjoyed the historical details that were woven into the story, like the rebuilding of the city and the work that the mission did. This is the type of historical that I love, where the historical setting actually influences the plot rather than just being a stage backdrop.
There were no sex scenes or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this enjoyable novel.
I received an Advanced Reader Copy of this book from the publisher through Amazon Vine.
May 28, 2016
The third book in The Golden Gate Chronicles series is “Through the Shadows” by Karen Barnett. The great earthquake and subsequent fire in 1906 San Francisco caused the destruction of most of the city. Rebuilding the shops homes has become most important. Some individuals take this opportunity to fleece the unsuspecting citizens in order to gain wealth and power in the “new” San Francisco. Others try to use their talents to help the poor, underprivileged, and those preyed upon by unscrupulous human traffickers.
Elizabeth King has a past that she is not proud of. She is drawn to help the Mission, a home run by Donaldina Cameron to try to help the young Chinese girls who have been forced into prostitution and worse by those taking advantage of their hopelessness. She finds that she has much to give these girls and along the way she meets Charles McKinley. Charles is a young lawyer who is trying to prove himself in his uncle’s firm. He finds that all is not what it should be at the firm. He has given his services to the Mission to help in legal ways to free the girls in Ms. Cameron’s care. We think we live in a depraved society, but decades ago, times were just as bad. The comparison is quite interesting and caused me to read with more intensity that I normally would.
I was sent a free print copy of the book by the Litfuse Publicity Group and Abingdon Press in return for my honest review of the book. You can find this review on my blog at http://wp.me/p2pjIt-l0. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
Elizabeth King has a past that she is not proud of. She is drawn to help the Mission, a home run by Donaldina Cameron to try to help the young Chinese girls who have been forced into prostitution and worse by those taking advantage of their hopelessness. She finds that she has much to give these girls and along the way she meets Charles McKinley. Charles is a young lawyer who is trying to prove himself in his uncle’s firm. He finds that all is not what it should be at the firm. He has given his services to the Mission to help in legal ways to free the girls in Ms. Cameron’s care. We think we live in a depraved society, but decades ago, times were just as bad. The comparison is quite interesting and caused me to read with more intensity that I normally would.
I was sent a free print copy of the book by the Litfuse Publicity Group and Abingdon Press in return for my honest review of the book. You can find this review on my blog at http://wp.me/p2pjIt-l0. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
June 3, 2016
This book was so great and the story line so captivating. I really enjoyed the characters and they intrigued me so much with their lives and motives. This book is the third book in "The Golden Gate Chronicles" but I was never lost or trying to figure out what was going on. It definitely stands on it's own.
This novel was set in the early 1900's of San Francisco and we find Elizabeth trying to work out her past transgressions by helping the Chinese girls out of their bondage. Her past saddens me and the fact that she feels she can't trust God is truly sad, too. You can tell that she loves God but because of what has happened to her, she feels she must do other things to work out her redemption.
Charles McKinley is a man on a mission to change the corrupt politics of the city. Of course, he runs into resistance at every turn. Like Elizabeth, he wants to help the city and do what he feels is right. I really enjoyed this secondary story line as I felt it really added to the book.
I loved the pure, raw emotion we see in the characters and the many twists and turns that this story takes. The villains are quite intense (some are frankly, evil) and they add a lot to this story. You definitely have a story of good versus evil with this book.
This was a book I had a hard time putting down. The story moved along really well and you were left with enough questions that you wanted to find out what happens next. I really, really enjoyed this book and highly recommend it!
*This book was provided to me for my honest review by LitFuse Publicity Group
This novel was set in the early 1900's of San Francisco and we find Elizabeth trying to work out her past transgressions by helping the Chinese girls out of their bondage. Her past saddens me and the fact that she feels she can't trust God is truly sad, too. You can tell that she loves God but because of what has happened to her, she feels she must do other things to work out her redemption.
Charles McKinley is a man on a mission to change the corrupt politics of the city. Of course, he runs into resistance at every turn. Like Elizabeth, he wants to help the city and do what he feels is right. I really enjoyed this secondary story line as I felt it really added to the book.
I loved the pure, raw emotion we see in the characters and the many twists and turns that this story takes. The villains are quite intense (some are frankly, evil) and they add a lot to this story. You definitely have a story of good versus evil with this book.
This was a book I had a hard time putting down. The story moved along really well and you were left with enough questions that you wanted to find out what happens next. I really, really enjoyed this book and highly recommend it!
*This book was provided to me for my honest review by LitFuse Publicity Group
June 3, 2016
Through the Shadows is the third book in Karen Barnett's Golden Gate Chronicles. It is set primarily in San Francisco in 1908, a couple of years after the earthquake, as the city was rebuilt.
This novel, like the previous books in the series, features the King family. Elizabeth King is a former budding concert pianist who cut her career short after a complicated and unhappy relationship. She finds herself in San Francisco, working at a Mission that helps save very young girls from brothels in Chinatown.
Her life and work also connect her to Charles McKinley, an idealistic young attorney who wants to make a difference in the lives of the community.
This is a sensitively told story dealing with issues that are very relevant today, like immigration and choosing love over fear.
Elizabeth and Charles are warm, sympathetic characters, and there are other great supporting characters like Donaldina (head of the Mission) and George (a friend from Chinatown) that readers will care a lot about, too. It is wonderful to catch up with the rest of the King family (including Ruby's dachshund Otto!) in this book.
There is a strong Christian message of choosing to trust God's grace and accept his love for all people.
The historical details of San Francisco in the early 1900's are fascinating, and sure to interest fans of historical fiction. I enjoyed this book, and recommend it to other readers.
This novel, like the previous books in the series, features the King family. Elizabeth King is a former budding concert pianist who cut her career short after a complicated and unhappy relationship. She finds herself in San Francisco, working at a Mission that helps save very young girls from brothels in Chinatown.
Her life and work also connect her to Charles McKinley, an idealistic young attorney who wants to make a difference in the lives of the community.
This is a sensitively told story dealing with issues that are very relevant today, like immigration and choosing love over fear.
Elizabeth and Charles are warm, sympathetic characters, and there are other great supporting characters like Donaldina (head of the Mission) and George (a friend from Chinatown) that readers will care a lot about, too. It is wonderful to catch up with the rest of the King family (including Ruby's dachshund Otto!) in this book.
There is a strong Christian message of choosing to trust God's grace and accept his love for all people.
The historical details of San Francisco in the early 1900's are fascinating, and sure to interest fans of historical fiction. I enjoyed this book, and recommend it to other readers.
March 16, 2018
I am so sad to see this series end. I feel like I've lost several members of my family. This was also a wonderful book by Ms. Barnett. I enjoyed the historical aspects of this novel as well as those in the previous ones in the series. I think the actual person in this book, Miss Donaldina Cameron, was quite a lady. She had pluck and so much strength of character I wish I could have known her in real life.
This novel picks up a few years after the 1906 San Francisco earthquake with one of Dr. Robert King's sisters and her involvement in what Miss Cameron did for the children and women of Chinatown over the years. Robert's, from both book 1 and 2 in the series, sister Elizabeth comes to San Francisco to work for Miss Cameron as a sewing teacher. She leaves behind her mother and her career as a concert pianist due to a mysterious happening with her piano teacher. Elizabeth meets and takes an instant dislike to the younger Mr. McKinley, who has taken over her father's estate case and has bad news regarding the lack of money in the estate. Sparks fly. Enough to get her to find out more about Mr. Charles McKinley and fall for him hard, even though she doesn't believe herself worthy of him.
If you love clean historical romance, you will love this book as I do. Please take my advise and read it as soon as you can. Ms. Barnett is a fabulous writer and I anxiously await her next novel with baited breath. Enjoy!
This novel picks up a few years after the 1906 San Francisco earthquake with one of Dr. Robert King's sisters and her involvement in what Miss Cameron did for the children and women of Chinatown over the years. Robert's, from both book 1 and 2 in the series, sister Elizabeth comes to San Francisco to work for Miss Cameron as a sewing teacher. She leaves behind her mother and her career as a concert pianist due to a mysterious happening with her piano teacher. Elizabeth meets and takes an instant dislike to the younger Mr. McKinley, who has taken over her father's estate case and has bad news regarding the lack of money in the estate. Sparks fly. Enough to get her to find out more about Mr. Charles McKinley and fall for him hard, even though she doesn't believe herself worthy of him.
If you love clean historical romance, you will love this book as I do. Please take my advise and read it as soon as you can. Ms. Barnett is a fabulous writer and I anxiously await her next novel with baited breath. Enjoy!
May 23, 2016
My thoughts:
Being a fan of the other books by Karen Barnett in this series I knew this was a book I wanted to pick up and read. I loved getting to know Elizabeth King and the demons that were chasing her. She felt she could find refuge by hiding in a school for Chinese girls rescued from less than desired circumstances. But can she really or will her past follow her?
Throw in the decidedly handsome and eager Charles McKinley who wants to help her family find out how they could have lost everything in the great earthquake and you have a mix of temper and love in the best proportions. But when he finds out that his own family could be to blame for Elizabeth's misfortune what will he do? Will he turn his uncle over to the police or hope to find another way to restore the Kings money?
When Elizabeth's past comes to the school she teaches at and declares to the whole world just how fallen she really is can she ever take solace in music again or will she again need to flee and run? Will she find true forgiveness from a heavenly Father and in turn forgive herself?
Such a great book full of suspense and surprises. I truly enjoyed reading this one and hope that there are still more to come!
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own and not influenced in anyway.
Being a fan of the other books by Karen Barnett in this series I knew this was a book I wanted to pick up and read. I loved getting to know Elizabeth King and the demons that were chasing her. She felt she could find refuge by hiding in a school for Chinese girls rescued from less than desired circumstances. But can she really or will her past follow her?
Throw in the decidedly handsome and eager Charles McKinley who wants to help her family find out how they could have lost everything in the great earthquake and you have a mix of temper and love in the best proportions. But when he finds out that his own family could be to blame for Elizabeth's misfortune what will he do? Will he turn his uncle over to the police or hope to find another way to restore the Kings money?
When Elizabeth's past comes to the school she teaches at and declares to the whole world just how fallen she really is can she ever take solace in music again or will she again need to flee and run? Will she find true forgiveness from a heavenly Father and in turn forgive herself?
Such a great book full of suspense and surprises. I truly enjoyed reading this one and hope that there are still more to come!
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own and not influenced in anyway.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 62 reviews