What do you think?
Rate this book
Magnusverse
From the Library of Jurgen Leitner
Enter the library of an enigmatic collector, where occult books are guarded and researched at a fatal cost, with this uncanny eldritch horror novel.
Fear comes before the fall.
In the winding, perilous corridors of Jurgen Leitner’s private library, you never know what you’ll find. A starving cookbook. An ancient scroll that casts cool, predatory breezes. A cloth-bound hardback that compels you to DIG, DIG, DIG, DIG.
Free, these books are more than simply unnerving—they’re deadly. But the library keeps their dangers in check and their would-be readers safe. . . .
Or so Leitner claims.
For two of his employees, the risks are worth it. Hugh Franklin, research assistant, has finally found a place he belongs, where his skill in translation is valued, even if his employer is a bit odd. Sebastian Everett, acquisition specialist, can indulge his arcane ambitions, even if it means pretending to care about Leitner’s mission.
Though their tenures at the library were years apart, Hugh and Sebastian’s stories unfold in parallel, and their footsteps echo down the same eerie aisles, caught in a web spun long before either ever heard the name “Jurgen Leitner.”
Will they find a way out . . . or will the library consume them before it’s too late?
Fear comes before the fall.
In the winding, perilous corridors of Jurgen Leitner’s private library, you never know what you’ll find. A starving cookbook. An ancient scroll that casts cool, predatory breezes. A cloth-bound hardback that compels you to DIG, DIG, DIG, DIG.
Free, these books are more than simply unnerving—they’re deadly. But the library keeps their dangers in check and their would-be readers safe. . . .
Or so Leitner claims.
For two of his employees, the risks are worth it. Hugh Franklin, research assistant, has finally found a place he belongs, where his skill in translation is valued, even if his employer is a bit odd. Sebastian Everett, acquisition specialist, can indulge his arcane ambitions, even if it means pretending to care about Leitner’s mission.
Though their tenures at the library were years apart, Hugh and Sebastian’s stories unfold in parallel, and their footsteps echo down the same eerie aisles, caught in a web spun long before either ever heard the name “Jurgen Leitner.”
Will they find a way out . . . or will the library consume them before it’s too late?
10 pages, Audiobook
First published October 27, 2026
About the author
Premee Mohamed
86 books949 followersPremee Mohamed is a Nebula award-winning Indo-Caribbean scientist and speculative fiction author based in Edmonton, Alberta. She is an Assistant Editor at the short fiction audio venue Escape Pod and the author of the 'Beneath the Rising' series of novels as well as several novellas. Her short fiction has appeared in many venues and she can be found on Twitter at @premeesaurus and on her website at www.premeemohamed.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews
Want to Read
March 21, 2026cannot wait to read The Book That Kills You from hit audiodrama "Do Not Under Any Circumstance Read The Book That Kills You"
Want to Read
March 27, 2026Someone hit me with a pipe I’m so excited.
October 23, 2026
Some books are dangerous to read. Others are dangerous to even open. And then there are the books that will make you wish you’d never laid eyes on them at all. My thanks to Random House Worlds for the arc.
From the Library of Jürgen Leitner by Premee Mohamed and Jonathan Sims is a deliciously unsettling descent into a gothic library where books can kill, madness comes in a myriad of forms and even the most innocuous looking volume may be dangerous in ways that are truly horrifying.
From gruesome deaths and psychological torment to stranger, more inexplicable effects, the sheer variety of horrors lurking within these pages is a delight for anyone with a taste for the sinister. Just as fascinating are the methods devised to contain, combat and survive these dangerous tomes, each carrying its own peculiar menace.
The library itself is a marvel of atmosphere, where dark academia meets cosmic horror and the pursuit of forbidden knowledge brushes against the incomprehensible. Ominous dread seeps through the shelves but amid the supernatural dangers are the mundane banalities of life as a lowly intern. There is something darkly absurd about navigating the everyday indignities of a job when the books around you could drive you mad or kill you in any number of inventive ways.
Beneath the creeping horror lies a story of ambition and avarice, of secrets guarded and betrayals waiting to surface. Two interwoven timelines follow Hugh and Sebastian, whose very different attitudes towards the Library gradually come to light. As their motivations and goals emerge, the mystery takes shape and their paths converge. Each revelation draws the threads tighter, building towards a conclusion that is supremely satisfying.
Although connected to The Magnus Archives podcast this is a thoroughly compelling horror novel in its own right and requires no prior familiarity with the podcast to appreciate its sinister delights.
For those who love their libraries gothic, their books deadly and their horror steeped in creeping dread, this is a macabre invitation to turn the page. Just be careful what you read.
From the Library of Jürgen Leitner by Premee Mohamed and Jonathan Sims is a deliciously unsettling descent into a gothic library where books can kill, madness comes in a myriad of forms and even the most innocuous looking volume may be dangerous in ways that are truly horrifying.
From gruesome deaths and psychological torment to stranger, more inexplicable effects, the sheer variety of horrors lurking within these pages is a delight for anyone with a taste for the sinister. Just as fascinating are the methods devised to contain, combat and survive these dangerous tomes, each carrying its own peculiar menace.
The library itself is a marvel of atmosphere, where dark academia meets cosmic horror and the pursuit of forbidden knowledge brushes against the incomprehensible. Ominous dread seeps through the shelves but amid the supernatural dangers are the mundane banalities of life as a lowly intern. There is something darkly absurd about navigating the everyday indignities of a job when the books around you could drive you mad or kill you in any number of inventive ways.
Beneath the creeping horror lies a story of ambition and avarice, of secrets guarded and betrayals waiting to surface. Two interwoven timelines follow Hugh and Sebastian, whose very different attitudes towards the Library gradually come to light. As their motivations and goals emerge, the mystery takes shape and their paths converge. Each revelation draws the threads tighter, building towards a conclusion that is supremely satisfying.
Although connected to The Magnus Archives podcast this is a thoroughly compelling horror novel in its own right and requires no prior familiarity with the podcast to appreciate its sinister delights.
For those who love their libraries gothic, their books deadly and their horror steeped in creeping dread, this is a macabre invitation to turn the page. Just be careful what you read.
March 16, 2026
holy shit. absolutely incredible
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for providing me with the ARC.
I loved the atmosphere of the library, the magic books and evil schemes. I needed maybe more gore, although there was some horror, but it was presented after the fact. I wanted to be presented as it was happening right now. The dark academia vibes are strong, so if you are fan of the themes, do not skip this. The characters were interesting; we just got only two of them being more developed. I don’t often say this, but I wish it was longer. That’s why I couldn’t fully feel the impact of the ending, but it was very entertaining. I am not familiar with the Magnus Archive podcast, but I will listen to it, because I am so invested in this universe and I love short horror stories.
I loved the atmosphere of the library, the magic books and evil schemes. I needed maybe more gore, although there was some horror, but it was presented after the fact. I wanted to be presented as it was happening right now. The dark academia vibes are strong, so if you are fan of the themes, do not skip this. The characters were interesting; we just got only two of them being more developed. I don’t often say this, but I wish it was longer. That’s why I couldn’t fully feel the impact of the ending, but it was very entertaining. I am not familiar with the Magnus Archive podcast, but I will listen to it, because I am so invested in this universe and I love short horror stories.
Want to Read
March 17, 2026Where's the Michael Scott "Everybody stay calm" gif?
Want to Read
June 23, 2026Surely reading the book that makes people die and/or go insane will not make ME die and/or go insane!
Did Not Finish
August 13, 2026dnfing at 20% ish. i am so sick of books set in established universes trying to be a stand-alone. Publishers do this in theory to reach a new audience and gain sales without alienating new readers, but they fail to recognize that new readers do not take risks on 30-dollar hardcovers based on podcasts. if you've listened to the original series, which will be Literally Everyone Who Reads This Book, there will be no mystery or suspense or literally anything fun to unravel because you already have the answers. This is pissing me off so bad that I have to dnf like. who sat down and said yeah, Jurgen Leitner, the most interesting side character of all time, let's tell the story through the nothingburger interns of the guy who is famous for being killed to death hilariously. Spoilers ig
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 28, 2026
Not going to lie, I read this even though I’ve never listened to the podcast. Oddly enough this is my second podcast based book I read this year where I didn’t listen to the podcast first. And I loved both of them. I might have to go find some more.
This was a wild journey. What do you mean the books are all possessed and the interns are dispensable. Loved every minute of the mystery. The ending was so satisfying for once.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy. I need more of this story. All opinions are very much my own.
This was a wild journey. What do you mean the books are all possessed and the interns are dispensable. Loved every minute of the mystery. The ending was so satisfying for once.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy. I need more of this story. All opinions are very much my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
If you like the idea of cursed, possessed, or just plain evil books, this is one you have to read. Because the books in this particular library are more than just cursed. They can have horrific psychological effects and gruesomely bloddy deaths to anyone who stumbles upon them. The library is owned by the titular character who keeps them under strict protocols and he hires research assistants whenever a new book is found to figure out what effects a book might have.
Of course, there's a revolving door of assistants because they don't tend to last very long . This novel will follow two of them, Hugh and Sebastian, during different years as their stories collide in devastating ways. One is cursed by a particular tome and the other takes his place but has ambitions of his own to take possession of the books for himself. This is all going to lead to bloody mayhem and a twisty story that will have you shivering whenever you enter another library.
There are a few more characters who we get to know and they all have their parts to play (although it's not known to them at the time). Some of the deaths in here are delightfully disgusting and the dynamics between certain characters will eventually make things even worse. I highly recommend it.
I received and ARC of this book through Netgalley. This review is voluntary and is my own personal opinion.
Of course, there's a revolving door of assistants because they don't tend to last very long . This novel will follow two of them, Hugh and Sebastian, during different years as their stories collide in devastating ways. One is cursed by a particular tome and the other takes his place but has ambitions of his own to take possession of the books for himself. This is all going to lead to bloody mayhem and a twisty story that will have you shivering whenever you enter another library.
There are a few more characters who we get to know and they all have their parts to play (although it's not known to them at the time). Some of the deaths in here are delightfully disgusting and the dynamics between certain characters will eventually make things even worse. I highly recommend it.
I received and ARC of this book through Netgalley. This review is voluntary and is my own personal opinion.
November 7, 2026
the gimmick of owning a “leitner” is doing a lot for this books general appeal. it’s an okay story and the audiobook has some great sound design (this is a podcast company after all) but i feel like i would have gained more satisfaction from just putting a copy on my bookshelf and never opening it.
September 21, 2026
This review is for an ARC copy received from the publisher through NetGalley.
The premise of this book sounded right up my alley. But for whatever reason, it never really grabbed me. I don't know if it was the back-and-forth of the timelines or the writing itself, but I just couldn't get into it.
The premise of this book sounded right up my alley. But for whatever reason, it never really grabbed me. I don't know if it was the back-and-forth of the timelines or the writing itself, but I just couldn't get into it.
Want to Read
March 19, 2026THE MAGNUS ARCHIVES and PREMEE MOHAMED? Do not play with me rn............
Read
March 23, 2026trying to be normal about this while grocery shopping ......... (upcoming, late 2026)
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Thank you PRH Audio for the gifted Audiobook!
✦ 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 ✦
I had no idea that this was derived from a Podcast until I finished reading and googled the cover image. I hope that is a testament to just how much this stands on its own merit. This was an exceptionally eerie dark academia that felt completely alive and utterly uncanny.
The atmosphere was the sort of looming and heavy darkness that wraps around the reader and drags them into the story. The vibes were labyrinthian, and paired with the gothic, isolated setting - even something as mundane as cataloging books became an exercise in psychological survival.
The narrative is structured in a parallel dual-perspective that gradually unfolds an incredibly bizarre, occult mystery. On one side of the timeline is Hugh Franklin, a socially awkward translator who finds solace in the library. The second timeline introduces Sebastian Everett, an ambitious acquisition specialist whose motivations in regards to the library are entirely transactional. The pairing between the two was a really interesting contrast and kept me fully locked in on the mystery the entire time. In particular, Hugh’s descent into madness was incredibly well done, eerie and felt like a trainwreck in slow motion.
I think it's best to go into this one as blind as possible, because it is truly a unique and wild ride. Though classified as a horror novel, there are no jump scares or overly graphic violence. The terror stems from a palpable wrongness embedded in the setting and the creeping dread throughout.
While long-time fans of the creators' previous work will likely spot layers of deeper mythology, I simply found a beautifully written, medium-paced cosmic horror story. It was a toxic, enticing, and ultimately rewarding read that I recommend for anyone looking for a spooky, unique read this season.
✦ 𝗔𝘂𝗱𝗶𝗼 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗲𝘀 ✦
Multi-voice narration with Christian Coulson as the primary narrator, and Paul Sims (a co-host of the Magnus Archives podcast) provides the voice for Jurgen Leitner.
This audio was so much fun. The performances were immaculate, with Christian Coulson providing immense emotional range throughout his performance. I could feel the intensity of his fear, as well as the shifts in tone between Hugh and Sebastian. There were musical scores and sound effects throughout that were such an amazing touch and made this recording so special. This was one of the best audiobooks I’ve listened to all year - do not skip the audio!
𝙍𝙚𝙖𝙙 𝙞𝙛 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙡𝙤𝙫𝙚 𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙧𝙞𝙚𝙨 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙚𝙭𝙥𝙡𝙤𝙧𝙚:
Eldrich Monsters
Morally Grey Characters and Analysis
Bureaucratic Labor as a Trap
Parallel Narratives
The Illusion of Choice
✄----------
Genre: Psychological Horror, Dark Academia, Thriller
4 Stars
✄----------
Follow me on Instagram for more bookish content
✦ 𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬 ✦
I had no idea that this was derived from a Podcast until I finished reading and googled the cover image. I hope that is a testament to just how much this stands on its own merit. This was an exceptionally eerie dark academia that felt completely alive and utterly uncanny.
The atmosphere was the sort of looming and heavy darkness that wraps around the reader and drags them into the story. The vibes were labyrinthian, and paired with the gothic, isolated setting - even something as mundane as cataloging books became an exercise in psychological survival.
The narrative is structured in a parallel dual-perspective that gradually unfolds an incredibly bizarre, occult mystery. On one side of the timeline is Hugh Franklin, a socially awkward translator who finds solace in the library. The second timeline introduces Sebastian Everett, an ambitious acquisition specialist whose motivations in regards to the library are entirely transactional. The pairing between the two was a really interesting contrast and kept me fully locked in on the mystery the entire time. In particular, Hugh’s descent into madness was incredibly well done, eerie and felt like a trainwreck in slow motion.
I think it's best to go into this one as blind as possible, because it is truly a unique and wild ride. Though classified as a horror novel, there are no jump scares or overly graphic violence. The terror stems from a palpable wrongness embedded in the setting and the creeping dread throughout.
While long-time fans of the creators' previous work will likely spot layers of deeper mythology, I simply found a beautifully written, medium-paced cosmic horror story. It was a toxic, enticing, and ultimately rewarding read that I recommend for anyone looking for a spooky, unique read this season.
✦ 𝗔𝘂𝗱𝗶𝗼 𝗡𝗼𝘁𝗲𝘀 ✦
Multi-voice narration with Christian Coulson as the primary narrator, and Paul Sims (a co-host of the Magnus Archives podcast) provides the voice for Jurgen Leitner.
This audio was so much fun. The performances were immaculate, with Christian Coulson providing immense emotional range throughout his performance. I could feel the intensity of his fear, as well as the shifts in tone between Hugh and Sebastian. There were musical scores and sound effects throughout that were such an amazing touch and made this recording so special. This was one of the best audiobooks I’ve listened to all year - do not skip the audio!
𝙍𝙚𝙖𝙙 𝙞𝙛 𝙮𝙤𝙪 𝙡𝙤𝙫𝙚 𝙨𝙩𝙤𝙧𝙞𝙚𝙨 𝙩𝙝𝙖𝙩 𝙚𝙭𝙥𝙡𝙤𝙧𝙚:
Eldrich Monsters
Morally Grey Characters and Analysis
Bureaucratic Labor as a Trap
Parallel Narratives
The Illusion of Choice
✄----------
Genre: Psychological Horror, Dark Academia, Thriller
4 Stars
✄----------
Follow me on Instagram for more bookish content
October 30, 2026
What an incredible reading experience. This novel has its origins in a podcast, that I never listened to, no prior knowledge is needed to understand this world or the story.
This is a story for booklovers. I found so many clever references, a few instances that reminded me of Umberto Eco’s “The Name of the Rose” and chapter 20 reminded me a bit of the 1999 movie, “The Ninth Gate”.
Reading this standalone was everything I needed: reflection on books and on knowledge, commentary regarding the relationship between the rich and the poor, morally gray characters and books with fantastical power. It was such a delight and I know for sure that I will re-read it in the future.
This is a story for booklovers. I found so many clever references, a few instances that reminded me of Umberto Eco’s “The Name of the Rose” and chapter 20 reminded me a bit of the 1999 movie, “The Ninth Gate”.
Reading this standalone was everything I needed: reflection on books and on knowledge, commentary regarding the relationship between the rich and the poor, morally gray characters and books with fantastical power. It was such a delight and I know for sure that I will re-read it in the future.
October 27, 2026
5/5
YUP magnus archives never freaking misses
to my knowledge this was majority written by Premee Mohamed with input from Jonathan Sims and all this tells me is i absolutely need to read some of Premee's other works bc this hit crazy. you can definitely tell where Jonathan Sims left his input (he cannot resist the words viscera and vertigo) and they felt like little treats. and for the magnus archives truthers there were so many references to situations or people from the archives that i felt very pleased to notice. now its time to find an audiobook copy :D
YUP magnus archives never freaking misses
to my knowledge this was majority written by Premee Mohamed with input from Jonathan Sims and all this tells me is i absolutely need to read some of Premee's other works bc this hit crazy. you can definitely tell where Jonathan Sims left his input (he cannot resist the words viscera and vertigo) and they felt like little treats. and for the magnus archives truthers there were so many references to situations or people from the archives that i felt very pleased to notice. now its time to find an audiobook copy :D
unreleased
June 11, 2026EXCUSE ME???
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
FROM THE LIBRARY OF JURGEN LEITNER, by Premee Mohamed and Jonathan Sims, is a dark academia/horror novel about cursed books. Sounds interesting, right?
Honestly this is a tough one for me to review. While I enjoyed the imagery, some imaginative death scenes, and the basic premise, I never felt connected to any of the characters. After I finished reading, I did notice some reviews referencing a podcast. Having never heard this, perhaps that was the reason for my disconnect? It is marketed as a standalone, but I honestly felt that I was "missing something" throughout.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC of this novel. All opinions are my own.
Honestly this is a tough one for me to review. While I enjoyed the imagery, some imaginative death scenes, and the basic premise, I never felt connected to any of the characters. After I finished reading, I did notice some reviews referencing a podcast. Having never heard this, perhaps that was the reason for my disconnect? It is marketed as a standalone, but I honestly felt that I was "missing something" throughout.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-ARC of this novel. All opinions are my own.
September 29, 2026
3 STARS
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
What initially interested me about this book was the blurb: a story about a private library containing dangerous and cursed books? Owned by a man called Jurgen Leitner?`And this book was featured in the Horror category? That ticked a lot of my boxes: books about books, a kooky old man as a central figure and a horror book (because I resolved to read more horror this year and I have some catching up to do).
So far, so good. I only realized that this ties into an existent world when I was already quite a ways into the book. I had never heard about The Magnus Archives, a horror podcast about the Magnus Institute tasked with finding dangerous book (as far as I can make out), and I was not familiar with any of the established worldbuilding. This book is a prequel to the podcast so that didn't really matter all that much but, if you know me, you know that I like to go into series in order of publication to catch easter eggs etc. I wouldn't say that it completely made my reading experience unenjoyable but I was a little miffed once I found out about the podcast...
Still, I enjoyed the book overall. Although I couldn't quite warm up to either Hugh or Sebastian, let alone Leitner himself, the worldbuilding was intriguing. I was disappointed though that we did not get more specific information about the books themselves but, maybe, I'll have to check out the podcast for that (something I'm planning on anyway). The pacing was a little lackluster at times as well, I did struggle to keep picking the book up in the middle. And I must admit that one of the big twists in the end was fairly predictable to me, although I still have many questions that will probably never be answered.
I definitely don't regret having read this but it also didn't really meet my expectations from what I had imagined upon reading the blurb. While there were some horrifying moments throughout the book, it never felt truly like horror to me either... Overall, it's a solid 3 star read.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
What initially interested me about this book was the blurb: a story about a private library containing dangerous and cursed books? Owned by a man called Jurgen Leitner?`And this book was featured in the Horror category? That ticked a lot of my boxes: books about books, a kooky old man as a central figure and a horror book (because I resolved to read more horror this year and I have some catching up to do).
So far, so good. I only realized that this ties into an existent world when I was already quite a ways into the book. I had never heard about The Magnus Archives, a horror podcast about the Magnus Institute tasked with finding dangerous book (as far as I can make out), and I was not familiar with any of the established worldbuilding. This book is a prequel to the podcast so that didn't really matter all that much but, if you know me, you know that I like to go into series in order of publication to catch easter eggs etc. I wouldn't say that it completely made my reading experience unenjoyable but I was a little miffed once I found out about the podcast...
Still, I enjoyed the book overall. Although I couldn't quite warm up to either Hugh or Sebastian, let alone Leitner himself, the worldbuilding was intriguing. I was disappointed though that we did not get more specific information about the books themselves but, maybe, I'll have to check out the podcast for that (something I'm planning on anyway). The pacing was a little lackluster at times as well, I did struggle to keep picking the book up in the middle. And I must admit that one of the big twists in the end was fairly predictable to me, although I still have many questions that will probably never be answered.
I definitely don't regret having read this but it also didn't really meet my expectations from what I had imagined upon reading the blurb. While there were some horrifying moments throughout the book, it never felt truly like horror to me either... Overall, it's a solid 3 star read.
November 1, 2026
I loved the concept of this book. Books that have the potential to kill you? Amazing! The atmosphere of this book was fantastic and if you're a fan of dark academia, you should really enjoy this. I really enjoyed the writing in this book as well. It was pretty easy to read, yet felt elegant to me. My only complaint is that I found myself getting a bit bored at times, but I'm not sure if that was the book's fault or if it's because I was reading this on an oversea flight and was tired. I ordered this book and am waiting for it to come in the mail, and I think I'd like to reread it when my mental capacity is better! I honestly think it could be a higher rating than on a reread for me.
Disregarding the small complaint that I made, I still found this highly entertaining and again, the concept is fantastic. I'll surely be continuing this series. Also major props to the cover of this book! Absolutely stunning!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
Disregarding the small complaint that I made, I still found this highly entertaining and again, the concept is fantastic. I'll surely be continuing this series. Also major props to the cover of this book! Absolutely stunning!
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
This was quite an interesting addition to the canon of TMA. While it is a prequel, reading this before the show (at least the first two seasons, I'd say) would take away some of the mystery that really makes early TMA and there were definitely some easter eggs and characters that I think you appreciate more, knowing them from TMA.
I also would be really curious to go back and listen to the audiobook for this one. I know it has three narrators (including Jonathan and Paul Sims), so I'm very curious how that was done.
I also would be really curious to go back and listen to the audiobook for this one. I know it has three narrators (including Jonathan and Paul Sims), so I'm very curious how that was done.
October 31, 2026
5/5
This was absolutely amazing and exactly what I would have wanted. Hugh's and Sebastian's storylines fit so neatly and so well within the greater story. Leitner himself isn't used that heavily, I think a smart idea. There's enough here that is a wink and a nudge to lovers of the series (like me) while still having new and different horrors to touch on. Leitners library was so interesting to be in, and the assistants were a lovely bunch, especially Chuck. I liked how unlikable Sebastian was, and how pathetic Hugh was, both complimented each other so well, and I loved the trajectory of the story. A little slow down in the middle that quickly picked itself up. Maybe a bit predictable but still surprising and enjoyable to read.
This was absolutely amazing and exactly what I would have wanted. Hugh's and Sebastian's storylines fit so neatly and so well within the greater story. Leitner himself isn't used that heavily, I think a smart idea. There's enough here that is a wink and a nudge to lovers of the series (like me) while still having new and different horrors to touch on. Leitners library was so interesting to be in, and the assistants were a lovely bunch, especially Chuck. I liked how unlikable Sebastian was, and how pathetic Hugh was, both complimented each other so well, and I loved the trajectory of the story. A little slow down in the middle that quickly picked itself up. Maybe a bit predictable but still surprising and enjoyable to read.
November 5, 2026
I liked this book. It was cool to get some more backstory about Jurgen Leitner and more Magnus content is always great anyway
The different points in time for the different POVs were a cool idea
Sadly it didnt reach the same heights as the podcast itself for me
The twist if it was meant as one felt incredibly obvious to me and I wish the book had had a larger focus on the books themselves
The different points in time for the different POVs were a cool idea
Sadly it didnt reach the same heights as the podcast itself for me
The twist if it was meant as one felt incredibly obvious to me and I wish the book had had a larger focus on the books themselves
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
Draws you in and doesn't let go
November 3, 2026
Something about the writing style made me forget what I just read unless I concentrated really hard. I did enjoy how the two timelines intersected.
November 3, 2026
An absolutely wild ride of a book. I've never listened to The Magnus Archives before but this makes me want to check it out. Highly recommend the audiobook, I'm assuming it's similar to the podcast and really made the book feel more ~alive~.
November 1, 2026
i don’t know if i have ever felt this insane while reading a book ( ilysm magnus archives )
November 6, 2026
Before anything else: this is billed as a standalone, and technically it is. But I would never recommend it to someone who hasn’t listened to The Magnus Archives, in the same way I’d never recommend The Magnus Protocol before Archives. I’ve read a handful of other reviews, and I’m glad so many people are getting interested in the podcast because of this book. I’m just not sure how much they got out of the story without that context. Nearly every other sentence is a knowing nod to Archives (and Protocol), and skipping them means missing key information.
Hugh/Cobb:
If you know Archives, it’s obvious almost immediately that Hugh is Cobb (which isn’t necessarily a bad thing). The evidence piles up rather quickly, from his childhood, the incident at the museum, the addictive, uncontrollable and compulsive traits like kleptomania and lying, his talent for translation/encoding, and the spider “dream.” It’s all very Web. It reads like a statement Gertrude or Jon would take, or dig up in the archives, right before the statement giver meets their doom. Obviously, the best part of the book was finally getting to watch someone become an avatar from start to finish (besides a select few of the protagonist from Archives, of course). Hugh/Cobb is now my favorite depiction of an avatar of The Web (sorry Ep. 110: Creature Feature & Ep. 136: The Puppeteer).
I think my love for him is also helped by his extremely upsetting past & storyline. He grew up with a family ignoring abuse in his household, because paying attention to anything else hurt less than confronting it. That’s probably why he’s so hellbent on change, cacooning— metamorphosis. That’s why The Mother of Puppet’s embrace, at the end, was seen more to Hugh/Cobb like a pure embrace of love rather than being consumed whole. He could have gotten help as a kid, but he was treated as something to ignore, a problem that would take too long to fix. His family played at being “normal” with what they assumed were good intentions, never saying the quiet part out loud (their disdain for him- a reflection of their fractured family unit) and their coddling was more belittling and dismissive of his pain than anything. It left their youngest son helpless, a groveling mess repeating apologies in a bid for attention or little control over his life and others he wanted to love and be loved by— all when they already thought of him as gross and whiny. Despite this, he still left his family home, sparing them (as best as we can know) and finding more agency in his situation (even if that meant being unhoused (The Web’s arms later becoming his home)), where he could be more of himself (or what he was “becoming.”) Later he used all of it, his emotions of being ignored and having zero to no agency in his life (similar to the trapped books), to manipulate people for the Web’s master plan. That is to say, I really want to give him a hug (he reminds me of Michael, which in itself is a soft spot).
I also loved that even after Hugh/Cobb becomes something “other” (he was frankly already an outcast in society), the grey-and-white spider on Chuck’s sleeve implies he spared her (I’m assuming he pulled some stings and was the one to get her late to work). She was the closest thing to someone who cared about him, and she helped him as best she could under the circumstances. Is she screwed now that the Web has its eyes on her? Definitely. But in my opinion the Web isn’t the worst entity to be marked by, in the grand scheme of things. She’s talented with computers and long-term planning, as well as keeping secrets, so maybe she was already inclined toward it.
Lastly, I also don’t think that Hugh/Cobb is also truly dead after being embraced fully by The Web. I don’t think he’ll be popping up in any more stories, but he would be a fun character to put in a campaign for TMA TTRPG…
Sebastian:
Alright, now for Sebastian. I actually really liked him at first but found his arrogance really annoying in the second half, which I believe is fully intention. He is, up until the end, a cunning, smooth-talking man who will do anything for power (despite already being well-off), even when he doesn’t fully understand the magnitude of the situation he’s in. He thinks the architecture of the house isn’t holding the books back despite being instructed to mess with the house’s layout and each book’s wing by Hugh/Cobb in order to enact the change-in-power (which Sebastian believes is simply a transfer of name and the outcome being him being “all powerful,” not Leitner). Sebastian is literally five steps behind the whole time, which makes for a painful read, considering, if you’ve listened to the show, know this tale in a bloodbath.
I do appreciate the foreshadowing for his choice of death, however, as he is both very Flesh & Stranger coded. Like the Boneturner, Jared Hopworth (weird his friend is also named Sebastian and is a librarian), Sebastian is always striving for more and more, what he perceives as better and better. He’s obsessed with outward appearances, disgusted by Hugh/Cobb (by design),ruled by a sense of toxic masculinity, and always reads people fast so he can use them. He’s constantly around coffee and food (vegetarian), and around/talking about flowers too, which remind me of the garden in season 5 of the show. His body reacts to death (and the horrors he’s committed) while his mind stays numb, and he’d do anything to climb the social ladder (which, again, reminds me of Jared, who instead basically went on to retire from his life of crime). When Sebastian gets to choose a death for a co-worker, he goes straight to the Flesh: big, fast, and gory, just like how he wanted to reach the top as quickly as possible with no regard for human life (despite being one of the only people in good standing with Leitner). So it’s fitting that The Flesh came back to bite him in the ass.
He also nearly had a shot at becoming a Stranger (forgetting himself and his ambitions completely and leaving to act as someone else entirely), but his pride and sense of self got in the way. Even nameless, I was hoping he’d turn it around into something bigger. Obviously, the first handful of seasons demonstrate why The Stranger is a nightmare, but wouldn’t being something be better than nothing at all? He never had enough, though, even when he owned the library and its 900-something books. And that hunger is exactly how Hugh/Cobb got him to stamp every book and symbolically set ownership of everything free. He had Leitner’s trust, and if he’d been patient he probably could have taken the whole place once Leitner was gone (or needed someone to run his hoard effectively). But what good is a museum of someone else’s trash? He obviously liked the thrill of a gory death.
Leitner:
We actually got a little bit more of Leitner in this one. I won’t say that he was my favorite character, but his death was memorable and really set the tone for Elias’ plans. I did like seeing the parallels of Leitner and The Corruption. The strong medicinal smell coming off his breath, the hoarding (a big Corruption theme, especially in Episode 84: Possessive, my favorite Corruption story), and the way he just won’t die, like a cockroach scurrying around underground. How he survived until 2017, I don’t know. If I were Gertrude I would have killed him, but she probably saw him as expendable, someone to squeeze knowledge out of, even if his own hubris would kill him eventually. His fake grave marked with the last name Icarus is clearly what inspired the cover art which is a clever touch. Honestly, he deserved what was coming. If I were Elias, I’d have jumped him just as quickly, Jon or no Jon.
The house:
I was never a fan of the stories about architecture in the original podcast, despite being a lover of art irl. I found each countermeasure in each wing extremely fun, however. I loved The Lonely wing, where everything is forced into position to be seen constantly, and the books are pushed forward and labeled. The Spiral section was another favorite: a scenic walk through the garden where buildings disappear and reappear at random with new doors, all because of Sebastian meddling with the compasses inside. The whole outside section reminded me of the Biltmore Estate in NC. There are lots of allusions to classical mythology, which always makes me think of the Spiral: art, madness, and repeating patterns run through so many of its stories. The Spiral is one of my weaknesses. I feel weirdly parental toward its avatars. I have a soft spot for the Stranger too, and I really liked the bookseller.
What it adds to the main series:
The writing is great, and the book is a lot more on the nose than the podcast. It’s also gorier, since things can be described outright, similar to Jon and Martin’s travels in season 5. The voice acting was amazing (I listened to the audiobook while reading along), and I was very pleased to hear Paul Sims’ voice again for Leitner’s bits. I also liked seeing more of the actual book trade beyond statements and pieces about Gerry and his mom. The books themselves are much more antagonistic and powerful here, and I don’t think I took them as seriously as I should have during the main series. It’ll make relistens of the original show much more dreadful knowing that some books go beyond psychological torture and ghostly summonings.
This book makes Jon receiving “A Guest for Mr. Spider” as a child feel much more diabolical. The Web was already pulling strings, but now there’s the added layer that his guardian was truly targeted on purpose. Maybe someone slipped that book into a stack she bought, or maybe it just spawned there, which is equally terrifying (as a collector myself).
After everything, this story lends an element of the unknown horror back into the podcast. How far does The Web go? Can the books actually be destroyed completely, can we trust that fire would do the job when ripping cannot—given they are actual manifestations (some born and some man-made) of the entities? It also brings into question how much Gertrude and Elias actually knew about the world beyond (in Elias’ case) serving and feeding The Eye with their own hoard of knowledge (or what he presumed to be the ultimate truth).
The classism theme is strong, and the ironic answer at the end is giving power back to the people in a twisted way, by releasing the books back into the world. Maybe they were safer with Leitner, maybe not. By his logic, what are 40-some assistants compared to the countless horrors the books could unleash? He could have destroyed many of them, as Gerry shows in the main series (which I’m now doubting). But would they really be gone? I used to think burning them was a definite yes. Now I’m not so sure, since a book might reform or pop up again, the way Hugh/Cobb’s did after he spilled ink on it and tore it up. Would the bonfire have finished it off? Who knows.
Complaints:
The plot is a bit on the weaker side and I was expecting more. But since the story is literally about the downfall of one of the most pathetic characters in it, I don’t mind. My biggest problem is that the ending feels rushed, as if it’s missing about 75 pages to round things out.
Final thoughts:
I really enjoyed what this adds to the main narrative. It brings more uncertainty about what the entities can do, and another layer of cleverness to the whole thing. I’ll hand it to Elias (begrudgingly), this book made his plans a lot more clever. I’ll be checking out Premee Mohamed’s other work, and reading more of Jonathan’s, which I’m sorely overdue on.
Judging by the blurb, I’m guessing the next book, Work Your Fingers to the Bone, by Christopher Ruz, has to do primarily with The End and The Buried. They’re both very overlooked entities, which makes sense given most people they mark probably die before giving a statement, or become avatars with no reason to visit The Eye’s den in the original series. I really hope we get books centered on all 14 entities. Fingers crossed.
P.S. This book has convinced me even more that Martin should have been a Web (or Corruption) avatar instead of Lonely. Damn you, Peter.
Hugh/Cobb:
If you know Archives, it’s obvious almost immediately that Hugh is Cobb (which isn’t necessarily a bad thing). The evidence piles up rather quickly, from his childhood, the incident at the museum, the addictive, uncontrollable and compulsive traits like kleptomania and lying, his talent for translation/encoding, and the spider “dream.” It’s all very Web. It reads like a statement Gertrude or Jon would take, or dig up in the archives, right before the statement giver meets their doom. Obviously, the best part of the book was finally getting to watch someone become an avatar from start to finish (besides a select few of the protagonist from Archives, of course). Hugh/Cobb is now my favorite depiction of an avatar of The Web (sorry Ep. 110: Creature Feature & Ep. 136: The Puppeteer).
I think my love for him is also helped by his extremely upsetting past & storyline. He grew up with a family ignoring abuse in his household, because paying attention to anything else hurt less than confronting it. That’s probably why he’s so hellbent on change, cacooning— metamorphosis. That’s why The Mother of Puppet’s embrace, at the end, was seen more to Hugh/Cobb like a pure embrace of love rather than being consumed whole. He could have gotten help as a kid, but he was treated as something to ignore, a problem that would take too long to fix. His family played at being “normal” with what they assumed were good intentions, never saying the quiet part out loud (their disdain for him- a reflection of their fractured family unit) and their coddling was more belittling and dismissive of his pain than anything. It left their youngest son helpless, a groveling mess repeating apologies in a bid for attention or little control over his life and others he wanted to love and be loved by— all when they already thought of him as gross and whiny. Despite this, he still left his family home, sparing them (as best as we can know) and finding more agency in his situation (even if that meant being unhoused (The Web’s arms later becoming his home)), where he could be more of himself (or what he was “becoming.”) Later he used all of it, his emotions of being ignored and having zero to no agency in his life (similar to the trapped books), to manipulate people for the Web’s master plan. That is to say, I really want to give him a hug (he reminds me of Michael, which in itself is a soft spot).
I also loved that even after Hugh/Cobb becomes something “other” (he was frankly already an outcast in society), the grey-and-white spider on Chuck’s sleeve implies he spared her (I’m assuming he pulled some stings and was the one to get her late to work). She was the closest thing to someone who cared about him, and she helped him as best she could under the circumstances. Is she screwed now that the Web has its eyes on her? Definitely. But in my opinion the Web isn’t the worst entity to be marked by, in the grand scheme of things. She’s talented with computers and long-term planning, as well as keeping secrets, so maybe she was already inclined toward it.
Lastly, I also don’t think that Hugh/Cobb is also truly dead after being embraced fully by The Web. I don’t think he’ll be popping up in any more stories, but he would be a fun character to put in a campaign for TMA TTRPG…
Sebastian:
Alright, now for Sebastian. I actually really liked him at first but found his arrogance really annoying in the second half, which I believe is fully intention. He is, up until the end, a cunning, smooth-talking man who will do anything for power (despite already being well-off), even when he doesn’t fully understand the magnitude of the situation he’s in. He thinks the architecture of the house isn’t holding the books back despite being instructed to mess with the house’s layout and each book’s wing by Hugh/Cobb in order to enact the change-in-power (which Sebastian believes is simply a transfer of name and the outcome being him being “all powerful,” not Leitner). Sebastian is literally five steps behind the whole time, which makes for a painful read, considering, if you’ve listened to the show, know this tale in a bloodbath.
I do appreciate the foreshadowing for his choice of death, however, as he is both very Flesh & Stranger coded. Like the Boneturner, Jared Hopworth (weird his friend is also named Sebastian and is a librarian), Sebastian is always striving for more and more, what he perceives as better and better. He’s obsessed with outward appearances, disgusted by Hugh/Cobb (by design),ruled by a sense of toxic masculinity, and always reads people fast so he can use them. He’s constantly around coffee and food (vegetarian), and around/talking about flowers too, which remind me of the garden in season 5 of the show. His body reacts to death (and the horrors he’s committed) while his mind stays numb, and he’d do anything to climb the social ladder (which, again, reminds me of Jared, who instead basically went on to retire from his life of crime). When Sebastian gets to choose a death for a co-worker, he goes straight to the Flesh: big, fast, and gory, just like how he wanted to reach the top as quickly as possible with no regard for human life (despite being one of the only people in good standing with Leitner). So it’s fitting that The Flesh came back to bite him in the ass.
He also nearly had a shot at becoming a Stranger (forgetting himself and his ambitions completely and leaving to act as someone else entirely), but his pride and sense of self got in the way. Even nameless, I was hoping he’d turn it around into something bigger. Obviously, the first handful of seasons demonstrate why The Stranger is a nightmare, but wouldn’t being something be better than nothing at all? He never had enough, though, even when he owned the library and its 900-something books. And that hunger is exactly how Hugh/Cobb got him to stamp every book and symbolically set ownership of everything free. He had Leitner’s trust, and if he’d been patient he probably could have taken the whole place once Leitner was gone (or needed someone to run his hoard effectively). But what good is a museum of someone else’s trash? He obviously liked the thrill of a gory death.
Leitner:
We actually got a little bit more of Leitner in this one. I won’t say that he was my favorite character, but his death was memorable and really set the tone for Elias’ plans. I did like seeing the parallels of Leitner and The Corruption. The strong medicinal smell coming off his breath, the hoarding (a big Corruption theme, especially in Episode 84: Possessive, my favorite Corruption story), and the way he just won’t die, like a cockroach scurrying around underground. How he survived until 2017, I don’t know. If I were Gertrude I would have killed him, but she probably saw him as expendable, someone to squeeze knowledge out of, even if his own hubris would kill him eventually. His fake grave marked with the last name Icarus is clearly what inspired the cover art which is a clever touch. Honestly, he deserved what was coming. If I were Elias, I’d have jumped him just as quickly, Jon or no Jon.
The house:
I was never a fan of the stories about architecture in the original podcast, despite being a lover of art irl. I found each countermeasure in each wing extremely fun, however. I loved The Lonely wing, where everything is forced into position to be seen constantly, and the books are pushed forward and labeled. The Spiral section was another favorite: a scenic walk through the garden where buildings disappear and reappear at random with new doors, all because of Sebastian meddling with the compasses inside. The whole outside section reminded me of the Biltmore Estate in NC. There are lots of allusions to classical mythology, which always makes me think of the Spiral: art, madness, and repeating patterns run through so many of its stories. The Spiral is one of my weaknesses. I feel weirdly parental toward its avatars. I have a soft spot for the Stranger too, and I really liked the bookseller.
What it adds to the main series:
The writing is great, and the book is a lot more on the nose than the podcast. It’s also gorier, since things can be described outright, similar to Jon and Martin’s travels in season 5. The voice acting was amazing (I listened to the audiobook while reading along), and I was very pleased to hear Paul Sims’ voice again for Leitner’s bits. I also liked seeing more of the actual book trade beyond statements and pieces about Gerry and his mom. The books themselves are much more antagonistic and powerful here, and I don’t think I took them as seriously as I should have during the main series. It’ll make relistens of the original show much more dreadful knowing that some books go beyond psychological torture and ghostly summonings.
This book makes Jon receiving “A Guest for Mr. Spider” as a child feel much more diabolical. The Web was already pulling strings, but now there’s the added layer that his guardian was truly targeted on purpose. Maybe someone slipped that book into a stack she bought, or maybe it just spawned there, which is equally terrifying (as a collector myself).
After everything, this story lends an element of the unknown horror back into the podcast. How far does The Web go? Can the books actually be destroyed completely, can we trust that fire would do the job when ripping cannot—given they are actual manifestations (some born and some man-made) of the entities? It also brings into question how much Gertrude and Elias actually knew about the world beyond (in Elias’ case) serving and feeding The Eye with their own hoard of knowledge (or what he presumed to be the ultimate truth).
The classism theme is strong, and the ironic answer at the end is giving power back to the people in a twisted way, by releasing the books back into the world. Maybe they were safer with Leitner, maybe not. By his logic, what are 40-some assistants compared to the countless horrors the books could unleash? He could have destroyed many of them, as Gerry shows in the main series (which I’m now doubting). But would they really be gone? I used to think burning them was a definite yes. Now I’m not so sure, since a book might reform or pop up again, the way Hugh/Cobb’s did after he spilled ink on it and tore it up. Would the bonfire have finished it off? Who knows.
Complaints:
The plot is a bit on the weaker side and I was expecting more. But since the story is literally about the downfall of one of the most pathetic characters in it, I don’t mind. My biggest problem is that the ending feels rushed, as if it’s missing about 75 pages to round things out.
Final thoughts:
I really enjoyed what this adds to the main narrative. It brings more uncertainty about what the entities can do, and another layer of cleverness to the whole thing. I’ll hand it to Elias (begrudgingly), this book made his plans a lot more clever. I’ll be checking out Premee Mohamed’s other work, and reading more of Jonathan’s, which I’m sorely overdue on.
Judging by the blurb, I’m guessing the next book, Work Your Fingers to the Bone, by Christopher Ruz, has to do primarily with The End and The Buried. They’re both very overlooked entities, which makes sense given most people they mark probably die before giving a statement, or become avatars with no reason to visit The Eye’s den in the original series. I really hope we get books centered on all 14 entities. Fingers crossed.
P.S. This book has convinced me even more that Martin should have been a Web (or Corruption) avatar instead of Lonely. Damn you, Peter.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Read
March 20, 2026On my birthday??
Displaying 1 - 30 of 182 reviews