Promise is a dark MM mafia romance featuring broken boys, forced separation, second chances and undying yearning. Expect an obsessive, possessive alpha male who would burn the world down for his boy.
So, this is the story of Cole and Dylan who meet, get drawn to each other, and live a short happiness until they are separated for 6 years. They find each other again and have to make sure no outside forces can separate them again.
First, let me start by saying that this is my personal opinion. Not everyone will have the same issues as me. So, if you don't share my hangups, then give this book a chance.
I tolerated until about 35% before skimming through the rest.
If I can give this book 5 stars, it would be for: - Chapter 1 - Cole and Dylan being each other's first and last. - During the separation, there is no one else for either of them. They didn't want anyone else and were waiting for each other. - The matching tattoos - Epilogue 2 and the proposal
Now let's talk about my issues with the book. I may mention few minor spoilers in the process.
- They meet when Cole is 17 and Dylan is 15. We have some chapters before 35% describing that period. Also, the author has "sexual activities between minors" in the content warnings. My issue is not the presence of sexual activity between minors but it is how it is presented and how frequent. After the first time they meet and spend time together, Cole's POV is "As soon as I got home that night, I excitedly looked him up on every social platform I could think of. I spent a solid four hours scrolling through and obsessively analysing every detail of every photo I could find of him. Down the rabbit hole I went. I screenshotted every single picture, then compulsively jerked off to his face, imagining he was in the room with me, kneeling between my legs." The thought of a 17 year old thinking like that about a 15 year old just made me uncomfortable. Their whole relationship is lustful and that what made me more uncomfortable. The excess of dirty talking of Cole to Dylan, Cole spanking Dylan, Cole getting a butt plug and using on Dylan so he can learn to take his cock, making the plug vibrate while Dylan is getting the matching tattoo, made me so uncomfortable that I started skimming after that which was about 35%. If the sexual activity between them is written in sensational way, without the dirty talk and spanking and begging to come, I wouldn't gotten such ick.
“Ahh fuck, fuck, ffuucuck. Cole. Please.” He begs below me. Like music to my ears. He’s getting close, and I’m dangerously on the edge as well. “Please what, baby? Hmm, you want to come? is that it? Do you want me to let you come?” I groan out. “Beg me for it, my dirty boy.” My finger in his ass moves faster, and I keep my lips firmly wrapped around his dick. “Please, Cole, please let me shoot my load down your throat. I want it so bad,” he whines out in a desperate plea.
Like my head cannot fathom a 17 and a 15 year old talking like that. it's cringy and icky. Also, although we have some chapters in the past, mostly they are about lust and them being horny and doing it constantly. Like why couldn't we just have them watch a movie for once? have a conversation? show me why they love each other? what makes them special to each other? why are they attracted to each other?
That brings me to a very important question. Why couldn't Dylan be 17 as well? Either that or make them both 15 or 16 experimenting sexually without dirty talk and kinks and such.
- It felt like the author had a check list of tropes and is checking them off. Spanking✅ 69✅ Butt plug✅ Homophobic dad✅ Matching tattoos✅ Daddy kink ✅ cus all of a sudden at 75%, Dylan start calling Cole "daddy." Primal play ✅ Handcuffs ✅ Dub-Con ✅ and the list goes on and on. It gets to a point when everything feels overwhelming and messy.
- My next issue contains a minor spoiler. . . . During the present, and before they reunite, Dylan's boss is always hitting on him and he succeeds to drug him and attempts to rape him. He manage to lick him and touch him briefly before Dylan is saved. The whole incident traumatizes Dylan. Fast forward, What does Cole do as punishment cus Dylan took control the night before? HE DRUGS HIM AND HE FREE USES HIM. He does occasionally ask him to blink twice for yes, once for no.
"he won’t be back to full strength until tomorrow, at least. Plenty of time to play with my helpless little toy." “Fuck, baby. That’s it, take this fucking dick. You going to be my good little fuck doll and let me pound your ass over the hood of this car hmm?” “Such a good boy. Although, it’s not like you have a choice anyway,” I snicker.
And you would think that maybe this is done as some sort of therapy to make Dylan forget his rape incident, but there is no mention of that. Just mentions of it being punishment/revenge for Dylan taking dominance the night before. So you are telling me that the man you love get drugged and almost raped for you to drug him without his knowledge and free use him as a punishment for handcuffing you and having his ways with you? Like I understand Dark Romance, but couldn't we get revenge in a way that isn't be the same exact way of a traumatizing event that happened literally not so long ago??!!!!
- After 35% and their reunion, I swear that there is a sex scene every 2-3 pages . So 35% until the end, it's pure smut. It's sex scene after the other. NON STOP. Even Epilogue 1 is a sex scene. It's TOO much, well for me personally.
- Of course the few women mentioned in the book have to be the worse. We have Dylan's ‘house mum’ and according to him "She doesn’t exactly have a kind and generous heart. she does fuck all. She’s probably in the middle of a forty-eight-hour bender." There is also Dylan's current coworker Courtney who always hit on him and can't take no for an answer and become OTT crazy.
So, I'm not gonna rate the book (which would be a low rating tbh) cus I skimmed after 35%. Again, there are a few things I liked, but I also had major issues with different aspects of the book. We all have different reading tastes, so if the issues that bothered me doesn't affect you, then happy reading!
Some promises survive the years. Some loves survive the darkness. And some people would burn the entire world down to get back the person they lost. Promise by Shy Murdoch was an emotional, dark, and angsty MM mafia romance that pulled me in with its themes of love, loss, revenge, and second chances. Cole is a mafia heir with a homophobic ruthless father, Dylan is a foster kid who gets sucked into the hurricane obsessive love. When they were teenagers they met at a cemetery but their connection began on a Ferris wheel. Then, they’re forced to separate for their each others safety. The six-year separation was heartbreaking. Watching two people who had once been inseparable become strangers to each other, with years of pain and unanswered questions standing between them, made their story all the more compelling. The yearning was everything.
“I don’t think I could live without him by my side. I know it’s only been a few months, but I also know I’m falling in love with him.” and “My heart. My broken and disfigured excuse for a heart… starts beating again.”
I loved the potential for two characters who had once meant everything to each other to find their way back together after so much had changed. Six years was a long time to carry unresolved feelings, broken promises, and memories of someone you never truly stopped loving. Their reunion carried the weight of everything they had lost, making the second-chance romance especially emotional.
Speaking of broken promises, I understand why the author titled her book Promise because there are a dozen of promises that these precious guys make to each other throughout the book, it’s so damn sweet and heartwarming.
‘Promise to show me a good time?’
‘Don’t ever stop sneaking in here. Promise?’
‘“Trust me?” I ask. He gives me a small but determined nod. “Promise?” I press.’
‘Listen to me, I will be okay. I promise. Just stay over your side of town until you hear from me again, promise me? Me: Okay… I promise.’
‘“I’m sorry, baby,” he whispers. “I’ll tell you everything later, okay. I promise.’
‘And this is the promise I make to myself. It’s always been us against the world, but if Dylan wants to hold the world in the palm of his hand, I will make it happen’
The mafia element added another layer of darkness to everything. Seeing the protagonist become a ruthless killer for his father made the contrast between the boy he had been and the man he had become particularly interesting. It raised questions about how much of himself Cole had sacrificed to survive and whether there was anything left of the person his sweet Dlyan had once known. I also loved the darker themes woven throughout the story. The revenge plot, power struggles, morally grey characters, and dangerous loyalties added tension to the romance, while the hurt/comfort elements offered the potential for softer moments amid all the darkness. And, of course, the touch him and die energy was a massive draw. There's something irresistible about a character who might be ruthless to the rest of the world but would do absolutely anything for one person he loves.
‘If anyone were to ever hurt him, I would hunt them down, break their legs, and become the face of their deepest nightmares.’
There’s a lot of spicy scenes in this book, especially after the half way mark so if a fairly dark smutty book is what you’re after then tuck in because it gets pretty steamy.
‘“I’m sorry, baby,” he whispers. “I’ll tell you everything later, okay. I promise. But I need you so fucking bad right now. If I have to wait another second, I think I might die.”’
The pacing was steady and easy to follow, the first chapter grabbed me immediately because it really strong, diving right into it the plot. I liked the descriptive way the author writes, honestly, it seems natural when it probably shouldn’t be. The book is just under 300 pages. Perfection. Not too long, not too short. I listened to many dark romance playlists during this book, including the recommended playlist and it set the mood deliciously.
‘I have never felt like this before in my entire life. I fear that without him, I would cease to exist. For the first time in my life, I feel... loved?’
‘Honestly, every time we’re together, I can’t keep my hands off him. I don’t want to, either. He feels like... home.’
Oh and art piece just before chapter 19… it’s deliciously explicit and during the time reading it I desperately needed them to get there happily ever after and possibly another tour- you’ll know what I mean.
‘Burn me alive, my devil, so I can be yours forever.’
Again, the author has a way with words that’s almost poetic.
I liked reference to Alice and wonderland, the Cheshire cat, and maybe it’s symbolism for how crazy in love they both are. ‘We have been officially dating for a few weeks now, and in those few weeks there hasn’t been a single day that I haven’t had a smile on my face as wide as the Cheshire Cat.’
Tropes: * Dark MM mafia romance * Second-chance romance * Forced separation * Broken boys * Yearning and unresolved feelings * Hurt/comfort * Morally grey characters * Revenge and power struggles * Protective, touch him and die dynamics * Back to back spice with dub-con * Stalking * Obsessed at first meeting * Codependency * Flashbacks
Triggers: * Gore, blood, torture, and death * Abuse * Homophobic themes * Attempted SA (not MC) * Dub-con and * Drugs * Self-harm
Some scenes in this book may be sensitive to readers, please check your triggers before reading please!
At first I thought there wasn’t much development between them that they would be so obsessed with each other as described but as more flashbacks were told I began to understand, they didn’t just have that one night together, they began a secret relationship; watching tele, road trips to waterfalls they swim in, matching tattoos, etc. So, that was cute.
Maybe what’s missing is less seclusion, I feel like they’re were a world of their own, there’s not much details about their lives or they’re attachments and they’re trauma is easily overlooked especially the self harm aspect. Also, I missed the fast-paced plot in the second half as the rest of the book was just back to back smut scenes which if that’s your thing then this is the book for you. Personally, I was expecting a bit more action in second half rather than just a collection of implicit scenes but at least I got a final action scene in last two chapters and the author had a good tied-up-loose-ends ending epilogue. Also, there was a little twist at the end but I’d be lying if I said I didn’t see it coming too.
For readers who love angsty second chances, obsessive devotion, morally grey mafia characters, and romance filled with yearning, and a simplistic fast paced slightly poetic romance focussed plot then Promise was a story worth picking up.
Thank you to Shy for this ARC, I enjoyed this chaotic MM duo. Cole and Dylan are in my heart, and I’m glad they got their happily ever after.
Shy Murdoch did an impressive job with her debut novel Promise. Her writing style and voice is both easy and gripping. The book as the usual three acts; the first is heavy in storytelling. The story is good and I was sucked in right away. Told in present day and flashbacks the plot is engaging and interesting. Shy made it easy to fall in love with Dylan, the sweet baby who keeps getting the shite end of the stick (That boy is going to need serious therapy), and Cole, the son of a homophobic and vindictive Mafia boss. We read about the boys meeting as teens, falling in love and the forced apart, and Coles plan to get back to his boy.
The second act is mostly steamy spicy scene after scene when the MMCs now in their 20s are reunited. The story falls a bit away and is just used as a device for the spice. I'm not complaining the spice was hot and various, this is after all a mm romance novel.
The third act returns to heavier storytelling and finishes with a "twist" and a hard won HEA. The book finishes well and doesn't use a third act break-up for drama. These poor boys have been separated enough. There are some dark themes, so if you are sensitive to them read the trigger warnings. This is a dark and violent MM romance. I think shy did a good job with her first novel especially after learning about her from her author bio. I will absolutely pick up her next novel and see how her style evolves over time.
I absolutely love getting the chance to read an author's debut novel and reaching the end thinking about how excited I am for their next book. This is exactly how I felt about Promise. Throughout the story, I kept thinking, "Leave them alone!" while trying to remind myself that this is a HEA. The anxiety I felt at times was through the roof! I loved Cole and Dylan so much, and damn, the spice was spicing! I also hated so many characters, not because they were poorly written,the opposite. Shy had written them so well that we were meant to despise them, and trust me, I DID! I wanted to fight so many of them. LOL. And then I had a "WHAT THE FUDGE?!" moment, which I absolutely loved!
Emotion, suspense, and so much spice make for an unputdownable debut novel! I absolutely loved Cole and Dylan’s love and devotion to each other. Their agony of living 6 years apart was heartbreaking. The rollercoaster of feelings when they are reunited was really well written. It was refreshing to read a book where all the major conflict was with outside forces and not between main characters. Even if there is conflict between them, Dylan can handle it. Iykyk…the spice was so good and I loved the dominant/submissive dynamic between the two. Cole’s praise…❤️ I love them!
Dylan and Cole were just meant to be right from day one. These two never forgot about each other, they were their firsts and their lasts and it was so beautiful and heartbreaking to read their story! When they got taken apart I was so upset, but it only served to cement their love together even more and give Cole something to work towards and something for his darkness to build towards. Their adult selves were so broken without each other, they were missing another piece of their soul and it was so evident on the page, I just kept thinking hold on Dylan he’s coming. These broken boys become broken men go heal each other all over again and become each other’s light again. It’s so beautiful! The little twist, I was hoping I was right and I was! Perfect!
Thank you to the author for letting me read this as an ARC. She did not request for a review in an exchance for ARC. Everything I say here is my own opinion 🖤
I love love LOVE THIS BOOK SO MUCH 😭
It had me at MM but when it said SECOND CHANCE?!
Deadass nearly threw my phone across the room 😭
I was excited when I saw it on my FYP and when I read it... no regrets whatsoever.
Dylan and Cole are EVERYTHING 🥹 The fact that they waited for each other for SIX YEARS 😫 The writing and world building were easy to follow.
The plot and the pacing was also in my opinion good too.
I will never look at a ferris wheel the same way again 😭
I’m lucky enough to be on the street team for Shy and got to read Promise early!
Absolutely adore this concept. I really really loved the beginning of the book where the boys story really begun and watching them meet and fall in love. My heart broke when they were ripped apart.
Watching them both struggle in their own lives for years and still yearned for each other was utterly beautiful.
Their reunion was SO good!
Holy spice, if you’re into spice this ones for you!
I really liked the twist, I’m proud of myself that I caught it early on though!
Happy reading everyone 🥰
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
A story of two broken boys who yearn for each other. Both boys were just surviving in the 6 years they were apart. Cole was plotting, Dylan was literally just getting through each day. These two boys were soulmates, their connection was instant and I loved that their was never anyone else for either of them. Both of them would do anything for each other and I'm glad that they got their HEA.
First, I want to thank the lovely Shy Murdoch for the gifted eARC of Promise to read and provide my honest, spoiler free review.
My Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
My Thoughts: It’s here! It’s finally here! I’ve been waiting for so long to read Dylan and Cole’s story and let me just tell you that it did not disappoint!
Dylan and Cole have completely taken up room in my heart. Their backstory was so adorable and tragic all at the same time. However what really gets me is the fact that these two are the epitome of what I would expect true love to be. Six years….six years!!! These two were separated from one another for six years and have remained forever faithful to each other the entire time. Putting everything they have on the line all because of a promise that they made is the strongest form of love you could ever witness. To be willing to trust someone and their word for years without any contact is just a whole different level of commitment that I admired so much from Dylan and Cole.
The mafia aspect of this story was great and had a lot of moments that had me curious to know what would happen in the future. When I got towards the end of the story, I was a bit surprised at the little shock factor but honestly I wouldn’t want it to be done any other way. Cole being the most protective boyfriend in the world and Dylan being the most caring and strong willed boyfriend, willing to get his hands dirty as long as it meant him and Cole could always be together….they just truly will come for your heart if you decide to give their story a try.
Overall, this was such an enjoyable read and I’m so happy I finally had a chance to read this story. The pure love and yearning was so beautifully written that you can’t help but wonder just how much trust you would be willing to put into a promise with someone. Dylan and Cole were incredible and these babies deserved every single ounce of their happiness together and it made my heart so happy seeing their journey back to one another unfold in such a way.
An MM book with two broken boys who yearn for each other for years? ✅ Mafia? ✅ Second chance? ✅ Emotion and suspense? ✅
If you like any of these types of tropes I highly recommend this book! Shy did an amazing job at having the reader actually feel the heartache between Cole and Dylan. I was genuinely sad for these two and their 6 years of yearning. I love when a story has characters that are deeply in love and find their way back to each other!
Another aspect of the book I liked, the flashbacks. I am not usually one to like going back and forth to build up the story until present day (or when the stories collide to make it what it is) but this just worked. I didn’t have to sit and constantly think about the next present day chapter or vice versa because I was actually looking forward to both aspects. I wanted to figure out how they were separated and the full back story. I (obviously) wanted to find out what happens in the end for these two and if they were able to get their HEA. I really feel that this was done great!
The only thing I think that I was disappointed about was once they did come back together, everything seemed rushed. Randomly he’s standing in his bedroom and they immediately are just with each other. I obviously loved the reunion and was so excited for it, I just felt like there should have been a small gradual “hello” or something vs immediate. However, with that being said, I obviously know their connection and yearning was everything and they had waited 6 years for the reunion. I really liked the fact they still had that fire and love between them, I just think, personally, I would have liked it to seem not as rushed? Again, totally a me thing.
With that being said, if you really like a good emotional yearning with second chances, I highly recommend this book because it doesn’t not disappoint. The suspenseful parts and flashbacks make the story even better!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This was so so good! Dylan and Cole fell in love as teenagers they met one night and that night their bond was formed! They had a lot of stolen moments and kisses the thing is Cole’s dad a mafia boss is a POS and he catches them! He beats them both up pretty bad but he gives Cole a choice come with his forget Dylan and go with him and Cole makes Dylan a promise he will come and find him again! Heartbreaking so fast what these two boys had to go through! Cole has been working with his dad planning his demise when he approaches his dads rival! Who will take over his dads empire if he finds Dylan for him and helps him kill his dad! When Xavier made a weird face at Dylan’s last name I knew what was coming!! 6 years apart so many lonely nights for both boys so many tears so much heartache! Their reunion was so so sweet poor Dylan thought Cole was an illusion! Their promises their bond never broken! Let me tellllll you they made up for lost time with the spice!! The praise the good boy the taking control! Good mercy but the love they had for each other never ever wavered despite being apart for 6 years!! Of course Coles dad didn’t give up and they had to always be on their toes and Dylan did get hurt but they got out! When Dylan heard the devastating tale of his Mom and what Cole’s dad did was so hard but the 3 of them got what they never really had which was a family! The second epilogue made me cry!! To see them free finally and being happy and getting to just be together without worry!!! Dylan and Cole fought so damn hard for their HEA!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
“A soft, warm light had finally begun shining in my cave of darkness. Fresh air found its way into my lungs and the tension and despair washed right out of me, like a wave reclaiming shells from the shore. I knew straight away that I wanted him. I wanted to hear his voice, touch his skin, and eventually claim his heart. I fell for him instantly. And the day I realised that I loved him, my heart stopped beating for me and started beating for him.“
there aren’t enough words to describe what i feel for these boys and their story. holy bajeebus, what a ride.
i really enjoyed how the story went back & forth between the past and the present. it gave just the right amount of background without dragging the plot out or feeling rushed. what these boys go thru just to be together…it’s a lot. you must check the trigger warnings here. it’s heavy and sad and gruesome.
BUT LET ME TELL YOU WHAT-it is also so friggin’ steamy hot, sooo filthy…OMG. Cole is a million percent a Daddy and he has zero shame in his game. don’t count Dylan out though…he gets his time to shine and he makes it COUNT hehehehe!
i’m opting to not post any spoilers since this is an ARC and i want everyone to get their chance once this book drops on 11/10/26. @shymurdochauthor, babes, i’m so glad i found you and am SO PROUD of you. your debut novel and you SLAYED! thank you for letting me be a part of your journey. for letting me get to love on these boys before the rest of the world does. it means so much to me.
I think this was a good debut novel. I enjoyed both MCs and their dynamic together. The beginning started off strong- it was instantly exciting and captivating, so raw and emotional. The boys back stories were written well and really had the reader rooting for them. I also really liked the dual timeline aspect in the beginning.
I think the story lost some momentum in the middle. The spice was a bit much for me- I get they had to make up for lost time but damn they have got to be sore- in between all the banging the plot was entertaining. I think the pacing was a bit off which could also be due to the amount of spice. It felt very stop and go- from super serious and urgent “we are in danger” to extreme lust where nothing else matters except being naked. It lost some of the emotional impact that the made the beginning of the story so captivating. The dual timeline also stops somewhere in the middle of the story which I think impacts the emotional balance.
By the end of the story the pace picked up again and it became both exciting and infuriating- it was very good. I liked how everything was wrapped up and I enjoyed both epilogues. These boys really deserved their happily ever after.
I did really enjoy the premise of the story as it is a non traditional mafia romance where the MC escapes his mafia family to reunite with his love and keep him safe outside of the mafia world.
Promise is a refreshing new story introducing us to Shy’s voice. Murdoch does a great job of starting the plot and keeping the readers engaged and wanting more from the beginning. Towards the later part of the book it did feel fast-paced but it is set up as a snowball narrative so we are prepared. I just loved the characters and story so much I wanted more, but am more than satisfied with what we got. Murdoch introduces emotional writing and touched on subjects of mental health and abandonment that help us understand our characters and their actions clearly. Parts of the writing and character voices were funny and genuine.
We are introduced to Cole and Dylan and you cant help but love and root for them. Murdoch does a great job of showing us how one person can center us and save us from a hard life, giving us something to fight for when we don’t have the strength to fight for ourselves.
Cole Draven: Our protector & Savior. A dedicated man who keeps his promise no matter what.
Dylan O’shea: Secure & Loyal. Sure in himself/sexuality and feelings for Cole. Bratty, playful, needy (not a bad thing) a true fighter & Survivor.
TROPES: 💜Broken Boys 🎡Yearning 💜Mafia 🎡Second Chances 💜Touch him and Die 🎡Power stealing 💜Hurt/Comfort 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️Spiceeee
Promise by Shy Murdoch ARC Review ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🌶🌶🌶🌶 This book had me hooked right from chapter one! When I tell you I didn't want to put this book down, I mean it. Dylan & Cole were end game since the second they met, the love between them was so strong I could literally feel it. They would give and do anything for one another. My two broken boys, my heart hurt for them and everything they went through. I'm just so happy that they found each other again.
I love how possessive and protective Cole is, don't get me wrong Dylan is the same way but the way Cole protects Dylan is on a whole other level. Rightfully so after everything they've been through. I absolutely loved it when Dylan flipped the roles, that was one of my favorite scenes in the whole book. I didn't see that coming but I loved every second of it.
Ahhh, and Cole's revenge?!?!? I'll tell you right now, Dylan was not the only one questioning if he was sane! 😂☠️ I can't tell you enough how much I loved this book, it was so damn good. If you haven't read it yet you definitely need to. It's a must. 💜😍🥹
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This book was probably the first ARC I applied to. It was amazing and it’s unbelievable to think this is a debut novel. The story and the concept are beautiful. The love between Dylan and Cole is so incredibly strong and beautiful, and it’s unreal to think they waited and pined and suffered for SIX YEARS before reuniting. The chemistry between them, the yearning, the pining, Cole being the one commanding/in control and Dylan being the brat he is, chefs kiss. There were some moments that were absolutely HILARIOUS, most of them about Dylan in some of his most bratty instances~ I really liked how she handled the darker themes too. It was raw and true, like the love between the two MMCs. So yes, please do check the trigger warnings before starting this book. But if you do enjoy reading darkish themes with good banter, crazy chemistry and a heavy dose of pining and healing, this book is for you!
I’ve been impatiently waiting for this one since the day I was invited to be on Shy’s ST! And it did not disappoint!!
Two broken boys find one another as teenagers and know in their souls that they are meant for one another. Then they are ripped apart, literally, turning their world upside down. After years of building trust and gathering information, all while being heartbroken, Cole is ready to take down the enemy (his dad) and go get the other half of his heart.
Dylan has been surviving while he waits for Cole to find him. His boss is a creep and his coworker is psycho. Both seem to be oddly obsessed with him. But he belongs to Cole. And Cole is coming to reclaim him.
The angst, the banter, the spice, the yearning, the heartache…..was all worth it when they get their hard earned HEA! 💜
Thank you so much to the Author for this amazing ARC! I finished it all in one sitting! I loved getting to see them meet and fall in love when they were teenagers before they were torn apart. I HATE Cole’s father so much.. he deserved what was coming to him. My heart broke seeing how miserable they were without each other for all those years. When they finally reunited the spark never once went out, if anything the time apart made their love even stronger. They are the definition of ride or die & soulmates. They just know what the other is thinking or feeling without ever having to say anything. The spice was CRAZY HOT🥵🔥 I really loved how protective & gentle Cole was with Dylan. He grew up to be such an amazing partner despite how mistreated and abused he was growing up. I was crying so hard towards the end & was scared they were having a Romeo and Juliet ending... that’s just how strong their love is.. they simply can’t live without each other. I’m so happy they got the happy ending they deserved! 💜
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I enjoyed this book and think Shy has some really great potential as a writer! This is a fantastic first book!
I'm going to start with my negative thoughts first to get them out of the way. I personally think the characters were maybe written too young because some of the back story is this having smex. I don't enjoy reading about 15 & 17yo smex scenes so it did take away from the story for me. It was hard for me to get past. I understand teenagers do in fact do the deed, but i think she could have written about it less graphically like "He was my first" blah blah. Save the smex for the adults!
Okay onto the positive! I think this book was written well and it was easy for me to read! I enjoyed her writing style and how fast paced the book was (I know this isn't for everyone). This has everything you could want out of an MM romance book. I loved the yearning and the complete and utter obsession from both boys! I especially liked how the book would go from present to flashbacks as I think this really added to the story. It makes you want to keep reading to see how they got to where they are now.
Overall this was a good first book! I'm looking forward to what else she puts out!
Promise had me hooked right from the start. Dylan and Cole’s relationship is beautiful, until they’re forcibly separated. The writing style is utterly captivating.
I despise Cole’s father! What he does to them is utterly evil! What Cole and Dylan go through on their way to their HEA is almost unbearable. I strongly recommend reading the trigger warnings!
TROPES
💜Broken boys 🖤Yearning 💜Mafia 🖤Forced separation 💜Second chances 🖤Touch him and d!e 💜Power stealing 🖤Hurt/comfort
Forced Separation then reunited years later will always be one of my favs 😭😭😭 i loved this book so much. My angel Dyl deserved the absolute best and Cole gave it to him. Cole was such a good boyfriend. He did everything to find his way back to Dylan ☹️☹️and the way Cole always took care of him and did everything for him. The toxic codependency was perfect, one of my favs also! and the classic ending!! I loved it.
dark messy emotional full of love.this book has me feeling all sorts of feelings....rooting for the main characters the whole time..Cole and Dylan had my heart in a choke hold....Mafia elements thrown in that kept me on the edge of my seat..Coles dad is a dick.after everything they go through.they deserve their HEA .
I was luckily enough to get an ARC for this book and I was hooked from the first page!
The attention to detail and character development was incredible and i strongly recommend adding this to your TBR if it isn't already. MM Romance readers will definitely love this book.
For a debut novel I think Shy did an exceptional job and i couldn't help but fall in love with Cole and Dylan. 5 Stars
I was lucky enough to be on the ARC team for this book and I was so excited to read it. Such an awesome debut book for the author. It took me ages to word my review properly because I loved the concept of the book and the characters were excellent. It was a fun and really spicy read plus it had some of my favourite tropes in it. This story was also PACKED so much happened and it was such a wild ride.
The utter obsession between these 2 characters was written so perfectly.
However, there were some aspects of the book that didn’t work for me personally which took away from my overall enjoyment of the book. Hence the 3 star rating, I do however really look forward to seeing what Shy does next.