Steampunk doesn't need to be Victorian. This steampunk is Baghdadi.
Where mountains are forged from fallen angels. Where clockwork Djinn wear grief as armour. Where magic is of soul and prayer.
We are all touched by the threads of destiny. It is how stories are woven.
After the sky was split asunder. After the Djinn burned the sea into the crystal sands of the sa’hraa. After the footsteps of angels left valleys so deep that even their tears could not fill them. There stands a city. And a long loneliness.
Alone, the walls of Baghdad have sung for ten thousand years. A final wonder and refuge against endless storms. A brass city built by the Blessing and powered by the steam and song of the ancient Sah. Its walls weaken and its rulers grasp at immortality, beating their bodies into twisted automatons.
Alone, a scholar reads by dwindling candle and burning hope. She is cursed with a stolen gift. And a terrible truth. The Ruh, the soul, is fading from this world. Her journey will lead her through old legends and twisted schemes. But first she must marry a monster.
Alone in the vast desert sands stumbles a man, lost to memory and forgotten by fate itself. Every wish he makes damns him. Desperately, he searches for an answer. His only possessions? A relic of a forgotten world.
Born in the needlessly moody isles of the UK, Ibraheem Qureshi is a muslim fantasy writer who firmly believes that stories are a doorway to the soul. So why not add a dragon or two to make things interesting?
FREE hand drawn art, short stories and lore drops when you sign up to Ibraheem Qureshi's mailing list on: https://ibraheemqureshiauthor.com/
This is a wonderful book. The world building is fascinating, the characters are flawed but real and there is genuine emotional payoff. I can’t wait for the next book in this series! This man is a first-rate storyteller. I will be thinking about all the layers of this narrative for quite a while.
One of the best Fantasies I’ve ever read!! Please please release the sequels asap😭😭😭
Book is Of Soul and Steam by Ibraheem Qureshi. As a fantasy book, it checks out all my list of favourites, political intrigue, hint of romance, betrayal, found family and lots of descriptive world building. It is quite a big book and every page was actively worth it.
The next part is a guide to the book with minor spoilers (no spoiling of the plot line or the ending)…uou can skip to the next part if you want to avoid that.
A Guide
This book revolves around the city of Baghdad where automatons, people, djinn and many Arab mythical creatures exist side by side. The city is ruled by a descendant of a powerful ruler, whose whereabouts are not presently known. The aristocracy are the ruler-adjacent Sayyidi who like any other elite class, have weird parties and live in extreme affluence. The scholar class of Sah with their (soul) ruh magic was purged by the Sayyidi and the Yol Adelai (Soldier regimens). Similar fate has occured for knowledge seeking Mazari as well. The commoners or Falah are four tribes, Yemi, Lebani, Quori and Azumi work in factories, farms, as lodestone collectors or leapers (lodestones power the machinery of basically everything) and every other job required.
It follows a dual-pov of Esen (origins unknown) with a side- kick rock ( who has endless sarcasm btw) and a magical book for some reason wants to reach Baghdad. He is lost without many memories who is saved (literally and metaphorically) from a large endless desert by Ayber, a ‘leaper’ while looking for lodestones. They reach Baghdad and Esen is instantly disappointed by what the city has become. He survives by wishes that are granted by the rock and things get better and worse (!!!!!)
Second pov is of Hayla who I adored completely. She is a ‘Mazari’, seeker of knowledge and one of the last of her kind. She searches for answers about the Library of Baghdad from where she seeks answers to fix the system in Baghdad. She is saved from a monster 👀 by Jazari, a sayyidi and they work together to try to find out about the location of the lost library.
The Characters Oh my days, the characters are amazing. I immediately rooted for Hayla and Esen and hopefully their paths cross (please make it happen quickly !!!🥲)
Esen is tough and lost and brave and stupid as his rock reminds him often, but how could i not fallen for this short king😉 Him with Ashy was the best of the best. His background is bit strange but I think there are some strategically placed Easter eggs which I’m hoping will be taken up in the series.
Ayber is probably the sweetest person in this book as a whole after Ashy of course. He is probably my most favourite person with disability in a book ever. He is so full of hope in a dark and dying world with a lot of loss. How he smiles with children and is kind to everyone is a complete mystery to me. I hope he features in the next series more and i guess there is a lot of heart break to come.
Hayla, Hayla, Hayla A girl after my own soul. Her search for knowledge and her love brings me so much envy. Portrayal of sadness and guilt by her character is probably one of the best i have ever seen in fiction, especially fantasy where this emotion is usually neglected. She is recruited by Jazari after he saves her. She is resourceful and gifted in ‘reading’ ruh (soul).
Jazari My shayla Jazari, will you break my heart? His favourite colour is white😭😭 I wish i could have recognized you for the man you are early on. This man tries so much, so much that we cannot fathom how deep this guy is.
The characters do not feel flat but are well rounded individuals, be it Hafsah, Bilal, Haroon, the royalty🥸 (thats all the respect they deserve). They read like people who do want to live peacefully but within their own ideas of peace.
The writing and language
The descriptions are very detailed especially of the sights, surroundings, stories and the lore. It feels so rich and immersive and real. It took some time to reach to the level of this writing because commonly used words like sun = shams Earth = aerde Ays = moons Ruh = soul
This was surprising and yet my knowledge of arabic and patience came through. I think a glossary for this book will be useful especially for readers of a wider audience who read over multiple days and have no connection towards west asia or west asian languages.
It was difficult to start and surprisingly easy to continue because let me reiterate, it is an amazing book and is well written. I found some punctuation errors and at one place i think your and you’re switched but otherwise no hitches throughout the story and it’s completely harmless so wont deter from the reading experience. It does start as a slow pacing but for me, the world it showed was interesting enough to continue on.
Recommendations and Rating I would recommend everyone to buy this book but especially if they are interested in long running plots and political intrigue. 4.75/5 stars rounded to 5.
I will be very much looking forward to the sequels and whatever books this author writes. Truly loved this
This review is NOT sponsored. Unbiased review based on ARC provided via BookFunnel
The End Thank you for reading my review…Do let me know if there are any perspectives I missed. I love discussing books and learning more so pls tell me if there are any errors in my review and how i can improve on writing more of these… If you found this helpful, also i would love to have this liked🫠
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I cannot believe this is Ibraheem Qureshi's debut novel. It felt like he picked me up by the neck, swung me around over his head, slammed me down onto a soft comfy couch, gave me a hug, patted my head, and handed me a cup of chai. This book is a wild, wild ride. The worldbuilding, characters, and unexpected emotional depth completely pulled me in. (Full review below. No Spoilers.) Series: Incomplete (Book 1) Spoilers: None Genre: Fantasy | Steampunk Subgenre: Islamic-Infused Steampunk | Desert Fantasy Overall: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Maturity: Mature Spice: 🌶️🌶️ Violence: 🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪 The Terrain: Deeply Philosophical Magic | Rich Worldbuilding | Dark Themes | Adventure | Forced Alliance | Enemy to Allies | Quest/Rescue | Save the World | Cursed Power | Stolen Gifts | Political Intrigue | Class Warfare Story Review: I cannot believe this is Ibraheem Qureshi’s debut novel. It felt like he picked me up by the neck, swung me around over his head, slammed me down onto a soft comfy couch, gave me a hug, patted my head, and handed me a cup of chai. This book is a wild, wild ride. The story takes place in a steampunk version of Baghdad. The gods have torn the sky and sea asunder, and the earth is infiltrated by Djinn who burn the sea and leave the world a barren desert. We get the POV of two main characters. There is Esen, a man lost, wandering through the desert with his smartass, talking rock. We follow him into the city where he makes a few friends and more than a few enemies, and finds another very special little surprise along the way. I am convinced this man is more than he knows and in time, he, and we, will find out who he really is. Then we have Hayla, a young woman with a special talent and thirst for knowledge that ends up tying her to Jazari, a man who would be expected to destroy someone like Hayla, and more specifically, because of the talent she carries. Hayla is brash, brave, smart, and clearly destined for way more than she ever dreamed. I cannot wait to see where they end up in the next book. Jazari is not entirely human - but as his story unfolds he certainly feels more human than any of his ilk. We watch each of these characters journey towards the thing they most yearn for, but the journey is fraught with lies, betrayal, violence, and treachery from friend and foe. This book ends on a cliffhanger. Because Ibraheem Qureshi is a Muslim fantasy writer, some of the terms he uses may not be well known to those who are unfamiliar with that vernacular. However, with patience, you will be able to figure out, or he will tell you, what each is, and like me, you’ll learn something new. This book really touched me in a way I had not expected. There is so much violence perpetrated by those in power, but ordinary people just keep being extraordinary. Content Warnings: Violence and Murder | Physical Abuse and Torture | Suicide and Self-Harm | Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder | Disordered Eating | Alcoholism and Substance Abuse Disclosure(s): Advanced Reader Copy Reviewer(s): Ilse V. Stern
the fact that Of Soul and Steam is Ibraheem Qureshi's debut novel says a lot about their potential: it knows no bounds.
I was obsessed with this book from the beginning to the end. the worldbuilding is complex and fascinating, the scenery vivid and filled with characters who are so deeply human (with a spice of magic, of course, but you know what I mean). I felt their wants as intensely as if they were my own, and I cannot wait to see where this story goes next.
this was one of my favourite books I have ever had the privilege to read in advance. thank you so much to the author for providing me with an ARC copy! I will definitely need a paperback for my shelf.
This steampunk fantasy with soul magic that can be seen by few and manipulated by even fewer, in a world where the elite choose to replace their body parts with machinery, while the regular falah tribes have to risk their lives in the deserts outside of the mechanical moving walls of Baghdad, is an epic tale of the search for knowledge, the injustices of the world and the greed of human kind.
Our female protagonist Hayla is reluctantly bound to her broody side-kick in the quest for the lost library that unlocks the mysteries of the Ruh - the soul magic.
Esen, the grumpy loner, and his sarcastic talking rock are only concerned about escaping the desert Djinn who’ll eat your soul, when he finds himself becoming part of a community.
We follow these very different characters point of views and separate trials and tribulations throughout the desert, the luscious inner part of Baghdad, and everything inbetween.
There are mechanical birds and butterflies, the world building is rich and lush, and the characters feel real, nuanced and three-dimensional.
I’m so impressed by this whole story and convinced that there is a lot hidden in the background that I will immediately be re-reading it.
I implore everyone to read it, so I can start discussing fan theories asap!!!
"The cogs remember what the flesh forgets, but it is the Ruh that turns the wheel."
First of all, a huge thank you to the author for giving me the chance to read this as my very first ARC, it was such a memorable experience to be part of the early reading journey🥰🥰
The concept behind Of Soul and Steam is just incredible. A clockwork, steampunk Baghdad mixed with Middle Eastern mythology? Brilliant. The world feels alive, grand, and tense all at once. What really stood out to me was the story and the magic system, they felt so unique, unlike anything I've come across in other fantasy books. Blending steam engines and lodestones with soul energy (Ruh) was such a creative touch that felt totally fresh.
"A bird built of clockwork may fly, but it does not know why it sings until the storm strikes."
I also really enjoyed the characters, especially the talking rock (such great banter!), Esen, Hayla, and Jazari. I have to admit, I secretly hoped for a bit more romance between Hayla and Jazari, but watching their dynamic and quiet bond develop was still really fun to follow.
What touched me the most, though, was little Aisha and her relationship with Esen. Seeing him step into this unexpected "father" role was so moving. Their emotional connection is deeply complicated, it’s not just a protector taking in an orphan; it’s tangled up in the lingering memories, grief, and fierce maternal instincts of her mother’s sacrificed Ruh echoing inside his head. Watching him wrestle with those foreign feelings while genuinely caring for this little girl gave the story so much heart. Oh I love Grumpy Esen🥰
That being said, it wasn't an easy read all the way through. Two things tripped me up:
No glossary for all the new terms: Early on, I felt pretty lost. There are so many unfamiliar words and made-up terms thrown at you at once without an easy guide to check, so it took extra effort just to follow what was happening. But the author said that he will insert them on the date release book. I’m happy to hear that and definitely will have to put this book on the very top of my endless wishlist😀😀
Vague character goals at the start: We don't get much backstory early on, so for a good chunk of the book, it was hard to tell what the characters were actually trying to achieve.
Still, once the plot picked up and I got used to the world, it turned into such a fun and satisfying ride. Jumping on the sliding Avlu gates or riding on the thunder fa’aras and get stuck in the middle Qa’waat storms/the quartz tempest or just witnessing the magnificent Djinn transform the body shape, or watching the clockwork animals wandering on your garden? Ooh, it was so satisfying I want to have them pictured/animated!!
I really hope this gets an official physical release soon! I’d love to buy a print copy, especially if it comes with a glossary, maps, and illustrations drawn by the author. And I honestly can’t wait for book two, I need to know what happens to Hayla and Esen next!
Let me start by saying like 90% of whatever criticism I have is about editing and proofreading. Also, I hope the fans of steampunk and fantasy from all walks of life enjoy this book, but as a Muslim who used to study Arabic, I had the ‘I understood that reference’ quote pop up in my head now and then, and it really elevated the entire experience. So I am going to be biased, but man, this book needs a glossary. It took me a minute to realise ‘shams’ meant the sun and not the plural for ‘sham’.
I wasn’t hooked immediately, but the ambition of this story was impressive from the get-go. The author uses monotheism in his worldbuilding while avoiding preaching to his audience and ultimately focusing on the themes of power, solidarity, greed, and the pursuit of knowledge. There is some risk in making the two main characters not only completely separate from each other, but also people with murky at best backstories, and yet I got on board with them quickly because they kept making decisions that retained my interest. We are basically dropped in the middle of the desert with someone who needs to figure it out as they go, and honestly, same, Esen. Still, I couldn’t get used to the protagonists talking to themselves like they’re anime characters, and I was glad when that quirk stopped being so noticeable. Other than that, I loved the compromises they had to make between the clarity of their understanding of good and evil and the moral ambiguity of their actions.
It makes sense that the author is an artist because the language is incredibly visual. Even when I didn’t understand what was going on I could still imagine the scenery and it looked stunning. And the plot kept me on my toes because at no point was I sure what was about to happen next (except maybe for the romance part, but oh well, why rediscover the wheel).
It’s not all rainbows, though. I wouldn’t hold an indie self-published book to the same standard as a traditionally published one with a long list of editors and beta readers, but God, I wished someone took a cold, emotionless look at this text (and I hope someone actually has before its official release). There were mistakes easy to overlook in writing but glaringly obvious when you read it for the first time, the writing, while poetic and witty, had some anachronistic bits like ‘emotional investment’ that aren’t terrible in and of themselves but somewhat date the text, and there were repetitions and inconsistencies that don’t let this book shine on the level it deserves.
Speaking more broadly, the entire story could use some critical treatment to be more precise in its themes. I’m still not sure exactly how finding the library would fix the city, but hey, I’m all for my personal friend Hayla binta Finawul achieving all her goals. I could feel the quality of writing improving as the story progresses, but there’s a reason we need editors. To be fair though, it’s a widespread problem I’ve been observing more and more.
I felt like the ending was a little too abrupt while also dragging its feet a little. Still, I am now firmly on this fa’aras and looking forward to finding out where this story goes. And there better be some explanation about who Hayla because I still don’t get that one.
I received an Advanced Readers Copy from the author. I didn't finish this book for now but am rating it 4 stars because I think I will really enjoy it later. Right now, there are a lot of unfamiliar terms making the story confusing and I don't have time to dedicate to learning them. But, so far it's a very interesting adventure. From my understanding the last of civilization is in Baghdad and one young woman is trying to hold reality together. I might be misunderstanding. I definitely plan to reread this book and finish at a later date.
Genuinely not sure how I could even sum up such an incredible adventure and powerful prose, silly banter, and an incredibly diverse cast of characters and story. At first, it was a little hard to understand as you are thrown into such a whirling expanse of Djinn and magic, wishes, great mechanical beasts, and a complicated social order. But, as the dual perspectives flesh out, the song behind the words and the mysteries become an insatiable need to explore further.
This felt like a kind of traditional historical or folkloric epic, set in an unimaginable expanse of class disparity, where two characters must - on their own paths - find a way to survive cruelty, injustice, power, greed, and twisted souls in order to save what good is left in their hearts. This world sings a song of love, regret, agony, and most importantly - hope. Can these two sides of the same coin weave a path through magic that leads to salvation? Or will they fall prey to the tricks and trials of ancient beasts?
Absolutely a 5 star experience, and where the story ended for now was incredibly perfect and well tied up. The suspense is there, but I feel content and excited to see where these adventures and mysteries lead us to next time.
Thank you to the author for trusting me with an ARC! This will be a series I want on my physical shelf for life.
This book was a fantastic read. This is my first ARC review. Being a small part of this book’s journey is an honor. Thank you.
A wonderful debut novel by Ibraheem Qurreshi. I’m giving this book a 4.75 star rating for a few reasons.
1.) The characters each have their own personalities, flaws, motives, and quirks making each of their progressions through the story feel real and grounded in such a magical world. In just this one book the characters evolved so much, and I look forward to seeing how much more they will develop-- and also meeting some new ones (side-eyeing the secret penpal! Who is it??).
2.) I loved the setting of this book. The magic system is unique and rich, and I cannot wait to see how Hayla unlocks her full potential! The weight of humanity in all its ugliness and glory is almost palpable as you flip the pages. It is such a complex world that it took a couple chapters to really start to understand the threads of the story, but Ibraheem did a wonderful job of weaving them together in a way that made it impossible to stop reading. The dual perspectives I think did this so perfectly.
3.) What an ending! Quite the cliff hanger - I couldn’t put the book down in the last several chapters, the call of the Ruh was too strong to resist. I felt the full range of emotions as I read through this story, from amusement, outrage, to grief. As a parent, Esen’s struggle directly pulls at my heart strings - as a mother I would have put no less a hold on his heart to save my daughter. The connection building between Hayla and Jazari is tentative, heartwarming, and so full of potential. I must read the next book!
My only negative comment is that I would love a glossary, it took a while for me to understand a few phrases throughout the book. From what I understand, that is already on the books (forgive the pun)! And as such, it does not merit the loss of a star for me. I definitely want to purchase a physical copy for the amazing art that I have had the privilege to get a sneak peak of <3.
I loved many aspects of the story. The concept is wonderful and unique - a steampunk Arabic fantasy!
As a non-Arabic speaker, I enjoyed the discovery of (and my interpretation of) concepts like Ruh and who the Sah were, among many other words foreign to me. Most of the names and groups were evident enough based on context, and I appreciated how little world exposition/info dumping there was. Throw me into the action and I’ll figure it out!
The characters were unique, well developed, and appealing in ways that show the author’s skills well. Add to that the fantastic descriptions, wildly creative world building, and plenty of genuine humor, and we have a unique and engaging epic that I’ll look forward to continuing!
As others have noted, the book would benefit from another line-level editing pass.
Wow! What an incredible and immersive world Qureshi has created. If you love steampunk but have felt stagnant in the typically Western-centric, Victorian-era settings, you need to give this a try. Set in Baghdad, during an unspecified time, this setting is firmly West Asian and Islamic in aesthetics and practices. We follow two characters as they navigate this world and see both the poor underbelly and rich upper crust of Baghdad. Their stories are firmly separated by motivations, but the two weave together neatly as they both interact with the unfeeling Qa’waat and the very deeply emotional Ruh that binds the world. Qureshi gives us just enough of a taste of the rich history the city has to intrigue and enrapture us. After reading Book 1 I am very excited and waiting with anticipation for Book 2.
I received an advance reader copy from the author.
Steampunk Baghdad. Giant storms rage outside of the city walls and Djinn roam the storm looking for souls. A scholar with a gift and a man with a talking rock both looking for answers.
The world is intricate and wondrous, the main characters are relatable and flawed in the best way. The banter between characters is top notch, I laughed and cried within the very same chapter.
Qureshi's writing is vibrant and wildly engaging. Some of the terminology/mythos was unfamiliar to me but after a quick search and more context in the story this quickly became a non-issue.
It's blood and bone, metal and steam, and the Ruh that runs through it all. I cannot wait to visit this world again.
This is an ARC review There are not enough stars in the universe to rate this book highly enough. Its as intricate and beautiful as the clockwork creatures imagined within its pages. Each character is woven together like cogs themselves. The prose is beyond beautiful and there were times it made me sit back just to take a moment to take it all in. Esen and Hayla are incredibly complex and such amazingly enjoyable characters. Though I am biased toward Hayla herself, her personality brings me so much joy. Esen's grumpiness is beyond relatable. And the talking rock itself is a wonderful addition to this vibrant cast of characters. I am beyond excited to see where this story takes us next.
Wow. I have yet to read a story that’s anything like Of Soul And Steam. It is captivating right from the beginning, keeping you want to read more. ( If a sarcastic talking rock doesn’t want you to read even more I don’t know what to tell you..)
Some terms might make it a bit difficult to get through at first, as they might sound unfamiliar. But the moment you understand, which the author doesn’t take long to explain by the way, you are swept in a story full of adventure and soul in a world that doesn’t see everyone as equal.
This book truly makes me want to read more of this author.
I think the debut novel is a bold interpretation of an underrepresented form of folklore and mythology in Western literature. I enjoyed the pacing and character development of the two alternating protagonists, but found the unfamiliar language to be an impediment to my immersion. I plan to correct this on a second read through, where I can focus more on the machinations of the story and less upon definitions and in-setting words. I look forward to the next piece in the series!
I was lucky enough to be chosen as part of the group reading the ARC of Of Soul and Steam. It is magnificent! Ibraheem Qureshi has created a world that made me smile, laugh, rage, and almost cry. It is one I hope to get to visit many more times. I never even knew I needed Muslim steampunk, but now I can't imagine a literary world without it. Of Soul and Steam is one of the absolute most original additions to the fantasy world since Evan Winter's The Rage of Dragons or Blood at the Root by LaDarrion Williams. However good you think it is, you'll almost certainly be wrong...it's better.
This was such a refreshing read! I’m always a fan of multiple POVs and the storytelling was crafted so well. The main characters are so witty and stubborn(respectfully) which definitely added to my investment in the story. It’s great being exposed to other cultures so adding a fantasy element to that is so exciting and interesting. This was a great read and I would love to see what else this author writes!
(I was given an Advanced Copy to review.) This book is so much fun! And refreshing, because of the glorious, lush descriptions, punctuated by witty banter (and a deeply cynical rock), and steadily developed worldbuilding. It didn't take long to decipher the colloquial language of the world, and there is a wonderfully lyrical quality to the writing. The characters were intriguing, and their development was believable. I'm looking forward to reading more of Qureshi's work.
This book is a really fun journey with a great weaving plot and intricate worldbuilding, and I want artwork of steampunk Baghdad so badly. I felt like this book really started to hit its stride a third of the way in, and I couldn’t put it down after that.
The bantering tone didn’t always land for me, but I think it kept the story balanced with lightheartedness. I definitely hope to read more from Qureshi!
Oh my, what an exciting journey! I don’t want to spoil too much, but this threw me into a fantasy world I’ve not yet experienced. I had the absolute privilege of getting an ARC from the author and I enjoyed the book completely. The characters are complicated but lovable, the story left me wanting more and the magic system was like a breath of fresh air. Highly recommend, especially in a cold German winter, when you’re missing the sun. ☀️🧞🏜️
What an absolute blast! An incredible romp through everything from magic desert storms to political intrigue to steam powered train-worms. I’m excited to see what comes next from Ibraheem Qureshi, his prose and world building in his debut novel are leaps and bounds better than some established authors.
I received an Advanced Readers Copy from the author and I am glad I did. This an engrossing book A unique fantasy book, full of mythology and poetry. I don't want to go into much detail about the plot, because I think it's one of those books you have to discover for yourself, but I do recommend that you read it if you love fantasy with steampunk elements and complex magical systems.
Loved it! The world-building, interesting characters, and a fascinating combination of setting and steampunk make this one an enthralling fantasy, and excellent work for a first novel from this author. I hope we get to see even more in sequels!
Of Soul and Steam sounds like a fascinating fantasy adventure filled with rich world-building, ancient legends, magical mysteries, and unforgettable characters. The imaginative vision of a brass city inspired by Baghdad, combined with djinn, destiny, and a mysterious talking rock, makes this story especially intriguing. I love the originality of the concept and the sense of adventure promised by the description. This looks like a wonderful read for fans of epic fantasy and immersive storytelling. I’m looking forward to discovering more of this unique world
The world building is immaculate. The feel. The drama. The language (oh, language - we'll come back to you). The people. The machinery. The politics. Just... chef's kiss. If you are looking for a fresh, intricate and colourful setting - Of Soul and Steam is 100% for you. I just want more of this world. More of the culture. More of the worker class. How did everyone get this way?! Incredible.
The characters are fantastic. It's told from a dual perspective: Hayla is a young scholar, trying to find a secret; Esen is.. lost in the desert with a talking rock. I related more to Hayla's journey and was intrigued by her forced marriage (don't worry, no forced anything else!!) to Jazari, who himself is an incredibly complex character. Esen... I found his character took a lot more time to develop, particularly what he really wanted. But the last 30% of the book - yes! He figures out a lot.
The writing is exceptional... so many times I stopped and reread a phrase several times, just for the sheer poetry of the language.
I did hit a couple of snags.
Language. There are a lot of new terms, political factions, races, bits of history, etc and I sometimes found myself working very hard to puzzle them out. And I wasn't always successful. So there were times when my eyes skimmed passages to GET TO THE PLOT because at least I mostly understood what was happening. The author has indicated that there will be a glossary in the published version which I think will help. A lot of things were eventually evident because of context but there were some times I would have liked to flip to the back and look something up.
Clear character goals and motivations. As mentioned, I understood what was happening with Hayla but Esen, not as much, which made me a little impatient. He meets some of the best characters in the book and they help fill out his chapters, but I really didn't get what he was about until the last 1/3 or so. I'm glad I stuck with it - his evolution is really powerful - but I can see how some readers might get frustrated.
Congrats to Ibraheem Qureshi on his debut novel! And many thanks for letting me read an ARC! Of Soul and Steam was a little out of my usual reading sphere, but I really did enjoy it. Warning, it ends on a couple of cliffhangers - so hopefully Qureshi will release the next one soon.
In Of Soul and Steam, the author creates a vivid and rich steampunk world that looks very different than the ubiquitous Victorian setting associated with the genre. Instead the reader is placed in a version of Baghdad with clockwork walls, steam-powered (what I will call) land ships, magic, a rigid social hierarchy, body mods, and a talking rock. The setting feels real, breathing and cohesive.
The author not only turns the steampunk aesthetic on its ear, but addresses the criticism that steampunk has no depth beyond being an aesthetic. They accomplish this feat by not paying short shrift to the punk aspect, subtly interweaving questions around conformity, classism, and cultural identity.
The two main characters, Essen and Hayla have depth and allow the reader to experience the world crafted from two very different perspectives. While I I won’t claim to have fallen in love with them I did find them interesting and engaging.
As for where I think this work falls short, it is how the world is presented to the reader. I feel for all the expansiveness of the world building, I didn’t get a fundamental understanding of most if any of it. It didn’t affect my understanding or enjoyment of the story however. To be fair this probably leans into my preferences as a reader rather than any type of objective critique. And it could very well be that this understanding will come in subsequent works in the series. The only other thing of note for me was that the two main plot lines of the main characters are completely separate. Something other than them occurring in the same place to tie them together, if loosely would have been nice.
All in all if you’re looking for a steampunk read that stands out, I don’t think this will disappoint.
I did receive this book as an ARC from the author in exchange for an honest review; thank you to the author.
This was written in such a gorgeous manner and the story was told beautifully. I honestly fell in love with it from the prologue. From my perspective, and in the best way possible, this almost felt like being a fly on a wall of a DND campaign. I enjoyed all the characters and perspectives we got, their dynamics, and the overall storyline as a whole. I also really love how the author infused Islamic mythos and folklore into this, and it was very interesting to follow. I am so happy to have found a new five star read to add to my list this year!
Complex and dynamic fantasy, turning the genre of steampunk fantasy right on its head!
This book is a masterpiece; it was an honour to sit and read the ARC. The beauty of the language and cultural appreciation were refreshing and enigmatic. I learned so many new words and developed a newfound appreciation for fantasy books steeped in history and beliefs beyond the Western world. I always try to read diversely, but this book really moved me in ways others haven't before.
It's decadent, well thought out, and just a joy to read! I highly recommend it!!
Arc review Awesome multi-layered steam punk style story told from 2 perspectives. Both just trying to survive, both gifted. Djinn magic, power struggles. Ancient lost magic. This story if full of life and death.