This is the easiest 5 star review I've ever given. What a wonderful and humane book. It advertises itself as YA, but all that really means is that the narrator is an adolescent, and there are plenty of "adult" literary books that feature the same. If no one told me this is a YA book I would have never called it one. What it is is a smart and deeply sympathetic presentation of what it is like to grow up "different" in an extremely conservative, Pentecostal, small town Arkansas millieu. The narrator of the book, Casper Quinn, tries to go along and not stand out like a sore thumb, but he can't help himself. He's simply too different, both on the outside and inside, but mostly on the inside. His best friend Brant Mitchell is different too, as it turns out, although it is much harder to tell with Brant, as he plays the role of the earnest, clean cut, devoted young Christian boy to perfection. No one in town, not even Brant and Casper's girlfriends, suspect how different the boys are. Well, actually, the girls do suspect it (but they're not sure of it).
But there's also another little lingering problem, suggested by a back cover blurb that explains that Brant Mitchell has "two secrets." This second secret is subtly rendered by the author, and I think most readers won't figure it out in advance, although in full disclosure I should admit that I had it figured out almost immediately. So possibly others will too. I won't lay a big spolier inside this review, so just trust me that the second secret is intriguing, has been amply if subtly prepared by the author, and has important metaphorical ramifications for the book. How's that for a tease? The other element to point out is that the time period of the book is the summer of 2012, when the Chic-fil-A/homosexuality controversy was at its height and conservative Christians everywhere in America were flocking (no pun intended) to the restaurant chain to buy and eat as much of its chicken as possible. It all amounted to ridiculous grandstanding, rightly lampooned by Night in his novel; but at the same time, the very vocal and physical support by Casper's church for the restaurant chain puts Casper in a complete moral quandary. I think readers will enjoy see what Casper does as a result, when the mental pressure really cranks up.
This is a superb book, brilliantly written and effectively characterized. Most of all, it's deeply sympathetic--toward everyone. It's a mark of Night's refined sensibility--both as a writer and as a person--that readers won't and shouldn't hate the Pentecostal characters, even though Night is not on their side. Not at all. Not even a little bit.