Both Buddhism and dance invite the practitioner into present-moment embodiment. The rise of Western Buddhism, sacred dance and dance/movement therapy, along with the mindfulness meditation boom, has created opportunities for Buddhism to inform dance aesthetics and for Buddhist practice to be shaped by dance.
This collection of new essays documents the innovative work being done at the intersection of Buddhism and dance. The contributors--scholars, choreographers and Buddhist masters--discuss movement, performance, ritual and theory, among other topics. The final section provides a variety of guided practices.
Articles were of course uneven. Some 5* articles to re-engage: 65-71 Horan/5rhythms; 120-127 (see 130-2 also): Teachers/cadre/facilitation team of ongoing rx of built trust and affection necessary to create conditions for larger, broader, less-persistent sangha. ---- 13 [...] all sensory fields are commonly used in Buddhism to discover not the nature of the object but the nature of the perceiving subject. [...] A meditation that finds expression in mindfulness of the body is not concerned with an objective knowledge, but rather [...] with a way to know oneself deeply and be free. 14 We open to discovery of our essence when the dichotomy of body-mind is dropped. [...] we explore movement to discover the nature of awareness. 15 What does it mean to sit or walk for fifteen minutes, or for an hour, from the point of view of being present? 24 [...] incarcerated men we visit may not be used to sitting quietly and still for any length of time, so we often start out using some kind of movement [...] Men, in my opinion, may be [...] less used to paying attention to bodily sensations-- so using movement as a mindfulness practice also trains their awareness of sensations in different parts of the body. [...] Using mindful movement, we direct their attention to the somatic experience [...] We remind the men to come back to the physical sensations when they find themselves thinking about something else. In this way, we begin to introduce emotion regulation through choosing not to follow a particular train of thought and instead to intentionally focus on the physical sensation of the movement were engaged in. 25 Developing internal awareness also helps [...] We can learn just to attend to the sensations as they arise without needing them to be different. [...] This helps us to develop some tolerance capacity for learning to still the body and mind. 26 Beyond supporting general well being, mindful movement can also be a powerful and skillful means toward developing the stability of mind leading to awakening. 29 The more I immersed myself into my bodily and sensory experience, the more states of non-identification with them became predominant [...]. I deeply understood they were not "mine" to have. [...] the suffering, I was beginning to understand was therefore inherently universal. Spontaneously, upon grasping these realizations, endless waves of compassion arose within me, for not only my own misery but also for the misery of the entire human race. 39 Our current world demands new kinds of Dharma, new Dharma doors. I believe movement to be one of those doors. 42 [...] I am so busy in my thoughts that I miss out on opportunities to be kind to myself and to others. [...] The American Dance Therapy Association defines dance therapy as "the psychotherapeutic use of movement as a process which furthers the emotional, physical, and cognitive integration of the individual." 49 When a simple, everyday movement becomes imbued with feeling, it [...] becomes the dance of our shared humanity, which cuts across the isolation that is the hallmark of so much mental illness and disease. 60 Witnessing the life and death of a patterned habitual story line is an enlightening experience. [...] Attention notices the reactivity in the first place and then witnesses the pattern's entire life-death cycle. We are left with naturally arising qualities of mind which inspire true caring for countless other beings. These qualities[...]: love, compassion, joy and equanimity. Discovering such remarkable qualities arising naturally in the course of a dance is both profound and very ordinary. 62 Tuning is based on constructing dances in space and exposes communication between the dancers. The practice includes using verbal calls [...] These calls and actions reveal the dance-making desires of the collaborators, something that usually remains mysterious and vague during dance improvisations. [...] By attending to our sensations and feelings, we can discover our own ethical discipline. We can bow to our mistakes and begin again. 63 Transcendent effort is remembering that forgetting is not something we can control. [...] The moment of remembering is a cause for celebration, no matter what. [...] The idea of moving is disembodied and has a quality of ambition. Sensed moving is embodied with awareness flowing throughout the body and is related to curiosity. 65 Meditative stillness and movement inform each other, and are cathartic in combination. [...] Rumi [...] suggested that in order to fully understand stillness, one must dance. 66 If our happiness is based on conditions, as soon as the conditions change, so then does our happiness. If one learns how to find happiness beyond causes and conditions, then one can find lasting peace. 67 Gabrielle [...] inspired us to move our feet and land in our heart. 68 The first rhythm is Flowing. This is the yin energy, the aspect of our nature that knows how to receive. The second rhythm is Staccato, the yang energy. This is the aspect of our nature that gives. The third rhythm is Chaos. This is the holy union of the first two rhythms. Chaos allows us to break open and surrender. Chaos moves us and naturally delivers us into the state of Lyrical, the fourth rhythm. Lyrical is a state of being in which everything is free to reform, shape-shift, morph, and change. Lyrical empties us unto the fifth rhythm, Stillness. Stillness is the state of being that allows us to integrate and unify. [...] It is here that one can experience connection to oneness in ourselves, each other, the sangha, and the divine. [...] To learn how to dance through life with grace is a sacred task that we are entrusted with at birth. 69 The next step for me came in the form of practicing the Brahma Viharas in motion. It is here that practitioners can open the gateway of the body for the heart and mind to follow. These practices have acted as a poultice to the wounds of my heart. I see them as the antidotes to suffering. [Try!] [...] The path of the 5Rhythms is also, literally and physically a process of purification. When the body moves, it sweats. [...] We are excavating the past so we can live fully in the present. 71 My job is to help people integrate their past and re-establish a safe and loving relationship to their body. In some ways it is like seducing the mind back into the body from wherever it had to go to survive. [...] As a person begins to move and sweat, presence is established in the body. The result of embodied presence is a calming of the mind and the nervous system. Once a person has stabilized, they can find a sense of safety. If we begin here, then success in meditation is possible. [...] Both maps of Dharma and Rhythms give us directions out of isolation and into connection. They show us how to transform fear into fearlessness and anger into forgiveness. Forgiveness, in turn, can bring lessons on compassion. [...] An expanded capacity to be with my own vulnerability has aroused in me an increased compassion for others. [...] Remember it is not enough to just sit. It is not enough to just dance. Establish a mindful balance between these two poles. Commit to the discipline of your practice. Keep showing up to do the work. 83 What does it mean to bring a dance practice to the core of an attempt to live a dharma life? 85 Contact Improvisation eventually worked its way into the heart of my movement practice. [...] the strong sangha-like community that has formed around this modality to the meditative practices within it, like the "small dance." 87 In dancing Contact Improvisation, a deeper connection with others is always available and one is focusing on a perceptual field that is always changing. For me, being ready for connection and ready for change in this way can be an expression of Right View. [...] Mindfulness must be engaged in point-of-contact connectivity, as well as the constantly changing subject-to-subject relationship. Beyond mindfulness of the body, mindfulness of connectivity and change can open up an immediate experience of impermanence and lack of being a separate self. All this requires attending to a broader field of experience [...] Sangharakshita [...] "The ego does not really exist; it is not a thing but a thought; not a metaphysical entity but an epistemological error." 89 In both vipassana practice and contact dance, experience is constantly arising and passing away, with no fixed self to grasp at it, exposing the lie of the "epistemological error" that is the ego project. 96 I encourage leaders to trust themselves and follow their longing and delights. 99 Practitioners pair up [...] facing one another. Since the task is to continue to follow one's own breath as the leader for the movement, it requires concentration not to get too caught up in the tempo of the partner's breath. I love this part because it teaches empathy without codependency. [...] The seventh part is Dance in a group [...] This final part teaches the ultimate practice in letting go. [...] With many others dancing in full view, practitioners experience their lack of control over the movements around them, and continue to focus on their own breath to set the pace for their movement. 110 Adding Mudra Space Awareness training to ensemble and meditation practices creates a firewall against ego and separatism, the hindrances to ensemble play. [...] ensemble members can take risks, protected within the bounds of benevolent space. 111 We also glimpse possible linkages between our experience of difficulty in practice with our struggle to maintain a fabricated story line of separate selfness as we try to match solid space with solid body. [...] you are empty of the self that always has to be protected. 115 When anxiety arose, I could observe it with kindness and stability instead of hatred. I could make room for the unpleasantness of anxiety and self-doubt. 117 [...] I ask myself, what kind of conceit is happening? What has been built up, and is it feeding on greed, anger, or delusion (the three roots of unwholesome mental states in Buddhism)? 120 [...] festivals, and audiences at performances -- these gatherings have been essential in integrating my internal experiences of Dharma, of impermanence and interconnection, into the relational and external realms. Clinging to these groups, no matter how much I may enjoy the people and the experiences, only brings me suffering. Equally, if I don't engage fully and authentically, I suffer because of my unwillingness to connect in a meaningful way. I've thus had to find my own middle way between craving and detaching from these experiences. [...] I gave space and quiet for my heart, as it broke a thousand times over at being forgiven and released from scrutiny. [...] The [meta] phrases became embedded in my mind, and the feelings they evoked were embossed on my heart. 121 Without the strong connections we have created and committed to as a [leadership] group, we would not be able to hold a larger community in any stable way whatsoever. 123 The practice of loving awareness is ever-present in the process of performance. 124 My heart warms as this impromptu performance creates a spontaneous community, though I'm aware of its fleeting impermanence. [...] Most fascinating to me is how a loving, intentional community can be created within a very short time if we are generous and open to what is available to us. 127 What we've found is an understanding of sangha as the cultivation of spirited gatherings that unify otherwise scattered groups of like-minded individuals, and as the fostering of kindness, care, and sharing in each other's joys. 130 [...] I will discuss a model of contemplative training [...] through which necessary conditions are established for spontaneous realization. 132 Commit -- Whatever's happening, stay with it. Amplify -- Whatever you're doing, turn it up. Inquire -- As a situation unfolds, dig deeper. 148 Get Down [...] holding dance as being playful and curious about movement. We focus on how we feel more than how we look. [...] We follow our joy and authenticity, welcoming the ways in which truth, the Dharma, enters our lives. Join Up [...] We enter the collective ritual by paying more attention to how others are moving around us. [...] a more playful tone as we celebrate our shared practice, our Sangha. [...] Much of the suffering that Buddhism is so well known for talking about arises when we push against these natural laws of change and interconnection. [...] We experience dukkha when we try to live in an unchanging world as separate beings, when we do not surrender to what is. Dharma Jam offers a format for this surrender. 149 [...] drinking the nectar without harming the flower. [...] Our dance thus becomes a ritual offering. We offer two of our most precious possessions -- time and ourselves -- back to the universe. We offer these as we realize these are not ours to begin with. We offer the universe back to itself. 152 I guide them to be aware of pleasant, neutral, and unpleasant elements of their present moment experience, while lessening their instinct to grasp the pleasant and fight off the unpleasant. 178 Dances of Universal Peace [Sufi] We long to connect. 181 We become aware of our judging and comparing mind, and let go. We become aware of tensions in the body and tightness in the mind and consciously soften, bringing our awareness back to the present moment. The circle is able to hold our emotional states, our bliss, our longing, our yearning, and our pain without analyzing or talking. By remaining present with just what is, without pushing and pulling on our emotions, we are able to see the play of the mind. [...] As a Buddhist practitioner, I consider the Dances to be exactly half way between the cushion and everyday life. 182 [...] the Buddha said that if we want to bring heaven to earth we have to abide in the Brahma Viharas. The Dances are the perfect place to practice these teachings. Negative mind states such as "the comparing mind" can arise at any time, and instead of reacting in habitual ways we can apply meditative antidotes and purify consciousness. 184 [...] Dances of Universal Peace are part of the new rituals that are being called into being. They are a communal expression of our need to come together and say "no" to destruction and "yes" to life. They are part of the solution to the loneliness and isolation of our times [...] where we show up for each other without an agenda. [...] Healing between the sexes can also take place as we practice simply being present for each other. 187 Meditation becomes another means of [...] control [...] Ultimately, what we are trying to override in the attempt to fulfill our various ego aims through meditation is our own somatic experience of reality. [...] In top-down meditation practice, [...] This approach is not without important benefits, helping us to calm down, reduce our stress, become less distracted and more focused, sleep better, and so on. Another method of meditation within Buddhism-less well-known but characteristic of the yogic practices considered the most advanced in Tibetan Buddhism-is based on entering and identifying with the Soma, 188 What I have found in my more than forty years of teaching meditation is that when meditation is presented as a left-brain, top-down practice, it can be very difficult to sustain and frequently doesn't really lead to long term results; [...] However, when meditation is taught as a somatic, bottom-up, embodied practice, it works in a very natural, effortless, and beautiful way. [...] By drawing on the yogic practices [...] which explore the body from within, we can learn to allow the experience of the Soma to communicate with our conscious mind and to become known to us in a direct-that is nonconceptual-way. 189 1. You develop the awareness that you have a body that is actually independent of your ego, and not purely a function of your conscious mind. 2. You begin to include this new awareness as part of your ongoing way of feeling and sensing yourself and of being at home in the world. 3. You become sensitive to the livingness of your body: it's dynamic, an ever-changing reality, almost an independent entity, filled with energy and life. 4. You see that what you think about and what you experience in your body are often not the same thing, and that your thoughts, when they take over, often simply disconnect you from your own experiential ground, which is your body. 190 5. You begin to see the impact on your body when you turn away from it through discursive thinking-you become numb, tense, feel that you've lost your ground. Because you've had the experience of the simplicity and directness of your body, purely conceptual and filtered experience doesn't feel right anymore. 6. You discover that you can actually best address a difficult or challenging situation by coming back to your body and listening deeply to it; you are learning how to heal yourself. 7. You begin to experience a state of being that is embodied, visceral, grounded, open, and always in process, and you begin to feel this is your home. 8. You realize that there's a much bigger range of emotional and perceptual information coming to you than you had ever been aware of before. 9. You begin to sense the limitless terrain of your physical being-the endless, open spaces we can enter through the body. Now you have a context within which you can actually experience the energy of your body, and the tremendous inspiration that arises for life, without the mediation of your ego. Taking Refuge Through the Body [...] There's a softening of the ego process as you come to understand experientially that the body is more fundamental than the ego. The ego is not so hard and rigid and arrogant any more. And that's the moment at which you can truly take refuge. You can commit to a spiritual journey because you know who's taking refuge; you're coming to it as a full person, an open person [...] 203 Meditation in the West, so associated with relieving an individual's stressful day, contrasts from the Buddhist aim -- to meditate for the benefits of others. 226 Authentic Movement is a profoundly simple form in which movers close their eyes and wait for an impulse to move, and then follow the impulse where it leads. [...] Movement occurs in the presence of a witness [...] without judgment or interpretation. As in meditation, the work of the witness may appear easy, but is only accomplished through experience. [...] While she watches, she opens herself to her own experience: her thoughts, feelings, memories, and physical sensations. She allows herself to be touched, metaphorically, by what she sees. 227 The witness creates a container, a safe space in which the movers can do their work. [...] If a mover touches her while moving, she does not move away, nor does she respond. She allows the mover to make all the choices. [...] Authentic Movement is practiced in silence, without music. [...] Movers are invited to follow their impulses to make sounds in the same way that they are invited to follow their impulses to move. [...] movers may gently encounter other movers in the space. When this happens, each mover's task is to listen to her inner impulse, and recognize whether she wants to stay and move with this other, or whether she wants to step back and continue alone. She must not try to make her decision based on what she thinks the other wants from her; rather she must try to stay true to herself. 237 Once, at a Buddhist retreat [...] "So, Tuning is the opposite of meditation!" I think she meant that a meditator is "supposed to" rise above desire. For me Tuning and meditation are about getting intimate with the process of desire as it experientially unfolds.
I enjoyed several of the essays in this book. It was heartening to read of how to practice mindfulness and dharma in a dance context. That said, though, writing about dancing gets frustrating for the reader, as it makes one want to either watch the dance or just dance.
This is a long-awaited -- and somewhat overdue -- first book of its kind. It is a book which will be of much value to anyone for whom movement and dance (or mindfulness meditation, or Dharma, or embodiment practices or somatics...) is an important part of their lives, but especially those for whom two or more of these categories are compelling interests.
As one who has been exploring and practicing all of these in their combination and integration, this book is for me a precious resource indeed.
By allowing a space for many experiences and perspectives to be shared on this theme (the interweaving of these topics into a whole), Dancing With Dharma is a landmark text which we hope will give impetus to more projects of its kind--, and an ongoing conversation.
For the last two or three years of my life, especially, I've been exploring the integration of movement, dance, mindfulness, somatics and Dharma with a passion. Sadly, this is a somewhat rare combination of interests when taken as an interwoven whole, but with books like this now available for the reader, we should rightly expect this interest will continue to emerge and grow. All of these things go together beautifully. Thank you Harrison Blum!