What do you think?
Rate this book


320 pages, Paperback
First published April 5, 2016
I've been a fan of Havill's Posadas County mysteries since they were the Bill Gastner mysteries and they're always a good read. Come Dark started out fabulous, one of the best I've read, but I was disappointed by the ending. After taking the vast majority of the book to set up two mysteries, slowly and carefully intertwining them both, the novel wrapped them both up in three contrived chapters. It's still a good read but the ending kept if from being great.
I like mysteries where the detectives solve the mysteries and catch the perpetrators. In this one, the people are caught not by the striving and skill of the detectives, but basically by happenstance. There was no reveal, just a way too tidy summing up the criminals. It was too neat, too quick, and too easy.
This also might have the smallest amount of space given to former series star Bill Gastner. I enjoy Estelle, although her super-talented kids tend to be an annoying subplot, but Gaster is one of the more unusual and fascinating characters in today's mystery world. I just hate seeing him phased out more and more. I want more of him discussing items while eating green chili.