What do you think?
Rate this book
The Soul in Anguish: Psychotherapeutic Approaches to Suffering
The Soul in Psychotherapeutic Approaches to Suffering presents a variety of approaches to psychotherapeutic work with suffering people, from the perspectives of both Jungian and psychoanalytic psychology. An important theme of the book is that suffering may be harmful or helpful to the development of the personality. Our culture tends to assume that suffering is invariably negative or pointless, but this is not necessarily so; suffering may be destructive, but it may lead to positive developments such as enhanced empathy for others, wisdom, or spiritual development. The book offers professionals in any helping profession various frameworks within which to view suffering, so that the individual's suffering does not seem to be random or meaningless. Cognitive-behavioral approaches, the approach of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of the American Psychiatric association, and the promise of evidence-based strategies may or may not be applicable to the unique circumstances of the suffering individual. These approaches also ignore the unconscious sources of much suffering, its implications for the ongoing development of the personality, and the nuances of the therapeutic relationship. We cannot objectify or measure suffering; suffering is best viewed from within the individual's perspective, because people with the same diagnosis suffer in unique ways. The Soul in Anguish is a groundbreaking, meticulously researched study from an outstanding Jungian analyst and scholar. It provides illuminating ways into the transformative potential of suffering and how it can be dealt with in the consulting room. Charting the soul's agonies with great compassion and profound sensitivity, Dr. Corbett skillfully delineates clinical, philosophical and spiritual concepts of suffering that testify to the endurance of the human spirit. This book is an enlightening read for anybody with a passionate concern for the human soul.
- Ursula Wirtz, PhD, Jungian Analyst, Author of Trauma and The Mystery of Transformation With extraordinary candor The Soul in Anguish brings its readers face to face with one of the most difficult topics in life, suffering. This remarkable exploration of the range of suffering, especially as encountered in psychotherapy, mines for meaning and finds both its positive and negative expressions. Transcending the categorical, pathological descriptions of the DSM, The Soul in Anguish reveals the archetypal nature of the experience of suffering. Dr. Lionel Corbett offers healing to mind, soul and body, in this uplifting engagement with what is usually either avoided in most treatments or only touched upon, i.e., anguish. This book reimagines our pain and anguish to bring about the possibility of a true psychological and soulful grasp of suffering. No therapist should miss the opportunities of Dr. Corbett's rich study.
- Joe Cambray, Ph.D., Past-President IAAP, Author DR. LIONEL CORBETT trained in medicine and psychiatry in England and as a Jungian Analyst at the C.G. Jung Institute of Chicago. His primary interests the religious function of the psyche, the development of psychotherapy as a spiritual practice, and the interface of Jungian psychology and contemporary psychoanalytic thought. Dr. Corbett is a professor of depth psychology at Pacifica Graduate Institute. He is the author of numerous papers and three The Sacred Psychotherapy as a Spiritual Practice, Psyche and the Sacred , and The Religious Function of the Psyche . He is the co-editor Jung and Aging, Depth Psychology, Meditations in the Field , and Psychology at the Threshold.
- Ursula Wirtz, PhD, Jungian Analyst, Author of Trauma and The Mystery of Transformation With extraordinary candor The Soul in Anguish brings its readers face to face with one of the most difficult topics in life, suffering. This remarkable exploration of the range of suffering, especially as encountered in psychotherapy, mines for meaning and finds both its positive and negative expressions. Transcending the categorical, pathological descriptions of the DSM, The Soul in Anguish reveals the archetypal nature of the experience of suffering. Dr. Lionel Corbett offers healing to mind, soul and body, in this uplifting engagement with what is usually either avoided in most treatments or only touched upon, i.e., anguish. This book reimagines our pain and anguish to bring about the possibility of a true psychological and soulful grasp of suffering. No therapist should miss the opportunities of Dr. Corbett's rich study.
- Joe Cambray, Ph.D., Past-President IAAP, Author DR. LIONEL CORBETT trained in medicine and psychiatry in England and as a Jungian Analyst at the C.G. Jung Institute of Chicago. His primary interests the religious function of the psyche, the development of psychotherapy as a spiritual practice, and the interface of Jungian psychology and contemporary psychoanalytic thought. Dr. Corbett is a professor of depth psychology at Pacifica Graduate Institute. He is the author of numerous papers and three The Sacred Psychotherapy as a Spiritual Practice, Psyche and the Sacred , and The Religious Function of the Psyche . He is the co-editor Jung and Aging, Depth Psychology, Meditations in the Field , and Psychology at the Threshold.
- GenresPsychology
380 pages, Paperback
First published July 24, 2015
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
February 5, 2016
An incredible look at human suffering from different views of self-psychology. I was originally attracted to this title because I am exploring the role and affects of suffering due to grief, on personal transformation and development. The chapter on suicidality may be particularly helpful to psychotherapists who struggle with their own views and shadow material regarding suicide. "...the wish to commit suicide is a desire for a psychological rebirth, "egocide," or a radical transformation of the personality. The therapeutic task is to help the person distinguish between ego death and physical death." I want to reread sections of this book when I have more time to devote. I'd highly recommend this title for anyone interested in suffering from the viewpoint of depth psychology or self-psychology.
August 2, 2016
Dr. Corbett's book is a thorough survey of how suffering is addressed in various schools of psychotherapy/psychoanalysis. Apart from its comprehensive coverage of the subject, it is apparent that Lionel Corbett understands the subject by virtue of his own anguish and suffering. This book would be a useful addition to any therapist's library. For laypersons interested in the subject of suffering, the book will provide an exceptional overview. There are occasions when the material may appear dense but this reflects the extraordinary depth of understanding and mastery possessed by the author.
July 1, 2026
from Gemini
萊昂內爾·科貝特（Lionel Corbett）的著作《**The Soul in Anguish: Psychotherapeutic Approaches to Suffering**》（中譯：痛苦的靈魂：心理治療對苦難的應對方法）是一部融合榮格深度心理學、精神分析與靈性關懷的經典作品。
這本書的核心精華與佳句整理如下：
---
## 核心重點（The Core Insights）
### 1. 苦難的「原型」本質與意義轉化
現代西方文化和醫學模式傾向於將痛苦視為隨機、無意義且需要被立刻消滅的「症狀」或「疾病」。然而，科貝特指出，痛苦具有原型（Archetypal）的特質，是人類靈魂不可或缺的一部分。
* 書中將苦難視為一種**閾限狀態（Liminality）**，如同原始部落的「成年禮」（Rite of Passage）。痛苦摧毀了舊有的自我世界觀與價值觀，強迫個體進入一個未知的過渡期，進而孵化出新的意識與人格。
### 2. 超越 DSM 的病理化標籤
科貝特強調，心理治療不應該只專注於符合《精神疾病診斷與統計手冊》（DSM）的診斷代碼。
* 他主張：**「我們治療的不是『疾病』，而是『正在受苦的人』。」** 即使擁有相同的診斷標籤，每個靈魂受苦的方式與深層意義都是獨一無二的。
### 3. 苦難作為與「神聖」相遇的通道
從詞源學來看，「受苦」（Suffer）與「肥沃、結果實」（Fertile / Bear fruit）擁有相同的字根。科貝特認為，心靈的痛苦往往會引發個體的「靈性危機」，這時傳統的宗教教條可能失效，但這恰恰是個體透過潛意識（如夢境、心靈象徵）直接與內在的「神聖（The Sacred）」或「原型自我」相遇的契機。
### 4. 治療師作為「見證者」的角色
面對極大的痛苦、虐待或孤獨，治療師的任務不是扮演高高在上的專家去「修復」或「解釋」病患，而是成為一個穩固的「見證者（Witness）」與煉金術般的容器。透過不帶評判的陪伴、凝視與承載，讓受苦的靈魂感到安全，痛苦才得以轉化。
---
## 本書精華（Key Summary）
* **痛苦的雙面性：** 苦難可能摧毀一個人，也可能促進人格的深化。關鍵在於心靈如何去回應它。科貝特用了一個生動的比喻：**「航行者無法改變風向（命運/苦難），但可以調整風帆（心靈的回應方式）。」**
* **具體心理狀態的剖析：** 書中後半段深入探討了嫉妒、仇恨、悲傷和孤獨等難以言喻的心靈痛苦，並從深度心理學角度分析了殘酷行為、施虐與受虐的心理機制。
---
## 經典佳句（Quotes & Golden Nuggets）
> **"It can be argued that disorders are the root cause of suffering and so should be the prime target of psychotherapy; but we do not treat disorders, we treat suffering people who are vastly more complex than their diagnosis."**
> 「有人會認為心理疾病是苦難的根源，因此應成為心理治療的首要目標；但我們治療的不是疾病，我們治療的是正在受苦的人，他們遠比他們的診斷結果要複雜得多。」
> **"Soul does not speak in facts—it speaks in symbols."**
> 「靈魂不說事實，它說的是象徵。」
> **"Suffering can be the path through which we meet the divine. Every crisis holds the seed of transformation."**
> 「苦難可以成為我們與神聖相遇的道路。每一次危機都握有轉化的種子。」
---
### 💡 總結
這本書是一劑給現代人被「去靈魂化」醫學模式傷害時的解藥。它溫柔地告訴我們：你感到的痛苦與心靈乾涸並非只是單純的生病，那是你的靈魂正在經歷一場艱難的淬鍊，試圖在廢墟中開出更具慈悲心與智慧的果實。
萊昂內爾·科貝特（Lionel Corbett）的著作《**The Soul in Anguish: Psychotherapeutic Approaches to Suffering**》（中譯：痛苦的靈魂：心理治療對苦難的應對方法）是一部融合榮格深度心理學、精神分析與靈性關懷的經典作品。
這本書的核心精華與佳句整理如下：
---
## 核心重點（The Core Insights）
### 1. 苦難的「原型」本質與意義轉化
現代西方文化和醫學模式傾向於將痛苦視為隨機、無意義且需要被立刻消滅的「症狀」或「疾病」。然而，科貝特指出，痛苦具有原型（Archetypal）的特質，是人類靈魂不可或缺的一部分。
* 書中將苦難視為一種**閾限狀態（Liminality）**，如同原始部落的「成年禮」（Rite of Passage）。痛苦摧毀了舊有的自我世界觀與價值觀，強迫個體進入一個未知的過渡期，進而孵化出新的意識與人格。
### 2. 超越 DSM 的病理化標籤
科貝特強調，心理治療不應該只專注於符合《精神疾病診斷與統計手冊》（DSM）的診斷代碼。
* 他主張：**「我們治療的不是『疾病』，而是『正在受苦的人』。」** 即使擁有相同的診斷標籤，每個靈魂受苦的方式與深層意義都是獨一無二的。
### 3. 苦難作為與「神聖」相遇的通道
從詞源學來看，「受苦」（Suffer）與「肥沃、結果實」（Fertile / Bear fruit）擁有相同的字根。科貝特認為，心靈的痛苦往往會引發個體的「靈性危機」，這時傳統的宗教教條可能失效，但這恰恰是個體透過潛意識（如夢境、心靈象徵）直接與內在的「神聖（The Sacred）」或「原型自我」相遇的契機。
### 4. 治療師作為「見證者」的角色
面對極大的痛苦、虐待或孤獨，治療師的任務不是扮演高高在上的專家去「修復」或「解釋」病患，而是成為一個穩固的「見證者（Witness）」與煉金術般的容器。透過不帶評判的陪伴、凝視與承載，讓受苦的靈魂感到安全，痛苦才得以轉化。
---
## 本書精華（Key Summary）
* **痛苦的雙面性：** 苦難可能摧毀一個人，也可能促進人格的深化。關鍵在於心靈如何去回應它。科貝特用了一個生動的比喻：**「航行者無法改變風向（命運/苦難），但可以調整風帆（心靈的回應方式）。」**
* **具體心理狀態的剖析：** 書中後半段深入探討了嫉妒、仇恨、悲傷和孤獨等難以言喻的心靈痛苦，並從深度心理學角度分析了殘酷行為、施虐與受虐的心理機制。
---
## 經典佳句（Quotes & Golden Nuggets）
> **"It can be argued that disorders are the root cause of suffering and so should be the prime target of psychotherapy; but we do not treat disorders, we treat suffering people who are vastly more complex than their diagnosis."**
> 「有人會認為心理疾病是苦難的根源，因此應成為心理治療的首要目標；但我們治療的不是疾病，我們治療的是正在受苦的人，他們遠比他們的診斷結果要複雜得多。」
> **"Soul does not speak in facts—it speaks in symbols."**
> 「靈魂不說事實，它說的是象徵。」
> **"Suffering can be the path through which we meet the divine. Every crisis holds the seed of transformation."**
> 「苦難可以成為我們與神聖相遇的道路。每一次危機都握有轉化的種子。」
---
### 💡 總結
這本書是一劑給現代人被「去靈魂化」醫學模式傷害時的解藥。它溫柔地告訴我們：你感到的痛苦與心靈乾涸並非只是單純的生病，那是你的靈魂正在經歷一場艱難的淬鍊，試圖在廢墟中開出更具慈悲心與智慧的果實。
February 21, 2017
This book is absolutely amazing. Corbett is an excellent writer and great and providing multiple perspectives, while still elaborating areas in which we can cultivate our own deep meaning. Game changer for me.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews