Photographer Alex Rutledge just wants to get out of town to his assignment on the Cayman Islands. When close friend and Vietnam vet Sam Wheeler gets a call to identify a body in Fort Lauderdale as possibly his sister, Alex tags along. The detective on the case tells Sam that he is going to run a squib in the paper announcing the woman's death to see what information comes forth.
When Alex and Sam return to Key West, Alex is called out to photograph a crime scene. Alex freelances upon occasion with the KWPD, but death really is not his favorite subject. This time it is the mayor of Key West, and it looks like suicide to the cops, but it looks like murder to Alex. Clues don’t add up, yet the city cops are not treating this like homicide. Alex has seen Detective Sgt. Dexter Hayes botch investigations before, and Alex is convinced his attitude is far too indifferent to ferret out the truth.
Before Alex can pack for the Cayman Islands, he finds out that long-time Key West resident Naomi Douglas passed away in her sleep. Particularly fond of Naomi since she encouraged his photography, Alex is surprised to learn he is named executor of her estate. Maybe he has been around too much death, but upon visiting Naomi’s home to secure valuables before his trip, things just do not feel right. Alex calls in a favor from sheriff “Chicken Neck” Liska who sends a deputy to check out the house.
Alex’s new roommate Teresa asks him to join her and an old friend for dinner. Whitney Randolph immediately rubs Alex the wrong way, so Alex excuses himself to check on Sam. Focused on his encounter in Fort Lauderdale, Sam decides that if his sister is alive and might be in danger, he could never forgive himself for ignoring the warning signs. Sam heads back to the Gold Coast to uncover whatever clues he can find.
Still not satisfied that his feelings are wrong about Naomi Douglas’s death, Alex is sure there are just too many tangled clues to be coincidence. Has a love affair gone sour? What about the museum proposal on which Naomi had done so much work? Who might want to sway the mayor’s vote? Will Sam find his sister? The apparently different plot lines start to weave in and out of each other until they are completely intermingled. Seeing how all the factors influenced each other and the people involved kept my interest piqued in both the action occurring and the personal relationships explored.
This is the fourth entry in the Alex Rutledge series. The characters were familiar yet OCTOPUS ALIBI takes a much closer look into who the individual characters are and what motivates them. The friendship between Sam and Alex that has been so central to all the books is examined on a much deeper level. Key West is as much a character as the people who live there. Perhaps it is the observation skills of a photographer – both the character and the author -- that brings forth the small details. Corcoran has taken a step forward with more relaxed writing in OCTOPUS ALIBI.
Will Alex find himself in trouble in Paradise again? You can bet on it. I’m looking forward to it.