On the whole, this is a fantastic book. It sheds light on Black history and activism in one of the whitest big cities in the US, weaving an illuminating narrative about the roles of Black institutions and individuals in shaping the city today. Although the history ostensibly ends in the 80s, almost all of the issues being addressed by the Panthers and other Black activists throughout the 20th century continue to impact Portlanders of color. The writing is thoroughly engaging, informative, and well-paced. At no point did the book feel like an academic slog.
HOWEVER. The fawning narrative of Neil Goldschmidt's tenure as Portland City Councillor and then Mayor is inexcusable given his 2004 confession (12 years prior to this book's publishing) that he spent years raping a minor. The authors have no qualms about discussing Huey Newton's descent into patriarchy and violence, but give no mention of Goldschmidt's revelations, not even in the afterword. The book leaves readers with the impression that Goldschmidt was a flawed hero (due to his policies, not his personal actions) but nonetheless the hero that Portland's Black community needed to institutionalize the work that the Portland Panthers had started. He may have had a lasting positive impact in the city but he was not a hero.
As a history of Black Portland and a window into the conditions impacting Black Portlanders today, this should be required reading throughout the city. But every copy should be handed out with a copy of Goldschmidt's confession tucked into the fifth chapter.