Not so very long ago (though far longer than I'd like to admit) I was a university student taking Summer courses to pass the time. One of these was a Young Adults Fiction class, and "Forest" was on the reading list... I did not read it. In fact, I think it is the only one that I did not get around to, and when I heard the class discussion (they hated it! they loathed it to its very core!) I vowed that one day, I would not only read - but I would enjoy - this book.
Many years later, the spark of rebellion has worn down some, but I was browsing my bookshelf when this one caught my eye. I figured I'd give it a try... To begin with, this is a book about cats. Feral cats. That will put a lot of people off before they have even started. I'm not sure who the target audience is supposed to be; but cat lovers won't enjoy watching the pitiful creatures suffer, cat haters won't get through the first chapter, and young adults will probably be bored out of their brains, because in a world of "Twilight" and "The Infernal Devices", this one simply does not compare.
That said, those who can endure will discover an interesting story with exceptional writing. The prose itself is the star of this book, and Sonya Hartnett knows how to turn a phrase. She also knows a lot about cats, and imbues them with attitudes and ideas which can't be too far from the mark. They are definitely cat-like, but I'm not sure that they're very likeable or very interesting. I think that the best characters in the novel were the other wild animals, from foxes to dogs, possums to echidnas, lizards to rats. These were my favourite scenes.
Ultimately, the story is a bleak and grizzly one. All of the animals suffer needlessly, and there are no easy solutions to the feral situation. Hartnett doesn't pretend that there are. On the one hand, the ferals left unchecked will destroy the forest and each other, and yet the trapping and killing of the animals is shown to be a brutal and inhumane process. I wouldn't recommend this novel because I don't think anybody would enjoy reading it. This is one wayward animal story that not even Walt Disney himself could work with...