This book is NOT a good pick if you are just starting with guitar. Note that several 5 star reviews mention they already knew how to play electrical, acoustic, or another related instrument before starting. That is vital.
I can read sheet music. I am coming from a piano background. For starting guitar, I highly recommend something else.
1. Exercises scale too rapidly.
There are not enough exercises at a basic level for someone who is learning finger placement (and how to contort fingers to fit. Hint: if it feels like your fingers might break, you might need a smaller instrument. Do not listen to the 6.5 foot tall male who says you just need to try harder. Listen to your joints and thank me later.) I ended up playing out of my level 1 piano book for extra practice before breaking down and ordering The Guitarist’s Way, which moves at a much slower pace.
2. No fingering notes are given after adding in the ring finger.
Initially, all songs are i,m,i,m, etc. When ‘a’ (ring finger) is introduced, it’s explained that the placement prevents awkward crossovers… and then it’s never noted in the music again. Clearly, I’m supposed to be using that finger in other pieces, but everything feels awkward in the beginning. How do I know when it’s “use ‘a’ here instead of ‘m’” awkward? Very annoying.
3. Limited discussion of the instrument itself
When I got to Malagueña, I realized something was very wrong- my fingers were nearly coming out of joint trying to follow the book’s fingering. I knew there was an issue early on in the fingering exercises from chapter 1; after watching some YouTube videos, it became apparent that the guitar neck was definitely too wide. Over the holidays, tried a different family member’s guitar- voila! I can play! Would’ve been nice to know earlier. (FYI- don’t listen to the idiots who say, “you just need to stretch more.” No. This is not the 1800’s. You don’t need to break your fingers for the sake of art. Someone out there makes an instrument that fits you. Is it an acoustic instead of a classical guitar? Is it sized for a child? Who the frick cares! Go play! Enjoy not being in pain! Fire the teacher who tells you otherwise! Your true friends and family shouldn’t care if you’re playing a classical instrument handcrafted in Spain or an acoustic pawn shop leftover.)
4. Video or CD needed
[the cover here says CD edition, but my edition did not come with CD... if you are set on this book, get one with a CD]
Because sometimes a song seems to have an awkward chord or note, and hearing how it should sound can be helpful. I’ve found mistakes in books before; music helps confirm the notes are correct.