Ultimately a pretty good series, so I'm glad I already had the rest on hand and kept going after that weird blip of volume 2. I'll have to try it again with the full context, I guess.
There are some loose ends, and Takaguchi even admitted to completely forgetting about a couple characters in the final chapters, which is part of that weird messiness I kept noticing throughout. Mizusawa still isn't married, and there are some hints that it might not go through, although we did see at least a glimpse of his fiancee's hair, so she definitely exists. And I was super surprised that Nakaya went back to his grandmother's house instead of jetting off to Canada to get his boyfriend back...but there's potentially a bit of hope that they could pick things up again a few years down the line.
Or maybe they won't. Maybe that's the point, that relationships end and heartbreaks happen, and that doesn't mean they weren't worthwhile. Even the future of Shino and Tenryu is left up in the air, since their relationship is new, Tenryu's already been through one divorce, and who knows what will happen a decade or two down the line. But for now, they're happy, and I did like that Nakaya stepped up to be sure he and his dad would always stay in each other's lives, no matter what. He did some definite maturing over the course of these volumes, while Shino opened up his heart a lot more and let himself go after the things he truly wanted.
I also, unexpectedly, ended up liking the grandma, who apologized to Shino and doesn't actually have a bad relationship with Nakaya. Too bad none of this happened while Nakaya's mother was alive, and I wish there'd been more of an explanation of why she never got in touch with Shino during all these years, when she expressed to Nakaya that she'd like to see them meet. But again...loose plot threads that weren't ever going to be gathered together with the way this mangaka writes. (Lots of interesting ideas that just get dropped, changed partway through, or entirely forgotten about.)
Tenryu losing all access to his child and not fighting for the ability to see her is still a bit weird and something you'd think he and Shino would talk about, but I guess they're too wrapped up in the newness of being with each other to spend a lot of time talking about stuff like that. Maybe that'll come later on in their relationship.
This series still feels like it was trying to wear too many hats - is it a gritty, sad, realistic story about mature relationships, or a silly humor manga about a buncha guys lusting after a uke VA? The different volumes kinda went in wildly different directions, but I do mostly like where it ended up. Not perfect by any means, but I like the art, the characters, and the way their stories made me think.
And the art was especially nice in this final volume - Takaguchi went all out on the scenes with Shino and Tenryu in particular, which added depth to the progression of their relationship and really made it feel like something substantial and important. Not all of the characters are perfectly happy, but they're trying, and that's worth something, too.
(I will say that if you're going to run a little side story about a "chubby magical girl" show that you excitedly talk in the end notes about kinda wanting to turn into a real anime, she should actually be...something other than completely stick thin...but y'know. That's a separate issue.)