Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Her Son's Wife

Rate this book
Lottie, cheaply dressed and cheaply perfumes, shatters Mary Bascomb's life, undermining not only the neat comfort of her home, but also her carefully-laid plans for her son's future. Mary's years of control - both as a mother and a teacher - count for nothing against the impact this slovenly young woman has upon Ralph's affections. Humiliated and rebuffed, Mary constructs a barrier of indignation against this marriage. And when the pleasure of self-righteous disapproval fades, devises a means of regaining her supremacy...

First published in 1926, Her Son's Wife incisively explores the destructive potential of a mother's love for her son. A story of possession and the misuse of emotional power, it is a memorable work with an acid edge.

364 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 1926

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Dorothy Canfield

21 books1 follower
See also in GR: Dorothy Canfield Fisher

Library of Congress Authorities:
Fisher, Dorothy Canfield, 1879-1958
See from: Canfield, Dorothy, 1879-1958
See from: Fisher, Dorothea Frances Canfield, 1879-1958
See from: Fisher, John Redwood, Mrs., 1879-1958
Some fiction works continued to be published under her maiden name after marriage.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
30 (39%)
4 stars
31 (40%)
3 stars
10 (13%)
2 stars
5 (6%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
Profile Image for Theresa.
377 reviews
March 23, 2016
Mary Bascomb is a proud, independent woman - and she has a right to be. After all, not only is she an accomplished teacher in the local school district, she has raised a son (Ralph) solely by herself after her husband died early in the marriage. Her plans for her son include law school like his father and grandfather before him. Ralph is presently completing his (pre-law) university degree, and the only thing left now is to find Ralph a wife... but he won't need to lift a finger as Mary Bascomb has a wife picked out for him, groomed awaiting the proper time (perhaps after law school?) in the wings.

Obviously, Mary Bascomb is a woman who likes to be in control:

"...she was the one who always had to see to everything. Ralph was so careless and heedless. He was a good boy, Ralph was, but not quick to see changes in his mother's mood, absorbed in his own trivial interests. She often had to exaggerate her expression before he took note of it. Although it was true that when he had been selfish and careless and had hurt her, he was uneasy till she allowed herself to smile and forgive him and be cheerful again. Yes, Ralph was much easier to manage than many boys would have been."

After a particularly trying day at school with parents waiting in line to speak to her about their child's progress (or lack thereof) in her classroom, Mrs. Bascomb finds a letter waiting in her mailbox, a letter from Ralph. He divulges the news that he has married a girl he met from his college town.

What is Mrs. Bascomb to do? After a long, agonizing, sleepless night, Mrs. Bascomb grits her teeth and sets her course. Ever the one to 'do the right thing' she sends a telegram welcoming the young couple into her home.

Needless to say, this book is full of surprises. Not only is Lottie *not* the choice Mary Bascomb picked for her son, but Lottie is flighty, careless in speech and manners, slothful, and generally an all-around poor choice for her son! What to do?

Mrs. Bascomb's life begins to change as she returns home from a long day at school to a disorderly house, dirty dishes in the sink and dinner to prepare (by herself) for the three of them. Despite the reader's initial reaction to Mrs. Bascomb's character (as she dismisses so insensitively the concerns of after-school parental crowd in the first chapter), one's sympathy cannot but be engaged as this novel progresses. It is heartbreakingly honest in its expose of Mrs. Bascomb's determination to make a success of her son's marriage.

It is not until Lottie has a baby that things begin to change for Mary Bascomb. Seeing her beloved, deceased husband in her granddaughter's eyes, she begins to find purpose and meaning behind her martyrdom... and danger. Her granddaughter cannot be left to such a mother as her son's wife is to raise! What to do?

Full of surprises, Dorothy Canfield (Fisher) is an accomplished author, bringing characters to life, exposing human dilemmas and revealing motivations that are often hidden from oneself but visible to others. She deftly weaves together a story that moves quickly (I just had to find out how this was going to be resolved!) Although this novel is not the light, sweetly happily-ever-after type of literature (in fact, it was quite exasperating to read at times! the choices made in this novel are sooo frustrating to see!), it is also realistic and thought provoking. The question is not "what mother does not want the best for her son", but rather, "to what lengths should a mother go to ensure the well-being of her family"? Although with the best of intentions (despite her faults), Mary Bascomb finds herself consumed by guilt and constantly weighing the consequences of her 'sacrificial love'. It is also possible to see how her character and even outlook changes as her circumstances bring her to the point of decisions that not only affect her family but, although un-looked for, also herself.

Although I never did find myself appreciating Lottie (or even Mrs. Bascomb herself) very much, I found understanding and sympathy for their plight as I came to the final pages. In "Her Son's Wife", the author does not try to whitewash Mary Bascomb's manipulative behavior; rather, she leaves it to the reader to decide whether her influence upon her daughter-in-law is worth the sacrifice to save her granddaughter.

"She grew afraid of a question which asked itself of her, like a far-away half-heard voice, in moments when her mind was not intent on active thoughts. It asked her, 'What is the use of being so right, and others being so wrong, if it does not help you to serve the one human being who needs you?"

I will be looking for more of Dorothy Canfield Fisher's work!





88 reviews
April 18, 2015
I loved this book. At 63 it touched me like a book seldom does. Right time in life for me to discover this gem.
Profile Image for Joanna King.
26 reviews
October 16, 2016
Considering this book is nearly 100 years old the prose seemed modern and fresh. Vividly drawn characters, involving descriptions of emotions. A storyline that pulls the reader along with urgency. Loved it and want to read more of this author's work.
508 reviews227 followers
February 26, 2019
It's been a long time since I couldn't put down a book. This was riveting.
Profile Image for Thomas Hogglestock.
218 reviews129 followers
May 1, 2020
At least two plot twists that were totally unexpected and one of them kind of macabre. An interesting read. Could have used some editing.
Profile Image for Susan.
1,532 reviews57 followers
January 8, 2012
I've read and enjoyed this author's The Bent Twig, The Brimming Cup, Seasoned Timber, and the Homemaker as well as some of her short stories. She often focusses on characters' struggles, ethical dilemmas, and growth in day to day situations and relationships as she does in Her Son's Wife. But two-thirds through this story of a woman's unhappiness with her daughter- in-law, the plot takes an odd twist, and the characters and situations become unbelievable.
Profile Image for Evelyn.
1 review
October 28, 2019
This is a terrific send-up of sentimental maternalism and shows one family as a place where venality can play out in microcosm. That in the case of Mary Bascomb it all pivots around a supreme self-righteousness makes it a lesson for any time. The moral is complicated by the main character's success--everything seems to work out quite well. I don't want to spoil it with too much analysis; this is a creepy page turner that will surprise you in its subtlety.
Profile Image for Stephanie.
86 reviews6 followers
March 1, 2010
I reached for this volume because Dorothy Canfield Fisher's name is synonymous with Vermont literature, at least in a way. There's a children's literature award given in her name annually.

That said, it was interesting to read a novel written by the Great Lady, though not for the kiddies. It features a domineering schoolmarm, her passively-aggressive prodigal son, and the trashy wife he marries. Said d.s. must come to terms with her desire to manipulate everyone in her path (the traditional means of power gathering in the olde days) for the love of her grandchild, who is the light that shines through a path otherwise strewn with tacky temptations.

Interesting.
260 reviews1 follower
July 10, 2012
This author was popular when I was a kid, but I'm just now reading her books. I've read this and "The Homemaker" and they were even more intriguing because of the fact that they were written in the 20s (this one) and into the 40s (The Homemaker, I think) or 50s. She went to Ohio State and lived her adult life in Vermont. Very interesting writer!
Profile Image for Lisa Bywell.
262 reviews4 followers
September 25, 2016
Heart breaking at first and then takes a deliciously dark twist.
Profile Image for Irma Servatius.
159 reviews2 followers
August 16, 2018
very evocative and dark.
came here on the recommendation of steven isserlis, stayed for the terrific prose and the intriguing plot twists.
2 reviews9 followers
March 12, 2024
There are many ways to view the “heroine” of Her Son’s Wife, Mary Bascomb. While her pride and arrogance in the beginning of the book are understandable in view of her circumstances, i.e. widowed as a young woman with a son to raise, , hard-working respected schoolteacher, we see her self-image crumble and her self-awareness dawn as the story progresses. The truth of who Mary Bascomb really is becomes clear as she sacrifices false values on the altar of love. Her son Ralph and granddaughter Dids become her sole focus in life. Their welfare overrides her pride, her personal comfort, and even her own integrity. I came to love Mary Bascomb for her ingenuity and dedication. Dorothy Canfield is subtle but pervading in bringing out the tremendous influence for good or evil each of us can have on others. Her characters are deep and believable. And I always emerge from reading one of her books with more compassion for others and more appreciation for my own life and opportunities. In my opinion, this book is a must-read!
1,176 reviews2 followers
October 26, 2026
I want to trash this novel because I do hate the subservience that it illustrates. But I can't. Because I think the rest of the story, depicting a woman who learns the hard way, how to organise her own household and how to safeguard her beloved granddaughter is brilliant. Dorothy Canfield seems to know the exact psychology of Mrs Bascom's time and that of her awful daughter in law . Brilliantly thought out. And written.
12 reviews
July 9, 2026
Subtle Study of Domestic Relationships

Although set some time ago this novel is very much worth.readung as it shows the growth of an intelligent widow and teacher from comparative youth to her 60s

During the time she is a rock on which her family depends but it takes her time to understand the true nature of her son and daughter in law. A wise book
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews