What do you think?
Rate this book
Valiant Hearts #3
Courageous
Inspired by the vision of the Young Lady Sapphira, Rosalind of Ipsworth joins a group of men, women, and children as a defender of the cross, seeking to free captives from prisons near Tripoli. She gladly gives herself to the cause, as she's haunted by a tragic mistake and no longer deserves such joys as marriage and family might bring.
Sir Randel Penigree was reared to serve in the church, but dreams of protecting the innocent as a knight. Joining a crusade to escape humiliation at home, he finds himself drawn to Rosalind as they partner to train and protect a group of young adolescents. When they face political machinations, danger, and an unknown enemy bent on their destruction, they are forced to reconsider their priorities and the very nature of the God they serve.
Sir Randel Penigree was reared to serve in the church, but dreams of protecting the innocent as a knight. Joining a crusade to escape humiliation at home, he finds himself drawn to Rosalind as they partner to train and protect a group of young adolescents. When they face political machinations, danger, and an unknown enemy bent on their destruction, they are forced to reconsider their priorities and the very nature of the God they serve.
362 pages, Paperback
First published June 1, 2016
20 people are currently reading
992 people want to read
About the author
Dina L. Sleiman
10 books273 followersAward-winning author, Dina Sleiman, writes stories of passion and grace. Most of the time you will find this Virginia Beach resident reading, biking, dancing, or hanging out with her husband and three children, preferably at the oceanfront. Since finishing her Professional Writing MA in 1994, she has enjoyed many opportunities to teach literature, writing, and the arts. Her debut novel, Dance of the Dandelion with Whitefire Publishing, won an Honorable Mention in the 2012 Selah Awards, and her cross-over YA novel, Dauntless, won the 2016 Carol Award. Also look for her books, Love in Three-Quarter Time, Dance from Deep Within, and the rest of her Valiant Hearts series with Bethany House Publishers. Join her as she discovers the unforced rhythms of grace. For more info visit her at http://dinasleiman.com/
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
July 14, 2016
I've enjoyed the VALIANT HEARTS series by Dina L. Sleiman. They're adventurous, somewhat unique, romantic, and retellings of legends such as Robin Hood and Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. Courageous was a pretty good tale, keeping my interesting and giving me some thoughts to mule over.
It follows the life of a few different characters, one of them being Rosalind, who we met in Chivalrous and were left knowing only she had made some tragic mistakes and was far from healed inside.
After a vision from a young girl named Lady Sapphira, Rosalind sets out on a crusade to free some prisoners with a group of other zealous warriors. Will they find victory ... and healing, along the way?
I was excited to read Rosalind and Sir Randel's story! Lady Sapphira was an interesting POV character as well. And, oh my goodness, I totally did not figure out the whole mysterious villain! That was rather a shock for me, finally finding out who it was! I loved the secondary stories of people finding Christ ... beautiful. ^_^ It was fun to read about the travels. Delightful to get another peek at the lovely characters from the previous books in the series! Courageous was a thoughtful, messy, ultimately beautiful story of redemption, grace, and following God's guidance.
There were certain points of the book concerning faith and whatnot that had me kind of confused. I wasn't sure what to think about a few aspects, and not sure I agreed with others. But in the end, I think most things were sorted out in a way I understood and found to be Biblical.
Another note, I do not like reading from the villain's POV. Especially when it gets gruesome. Just not my thing. That happened in this book, just to give you a heads up.
Anyway, I enjoyed this novel! And there were some truly poignant and precious moments. Adventure, faith, and some romance. It was a good book.
I received a copy of Courageous from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
It follows the life of a few different characters, one of them being Rosalind, who we met in Chivalrous and were left knowing only she had made some tragic mistakes and was far from healed inside.
After a vision from a young girl named Lady Sapphira, Rosalind sets out on a crusade to free some prisoners with a group of other zealous warriors. Will they find victory ... and healing, along the way?
I was excited to read Rosalind and Sir Randel's story! Lady Sapphira was an interesting POV character as well. And, oh my goodness, I totally did not figure out the whole mysterious villain! That was rather a shock for me, finally finding out who it was! I loved the secondary stories of people finding Christ ... beautiful. ^_^ It was fun to read about the travels. Delightful to get another peek at the lovely characters from the previous books in the series! Courageous was a thoughtful, messy, ultimately beautiful story of redemption, grace, and following God's guidance.
There were certain points of the book concerning faith and whatnot that had me kind of confused. I wasn't sure what to think about a few aspects, and not sure I agreed with others. But in the end, I think most things were sorted out in a way I understood and found to be Biblical.
Another note, I do not like reading from the villain's POV. Especially when it gets gruesome. Just not my thing. That happened in this book, just to give you a heads up.
Anyway, I enjoyed this novel! And there were some truly poignant and precious moments. Adventure, faith, and some romance. It was a good book.
I received a copy of Courageous from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
July 11, 2016
Note: I received this book for free, specifically to review it.
As a History major, I have certainly learned a thing or two about the Crusades. The basic gist? There were a lot of them, and they were–as Sleiman puts it– “messy”. Even during a class on the Crusades, it can be challenging to keep them all straight, and it becomes far more difficult when you’re not in class anymore. They seem to just combine into one jumble of violence, religious zeal, prejudice, and hardship (for people of all ages, not just men).
With that ‘jumble’ in mind, I was eager to educate myself again as I read Courageous. Sleiman does not disappoint: although there’s not exactly an enormous history lesson in the book, I learned a lot about the children’s crusades in particular–and from a variety of perspectives. The book’s plot focuses on Rosalind and Randel, two young people who are (in essence) the chaperones for a young visionary, Sapphira, and the other children who have been permitted to accompany her. On a quest to save several prisoners in the Holy Land, the group (bolstered by a small fighting force, in keeping with Sapphira’s noble status) leaves Northern Britannia to achieve their goal.
Sleiman in no way makes the journey easy. Several of the characters die, and the entire group faces a variety of struggles–including challenges against their faith. But one particular challenge manifests itself in the relationship between Rosalind and Randel: the ability to forgive oneself. Both Rosalind and Randel have committed sins that they punish themselves for–and both have, in turn, convinced themselves that they do not deserve love or marriage.
As the two characters find themselves getting closer to their religious convictions on the journey, they also find themselves getting closer to each other. A cliche, yes; however, while this burgeoning romantic relationship is one that is clearly outlined in the book’s description (and one that manifests itself early on in the story with a ‘fake’ relationship), the romance’s similarity to a typical modern romance-novel ends there. Sleiman artfully manages to weave together multiple characters’ perspectives, and introduces enough problems to ensure that Rosalind and Randel’s relationship actually takes a back-burner many times in the book. There’s also none of the passive-aggressive tension that most fictional couples experience; Rosalind and Randel are great friends from the start, and there are no arguments between them. Their friendship actually lasts throughout the novel, which is truly refreshing. The only obstacle to their happiness is each person’s respective guilt; in short, both Rosalind and Randel are convinced that they don’t deserve the relationship–and the reader is convinced that they could both use a little therapy.
The book’s main relationship is unique in that it is both subtle and consistently amicable; however, the other relationships are often less so, creating plenty of petty drama to entertain readers in between attacks. Sleiman has created an impressive roster of characters, and juggles them without any observable tension or hastiness in the story. She actually manages to add a bit of depth to almost every character–even those who only have a few lines–and also has the ability to aptly describe the perspectives of characters who are in very different situations and age ranges!
The plot has an excellent progression, introducing each theme–romance, drama, humor, and battles–at just the right time. As soon as you start wondering what’s going on with a certain character or how a certain relationship is faring, Sleiman brings it back–almost as if she had read your mind. The language is also a nice mix between modern language and traditional speech patterns (and Sleiman does recognize the intentional mix in her historical notes). One thing that particularly struck me about Courageous was the rich, vivid descriptions: with only a sentence or two, Sleiman often manages to describe a scene in a way that is both very unique and, somehow, dead-on in accuracy.
In addition, while the religious aspects of Sleiman’s story are virtually unavoidable, strong religious convictions don’t seem particularly necessary as a reader. You may not care much for organized religion–but you could probably still enjoy this book, particularly if you have any interest in the Crusades or the normal (as well as the abnormal) people who participated in them.
Overall, I was very pleasantly surprised by this book. I had expected an overwrought love story, with a pretty predictable plot and just a smattering of historical information; instead, I was exposed to a companionable story that was exciting, well-written, and riddled with plot twists. Well done, Mrs. Sleiman; I’ll be looking into your other books, including the other two in this series!
As a History major, I have certainly learned a thing or two about the Crusades. The basic gist? There were a lot of them, and they were–as Sleiman puts it– “messy”. Even during a class on the Crusades, it can be challenging to keep them all straight, and it becomes far more difficult when you’re not in class anymore. They seem to just combine into one jumble of violence, religious zeal, prejudice, and hardship (for people of all ages, not just men).
With that ‘jumble’ in mind, I was eager to educate myself again as I read Courageous. Sleiman does not disappoint: although there’s not exactly an enormous history lesson in the book, I learned a lot about the children’s crusades in particular–and from a variety of perspectives. The book’s plot focuses on Rosalind and Randel, two young people who are (in essence) the chaperones for a young visionary, Sapphira, and the other children who have been permitted to accompany her. On a quest to save several prisoners in the Holy Land, the group (bolstered by a small fighting force, in keeping with Sapphira’s noble status) leaves Northern Britannia to achieve their goal.
Sleiman in no way makes the journey easy. Several of the characters die, and the entire group faces a variety of struggles–including challenges against their faith. But one particular challenge manifests itself in the relationship between Rosalind and Randel: the ability to forgive oneself. Both Rosalind and Randel have committed sins that they punish themselves for–and both have, in turn, convinced themselves that they do not deserve love or marriage.
As the two characters find themselves getting closer to their religious convictions on the journey, they also find themselves getting closer to each other. A cliche, yes; however, while this burgeoning romantic relationship is one that is clearly outlined in the book’s description (and one that manifests itself early on in the story with a ‘fake’ relationship), the romance’s similarity to a typical modern romance-novel ends there. Sleiman artfully manages to weave together multiple characters’ perspectives, and introduces enough problems to ensure that Rosalind and Randel’s relationship actually takes a back-burner many times in the book. There’s also none of the passive-aggressive tension that most fictional couples experience; Rosalind and Randel are great friends from the start, and there are no arguments between them. Their friendship actually lasts throughout the novel, which is truly refreshing. The only obstacle to their happiness is each person’s respective guilt; in short, both Rosalind and Randel are convinced that they don’t deserve the relationship–and the reader is convinced that they could both use a little therapy.
The book’s main relationship is unique in that it is both subtle and consistently amicable; however, the other relationships are often less so, creating plenty of petty drama to entertain readers in between attacks. Sleiman has created an impressive roster of characters, and juggles them without any observable tension or hastiness in the story. She actually manages to add a bit of depth to almost every character–even those who only have a few lines–and also has the ability to aptly describe the perspectives of characters who are in very different situations and age ranges!
The plot has an excellent progression, introducing each theme–romance, drama, humor, and battles–at just the right time. As soon as you start wondering what’s going on with a certain character or how a certain relationship is faring, Sleiman brings it back–almost as if she had read your mind. The language is also a nice mix between modern language and traditional speech patterns (and Sleiman does recognize the intentional mix in her historical notes). One thing that particularly struck me about Courageous was the rich, vivid descriptions: with only a sentence or two, Sleiman often manages to describe a scene in a way that is both very unique and, somehow, dead-on in accuracy.
In addition, while the religious aspects of Sleiman’s story are virtually unavoidable, strong religious convictions don’t seem particularly necessary as a reader. You may not care much for organized religion–but you could probably still enjoy this book, particularly if you have any interest in the Crusades or the normal (as well as the abnormal) people who participated in them.
Overall, I was very pleasantly surprised by this book. I had expected an overwrought love story, with a pretty predictable plot and just a smattering of historical information; instead, I was exposed to a companionable story that was exciting, well-written, and riddled with plot twists. Well done, Mrs. Sleiman; I’ll be looking into your other books, including the other two in this series!
August 8, 2016
Dina Sleiman's latest historical, Courageous, is set in the often overlooked medieval Crusades and is solid, satisfying ending to her debut YA trilogy. With just the right mix of action, romance, and a plausible historical setting, Sleiman brings the Crusades to life!
While Sleiman's previous novels, Dauntless and Chivalrous, were based on Robin Hood and Arthurian legends respectively, the protagonists in Courageous do not seem to have the same "legendary" connections, though I can see shades of Joan of Arc in thirteen year-old Sapphira. Regardless, I enjoyed getting to know Rosalind and Randal (both first introduced in Chivalrous), along with their motley band of young charges.
I admit, I wasn't initially enthusiastic to hear that this novel was set during the Crusades --what some would argue to be a low or dark point of Christianity. However, Sleiman's even-handed approach and obvious research won me over. The "Christians" had many reasons for going on crusades --some with religious sincerity, some for financial or political profit, etc. Likewise the different Muslim sects and attitudes towards the European Crusaders are carefully and respectfully portrayed. By no means is either exhaustive or perfect. However, I appreciated that Sleiman tried not to fall into stereotyping the Christian crusaders or Muslim people, but sought to give readers a peek into the complexities and challenges cultural differences can make. I was so impressed with this handling that it makes me want to check out Sleiman's 2013 contemporary novel, Dance from Deep Within, which centers around three college classmates (one secular, one Christian, and one Muslim).
I've really enjoyed Sleiman's Valiant Hearts series and am eagerly looking forward to her next projects! Sleiman would definitely be one of my top recommendations for teens and adults alike looking for Christian YA medieval novels.
Four and a half stars!
[Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the author for review purposes.]
While Sleiman's previous novels, Dauntless and Chivalrous, were based on Robin Hood and Arthurian legends respectively, the protagonists in Courageous do not seem to have the same "legendary" connections, though I can see shades of Joan of Arc in thirteen year-old Sapphira. Regardless, I enjoyed getting to know Rosalind and Randal (both first introduced in Chivalrous), along with their motley band of young charges.
I admit, I wasn't initially enthusiastic to hear that this novel was set during the Crusades --what some would argue to be a low or dark point of Christianity. However, Sleiman's even-handed approach and obvious research won me over. The "Christians" had many reasons for going on crusades --some with religious sincerity, some for financial or political profit, etc. Likewise the different Muslim sects and attitudes towards the European Crusaders are carefully and respectfully portrayed. By no means is either exhaustive or perfect. However, I appreciated that Sleiman tried not to fall into stereotyping the Christian crusaders or Muslim people, but sought to give readers a peek into the complexities and challenges cultural differences can make. I was so impressed with this handling that it makes me want to check out Sleiman's 2013 contemporary novel, Dance from Deep Within, which centers around three college classmates (one secular, one Christian, and one Muslim).
I've really enjoyed Sleiman's Valiant Hearts series and am eagerly looking forward to her next projects! Sleiman would definitely be one of my top recommendations for teens and adults alike looking for Christian YA medieval novels.
Four and a half stars!
[Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the author for review purposes.]
July 4, 2016
Charming Courage
Rosalind of Ipsworth carries a burden she simply can’t unload. Sir Randel Penigree bears a shame he can’t move past.
Together they board a ship to the Holy Land to fight in the Crusades. Each with a different purpose. Each wanting to pay penance for the sin they committed.
What they find is so much more. They’re tasked with keeping watch on the children board the ship, but that proves to be a challenge when one of those children holds a special gift. Plus, there’s someone who wishes to see Randel pay with his life for his sin. Their adventures become more than they expected—filled with mystery and mayhem around every corner.
Will Rosalind and Randel lead the children to their doom or will their knight skills steer them Forward, ever forward to victory?
Courageous is book three in Dina L. Sleiman’s Valiant Hearts series and is said to be the last, but I hope not! I absolutely loved this medieval trilogy and this latest installment doesn’t disappoint.
Ms. Sleiman’s writing is superb! Her characters jump off the page and you feel every emotion with them. Rosalind’s sadness, Randel’s anger, Sapphira’s low self-esteem, the antagonist’s rage. All of it. You’re right with them on every page.
The setting is well written. You rock with the ship, travel across the countryside in the Holy Land, and shiver as they take cover waiting to attack. Her sensory detail is excellent. You can taste the food at the feasts.
The plot keeps you glued with lots of twists, keeping you guessing and turning the pages. It’s an amazing story of God’s love, redemption, and forgiveness.
I give Courageous five swords. This is one fight you won’t want to miss!
**I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from Baker Publishing Group in exchange for my honest review.
Rosalind of Ipsworth carries a burden she simply can’t unload. Sir Randel Penigree bears a shame he can’t move past.
Together they board a ship to the Holy Land to fight in the Crusades. Each with a different purpose. Each wanting to pay penance for the sin they committed.
What they find is so much more. They’re tasked with keeping watch on the children board the ship, but that proves to be a challenge when one of those children holds a special gift. Plus, there’s someone who wishes to see Randel pay with his life for his sin. Their adventures become more than they expected—filled with mystery and mayhem around every corner.
Will Rosalind and Randel lead the children to their doom or will their knight skills steer them Forward, ever forward to victory?
Courageous is book three in Dina L. Sleiman’s Valiant Hearts series and is said to be the last, but I hope not! I absolutely loved this medieval trilogy and this latest installment doesn’t disappoint.
Ms. Sleiman’s writing is superb! Her characters jump off the page and you feel every emotion with them. Rosalind’s sadness, Randel’s anger, Sapphira’s low self-esteem, the antagonist’s rage. All of it. You’re right with them on every page.
The setting is well written. You rock with the ship, travel across the countryside in the Holy Land, and shiver as they take cover waiting to attack. Her sensory detail is excellent. You can taste the food at the feasts.
The plot keeps you glued with lots of twists, keeping you guessing and turning the pages. It’s an amazing story of God’s love, redemption, and forgiveness.
I give Courageous five swords. This is one fight you won’t want to miss!
**I received a complimentary e-copy of this book from Baker Publishing Group in exchange for my honest review.
July 11, 2016
(My 15 year old daughter's review.)
Courageous is a compelling and interesting story about love finding you even when you're not even looking for it. We follow Randel and Rosalind, whom are led by a prophetic vision from God, to find and rescue some of his people. Along with Sapphira, the one who got the message, and several other children, they embark on a journey into new and foreign lands.
I enjoyed this book just as much as I did the first two, and I enjoyed the ending even more so. One way to get me hooked is featuring strong women, and this book had plenty of them. Some of them were physically strong, while some were spiritually strong. I appreciated the diversity.
One of my favorite aspects of the book was the twist surprise villain. No spoilers, but I managed to figure it out. ;)
Overall, I'd say this was my favorite book in the series so far. I look forward to more books like these.
I received a free copy of this book from the author/publisher, for my honest review. The opinions expressed here are my own.
Courageous is a compelling and interesting story about love finding you even when you're not even looking for it. We follow Randel and Rosalind, whom are led by a prophetic vision from God, to find and rescue some of his people. Along with Sapphira, the one who got the message, and several other children, they embark on a journey into new and foreign lands.
I enjoyed this book just as much as I did the first two, and I enjoyed the ending even more so. One way to get me hooked is featuring strong women, and this book had plenty of them. Some of them were physically strong, while some were spiritually strong. I appreciated the diversity.
One of my favorite aspects of the book was the twist surprise villain. No spoilers, but I managed to figure it out. ;)
Overall, I'd say this was my favorite book in the series so far. I look forward to more books like these.
I received a free copy of this book from the author/publisher, for my honest review. The opinions expressed here are my own.
February 27, 2019
I LOVED the first two books in the Valiant Hearts series. Sadly I didn’t enjoy this one as much and I have specific reasons as to why. It’s not the characters nor the plot; the main characters are nicely developed and likable and the plot is engaging and exciting.
However I just had some MAJOR issues with certain things. One, the author did a nice job writing sympathetic likable Muslim characters despite the ingrained prejudice of the European MCs and the not-likable “bad guys” that were also Muslim. I loved Rabia, she was such a good character! We had discussion about Christian/Muslim similarities! Yay! But then at the end Rabia converts to Christianity. To be fair her father doesn’t but still. I feel like it would have been better to just let Rabia keep her original beliefs AND keep her new Christian friends.
Two. I really really did not like how Sapphira’s and the others’ praying IMMEDIATELY fixes Randel’s very obvious PTSD problems. Nor did I like how it’s presented like it’s some dark/satanic issue threatening him and other characters have to get rid of it with the power of prayer. That’s a horrible message to send to readers. Mental trauma isn’t going to insta-fix when your friends pray for you. This was the worst issue with this book in my opinion.
Three, I’m not sure I like the way Jocelyn was handled. I don’t consider this a spoiler because I saw it from the beginning but connecting her promiscuous ways with being a horrible evil person is...not the best. I don’t know. Later something horrible happens to her and it comes off as “well she got what she deserved” even though Rosalind and others do not treat her as such..
I’m so sorry to be writing a negative review of this book because the first two were SO good (Chivalrous especially was ah-mazing!!) and also, after reading the author’s note at the end, I believe she had very good intentions writing this story. But this is just the way I feel. Courageous is not a bad book but I just feel like there are issues I can’t overlook.
However I just had some MAJOR issues with certain things. One, the author did a nice job writing sympathetic likable Muslim characters despite the ingrained prejudice of the European MCs and the not-likable “bad guys” that were also Muslim. I loved Rabia, she was such a good character! We had discussion about Christian/Muslim similarities! Yay! But then at the end Rabia converts to Christianity. To be fair her father doesn’t but still. I feel like it would have been better to just let Rabia keep her original beliefs AND keep her new Christian friends.
Two. I really really did not like how Sapphira’s and the others’ praying IMMEDIATELY fixes Randel’s very obvious PTSD problems. Nor did I like how it’s presented like it’s some dark/satanic issue threatening him and other characters have to get rid of it with the power of prayer. That’s a horrible message to send to readers. Mental trauma isn’t going to insta-fix when your friends pray for you. This was the worst issue with this book in my opinion.
Three, I’m not sure I like the way Jocelyn was handled. I don’t consider this a spoiler because I saw it from the beginning but connecting her promiscuous ways with being a horrible evil person is...not the best. I don’t know. Later something horrible happens to her and it comes off as “well she got what she deserved” even though Rosalind and others do not treat her as such..
I’m so sorry to be writing a negative review of this book because the first two were SO good (Chivalrous especially was ah-mazing!!) and also, after reading the author’s note at the end, I believe she had very good intentions writing this story. But this is just the way I feel. Courageous is not a bad book but I just feel like there are issues I can’t overlook.
July 13, 2016
Several characters in this story wrestle with spiritual issues, attempt to discern what is God’s will in various situations, and seek truth, faith, and the peace of God. Initially, since the story touches on differences in religions and spiritual beliefs, I was hopeful that it would have a powerful message of redemption, a loving presentation of the truth of the Bible, and a clear distinction between the Christianity of the Bible and the heartbreaking errors of belief held by the other religions in the story.
While all three of these hopes were partially realized, I was severely disappointed overall. First, there was only a very vague and shallow description of redemption in the lives of a couple of the struggling characters, and the ‘peace’ they received came to them supposedly simply through attending a ‘prayer meeting’ held by a group of children. Receiving of the Lord’s peace and forgiveness is certainly possible to anyone who expresses true repentance of sin! But since it is a personal matter, it must be dealt with personally - must be taken up by the individual and settled between the Lord and them alone. This type of scene was not related. Second, while the Gospel (the fact that Jesus Christ made the atoning sacrifice for mankind by dying on the cross, then rising from the dead, and that faith in Him and belief on Him is the only way a man’s or woman’s sins are covered and they can get to Heaven) was presented/touched on in a couple of places, it was vague and unclear; it was certainly not stressed, though there were several excellent opportunities for the characters to do so, even enhancing the impact of the story. Third, a clear distinction between the religious beliefs of the characters was just not there. There were even conversations among the characters, discussing how their religions were different, then stating that they were ‘not so very different from each other’. I found this disturbing. Either you have the truth, or you do not. Either you are believing the truth, or you are believing a lie, no matter how sincerely. And sadly, so many believe lies.
Overall, I felt that the author’s stand on the fundamental teachings of God’s Word was shaky, at best. This is the primary reason I must say that I was disappointed in this book.
There were a few other issues that I personally did not appreciate. One was that, though intimate immorality was discussed and portrayed as wrong, there were several kisses shared by an unmarried man and woman, and this was treated as if it was fine. The other was that there were ‘women knights’, and women actively involved in battles. Even the author concedes that this is not historically accurate – traditionally, while women sometimes were trained in self-defense skills or as archers, the men were the knights, the protectors, and the guards for the women and the children precious to them.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review.
While all three of these hopes were partially realized, I was severely disappointed overall. First, there was only a very vague and shallow description of redemption in the lives of a couple of the struggling characters, and the ‘peace’ they received came to them supposedly simply through attending a ‘prayer meeting’ held by a group of children. Receiving of the Lord’s peace and forgiveness is certainly possible to anyone who expresses true repentance of sin! But since it is a personal matter, it must be dealt with personally - must be taken up by the individual and settled between the Lord and them alone. This type of scene was not related. Second, while the Gospel (the fact that Jesus Christ made the atoning sacrifice for mankind by dying on the cross, then rising from the dead, and that faith in Him and belief on Him is the only way a man’s or woman’s sins are covered and they can get to Heaven) was presented/touched on in a couple of places, it was vague and unclear; it was certainly not stressed, though there were several excellent opportunities for the characters to do so, even enhancing the impact of the story. Third, a clear distinction between the religious beliefs of the characters was just not there. There were even conversations among the characters, discussing how their religions were different, then stating that they were ‘not so very different from each other’. I found this disturbing. Either you have the truth, or you do not. Either you are believing the truth, or you are believing a lie, no matter how sincerely. And sadly, so many believe lies.
Overall, I felt that the author’s stand on the fundamental teachings of God’s Word was shaky, at best. This is the primary reason I must say that I was disappointed in this book.
There were a few other issues that I personally did not appreciate. One was that, though intimate immorality was discussed and portrayed as wrong, there were several kisses shared by an unmarried man and woman, and this was treated as if it was fine. The other was that there were ‘women knights’, and women actively involved in battles. Even the author concedes that this is not historically accurate – traditionally, while women sometimes were trained in self-defense skills or as archers, the men were the knights, the protectors, and the guards for the women and the children precious to them.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review.
July 12, 2016
I have read and enjoyed Dina Sleiman's first two books in the Valiant Hearts series, Dauntless and Chivalrous. Even though the books are young adult novels, I enjoyed spending time jumping back into the historical realm of the middle ages and following the heroines and heroes on their journeys. With Courageous, there is no exception.
I believe the most important aspect of a historical novel is the research. If the research isn't done right, than the story falls apart. Sleiman has definitely done her research. With all the information into the Muslim heritage with what they believe to the Crusades to the Holy Land with the children Crusades to Jerusalem, I never once doubted Sleiman's story. She wrapped me in this original adventure and took me for a great ride. I enjoyed the novel, but there are moments where the story drags and features repeated actions, for instance, battle, camp, battle, camp. I still enjoyed the novel though. The setting of traveling through the wilderness to accomplish what they have believed God allowed them to do jumps off the page.
What would a crusade story be without some sort of lesson to take away? With Courageous, Sleiman does a good job at allowing the heroine, Rosalind, and the hero, Randel to fight and struggle with their past mistakes. But they both learn the power of God's forgives and his ability to allow them to forgive themselves and move on with their life. Because of God's grace, Rosalind and Randel were able to fall in love and move forward with their life. Randel and Rosalind both have a desire to protect and love children. It brought out the innocence and purity from their past mistakes.
Courageous is written in Randel, Rosalind, and the person seeking revenge's perspective. The dialogue matched the characters. Even the internal monologues showed the struggle all three of these characters experienced throughout the book. The pace of the prose and dialogue moved at a good clip. Once I was engrossed in the story, I did not get taken out of the story.
With Dina Sleiman's conclusion to her Valiant Heart series, Courageous is a great researched novel that reminds me a lot of a Arthurian legend with the hunt of something greater than oneself. With a memorable cast and a unique premise, Courageous is a book that will stay with me long after I finished the novel. A must read for fans of Dina Sleiman's other books and fans of Melanie Dickerson.
I received a complimentary copy of Dina Sleiman's Courageous from Bethany House Publishers and the opinions stated are all my own.
I believe the most important aspect of a historical novel is the research. If the research isn't done right, than the story falls apart. Sleiman has definitely done her research. With all the information into the Muslim heritage with what they believe to the Crusades to the Holy Land with the children Crusades to Jerusalem, I never once doubted Sleiman's story. She wrapped me in this original adventure and took me for a great ride. I enjoyed the novel, but there are moments where the story drags and features repeated actions, for instance, battle, camp, battle, camp. I still enjoyed the novel though. The setting of traveling through the wilderness to accomplish what they have believed God allowed them to do jumps off the page.
What would a crusade story be without some sort of lesson to take away? With Courageous, Sleiman does a good job at allowing the heroine, Rosalind, and the hero, Randel to fight and struggle with their past mistakes. But they both learn the power of God's forgives and his ability to allow them to forgive themselves and move on with their life. Because of God's grace, Rosalind and Randel were able to fall in love and move forward with their life. Randel and Rosalind both have a desire to protect and love children. It brought out the innocence and purity from their past mistakes.
Courageous is written in Randel, Rosalind, and the person seeking revenge's perspective. The dialogue matched the characters. Even the internal monologues showed the struggle all three of these characters experienced throughout the book. The pace of the prose and dialogue moved at a good clip. Once I was engrossed in the story, I did not get taken out of the story.
With Dina Sleiman's conclusion to her Valiant Heart series, Courageous is a great researched novel that reminds me a lot of a Arthurian legend with the hunt of something greater than oneself. With a memorable cast and a unique premise, Courageous is a book that will stay with me long after I finished the novel. A must read for fans of Dina Sleiman's other books and fans of Melanie Dickerson.
I received a complimentary copy of Dina Sleiman's Courageous from Bethany House Publishers and the opinions stated are all my own.
November 25, 2016
I highly recommend reading Dina L. Sleiman's Valiant Hearts trilogy. Each book is set during the medieval time period with complex characters making hard choices. The books have aspects that bring to mind heroes from legends, like Robin Hood. This book has a character who is a young lady who has visions from God. She reminds me of Joan of Arc.
This book is set during the Crusades. Honestly, the Crusades are a point in history that bother me. It is easy to look back on history and not agree with what our fore-bearers did. This book gave me a different perspective and a little bit of appreciation for the religious fervor that sparked the Crusades. The issues are complex and Sleiman presented them in a way that helped me understand the reasons why the Catholic Church went to war for the Holy Land. I appreciated the Muslim perspective as well. Both sides were represented respectfully.
The story is told from four perspectives: Randel, Rosalind, Sapphira, and the villain. It took me a while to figure out who the villain in the story was. There were several people who seemed to stand out and have the anger that I expected. I didn't figure it out until about 3/4 of the book, just before it was revealed.
The book also talks about forgiveness. Forgiveness from God and forgiving yourself. Many people in this story make mistakes. I loved how freely forgiveness was given and love was granted. It is a reminder not to be so hard on ourselves and the love that the Father has for his children.
The romance is sweet and clean. The book has war violence, innuendo, and kissing.
This book is set during the Crusades. Honestly, the Crusades are a point in history that bother me. It is easy to look back on history and not agree with what our fore-bearers did. This book gave me a different perspective and a little bit of appreciation for the religious fervor that sparked the Crusades. The issues are complex and Sleiman presented them in a way that helped me understand the reasons why the Catholic Church went to war for the Holy Land. I appreciated the Muslim perspective as well. Both sides were represented respectfully.
The story is told from four perspectives: Randel, Rosalind, Sapphira, and the villain. It took me a while to figure out who the villain in the story was. There were several people who seemed to stand out and have the anger that I expected. I didn't figure it out until about 3/4 of the book, just before it was revealed.
The book also talks about forgiveness. Forgiveness from God and forgiving yourself. Many people in this story make mistakes. I loved how freely forgiveness was given and love was granted. It is a reminder not to be so hard on ourselves and the love that the Father has for his children.
The romance is sweet and clean. The book has war violence, innuendo, and kissing.
July 21, 2016
I really enjoyed the diversity of characters in this story. I knew Rosalind would be on a crusade, but I didn't realize how much the children would be involved. I grew attached I think to almost all of them and loved seeing the spiritual growth in each of them.
For some reason I didn't fully connect with Rosalind as I had connected with the two previous heroines in this series. Surprisingly, I very much enjoyed Lady Sapphira and her story. I didn't expect for her to be one of my favorite character's, but she quickly became it. It was amazing to see her bold faith and trust! Leo was another character that quickly became a second favorite. He usually always brought a smile to my face.
One reason I did not give this novel a full five stars is the romance between Rosalind and Randel. I'm not quite sure why, but I didn't quite grow attached to their budding relationship.
Overall, this was a great adventure of a read! I definitely would recommend this series to younger and older teens as it had a beautiful message of faith, trust, love, and salvation.
*(I received this novel from the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
For some reason I didn't fully connect with Rosalind as I had connected with the two previous heroines in this series. Surprisingly, I very much enjoyed Lady Sapphira and her story. I didn't expect for her to be one of my favorite character's, but she quickly became it. It was amazing to see her bold faith and trust! Leo was another character that quickly became a second favorite. He usually always brought a smile to my face.
One reason I did not give this novel a full five stars is the romance between Rosalind and Randel. I'm not quite sure why, but I didn't quite grow attached to their budding relationship.
Overall, this was a great adventure of a read! I definitely would recommend this series to younger and older teens as it had a beautiful message of faith, trust, love, and salvation.
*(I received this novel from the author in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts expressed are my own.)*
July 12, 2016
Review coming soon... http://www.faithfullybookish.com
Rosalind and Sir Randel embark on a treacherous adventure with a large load of emotional baggage. Rosalind is still determined to deny herself any happiness as she continues to grieve her unborn child. Sir Randel has regrets of his own haunting him in his dreams and occasionally snatching his awareness during the day.
Although I enjoyed the first two books of this series, Courageous quickly sailed away from my expectations and my heart just wouldn’t go along for the ride. Even though the plot wasn’t my cup of tea, I liked the characters and the thread of redemption was beautifully woven through their struggles. Watching both Rosalind and Sir Randel learn to forgive themselves and accept God’s grace as sufficient was an encouraging reminder to do the same in my own non-fiction life!
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
Rosalind and Sir Randel embark on a treacherous adventure with a large load of emotional baggage. Rosalind is still determined to deny herself any happiness as she continues to grieve her unborn child. Sir Randel has regrets of his own haunting him in his dreams and occasionally snatching his awareness during the day.
Although I enjoyed the first two books of this series, Courageous quickly sailed away from my expectations and my heart just wouldn’t go along for the ride. Even though the plot wasn’t my cup of tea, I liked the characters and the thread of redemption was beautifully woven through their struggles. Watching both Rosalind and Sir Randel learn to forgive themselves and accept God’s grace as sufficient was an encouraging reminder to do the same in my own non-fiction life!
I requested the opportunity to read and review this title through NetGalley. The opinions expressed are my own.
July 18, 2016
Another exciting adventure from Dina Sleiman. This is book three of her "Valiant Hearts" series and I'm hoping we'll see a book four. (Because we need to know what's happening to Sadie next, right?)
Set during the Crusades, Sleiman takes us to the Middle East during a very turbulent time in history. Sir Randel Penigree and Rosalind of Ispswich are in charge of a troop of children who sail on ships filled with crusaders. They are following the leading of Lady Sapphira, herself a child, who has had a vision from the Lord. Along the way, they'll see battle, lose loved ones, mingle with Muslims, and find that doing the Lord's work doesn't always end the way they assumed it would.
Engaging characters, beautifully expressed historical setting, and enough action to keep readers turning the pages. There's even a bit of a mystery, a who-done-it, in the middle of it all. Young adults will love it, but please, don't overlook these books just because you happen to be an adult!
Set during the Crusades, Sleiman takes us to the Middle East during a very turbulent time in history. Sir Randel Penigree and Rosalind of Ispswich are in charge of a troop of children who sail on ships filled with crusaders. They are following the leading of Lady Sapphira, herself a child, who has had a vision from the Lord. Along the way, they'll see battle, lose loved ones, mingle with Muslims, and find that doing the Lord's work doesn't always end the way they assumed it would.
Engaging characters, beautifully expressed historical setting, and enough action to keep readers turning the pages. There's even a bit of a mystery, a who-done-it, in the middle of it all. Young adults will love it, but please, don't overlook these books just because you happen to be an adult!
November 12, 2019
A great way to end a pretty neat series! I love how all of Dina’s books are in completely different settings, all with awesome characters that show up throughout the three novels.
This book was incredible with all the elements of faith and prayer, and I loved reading about the Muslim faith and how it worked alongside Christianity. Beautiful.
I actually loved this book!!
This book was incredible with all the elements of faith and prayer, and I loved reading about the Muslim faith and how it worked alongside Christianity. Beautiful.
I actually loved this book!!
August 14, 2017
This is my favourite in the Valiant Hearts series. Rosalind of Ipsworth was a minor character in the previous book but in this novel she comes into her own. The tragic mistake of her past haunts her, making her perhaps a more rounded character than the other heroines of the series. Sir Randel Penigree is also haunted by the past - an accident in which he killed one of the troops in his charge.
I didn't particularly like the literary device used to keep the villain anonymous, even when as a reader I was privy to the villain's point-of-view. It felt forced. Still, I felt this was the book in the series with the richest and most nuanced texture, character-wise. It felt like there was a lot more at stake here than in the other novels. With its background of the Crusades and shadowy political intrigue amongst even the defenders of the faith, there was a lot less surety that the promised happy-ever-after of a romance would actually eventuate.
I didn't particularly like the literary device used to keep the villain anonymous, even when as a reader I was privy to the villain's point-of-view. It felt forced. Still, I felt this was the book in the series with the richest and most nuanced texture, character-wise. It felt like there was a lot more at stake here than in the other novels. With its background of the Crusades and shadowy political intrigue amongst even the defenders of the faith, there was a lot less surety that the promised happy-ever-after of a romance would actually eventuate.
February 10, 2023
Will write a review for this soon!
July 20, 2016
A new tale, a new heroine, and a great conclusion to the trilogy!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review. The views expressed in this review are my own.
Rosalind of Ipsworth has shouldered a burden for a sin she has committed for a long time. Determined to atone, she trains to take part in the crusades. The Duke’s niece had a vision to go on a crusade and release the captives from the Holy Land. She also saw that children should be included in this crusade. Rosalind is assigned to oversee the children, but can also fight if she must. Once this is over, she will join the church convent to play out the rest of her life. But for some reason, young men seem to feel that she is available for their courtship. Of anybody, she feels most connected to Sir Randel Penigree, but he is also destined for a life of solitude as a warrior monk.
Sir Randel Penigree is haunted by his past involvement in wars. In an unfortunate battle in England, his entire regiment was destroyed by the Scots. He even accidentally killed one of his own men and carries that with him everywhere. Now he has been tasked to lead the army going on the crusades. However, someone is with the group that wants to avenge the previous death he caused and stop at nothing to complete it. Will Randel be able to become a warrior monk or will he meet his own doom at the crusades?
Thank you Dina Sleiman for continuing Rosalind’s story. In my review of Chilvarous I concluded by pleading with the author to write Rosalind’s story for the next book and I’m so glad that she delivered. This was a story about courage, but even more about forgiveness. Both of the main characters, Rosalind and Randel, were carrying their burdens even after they had been forgiven. They couldn’t forgive themselves. But with the help of Father Andrew, they finally see that they have been set free.
The story lime is similar to the other two books. The two main characters have a love story. There is a villain that is after the male main character. In the end, hope prevails and love conquers all. But it is a really good read and highly recommended.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review. The views expressed in this review are my own.
Rosalind of Ipsworth has shouldered a burden for a sin she has committed for a long time. Determined to atone, she trains to take part in the crusades. The Duke’s niece had a vision to go on a crusade and release the captives from the Holy Land. She also saw that children should be included in this crusade. Rosalind is assigned to oversee the children, but can also fight if she must. Once this is over, she will join the church convent to play out the rest of her life. But for some reason, young men seem to feel that she is available for their courtship. Of anybody, she feels most connected to Sir Randel Penigree, but he is also destined for a life of solitude as a warrior monk.
Sir Randel Penigree is haunted by his past involvement in wars. In an unfortunate battle in England, his entire regiment was destroyed by the Scots. He even accidentally killed one of his own men and carries that with him everywhere. Now he has been tasked to lead the army going on the crusades. However, someone is with the group that wants to avenge the previous death he caused and stop at nothing to complete it. Will Randel be able to become a warrior monk or will he meet his own doom at the crusades?
Thank you Dina Sleiman for continuing Rosalind’s story. In my review of Chilvarous I concluded by pleading with the author to write Rosalind’s story for the next book and I’m so glad that she delivered. This was a story about courage, but even more about forgiveness. Both of the main characters, Rosalind and Randel, were carrying their burdens even after they had been forgiven. They couldn’t forgive themselves. But with the help of Father Andrew, they finally see that they have been set free.
The story lime is similar to the other two books. The two main characters have a love story. There is a villain that is after the male main character. In the end, hope prevails and love conquers all. But it is a really good read and highly recommended.
September 28, 2016
Haunted by their past mistakes and hoping to make penance, Rosalind and Randel join a group of men, women, and children on a crusade to the Holy Lands. While on the ship, Rosalind and Randel find themselves partnering to train and care for the small group of children on the crusade. Their friendship grows ever closer, and Randel and Rosalind soon agree to pretend to court each other to discourage the other single adults on the journey. But the dangers of falling in love are nothing compared to what awaits them in the Holy Land.
Courageous is the third book in the Valiant Hearts Series by Dina Sleiman. Though some of the characters are the same as in previous books, it is largely a standalone featuring a new journey, setting, and romance. And did I mention women and children warriors? The setting takes the characters to the Holy Land in the Middle East, and it is fraught with war, political stress, and religious differences as it continues to be in the present. Sometimes, there is no way to know who is really on your side.
The themes were the most memorable parts of this story. One major theme was guilt and its effects. Both the main characters were wracked with guilt over the things they had done, but they refused to forgive themselves of it or seek God for forgiveness. And since they both had guilt, they could better understand and help each other through it. Another theme worth mentioning centered on religious differences. There is some controversy over whether the crusades should have ever been fought, since today’s society teaches religious tolerance and since some of the wars were so needlessly brutal. Courageous touches on these topics and creates an acceptable compromise through the characters actions; they learned to work with the Muslims and respect and befriend them even in their differences.
Courageous was a fascinating adventure with memorable characters and epic plot twists! I recommend it to readers of YA historical fiction.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Courageous is the third book in the Valiant Hearts Series by Dina Sleiman. Though some of the characters are the same as in previous books, it is largely a standalone featuring a new journey, setting, and romance. And did I mention women and children warriors? The setting takes the characters to the Holy Land in the Middle East, and it is fraught with war, political stress, and religious differences as it continues to be in the present. Sometimes, there is no way to know who is really on your side.
The themes were the most memorable parts of this story. One major theme was guilt and its effects. Both the main characters were wracked with guilt over the things they had done, but they refused to forgive themselves of it or seek God for forgiveness. And since they both had guilt, they could better understand and help each other through it. Another theme worth mentioning centered on religious differences. There is some controversy over whether the crusades should have ever been fought, since today’s society teaches religious tolerance and since some of the wars were so needlessly brutal. Courageous touches on these topics and creates an acceptable compromise through the characters actions; they learned to work with the Muslims and respect and befriend them even in their differences.
Courageous was a fascinating adventure with memorable characters and epic plot twists! I recommend it to readers of YA historical fiction.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
September 29, 2016
When I first heard about this author's debut novel I was instantly intrigued and I knew I had to read it. I was lucky to get a copy for review and I loved it so I eagerly awaited book two, hoping it would live up to its predecessor. And it gloriously did, earning this author a spot on my must read list. So this third book had a lot to live up to and thankfully it was as good as the first two!
I can honestly say I have never read a book that centered around a crusade so this was an entirely know new territory for me. But it was a very interesting setting!
We got to meet Rosalind in the last book and Randall made some appearances so I was excited to see where their story would take them and how it would play out. I loved the way that their easy friendship slowly blossomed into something deeper, even though they had both decided marriage wasn't in the cards for them. Both had pasts that haunted them and it seemed like they both centered their lives around trying to atone for the things they had done. So it was beautiful to watch as they learned to accept that God had truly forgiven them and that they were not defined by the sins they had committed.
The mystery of who was the traitor in the group who wanted Randall dead kept me guessing until it was revealed and it was fun trying to figure it out.
There were a few bits near the end that didn't seem to flow as smoothly as the rest and seemed a bit forced, but it didn't detract from my enjoyment of this book! I really liked the very end and getting to see all of the characters together!
So basically this book (and the series it is a part of) is amazing and you definitely need to read them!
I received this book free from the publisher in exchange for my review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
I can honestly say I have never read a book that centered around a crusade so this was an entirely know new territory for me. But it was a very interesting setting!
We got to meet Rosalind in the last book and Randall made some appearances so I was excited to see where their story would take them and how it would play out. I loved the way that their easy friendship slowly blossomed into something deeper, even though they had both decided marriage wasn't in the cards for them. Both had pasts that haunted them and it seemed like they both centered their lives around trying to atone for the things they had done. So it was beautiful to watch as they learned to accept that God had truly forgiven them and that they were not defined by the sins they had committed.
The mystery of who was the traitor in the group who wanted Randall dead kept me guessing until it was revealed and it was fun trying to figure it out.
There were a few bits near the end that didn't seem to flow as smoothly as the rest and seemed a bit forced, but it didn't detract from my enjoyment of this book! I really liked the very end and getting to see all of the characters together!
So basically this book (and the series it is a part of) is amazing and you definitely need to read them!
I received this book free from the publisher in exchange for my review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
July 17, 2016
Books geared toward young adults today are filled with images and insinuation some parents don’t want their kids immersed in. They probably get plenty of those things hanging around their unchurched friends at school. So it is encouraging that some authors are offering engaging, well-written coming-of-age stories that are not only entertaining but filled with a message of hope and salvation.
Dina Sleiman’s “Valiant Heart” series is one that offers adventure while at the same time offering a positive message. Book three in this series, “Courageous,” is the best yet.
Rosalind of Ispwich is determined to atone for her greatest sin—the one that haunts her and drives her forward. She believes that joining Sapphira’s crusade to help free captives in Tripoli will help God forgive her. Together with Sir Randel Pennigree, Rosalind helps train and care for the children brought along. As the two for a plan to ward of unwanted attention from others on the ship, each of the two adults begin to confront their past shame.
This story has so much to entertain readers—battles, miracles, fights—but the true heart of this story is the children. The children whose job is to support the knights and soldiers in prayer. Led by young Sapphira who listens to God with her whole heart, each of the children as well as Randel and Rosalind change as they listen to God’s direction for both battle and for their lives.
****Bethany House Publishers provided me with a complimentary copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest and fair review. All opinions expressed are my own
Dina Sleiman’s “Valiant Heart” series is one that offers adventure while at the same time offering a positive message. Book three in this series, “Courageous,” is the best yet.
Rosalind of Ispwich is determined to atone for her greatest sin—the one that haunts her and drives her forward. She believes that joining Sapphira’s crusade to help free captives in Tripoli will help God forgive her. Together with Sir Randel Pennigree, Rosalind helps train and care for the children brought along. As the two for a plan to ward of unwanted attention from others on the ship, each of the two adults begin to confront their past shame.
This story has so much to entertain readers—battles, miracles, fights—but the true heart of this story is the children. The children whose job is to support the knights and soldiers in prayer. Led by young Sapphira who listens to God with her whole heart, each of the children as well as Randel and Rosalind change as they listen to God’s direction for both battle and for their lives.
****Bethany House Publishers provided me with a complimentary copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest and fair review. All opinions expressed are my own
September 4, 2016
Crusade stories can be hit or miss for me, as I do not always agree with the author's interpretation of what happened. This story started out a bit shaky on that ground, though as the story progressed I found more that I agreed with. While I cannot say I was satisfied with all the characters' decisions and conclusions toward the end, I can say that I was overall satisfied with the story.
Randel and Rosalind are two characters who have committed tragic acts in the past and continue to punish themselves. Like many people who went on Crusade in history, their goal is to find some form of absolution. Instead, they come to terms with the realization that there is nothing they can do, only God's grace is sufficient. It was a worthwhile message, along side that of Lady Sapphira, who struggles with the weight of following God's call on her life.
Overall, the story is less a love story between to characters and instead a love story between the characters and God. That is what I most appreciated about this story and would recommend it to anyone looking for more than the typical romance.
I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Randel and Rosalind are two characters who have committed tragic acts in the past and continue to punish themselves. Like many people who went on Crusade in history, their goal is to find some form of absolution. Instead, they come to terms with the realization that there is nothing they can do, only God's grace is sufficient. It was a worthwhile message, along side that of Lady Sapphira, who struggles with the weight of following God's call on her life.
Overall, the story is less a love story between to characters and instead a love story between the characters and God. That is what I most appreciated about this story and would recommend it to anyone looking for more than the typical romance.
I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
July 22, 2016
This is another incredible medieval tale!
This is a stand-alone story. A number of the characters were in secondary roles in the earlier books in the series but there is enough information included in this book about them that you don’t need to have read either of the previous novels before this one.
I loved getting to know more about Rosalind and meeting Randel. They are both wonderful though flawed characters. They each have deep seated guilt that they are carrying from things that have happened in their pasts. They each have a journey to travel to try and deal with their guilt and learn to accept God’s love and forgiveness as truth.
I thoroughly enjoyed the action and battle scenes. Part of what I liked was that there are no graphic details given and yet the fear and focus that the knights and other fighters experienced was clearly expressed.
The other aspect of this group of crusaders and their battles was the attention that they had on prayer and seeking God’s guidance. This is how I believe we are all supposed to live and I love it when that is how the characters in books live as well.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
This is a stand-alone story. A number of the characters were in secondary roles in the earlier books in the series but there is enough information included in this book about them that you don’t need to have read either of the previous novels before this one.
I loved getting to know more about Rosalind and meeting Randel. They are both wonderful though flawed characters. They each have deep seated guilt that they are carrying from things that have happened in their pasts. They each have a journey to travel to try and deal with their guilt and learn to accept God’s love and forgiveness as truth.
I thoroughly enjoyed the action and battle scenes. Part of what I liked was that there are no graphic details given and yet the fear and focus that the knights and other fighters experienced was clearly expressed.
The other aspect of this group of crusaders and their battles was the attention that they had on prayer and seeking God’s guidance. This is how I believe we are all supposed to live and I love it when that is how the characters in books live as well.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for my honest review.
September 10, 2016
Ah, the third and final installment of the lovely Valient Hearts series. I have enjoyed each one of them.
"Courageous" was a great book and a great finish to the series. Sad to see them end, but they are a great collection and one I am ever so pleased to own! Not to mention, they are utterly beautiful to look at!
I only had one concern about the book; In my opinion, it gave off the impression that all religions are almost equal, as if we all worship the same God, just differently. However, we don't all worship the same God. There is only one living God. And I wish that would have been clearly and strongly portrayed.
(Of course I am not saying at all that we are to hate other religions - but we definitely don't want to conform to them or blend their religious customs into Christianity).
But otherwise, I did greatly enjoy this book, and look forward to revisiting the entire series. :) They're very well written.
I would recommend it to ages 16+
*Dina Sleiman was kind enough to bless me with a copy of this book for free. I was not required to review, and all thoughts are entirely my own.
"Courageous" was a great book and a great finish to the series. Sad to see them end, but they are a great collection and one I am ever so pleased to own! Not to mention, they are utterly beautiful to look at!
I only had one concern about the book; In my opinion, it gave off the impression that all religions are almost equal, as if we all worship the same God, just differently. However, we don't all worship the same God. There is only one living God. And I wish that would have been clearly and strongly portrayed.
(Of course I am not saying at all that we are to hate other religions - but we definitely don't want to conform to them or blend their religious customs into Christianity).
But otherwise, I did greatly enjoy this book, and look forward to revisiting the entire series. :) They're very well written.
I would recommend it to ages 16+
*Dina Sleiman was kind enough to bless me with a copy of this book for free. I was not required to review, and all thoughts are entirely my own.
September 5, 2016
Dina Sleiman's third entry in her Valiant Hearts series continues the journey into the medieval era with a trip to the Holy Land during the Crusades. Rich in historical detail, full of the grace of God, this one completes the series. It's quite clear Sleiman has done her homework with her detail research into the era and events. Quite an adventure with some romance thrown in, we read Rosalind's story. She was a secondary character in last book, Chivalrous. Rosalind carries the weight of a grievous sin, not understanding that God has already forgotten it when she repented. Sir Randel also carries a weight in his heart. God is able to set these two free if they will allow His healing to flood their hearts.
*I was gifted with a copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
*I was gifted with a copy of this book by the publisher in exchange for my honest review, which I have given.
January 9, 2020
3.5 Stars
Staying in the same 13th century setting as the earlier novels, we now meet seventeen year old Rosalind of Ipsworth, an employee of Sir Allen and Lady Gwendolyn (introduced in Chivalrous, Valiant Hearts #2). With the community having recently been spiritually moved by the divine visions experienced by thirteen year old Lady Sapphira, the decision is made to put together a group to travel to the Holy Land to hopefully free Christians being held captive by Muslim soldiers. One of the captives, Lord Richard De Montfort, is brother of Duchess Adela De Montfort and cousin of Lady Sapphira.
This Holy Land party made up of mostly women and children, with a few men as well, seek to defend the cross and free Christians being held captive in Tripoli. There is also hope that Christian forces can overthrow Muslim rule currently reigning over the area. Lady Gwendolyn and Rosalind trained together in combat arts with this mission in mind, but once Gwen discovers she is with child, she urges Rosalind to continue on without her. Officially, Rosalind's role will be to watch over the young girls in the group as well as serve as special attendant to Lady Sapphira. Though that may be professional position on this trip, her internal motivation is the hope that going on this crusade will help ease the guilt plaguing her in connection to a horrible mistake from her past.
Also along on the journey are Sadie, one of the original Farthingale Forest Ghosts, and Randel Penigree, a close friend of Sir Allen & Lady Gwen. Randel's greatest desire is to have enough success on this crusade to finally win the approval of his parents and secure a spot as a warrior monk for the Templar Knights. Sir Randel's position is to train the young boys of the group as reinforcement soldiers. Working together with the groups of children, Rosalind and Randel's friendship continues to grow. Though it verges on turning into something deeper, both hesitate to acknowledge anything beyond the platonic, as they both carry secrets that convince them neither are suited for committed relationships... unless it's to the church.
Courageous, in my opinion, had the most cinematic (epic is scope / description) scenes of the entire trilogy. Additionally, the plot also periodically provides some intrigue, in the moments when the POV switches from third to first person. This first person narrator is unidentified for most of the book, and clues to their identity are kept minimal. The one point that is made clear is that they want Sir Randel dead... and there are just enough clues provided to show the reader that this mystery person is someone who is clearly within close proximity to Randel pretty much all the time, but that they are waiting for just the right moment to carry out their plan.
Though this is technically a historical fiction piece, only minimal portions of the plot are spent actually focusing on that aspect. The majority of the storytelling focuses on the various romances within this group of people. Not that the characters and these relationships aren't entertaining, but I was a little disappointed to see that so early in the novel the plot is already falling on the romance trope of "let's fake a romance but then oops, we're probably going to fall in love for real". On top of that, for being a woman of the 12th century, Rosalind's mannerisms and dialogue often read pretty modern.
One of the best take-aways from this novel is the way in which Sleiman's story brings home the fact that while the children of these Crusade missions might have been blessed with visions and extraordinary strength and grit, at the heart they were still CHILDREN, with all the same fears and concerns of any other child that age. All in all, this was nearly a 4 star read for me, minus some issues here and there... the main one being the closing chapters. I didn't love the underlying tone the stories of some of these characters creates: this unspoken stance that Christians are better than Muslims and that Muslims, for the most part, needed to be killed, captured, converted, or shunned... and though friendships might be established, the friendships were ultimately stronger if everyone could come around to the Christian faith. While I get that this is, at the end of the day, a Christian fiction work, it bothered me that this trilogy would close on that note.
FTC DISCLAIMER: Bethany House Publishing kindly provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The opinions above are entirely my own.
Staying in the same 13th century setting as the earlier novels, we now meet seventeen year old Rosalind of Ipsworth, an employee of Sir Allen and Lady Gwendolyn (introduced in Chivalrous, Valiant Hearts #2). With the community having recently been spiritually moved by the divine visions experienced by thirteen year old Lady Sapphira, the decision is made to put together a group to travel to the Holy Land to hopefully free Christians being held captive by Muslim soldiers. One of the captives, Lord Richard De Montfort, is brother of Duchess Adela De Montfort and cousin of Lady Sapphira.
This Holy Land party made up of mostly women and children, with a few men as well, seek to defend the cross and free Christians being held captive in Tripoli. There is also hope that Christian forces can overthrow Muslim rule currently reigning over the area. Lady Gwendolyn and Rosalind trained together in combat arts with this mission in mind, but once Gwen discovers she is with child, she urges Rosalind to continue on without her. Officially, Rosalind's role will be to watch over the young girls in the group as well as serve as special attendant to Lady Sapphira. Though that may be professional position on this trip, her internal motivation is the hope that going on this crusade will help ease the guilt plaguing her in connection to a horrible mistake from her past.
Also along on the journey are Sadie, one of the original Farthingale Forest Ghosts, and Randel Penigree, a close friend of Sir Allen & Lady Gwen. Randel's greatest desire is to have enough success on this crusade to finally win the approval of his parents and secure a spot as a warrior monk for the Templar Knights. Sir Randel's position is to train the young boys of the group as reinforcement soldiers. Working together with the groups of children, Rosalind and Randel's friendship continues to grow. Though it verges on turning into something deeper, both hesitate to acknowledge anything beyond the platonic, as they both carry secrets that convince them neither are suited for committed relationships... unless it's to the church.
Courageous, in my opinion, had the most cinematic (epic is scope / description) scenes of the entire trilogy. Additionally, the plot also periodically provides some intrigue, in the moments when the POV switches from third to first person. This first person narrator is unidentified for most of the book, and clues to their identity are kept minimal. The one point that is made clear is that they want Sir Randel dead... and there are just enough clues provided to show the reader that this mystery person is someone who is clearly within close proximity to Randel pretty much all the time, but that they are waiting for just the right moment to carry out their plan.
Though this is technically a historical fiction piece, only minimal portions of the plot are spent actually focusing on that aspect. The majority of the storytelling focuses on the various romances within this group of people. Not that the characters and these relationships aren't entertaining, but I was a little disappointed to see that so early in the novel the plot is already falling on the romance trope of "let's fake a romance but then oops, we're probably going to fall in love for real". On top of that, for being a woman of the 12th century, Rosalind's mannerisms and dialogue often read pretty modern.
One of the best take-aways from this novel is the way in which Sleiman's story brings home the fact that while the children of these Crusade missions might have been blessed with visions and extraordinary strength and grit, at the heart they were still CHILDREN, with all the same fears and concerns of any other child that age. All in all, this was nearly a 4 star read for me, minus some issues here and there... the main one being the closing chapters. I didn't love the underlying tone the stories of some of these characters creates: this unspoken stance that Christians are better than Muslims and that Muslims, for the most part, needed to be killed, captured, converted, or shunned... and though friendships might be established, the friendships were ultimately stronger if everyone could come around to the Christian faith. While I get that this is, at the end of the day, a Christian fiction work, it bothered me that this trilogy would close on that note.
FTC DISCLAIMER: Bethany House Publishing kindly provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The opinions above are entirely my own.
March 18, 2024
It was a good end to the trilogy with high stakes, a sweet couple, and tales of redemption and salvation.
Though the setting of the Crusades was not my favorite, Sleiman told both the good and bad sides of the Christians and the good and bad sides of the Moslems.
Prayer and trust was an evident theme, though there were a lot of speech of visions and dreams so if that deters you I would not read the book. I believe in them so I did not have too much of a problem with them. I may have had some dreams from the Lord but never as direct as Sapphira in the book.
One of the downsides to the book (as well as the series) is that there was always a mysterious person out to kill one of the characters. And if I am remembering correctly, it is always the guy I feel like. And there is no redemption on their side. That saddens me because I love a good story where the antagonist is convicted and changes his ways. I do not believe there is anyone too far gone if they just humble themselves. But I did find that three people seeking to kill a main character to be overdone by this point and a bit unrealistic. I would like to see some spiritual warfare, though sometimes it IS through other people, but sometimes it is not. One does not need a plot of revenge or villain to make a good story with stakes.
I also wished that Sapphira and some of the other children had a bit more flaws and mistakes. For as young as they are, they were more often the heroes of the story than seasoned warriors. If I recall myself at their age, I was always making some mistake and being mouthy or something. The children seemed to be the adults and the adults seemed to act like children.
Overall, it was a pleasant and easy read. I enjoyed it and stayed up late multiple nights to read a few chapters.
If you want a sweet Christian romance set during the Crusades, it definitely fits the genre.
Though the setting of the Crusades was not my favorite, Sleiman told both the good and bad sides of the Christians and the good and bad sides of the Moslems.
Prayer and trust was an evident theme, though there were a lot of speech of visions and dreams so if that deters you I would not read the book. I believe in them so I did not have too much of a problem with them. I may have had some dreams from the Lord but never as direct as Sapphira in the book.
One of the downsides to the book (as well as the series) is that there was always a mysterious person out to kill one of the characters. And if I am remembering correctly, it is always the guy I feel like. And there is no redemption on their side. That saddens me because I love a good story where the antagonist is convicted and changes his ways. I do not believe there is anyone too far gone if they just humble themselves. But I did find that three people seeking to kill a main character to be overdone by this point and a bit unrealistic. I would like to see some spiritual warfare, though sometimes it IS through other people, but sometimes it is not. One does not need a plot of revenge or villain to make a good story with stakes.
I also wished that Sapphira and some of the other children had a bit more flaws and mistakes. For as young as they are, they were more often the heroes of the story than seasoned warriors. If I recall myself at their age, I was always making some mistake and being mouthy or something. The children seemed to be the adults and the adults seemed to act like children.
Overall, it was a pleasant and easy read. I enjoyed it and stayed up late multiple nights to read a few chapters.
If you want a sweet Christian romance set during the Crusades, it definitely fits the genre.
October 13, 2017
My Thoughts:
This one started slow for me. There is a lot of set up, a lot of learning about characters and the situations of their past. Even though I wasn't immediately drawn into the book, I persevered for a couple of reasons. First— it was a review book. I had to read it. Second— I had read CHIVALROUS her last medieval novel. I knew she is a good writer. When I got to page 142, I started getting interested. Things started happening. By the time I passed page 200, I had to finish it. ~smile~ Truthfully, a lot of books are like that for me. Oh, there are 358 pages in all if you're wondering.
Once in, I was all in. What began as an agreement of convenience, grew into a true friendship for Randel and Rosalind. Together they worked through terrible circumstances and came out of it stronger. I had spent the first couple hundred pages getting to know the characters, so it was interesting to watch them meet new situations, form relationships, and engage the enemy.
Themes were forgiveness, guilt, repentance and freedom from the past mistakes and sins. There was also an emphasis on truly knowing and experiencing God rather than just knowing about Him.
Thank you Bethany House for this review book. I received this book in exchange for an honest blog review.
Disclosure: I was sent a sample of this product for review purposes only. I was not compensated in any way. All opinions are my own based on my experience with this product. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."
This one started slow for me. There is a lot of set up, a lot of learning about characters and the situations of their past. Even though I wasn't immediately drawn into the book, I persevered for a couple of reasons. First— it was a review book. I had to read it. Second— I had read CHIVALROUS her last medieval novel. I knew she is a good writer. When I got to page 142, I started getting interested. Things started happening. By the time I passed page 200, I had to finish it. ~smile~ Truthfully, a lot of books are like that for me. Oh, there are 358 pages in all if you're wondering.
Once in, I was all in. What began as an agreement of convenience, grew into a true friendship for Randel and Rosalind. Together they worked through terrible circumstances and came out of it stronger. I had spent the first couple hundred pages getting to know the characters, so it was interesting to watch them meet new situations, form relationships, and engage the enemy.
Themes were forgiveness, guilt, repentance and freedom from the past mistakes and sins. There was also an emphasis on truly knowing and experiencing God rather than just knowing about Him.
Thank you Bethany House for this review book. I received this book in exchange for an honest blog review.
Disclosure: I was sent a sample of this product for review purposes only. I was not compensated in any way. All opinions are my own based on my experience with this product. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising."
July 23, 2020
Quick Review:
I give this book 3 out of 5 stars because it was an enjoyable story, which also deals with some challenging issues, but the writing style was too much ‘telling’ and not enough ‘showing’.
Plot Summary:
This book was set in 1219 and is about a group of children, led by a ex-lady’s maid and a disgraced knight, who go on a crusade to the middle east. It follows them on their quest to see captives freed, while also following their journeys with God as they deal with past hurts and mistakes.
My Thoughts on the Book:
This book covered some weighty topics, including Christian-Muslim relations, brutality of war and abortion, however, these issues are scattered throughout a plot that feels like a strange mixture of a Jane Austen romance set during the Crusades. This book had a lot of potential to be really good, however, the writing style was too much ‘telling’ and not enough ‘showing’ for my liking. The characters face some really tough challenges but I found it difficult to relate to them or feel their emotions. One thing I do enjoy about all the Valiant Hearts series, is that all the characters are journeying with God and we see their struggles and revelations play out over the course of the book.
I give this book 3 out of 5 stars because it was an enjoyable story, which also deals with some challenging issues, but the writing style was too much ‘telling’ and not enough ‘showing’.
Plot Summary:
This book was set in 1219 and is about a group of children, led by a ex-lady’s maid and a disgraced knight, who go on a crusade to the middle east. It follows them on their quest to see captives freed, while also following their journeys with God as they deal with past hurts and mistakes.
My Thoughts on the Book:
This book covered some weighty topics, including Christian-Muslim relations, brutality of war and abortion, however, these issues are scattered throughout a plot that feels like a strange mixture of a Jane Austen romance set during the Crusades. This book had a lot of potential to be really good, however, the writing style was too much ‘telling’ and not enough ‘showing’ for my liking. The characters face some really tough challenges but I found it difficult to relate to them or feel their emotions. One thing I do enjoy about all the Valiant Hearts series, is that all the characters are journeying with God and we see their struggles and revelations play out over the course of the book.
December 3, 2019
Maybe it’s not fair to review this since I couldn’t even finish the book, but I don’t care. Like the others in the series, there is promise in the conflict and some of the characters... but then the out-of-place preaching comes in. It feels tossed in there for the sake of prattling on about religion.
As for Rosalind’s “sin”... I know this is set in medieval times, and attitudes back then were different, but it just feels like an excuse to preach about the “evils” of some very necessary medical choices that some women must make, for the sake of their health or reputations or what have you.
As for Rosalind’s “sin”... I know this is set in medieval times, and attitudes back then were different, but it just feels like an excuse to preach about the “evils” of some very necessary medical choices that some women must make, for the sake of their health or reputations or what have you.
August 23, 2018
This book seemed to have the most historical information of the series. (Meaning: I didn’t enjoy it quite as much) it took me longer to read than the others because it was filled with so much info instead of getting on with the story. The last half/third went a lot quicker and seemed to pick up though. It had a good message and wasn’t as sappy as the others either.
May 11, 2017
Overall a decent read, although I wasn't a big fan of Rosalind from the second book and I think I would have enjoyed a book with Sadie as the main character more.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews