What do you think?
Rate this book
Teaville Moral Society #1
A Heart Most Certain
A Fresh Voice in Historical Romance!
Lydia King knows what it's like to be in need, so when she joins the Teaville Moral Society, she genuinely hopes to help the town's poor. But with her father's debts increasing by the day and her mother growing sicker by the week, she wonders how long it will be until she ends up in the poor house herself. Her best chance at a financially secure future is to impress the politician courting her, and it certainly doesn't hurt that the moral society's president is her suitor's mother. Her first task as a moral society member—to obtain a donation from Nicholas Lowe, the wealthiest man in town—should be easy . . . except he flat-out refuses.
Despite appearances, Nicholas wants to help others but prefers to do it his own way, keeping his charity private. When Lydia proves persistent, they agree to a bargain, though Nicholas has a few surprises up his sleeve. Neither foresee the harrowing complications that will arise from working together. When town secrets are brought to light, this unlikely pair must decide where their beliefs—and hearts—truly align.
Lydia King knows what it's like to be in need, so when she joins the Teaville Moral Society, she genuinely hopes to help the town's poor. But with her father's debts increasing by the day and her mother growing sicker by the week, she wonders how long it will be until she ends up in the poor house herself. Her best chance at a financially secure future is to impress the politician courting her, and it certainly doesn't hurt that the moral society's president is her suitor's mother. Her first task as a moral society member—to obtain a donation from Nicholas Lowe, the wealthiest man in town—should be easy . . . except he flat-out refuses.
Despite appearances, Nicholas wants to help others but prefers to do it his own way, keeping his charity private. When Lydia proves persistent, they agree to a bargain, though Nicholas has a few surprises up his sleeve. Neither foresee the harrowing complications that will arise from working together. When town secrets are brought to light, this unlikely pair must decide where their beliefs—and hearts—truly align.
391 pages, Paperback
First published August 1, 2016
275 people are currently reading
1622 people want to read
About the author
Melissa Jagears
19 books876 followersI would love to connect with you through newsletter! I only send big updates, releases, and important stuff: http://newsletters.melissajagears.com/
My Review Star System:
A rare solid 5 means I LOVED it or was so impressed that I bring these books up in random conversations.
4.5-4 means great story. Recommended.
I don't post 3 star or below for newer Christian fiction (conflict of interest--I might have to work with the author). But any 3s mean the author wrote a good story, just something about it made it not a favorite.
2 was not that great and never redeemed itself.
1 aggravated me so much or was so poorly done I DNF or if I did finish, I wished I could get my time back.
My Review Star System:
A rare solid 5 means I LOVED it or was so impressed that I bring these books up in random conversations.
4.5-4 means great story. Recommended.
I don't post 3 star or below for newer Christian fiction (conflict of interest--I might have to work with the author). But any 3s mean the author wrote a good story, just something about it made it not a favorite.
2 was not that great and never redeemed itself.
1 aggravated me so much or was so poorly done I DNF or if I did finish, I wished I could get my time back.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 274 reviews
August 24, 2016
FULL REVIEW FOUND AT LITERARY CAFE: http://literarycafe.weebly.com/home/a...
Melissa Jagears took a chance by writing on several sensitive subjects that most Christians don't even want to touch. Christian neglect and hypocrisy, prostitution, tithing and helping the poor. What a mouthful, and once you read it, a mindful. A mind full of questions. Do we still neglect the poor and needy? Do we shun people for their pasts, even though Christ has already made a clean way for their future? Do we give the bare minimum required of us, and forget about ever giving of ourselves, or giving over and above our call of duty? I think all too often we would be guilty of answer yes to at least one of these questions.
-Honesty
Melissa writes with a frankness that isn't often found in historical fiction, even nonfiction. This may not apply much to today's world, but in the novel the protagonist asks this of herself:
What is the difference between an upright moral woman who marries a man for his riches, or a prostitute who sells her body for the same?
Think about that. Just think.
-Character Growth
Although somewhat sudden and less explained that I would usually prefer, I enjoyed how both characters grew throughout the book, influencing one another and changing one another slowly and gradually.
-Plot Depth
In so, so many contemporary books there's a single conflict/drive. That is to say, one problem that is to be resolved by the end of the book/series. Usually, it's some form of romantic interest, which I (and Joshua) find utterly boring when it's the only focus of the novel.
While this was a romance novel, it was in no way bland or uninteresting as the previous scenario mentioned. Mrs. Jagears auspiciously incorporated multiple conflicts and resolved them with excellence.
-Dynamics
Following along closely to plot depth, the characters weren't shallow either. Their dynamics were beautifully worded, and the many deep conversations they had not only kept you interested but challenged you to think deeply upon these sensitive subjects. I can recount more than once setting the book down to ponder the words and concepts Melissa wrote. There's too few a book about which that could be stated.
-they READ
Not just one, but BOTH main characters are avid readers. It can't get much better than that, can it? Oh, but yes, it did. Nicholas, who appears harder than ice and completely uninterested in anyone but himself, not only lets Lydia (the protagonist, who you'll just adore) borrow his books, but discusses them with her. And, and, and... Oh, wait, spoiler. You'll just have to read it ;)
And because I always like to include a few minor touch-ups in every review... Here come the critiques.
-Pace
Not a very big issue, although I will admit that at points the pace was 90 to nothing, and other times it seemed to drag on just a bit. But for the most part, it held my interest the entire time.
-Reasoning
Just a few times I found myself wondering the logic behind actions some of the characters made... It just confused me a little. Again, not a big issue, because most of the time each train of thought was laid out and you knew exactly why the person felt the way they did.
FULL REVIEW (WITH CONTENT OVERVIEW) FOUND HERE: http://literarycafe.weebly.com/home/a...
Melissa Jagears took a chance by writing on several sensitive subjects that most Christians don't even want to touch. Christian neglect and hypocrisy, prostitution, tithing and helping the poor. What a mouthful, and once you read it, a mindful. A mind full of questions. Do we still neglect the poor and needy? Do we shun people for their pasts, even though Christ has already made a clean way for their future? Do we give the bare minimum required of us, and forget about ever giving of ourselves, or giving over and above our call of duty? I think all too often we would be guilty of answer yes to at least one of these questions.
-Honesty
Melissa writes with a frankness that isn't often found in historical fiction, even nonfiction. This may not apply much to today's world, but in the novel the protagonist asks this of herself:
What is the difference between an upright moral woman who marries a man for his riches, or a prostitute who sells her body for the same?
Think about that. Just think.
-Character Growth
Although somewhat sudden and less explained that I would usually prefer, I enjoyed how both characters grew throughout the book, influencing one another and changing one another slowly and gradually.
-Plot Depth
In so, so many contemporary books there's a single conflict/drive. That is to say, one problem that is to be resolved by the end of the book/series. Usually, it's some form of romantic interest, which I (and Joshua) find utterly boring when it's the only focus of the novel.
While this was a romance novel, it was in no way bland or uninteresting as the previous scenario mentioned. Mrs. Jagears auspiciously incorporated multiple conflicts and resolved them with excellence.
-Dynamics
Following along closely to plot depth, the characters weren't shallow either. Their dynamics were beautifully worded, and the many deep conversations they had not only kept you interested but challenged you to think deeply upon these sensitive subjects. I can recount more than once setting the book down to ponder the words and concepts Melissa wrote. There's too few a book about which that could be stated.
-they READ
Not just one, but BOTH main characters are avid readers. It can't get much better than that, can it? Oh, but yes, it did. Nicholas, who appears harder than ice and completely uninterested in anyone but himself, not only lets Lydia (the protagonist, who you'll just adore) borrow his books, but discusses them with her. And, and, and... Oh, wait, spoiler. You'll just have to read it ;)
And because I always like to include a few minor touch-ups in every review... Here come the critiques.
-Pace
Not a very big issue, although I will admit that at points the pace was 90 to nothing, and other times it seemed to drag on just a bit. But for the most part, it held my interest the entire time.
-Reasoning
Just a few times I found myself wondering the logic behind actions some of the characters made... It just confused me a little. Again, not a big issue, because most of the time each train of thought was laid out and you knew exactly why the person felt the way they did.
FULL REVIEW (WITH CONTENT OVERVIEW) FOUND HERE: http://literarycafe.weebly.com/home/a...
March 22, 2017
4.5 solid stars of excellent quality
THIS BOOK IS AWESOME Y'ALL. I am so behind on reviews it's ridiculous, and I feel awful because this one was actually a review request, so, until I get all my wits together once again, I just wanted to say that I loved this book. It was deep, intriguing and highly interesting, and I strongly recommend it. This is not your typical light-tea-party romance, ooooohh noooooo! It's way more intricate, and superbly written.
If author Melissa Jagears isn't already on your radar of authors-I-need-to-watch-because-their-books-are-so-awesome, add her to your list RIGHT NOW! You will not regret it. I have loved everything I've read by this author so far, and this book took it even a step further because it was so deep. As much as I love Christian historical romance, the big majority of them qualify only as fluffy escapism, and most are not even well-written. A Heart Most Certain, I guarantee you, is not one of those at all.
Firstly, it's interesting and different from the first few chapters, and not only are you sucked right into the story, but you can tell it's going to be something grand. And it is. Wow. I was completely amazed at the depths of this book: the character development, the issues brought up, the writing, everything was profound, well-thought out, and challenging. This is a daring book. It asks the hard questions and makes you examine your own heart. Few Christian fiction novels attain such a level as this one. There is nothing shallow or cliché about A Heart Most Certain, and I can't tell you how surprised and satisfied I was to read this.
I wouldn't recommend to younger readers however, this is certainly a tougher book dealing with mature subject matters. The romance isn't the focus of the story (although it was beautifully done too!), and despite the divinely gorgeous cover that hints at a sweet novel of moonlit moments and walks around beautiful gardens, it is not the case!! It's absolutely wonderful, but be prepared for something challenging ;)
Melissa Jagears, bravo! You have accomplished a true Christian fiction novel, something I'm sure many aspire to but fail to deliver. I cannot wait to read the next book in this series!!
A huge thank you to the author and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book to review, and all apologies that my full review is so late, and that I stupidly forgot to give it a rating when I first reviewed it. I LOVED IT!!!
THIS BOOK IS AWESOME Y'ALL. I am so behind on reviews it's ridiculous, and I feel awful because this one was actually a review request, so, until I get all my wits together once again, I just wanted to say that I loved this book. It was deep, intriguing and highly interesting, and I strongly recommend it. This is not your typical light-tea-party romance, ooooohh noooooo! It's way more intricate, and superbly written.
If author Melissa Jagears isn't already on your radar of authors-I-need-to-watch-because-their-books-are-so-awesome, add her to your list RIGHT NOW! You will not regret it. I have loved everything I've read by this author so far, and this book took it even a step further because it was so deep. As much as I love Christian historical romance, the big majority of them qualify only as fluffy escapism, and most are not even well-written. A Heart Most Certain, I guarantee you, is not one of those at all.
Firstly, it's interesting and different from the first few chapters, and not only are you sucked right into the story, but you can tell it's going to be something grand. And it is. Wow. I was completely amazed at the depths of this book: the character development, the issues brought up, the writing, everything was profound, well-thought out, and challenging. This is a daring book. It asks the hard questions and makes you examine your own heart. Few Christian fiction novels attain such a level as this one. There is nothing shallow or cliché about A Heart Most Certain, and I can't tell you how surprised and satisfied I was to read this.
I wouldn't recommend to younger readers however, this is certainly a tougher book dealing with mature subject matters. The romance isn't the focus of the story (although it was beautifully done too!), and despite the divinely gorgeous cover that hints at a sweet novel of moonlit moments and walks around beautiful gardens, it is not the case!! It's absolutely wonderful, but be prepared for something challenging ;)
Melissa Jagears, bravo! You have accomplished a true Christian fiction novel, something I'm sure many aspire to but fail to deliver. I cannot wait to read the next book in this series!!
A huge thank you to the author and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book to review, and all apologies that my full review is so late, and that I stupidly forgot to give it a rating when I first reviewed it. I LOVED IT!!!
February 5, 2017
I’ve been a fan of Melissa Jegears ever since I read the first book in her Unexpected Brides series. While A Heart Most Certain tells a different type of story, it’s no less poignant, gripping and a deep pleasure to read. I was touched by the giving hearts of the characters, aghast at the injustices that they fought and captivated by the tender romance.
Lydia King and Nicholas Lowe are engaging characters and utterly compelling. They both have valuable things to teach one another, but it takes quite some time for them to realize it. Lydia is brave, but not unrealistically so for the time period of the story. She’s no simpering miss, but rather a determined young lady, who wants to do right by her family, but also can’t ignore the plight of those in her community. When the conflict between reputation and being a true help to those in need becomes apparent in her interaction with Nicholas, she must decide what is really important – yes, reputation is everything, but what good is a stellar reputation if she faces potential danger and misery in her future?
Nicholas is used to being able to use money to solve many plights and problems, except for his own – for him, while used to the betterment of many in his community – money is a way of absolving himself from his past mistakes. Lydia puts a wrench in his anonymity with her persistence and also makes him questions his own methods – how can he help those trapped in sin in his town, but be unwilling to reach out to the members in his church who need to be shown a different way – a way other than being hypocritical of the very people he and Lydia are trying to help.
The interaction between Lydia and Nicholas is dynamic. Opposites in many ways, they also challenge each other. Their more serious conversations cause the reader to think and reflect on their own lives, while their humorous moments are sure to bring a smile to the reader’s face.
While this story does have a lovely romantic thread, the highlight is most assuredly the in-depth look at the plight of the women and young girls who are forced into prostitution, yet can find little help when they are delivered from it. Though the subject matter is sobering, the narrative is never heavy-laden or without hope. Other themes are touched on as well, including the double standard between the behavior and judgement of men and women, especially as it relates to social activities and marriage. The unfairness of it all made me truly admire people who fought for those in need despite adversity and judgement. I appreciate how far things have come since then, but this story has left me with the reminder to stand up for injustices, to speak up when something is wrong. In addition, Melissa highlights the need of Christians to fight disillusionment with the church, that supporting the body of Christ is important and necessary to the kingdom.
The tenderness of this story’s ending speaks to Melissa’s skill as a romantic historical fiction writer. Readers who love a heartfelt happily-ever-after will be eager to reach the culmination of Lydia and Nicholas’s journey, while at the same time eager to visit Teaville once again. Highly recommended for readers looking for a historical romance, with a poignant message at its core.
Lydia King and Nicholas Lowe are engaging characters and utterly compelling. They both have valuable things to teach one another, but it takes quite some time for them to realize it. Lydia is brave, but not unrealistically so for the time period of the story. She’s no simpering miss, but rather a determined young lady, who wants to do right by her family, but also can’t ignore the plight of those in her community. When the conflict between reputation and being a true help to those in need becomes apparent in her interaction with Nicholas, she must decide what is really important – yes, reputation is everything, but what good is a stellar reputation if she faces potential danger and misery in her future?
Nicholas is used to being able to use money to solve many plights and problems, except for his own – for him, while used to the betterment of many in his community – money is a way of absolving himself from his past mistakes. Lydia puts a wrench in his anonymity with her persistence and also makes him questions his own methods – how can he help those trapped in sin in his town, but be unwilling to reach out to the members in his church who need to be shown a different way – a way other than being hypocritical of the very people he and Lydia are trying to help.
The interaction between Lydia and Nicholas is dynamic. Opposites in many ways, they also challenge each other. Their more serious conversations cause the reader to think and reflect on their own lives, while their humorous moments are sure to bring a smile to the reader’s face.
While this story does have a lovely romantic thread, the highlight is most assuredly the in-depth look at the plight of the women and young girls who are forced into prostitution, yet can find little help when they are delivered from it. Though the subject matter is sobering, the narrative is never heavy-laden or without hope. Other themes are touched on as well, including the double standard between the behavior and judgement of men and women, especially as it relates to social activities and marriage. The unfairness of it all made me truly admire people who fought for those in need despite adversity and judgement. I appreciate how far things have come since then, but this story has left me with the reminder to stand up for injustices, to speak up when something is wrong. In addition, Melissa highlights the need of Christians to fight disillusionment with the church, that supporting the body of Christ is important and necessary to the kingdom.
The tenderness of this story’s ending speaks to Melissa’s skill as a romantic historical fiction writer. Readers who love a heartfelt happily-ever-after will be eager to reach the culmination of Lydia and Nicholas’s journey, while at the same time eager to visit Teaville once again. Highly recommended for readers looking for a historical romance, with a poignant message at its core.
September 30, 2016
When the author asked if I'd be willing to be an influencer for her new book, I jumped at the chance...because I'd already loved the novella set in this town, and I really liked Lydia and her fascination for books.
It was a delightful moment to get this in the mail and realize what sort of enjoyment I was in for! I'd just gotten it started, though, when a sickness and death in the family brought my intelligent-reader brain to a halt. There was no way I could create a nice, reasoned review...so now, this is embarrassingly late!
I savored so many details in this story. My favorite part was Lydia's passion for good reading, something I obviously share with her. I was very impressed that Jagears didn't only include known classics of today (which is an author pet peeve of mine, as it is unrealistic) but mentioned others such as Laura Jean Libbey, a popular writer of the day who is mostly forgotten today. +1 for that detail!
The little working details were all there, too, careful as worldbuilding in a fantasy (which, indeed, does share many characteristics of a recreation of a historical world). Lydia's good dresses were handmedowns; many of her gowns show careful mending. This in particular is delightfully refreshing, as many heroines are portrayed with lavish and perfect wardrobes. For certain scenes, the horses and carriages/conveyances are mentioned, with a few words of why certain styles are suited to rich men/poor men/etc.
Well, then...the hero. I suppose if you've read the back cover, you're pretty sure who he turns out to be. The town's most famous miser is a hero in disguise, only--best part--he doesn't think he really is. A fine man content to hide his qualities under a disguise? One who prefers to help fallen women than to hurt them or censure them? Well, it makes for good reading.
I'll stop here, lest I betray too much of the content...but I love it, and if you enjoy history, or just-right romance, or a good bit of page-turning suspense, be sure to give this book a try!
Thanks to the author for my free copy.
It was a delightful moment to get this in the mail and realize what sort of enjoyment I was in for! I'd just gotten it started, though, when a sickness and death in the family brought my intelligent-reader brain to a halt. There was no way I could create a nice, reasoned review...so now, this is embarrassingly late!
I savored so many details in this story. My favorite part was Lydia's passion for good reading, something I obviously share with her. I was very impressed that Jagears didn't only include known classics of today (which is an author pet peeve of mine, as it is unrealistic) but mentioned others such as Laura Jean Libbey, a popular writer of the day who is mostly forgotten today. +1 for that detail!
The little working details were all there, too, careful as worldbuilding in a fantasy (which, indeed, does share many characteristics of a recreation of a historical world). Lydia's good dresses were handmedowns; many of her gowns show careful mending. This in particular is delightfully refreshing, as many heroines are portrayed with lavish and perfect wardrobes. For certain scenes, the horses and carriages/conveyances are mentioned, with a few words of why certain styles are suited to rich men/poor men/etc.
Well, then...the hero. I suppose if you've read the back cover, you're pretty sure who he turns out to be. The town's most famous miser is a hero in disguise, only--best part--he doesn't think he really is. A fine man content to hide his qualities under a disguise? One who prefers to help fallen women than to hurt them or censure them? Well, it makes for good reading.
I'll stop here, lest I betray too much of the content...but I love it, and if you enjoy history, or just-right romance, or a good bit of page-turning suspense, be sure to give this book a try!
Thanks to the author for my free copy.
August 18, 2016
First of all… y’all are going to LOVE Lydia. Why? Well, many reasons. But specifically because she’s a READER! She can’t help herself. Waiting in Nicholas’ office for him to return, what does she do? Pilfers a book off his desk and starts reading it. (Can anyone else relate to that or just me?) When she’s struggling to find something in common with a woman she’s just met – a woman from a different socioeconomic background than her own – it only takes discovering this woman’s shared love of books for the walls to come down and an instant friendship to be made. And I know we all can relate to that!
Nicholas? Swoony, gruff, more-tenderhearted-than-he-appears Nicholas? Also a READER! Just go ahead and get your swooning couches (or close facsimiles) ready because not only is Nicholas is a reader but he lets Lydia borrow his books. And he talks about them with her. And he wonders what she thinks about his favorite books. And he buys her a … but no. I can’t reveal that part. You’ll just have to read it for yourself.
In the process of “reforming” Nicholas, Lydia herself ends up being transformed. Thanks to Nicholas (swoon!) as well as a handful of women from Teaville’s red light district, she not only learns what it means to help the least of these but also gains a deeper understanding of who she is – and who she isn’t. I think that anyone who has ever been stretched out of their comfort zone will instantly embrace Lydia’s story. Anyone who has stood at the threshold of “safe” versus “risky” will identify with both her and Nicholas and their journey.
And even though A Heart Most Certain is set in early 1900s Kansas, its message and insights are just as timely for today. Because women and girls my niece’s age and younger are still being forced into prostitution due to a variety of circumstances. Because the church is still full of people who like to be self-righteous as well as people who risk reputation and safety to help the marginalized. Because we still live in the constant struggle between the two sides, in the church and within ourselves. Because “the least of these” could be any one of us with the shifting of a few minor circumstances. And because the same Jesus who died for you also died for me … and He also died for the self-righteous and the marginalized and the prostitute and the impoverished and the corrupt. This theme is what elevates A Heart Most Certain beyond a mere romance (though that aspect to the story is quite dreamy) and makes it a book that everyone needs to read.
Bottom Line: A book set over 100 years ago has important things to say to our world today, and A Heart Most Certain accomplishes its message through a delicious love story that will certainly head straight to every bookworm’s heart. Melissa Jagears is at the top of her game with this new series, with these characters, and with this story in particular, and I’m quite looking forward to the next books in the Teaville Moral Society series.
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
See my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
Nicholas? Swoony, gruff, more-tenderhearted-than-he-appears Nicholas? Also a READER! Just go ahead and get your swooning couches (or close facsimiles) ready because not only is Nicholas is a reader but he lets Lydia borrow his books. And he talks about them with her. And he wonders what she thinks about his favorite books. And he buys her a … but no. I can’t reveal that part. You’ll just have to read it for yourself.
In the process of “reforming” Nicholas, Lydia herself ends up being transformed. Thanks to Nicholas (swoon!) as well as a handful of women from Teaville’s red light district, she not only learns what it means to help the least of these but also gains a deeper understanding of who she is – and who she isn’t. I think that anyone who has ever been stretched out of their comfort zone will instantly embrace Lydia’s story. Anyone who has stood at the threshold of “safe” versus “risky” will identify with both her and Nicholas and their journey.
And even though A Heart Most Certain is set in early 1900s Kansas, its message and insights are just as timely for today. Because women and girls my niece’s age and younger are still being forced into prostitution due to a variety of circumstances. Because the church is still full of people who like to be self-righteous as well as people who risk reputation and safety to help the marginalized. Because we still live in the constant struggle between the two sides, in the church and within ourselves. Because “the least of these” could be any one of us with the shifting of a few minor circumstances. And because the same Jesus who died for you also died for me … and He also died for the self-righteous and the marginalized and the prostitute and the impoverished and the corrupt. This theme is what elevates A Heart Most Certain beyond a mere romance (though that aspect to the story is quite dreamy) and makes it a book that everyone needs to read.
Bottom Line: A book set over 100 years ago has important things to say to our world today, and A Heart Most Certain accomplishes its message through a delicious love story that will certainly head straight to every bookworm’s heart. Melissa Jagears is at the top of her game with this new series, with these characters, and with this story in particular, and I’m quite looking forward to the next books in the Teaville Moral Society series.
(I received a copy of this book in exchange for only my honest review.)
See my full review at Reading Is My SuperPower
February 4, 2017
This book has a wonderful message. I really enjoyed reading it! I'm going to miss Lydia and Nicholas. I really liked how the author told Lydia's story. Some parts really stirred my heart. It was a good reminder to me. I would encourage readers to read this because it's a great entertaining novel. More importantly, A Heart Most Certain will remind you not to judge but to reach out and love others, not only in word but in deed.
September 17, 2016
I really appreciated the compassion of the main characters in this book. Both Lydia and Nicholas have strong ideas of the most effective way to improve society and the circumstances of the poor, and their differences complement each other as they compromise a little and teach each other a lot. The problem of prostitution is addressed head-on, and many attitudes about it are represented in the various community members. I appreciated that Lydia and Nicholas learned from each other's unique way of solving problems while still sharing a common goal of helping those in need. The first half of the book was a bit slow paced for me, but the author did an excellent job of providing a foundation for the events that came later in the plot where there was much more happening and the suspense is heightened. I loved that Lydia is a voracious reader! She uses her love of books to connect not only with Nicholas but other women from different walks of life. Nicholas definitely reminded me of Mr. Thorton from North and South (but more more philanthropic)- a hard, unyielding exterior but a heart of gold inside, just trying his best in the way he knows how. The feelings between Lydia and Nicholas are a slow simmer through most of the book but when they finally express their feelings it is full heat! Their special moment is descriptive with emotion, words, and action, and it made the book for me since I'm one who reads for the romance ;)
(Thank you to Bethany House Publishing and the author for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
(Thank you to Bethany House Publishing and the author for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review)
August 18, 2016
In Melissa Jagears new series, Teaville Moral Society, readers get a good look at what life was like for prostitutes and their children in the early 1900s. The church body didn't welcome them and created an environment of very limited options.
Lydia and Nicholas both show character growth in the pages of A Heart Most Certain. I especially enjoyed getting to know some of the minor characters such as Sadie and Robbie. Most of all I appreciated the author's historical note following the epilogue.
This novel is recommended for fans of historical fiction.
Lydia and Nicholas both show character growth in the pages of A Heart Most Certain. I especially enjoyed getting to know some of the minor characters such as Sadie and Robbie. Most of all I appreciated the author's historical note following the epilogue.
This novel is recommended for fans of historical fiction.
August 8, 2016
This book is fantastic! It is a true historical fiction, and I love the undertones of forgiveness and hearts being changed.
What I loved: The character of Nicholas is priceless. His concern for the down-trodden and his love for the “unlovely” simply make his character shine. The fact that he does his good deeds in secret makes him more special. And Lydia King … even though her poor but “aristocratic” and almost haughty personality is evident in the beginning, the reader cannot help but like her because of her love for her mother and desire to protect and provide for her family ... even if it means marrying for money and not love. By the end of the story, her character softens, and she becomes a caring and forgiving woman.
What I didn’t like: Since I have little time for reading, tackling a book this long is not something I usually enjoy. However, this plot kept me turning pages, and putting it down was hard. Even though I couldn’t wait to finish the book, I believe Ms. Jagears included nothing that was repetitive or unnecessary. Each chapter and each scene contributed to the story and only made it better.
Over all, I give this book five stars. I loved it completely, and I highly recommend it to anyone loving a good historical book and a wonderful, sweet romance.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book for an honest review, and all the opinions and thoughts are my own.
What I loved: The character of Nicholas is priceless. His concern for the down-trodden and his love for the “unlovely” simply make his character shine. The fact that he does his good deeds in secret makes him more special. And Lydia King … even though her poor but “aristocratic” and almost haughty personality is evident in the beginning, the reader cannot help but like her because of her love for her mother and desire to protect and provide for her family ... even if it means marrying for money and not love. By the end of the story, her character softens, and she becomes a caring and forgiving woman.
What I didn’t like: Since I have little time for reading, tackling a book this long is not something I usually enjoy. However, this plot kept me turning pages, and putting it down was hard. Even though I couldn’t wait to finish the book, I believe Ms. Jagears included nothing that was repetitive or unnecessary. Each chapter and each scene contributed to the story and only made it better.
Over all, I give this book five stars. I loved it completely, and I highly recommend it to anyone loving a good historical book and a wonderful, sweet romance.
I was given a complimentary copy of this book for an honest review, and all the opinions and thoughts are my own.
August 11, 2016
A Heart Most Certain is the first of the new Teaville Moral Society series. I enjoyed this book. It is a little deeper than the others by Melissa Jagears, but it still has those fun moments that made me giggle. A wonderful story of redemption.
Highly recommended
5 plus stars
Highly recommended
5 plus stars
July 11, 2016
I have to say that I wasn't sure what to think of the first chapter of this book. I was mistakenly thinking it was a rewrite of a Charles Dicken's novel and set it aside for awhile. I am so glad I picked it back up, because after the first chapter, I was hooked.
This story took me on a journey I did not expect. Nicholas Lowe, hard skin flint, widower and the Lydia, the daughter of a drunken gambler and dying mother were not that unusual of characters, but how Ms. Jagears portrays them is what is unique. If you don't want to see any of the seedy underbelly of the time period, this probably not the book you want to pick up. While nothing descriptive is included, it is eluded to. Gamblers, dance halls, brothels, and the selling of under age women are all eluded to in this book. It is not a pretty sight, but you also, without the details, get to see what life was like for the less fortunate of that time.
Most of all, you get to see how the church handled things and see glimpses of the modern church, hidden behind talk of freedom and love for all. It was a fascinating story.
This book was given to me for my honest review by NetGalley and Bethany House. The opinions contained herein are my own.
This story took me on a journey I did not expect. Nicholas Lowe, hard skin flint, widower and the Lydia, the daughter of a drunken gambler and dying mother were not that unusual of characters, but how Ms. Jagears portrays them is what is unique. If you don't want to see any of the seedy underbelly of the time period, this probably not the book you want to pick up. While nothing descriptive is included, it is eluded to. Gamblers, dance halls, brothels, and the selling of under age women are all eluded to in this book. It is not a pretty sight, but you also, without the details, get to see what life was like for the less fortunate of that time.
Most of all, you get to see how the church handled things and see glimpses of the modern church, hidden behind talk of freedom and love for all. It was a fascinating story.
This book was given to me for my honest review by NetGalley and Bethany House. The opinions contained herein are my own.
August 20, 2016
I've only read one other book by Melissa Jagears, and while it was really good, it was more or less the average Christian historical romance novel. Even so, I decided to review A Heart Most Certain ... and as I got into this book, I was blown away!
Book One in the TEAVILLE MORAL SOCIETY is a story about Lydia King and Nicholas Lowe. It's a tale about a moral society gone wrong, and a rich man who refuses to give to his church for interesting reasons. A story of redemption and forgiveness, of true charity - it examines the sometimes not-so-clear line between judging sin and condemning hearts. Journey to 1905 Teaville, Kansas for this eye-opening adventure!
This novel was interesting, bold, and just lovely! I really enjoyed the exchanges between Lydia and Nicholas, and the raw look at motives of the heart. The message/faith aspect of A Heart Most Certain was different than most historical romance, and very thought-provoking! One of the themes included prostitution and the like; which was heartbreaking! It's sickening to see how the issue was ignored back then by Christians ... men were excused and prostitutes (no matter age or life story) condemned. So the tale of how some of the characters pushed back against that and opened their arms to these desperate women was beautiful. I would recommend caution, because of these themes, A Heart Most Certain calls for a slightly more mature audience. (Also, in the ending, the kissing was a little much.) Otherwise, it was great!
I really, really enjoyed it. Faith, struggle, decisions - 'Should I do what's easiest? Or what's right?' Also, a dash of suspense! Issues in society, and issues of the heart are explored. Well-done, Melissa Jagears! ^_^ I look forward to reading more.
I received a copy of A Heart Most Certain from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
Book One in the TEAVILLE MORAL SOCIETY is a story about Lydia King and Nicholas Lowe. It's a tale about a moral society gone wrong, and a rich man who refuses to give to his church for interesting reasons. A story of redemption and forgiveness, of true charity - it examines the sometimes not-so-clear line between judging sin and condemning hearts. Journey to 1905 Teaville, Kansas for this eye-opening adventure!
This novel was interesting, bold, and just lovely! I really enjoyed the exchanges between Lydia and Nicholas, and the raw look at motives of the heart. The message/faith aspect of A Heart Most Certain was different than most historical romance, and very thought-provoking! One of the themes included prostitution and the like; which was heartbreaking! It's sickening to see how the issue was ignored back then by Christians ... men were excused and prostitutes (no matter age or life story) condemned. So the tale of how some of the characters pushed back against that and opened their arms to these desperate women was beautiful. I would recommend caution, because of these themes, A Heart Most Certain calls for a slightly more mature audience. (Also, in the ending, the kissing was a little much.) Otherwise, it was great!
I really, really enjoyed it. Faith, struggle, decisions - 'Should I do what's easiest? Or what's right?' Also, a dash of suspense! Issues in society, and issues of the heart are explored. Well-done, Melissa Jagears! ^_^ I look forward to reading more.
I received a copy of A Heart Most Certain from Bethany House Publishers in exchange for my honest review.
July 28, 2016
What I Loved...
Nicholas Lowe, oh how I love thee. Not because he's rich, heaven forbid, or because he is so handsome, but because of his deep seeded love for the Lord and ministry. His genuine desire to help those who were deemed soiled and his ability to see through "Christians," spoke to my heart.
Although this is a historical romance, much of the behaviors of the Christians then still apply today. I applaud Jagears for taking a road less often traveled in CF and not just writing about a typical villain whose greed or violence is what makes him the antagonist but about Christians that accept what is popular as appropriate or turn a blind eye in order to save their reputation or not get too involved...
See Full Review Here
Disclaimer: This book was provided by the publisher through Netgalley. The opinion of this book, is my own and I was not paid or compensated for my review.
Nicholas Lowe, oh how I love thee. Not because he's rich, heaven forbid, or because he is so handsome, but because of his deep seeded love for the Lord and ministry. His genuine desire to help those who were deemed soiled and his ability to see through "Christians," spoke to my heart.
Although this is a historical romance, much of the behaviors of the Christians then still apply today. I applaud Jagears for taking a road less often traveled in CF and not just writing about a typical villain whose greed or violence is what makes him the antagonist but about Christians that accept what is popular as appropriate or turn a blind eye in order to save their reputation or not get too involved...
See Full Review Here
Disclaimer: This book was provided by the publisher through Netgalley. The opinion of this book, is my own and I was not paid or compensated for my review.
February 21, 2017
Well, well, well, I am not exactly sure what I should say about this book. I liked part of it, and I didn’t like part of it.
But! First, I will start with the parts that I did like!!!
I really liked the fact that Lydia and Nicholas got off on the wrong foot. I mean, at first, they both couldn’t stand each other. Well, at the beginning at least…
Anyway, Nicholas was pretty cool. I liked him. I mean, I didn’t fall in love with him like I do with some main guy characters, but he still was nice! As for Lydia, she was genuinely pleasant. I liked her fighting spirit and her willingness to go to the unknown.
Now for the parts that I didn’t like so much…
To be honest, I thought Jagears dragged the book on for just a tad bit too long. I was starting to get bored at the end.
I also couldn’t really find the climax–or most exciting part. The whole storyline seemed kind of flat, if you know what I mean.
Don’t get me wrong. The plot of the story was very thoughtful and creative. I just think that maybe Jagears could have thought of a more exciting climax or shortened the story.
I would like to add something VERY important to my book reviews! I have talked so much about the book covers, that I will now be rating the book covers as well as the writing between the covers.
This cover deserves five stars. The woman’s dress is beautiful, and I love it that she is holding the arm of an ‘unknown’ man.
So, I think that I would give this book two stars. I am sorry to say that I personally wouldn’t read this book again.
Title: A Heart Most Certain
Author: Melissa Jagears
Author’s Website: http://melissajagears.com/
I received this book from the Bethany House Division
This review is written in my own opinions and words.
But! First, I will start with the parts that I did like!!!
I really liked the fact that Lydia and Nicholas got off on the wrong foot. I mean, at first, they both couldn’t stand each other. Well, at the beginning at least…
Anyway, Nicholas was pretty cool. I liked him. I mean, I didn’t fall in love with him like I do with some main guy characters, but he still was nice! As for Lydia, she was genuinely pleasant. I liked her fighting spirit and her willingness to go to the unknown.
Now for the parts that I didn’t like so much…
To be honest, I thought Jagears dragged the book on for just a tad bit too long. I was starting to get bored at the end.
I also couldn’t really find the climax–or most exciting part. The whole storyline seemed kind of flat, if you know what I mean.
Don’t get me wrong. The plot of the story was very thoughtful and creative. I just think that maybe Jagears could have thought of a more exciting climax or shortened the story.
I would like to add something VERY important to my book reviews! I have talked so much about the book covers, that I will now be rating the book covers as well as the writing between the covers.
This cover deserves five stars. The woman’s dress is beautiful, and I love it that she is holding the arm of an ‘unknown’ man.
So, I think that I would give this book two stars. I am sorry to say that I personally wouldn’t read this book again.
Title: A Heart Most Certain
Author: Melissa Jagears
Author’s Website: http://melissajagears.com/
I received this book from the Bethany House Division
This review is written in my own opinions and words.
July 27, 2016
What is the difference between an upright moral woman who marries simply for financial gain and the prostitute who sells her body for money? Melissa Jagear's A heart Most Certain tells the story of one such woman, Lydia King. Lydia is almost engaged to Sebastian Little, the mayor's son. Once married she will want for nothing, except love. Nicholas Lowe is a miserly man who refuses to help fund the Moral Society. It is up to Lydia to prove her worth to the Littles by getting a donation from Mr. Lowe.
The story is strong, with interesting , well-developed characters. I am glad to see that it is the first in a series of books. I look forward to visiting the town of Teaville again.
I was given this book by netgalley.com for review purposes. All thoughts are my own.
The story is strong, with interesting , well-developed characters. I am glad to see that it is the first in a series of books. I look forward to visiting the town of Teaville again.
I was given this book by netgalley.com for review purposes. All thoughts are my own.
August 7, 2016
Nicholas Lowe is the big business owner in Teaville, who on the outside acts shrewd and harsh to those who ask him for charitable handouts. The entire town assume every which way he should be spending his money and naturally each one believes it should be for their own cause. Lydia King is the daughter of a terminally ill mother, and a father who has lost himself to gambling and drink. Desperate to provide for her mother and herself she hopes to marry Sebastian Little, the Mayor's son. She is a member of the Teaville Moral Society (named for the series) and in her efforts to prove her worth to the groups leader, Sebastian's mother, Lydia embarks on a quest to entice funds from Nicholas. Despite his constant refusals, and attempts to hide from her - their paths cross and then unite, as they both learn that first, second and even third impressions about a person can often be entirely wrong. How often do we judge another based on what we think we see, when in actuality we can't see the truth at all - blinded by our own unwillingness to be open to truth?
There is much that is unsavory and corrupt in the town of Teaville, and plenty poverty and suffering. Lydia is fighting for the Moral Society and for self-preservation, yet as her journey unites with Nicholas, he is able to open her heart to a new way of thinking. She steps out of her comfort zone, and in essence Nicholas unknowingly begins to do the same. The romance and friendship of these two characters is natural and unhurried. I enjoyed getting to know their inner thoughts, concerns and fears. Melissa writes so skillfully, that I always get drawn right in, and find it really hard to put down her books. There's much that's uncomfortable to read in the plot of this book, she tackles the very real problem of prostitution in the 19th century, and how corrupt the local city government could become when it comes to rely on the funding from fines. The reality of the power those in authority could exert. If you can handle this difficult subject that she uses as a baseline to the plot, you will come to appreciate the danger and desperation it was for so many. I also appreciated that she took on the very real state of the 'hypocrites' that we come across in society. In this case, Christians. It's as real today as I'm sure it was then, and many are turned away from religion because of it. Let those of us within the faith strive harder to be true followers and not by word only.
I really enjoyed Melissa's mail order bride series, that was by far the best on that subject I have read. I was excited to see she had begun a new series, and thoroughly enjoyed going on this journey with Lydia & Nick. 5 stars for a powerful and engaging read. I especially connected with the part in which Bernadette, the Pastor's wife, reflects on doing things for others based on appearances and doing them because that's what God really wants from us. She honorably, I think - took a time out and returned her time to studying her scriptures, and prayer, and getting her focus where she felt it needed to be. How often do we neglect those simple things, that keep our spirit strong, while we get caught up or lost in doing everything and anything, for whatever reason that may be? It was a good reminder that in order to truly give your best to another, it is vital to take care of your spiritual strength first - and to do things for the right reasons.
Thank you to Netgalley & Bethany House for the ARC of 'A Heart Most Certain'. This is my honest review.
There is much that is unsavory and corrupt in the town of Teaville, and plenty poverty and suffering. Lydia is fighting for the Moral Society and for self-preservation, yet as her journey unites with Nicholas, he is able to open her heart to a new way of thinking. She steps out of her comfort zone, and in essence Nicholas unknowingly begins to do the same. The romance and friendship of these two characters is natural and unhurried. I enjoyed getting to know their inner thoughts, concerns and fears. Melissa writes so skillfully, that I always get drawn right in, and find it really hard to put down her books. There's much that's uncomfortable to read in the plot of this book, she tackles the very real problem of prostitution in the 19th century, and how corrupt the local city government could become when it comes to rely on the funding from fines. The reality of the power those in authority could exert. If you can handle this difficult subject that she uses as a baseline to the plot, you will come to appreciate the danger and desperation it was for so many. I also appreciated that she took on the very real state of the 'hypocrites' that we come across in society. In this case, Christians. It's as real today as I'm sure it was then, and many are turned away from religion because of it. Let those of us within the faith strive harder to be true followers and not by word only.
I really enjoyed Melissa's mail order bride series, that was by far the best on that subject I have read. I was excited to see she had begun a new series, and thoroughly enjoyed going on this journey with Lydia & Nick. 5 stars for a powerful and engaging read. I especially connected with the part in which Bernadette, the Pastor's wife, reflects on doing things for others based on appearances and doing them because that's what God really wants from us. She honorably, I think - took a time out and returned her time to studying her scriptures, and prayer, and getting her focus where she felt it needed to be. How often do we neglect those simple things, that keep our spirit strong, while we get caught up or lost in doing everything and anything, for whatever reason that may be? It was a good reminder that in order to truly give your best to another, it is vital to take care of your spiritual strength first - and to do things for the right reasons.
Thank you to Netgalley & Bethany House for the ARC of 'A Heart Most Certain'. This is my honest review.
August 8, 2016
*My Thoughts*
As avid romance readers, a lot of us can attest to the fact that it is *fairly* easy to find a good swoon-worthy book to cuddle up with. And most of us could find a non-fiction book to talk some sense into us. But those precious gems that mix swoon-worthy romance & "Kick in the gut" Christian truths...those are the ones that are few and far between. Guess what? Melissa NAILS it.
Every. Single. Bit of it.
I started this book with the hope that it would at least be as good as books I had previously read by Melissa. I NEVER thought it would blow them out of the water, but oh-my-goodness does it!
I am in love with the hero...tough guys are always my favorite, but tough-vulnerable guys...swoon. And Lydia's (my great-grandmothers name! *smile*) tenacity had my grinning from ear to ear with every flip of the page. Their "relationship" was adorable and I felt happiness, pain, sorrow...whatever they felt.
However, that wasn't the clincher. What did it for me? That "kick in the gut" truth I was talking about. Wow. Melissa, in one single book, challenged everything I had once unconsciously thought about people, life, other people's opinions...everything.
Melissa chose a subject that many people find to be a hard pill to swallow, and turned it into something beautifully different.
This book isn't just a great romance...it's life changing.
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give A Heart Most Certain by Melissa Jagears...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
As avid romance readers, a lot of us can attest to the fact that it is *fairly* easy to find a good swoon-worthy book to cuddle up with. And most of us could find a non-fiction book to talk some sense into us. But those precious gems that mix swoon-worthy romance & "Kick in the gut" Christian truths...those are the ones that are few and far between. Guess what? Melissa NAILS it.
Every. Single. Bit of it.
I started this book with the hope that it would at least be as good as books I had previously read by Melissa. I NEVER thought it would blow them out of the water, but oh-my-goodness does it!
I am in love with the hero...tough guys are always my favorite, but tough-vulnerable guys...swoon. And Lydia's (my great-grandmothers name! *smile*) tenacity had my grinning from ear to ear with every flip of the page. Their "relationship" was adorable and I felt happiness, pain, sorrow...whatever they felt.
However, that wasn't the clincher. What did it for me? That "kick in the gut" truth I was talking about. Wow. Melissa, in one single book, challenged everything I had once unconsciously thought about people, life, other people's opinions...everything.
Melissa chose a subject that many people find to be a hard pill to swallow, and turned it into something beautifully different.
This book isn't just a great romance...it's life changing.
_______________________________________________________
*My Rating*
I give A Heart Most Certain by Melissa Jagears...
5 stars!!
_______________________________________________
*I received this book from Litfuse, the publisher and the author in exchange for an honest review, which I have given. All thoughts were my own and I was not compensated in any other way.
April 19, 2018
This was an enjoyable book that served as a great reminder to always judge less and love more! I loved both Lydia and Nicholas’s characters and enjoyed watching Lydia’s growth throughout the book. I am looking forward to the other books in this series.
June 30, 2019
Wow! Every year there's that one book that just takes me by surprise! That one book that when I look at the front cover and read the back cover I think it will probably end up being kinda so-so. That one book that I'm only reading because a friend shoved it in my arms and insisted. That one book that I got halfway through and suddenly went, "Wait! What?" and every previous assumption I'd made about the book suddenly flew out the window and I found I just couldn't read fast enough! That one book where the characters felt like me, where their ideas and fears and passions felt like my own. That one book that challenged my ideas about things like poverty, hypocrisy, tithing, witnessing vs. reputation, and many times made me set the book aside and ponder what I'd just read and whether or not I would be willing to let God use me in that way. That one book where I've had a spiritual thought niggling at me for weeks now and its like God used THAT ONE BOOK to say in clearly printed black and white that I have a problem in this area of my life and I need to deal with it! This is that one book. Its amazing, its beautiful, the romance is endearing, and the character lessons are incredible! Read this and let it become that one book for you!
August 22, 2016
Yes, A Heart Most Certain shows Melissa Jagears to be a fresh voice in historical romance (even if the title does sound more Siri Mitchell). Everything about A Heart Most Certain impressed me.
The writing was excellent, there was a clear and challenging Christian message, the plot was solid with plenty of twists and turns, and just enough predictability (hey, this is romance! There are some aspects we want to be predictable). And both lead characters were excellent—an intelligent heroine who wasn’t afraid to ask hard questions, and a truly heroic hero (okay, he might have been a bit too perfect. But that’s the closest I can get to a criticism about A Heart Most Certain).
Lydia and Nicholas are both excellent characters—complete opposites, so of course we know they are both going to have to change their views. The setting was portrayed well, both in terms of time and place—and reinforced why I’m glad I live now, not then. It’s also an example of how historical fiction can shine a light into some of our more modern social problems. We can be thankful for the truth of Nicolas’s words:
One day society will not condemn a man or woman for a past choice
and instead discern and judge the heart.
We might not treat “sinners” in the same judgemental way as Mrs Light’s Teaville Ladies Moral Society does, but we still have to guard against turning our faith into a religion of rules. Melissa Jagears is to be commended for not shying away from difficult subjects like prostitution, but showing a proper Christian response to the problem.
Recommended for fans of Francine Rivers, Karen Witemeyer and Dawn Crandall.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free book for review.
The writing was excellent, there was a clear and challenging Christian message, the plot was solid with plenty of twists and turns, and just enough predictability (hey, this is romance! There are some aspects we want to be predictable). And both lead characters were excellent—an intelligent heroine who wasn’t afraid to ask hard questions, and a truly heroic hero (okay, he might have been a bit too perfect. But that’s the closest I can get to a criticism about A Heart Most Certain).
Lydia and Nicholas are both excellent characters—complete opposites, so of course we know they are both going to have to change their views. The setting was portrayed well, both in terms of time and place—and reinforced why I’m glad I live now, not then. It’s also an example of how historical fiction can shine a light into some of our more modern social problems. We can be thankful for the truth of Nicolas’s words:
One day society will not condemn a man or woman for a past choice
and instead discern and judge the heart.
We might not treat “sinners” in the same judgemental way as Mrs Light’s Teaville Ladies Moral Society does, but we still have to guard against turning our faith into a religion of rules. Melissa Jagears is to be commended for not shying away from difficult subjects like prostitution, but showing a proper Christian response to the problem.
Recommended for fans of Francine Rivers, Karen Witemeyer and Dawn Crandall.
Thanks to Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free book for review.
August 4, 2016
Lydia knows what it is like to be poor and embarrassed by the actions of a family member. So she joins the Moral Society of her church. When the leader, her future mother-in-law, tasks her with getting money from the stingiest man in town. If she can get the money than she'll be considered worthy and a the type of wife that Sebastian needs for his political career. But Nicholas isn't really stingy. He just prefers to do his charity work anonymously and under his own terms. So he agrees to a wager of sorts with Lydia in hopes of showing her his side of things. Neither one gets exactly what they bargained for.
I've enjoyed all of the books by this author so far. But this one is my new favorite. I loved the uniqueness of the characters, the bit of drama/suspense that was thrown in at the end, the beautiful pictures she painted, and the strong faith of the main characters. The story is definitely entertaining and I had fun reading it, but it also had some deeper elements that made me think about charity, Christian giving, and faith. The female character was devoted to her mother and showed a Christian love that was willing to sacrifice personal wants for others. The well written plot and detailed descriptions brought the story to life. This book would be enjoyed by someone who enjoys clean romance, deeper issues, a little bit of drama, and fun, historical characters. Overall, this was a wonderful book that I really enjoyed and I am looking forward to the next book by this author.
I received this book free of charge in exchange for my honest review.
I've enjoyed all of the books by this author so far. But this one is my new favorite. I loved the uniqueness of the characters, the bit of drama/suspense that was thrown in at the end, the beautiful pictures she painted, and the strong faith of the main characters. The story is definitely entertaining and I had fun reading it, but it also had some deeper elements that made me think about charity, Christian giving, and faith. The female character was devoted to her mother and showed a Christian love that was willing to sacrifice personal wants for others. The well written plot and detailed descriptions brought the story to life. This book would be enjoyed by someone who enjoys clean romance, deeper issues, a little bit of drama, and fun, historical characters. Overall, this was a wonderful book that I really enjoyed and I am looking forward to the next book by this author.
I received this book free of charge in exchange for my honest review.
August 12, 2016
A Heart Most Certain was such a deep and moving story! The author did an amazing job of filling the book with rich, historic details which made me feel that I had traveled back in time to the fictional town of Teaville, Kansas.
This novel was truly a wonderful combination of history, romance, and social commentary. While a piece of historical fiction, the behavior of the church members toward women and children whom society had thrown away, was clearly not in tune with the teachings of the Bible. The hypocritical behavior of these people was very well-written. Watching Lydia and Nicholas attempt to do actual good for the downtrodden while others simply condemned them spoke volumes.
Not only did A Heart Most Certain address the issue of church hypocrisy and the attitudes of the hearts of its members, but there were some fabulously disturbing villains, who seemed almost untouchable. And through it all, there was a heartwarming love story that grew and flourished within the pages, coming to a beautiful conclusion. I am looking forward to future books in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
This novel was truly a wonderful combination of history, romance, and social commentary. While a piece of historical fiction, the behavior of the church members toward women and children whom society had thrown away, was clearly not in tune with the teachings of the Bible. The hypocritical behavior of these people was very well-written. Watching Lydia and Nicholas attempt to do actual good for the downtrodden while others simply condemned them spoke volumes.
Not only did A Heart Most Certain address the issue of church hypocrisy and the attitudes of the hearts of its members, but there were some fabulously disturbing villains, who seemed almost untouchable. And through it all, there was a heartwarming love story that grew and flourished within the pages, coming to a beautiful conclusion. I am looking forward to future books in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
April 17, 2024
Oh my. I can't wait to share my review with you...just hang in there, it will be up soon!
May 15, 2018
A Heart Most Certain
Lydia is a young lady from a family suffering financially due to her father's gambling and drinking. She was raised like a lady, and is quite lovely, so she is acceptable in society and now in a relationship with the mayor's son.
Jumping through hoops for her church's moral society her task is to get a donation from the richest man in the community for sewing machines to sew quilts for poor families before winter sets in. Not an easy proposition. Known as the equivalent of Ebenezer Scrooge, Nicholas simply refuses to give out donations.
This book is really too good for me to go into much detail as to how the donation came about, and what Lydia had to do to verify this donation and others that were promised. Nothing underhanded I assure you, but with the verification came some life altering lessons for Lydia.
Some spoilers...
My only real criticism is internal dialogue of the two main characters. There's way too much of it. I don't want to go into detail on this because it will detract from the good parts of this book. Just my own reading taste.
Anyway, this is a good book and worth the read.
Lydia is a young lady from a family suffering financially due to her father's gambling and drinking. She was raised like a lady, and is quite lovely, so she is acceptable in society and now in a relationship with the mayor's son.
Jumping through hoops for her church's moral society her task is to get a donation from the richest man in the community for sewing machines to sew quilts for poor families before winter sets in. Not an easy proposition. Known as the equivalent of Ebenezer Scrooge, Nicholas simply refuses to give out donations.
This book is really too good for me to go into much detail as to how the donation came about, and what Lydia had to do to verify this donation and others that were promised. Nothing underhanded I assure you, but with the verification came some life altering lessons for Lydia.
Some spoilers...
My only real criticism is internal dialogue of the two main characters. There's way too much of it. I don't want to go into detail on this because it will detract from the good parts of this book. Just my own reading taste.
Anyway, this is a good book and worth the read.
October 19, 2016
Lydia King is practical and somewhat naive but she's also determined and courageous and has a tender heart. While her practical side persuades her that, in order to not end up on the streets or in the poorhouse, she needs to marry the politician courting her, her tender heart is drawn to the needs of the people in the seedy side of town that Nicholas opens her eyes to. I really enjoyed her character and the way that she matured and changed throughout the book.
Nicholas is a good man with the heart to help the people that the rest of the town turn their backs on. But he has his reasons for doing it in secret which leads to misunderstandings. He frustrated me for the longest with his stubbornness in not giving Lydia the money for the sewing machines. I mean really! What could be wrong about sewing for the poor?! Of course he has his reasons and his explanation about the difference in the warm wool blankets they could buy with that money vs the non-practical blankets the ladies would sew made sense. But I also agreed with Lydia's point that even the poor could appreciate something pretty in their life.
When the two join forces, the unforeseen complications that arise and the town secrets that are brought to light give this story an intrigue that will keep you turning pages. Will Lydia give in the politician and the promise of a financially secure future or will she listen to her heart and take a chance on love? And will Nicholas put aside the hurts of the past and let his heart love again?
*Thanks to NetGalley & Bethany House for a complimentary copy of this book. I was not paid or required to write a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
Nicholas is a good man with the heart to help the people that the rest of the town turn their backs on. But he has his reasons for doing it in secret which leads to misunderstandings. He frustrated me for the longest with his stubbornness in not giving Lydia the money for the sewing machines. I mean really! What could be wrong about sewing for the poor?! Of course he has his reasons and his explanation about the difference in the warm wool blankets they could buy with that money vs the non-practical blankets the ladies would sew made sense. But I also agreed with Lydia's point that even the poor could appreciate something pretty in their life.
When the two join forces, the unforeseen complications that arise and the town secrets that are brought to light give this story an intrigue that will keep you turning pages. Will Lydia give in the politician and the promise of a financially secure future or will she listen to her heart and take a chance on love? And will Nicholas put aside the hurts of the past and let his heart love again?
*Thanks to NetGalley & Bethany House for a complimentary copy of this book. I was not paid or required to write a positive review and all opinions stated are my own.*
July 8, 2016
"A Heart Most Certain" is a Christian romance set in 1905 in Kansas. The historical details were a vital part of the plot. The author researched how the church at that time generally dealt with prostitutes. Lydia initially shared this opinion because she needed to keep a respectable reputation; it's all she has. Due to events in his own life, God has opened Nicholas' heart to helping ex-prostitutes but he does so in secret.
Nicholas teaches Lydia about creating relationships with those you're helping and viewing them as people. Lydia helps him see that he needs the help of fellow Christians even if there are hypocrites in the church. Both are better people for having met the other, and they shared a passion for helping overlooked people.
But Nicholas is reluctant to love another woman after his wife's betrayal, and Lydia is being pressured into marriage with a man that she doesn't love or respect. Lydia was very brave, and I sympathized with her struggle to make the right decisions as that wasn't always clear.
There were no graphic sex descriptions despite plenty of characters who were prostitutes. The minor amount of bad language was given as "he cursed" instead of the actual bad words. Overall, I'd recommend this interesting book.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
Nicholas teaches Lydia about creating relationships with those you're helping and viewing them as people. Lydia helps him see that he needs the help of fellow Christians even if there are hypocrites in the church. Both are better people for having met the other, and they shared a passion for helping overlooked people.
But Nicholas is reluctant to love another woman after his wife's betrayal, and Lydia is being pressured into marriage with a man that she doesn't love or respect. Lydia was very brave, and I sympathized with her struggle to make the right decisions as that wasn't always clear.
There were no graphic sex descriptions despite plenty of characters who were prostitutes. The minor amount of bad language was given as "he cursed" instead of the actual bad words. Overall, I'd recommend this interesting book.
I received an ebook review copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley.
October 17, 2016
This book was so different than the others that this author has written, but still just as good. For one thing, it was deeper than her others. I'll admit that I didn't find it to be the fluffy read I expected, but that's a good thing.
I remember meeting Lydia in the novella, Engaging the Competition. She was still in school in that novella. In this book, Lydia is grown up. She has a tender heart, but doesn't really understand being charitable until she meets Nicholas. As they go about their missions, Lydia has to admit some hard truths about herself. I loved the fact that the author didn't make it easy for Lydia. Nicholas, too, had to face some hard truths about himself and how others see him.
This is one book that while it is a historical romance, the romance actually took a back seat. It's been a while since I've seen that happen. I'm looking forward to the next in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author as part of her team of influencers. All she asked me to do was to help get the word out about the book, and to honestly give my opinion of the book. She did not ask me to like the book, though I did enjoy it. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Karen Witemeyer, Jody Hedlund Mary Connealy, historical fiction
Rating - 4 stars
I remember meeting Lydia in the novella, Engaging the Competition. She was still in school in that novella. In this book, Lydia is grown up. She has a tender heart, but doesn't really understand being charitable until she meets Nicholas. As they go about their missions, Lydia has to admit some hard truths about herself. I loved the fact that the author didn't make it easy for Lydia. Nicholas, too, had to face some hard truths about himself and how others see him.
This is one book that while it is a historical romance, the romance actually took a back seat. It's been a while since I've seen that happen. I'm looking forward to the next in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of the book from the author as part of her team of influencers. All she asked me to do was to help get the word out about the book, and to honestly give my opinion of the book. She did not ask me to like the book, though I did enjoy it. My thoughts and opinions are my own.
Recommended to fans of Karen Witemeyer, Jody Hedlund Mary Connealy, historical fiction
Rating - 4 stars
August 7, 2016
After reading and loving the prequel novella, Engaging the Competition earlier this year I was eagerly anticipating this new book! And I am absolutely delighted to say that I was not disappointed, this is a fabulous book! The message touched my heart in so many ways, this is one novel that I won't soon forget!
I have recently discovered that I tend to really enjoy stories of true love between a rich man and a poor girl, and Lydia and Nicholas' story was a beautiful example of loving someone for who they are rather than their money or lack thereof! I loved Lydia in the prequel and was really looking forward to her story, and it was a fantastic one!
I can't say it enough, this is a phenomenal book that everyone should read!
The pace was slower than I had expected it to be but that actually worked out well as I was able to savor the awesomeness!
Overall, I loved this book and highly recommend it! By the way, Nicholas is one of swoon-worthiest heroes I've ever read about! I plan to reread this book and the prequel novella many times in the future!
I was honored to receive a complimentary copy of this amazing book from the author and Bethany house publishers in exchange for helping to promote it! Thanks!
I have recently discovered that I tend to really enjoy stories of true love between a rich man and a poor girl, and Lydia and Nicholas' story was a beautiful example of loving someone for who they are rather than their money or lack thereof! I loved Lydia in the prequel and was really looking forward to her story, and it was a fantastic one!
I can't say it enough, this is a phenomenal book that everyone should read!
The pace was slower than I had expected it to be but that actually worked out well as I was able to savor the awesomeness!
Overall, I loved this book and highly recommend it! By the way, Nicholas is one of swoon-worthiest heroes I've ever read about! I plan to reread this book and the prequel novella many times in the future!
I was honored to receive a complimentary copy of this amazing book from the author and Bethany house publishers in exchange for helping to promote it! Thanks!
March 29, 2017
What I Loved: EVERYTHING! I loved everything about A Heart Most Certain. First of all, it's a lovely cover! One of my favorites of the year. But I guess it's time for me to dig a little deeper in this review...
From the very first scene, when Lydia compared Mr. Lowe to Scrooge, Melissa stole my heart. A Christmas Carol is one of my favorite stories and I thoroughly enjoyed the ongoing connection between the two men.
A Heart Most Certain challenges the reader, as it did its characters, to consider how they treat fallen people and their methods of evangelizing them. Lydia and Nicholas clashed from the very beginning with their drastically different views. It was a joy to watch them both grow and change.
The plot twisted in unexpected ways. I loved my time here in Teaville and I look forward to the next installment in the series.
Rating and Recommendation: Melissa Jagears has more than earned these 5 stars and I highly recommend this one to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction or those who are looking for a Christian book that addresses the tough subjects.
~I received a copy from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.
From the very first scene, when Lydia compared Mr. Lowe to Scrooge, Melissa stole my heart. A Christmas Carol is one of my favorite stories and I thoroughly enjoyed the ongoing connection between the two men.
A Heart Most Certain challenges the reader, as it did its characters, to consider how they treat fallen people and their methods of evangelizing them. Lydia and Nicholas clashed from the very beginning with their drastically different views. It was a joy to watch them both grow and change.
The plot twisted in unexpected ways. I loved my time here in Teaville and I look forward to the next installment in the series.
Rating and Recommendation: Melissa Jagears has more than earned these 5 stars and I highly recommend this one to anyone who enjoys Christian Historical Fiction or those who are looking for a Christian book that addresses the tough subjects.
~I received a copy from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts are my own.
August 15, 2016
Can I just say this is hands-down my favorite of Melissa Jagears books I’ve read? And I’ve read several. I’ll be honest, probably the thing I loved best about this book was the Pride and Prejudice vibe: Wealthy man who has his opinions about the others in the church and a tenacious woman who is on the brink of poverty herself but refuses to back down from her mission.
While they both have their flaws, Nicholas and Lydia are likable characters (because Jagears isn’t afraid to show their humanity to readers). As the two begin to let go of their own prejudices and see through the eyes of the other person, they both become even better people for it. A wonderful read that has me looking forward to the next in this series.
***Bethany House Publishers provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest and fair review. All opinions expressed are my own.
While they both have their flaws, Nicholas and Lydia are likable characters (because Jagears isn’t afraid to show their humanity to readers). As the two begin to let go of their own prejudices and see through the eyes of the other person, they both become even better people for it. A wonderful read that has me looking forward to the next in this series.
***Bethany House Publishers provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest and fair review. All opinions expressed are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 274 reviews