What do you think?
Rate this book
Return to the Canadian West #3
Where Hope Prevails
When Beth Thatcher returns to Coal Valley, she has much to be excited about. She anticipates Jarrick's proposal of marriage and perhaps a spring wedding. The mine is expanding, and there are more schoolchildren than ever.
But the town's rapid growth brings many challenges. A second teacher is assigned, and Beth finds herself going head-to-head with a very different philosophy of education--one that dismisses religion and rejects God. Fearful for the children who sit under the influence of Robert Harris Hughes, Beth struggles to know how to respond.
At the same time, Beth wonders if Jarrick is considering a position at her father's company simply for her sake. Should she admit her feelings on the matter? Or keep silent and allow Jarrick to make up his own mind?
But the town's rapid growth brings many challenges. A second teacher is assigned, and Beth finds herself going head-to-head with a very different philosophy of education--one that dismisses religion and rejects God. Fearful for the children who sit under the influence of Robert Harris Hughes, Beth struggles to know how to respond.
At the same time, Beth wonders if Jarrick is considering a position at her father's company simply for her sake. Should she admit her feelings on the matter? Or keep silent and allow Jarrick to make up his own mind?
448 pages, Paperback
Published August 2, 2016
250 people are currently reading
1932 people want to read
About the author
Janette Oke
347 books3,431 followersJanette Oke is a Canadian author known for her inspirational fiction, often set in a pioneer era and focused on female protagonists. Her debut novel, Love Comes Softly (1979), became the foundation for a successful series, followed by over 75 other novels. The first book in her Canadian West series, When Calls the Heart (1983), inspired the popular television series of the same name.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Born in Champion, Alberta, to farmers Fred and Amy (née Ruggles) Steeves during the Great Depression, Oke went on to graduate from Mountain View Bible College in Didsbury, Alberta, where she met her future husband, Edward Oke, who later became the president of the college. The couple has four children, including a daughter who has collaborated with Janette on several books.
A committed Evangelical Christian, Oke has authored numerous works exploring themes of faith. She has received various accolades for her contributions to Christian fiction, including the 1992 President's Award from the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association and the 1999 CBA Life Impact Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 136 reviews
January 18, 2018
This was a lovely conclusion to the trilogy! Definitely my favorite of the three! Perhaps it is because I could do identify with Beth and imagine myself in her shoes. Yeah, so much of Beth and her struggles are me! And once again, I admire and appreciate the strong, Biblical backbone and answers provided in this book. By the end, I was heartily cheering Beth along for the choices she made!
The spiritual content is the heartbeat of this book. It is what makes the characters the characters they are. The book would be nothing without it. I can’t say enough how much I appreciate Janette Oke’s (and in this series, Laurel Oke Logan’s) stance to present Biblical truth in her books.
The romance in this was very clean and unemotional. Honestly, I’m coming away with, “What romance?” There was so much else with this book than romance. Perhaps there were a couple of kisses mentioned (obviously not in detail), Beth missing Jarrick when they were apart, etc., but it was not at all a romance novel.
So yes, I’m very happy to have this book adorning my shelves, and happily recommend it.
The spiritual content is the heartbeat of this book. It is what makes the characters the characters they are. The book would be nothing without it. I can’t say enough how much I appreciate Janette Oke’s (and in this series, Laurel Oke Logan’s) stance to present Biblical truth in her books.
The romance in this was very clean and unemotional. Honestly, I’m coming away with, “What romance?” There was so much else with this book than romance. Perhaps there were a couple of kisses mentioned (obviously not in detail), Beth missing Jarrick when they were apart, etc., but it was not at all a romance novel.
So yes, I’m very happy to have this book adorning my shelves, and happily recommend it.
August 22, 2016
About this book:
“She leans forward for her first glimpse of the little mountain town that has captured her heart, but something has changed.
Elizabeth Thatcher's highly anticipated return to her beloved Coal Valley after a long summer with her family back east is filled with surprises . . . and not all of them good ones, in her estimation. Maybe the worst one of all relates to her treasured students. Can she adapt and learn to cope with this enormous change?
Her Mountie, Jarrick Thornton, hasn't yet proposed, but she already knows what her answer will be. His duties take him away from the valley much too often, in her view, but the two of them, with patience and understanding--and one significant misunderstanding--are learning to know each other better.
The dark cloud looming on the horizon in Beth's mind, though, is filled with questions about where their future might take them. As a member of the RCMP, Jarrick is stationed wherever his superiors send him . . . but what about her teaching position in Coal Valley?
Beth attempts to do her best with each obstacle she faces, but does she rightly assess each situation as it surfaces? Good intentions don't always lead to good results. . . .
A companion story to Hallmark Channel's When Calls the Heart TV series”
Series: Book #3 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. (Review of #1 Here! Book #2 review Here!) {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many Prayers; Many Scriptures are quoted, mentioned, remembered & talked about; Church going; Many Talks about God, His will, pleasing Him & hope; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God (not capital when an unbeliever is talking about God, though); Mr. Harris Hughes does not believe in God & many mentions of that; Many mentions of churches, a pastor & preaching; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers, thanking God & blessings over food; Mentions of faiths, Christians & religious people; Mentions of blessings; Mentions of Bible & lessons; Mentions of those in the Bible; Mentions of a Bible club; Mentions of the possibility of children being astray from Biblical teachings; Mentions of Christmas & a play; A few mention of religions; A couple mentions of Heaven; A couple mentions of singing hymns; A mention of the Lord’s Prayer;
*Note: Mentions of worldly gods; Mentions of ghosts; A mention of superstition.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘hush up’; Pain (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of the mine explosion & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of an attempted suicide & blood (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a bear & bear attack (barley-above-not-detailed); Mentions of injuries (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of Book #2’s kidnapping; Mentions of gossip & jealousy; A few mentions of a bootlegger, threats, evil & jail; A few mentions of a saloon/pool hall; A couple mentions of a nightmare; A couple mentions of a pipe & smoke; A mention of tobacco; A mention of a nightclub.
Sexual Content- A nose kiss, a head kiss, a forehead kiss, and two barely-above-not-detailed kisses; Embraces, Touches, Warmth & Nearness (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of making eyes & mooning over someone (married or engaged); A couple mentions of a wife & a baby who died in childbirth; A few mentions of a rumor that a man acted ungentlemanly towards a young girl (which didn’t actually happen); Mentions of crushes & blushes; Mentions of reputations & chaperons; Mentions of a honeymoon (no details); Love, being in love & a bit of the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s
317 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Ahhh, such a Janette Oke book! Such a sweet story-line and lots of Spiritual Content! Even though this series isn’t very close to the TV Show it’s a companion to, it makes me look forward to the Christmas special. I am hoping for another book in this series, though! ;)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House Publishers) for this review.
“She leans forward for her first glimpse of the little mountain town that has captured her heart, but something has changed.
Elizabeth Thatcher's highly anticipated return to her beloved Coal Valley after a long summer with her family back east is filled with surprises . . . and not all of them good ones, in her estimation. Maybe the worst one of all relates to her treasured students. Can she adapt and learn to cope with this enormous change?
Her Mountie, Jarrick Thornton, hasn't yet proposed, but she already knows what her answer will be. His duties take him away from the valley much too often, in her view, but the two of them, with patience and understanding--and one significant misunderstanding--are learning to know each other better.
The dark cloud looming on the horizon in Beth's mind, though, is filled with questions about where their future might take them. As a member of the RCMP, Jarrick is stationed wherever his superiors send him . . . but what about her teaching position in Coal Valley?
Beth attempts to do her best with each obstacle she faces, but does she rightly assess each situation as it surfaces? Good intentions don't always lead to good results. . . .
A companion story to Hallmark Channel's When Calls the Heart TV series”
Series: Book #3 in the “Return to the Canadian West” series. (Review of #1 Here! Book #2 review Here!) {There is another series that follows Beth’s aunt, Elizabeth, called the “Canadian West” series. Read Reviews of #1 Here, #2 Here, #3 Here, #4 Here, #5 Here, and #6 Here. You do not have to read the first series to understand this one, but it’s a great series to read. :) }
Spiritual Content- Many Prayers; Many Scriptures are quoted, mentioned, remembered & talked about; Church going; Many Talks about God, His will, pleasing Him & hope; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God (not capital when an unbeliever is talking about God, though); Mr. Harris Hughes does not believe in God & many mentions of that; Many mentions of churches, a pastor & preaching; Mentions of God; Mentions of prayers, thanking God & blessings over food; Mentions of faiths, Christians & religious people; Mentions of blessings; Mentions of Bible & lessons; Mentions of those in the Bible; Mentions of a Bible club; Mentions of the possibility of children being astray from Biblical teachings; Mentions of Christmas & a play; A few mention of religions; A couple mentions of Heaven; A couple mentions of singing hymns; A mention of the Lord’s Prayer;
*Note: Mentions of worldly gods; Mentions of ghosts; A mention of superstition.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘hush up’; Pain (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of the mine explosion & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of an attempted suicide & blood (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a bear & bear attack (barley-above-not-detailed); Mentions of injuries (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of Book #2’s kidnapping; Mentions of gossip & jealousy; A few mentions of a bootlegger, threats, evil & jail; A few mentions of a saloon/pool hall; A couple mentions of a nightmare; A couple mentions of a pipe & smoke; A mention of tobacco; A mention of a nightclub.
Sexual Content- A nose kiss, a head kiss, a forehead kiss, and two barely-above-not-detailed kisses; Embraces, Touches, Warmth & Nearness (barely-above-not-detailed); A couple mentions of making eyes & mooning over someone (married or engaged); A couple mentions of a wife & a baby who died in childbirth; A few mentions of a rumor that a man acted ungentlemanly towards a young girl (which didn’t actually happen); Mentions of crushes & blushes; Mentions of reputations & chaperons; Mentions of a honeymoon (no details); Love, being in love & a bit of the emotions.
-Beth Thatcher
P.O.V. of Beth
Set in the 1920s
317 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars (and a half)
My personal Rating- Four Stars
Ahhh, such a Janette Oke book! Such a sweet story-line and lots of Spiritual Content! Even though this series isn’t very close to the TV Show it’s a companion to, it makes me look forward to the Christmas special. I am hoping for another book in this series, though! ;)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House Publishers) for this review.
September 10, 2016
I was so excited to read this but I ended up being disappointed.
1) The "mystery" was never fully explained beyond who Beth thought the perpetrator was and why - but it was never confirmed.
2) The antagonistic relationship between the two teachers was kind of awkward and didn't serve much purpose. It seemed like filler to me. Also, Beth beats herself up so much over the way she treats Robert, but I didn't really think she was out of line in a lot of things she said. She just seemed to dwell on it so much that it was almost an obsession for her.
3) Jack was barely in it.
4) Marnie - and everyone's reaction to her (specifically their lack of reaction).
5) Beth's role as subordinate. I know these books are set in an earlier time period, but there are plenty of books out there set in the early 20th century that don't reinforce the idea that women are beneath men.
I did like the character of Julie, who has matured a lot since the second book. She wasn't in it enough in my opinion.
Overall probably a 2.5. I'm sorry to give this such a low rating but I just didn't enjoy this one as much as the first or second in the series.
1) The "mystery" was never fully explained beyond who Beth thought the perpetrator was and why - but it was never confirmed.
2) The antagonistic relationship between the two teachers was kind of awkward and didn't serve much purpose. It seemed like filler to me. Also, Beth beats herself up so much over the way she treats Robert, but I didn't really think she was out of line in a lot of things she said. She just seemed to dwell on it so much that it was almost an obsession for her.
3) Jack was barely in it.
4) Marnie - and everyone's reaction to her (specifically their lack of reaction).
5) Beth's role as subordinate. I know these books are set in an earlier time period, but there are plenty of books out there set in the early 20th century that don't reinforce the idea that women are beneath men.
I did like the character of Julie, who has matured a lot since the second book. She wasn't in it enough in my opinion.
Overall probably a 2.5. I'm sorry to give this such a low rating but I just didn't enjoy this one as much as the first or second in the series.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 4, 2016
Beth Thatcher has returned to Coal Valley and is shocked at how it looks, she doesn’t recognize her beloved valley, most of the prized trees have been clear-cut, and ugly stumps remain. I could sympathize with her here, I don’t like change, and coming to grips with it is not easy.
There is a lot more changes that she has to come to terms with, as the town has grown a lot in the short time that she has been gone, she finds a new teacher here, but wait a moment isn’t Beth the teacher? Oh poor Beth, but she is back and we know that Jarrick is about to pop the question, and her dear friends are there for her.
Beth is about to learn some dear life lessons, and God is her conscience and at times she is reminded of her Faith. This story tests Beth right up to almost the last page, and reminders are here from the past books, along with a reference to Beth’s Aunt Elizabeth.
I will admit that I have read all of Janette Oke’s books, and now Laurel’s, and have not been disappointed.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
There is a lot more changes that she has to come to terms with, as the town has grown a lot in the short time that she has been gone, she finds a new teacher here, but wait a moment isn’t Beth the teacher? Oh poor Beth, but she is back and we know that Jarrick is about to pop the question, and her dear friends are there for her.
Beth is about to learn some dear life lessons, and God is her conscience and at times she is reminded of her Faith. This story tests Beth right up to almost the last page, and reminders are here from the past books, along with a reference to Beth’s Aunt Elizabeth.
I will admit that I have read all of Janette Oke’s books, and now Laurel’s, and have not been disappointed.
I received this book through Net Galley and the Publisher Bethany House, and was not required to give a positive review.
July 12, 2021
A great conclusion to the series! I was absolutely delighted to return with Beth to Coal Valley, but like her, I was a bit surprised by all the changes that had occurred. As a person that shies away from change, I really related to Beth's feelings. However, Beth's personal journey encouraged me as well to understand and be content with changes.
I enjoyed all the moments with Beth and the people of Coal Valley, and I will miss every single one of them. I do wish we got to read more about Jarrick and their life afterwards though.
I ended up reading this series because I'm such a huge fan of the Canadian West series, and although for me it just wasn't quite as good, I still greatly enjoyed this series. It was a privilege to go on Beth's journey and watch her blossom into a strong and beautiful woman.
I enjoyed all the moments with Beth and the people of Coal Valley, and I will miss every single one of them. I do wish we got to read more about Jarrick and their life afterwards though.
I ended up reading this series because I'm such a huge fan of the Canadian West series, and although for me it just wasn't quite as good, I still greatly enjoyed this series. It was a privilege to go on Beth's journey and watch her blossom into a strong and beautiful woman.
September 7, 2016
A sweet conclusion that wrapped things up, yet not in a way that left it feeling rushed nor dismissed. Beth's and Jarrett's story continues to blossom, and they learn much more about each other, and themselves. I love the growth and development in the whole series of the characters, especially of Beth, from a somewhat spoiled rich girl, to someone that relies on her faith and trust in God. The romance was lovely, but I've always enjoyed the journey of the town, and its people the most. The relationships throughout have a special place in my heart, and then from the beginning, we (and Beth) are thrown in a frenzy with all the change happening! Change and the aftermaths of change, be it good or disheartening, how these characters accept (or deny) and carry on, that's what makes this last installment riveting to say the least. It was a good and lovely goodbye.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly Blog .
NOTE: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly Blog .
NOTE: I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
January 5, 2020
After a year I have finally finished the When Calls the Heart saga. While I liked the first series better, the Canadian West, this sequel series is good to. It was nice to see familiar characters from the TV show, even if the book and show are nothing alike.
Elizabeth’s struggle with Mr. Harris Hughes was something I really related to. I didn’t appreciate his opinions either. It helps you to reflect on your own relationships and see how others view your actions.
Elizabeth’s struggle with Mr. Harris Hughes was something I really related to. I didn’t appreciate his opinions either. It helps you to reflect on your own relationships and see how others view your actions.
October 16, 2021
Elizabeth Thatcher returns to Hope Valley to teach and she has since become engaged to Mountie Jack Thorton. She is getting ready to teach and get ready for her wedding as well.She also has to deal with her new teacher who is a man and she not sure about him.He has different ideas about teaching then she does.
June 15, 2023
Third book in the Return to the Canadian West series. I really enjoyed all three books and am sorry to see it end.
August 7, 2016
First sentence: It wasn't just that there were far fewer potholes--the road through the thick woods leading to Coal Valley had clearly been graded in Beth's absence over the summer--but something else seemed strange.
Premise/plot: Where Hope Prevails is the third book in the Return to the Canadian West series by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan. The series is set in the early twentieth century. (Beth does a lot of traveling back and forth by automobile.) Beth Thatcher, our heroine, teaches in the town of Coal Valley. She's in love with a Canadian Mountie, Jarrick Thornton, who is stationed in the region--but not in Coal Valley itself. He works from a much larger town, Lethbridge.
The book opens with her return to Coal Valley at the beginning of a new school year. A few things have changed this second year. First, she'll no longer be boarding with Molly. She'll have her own place, and, she's not excited about it. Second, there is another teacher in town, Robert Harris Hughes, and they'll have to work out between them how to best teach the children. He wants to divide up subjects between them. She wants to divide the children up by age. These two are as opposite as can be. And they seem destined to argue. If Jack wasn't such a huge part of the story, one might fear that these two who love to argue might stereotypically fall in love by the end of the book.
Much of the book focuses on WEDDING PLANS. Some might say that a lot happens--that there is always something happening--but whether that "something happening" is exciting or not might be up for question. How exciting is it to read about characters making fabric flowers and tulle bows and lamenting the lack of an arch? That's not fair to the book. It isn't. It really isn't. Readers see Beth interacting with the folk of Coal Valley--Molly and Frank and Marnie, mainly. Some town politics also come into it. There is an election for mayor in the middle of the book. But a large part of the "something happening" is Beth struggling with things emotionally, mentally, spiritually. I would still say that it is character-driven.
My thoughts: Since it feels like it has been ages since I've read the first two books in the series, and, since it hasn't been that many months since I've seen the seasons of the television show, I felt a bit out of sorts. What does the book have in common with the television show? How about just the character names? And the fact that Beth is a teacher and that Jack is a Mountie? I would say that the books have very, very, very little in common with the television show. I think one can argue that that is a definite strength. But also that it can prove frustrating...if you let it.
I like the series well enough. I do. I definitely like book Julie a bit better perhaps. And the book is not like a soap opera at all. (The tv show very much IS a soap opera.)
Premise/plot: Where Hope Prevails is the third book in the Return to the Canadian West series by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan. The series is set in the early twentieth century. (Beth does a lot of traveling back and forth by automobile.) Beth Thatcher, our heroine, teaches in the town of Coal Valley. She's in love with a Canadian Mountie, Jarrick Thornton, who is stationed in the region--but not in Coal Valley itself. He works from a much larger town, Lethbridge.
The book opens with her return to Coal Valley at the beginning of a new school year. A few things have changed this second year. First, she'll no longer be boarding with Molly. She'll have her own place, and, she's not excited about it. Second, there is another teacher in town, Robert Harris Hughes, and they'll have to work out between them how to best teach the children. He wants to divide up subjects between them. She wants to divide the children up by age. These two are as opposite as can be. And they seem destined to argue. If Jack wasn't such a huge part of the story, one might fear that these two who love to argue might stereotypically fall in love by the end of the book.
Much of the book focuses on WEDDING PLANS. Some might say that a lot happens--that there is always something happening--but whether that "something happening" is exciting or not might be up for question. How exciting is it to read about characters making fabric flowers and tulle bows and lamenting the lack of an arch? That's not fair to the book. It isn't. It really isn't. Readers see Beth interacting with the folk of Coal Valley--Molly and Frank and Marnie, mainly. Some town politics also come into it. There is an election for mayor in the middle of the book. But a large part of the "something happening" is Beth struggling with things emotionally, mentally, spiritually. I would still say that it is character-driven.
My thoughts: Since it feels like it has been ages since I've read the first two books in the series, and, since it hasn't been that many months since I've seen the seasons of the television show, I felt a bit out of sorts. What does the book have in common with the television show? How about just the character names? And the fact that Beth is a teacher and that Jack is a Mountie? I would say that the books have very, very, very little in common with the television show. I think one can argue that that is a definite strength. But also that it can prove frustrating...if you let it.
I like the series well enough. I do. I definitely like book Julie a bit better perhaps. And the book is not like a soap opera at all. (The tv show very much IS a soap opera.)
August 21, 2016
Wow!!! is really I can say about this book!!
What an arrogant man!! Who does he think he is anyway?
I almost felt sorry for Beth who returned to Coal Valley to everything changed and new ppl in town. Beth isn't one for change and I have to admit I'm not one for change either even if it is for good. Beth has a lot to overcome. But, I believe she can with the Lords help. Beth also has a challenge.
A new teacher has come to town. Beth isn't sure what his motives are and does t like his ideas for teaching.
Mr.Harry Hastings is new in town and thinks he knows it all! His beliefs differ very differently from Beths. I shouldn't have been shocked as there are a lot of non believers ot there.
I love Mrs. Molly. she runs a boarding house and is a wonderful person and counselor.
Sometimes it seems as of she's a second mother to Beth with her wisdom and wise ways. One things for sure, she definitely kows the Lord.
I love her husband Frank as well. He has a lot of knowledge about the town and who has settled there since it was founded.
It seems to me there is a little mystery involved. Someone is causing a ruckus down by the river. Who is doing it and why?
Beth thinks she can take matters into her own hands and concoct them to go her way.But, when things don't go her way she seems confused and wants to throw a temper tantrum.
Jarrack is still the sweet man that he aways is. He is still my hero! I just looove a Mountie.
I loved this book for. any reasons. first I lived it ease the author is showing us there is still hope no matter what happens in our lives! If and when God allows it, it will happen for He knows what will happen before we do!
Two, she is showing is that there is friendship in this town called Coal Valley. people still do gatherings and feel safe plus they don't mind helping one another. I love that! I wish we could trust like that in today's world but we're not sure who has your back and who doesn't.
One thing I know for sure is God's got our backs. He is always there if you need a true friend.
I received a copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review
I love Janette Oak. I definitely love her writing style! I also wanted to say I loooooved the book cover.
I gave this book a 5 star rating because it was full of wonderful people and I especially enjoyed retuning to my previous friends.
What an arrogant man!! Who does he think he is anyway?
I almost felt sorry for Beth who returned to Coal Valley to everything changed and new ppl in town. Beth isn't one for change and I have to admit I'm not one for change either even if it is for good. Beth has a lot to overcome. But, I believe she can with the Lords help. Beth also has a challenge.
A new teacher has come to town. Beth isn't sure what his motives are and does t like his ideas for teaching.
Mr.Harry Hastings is new in town and thinks he knows it all! His beliefs differ very differently from Beths. I shouldn't have been shocked as there are a lot of non believers ot there.
I love Mrs. Molly. she runs a boarding house and is a wonderful person and counselor.
Sometimes it seems as of she's a second mother to Beth with her wisdom and wise ways. One things for sure, she definitely kows the Lord.
I love her husband Frank as well. He has a lot of knowledge about the town and who has settled there since it was founded.
It seems to me there is a little mystery involved. Someone is causing a ruckus down by the river. Who is doing it and why?
Beth thinks she can take matters into her own hands and concoct them to go her way.But, when things don't go her way she seems confused and wants to throw a temper tantrum.
Jarrack is still the sweet man that he aways is. He is still my hero! I just looove a Mountie.
I loved this book for. any reasons. first I lived it ease the author is showing us there is still hope no matter what happens in our lives! If and when God allows it, it will happen for He knows what will happen before we do!
Two, she is showing is that there is friendship in this town called Coal Valley. people still do gatherings and feel safe plus they don't mind helping one another. I love that! I wish we could trust like that in today's world but we're not sure who has your back and who doesn't.
One thing I know for sure is God's got our backs. He is always there if you need a true friend.
I received a copy of this book from Bethany House in exchange for an honest review
I love Janette Oak. I definitely love her writing style! I also wanted to say I loooooved the book cover.
I gave this book a 5 star rating because it was full of wonderful people and I especially enjoyed retuning to my previous friends.
August 3, 2017
As with the first two books in this series, it wasn't super high action (though there was a bit) and felt like a light read to me. We were back in Coal Valley for most of the book (yay!) but things are a little different this time around.
First off, There is also a new teacher in town due to the town growing so much while Elizabeth was away. However, no one bothered to tell Beth that before she arrived in Coal Valley, so this comes as a shock to her and she is a little miffed about it.
I understood why she treated the new teacher the way she did, but silently hoped she would come around somehow, if it was for the best. There was more than one marriage in the book--one comes as quite a surprise, and I wasn't quite sure how I felt about it, but times were different back then.
There were a few kisses in this book, though not greatly detailed. I really liked how Beth and Jarrick treated each other with dignity and honor throughout their whole courting phase, always seeking to put God first and do the right thing. That was really beautiful, imo.
A few situations popped up as an after thought—a bunch of tools being stolen, and while it was made a big deal in the book, I don't think we ever really figured out what the deal was with that. So I was kind of wondering, "Why even put that in there?"
In the end, our new teacher is in need of a trustworthy reference in regards to his character, as he must appear in court for an accusation against him. Beth says she cannot testify as that day is her wedding day,
All in all, this was a good read. The only reason I am rating four stars is because I like a bit more action, however, I think anymore action might have ruined this book a little, but also, because of the kissing, since I prefer to not read about people kissing each other. :)
First off, There is also a new teacher in town due to the town growing so much while Elizabeth was away. However, no one bothered to tell Beth that before she arrived in Coal Valley, so this comes as a shock to her and she is a little miffed about it.
I understood why she treated the new teacher the way she did, but silently hoped she would come around somehow, if it was for the best. There was more than one marriage in the book--one comes as quite a surprise, and I wasn't quite sure how I felt about it, but times were different back then.
There were a few kisses in this book, though not greatly detailed. I really liked how Beth and Jarrick treated each other with dignity and honor throughout their whole courting phase, always seeking to put God first and do the right thing. That was really beautiful, imo.
A few situations popped up as an after thought—a bunch of tools being stolen, and while it was made a big deal in the book, I don't think we ever really figured out what the deal was with that. So I was kind of wondering, "Why even put that in there?"
In the end, our new teacher is in need of a trustworthy reference in regards to his character, as he must appear in court for an accusation against him. Beth says she cannot testify as that day is her wedding day,
All in all, this was a good read. The only reason I am rating four stars is because I like a bit more action, however, I think anymore action might have ruined this book a little, but also, because of the kissing, since I prefer to not read about people kissing each other. :)
September 29, 2016
Beth returns to Coal Valley planning for a year of teaching and a wedding in the spring. But she doesn’t expect the many changes that have happened while she has been gone all summer. The town has expanded, many trees cut down, and a second teacher hired to accommodate all the new children—a man who does not hold the same beliefs in God and who has moved into her previous home, forcing her to relocate.
Where Hope Prevails is the third and final book in the Return to the Canadian West series by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan. It is a sweet story of growth for Beth, her fiancé, and the many people in her beloved town. Much of the story focuses on Beth as she comes to terms with the changes happening in Coal Valley, especially with the other teacher who she consistently tries to thwart rather than showing him God’s love. The story is rich in historical detail, growing relationships, and sometimes-funny misunderstandings. Beth faces some of her insecurities and learns a little more of what it will mean to be a wife, including facing overbearing in-laws and talking to her partner in a way that is truthful and respectful. Through Beth’s relationship with the other teacher, she struggled with trusting him to teach the children the truth though she believed in God and Creation and he believed in Atheism and Evolution. The most memorable parts of the story truly did focus on the growth of the different characters, and it was very well done.
I enjoyed this book immensely and recommend it to those who love sweet, historical romance.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Where Hope Prevails is the third and final book in the Return to the Canadian West series by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan. It is a sweet story of growth for Beth, her fiancé, and the many people in her beloved town. Much of the story focuses on Beth as she comes to terms with the changes happening in Coal Valley, especially with the other teacher who she consistently tries to thwart rather than showing him God’s love. The story is rich in historical detail, growing relationships, and sometimes-funny misunderstandings. Beth faces some of her insecurities and learns a little more of what it will mean to be a wife, including facing overbearing in-laws and talking to her partner in a way that is truthful and respectful. Through Beth’s relationship with the other teacher, she struggled with trusting him to teach the children the truth though she believed in God and Creation and he believed in Atheism and Evolution. The most memorable parts of the story truly did focus on the growth of the different characters, and it was very well done.
I enjoyed this book immensely and recommend it to those who love sweet, historical romance.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
July 14, 2017
I liked the other two in this series but for some reason this one drove me nuts, Beth in particular. I think because of her naïveté and mooniness over Jarrick (please! Just call him Jack!) and the conservative ethos about marriage. There didn't seem to be much character development in this one to me and there was so little about Beth's actual teaching. Hmm, I'm not sure, but it just didn't sit well with me.
September 24, 2016
This is a gentle read from the mother-daughter duo of Janette Oke and Lauren Oke Logan. I've enjoyed Janette's wonderful books for years, and normally rate her books higher. In this instance, the main female character, Beth, didn't capture my heart the way most of Janette's protagonists do. Maybe it's just me, so Jeanette Oke fans, give this book a try!
September 17, 2016
Pretty good - it ended well, but I wanted more - it didn't tell me what happened after the ending. Overall, this was good, but this was my least favorite one.
July 2, 2018
first ever where I like the TV show or movie better than the books
September 29, 2024
I like the TV series better, but it's been fun to read these books about Coal Valley, the schoolteacher, the Mountie, and all the others in the town. Here are some quotes I liked:
"Summer's so long without you' (p. 17)."
"The school board come, had a long look at our town, made a list of kids we got now, and decided it'll take two teachers to educate 'em all (p. 21)."
"'The way I figure, I've got more'n my share of blessed' (p. 31)."
"'A mighty fortress is our God... A bulwark never failing' (p. 39)."
"Jarrick appeared in the hallway as soon as she paused at the reception desk. Beaming his welcome and lifting both hands toward her, he crossed the room in long strides (p. 42)."
"'You know that I love you... More than I could ever have imagined. And that you're so much more--more precious, exciting, generous, and courageous a person than I had pictured I'd ever meet' (p. 45)."
"'Sweetheart... I just want to take care of you in the best way I know how. I would give up anything on earth to be sure I was making the right decision for the two of us. You mean so much to me, Beth. I can't even describe it' (p. 48)."
"'I'll take care of you, Beth. I'll love you as best I can--God helping me' (p. 49)."
"'I'm the other teacher' (p. 59)."
"'I believe in teaching fundamental skills first and using other subjects to enrich the lessons. And I assure you... that I received my teaching degree from the best women's college in Ontario' (p. 65)."
"'I've found ya can't cling to what ain't gonna be--can't even build on the ruins till the wishin' for what ya wanted first dies away. But it takes time for that to happen' (p. 79)."
"School would begin shortly, and there was a cat in her kitchen. She couldn't leave it inside, yet dared not touch it. So she waited, desperately wondering what on earth to do (p. 82)."
"'And that's the way God loves, even more so, no matter what. But like your mother, Jonah, we can please Him by doing things that are kind and good, by obeying what He tells us in the Bible, and by making a fine place for the people of our church to meet. This is a place where we can learn more about Him, pray, and sing hymns of praise. Doing it together is good for us, and it's something God likes a lot' (p. 85)."
"'Miss Thatcher, you could invite the teacher fer supper. Ya got lots of good' (p. 97)."
"'Mr. Harris Hughes, I'm afraid I do not agree with your philosophy of education. And I feel quite confident that my students are advancing nicely without your methods' (p. 114)."
"'As far as God is concerned, I simply don't believe in him, Miss Thatcher. He can't be proven, and I can't think of any reason why a supposed god would hide himself from those he makes greater claims to love. Religion appears to me to be a vain attempt to control one's environment with superstition' (p. 116)."
"'I don't want to be a political figure. I want to be more of a shepherd--a servant. I don't think the two roles are complementary' (p. 135)."
"'It's so hard to think about leaving' (p. 140)."
"They are exactly what this meeting is about--the children. The school is for them, and the town will be theirs soon enough. Oh, Father, please help me to do whatever I can on their behalf, and help me to honor You with every word and action (p. 150)."
"'Every public servant is accountable to God, first and foremost' (p. 156)."
"'Do ya love him, Beth?' (p. 176)"
"'So I gather we don't like him, then? Why didn't you just tell me so in the first place?' (p. 204)"
"Julie's considerable energies were now focused on winning the election for Frank (p. 210)."
"The project quickly became a school assignment. Beth took some time the following day to discuss the election with her students and to format a list of questions related to their town. What should the mayor do first? What did Coal Valley need most? What problems did its citizens observe? (p. 212)"
"'Help Jarrick now what is best. For him and for our marriage to come' (p. 215)."
"'I think you could be honest with him. Not demanding--simply honest' (p. 229)."
"'When do you plan on being married? And where will you live?' (p. 242)"
"'I don't feel we've had nearly enough time together, Jarrick. I know I'll think of a million things as soon as my head hits the pillow' (p. 249)."
"'Where are we going on our honeymoon? I need to know how to pack. I don't think you understand that a woman needs to prepare for these things' (p. 250)."
"'You know everything about what's going to happen, Lord God. You have a perfect solution. I'll wait for You' (p. 267)."
"Waving goodbye to Jarrick after so little time with him was almost more painful than not having seen him at all (p. 280)."
"It seemed almost unbelievable to Beth that so many of the people she loved could be in one place. She stole quick glances at her mother, who seemed to have come to terms with the rather austere surroundings and was making a point of joining in the conversations (p. 296)."
"'Mother Thornton... I wanted to thank you for your wonderful son--for all you've done to train him up in the way he should go.' (p. 317)"
"Summer's so long without you' (p. 17)."
"The school board come, had a long look at our town, made a list of kids we got now, and decided it'll take two teachers to educate 'em all (p. 21)."
"'The way I figure, I've got more'n my share of blessed' (p. 31)."
"'A mighty fortress is our God... A bulwark never failing' (p. 39)."
"Jarrick appeared in the hallway as soon as she paused at the reception desk. Beaming his welcome and lifting both hands toward her, he crossed the room in long strides (p. 42)."
"'You know that I love you... More than I could ever have imagined. And that you're so much more--more precious, exciting, generous, and courageous a person than I had pictured I'd ever meet' (p. 45)."
"'Sweetheart... I just want to take care of you in the best way I know how. I would give up anything on earth to be sure I was making the right decision for the two of us. You mean so much to me, Beth. I can't even describe it' (p. 48)."
"'I'll take care of you, Beth. I'll love you as best I can--God helping me' (p. 49)."
"'I'm the other teacher' (p. 59)."
"'I believe in teaching fundamental skills first and using other subjects to enrich the lessons. And I assure you... that I received my teaching degree from the best women's college in Ontario' (p. 65)."
"'I've found ya can't cling to what ain't gonna be--can't even build on the ruins till the wishin' for what ya wanted first dies away. But it takes time for that to happen' (p. 79)."
"School would begin shortly, and there was a cat in her kitchen. She couldn't leave it inside, yet dared not touch it. So she waited, desperately wondering what on earth to do (p. 82)."
"'And that's the way God loves, even more so, no matter what. But like your mother, Jonah, we can please Him by doing things that are kind and good, by obeying what He tells us in the Bible, and by making a fine place for the people of our church to meet. This is a place where we can learn more about Him, pray, and sing hymns of praise. Doing it together is good for us, and it's something God likes a lot' (p. 85)."
"'Miss Thatcher, you could invite the teacher fer supper. Ya got lots of good' (p. 97)."
"'Mr. Harris Hughes, I'm afraid I do not agree with your philosophy of education. And I feel quite confident that my students are advancing nicely without your methods' (p. 114)."
"'As far as God is concerned, I simply don't believe in him, Miss Thatcher. He can't be proven, and I can't think of any reason why a supposed god would hide himself from those he makes greater claims to love. Religion appears to me to be a vain attempt to control one's environment with superstition' (p. 116)."
"'I don't want to be a political figure. I want to be more of a shepherd--a servant. I don't think the two roles are complementary' (p. 135)."
"'It's so hard to think about leaving' (p. 140)."
"They are exactly what this meeting is about--the children. The school is for them, and the town will be theirs soon enough. Oh, Father, please help me to do whatever I can on their behalf, and help me to honor You with every word and action (p. 150)."
"'Every public servant is accountable to God, first and foremost' (p. 156)."
"'Do ya love him, Beth?' (p. 176)"
"'So I gather we don't like him, then? Why didn't you just tell me so in the first place?' (p. 204)"
"Julie's considerable energies were now focused on winning the election for Frank (p. 210)."
"The project quickly became a school assignment. Beth took some time the following day to discuss the election with her students and to format a list of questions related to their town. What should the mayor do first? What did Coal Valley need most? What problems did its citizens observe? (p. 212)"
"'Help Jarrick now what is best. For him and for our marriage to come' (p. 215)."
"'I think you could be honest with him. Not demanding--simply honest' (p. 229)."
"'When do you plan on being married? And where will you live?' (p. 242)"
"'I don't feel we've had nearly enough time together, Jarrick. I know I'll think of a million things as soon as my head hits the pillow' (p. 249)."
"'Where are we going on our honeymoon? I need to know how to pack. I don't think you understand that a woman needs to prepare for these things' (p. 250)."
"'You know everything about what's going to happen, Lord God. You have a perfect solution. I'll wait for You' (p. 267)."
"Waving goodbye to Jarrick after so little time with him was almost more painful than not having seen him at all (p. 280)."
"It seemed almost unbelievable to Beth that so many of the people she loved could be in one place. She stole quick glances at her mother, who seemed to have come to terms with the rather austere surroundings and was making a point of joining in the conversations (p. 296)."
"'Mother Thornton... I wanted to thank you for your wonderful son--for all you've done to train him up in the way he should go.' (p. 317)"
Read
January 18, 2018So, honestly, I liked Beth's character a lot better in the first book. At that point she seemed courageous, adventurous, and able to see needs in her world and find creative ways to respond to them. I admired that.
In this book, she just kept annoying me. One problem was her interactions with the new teacher. Yes, he was arrogant. However, her refusal to even talk to him about their shared school when he kept asking seemed like a poor choice. Also, of all the things she could have had issues with, the things she chose to focus on seemed strange. (ex: When he wanted to share the teaching load by having each of them focus on teaching the subjects they were strongest in, she seemed to think that suggestion was practically evil.) Plus her relationship with Jack was annoying. (ex: Thinking it was appropriate to let him make major life decisions for both of them without even sharing her opinion, even though the choice he was leaning towards was practically making her cry herself to sleep. Granted, she eventually realized this was not the best approach, but that realization was not given enough elaboration.) Also, it is weird to me that Beth is super conservative about gender roles, but does not seem to think that her getting married will in any way interfere with her continuing to teach. I'm pretty sure most female teachers at the time lost their jobs when they got married, whether or not they wanted to.
So, yes, I would probably read more books in this series if there were more I want to know what happens next. But I hope Beth gets some of her good qualities back.
In this book, she just kept annoying me. One problem was her interactions with the new teacher. Yes, he was arrogant. However, her refusal to even talk to him about their shared school when he kept asking seemed like a poor choice. Also, of all the things she could have had issues with, the things she chose to focus on seemed strange. (ex: When he wanted to share the teaching load by having each of them focus on teaching the subjects they were strongest in, she seemed to think that suggestion was practically evil.) Plus her relationship with Jack was annoying. (ex: Thinking it was appropriate to let him make major life decisions for both of them without even sharing her opinion, even though the choice he was leaning towards was practically making her cry herself to sleep. Granted, she eventually realized this was not the best approach, but that realization was not given enough elaboration.) Also, it is weird to me that Beth is super conservative about gender roles, but does not seem to think that her getting married will in any way interfere with her continuing to teach. I'm pretty sure most female teachers at the time lost their jobs when they got married, whether or not they wanted to.
So, yes, I would probably read more books in this series if there were more I want to know what happens next. But I hope Beth gets some of her good qualities back.
August 17, 2025
I really don't know what to say about this series...
Here's what I will say though:
The books are decent, but there are some kinda weird elements I think are objectionable.
For example, it kind of seemed to promote elopement. It happened twice in the series. The first time it was like "Oh my, how ROMANTIC! Good for them!" The second time (spoiler I guess) The object of the elopement is a fifteen year old girl marrying a twenty-two year old.
...
BRO WHAT!?!?!
Of course that caused a bit of a scandal for some people. But some people thought it was totally okay, and, well it WASN'T! Seems historically inaccurate to me, but what do I know...
The actual story was decent enough. The love story was actually really cute and not overly sappy. Would have liked to see more of her beau though. He was great and she was, well, a woman. Also she was a total hypocrite because she's terrified of the fact that the man is 7 years older than the girl, even though she's like 23 and her boyfriend is 29. But whatever.
Despite all of this, the story was interesting enough. I guess I recommend it. I'd give it maybe 7.5/10
Here's what I will say though:
The books are decent, but there are some kinda weird elements I think are objectionable.
For example, it kind of seemed to promote elopement. It happened twice in the series. The first time it was like "Oh my, how ROMANTIC! Good for them!" The second time (spoiler I guess) The object of the elopement is a fifteen year old girl marrying a twenty-two year old.
...
BRO WHAT!?!?!
Of course that caused a bit of a scandal for some people. But some people thought it was totally okay, and, well it WASN'T! Seems historically inaccurate to me, but what do I know...
The actual story was decent enough. The love story was actually really cute and not overly sappy. Would have liked to see more of her beau though. He was great and she was, well, a woman. Also she was a total hypocrite because she's terrified of the fact that the man is 7 years older than the girl, even though she's like 23 and her boyfriend is 29. But whatever.
Despite all of this, the story was interesting enough. I guess I recommend it. I'd give it maybe 7.5/10
December 21, 2017
Loved this book !
Ever since my mom introduced me to "Love Comes Softly " when I was a teenager , I have always loved reading Oke's books. This latest installment of the When Calls the Heart series (now , "return")
is better than the TV series, in my opinion , as the books keep a strong Biblical, "be kind and forgiving" message throughout the story. However, I have learned over the years that when it comes to movies vs. books , you have to be willing to put up a brick wall and separate the two. Yes, there will be parallels , but they are few and far between . So , I am personally wishing for season 4 for Christmas, and am also looking forward to seeing season 5 of WCTH (when it's out on DVD, as our family can't afford paid tv)! Thanks so much to the amazing mother /daughter team that wrote such a wonderful book !
Ever since my mom introduced me to "Love Comes Softly " when I was a teenager , I have always loved reading Oke's books. This latest installment of the When Calls the Heart series (now , "return")
is better than the TV series, in my opinion , as the books keep a strong Biblical, "be kind and forgiving" message throughout the story. However, I have learned over the years that when it comes to movies vs. books , you have to be willing to put up a brick wall and separate the two. Yes, there will be parallels , but they are few and far between . So , I am personally wishing for season 4 for Christmas, and am also looking forward to seeing season 5 of WCTH (when it's out on DVD, as our family can't afford paid tv)! Thanks so much to the amazing mother /daughter team that wrote such a wonderful book !
August 14, 2018
This is an enjoyable ending to this 3 book series.
Elizabeth Thatcher is back for her second year of teaching in Coal Valley.
Over the summer the town has arranged a new place for the school. However, Elizabeth is shocked to find the town has hired a teacher to work with the older children and she will be working with the younger children. It is challenge to Elizabeth as the teaching philosophy does not agree with the other teacher.
During the course of the story, Elizabeth's beau proposes. It is a major decision when he father offers Mountie, Jarrick Thornton.....Elizabeth's future husband, a job in his company. Does he want to continue to be a Mountie or work for Elizabeth's fater?
Elizabeth Thatcher is back for her second year of teaching in Coal Valley.
Over the summer the town has arranged a new place for the school. However, Elizabeth is shocked to find the town has hired a teacher to work with the older children and she will be working with the younger children. It is challenge to Elizabeth as the teaching philosophy does not agree with the other teacher.
During the course of the story, Elizabeth's beau proposes. It is a major decision when he father offers Mountie, Jarrick Thornton.....Elizabeth's future husband, a job in his company. Does he want to continue to be a Mountie or work for Elizabeth's fater?
August 30, 2018
I wanted to love this book, because I’m obsessed with the show! Sadly, the show is a lot better than the book!
First, Beth needs to stand up for herself and speak her mind! She seems so wishy washy and timid (what happened to string frontier woman?), to the point where it’s annoying. This book dragged longer than the other ones and seemed to be just a constant back and forth to fill pages of “I don’t like the new teacher” and “oh no I don’t want Jack to quit his job and I don’t want to leave the West but I can’t tell him!”
Lastly, I know this is a religious series, but it was a little too much for me. I’m all for faith, God’s guidance and prayers, but it was too constant for me.
I’m probably still going to read the first 3 books in the series however, hoping they’re a little better!
First, Beth needs to stand up for herself and speak her mind! She seems so wishy washy and timid (what happened to string frontier woman?), to the point where it’s annoying. This book dragged longer than the other ones and seemed to be just a constant back and forth to fill pages of “I don’t like the new teacher” and “oh no I don’t want Jack to quit his job and I don’t want to leave the West but I can’t tell him!”
Lastly, I know this is a religious series, but it was a little too much for me. I’m all for faith, God’s guidance and prayers, but it was too constant for me.
I’m probably still going to read the first 3 books in the series however, hoping they’re a little better!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 20, 2018
Because I watched the series "When calls the heart" I was immediately drawn to this book. Although the book flows very narrowly to this book, I still loved it. It is stated that this book is a follow up to the series which is also a book series. In this book Elizabeth Thatcher is taught many valuable lessons as it relates to judging and not being so quick to dismiss someone. When faced with such challenges she succumbed to her harsh thought processes of the new teach Mr. Harris Hughes and was wrong. So being pricked in her heart by God she was then inclined to come to his aide. She did so and everything worked for the good. She never know, that her act of selflessness and willingness to come to his aide may have shown him that her God is indeed real and change his heart.
June 26, 2017
This story is better than the second and comparable to the first. Beth returns to Coal Valley only to find things have changed quite a bit since she left for the summer. The town has grown considerably, and the way she trips over the tree stumps around the town (trees have been cut down to make room for expansion) are a good metaphor for the way she resists and fights against change. I appreciate her failings because she seems so real and relatable. She is a good example of overcoming challenges and turning to God in difficult times. The book finishes nicely, however I find myself wishing there were more books to the series.
April 18, 2019
Where Hope Prevails centers around Beth’s excitement of finding her new life as a frontier woman in the Canadian West. Beth returns to Coal Valley and discovers some challenges with teaching at the school. Beth also continues developing her relationship with Jarrick, as well as the rest of the people in Coal Valley.
Beth grows emotionally and spiritually. The story is filled with loyalty, faith, and prayer. Each character is described with detail and uniqueness. This was a charming Canadian West romance. The author describes how it was in the late 1940’s in the Canadian Rockies quite vividly.
I will be reading more of these historical fiction novels by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan.
Beth grows emotionally and spiritually. The story is filled with loyalty, faith, and prayer. Each character is described with detail and uniqueness. This was a charming Canadian West romance. The author describes how it was in the late 1940’s in the Canadian Rockies quite vividly.
I will be reading more of these historical fiction novels by Janette Oke and Laurel Oke Logan.
May 4, 2025
a sweet ending to a sweet series. i definitely enjoyed this book, still hanging onto that 4-4.5 star rating, but it was such a sweet, nostalgic read. im sure anyone who watched the tv show first wants to know but the book series concludes with a sweet ending rather than the tragic one halfway through the tv show seasons. after that, everything is purely fiction lol. but i really did enjoy this book!! the author greatly improved in her writing style, even when a few things could have been improved even more, but that's what writing teaches every author. nevertheless, i am sad to say goodbye to this beloved, nostalgic book series.
June 4, 2025
This excellent book dives into several areas pertinent within today's culture. First, it enforces the Biblical view of marriage. Different aspects of conflict are described--the inner thoughts accurately disclosed. Second, it clearly gives the need for community within the lives of individual characters. Civic duty and the role of due process is exemplified. Third, the integrity of the family unit and its dynamics are woven throughout its pages. The bonds of sisters, friends, and mentors are gently explored.
December 23, 2017
This is such I lovely story. However, I wish I read the other books in the series first. Even though this book does stand alone and tells a story, I would have related better if I knew some of the background. With that said, I do love the relationship Elizabeth has with Jack. Event though they can be miles apart their love still survives. Also, with Elizabeth being a small town teacher her will is like iron. Even though she faces of troubled times she never gave up hope.
December 1, 2019
After a somewhat disappointing second book I was happy to discover this third book in the series was wonderful again. Great to step back into Coal Valley one last time. I once again enjoyed the warmth of the town’s people and it was fun to join Elizabeth in this part of her journey. I kind of wish there was one more book to follow her and Jarrick into the next phase of life, but I guess that story would be a lot like the original Canadian West series...so I might just revisit those books..!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 136 reviews