This reexamination of Ernesto "Che" Guevara's thoughts on socialism, democracy, and revolution is a must-read for today's activists―or anyone longing to fight for a better world.Fifty years after his death, Guevara remains a symbol to legions of young rebels and revolutionaries. This unique book provides a way to critically engage with Guevara's economic views, his ideas about revolutionary agency, and his conduct as guerrilla commander and government administrator in Cuba.Samuel Farber was born and raised in Cuba. He has written extensively on Cuba and the Cuban Revolution and is author of Cuba Since the Revolution of 1959.
Many of the criticisms made of Che hit home, but Farber's politics are too close to New Left anti-Stalinism (eg, describing the Stalinist countries as class societies, and even referring to Soviet 'imperialism') for the critique to be really serious, at least for a Trot like me. It's also a quite incomplete analysis of Che's politics, being very selective about the aspects of Che's thought being discussed. As such, it's a bit superficial. The most interesting part is the discussion of the internal divisions in the revolutionary movement before and after the revolution. Not very highly recommended, but maybe have a look if you're curious and want to brush up quickly on your awareness of Che's shortcomings.
Amended: ... On reflection (a few days after reading it) I've downgraded it to a meagre 1 star. It really is very superficial, and it only hints at the kinds of commentary and criticism that a Marxist would make of Che. Its criticisms are OK on a basic level, but really give too much ground to the liberal narrative of an undemocratic or even anti-democratic revolution in Cuba. Only the weakest parts of Che's praxis are considered at length and those - as I've already said - are considered only superficially. I may remove Farber's other work from my To Read list after this.
I certainly learned a lot about Che Guevara's politics from this book. It was a little dry, although I'm not sure how that could have been mitigated so I don't blame the author for that. It was very straightforward at the same time, and clearly pointed out the flaws with Che's politics as well as what made him unique. I enjoyed it and thought it was an important book for any revolutionary to read, so that we can learn from the mistakes of those who came before us rather than simply idolizing them.
To be honest, this is quite a dry book. The content is a slow burn, and I found myself getting a little bored towards the end. Nevertheless, with considerable patience, I would say that this book is definitely worth reading.
It took me nearly three months to complete because I needed that much time to process and reflect on its contents. My interest and curiosity about Che Guevara were the main reasons I continued reading. Having previously read several books about Che in different languages, most of which highlighted his positive characteristics, revolutionary qualities and contributions, I found Samuel Farber’s work particularly interesting for taking a different approach.
Rather than simply celebrating Che’s revolutionary image, the book focuses primarily on his political practices, ideological positions and the weaknesses and trade-offs within Cuban society that emerged from his political experiences and the application of socialist principles. This was something I genuinely appreciated because, although I admire Che’s bravery, determination and fighting spirit, I also believe that understanding his shortcomings is equally important.
I was particularly surprised by some of the decisions made during his revolutionary involvement and subsequent political experience, including their implications for ordinary civilians, his strict actions at La Cabaña Fortress, and certain decisions during guerrilla warfare. One particular discussion that caught my attention was the role of women in revolutionary warfare. Although Che acknowledged that women were capable of fighting alongside men and recognised the importance of female cadres within revolutionary movements, the practical roles he emphasised for women in guerrilla warfare still largely revolved around responsibilities such as messengers, couriers and cooks. Personally, I found this rather contradictory and difficult to reconcile with the revolutionary ideals of equality. However, I would have appreciated more substantial evidence to support such critical arguments.
This brings me to one of my main criticisms of the book. While Farber presents several critical interpretations of Che’s political positions and practices, I feel that the footnotes alone are insufficient to substantiate certain arguments, particularly when discussing such controversial historical matters. Some of the other books I have read about Che provide more direct historical material, including his personal letters, his Apuntes (notes), and even the letter he wrote to Fidel Castro before departing for the Congo to participate in another revolutionary struggle. I believe incorporating more primary sources, documentary evidence and historical correspondence would have strengthened the author’s arguments considerably.
There are still numerous passages that I highlighted and annotated throughout the book, many of which have left me with unanswered questions. Unfortunately, this review is far too short to accommodate all my thoughts, doubts and disagreements. Perhaps that is another indication of how much there is to discuss when examining a historical figure as complex as Che Guevara.
Overall, I would recommend this book to readers who have a genuine interest in Che Guevara, particularly those willing to look beyond his revolutionary reputation and examine the political realities behind his ideas and actions. It may not be the most entertaining or accessible read, especially for those who prefer a faster narrative, but it certainly offers an alternative perspective worth considering.
Not a particularly easy read, but definitely worth my time. I would say it is worth reading at least once, especially if you are genuinely interested in understanding Che Guevara beyond the familiar revolutionary image.
If The Politics of Che Guevara: Theory and Practice makes for a slightly disappointing read, it’s largely due to the fact that Samuel Farber’s subject is neither a particularly great thinker nor a terribly compelling personality.
Farber takes pains to highlight that Che’s Marxism-Leninism departed from the allegedly democratic traditions of classical Marxism. Che namely differed from Marx in his extreme “voluntarism,” or belief that the revolution could be made in any country, not simply those with advanced capitalist economies and large urban proletariats as prescribed by Marx and Engels. According to Farber, Che’s main takeaway from Marx was that workers are fundamentally alienated under capitalism and that they could only be liberated under a one-party regime that replaced market economics with collectivism and state ownership. But because such a regime would be a revolutionary workers’ state, any mechanisms for exercising checks on its power—political democracy, civil liberties, collective bargaining—would be inherently bourgeois and counter-revolutionary.
Engaging as Farber does with such a thin and illogical ideology can be exhausting. As a result, Farber accidentally makes the shrewd and charismatic Fidel Castro, more interested in amassing personal power than in propagating Marxist-Leninist orthodoxy, a much more compelling protagonist of the Cuban Revolution than Che, despite the latter’s ubiquity.
Very theory heavy and not exactly a full history of Che like I thought it would be. Theory is in the title so I should’ve figured that out. It’s definitely helpful in sifting through this blind worship of Che Guevara that I hear from many leftists and uses lessons from what worked and what didn’t to propose that socialism, democracy and revolution need to go together to create the world we want to see.
Without a stronger grasp of the historical and political context of Cuba, many parts of this book were difficult to fully grasp but it was still full of insightful moments. Farber offers a balanced account of Guevara's politics, addressing his influences, shifts in ideology, strengths and weaknesses with deliberate care to neither deify nor condemn him. I would recommend this to anyone interested in historical leftist politics, so long as they don't mind heavily academic language.
This very white looking ex cuban seems to be a HATER, in my opinion. He left before the revolution, but has many ideas about how they did it "wrong" in his mind, sitting pretty in the belly of the beast (amerikkka).
A surprisingly easy read. Samuel Farber was invited to a talk hosted by Haymarket Books, so I assume he's not an imperialist and has valid critics about Che. The main new thing I learned is that Che wasn't pro-workers.
I also feel like I need to learn more about Lenin, Trotsky, and Stalin now.
Excellent work here. Farber has a clear understanding of Marxism, and all of Che's perversions and deviations from it. If you own a Che t-shirt, you'll probably want to burn it after reading this book. But, hey, the truth hurts, right?