Having come across the disreputable, controversial Aleister Crowley in my 20-volume collection on the Supernatural when I was fourteen or fifteen, I began reading this book with both eyebrows raised. Midway through, only one eyebrow remained raised. By the time I finished the book, I had come to the conclusion that Crowley, despite his occasional attempts at injecting his ideas and beliefs into some stories, was no mediocre writer. Given his enfant terrible image and his veddy British English prose (he's "rum," Aleister is), I think his books would have done well today. Below are my thoughts on some of the stories I fancied from this collection, sorted in chronological order. I can describe them best by comparing them to other writers I'm already familiar with.
1) The Drug - Obviously inspired by a strong, recreational drug-induced trip down the twilight zone. Worth the read for the curious, or for comparative purposes.
2) Cancer? - Hypochondria on steroids. Progresses ridiculously, but most readers will be able to relate to the some of the protagonist's sentiments of doom.
3) The Dream Circean - One of the best stories in this collection, and the first story that made me take the writer seriously.
4) The Violinist - I don't know what to make out of this passionate piece of flash fiction, but I liked it.
5) The Vixen - The story unfolds and ends like a Sheridan Le Fanu or Lafcadio Hearn gothic yarn. Short and satisfying.
6) The Woodcutter - Isak Dinesen meets Stephen King.
7) Professor Zircon - This vignette starts out with the bonhomie of a Colette short story, with a girl straight out of an F. Scott Fitzgerald novel, and ends with Lovecraftian flair. An end you'll have seen coming, if you're a Lovecraft fan like me.
8) The Testament of Magdalen Blair - If I had been asked to read this ghastly narrative and guess the writer, I would have sworn by H.P. Lovecraft. It reads very much like his stories (The Case of Charles Dexter Ward comes to mind).
9) The Stratagem - This struck me as Kafkaesque, but it's the funniest story here. The end is guaranteed to elicit a guffaw (or a groan). I ended with the former.
10) The Chute - This makes me wonder if Crowley was channeling Somerset Maugham when he wrote this fascinating vignette. (Actually, Maugham despised Crowley, and supposedly wrote The Magician with Crowley in mind. The feeling was mutual, and Crowley attempted to sue Maugham for libel).
11) Felo De Se - Worth a mention if only because I learned a new, impressive word for suicide, aka felon of himself.
12) Robbing Miss Horniman - Naughty piece of wordplay at work? Perhaps. This is a story within a story. The narrative starts out like an F. Scott Fitzgerald story, with a plot typical of Maugham; filing this one under Maugham-light.
13) Face - A spine-chilling tale of lovers "thwarted by a malign star." A star that went by the name of race.
14) Atlantis - A travelogue on the fabled Atlantis, this is the longest story here, and I vacillated between interest and boredom. It sounds like a mishmash of H.G. Wells's The Time Machine and The Country of the Blind. And it sounds like Crowley wasn't going science fiction on us here, I think he really believed this stuff. Oh, and it ends somewhat like A Canticle for Leibowitz.
15) The Mysterious Malady - A story so predictable, you'll know how it unfolds by the second page. Which of course, only makes you keep going...
16) Black and Silver - Another tidy tale that seems filched from Maugham--Maugham-light.
17) The Humour of Pauline Pepper - Funny! This would have made an ideal Chaplin silent movie.
18) A Nativity - The end leaves a disturbing visual. Especially since the probability of this occurring in families of the same demographic is high.
19) Every Precaution - A cautionary tale on absinthe. And then some.
20) God's Journey - Reads like an unabridged, unsanitized Grimm's fairy tale, spliced with the gothic touch of Isak Dinesen.
21) Colonel Pacton's Brother - Crowley writes Kipling fare. Or so it looks to me.
22) As You Were - Again, this reads like a Kipling tale.
23) Only a Dog - Now here we have what sounds like a melancholic short story, from his earlier selections, by Anton Chekhov!
24) The Escape - Exasperating read, with an ending I didn't expect, and which made the read worthwhile. Again, it felt like Crowley was in Kipling territory here.