The short of it: Brilliant body-positive memoir manga. The second half about Rokudenashiko's artistic journey is particularly relatable for artists, but the whole thing is wonderful. I really appreciated the inside look into Japanese society--the penal system in particular. Although the art might not be considered great by all, I loved it. It was very charming and suited the loose, naive, 'wide-eyed' feeling as Rokudenashiko discovers more and more while being processed by the system. I would highly recommend it.
The main focus was more what she went through than her art itself though later in the book she does explain how she got to be making “manko (/vagina) art” (and comics in general!) and we do get to see Manko-chan’s comic adventures too which is fun. There are photos and screenshots and so on to help build up a fuller visual context too. (Usually photo inserts in books like this would annoy me, but it actually worked really well here.)
I thought there would be a little bit more in-depth discussion about her feminist rational, but instead, she speaks very simply about her intentions. There are no over-complicated theses. It is what it is. And, as it turns out, that was just as fulfilling to see. It could probably all be boiled down to “vaginas are just body parts like an arm or a foot so let’s normalise and accept them and not just sexualise them”. Simple! And rather inoffensive really. But that landed her in jail (proving why she's needed).
I hadn’t realised there would be so much information on the Japanese justice system or the complications of a trial of this nature in Japanese society. It made me think about how foreigners in Japan often say how kind and helpful the police are, but I think every Japanese novel I’ve ever read has only ever referenced the police in a negative way; either negligent or abrasive (and that hasn’t just been in crime novels!). It makes me wonder if the system is two-faced, smiling at foreigners while keeping Japanese citizens (or, I guess, those who look asian) “in check”. It certainly seems that way, but I don’t know enough to say for certain.
We get a lot of cultural insight into Japan despite the book tackling a very niche issue which is also really interesting, but it’s all still really engaging. Rokudenashiko is a great example of someone taking their work seriously, but not taking themselves too seriously, and advocating body positivity and feminism through her art in a society where concepts like that are strongly resisted.
The book is not at all academic or explicit or preachy. It’s just a fun story about how the exploration of an idea (body positivity and the de-sexualisation of a body part) led one small time artist to big trouble (and some silver lining stuff too). I would recommend this book to: anyone wanting a fun manga that gives some insight on Japanese culture; anyone interested in body positivity or feminism; and anyone in possession of or who, in some way, appreciates the humble vagina.
I also feel this idea of body policing is particularly pertinent in the current France Burkini Ban climate…