Isabella de Valois was 3 years old when, on a hot August day in 1392, her father suddenly went mad. Less than four years later, she was married by proxy to the English King Richard II and arrived in England with a French retinue and her doll’s house. Richard’s humiliating deposition and brutal murder by his cousin, the future Henry IV, forced Isabella’s desperate return to France where she found her country fatally divided.Isabella’s sister, Catherine de Valois, became the beautiful young bride of Henry V and is unique in history for being the daughter of a king, the wife of a king, the mother of a king and the grandmother of a king. Like her sister, Catherine was viewed as a bargaining chip in times of political turmoil, yet her passionate love affair with the young Owain Tudor established the entire Tudor dynasty and set in motion one of the most fascinating periods of British history.The Sister Queens is a gripping tale of love, exile and conflict in a time when even royal women had to fight for survival.
I kind of want to read this as I love Isabelle and Catherine de Valois and their era, but when one of the first few pages contains a howling error - Richard II's uncle Lionel of Antwerp attending Isabeau of Bavaria's coronation as queen of France in 1389, 21 years after he died - I'm not sure I can quite bring myself to.
I knew before I picked up The Sister Queens: Isabella and Catherine de Valois that although the description and title promised this was a biography of these two women, there just isn’t enough surviving information about them to fill a book. I had read the reviews here on GoodReads and was prepared for The Sister Queens to be more of a general history of the clash between France and England in the late 14th and early 15th centuries, as well as their civil conflicts.
But I was prepared for it. It would be fine. Or so I thought.
Obviously, and as expected, there’s a lot of padding. There’s two sorts of padding. The first is the one I expected, in that author Mary McGrigor focuses on a lot of stuff that isn’t strictly about Isabella or Catherine. But even then it feels overly padded - in the first section, supposedly about Isabella, we get an entire chapter dedicated to the political situation in Scotland, the main gist of it being that the English captured the future James I of Scotland. Why were we being told this? Well, eventually, near the end of the book, James I and Catherine become best friends and McGrigor speculates on whether they had an affair.
The second type of padding in this book is the type I like least in my non-fiction - fictionalisation and speculation. We get told that Isabella “must have” felt or thought this and McGrigor talks about Catherine’s mental state like she has a hotline to the afterlife. Often the result is so treacly that I felt like what McGrigor really wanted to write was a bunch of historical romance novels - Isabella and Richard II (never mind the fact she was only 10 when he died!), Catherine and James I, and Catherine and Owen Tudor.
The end result was that I could no longer trust McGrigor’s narrative. What was verifiable historical fact and what was McGrigor’s fiction? It was impossible to tell. Thus, the book became worthless to me as a work of historical reference.
Now comes the nitpicking. McGrigor’s account of Richard II’s conflict with and eventual deposition by the future Henry IV feels overly simple and partisan. Additionally, on page 190-1, McGrigor states “[Henry V’s] body was dismembered and the flesh stripped from his bones by boiling”, but we have conflicting reports and his body may have been embalmed (which did not involve reducing the corpse down to bones!).
McGrigor also clearly states that Catherine’s retirement to Bermondsey Abbey was at the instigation of Henry’s brother, Humfrey (or Humphrey), the Duke of Gloucester, who found out Catherine had secretly remarried despite an act of parliament forbidding her to do so without the consent of the King, and “did not survive” the birth of her fifth child and only daughter. In the first place, the myth of Catherine’s imprisonment in Bermondsey Abbey was invented by the Strickland sisters in the 19th century, and it is far more likely she was there of her own free will. Nor is it certain that she had a daughter or when she had her children. In fact, she almost certainly had only three or four children: Edmund, Jasper and Owen (the latter less well-attested than Edmund and Jasper but still well-evidenced), and Polydore Vergil mentions a daughter who became a nun, though he is our own source for this daughter. Furthermore, there is a possibility that Catherine's death was not caused by childbirth (though it probably wouldn’t have helped) cannot dismissed due to the “long, grievous malady” Catherine mentions having suffered in her will.
In addition to these, there are also numerous errors in the book. At the start of one chapter, McGrigor has the widowed Isabella returning at last to France as “a girl of 17” (p. 87). Three pages later, still freshly returned from England, she is 13 years old! Wow. Catherine’s name is at one time spelt “Katherine” and Katherine Swynford’s name is rendered Catherine, Katherine and Katheryn at various points. Eleanor Cobham enters the narrative under the correct name but quickly becomes “Elizabeth Cobham” for the rest of the book.
At one stage, McGrigor writes that “never had [Henry V] known a more clamorous reception than [sic] when entering Paris with his bride, in that freezing winter of 1520” (p.190). Well, given that he would’ve been dead 98 years in 1520, that clamorous reception is very understandable. I mean, zombie Henry V is a terrifying idea - and especially for the French!
In addition to needing a fact check, a proofread and less fictionalisation, the writing felt rather vague, as if it needed at least one good copy edit to clear up confusion. There were a couple of sentences I stumbled over, stared at, read out loud and then gave up trying to understand them. The book itself felt unfocused, the main narrative jumping around chronologically.
So even supposing that this book was advertised more truthfully, The Sister Queens was a massive disappointment. The only positives were the beautiful design of the book and that, in reaction to the out-and-out vilification of Humphrey/Humfrey Duke of Gloucester, I now care a hell of a lot more for Henry V’s brothers - him especially.
First point, this book was misnamed. It is rather a history of the nobility of France and England in the late 14th and early 15th centuries watching the machinations around and during the 100 Years War. Isabella and Catherine appear but are by no means the main character or even attributed much agency.
Secondly, there's a lot of shaky history here. Lots of speculating about love matches on very little evidence and ascribing of motives and feelings in a manner more appropriate for a romance novel at times.
Thirdly, the fact checking and editing was abysmal. I'm not great at this period in history but even internally it made basic errors of years, people's ages at certain events.
I didn't hate reading it but it was frustrating and I'm glad I picked it up free at a little library rather than spending money on it.
This is entertaining but has glaring inaccuracies, barely features the main characters and is of dubious accuracy given the mistakes I picked up on a casual read. This gives an overview of the Hundred Years War during the lifetimes of these women.
Honestly I was quite disappointed by this book as it seemed to focus more on Isabella and Catherine’s many relatives and in laws then it did on them. On the end I learned more about their family then them.
Though I do feel like I've learned more about this era in English and French history I can't deny the fact there are so many things wrong with this book.
The spelling of names constantly change, dates don't add up (Isabella was born in 1389 and apparently she was 17 in 1403...), people die and then on the following page they're alive again...
But most of all this really isn't a book about Isabella and Catherine de Valois. You could probably fill 2 pages with all the sentences that applied directly to their lives.
Royal history is interesting, but if there's really nothing to say about certain people because little has been documented about them, don't try to write about them 600 years later.
A really interesting read. I don't think either of these women get the respect and recognition they deserve, especially Catherin de Valois. This book walks you through the preamble of the War of the Roses. It starts with Isabella who is betrothed Richard II when she was only six years old. It follows how she was sent to England after the betrothal, her life there, how vulnerable she was after Richard's death, and then what happened to her after returning to France. Then the book switches its focus to Catherine, Isabella's youngest sister. Catherine marries Henry V, son of the man who deposed and killed her sister's husband. Sadly Catherine's marriage ends in tragedy like her sister's. Henry dies shortly after Catherine gives birth to son. She's then prevented from remarrying by her brother-in-law for several years. Catherine eventually marries Owen Tudor in secret. They go on to have four children. Their eldest son Edmund is the father of Henry VII. So Catherine is a woman who is 1. Daughter of a king (Charles IV of France) 2. Married to a king (Henry V) 3. Mother to a king (Henry VI) AND 4. Grandmother to a king (Henry VII)
The title is misleading, as one of the reviews stated, but that's precisely why I chose to read this book. I am more interested to know more about the politics surrounding the sisters. There were more than a few mistakes in the book (spelling and Historical as well) which is not acceptable, but overall I enjoyed it.
SO MANY PROBLEMS! Historical Inaccuracies: Example - the author contradicts herself by listing Isabella's age at one event as 13, then she states Isabella is 17.
Bad Editing: The author keeps mentioning how Catherine and and James (King of Scotland) could or maybe didn't have a love affair. She brings this up, with almost the same wording, several times. It reads like the editor read one chapter at a time with a great amount of distance between readings. There is very little flow.
Misleading: The book does not go into detail about the women. While Isabella is mentioned a bit more than Catherine, the book is mostly about the men involved in the fall of Richard II, the battles with in the French royal family, and Henry V's wars in France. There are only a few pages on Catherine and Owen Tudor, which should be a large part of the final chapters.
Disappointing for anyone who wanted to learn more about either Isabella or Catherine. More of a recital of relations between England and France than a biography of either woman - maybe of necessity since during their lifetimes, at least (not so much for Catherine considering her legacy as the ancestress of the Tudors), they played such a relatively small part in larger affairs, but an author shouldn't promise what they can't deliver.
An interesting read about a period in French history i'm not familiar with. Catherine of Valois was the great-grandmother of Henry VIII.Isabella's lifewas a tragic one.
Some queens get all the biographies. Anne Boleyn? Biographies coming out your ears. Catherine of Valois...barely a single, solid one to be found. This one focuses on the two sister queens, daughters of Charles the Mad and Isabeau of Bavaria (who I think deserves her own biography, and possibly a film or Netflix series, she was incredible). However, I feel like the author was more interested in the 100 Years War than the lives of the two sisters, since we go for whole chapters without hearing anything of them. Now, I understand that with these specific women, they had little to no part to play in the intrigues of the English and French courts, or the battles for control of France. But if you can't tell me exactly what they were doing, at least tell me what it was likely they were doing. So Catherine was sent to Poissy to be with her sister Marie for safekeeping? Great, tell me about the convent, what kind of institution was it, what would she have done there. But no, just incredible details about the capturing or not of this or that French town, and finally, the crowning insult, the birth of Edmund and Jasper Tudor, her real positive legacy, gets a single paragraph, without even giving their dates of birth. This on top of all the typos (feeling a bit smug that I knew some of the dates were incorrect) and not picking a spelling, variously spelling her with a C or a K as the whim took them. I have read it and quoted from it in my research, but it could and should have been so much better.
A great deal is usually written about Richard II and Henry V - two iconic kings of England. Most people recognise their names instantly because of their policies and untimely deaths. Richard - unpopular and savage, Henry - courageous military hero. Not many people, however, know about their wives. They both married sisters. Richard married, as his second wife, Isabella de Valois, daughter of Isabeau of Bavaria and the mad king Charles VI whose mental illness was transferred into the English royal family. Isabella was a child when she came to England and could never grow to become its Queen. Although crowned, her brief queenship ended when Henry IV deposed Richard II. Isabella was eventually sent back to France where she remarried and died in childbirth in her early twenties. Her sister Catherine de Valois is better known primarily because she lasted longer and gave birth to Henry VI, who became king of England and France. Catherine's marriage to Henry V was brief and she married a Welsh squire, Owen Tudor, starting the Tudor dynasty.
Mary McGrigor's tale of the two sisters is rich in detail and therefore is a perfect treat for a history enthusiast. It's highly recommended for fans of English & French royalty.
This was disappointing. It meandered quite a bit, and often went off on unrelated tangents after introducing an event or idea right at the start of the chapter. It was also was full of an incredible amount of supposition with very little facts to substantiate it, and often was hard to keep straight who exactly McGrigor was talking about. It didn't help when she kept changing names of people - eg. "Jane" often became "Jeanne" with no warning or explanation.
Although admittedly the French history for this period is immensely complicated, I'm not walking away feeling like I have a greater understanding of the people or period covered - although who knows, maybe its because of the way that it was written here. I know that people don't necessarily want a heavy, 500+ paged biorgaphy, but there is just so little information about the sisters that they are basically an afterthought. And the text itself seemed to breeze along rather quickly without getting into a whole lot of detail of people or events - it was a very shallow over-view of history, and unfortunately, I don't think I really learnt much more than what I already knew.
So much potential,I in crafting a history of the era, but it turned out wooden and not much more than a recitation of historical facts. These were multifaceted people and could have been presented in a more interesting fashion.
Nice and entertaining. I was pleasantly surprised that the author presented R2 in a positive light as few do. I was however disappointed how much Henry V info was given when it’s supposed to be about Catherine. There were a couple significant errors but overall a good read.
Not exactly incorrect but relies far too heavily on the chronicles and a number of select biographies. Completely ignores publications surrounding both queens.