So, this is my first accidental yet conscious foray into the Judge Dredd universe. The prior review I just did for Counterfeit Girl is technically my first, but I only really realized that after reading this compendium. Mega-City undercover serves as an interesting entry point, because it's a compilation of issues in the Judge Dredd universe that focuses on two judges dwelling within the Mega City world, Lenny Zero and Aimee Nixon (and company). They both interface with the underbelly of Mega-City.
The first set of issues compile the story of Lenny Zero, a judge who decides to double cross the justice department and the mafia, and the story follows him trying to escape detection and apprehension from both of these sides. We actually do see Judge Dredd in this incarnation, which I can't help but think is interesting here.
Our other sort of issue set, one that takes up more of the book is that of Aimee Nixon, a judge serving on the Wally Squad, a unit that serves to focus on the "Low Life," a notably dangerous and poor part of Mega City. I hesitate to say that this is really a set of issues about Aimee Nixon, although she is a large part of the stories, but rather that of the Wally Squad itself. Two of the stories focus more on her mentor/occasional partner Dirty Frank.
As with all kinds of compilations and anthologies, the stories were definitely hit or miss for me. The Low Life stories were certainly my favorite between the two sets, as the stories were more isolated and included a mystery to be solved. There's a sort of humor in many of them. I think Lenny Zero was a good story, but I struggled to really care about Lenny as a character. The story sort of took for granted that I actually cared about his fate from the outset, but I found it difficult to really get immersed in Lenny's story.
I'd say that the art was certainly not my style. The gritty, frenetic black and white art was hard to follow, and there were times that I had absolutely no idea who was talking or what was going on, even after re-reading the panels. Sometimes, there would be characters sharing the conversation, but because the artist opted to stylize and really zoom in on the character's face, I absolutely could not tell what was going on. This would be more of an issue in the Low Life stories. Counterfeit Girl got to benefit from color, which allowed me to more easily discern that was going on, as not only did you have shape cues to figure out what was going on but also color.
Overall, I'd say that the compilation was fine. There isn't anything so offensive that it warrants taking things below a 3, but this certainly didn't cause me to completely adore the Judge Dredd universe. I certainly have quite a bit more to go in my foray, but I also don't want to burn myself out either.