I have waited 4 years since buying this novel to read it. It has been a worthwhile wait now that I have finished it. This is my first introduction to Garcia’s writing and I am impressed. I can now look forward to reading his Dance On Fire trilogy.
I loved this novel. It kept me captivated and involved. The pace is consistent with no peaks or troughs to alter the pace. Compared to some horror novels I have read, I would regard Garcia’s attempt as a medium to low level of horror, but this is not a negative for me. There is enough creepiness to spike a mystery and suspense response that gets the adrenaline flowing. I would say this novel is more character than a plot-driven novel which I feel is a good choice by Garcia as having the horror perceived through the main character gives the reader the best chance to experience it as well. Once a reader has been endeared to a character, they are on the character’s side and empathise with them from what they experience. So, when a character becomes scared, freaked out, or whatever, then the reader is likely to experience similar. This is a good way to create the elements of fear, horror, suspense and mystery. Garcia has created this well from this method.
I loved the personal background to Paul. I felt there was a good balance of his feelings towards dealing with the loss of his wife and unborn son three years earlier with the events of the haunted house and circumstances involving Aunt Flora and her supernatural quest. Having lost one unborn child and one newborn, I can relate to Paul’s feelings of loss and how this is magnified with the loss of his wife simultaneously. I became emotional at the relationship he developed with Paul Jr and the tenderness he shows towards this child and I imagined the same towards my own unborn son and daughter, who lived only a few days all those years ago. It is a sign of a talented writer when they can identify the feelings and experiences of others and portray them realistically in their storylines.
I am not one for romance when it is the main plot theme or genre, but I love romance when it is a subplot and written by male authors. Garcia has met those two criteria for me. I loved the relationship between Anne and Paul. I loved her patience and acceptance of his ongoing grief but need to let go and come to terms with his loss without dismissing it. It was encouraging to see a positive relationship develop between Jason and Paul. I wonder if this depiction is a reflection of the author’s own relationship between himself and his sons? Authors are encouraged to write from their knowledge/life experience database (translated as “write what you know”), so this could be the case. Either way, it is a real positive here.
I did wonder why Garcia portrayed Anne to be the near exact likeness of Paul’s deceased wife, Angie, but it is only towards the last quarter of the novel that I realised why. It was very effective in joining the plot arcs together for this! Until this happened, I kept thinking, having this likeness serves no purpose at all. But a clever author always ties up loose ends either towards the end of the novel or at its end. If left undone, then there had better be a sequel to deal with this! Thankfully this is not needed here.
I loved the horror elements of this novel. However, I would have liked to have had more explanation or depiction of the satanic practices that Patricia and Flora used. Garcia seems to have skirted around this issue. All we see if that these two dappled in the occult to achieve their quest but there was no explanation as to how they did this to achieve their aims and how this released all those “ghosts” that seemed to have no purpose in the novel other than to be misplaced entities whose only role seemed to be to add a scary element to the satanic/occultic quest of Flora and Patricia and freak out Paul, Anne and Jason. Now I am not certain for sure what Garcia’s beliefs are towards God and the Bible but there is reference to such, and Heaven, but I felt the supernatural elements would have been enhanced if these references were more detailed or shown what they are based on. I did like the reference to what Paul Jr states in the Epilogue to Anne and Paul relating to Who gave him permission to deal with Flora and the message to Anne, Paul and Jason. That was a great finishing touch to this story.
For me, reading this novel before any of Garcia’s other works has given me a great introduction to the talent and creativity of this author and I am now a fan.
Strongly Recommended. 4/5 Stars