Фрейд для начинающих

by Richard Osborne

В популярной форме, с обилием картинок, имеющих, как правило, юмористический характер, излагаются основные положения из научного наследия основателя психоанализа Зигмунда Фрейда, эпизоды его биографии, сведения об основных современных приложениях психоаналитического метода и ученых, развивающих его.
Для широкого круга читателей.

Genres: Psychology, Philosophy, Nonfiction, Biography, Science, Graphic Novels

178 pages, Paperback

First published September 1, 1993

About the author

Pseudonym for Robert Tine

Reviews

[Gleb Gruzov · Rating 2 out of 5]

Юнг - Сила
Фрейд - Могила

[John Dawn · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a very clear, and logically structured introduction to the ideas of Freud; it gives the background , the life history and the development of his ideas and shows how they related to his times. Each stage in the development of his thinking is explained and the complexity of his ideas is wonderfully made accessible, and the drawings back up the material to make this an exciting introduction to a great thinker. His cultural impact is examined and the ways in which his ideas developed after his death is also explained, and the battles between his followers. Overall this makes a gripping and insightful introduction to a much misunderstood thinker, and does so with in quite a witty manner. Really quite impressive.

[wakeupf*ck · Rating 3 out of 5]

Freud’un psikanalizi nasıl geliştirdiği ve hatta bu fikri nasıl ortaya attığına dair açıklayıcı resimler ve yazılara sahip olan kapsamlı sayılabilecek bir kitaptı. Freud’un tüm çalışmalarından ziyade araştırmalarının başlangıcını yılan balıklarının üreme organlarıyla yapmış olması beni hem güldürdü biraz da şaşırttı. Psikanalizin temelini fizyolojik açıdan hayvan ve insanları oldukça araştırarak atmış olduğunu gördüm zaten psikoseksüel gelişim basamaklarında da bunun etkileri oldukça hissediliyordu. Ayrıca freud’un araştırmacı fakat bir o kadar garip bir ruha sahip olan arkadaşı Wilhelm Fliees’a kitapta birkaç sayfa için yer verilmiş olması da hoştu. Tüm fikirlerini ve araştırmalarını en ince ayrıntısına kadar wilhelm ile paylaştığını öğrendim ve arkadaşının oldukça garip olmasına karşın freud’un onun düşüncelerinin etkisinde uzun kalmamış olması da kendi zihninin güçlü bir iradesi olduğunun göstergesi. Çünkü arkadaşı bir insanın burnunun da bir cinsel organ olduğunu savunan bir tip ve cinsellik üzerine olan araştırmalarda freud’un bir süre wilhelm’ın etkisinde kaldığı net bir biçimde görülüyor fakat o dönemde yaptığı tüm çalışmaları ve araştırmaların gerçekliğini geniş zaman içerisinde reddederek kendi fikir ve analizlerine yönelerek psikolojide bir çığır açıyor. Fakat tüm bu fikirleri wilhelm’a anlatmayı da bırakmıyor

[Animesh Mitra · Rating 4 out of 5]

Good book for the beginners.

[Vitória Bredoff]

um dos meus primeiros contatos com psicanálise;
como disse quem me presenteou: "pouco rigoroso... mas vale como uma boa introdução!"

[NatalieAB · Rating 4 out of 5]

I knew that I was taking a chance reading a non-fiction book, designed more for adults than kids, only about psychoanalysis. I am happy to say I was pleasantly surprised! Richard Osborne did a fantastic job of creating a fun environment even with a serious topic. I laughed, I learned, and I'm happy that I read this book.

[Stan · Rating 1 out of 5]

Decent but not worth reading.

I think the comic-book format can be deployed for serious ends, like it is in Art Spiegelman's Maus books. But I found the comics in this book to be more of a hindrance than help to Osborne's story-telling needs.

The text in this book is generally pretty good. I'm a big fan of Freud, so I liked Osborne's mostly-adversarial take on him. I also liked that Osborne devoted many pages to describing Freud's competitors, acolytes and intellectual descendants.

But the reader of this fairly long comic-book is unlikely to gain any sense of why people like W. H. Auden called Freud "no more a person now but a whole climate of opinion."

https://poets.org/poem/memory-sigmund...

So, there's no way would I'd recommend that anyone vaguely interested in Freud should read this comic-book instead of any one of Freud's essays or books of equal length, like (in no particular order of importance):

Civilization & Its Discontents
Three Essays on Sexuality
The Ego & the Id
Leonardo da Vinci and a Memory of His Childhood
Totem & Taboo
"Remembering, Repeating and Working-Through"
The Future of an Illusion

Richard Rorty once wrote:

But not until Freud did we get a usable way of thinking of ourselves as machines to be tinkered with, a self-image that enabled us to weave terms describing psychic mechanisms into our strategies of character-formation.

. . . the intellectual's increased ability to treat vocabularies as tools rather than mirrors—is Freud's major legacy. He broke some of the last chains that bind us to the Greek idea that we, or the world, have a nature that, once discovered, will tell us what we should do with ourselves. He made it far more difficult than it was before to ask the question "Which is my true self?" or "What is human nature?" By letting us see that even in the enclave which philosophy had fenced off, there was nothing to be found save traces of accidental encounters, he left us able to tolerate the ambiguities that the religious and philosophical traditions had hoped to eliminate.

"Freud and Moral Reflection"
by Richard Rorty, Essays on Heidegger, 1991.

[Michael P. · Rating 4 out of 5]

Massively disappointed that FREUD is one of the few books in this series that does not reference Shakespeare when Freud did and Ernest Jones did. Jones is well covered in these pages. The Shakespeare is why I read the darn thing. Still, quite a good introduction to Freud and his shit-brained ideas. The book happily spends time on the psychoanalytical movement as championed by others, such as Jones, who to some degree disagreed with Freud, evolved his ideas, or applied them to areas Freud had not. There is a bit of fault finding, but basically this was written by a loyalist, which is also a disadvantage.

[Sean Sexton · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book is an excellent introduction and overview to Freud's work. It explains the difficult concepts of his theories in an entertaining way, comic-book style. But more importantly, it does a nice job of explaining difficult concepts in a very understandable and direct way.

[Sandra Clark · Rating 4 out of 5]

I love all these books.

[Rachelle · Rating 3 out of 5]

very childish way to explain Freud.