Caught between a 3.5 and a full four star.
Pros
- A Tradition In the Making
*To celebrate his and Nao's two month anniversary, Taiga gives her two flowers and tells her he plans to up the flower count to coincide with the numerical anniversary... I literally squealed. Imagine how big her wedding bouquet will be. God, I'm so invested!
-Tangible Anxiety/Authentic Speech
*This manga/story feels so true to life because it's not playing up the struggles of adolescence to a cartoonish degree (not naming names, but I do have one in mind as well its anime adaptation). Nao and Taiga aren't adept at words either, no declarations of undying love beyond the one that started it all and even when Nao finally says "I'm so in love with you", it slips out naturally. And she's legit embarrassed not because it's not true, but because, like most teenagers, she worries it's too soon to say. But, I mean, come on Nao. The guy basically gave you a pre-proposal back in volume one. No worries.
-Sharing the Spotlight
*It's not just the Nao and Taiga variety hour. Their friendships play a huge part in their journey to not only coupledom, but becoming functioning adults. There's full scenes dedicated to Misaki trying to understand why Taiga won't confide in him/genuinely missing his friend.
-Healthy Relationship Goals
*When Taiga's newfound "friend" Futami, decides he likes Nao enough to steal her away, Taiga does a call and response to the brooding YA heroes and goes "When I overheard you say that, I could've burst in the door, demand you get your hands off her/keep your mouth shut. But I had to think: would you make Nao happier than I could?". And to top it all off, Taiga seeks sage council from Nao's uncle (YA protagonists who are open and honest with parents. That really does break the mold) and after an intense convo, Taiga says, "No, you couldn't. Not because I'm superior to you, but my love makes her feel superior". He is all about keeping that smile on Nao's face, even if for a brief moment he thought someone else could do it better. I honestly love that both characters take the time to breath/regroup and understand that some people are just distractions from the real thing and not to make mountains out of a mole hills or even acknowledge the "danger".
*Nao realizes that Taiga's love inspires her to be better and they have several scenes where they are thinking of each other, but in a motivating from afar way. Huzzah for individual character growth!
Con
-Futami is a creep. I feel like giving this point a cute I.D. isn't worth it and honestly, he angered me too much to try. There's a point where Nao lends a sympathetic ear to Futami's popularity problem (alone/exhausted with being around people) and he appears to prey upon her kindness, saying how she's the only one who understands him and later kind of tricks both Taiga and Nao into wondering if his "I'll steal you if I have to" is all in their heads by saying "oh, I was just kidding... But not really." Gaslighting, perhaps?
Honestly, we didn't need the weird forced Futami. I'm ready to see where Nao and Taiga end up (hopefully at the altar) and I'm about halfway through.