What do you think?
Rate this book
Wish
Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese has been making the same secret wish every day since fourth grade. She even has a list of all the ways there are to make the wish, such as cutting off the pointed end of a slice of pie and wishing on it as she takes the last bite. But when she is sent to the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina to live with family she barely knows, it seems unlikely that her wish will ever come true. That is until she meets
Wishbone, a skinny stray dog who captures her heart, and Howard, a neighbor boy who proves surprising in lots of ways. Suddenly Charlie is in serious danger of discovering that what she thought she wanted may not be what she needs at all.
Wishbone, a skinny stray dog who captures her heart, and Howard, a neighbor boy who proves surprising in lots of ways. Suddenly Charlie is in serious danger of discovering that what she thought she wanted may not be what she needs at all.
240 pages, Hardcover
First published August 30, 2016
6718 people are currently reading
12354 people want to read
About the author
Barbara O'Connor
49 books657 followersBarbara O'Connor's awards include the Parents Choice Gold and Silver Award, American Library Association Notable Books, IRA Notable Books for a Global Society, School Library Journal Best Books, and Kirkus Best Books. Her books have been nominated for children's choice awards in 38 states and voted as a state favorite by children in South Carolina, Indiana, Kansas, and South Dakota.
Barbara was born and raised in Greenville, South Carolina. She draws on her Southern roots to write award-winning books for children in grades 3 to 6.
She currently lives in Asheville, NC. Her latest book is Wish, a middle grade novel published by FSG.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/barbar...
Barbara was born and raised in Greenville, South Carolina. She draws on her Southern roots to write award-winning books for children in grades 3 to 6.
She currently lives in Asheville, NC. Her latest book is Wish, a middle grade novel published by FSG.
http://us.macmillan.com/author/barbar...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,408 reviews
July 7, 2016
I often make the mistake of reading middle grade novels with awards in my head. Thinking about what the National Book Award Committee or the Newbery Committee might think about a book is fun, but it often taints my reading experience.
The time I spent with Barbara O’Connor’s Wish was magical. I never once thought about what award committees will think of this book, not because it doesn’t deserve consideration, but because this book is so obviously perfect and important for kids that it doesn’t really matter what anyone else thinks. Wish contains so much of what I love about middle grade fiction: an engaging plot (the word engaging doesn’t do it justice, but I’m too tired to think of something better), a main character that readers will fall in love with, unforgettable supporting characters (not an easy thing to do), and a setting so real you feel like you’ve been there.
I don’t really have anything else I’d like to say about Wish, but I would like to say that Barbara O’Connor is one heck of a talented writer. My students love her books. Reading them aloud builds community, empathy, and it is just plain fun.
The time I spent with Barbara O’Connor’s Wish was magical. I never once thought about what award committees will think of this book, not because it doesn’t deserve consideration, but because this book is so obviously perfect and important for kids that it doesn’t really matter what anyone else thinks. Wish contains so much of what I love about middle grade fiction: an engaging plot (the word engaging doesn’t do it justice, but I’m too tired to think of something better), a main character that readers will fall in love with, unforgettable supporting characters (not an easy thing to do), and a setting so real you feel like you’ve been there.
I don’t really have anything else I’d like to say about Wish, but I would like to say that Barbara O’Connor is one heck of a talented writer. My students love her books. Reading them aloud builds community, empathy, and it is just plain fun.
July 16, 2019
A touching read demonstrating that sometimes when you’re out there seeking for your own wish to be granted, you’re actually granting someone else’s.
September 16, 2025
In a Nutshell: A middle-grade novel about a little girl with a secret wish. A nice mix of characters though the lead character is not exactly typical middle-grade material. Somewhat bittersweet themes, and a good ending as befits the genre. Can lead to a thought-provoking discussion with kids. Not a perfect read, though.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
Some middle-grade books are purely entertaining, while some lend themselves to introspection and discussions. This book is in the latter category.
Some middle-grade books feature protagonists who are brave and kind and loving, while others are led by a character whose behaviour needs a lot of finetuning. This book is in the latter category.
Some middle-grade books depict the merits of the family you are born into while others highlight how a family can be built in different ways. This book is in the latter category.
In several ways, this is a typical middle-grade book. It offers a protagonist facing challenges, a nice new friend who becomes the voice of reason, and a loveable canine. However, it also breaks the norm several times, especially in its depiction of the lead character. This doesn’t necessarily work to its advantage.
Charlie isn’t an inspiring protagonist in any way. She is quick to lose her temper, is rude without justification, has a strong bias against the people she looks down upon as “hillbillies”, and is envious of her older sister. Charlie’s family background isn't the kind you often see in this genre. Her father is imprisoned and her mother seems to be facing a severe mental health issue. As such, several of Charlie’s problems can be attributed to her upbringing, but several others are directly because of her closemindedness. I am not a fan of the “Bullies need to be forgiven if their home circumstances are bad” theory; deliberate bad behaviour towards others is never justified.
In such cases, it is nice to see the character learn from their mistakes, change their thinking, and apologise when needed. Charlie does have a learning curve over the course of the story, but it is a bit too slow and unsteady to be satisfactory. She gets away with a lot in the book, and I am not sure what signal this sends to young readers.
The rest of the characters compensate excellently. Charlie’s Aunt Bertha and Uncle Gus are gems in every way. Middle-grade books often depict foster parents from within the extended family as being cruel or selfish, so seeing Bertha and Gus portrayed as kind-hearted and loving human beings was a refreshing change. Charlie’s new friend Howard and his family are also great characters, possibly too good to be true. As we see ‘Wishbone’ the dog on the cover, it would be easy to assume that he has a proper role in the story. But Wishbone is present in hardly a handful of scenes. He does add fun to the story, but I wish he had a larger presence in the plot, especially considering the cover.
Through Charlie’s experiences, the story offers several lessons to its little readers. Be it inculcating an attitude of gratitude for life’s little blessings, not being envious of others based on partial information, retaining hope even when things seem dismal, and not judging people based on hearsay or physical appearance, the lessons are not just important but also highly relevant in today’s world. Even Bertha and Gus are stellar examples of positive parenting, though they were a bit too lax for my liking. My favourite was the ‘problems on the clothesline’ analogy, something we all would do well to remember.
Charlie’s wishes are an important part of the story. Quite interesting how she knows so many ways of making wishes! Kids would already be aware of a couple of them, but they might enjoy the new wish-making methods as well. That said, this is merely a motif and doesn’t influence the story in any way. Don’t expect any magic or magical realism.
The plot itself is somewhat bland and predictable. Of course, middle-grade stories are often straightforward considering the target age group. But this book was a bit too on-the-nose about it. Also, I disliked the stereotyping of “Southern” USA – the portrayal seems too cliched. I have no personal experience to offer in this regard, so my opinion is just based on whatever books I have read set in this part of the world.
The ending is apt for the plot. Not too perfect, not too coincidental, not too forced. Just the best option possible given the circumstances.
The story is written in an easy-to-understand language. Do note that Charlie’s first-person includes a few regionalisms that might be considered grammatical errors elsewhere. (“Me and Howard” or “can’t hardly believe”) Her speaking style does suits her character.
🎧 The Audiobook Experience:
The audiobook, clocking at 4 hrs 41 min, is narrated by Suzy Jackson. She is outstanding! She gets the accents and the emotions right for all the characters. But the plot itself was such that I kept zoning out of the audio every now and then. The middle was especially challenging to sit through as it felt dragged.
Overall, this is a decent story, but fairly run-of-the-mill, found-family, middle-grade fiction. Charlie’s behaviour and circumstances ensure a touching and thought-provoking experience, but her character itself isn't a role model in any way except in her love for Wishbone. I wish some of her positive attributes had been highlighted more. That said, the lessons offered by the plot are important.
Recommended but not with gusto. This book will be a good option for middle-graders and adults to read together and discuss some of the finer points.
2.75 stars.
This was a library read. This book has a new companion novel titled ‘Dream’, which is next on my reading list. I *wish* it works better than this book.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Facebook ||
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Plot Preview:
Colby, North Carolina. Charlie Reese, who is almost eleven, has been making the same wish every single day since more than a year. By now, she is an expert at knowing all the ways possible to make a wish. However, when she is sent away to the Blue Ridge mountains to stay with her maternal aunt and her husband, whom Charlie hasn’t even met before, the little girl is sure that her wish won't ever come true in a backward town filled with “hillbillies”. But as we know, life has a way of throwing surprises your way when you least expect them.
The story comes to us in Charlie’s first-person perspective.
Some middle-grade books are purely entertaining, while some lend themselves to introspection and discussions. This book is in the latter category.
Some middle-grade books feature protagonists who are brave and kind and loving, while others are led by a character whose behaviour needs a lot of finetuning. This book is in the latter category.
Some middle-grade books depict the merits of the family you are born into while others highlight how a family can be built in different ways. This book is in the latter category.
In several ways, this is a typical middle-grade book. It offers a protagonist facing challenges, a nice new friend who becomes the voice of reason, and a loveable canine. However, it also breaks the norm several times, especially in its depiction of the lead character. This doesn’t necessarily work to its advantage.
Charlie isn’t an inspiring protagonist in any way. She is quick to lose her temper, is rude without justification, has a strong bias against the people she looks down upon as “hillbillies”, and is envious of her older sister. Charlie’s family background isn't the kind you often see in this genre. Her father is imprisoned and her mother seems to be facing a severe mental health issue. As such, several of Charlie’s problems can be attributed to her upbringing, but several others are directly because of her closemindedness. I am not a fan of the “Bullies need to be forgiven if their home circumstances are bad” theory; deliberate bad behaviour towards others is never justified.
In such cases, it is nice to see the character learn from their mistakes, change their thinking, and apologise when needed. Charlie does have a learning curve over the course of the story, but it is a bit too slow and unsteady to be satisfactory. She gets away with a lot in the book, and I am not sure what signal this sends to young readers.
The rest of the characters compensate excellently. Charlie’s Aunt Bertha and Uncle Gus are gems in every way. Middle-grade books often depict foster parents from within the extended family as being cruel or selfish, so seeing Bertha and Gus portrayed as kind-hearted and loving human beings was a refreshing change. Charlie’s new friend Howard and his family are also great characters, possibly too good to be true. As we see ‘Wishbone’ the dog on the cover, it would be easy to assume that he has a proper role in the story. But Wishbone is present in hardly a handful of scenes. He does add fun to the story, but I wish he had a larger presence in the plot, especially considering the cover.
Through Charlie’s experiences, the story offers several lessons to its little readers. Be it inculcating an attitude of gratitude for life’s little blessings, not being envious of others based on partial information, retaining hope even when things seem dismal, and not judging people based on hearsay or physical appearance, the lessons are not just important but also highly relevant in today’s world. Even Bertha and Gus are stellar examples of positive parenting, though they were a bit too lax for my liking. My favourite was the ‘problems on the clothesline’ analogy, something we all would do well to remember.
Charlie’s wishes are an important part of the story. Quite interesting how she knows so many ways of making wishes! Kids would already be aware of a couple of them, but they might enjoy the new wish-making methods as well. That said, this is merely a motif and doesn’t influence the story in any way. Don’t expect any magic or magical realism.
The plot itself is somewhat bland and predictable. Of course, middle-grade stories are often straightforward considering the target age group. But this book was a bit too on-the-nose about it. Also, I disliked the stereotyping of “Southern” USA – the portrayal seems too cliched. I have no personal experience to offer in this regard, so my opinion is just based on whatever books I have read set in this part of the world.
The ending is apt for the plot. Not too perfect, not too coincidental, not too forced. Just the best option possible given the circumstances.
The story is written in an easy-to-understand language. Do note that Charlie’s first-person includes a few regionalisms that might be considered grammatical errors elsewhere. (“Me and Howard” or “can’t hardly believe”) Her speaking style does suits her character.
🎧 The Audiobook Experience:
The audiobook, clocking at 4 hrs 41 min, is narrated by Suzy Jackson. She is outstanding! She gets the accents and the emotions right for all the characters. But the plot itself was such that I kept zoning out of the audio every now and then. The middle was especially challenging to sit through as it felt dragged.
Overall, this is a decent story, but fairly run-of-the-mill, found-family, middle-grade fiction. Charlie’s behaviour and circumstances ensure a touching and thought-provoking experience, but her character itself isn't a role model in any way except in her love for Wishbone. I wish some of her positive attributes had been highlighted more. That said, the lessons offered by the plot are important.
Recommended but not with gusto. This book will be a good option for middle-graders and adults to read together and discuss some of the finer points.
2.75 stars.
This was a library read. This book has a new companion novel titled ‘Dream’, which is next on my reading list. I *wish* it works better than this book.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Connect with me through:
My Blog || The StoryGraph || Instagram || Facebook ||
October 2, 2019
Do you think that every family in the American South in the current day is eating cornbread, turnip greens and succotash for every supper?
Seems hard to believe.
I mean. . . don't you think some of them eat spaghetti or hamburgers or fast food?
Don't get me wrong, I love Southern food, and I'd probably cook it at least once a week if I didn't think my family would spit it back out at me, but. . . it's one of my issues with this book.
There is the bad family: Mama sleeps on the couch all day, Scrappy (Daddy) is in a correctional facility. . . and then there is the good family: Aunt Bertha and Uncle Gus spend all day gardening and taking in stray cats and cookin' grits in a big ole cook pot.
Naturally, Charlemagne (Charlie) the protagonist, is going to be won over by all dem grits 'cause deys so good. . . and this is no spoiler-alert, 'cause you can see the story line coming on the first page.
I'm sorry, but I read chapter books aloud to my kids and this was just way too after-school-special for me, but, okay, the cover art is inspiring, and there is a beagle in the story.
My daughter says 4 stars, I say 3. . .
But that beagle on the cover is just begging me to be more generous.
Seems hard to believe.
I mean. . . don't you think some of them eat spaghetti or hamburgers or fast food?
Don't get me wrong, I love Southern food, and I'd probably cook it at least once a week if I didn't think my family would spit it back out at me, but. . . it's one of my issues with this book.
There is the bad family: Mama sleeps on the couch all day, Scrappy (Daddy) is in a correctional facility. . . and then there is the good family: Aunt Bertha and Uncle Gus spend all day gardening and taking in stray cats and cookin' grits in a big ole cook pot.
Naturally, Charlemagne (Charlie) the protagonist, is going to be won over by all dem grits 'cause deys so good. . . and this is no spoiler-alert, 'cause you can see the story line coming on the first page.
I'm sorry, but I read chapter books aloud to my kids and this was just way too after-school-special for me, but, okay, the cover art is inspiring, and there is a beagle in the story.
My daughter says 4 stars, I say 3. . .
But that beagle on the cover is just begging me to be more generous.
November 14, 2025
I was looking online for dog books at my local library, as part of my dog-love reading challenge that was presented to me by my Goodreads Friend, Stephen Wallace, and this one came up.
How can you resist this cover?
I learned immediately that readers in grades 3-6 will find it an entertaining read, and that middle-school readers could relate to the relationship between the characters.
Of course, as an adult reader, it was a sweet story.
Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese has been making the same secret wish every day since 4th grade. When trouble arises within her family, she is sent to live with family she doesn’t know in a place she has never been – the Blue Ridge Mountains.
There she encounters people she has never been around “hillbilly kids who probably eat squirrels.”
What is she in for here?
Wish is told from Charlie’s POV. She is unique, flawed, relatable, appealing.
She meets and makes friends with Howard who is laid back and kind.
All this…Provides the beginning for a perfect setting to when Wishbone, a skinny stray dog makes his entrance.
And of course…That is all it takes for love to open everyone’s hearts.
And maybe, just maybe wishes do come true.
Including finding family in the most unlikely places.
How can you resist this cover?
I learned immediately that readers in grades 3-6 will find it an entertaining read, and that middle-school readers could relate to the relationship between the characters.
Of course, as an adult reader, it was a sweet story.
Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese has been making the same secret wish every day since 4th grade. When trouble arises within her family, she is sent to live with family she doesn’t know in a place she has never been – the Blue Ridge Mountains.
There she encounters people she has never been around “hillbilly kids who probably eat squirrels.”
What is she in for here?
Wish is told from Charlie’s POV. She is unique, flawed, relatable, appealing.
She meets and makes friends with Howard who is laid back and kind.
All this…Provides the beginning for a perfect setting to when Wishbone, a skinny stray dog makes his entrance.
And of course…That is all it takes for love to open everyone’s hearts.
And maybe, just maybe wishes do come true.
Including finding family in the most unlikely places.
September 8, 2023
Charlie makes a wish every day. On an eyelash. Three birds on a power line. A yellow railroad car. A star. She has been collecting ways to wish and doesn't ever let one go to waste. What is her wish? It definitely isn't going to live with Gus & Bertha in a little bitty town. And she doesn't want an "up and down" boy like Howard for her backpack buddy, either. Fortunately, as time goes by a dog named Wishbone and some other changes will show Charlie that her wish is coming true. Barbara O'Connor definitely has a gift for writing about dogs and kids. I have loved every title I have read from her. The families in this book are not well off, but they are blessed in so many intangible ways. And a dog like Wishbone is like icing on the cake. Charlie's wish may come true before she even realizes it has happened.
March 12, 2024
Because I could never write a review this compelling.
‘Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese has been making the same secret wish every day since fourth grade. She even has a list of all the ways there are to make the wish, such as cutting off the pointed end of a slice of pie and wishing on it as she takes the last bite. But when she is sent to the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina to live with family she barely knows.’ Amazon
I loved everything about this sweet story. I’ve decided children’s books are what I will read for a while. Any child who reads this will learn about resilience, sadness, hope and most especially the unconditional love of a family and a very sweet dog. Sometimes families come in different sizes, different categories. This is quite simply a wonderful book.
‘Eleven-year-old Charlie Reese has been making the same secret wish every day since fourth grade. She even has a list of all the ways there are to make the wish, such as cutting off the pointed end of a slice of pie and wishing on it as she takes the last bite. But when she is sent to the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina to live with family she barely knows.’ Amazon
I loved everything about this sweet story. I’ve decided children’s books are what I will read for a while. Any child who reads this will learn about resilience, sadness, hope and most especially the unconditional love of a family and a very sweet dog. Sometimes families come in different sizes, different categories. This is quite simply a wonderful book.
February 12, 2021
This is such a sweet and heartfelt story, told from Charlie's POV. Don't let the book cover fool you. I didn't read the book blurb before reading the book, so based on the cover I expected a cute story about a girl and her dog. It's so much more!
Charlie is a feisty fifth grade girl whose parents can't properly care for her. As a result she's placed under the care of her aunt and uncle, who live in a different city. Not only does Charlie need to leave her family and her home, but now she must also attend a new school. This is Charlie's story about love, friendship, and acceptance.
Charlie is a feisty fifth grade girl whose parents can't properly care for her. As a result she's placed under the care of her aunt and uncle, who live in a different city. Not only does Charlie need to leave her family and her home, but now she must also attend a new school. This is Charlie's story about love, friendship, and acceptance.
March 3, 2025
Wish by Barbara O'Conner
5 Star Favorite
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
This book touched my heart in the best way. This is one of those rare stories that quietly sneaks into your heart and refuses to let go. Charlie is a character I won’t forget. We open the story with her sadness of longing for a family after her mother walked away from her when she was younger and her father is in jail, so she is living with her Aunt and Uncle - it's really like a foster situation from the child's POV. She has such longing for a family and to be home in Raleigh, NC and she is not happy to be alone, without her parents and older sister, in a "hillbilly small town".
We see her navigate a new home, form an unlikely friendship with Howard (the sweetest boy!), and open her heart to a stray dog (beagle!) named Wishbone. Your heart breaks for her but you also see her growth and it's beautiful. She continues to make "wishes" along that way and where things end is not where she thinks...
I teared up a few times in this one! Her journey of realizing that love, family, and belonging don’t always look the way we expect hit RIGHT IN THE FEELS YALL!
If you love stories about resilience, found family, and wishes that come true in unexpected ways, then Wish is a must-read. I’ll be thinking about this one for a long time. ❤️🐶✨
5 Star Favorite
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Blog Post: https://bookloveramanda.blogspot.com/...
This book touched my heart in the best way. This is one of those rare stories that quietly sneaks into your heart and refuses to let go. Charlie is a character I won’t forget. We open the story with her sadness of longing for a family after her mother walked away from her when she was younger and her father is in jail, so she is living with her Aunt and Uncle - it's really like a foster situation from the child's POV. She has such longing for a family and to be home in Raleigh, NC and she is not happy to be alone, without her parents and older sister, in a "hillbilly small town".
We see her navigate a new home, form an unlikely friendship with Howard (the sweetest boy!), and open her heart to a stray dog (beagle!) named Wishbone. Your heart breaks for her but you also see her growth and it's beautiful. She continues to make "wishes" along that way and where things end is not where she thinks...
I teared up a few times in this one! Her journey of realizing that love, family, and belonging don’t always look the way we expect hit RIGHT IN THE FEELS YALL!
If you love stories about resilience, found family, and wishes that come true in unexpected ways, then Wish is a must-read. I’ll be thinking about this one for a long time. ❤️🐶✨
May 22, 2016
This has to be one of my favorite books I've read so far this year! Barbara O'Connor does it again! She writes a beautiful story that has just enough humor to provide the right amount of laughter mixed with moments that pull on your heart strings. I fell in love with the characters, each playing such an important part in developing the plot of the story. The southern dialect and attention to detail helped me to really get into the story! O'Connor's choice of words and language make this a story that begs to be read out loud. Charlie, the main character, goes to live with an aunt and uncle when her parents can't take care of her any more. She feels abandoned and unwanted. With the help of a new friend, Howard, a stray dog she takes in, and her aunt and uncle, Charlie finally finds her place to belong. This is a story of friendship, family, and never giving up on your wishes!
April 24, 2016
I raced through this book in one night/day. And I finished it with a big happy cry. The book was so good for my heart and soul. And I know just what I need now: More Barbara O'Connor books.
April 2, 2025
This was such a beautiful and sweet story that touched my heart! This is a story of love, resilience, friendship, and found family. This book has a great balance of humor and moments that will pull at your heartstrings.
Charlie goes to live with her aunt and uncle when her parents can’t take care of her. She faces the hardships and feelings of being abandoned and unwanted. But along the way, she finds a new friend in Howard (he's an absolute gem), a cute furry companion, and people who genuinely care for her, where she finds her place to belong.
I've met and had kids similar to Charlie growing up with a family who cared for foster children, and they truly have some of the biggest hearts. It just takes time to learn what love looks like and grow trust with people who genuinely care.
I will definitely be reading more books by this author, and I highly recommend reading this gem of a book💕
Quote from the book: “You can’t judge people for the mistakes they make, you judge them for how they fix those mistakes.”
Charlie goes to live with her aunt and uncle when her parents can’t take care of her. She faces the hardships and feelings of being abandoned and unwanted. But along the way, she finds a new friend in Howard (he's an absolute gem), a cute furry companion, and people who genuinely care for her, where she finds her place to belong.
I've met and had kids similar to Charlie growing up with a family who cared for foster children, and they truly have some of the biggest hearts. It just takes time to learn what love looks like and grow trust with people who genuinely care.
I will definitely be reading more books by this author, and I highly recommend reading this gem of a book💕
Quote from the book: “You can’t judge people for the mistakes they make, you judge them for how they fix those mistakes.”
June 23, 2016
The magical cover is only a start to this wonderful book! Wish has to be one if my favorites of 2016! Students will devour this book. Told with humor & honesty this book follows Charlie's attempt to fit in, in a new town & capture a stray dog named Wishbone. Will Charlie love her new life? Or will her temper prevent her from making friends? Will her wish finally come true?
Charlie, Howard, Bertha, Gus & Wishbone are a cast of characters students will love & adore! Add this to your TBR & library ASAP!
Charlie, Howard, Bertha, Gus & Wishbone are a cast of characters students will love & adore! Add this to your TBR & library ASAP!
March 4, 2019
I read this for my Materials for Children class. And it was adorable! I really could relate to the main character, Charlie. She is a young girl dealing with moving to a different city to live with her aunt and uncle after her parents fell apart. While that didn’t ever happen to me, I did move around as a kid with my father being in the military. So I understood being in a new city around new people and how hard it can be to adjust. She found comfort in an awkward boy and a stray dog. Being a dog lover myself, I related to her on that level as well. This books was heart warming and sweet and a great lesson in what it is to be a real family.
February 21, 2017
Wonderful book! I basically read this in one sitting. I believe a lot of the upper elementary kids at my school will relate to this book.
January 25, 2024
Very good book but not a huge 'dog' book. Our heroine Charlie comes from a broken home to go live with her Aunt and Uncle. She has to move from big city Raleigh North Carolina, to a small town named Colby more in the mountains where people are said to eat squirrel. The dog part is she sees a stray dog, has to find a way to catch it, and then the dog is a comfort to her.
It was an adjustment coming from a previous book which also had a young girl main character, but had small normal type challenges, to this one where she has big problems, with her dad in prison, and her mom confined to her bed with severe depression. At various times she says really mean things to good people trying to help her and be her friend. Luckily she has a great friend and aunt and uncle.
Here is one passage of her thoughts after saying something mean in anger:
'When those words left my mouth, I could practically see them hurtling through the air toward Howard, quick and sharp like razors.'
This seems like a great book for youths to read. If they have a great family situation it will help give some empathy to those that don't and great examples of those who patiently deal with her. If they have a similar bad family they can know they aren't the only one, or that people understand.
The great thing about this book as the title strongly hints at, is regarding wishing. There is a LOT of wishing in this book and you will have to read it for the why. What is fun is how many different ways Charlie thinks will give you the opportunity to wish. I will add a few of my favorites:
'If you cut off the pointed end of a slice of pie and save it for last, you can make a wish when you eat it.'
'What I did see was a truck full of hay. Jackie's friend Casey told me if you count to thirteen when you see a truck full of hay, you can make a wish.'
'That was the rule for black-horse wishing. If you see a white horse, just make a wish. But for a black horse you have to shake your fist at it three times.'
'From far off in the trees outside the window came the song of a mockingbird. Hearing a bird sing in the rain is on my list of things to make a wish on.'
"Yellow railroad cars aren't too plentiful," he told me. "When you see one, make a wish."
Charlie learns from the people who help her. Like Howard who only finds the good part when things are bad and teaches her to say 'Pineapple' when she gets made. One bit about the uncle I really loved:
'Then Gus stood up and said the perfect Gus thing.
"Let's have some of that blackberry cobbler before supper."
So that's what we did.'
Then after supper, they had more blackberry cobbler. The only thing that bugged me is there was no mention of vanilla ice cream to go with it, so I had to just imagine that going with it on my own.
So maybe not a big 'dog' story, but a good story nevertheless. And having a dog in a any story does generally make it better. And no Kleenex needed for unhappy tears in the end.
It was an adjustment coming from a previous book which also had a young girl main character, but had small normal type challenges, to this one where she has big problems, with her dad in prison, and her mom confined to her bed with severe depression. At various times she says really mean things to good people trying to help her and be her friend. Luckily she has a great friend and aunt and uncle.
Here is one passage of her thoughts after saying something mean in anger:
'When those words left my mouth, I could practically see them hurtling through the air toward Howard, quick and sharp like razors.'
This seems like a great book for youths to read. If they have a great family situation it will help give some empathy to those that don't and great examples of those who patiently deal with her. If they have a similar bad family they can know they aren't the only one, or that people understand.
The great thing about this book as the title strongly hints at, is regarding wishing. There is a LOT of wishing in this book and you will have to read it for the why. What is fun is how many different ways Charlie thinks will give you the opportunity to wish. I will add a few of my favorites:
'If you cut off the pointed end of a slice of pie and save it for last, you can make a wish when you eat it.'
'What I did see was a truck full of hay. Jackie's friend Casey told me if you count to thirteen when you see a truck full of hay, you can make a wish.'
'That was the rule for black-horse wishing. If you see a white horse, just make a wish. But for a black horse you have to shake your fist at it three times.'
'From far off in the trees outside the window came the song of a mockingbird. Hearing a bird sing in the rain is on my list of things to make a wish on.'
"Yellow railroad cars aren't too plentiful," he told me. "When you see one, make a wish."
Charlie learns from the people who help her. Like Howard who only finds the good part when things are bad and teaches her to say 'Pineapple' when she gets made. One bit about the uncle I really loved:
'Then Gus stood up and said the perfect Gus thing.
"Let's have some of that blackberry cobbler before supper."
So that's what we did.'
Then after supper, they had more blackberry cobbler. The only thing that bugged me is there was no mention of vanilla ice cream to go with it, so I had to just imagine that going with it on my own.
So maybe not a big 'dog' story, but a good story nevertheless. And having a dog in a any story does generally make it better. And no Kleenex needed for unhappy tears in the end.
March 10, 2025
Cute story.
Language: N/A. Just uses of h*ck, d*ng, d*rn, and g*sh. Mentions of characters cussing but not what they said.
Violence: N/A.
Magic: N/A.
(Other: Charlie is living with her aunt and uncle because her dad is in jail for his ‘temper and fighting’ and it is mentioned that her mom has depression.)
I'm not sure what to think of this story honestly, the dog was cute…lol…Honestly, from start to finish it didn’t feel like the characters really grew or changed any, Charlie was stil Charlie and Howard was still Howard. Charlie had resolved to be better but we never actually got to really see her growth except in the very last chapter🤷♀️
Howard was a nice character to begin with but he never had an arc, and I get not wanting to fight but letting yourself be a push-over all the time didn’t seem like a very good lesson for kids. There are times to walk away sure, but you also shouldn't let people step on you all of the time. Just my thoughts. He was nice tho and I liked his character pretty well, I was just waiting for him to step up for himself but he never did.
Also, it rubbed me the wrong way that church was very frequent in the book and the characters were Christians yet it was the constant ‘wishing on objects and things’ that made their wishes come true. They believed wishing on stars and bird feathers and such was what made they're wish come true which was a little weird to me, considering the Christian aspect. Maybe, I'm overthinking it, but it irked me a little.
Overall, it was a sweet and cute story, Wishbone was really cute and honestly carried the story for me…lol…I loved the Appalachian setting, the descriptions were beautiful and it made me feel all cozy and at home! #AppalachianStrong
Anyway, if you're looking for a light read with a cute dog, this is a fuzzy summertime read.
9+
Language: N/A. Just uses of h*ck, d*ng, d*rn, and g*sh. Mentions of characters cussing but not what they said.
Violence: N/A.
Magic: N/A.
(Other: Charlie is living with her aunt and uncle because her dad is in jail for his ‘temper and fighting’ and it is mentioned that her mom has depression.)
I'm not sure what to think of this story honestly, the dog was cute…lol…Honestly, from start to finish it didn’t feel like the characters really grew or changed any, Charlie was stil Charlie and Howard was still Howard. Charlie had resolved to be better but we never actually got to really see her growth except in the very last chapter🤷♀️
Howard was a nice character to begin with but he never had an arc, and I get not wanting to fight but letting yourself be a push-over all the time didn’t seem like a very good lesson for kids. There are times to walk away sure, but you also shouldn't let people step on you all of the time. Just my thoughts. He was nice tho and I liked his character pretty well, I was just waiting for him to step up for himself but he never did.
Also, it rubbed me the wrong way that church was very frequent in the book and the characters were Christians yet it was the constant ‘wishing on objects and things’ that made their wishes come true. They believed wishing on stars and bird feathers and such was what made they're wish come true which was a little weird to me, considering the Christian aspect. Maybe, I'm overthinking it, but it irked me a little.
Overall, it was a sweet and cute story, Wishbone was really cute and honestly carried the story for me…lol…I loved the Appalachian setting, the descriptions were beautiful and it made me feel all cozy and at home! #AppalachianStrong
Anyway, if you're looking for a light read with a cute dog, this is a fuzzy summertime read.
9+
March 8, 2025
Our favorite parts of this book:
Set in Colby, NC which is about two hours from where we live...That was cool because most of the places it mentioned we've been to.
The dog, Wishbone, was adorable!
Set in Colby, NC which is about two hours from where we live...That was cool because most of the places it mentioned we've been to.
The dog, Wishbone, was adorable!
August 3, 2020
Perfect book to read with your kiddos! Mine both adored it ☺️
Charlie is a little rough around the edges, Howard is just sweeter than anything in the world. I love their friendship, I love found family books. Oh and I read the last tmfew pages through my own tears while my daughter's eyes "we're getting wet" (that's how she says it haha) beside me.
I originally bought this for my Reiny (8) and he liked it so much he asked me to read it with Owl (5). Definitely a heartwarming story 💕.
Charlie is a little rough around the edges, Howard is just sweeter than anything in the world. I love their friendship, I love found family books. Oh and I read the last tmfew pages through my own tears while my daughter's eyes "we're getting wet" (that's how she says it haha) beside me.
I originally bought this for my Reiny (8) and he liked it so much he asked me to read it with Owl (5). Definitely a heartwarming story 💕.
April 21, 2018
Wow, this was a really heartbreaking story, but I loved it so much. I loved all of it, but some phrases of the story really struck me. My favorite one was "That was it. I looked at the word love. I traced the letters with my finger. Then I folded the paper up and put it back in the envelope." I just though that was so overwhelming but I loved it so much because it defined the mc so much and really sharpened the perspective. Oh my, this book made what was supposed to be a relaxing Saturday a heart-rending time to curl up in a ball and bawl my eyes out. But really, I loved the book and I think everyone should read it!
November 13, 2022
What a cute book💜 I absolutely loved this! I randomly came across it at a thrift store because the cute cover drew me in, and I'm so happy I did! It's a beautiful addition to my shelf, both inside and out💕
I love middle grade stories, and books like these are why. They're so innocently heartfelt, and I just love the way that children view the world. It's so much simpler but at the same time so much more all-consuming. Every little moment means so much, and it's so precious.
I'll definitely be checking out more books by this author, because this was an absolutely beautiful surprise.
I love middle grade stories, and books like these are why. They're so innocently heartfelt, and I just love the way that children view the world. It's so much simpler but at the same time so much more all-consuming. Every little moment means so much, and it's so precious.
I'll definitely be checking out more books by this author, because this was an absolutely beautiful surprise.
February 2, 2019
Truyện gì đâu mà dễ thương quá trời <3 <3 <3 Cô bé Charlemagne “Charlie” phải rời khỏi thành phố Raleigh để đến sống cùng gia đình người dì ruột Bertha và chồng của bà là Gus tại thị trấn Colby heo hút tại North Carolina, sau khi cha của em thì phải đi tù vì tội đánh nhau, còn mẹ em thì thần kinh không ổn định, không đủ khả năng để nuôi con.
Cô bé Charlie luôn ước ao mình có được một gia đình trọn vẹn, không bị xé nát, được ở chung một nhà với ba mẹ và chị gái Jackie, được trở về thời quá khứ với những kỷ niệm đẹp, chứ không phải thực tại phũ phàng thế này, khi em đến sống tại một ngôi nhà cheo leo bên vách núi, tại một thị trấn xa xôi, kiểu vùng nông thôn, nơi người dân bị đồn là “chuyên ăn thịt sóc”. Charlie, với tâm tính nắng mưa thất thường, khó bảo, khó gần của một đứa trẻ ở độ tuổi dậy thì, lại gặp nhiều chuyện không may trong cuộc sống, đã căm ghét vô cùng cái thị trấn Colby đó, căm ghét cảnh sống xa cha mẹ, xa người chị ruột, mặc dù dì Bertha và bác Gus luôn hết lòng yêu thương, chăm sóc cho em.
Cũng dễ hiểu khi mà tất cả những gì Charlie luôn mong mỏi là một gia đình trọn vẹn, và hình ảnh gia đình ấy, em luôn nghĩ rằng chỉ có thể đạt được khi em quay lại Raleigh, khi ba em ra tù và mẹ em bình thường trở lại. Và suốt những tháng ngày sống ở Colby, những khi bắt gặp một cảnh tượng, hiện tượng nào đó có thể ban cho em một điều ước (đồng hồ chỉ 11h11, ba con chim đậu trên dây điện, 14 hàng hột bắp đều tăm tắp,…), em đều ước ao một gia đình trọn vẹn cho riêng mình.
Rồi với sự xuất hiện của “cậu bạn kèm cặp” Howard tóc đỏ và dáng đi cà nhắc, cùng chú chó hoang mà em gọi là Xương Chạc, Charlie dần dần nhận ra, hóa ra điều em luôn ước ao mong mỏi bấy lâu nay, em đã có được từ lâu rồi – gia đình trọn vẹn và giàu tình yêu thương ấy đã luôn ở bên em, dưới hình ảnh của dì Bertha, bác Gus, Xương Chạc… Hành trình để Charlie nhận ra sự thật ấy, cũng như để em học được rằng, gia đình không phải lúc nào cũng được xây dựng dựa trên máu mủ, mà là dựa trên tình yêu thương, hoàn toàn không phải là một hành trình dễ dàng cho cả Charlie lẫn những người thân của em.
Có nhiều đoạn thực sự xúc động, khi Charlie nhìn thấy cách gia đình Howard vui vẻ, hòa thuận bên nhau, và em chạnh lòng khi nghĩ đến tình cảnh của mình; khi Charlie mong mỏi được ở bên chị Jackie, nhưng rồi cũng như cha mẹ em, những người em yêu thương đều bỏ em mà đi mất… Khi Charlie học cách cư xử đúng đắn với một cậu bạn hết mực dễ thương là Howard, khi em dần dần mở lòng ra để đón nhận tình bạn, tình yêu thương, sự quan tâm, chăm sóc của những người thực sự muốn yêu thương em, bầu bạn với em.
Cảnh trí vùng Colby được tác giả miêu tả quá sức đẹp và quá sức nên thơ, làm mình cũng muốn tới đó sống suốt đời :))) Tuổi trẻ thì thường thích tới những chốn ồn ào, đông đúc, sôi động, nhộn nhịp để tìm kiếm những cơ hội mới, thách thức mới, trải nghiệm mới, nhưng chả hiểu sao mình chưa già mà đã thích về chốn nông thôn, không xồ bồ, không náo nhiệt để bình tâm rồi ha ha ha :D :D :D Không biết địa danh Colby ở North Carolina có thật không nhỉ? ^^ Nếu có thật thì mình muốn tới thăm thú một lần :)))
Cô bé Charlie luôn ước ao mình có được một gia đình trọn vẹn, không bị xé nát, được ở chung một nhà với ba mẹ và chị gái Jackie, được trở về thời quá khứ với những kỷ niệm đẹp, chứ không phải thực tại phũ phàng thế này, khi em đến sống tại một ngôi nhà cheo leo bên vách núi, tại một thị trấn xa xôi, kiểu vùng nông thôn, nơi người dân bị đồn là “chuyên ăn thịt sóc”. Charlie, với tâm tính nắng mưa thất thường, khó bảo, khó gần của một đứa trẻ ở độ tuổi dậy thì, lại gặp nhiều chuyện không may trong cuộc sống, đã căm ghét vô cùng cái thị trấn Colby đó, căm ghét cảnh sống xa cha mẹ, xa người chị ruột, mặc dù dì Bertha và bác Gus luôn hết lòng yêu thương, chăm sóc cho em.
Cũng dễ hiểu khi mà tất cả những gì Charlie luôn mong mỏi là một gia đình trọn vẹn, và hình ảnh gia đình ấy, em luôn nghĩ rằng chỉ có thể đạt được khi em quay lại Raleigh, khi ba em ra tù và mẹ em bình thường trở lại. Và suốt những tháng ngày sống ở Colby, những khi bắt gặp một cảnh tượng, hiện tượng nào đó có thể ban cho em một điều ước (đồng hồ chỉ 11h11, ba con chim đậu trên dây điện, 14 hàng hột bắp đều tăm tắp,…), em đều ước ao một gia đình trọn vẹn cho riêng mình.
Rồi với sự xuất hiện của “cậu bạn kèm cặp” Howard tóc đỏ và dáng đi cà nhắc, cùng chú chó hoang mà em gọi là Xương Chạc, Charlie dần dần nhận ra, hóa ra điều em luôn ước ao mong mỏi bấy lâu nay, em đã có được từ lâu rồi – gia đình trọn vẹn và giàu tình yêu thương ấy đã luôn ở bên em, dưới hình ảnh của dì Bertha, bác Gus, Xương Chạc… Hành trình để Charlie nhận ra sự thật ấy, cũng như để em học được rằng, gia đình không phải lúc nào cũng được xây dựng dựa trên máu mủ, mà là dựa trên tình yêu thương, hoàn toàn không phải là một hành trình dễ dàng cho cả Charlie lẫn những người thân của em.
Có nhiều đoạn thực sự xúc động, khi Charlie nhìn thấy cách gia đình Howard vui vẻ, hòa thuận bên nhau, và em chạnh lòng khi nghĩ đến tình cảnh của mình; khi Charlie mong mỏi được ở bên chị Jackie, nhưng rồi cũng như cha mẹ em, những người em yêu thương đều bỏ em mà đi mất… Khi Charlie học cách cư xử đúng đắn với một cậu bạn hết mực dễ thương là Howard, khi em dần dần mở lòng ra để đón nhận tình bạn, tình yêu thương, sự quan tâm, chăm sóc của những người thực sự muốn yêu thương em, bầu bạn với em.
Cảnh trí vùng Colby được tác giả miêu tả quá sức đẹp và quá sức nên thơ, làm mình cũng muốn tới đó sống suốt đời :))) Tuổi trẻ thì thường thích tới những chốn ồn ào, đông đúc, sôi động, nhộn nhịp để tìm kiếm những cơ hội mới, thách thức mới, trải nghiệm mới, nhưng chả hiểu sao mình chưa già mà đã thích về chốn nông thôn, không xồ bồ, không náo nhiệt để bình tâm rồi ha ha ha :D :D :D Không biết địa danh Colby ở North Carolina có thật không nhỉ? ^^ Nếu có thật thì mình muốn tới thăm thú một lần :)))
August 3, 2020
Ultimately, a heartwarming tale that will take you through all the feels. You'll hear a nonstop, pleasant, Southern twang within conversation, feel the heat of the dog days of Summer, and gain insight into the emotions a child may feel as their daddy is being corrected and their mama is incapable of getting on her feet.
This is a book about friendship and family and how sometimes the things we wish for come true right before our eyes but we're incapable of seeing them clearly until others see it in us and around us first.
This is a book about a girl and her dog too.
"Because of Winn-Dixie" left me wanting my own dog and a tree with bottles hanging from it in my backyard. This book, "Wish", has me wanting a dog named Wishbone and a house built into the side of a mountain, out in a country-like setting, where the skies are clear enough to see the first star come out each night.
I gave this book 4 stars because some of the conversations felt a wee bit stilted in places. A lot of moving parts and characters with an overarching theme. It was written and done well but fell a bit short of perfection to me.
I love, love, love the love and affection displayed by Bertha and Gus, the main protagonist's aunt and uncle, towards one another as well as to Charlie herself. Calling Charlie, "Butterbean", what a gem of a nickname/term of endearment!
I loved the neighbors, the Odom's, and how dirty but joyous and good their home life was despite the chaos presented from an abundance of boys being boys.
The juxtaposition of both homes in comparison to what Charlie had been reared in is stark and all too real.
I recommend this book to social workers, families that are fostering children, and to those children themselves who have been displaced. For humanity's sake, never forget people's humanness; and, help others to find and discover coping skills that work for them! Saying the word, "Pineapple" for instance when you're angry or frustrated! Before allowing your emotions to get the best of you simply say, "Pineapple", and be willing and able to walk away until you return yourself to a more peaceful state.
By page 53 I was crying. Everyone deserves and needs to be told what a blessing they are in the lives of others. Not only the words being said but the actions of embrace and feelings of love that often follow words like those once they've been spoken.
I also was a puddle of mush as this book came to a close. So much good and just the outcome I had wished for.
A hearty 4 stars, I highly recommend; this is a good read!
This is a book about friendship and family and how sometimes the things we wish for come true right before our eyes but we're incapable of seeing them clearly until others see it in us and around us first.
This is a book about a girl and her dog too.
"Because of Winn-Dixie" left me wanting my own dog and a tree with bottles hanging from it in my backyard. This book, "Wish", has me wanting a dog named Wishbone and a house built into the side of a mountain, out in a country-like setting, where the skies are clear enough to see the first star come out each night.
I gave this book 4 stars because some of the conversations felt a wee bit stilted in places. A lot of moving parts and characters with an overarching theme. It was written and done well but fell a bit short of perfection to me.
I love, love, love the love and affection displayed by Bertha and Gus, the main protagonist's aunt and uncle, towards one another as well as to Charlie herself. Calling Charlie, "Butterbean", what a gem of a nickname/term of endearment!
I loved the neighbors, the Odom's, and how dirty but joyous and good their home life was despite the chaos presented from an abundance of boys being boys.
The juxtaposition of both homes in comparison to what Charlie had been reared in is stark and all too real.
I recommend this book to social workers, families that are fostering children, and to those children themselves who have been displaced. For humanity's sake, never forget people's humanness; and, help others to find and discover coping skills that work for them! Saying the word, "Pineapple" for instance when you're angry or frustrated! Before allowing your emotions to get the best of you simply say, "Pineapple", and be willing and able to walk away until you return yourself to a more peaceful state.
By page 53 I was crying. Everyone deserves and needs to be told what a blessing they are in the lives of others. Not only the words being said but the actions of embrace and feelings of love that often follow words like those once they've been spoken.
I also was a puddle of mush as this book came to a close. So much good and just the outcome I had wished for.
A hearty 4 stars, I highly recommend; this is a good read!
July 22, 2016
Three birds on a wire. Seeing 11:11 on a clock. Finding 14 rows on an ear of corn. These were just a few of the unique things that Charlie would make a secret wish on in Barbara O'Connor's book Wish. Charlie has been wishing for the same thing since fourth grade, and she's not stopping now. After moving in with her aunt and uncle, Charlie becomes friends with neighbor-boy, Howard, who seems wise beyond his years, and also keeps feisty Charlie in check (pineapple, pineapple, pineapple!). One day, Charlie and Howard spot a stray dog, and she makes it her goal to catch him. After finally catching Wishbone, Charlie feels an immediate connection, and they are inseparable. But will Charlie's secret wish ever come true? Wish is a beautifully written book about perseverance, hope, and friendship! My wish is that you and your students will love this story and characters as much as I did! Pre-order this one now!
June 15, 2016
I can't wait for this book to get into the hands of young readers. So many things for them to love!
The characters will make you laugh and will totally win your hearts, even Charlie at her unhappy grumpiest. And the dog, ah- the dog! Love him, too. A perfect read-aloud, WISH has so much to talk about with middle-grade readers. Don't miss this one.
The characters will make you laugh and will totally win your hearts, even Charlie at her unhappy grumpiest. And the dog, ah- the dog! Love him, too. A perfect read-aloud, WISH has so much to talk about with middle-grade readers. Don't miss this one.
March 3, 2024
This is the book I wish I would’ve had as a young girl! This story touched my heart deeply. If you’re looking for a moving children’s/middle grade book, read this and then put it into the hands of a little girl. I cannot recommend this one enough!
September 24, 2016
This is the quietest book that begins to squeeze your heart, slowly, slowly, until you realize that you are looking for things to wish on just like Charlie, but just for Charlie! Charlie has been taken to her Aunt Bertha and Uncle Gus's home after it's been determined that she is no longer in a stable environment. Her father is in jail and her mother doesn't get out of bed. Her sister is about to graduate from high school so gets to move in with a friend. Charlie is alone in what she thinks of as a sad house in the Blue Ridge mountains, among those "awful" hillbillies. She must finish her fifth grade year, and it's not a friendly place. But Charlie doesn't exactly know how to make friends, and is also in trouble with the teacher quite a bit. Sadly, this is not a sympathetic teacher, although I kept hoping! It's after school is out that the story deepens. I loved that Barbara O'Connor keeps Charlie surrounded with love, from Bertha and Gus, from her only friend, Howard's family, from the setting and finally from a stray dog, Wishbone. That's part of the sweet story too. A dog's love cures a lot of things, and he helps Charlie, too. Without telling all the story, just know that as others have said, it's worth reading and learning from the inside out what a child who also feels like a stray wishes for every single day.
June 12, 2019
This and other reviews can be found on The Psychotic Nerd
Actual Rating: 3.5 Stars
Short and Simple Review
I picked this book up because it looked like a heartfelt MG book featuring the love of dogs. This book wasn't quite what I expected. I thought the dog would be more prominent. There was a bit where Charlie decided that the stray wondering around would become hers, but this was over really quickly so it wasn't as much of a dog book as I expected. That being said, this was still a wonderful book. It talks about some difficult things, such as family issues, but it is discussed in a voice that fits the age of the MC. I really liked Charlie and it made my heart hurt at times because she wanted a family and was prone to being angry. Overall this was a quick read and this would certainly be an MG book that I would recommend.
Actual Rating: 3.5 Stars
Short and Simple Review
I picked this book up because it looked like a heartfelt MG book featuring the love of dogs. This book wasn't quite what I expected. I thought the dog would be more prominent. There was a bit where Charlie decided that the stray wondering around would become hers, but this was over really quickly so it wasn't as much of a dog book as I expected. That being said, this was still a wonderful book. It talks about some difficult things, such as family issues, but it is discussed in a voice that fits the age of the MC. I really liked Charlie and it made my heart hurt at times because she wanted a family and was prone to being angry. Overall this was a quick read and this would certainly be an MG book that I would recommend.
June 25, 2016
I received this e-book from Net Galley in exchange for an honest review.
Let me begin by saying that the story is just as beautiful as the cover! I definitely need to get a copy of this for my classroom library because I know my students will fall in love with these characters!
The main character, Charlie Reese, is a young girl who has been sent to live with her aunt and uncle due to an unstable home life. All she wants is to go back home and be with her family, even though she knows it isn't that simple. Charlie believes that if she just keeps on wishing, things will turn out right. Along the way, she learns that love and friendship can be found even in the most unlikely places...even in the form of a stray dog!
A must-read for all ages!
Let me begin by saying that the story is just as beautiful as the cover! I definitely need to get a copy of this for my classroom library because I know my students will fall in love with these characters!
The main character, Charlie Reese, is a young girl who has been sent to live with her aunt and uncle due to an unstable home life. All she wants is to go back home and be with her family, even though she knows it isn't that simple. Charlie believes that if she just keeps on wishing, things will turn out right. Along the way, she learns that love and friendship can be found even in the most unlikely places...even in the form of a stray dog!
A must-read for all ages!
April 13, 2018
I loved everything about this book!! Starting with its gorgeous cover art and a main character I took to immediately, Wish is a story about hope in the face of hopelessness. Reading this book will break your heart, and then restore your faith in humanity. I am always humbled as a teacher how Barbara O’Connor opens my eyes to the stories behind “bad behavior” we sometimes see in our students, as she did years ago with How to Steal a Dog (which I also highly recommend). Ages 8 and up!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,408 reviews