What do you think?
Rate this book
Claiming Noah
This riveting debut novel of psychological suspense explores the dilemmas that arise when motherhood and science collide.
Catriona Sinclair has always had a well-developed sense of independence--in fact the one sore point in her otherwise happy marriage is her husband James's desire to take care of her. As she's often tried to explain to him, she took care of herself before she met him, and did a good job of it. But James has been especially attentive lately as they struggle to have a baby. They succeed at last through in vitro fertilization, but unwilling to risk the heartbreak of another miscarriage, they decide to make their "spare" frozen embryo available to another family.
Diana and Liam Simmons are desperate for a child. Unable to conceive, they are overjoyed to learn that as the closest genetic match to the Sinclairs they are the recipients of the embryo donation. Diana's only concern is her mother's disapproval of IVF, but any doubts raised are quickly eclipsed by Diana's joy of being pregnant.
As Diana is finding delight in every aspect of motherhood, Catriona keeps waiting for the rush of adoration she knows she is supposed to feel, but instead slips into a deep depression. Just as Catriona begins to find her way back to normalcy, one of the babies is kidnapped. Suddenly, all of their lives begin to unravel and intertwine, and none of them will ever be the same.
Catriona Sinclair has always had a well-developed sense of independence--in fact the one sore point in her otherwise happy marriage is her husband James's desire to take care of her. As she's often tried to explain to him, she took care of herself before she met him, and did a good job of it. But James has been especially attentive lately as they struggle to have a baby. They succeed at last through in vitro fertilization, but unwilling to risk the heartbreak of another miscarriage, they decide to make their "spare" frozen embryo available to another family.
Diana and Liam Simmons are desperate for a child. Unable to conceive, they are overjoyed to learn that as the closest genetic match to the Sinclairs they are the recipients of the embryo donation. Diana's only concern is her mother's disapproval of IVF, but any doubts raised are quickly eclipsed by Diana's joy of being pregnant.
As Diana is finding delight in every aspect of motherhood, Catriona keeps waiting for the rush of adoration she knows she is supposed to feel, but instead slips into a deep depression. Just as Catriona begins to find her way back to normalcy, one of the babies is kidnapped. Suddenly, all of their lives begin to unravel and intertwine, and none of them will ever be the same.
384 pages, Hardcover
First published March 1, 2015
29 people are currently reading
1219 people want to read
About the author
Amanda Ortlepp
2 books53 followersAmanda Ortlepp's debut novel, Claiming Noah, was published in Australia and New Zealand in 2015. Its ethical dilemmas and emotionally-charged themes struck a chord with mothers and book clubs in particular and it became a bestseller. Claiming Noah was published in the US and Canada in 2016. Amanda's second novel, Running Against the Tide, is set on the remote Eyre Peninsula in South Australia where her father grew up. It was published in Australia and New Zealand in 2016. Amanda lives in Sydney.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 238 reviews
December 16, 2017
Catriona Sinclair had always known how much her husband James wanted to be a father. Her desire to become a mother wasn’t so strong, but with her in her mid-thirties, she decided to have a child with James. After some time trying however, they went the IVF route – her eventual pregnancy made James ecstatic; but Catriona was nervous and scared, especially with how ill she was throughout the pregnancy.
Diana and Liam Simmons had been unable to fall pregnant, and had decided to adopt an embryo – one that successful parents had decided to donate to someone else in need after their own joy of pregnancy. Their delight at immediately falling pregnant – they’d only had the one chance – was obvious to everyone who knew them. When her baby was born, Diana knew she would never know such happiness again.
But Catriona was suffering a deep depression and felt no bond with her baby at all. Her diagnosis of puerperal psychosis, though not as common as post-natal depression, was a shock to her husband, but he vowed to care for their baby while she underwent treatment in the clinic.
When a baby was kidnapped, the police did everything in their power to find the child – but would they find him? Could they find the small, innocent victim before it was too late? The devastation the parents felt spiralled their lives out of control – would the despair ever ease?
Claiming Noah by Aussie author Amanda Ortlepp is an intense look at the trauma suffered when a child is taken – the repercussions to everyone involved and the aftermath of child-birth when things don’t run smoothly. I’m impressed that this is the author’s debut novel, and have no hesitation in recommending this psychological suspense novel to fans of the genre.
Diana and Liam Simmons had been unable to fall pregnant, and had decided to adopt an embryo – one that successful parents had decided to donate to someone else in need after their own joy of pregnancy. Their delight at immediately falling pregnant – they’d only had the one chance – was obvious to everyone who knew them. When her baby was born, Diana knew she would never know such happiness again.
But Catriona was suffering a deep depression and felt no bond with her baby at all. Her diagnosis of puerperal psychosis, though not as common as post-natal depression, was a shock to her husband, but he vowed to care for their baby while she underwent treatment in the clinic.
When a baby was kidnapped, the police did everything in their power to find the child – but would they find him? Could they find the small, innocent victim before it was too late? The devastation the parents felt spiralled their lives out of control – would the despair ever ease?
Claiming Noah by Aussie author Amanda Ortlepp is an intense look at the trauma suffered when a child is taken – the repercussions to everyone involved and the aftermath of child-birth when things don’t run smoothly. I’m impressed that this is the author’s debut novel, and have no hesitation in recommending this psychological suspense novel to fans of the genre.
November 6, 2015
The topic was interesting and what initially drew me to this novel. The story is told from the points of view of two women, Catriona and Diana. After failing to fall pregnant, Catriona and James embark on an IVF program. Despite some heartaches they eventually have a son, Sebastian. The remaining frozen embryo they choose to donate to another childless couple. Diana and Liam are the recipients of this donated embryo. The result is that Diana’s and Liam’s son, Noah is born within weeks of Sebastian. It sounds like everyone has what they want. This turns out not to be the case.
Catriona ends up with postnatal psychosis that leads to her spending time in a psychiatric hospital. Diana meanwhile, suffers what must be every parent’s worst nightmare, when she uncovers the pram to find her baby is missing. Where is Noah? That’s enough of the story to tell you this is an emotive read and I liked the way it was told from the two women’s points of view.
The story raises lots of issues, about IVF, frozen embryos and embryo adoption, parenting, and mental illness. While I appreciated the manner in which these topics were raised and had to keep reading to see how the story was resolved, I did have some problems with the plot. It didn’t hang together completely for me. At times I found it predictable and at other time it left me going, ‘Oh really!’ I found some of the actions of some characters quite bizarre. The male characters were portrayed in an unsympathetic manner for the most part.
Despite those quibbles there was no way I wasn’t going to finish the book. I knew how I thought it should end and also how I anticipated it might. Was the ending was it the right one? That’s something each person will have to decide for themselves. This was a quick read and I was happy to have read it. I just would have liked more complexity from the characters. This is a debut novel so it will be interesting to see what this author writes next.
Catriona ends up with postnatal psychosis that leads to her spending time in a psychiatric hospital. Diana meanwhile, suffers what must be every parent’s worst nightmare, when she uncovers the pram to find her baby is missing. Where is Noah? That’s enough of the story to tell you this is an emotive read and I liked the way it was told from the two women’s points of view.
The story raises lots of issues, about IVF, frozen embryos and embryo adoption, parenting, and mental illness. While I appreciated the manner in which these topics were raised and had to keep reading to see how the story was resolved, I did have some problems with the plot. It didn’t hang together completely for me. At times I found it predictable and at other time it left me going, ‘Oh really!’ I found some of the actions of some characters quite bizarre. The male characters were portrayed in an unsympathetic manner for the most part.
Despite those quibbles there was no way I wasn’t going to finish the book. I knew how I thought it should end and also how I anticipated it might. Was the ending was it the right one? That’s something each person will have to decide for themselves. This was a quick read and I was happy to have read it. I just would have liked more complexity from the characters. This is a debut novel so it will be interesting to see what this author writes next.
December 19, 2021
Claiming Noah by Australian author Amanda Ortlepp is a riveting read which had me hooked right from the start. After reading this book, it’s hard to believe this is a debut novel for this author. An absolute roller coaster ride when it comes to emotions whilst reading this book.
This book covers many issues such as infertility, motherhood and loss all of which are very cleverly entwined together for a fabulous and extremely entertaining read. Highly recommended.
This book covers many issues such as infertility, motherhood and loss all of which are very cleverly entwined together for a fabulous and extremely entertaining read. Highly recommended.
March 3, 2015
Claiming Noah, from debut author Amanda Ortlepp, tugs on the heartstrings, exploring a modern day dilemma raised by fertility treatments which challenges society's ideas of motherhood and family.
Unable to conceive naturally, Catriona and James turn to IVF to create their family but after the failure of two cycles, Catriona, already ambivalent about motherhood, agrees to just one last attempt and when her pregnancy is confirmed, insists the remaining embryo be donated. After a difficult pregnancy and long labour she delivers a son but from the moment Sebastian is placed in her arms she feels a nameless dread, and begins to spiral into postnatal psychosis.
Diana and Liam are excited when they are told a donor embryo is available and thrilled when it takes. Nine months later, Diana gives birth to Noah, and despite the exhaustion that comes with a newborn and Liam's casual indifference, Diana adores her beautiful son and then her world is turned upside down when he is abducted during a moment's inattention.
Almost two years later, while Diana still clings to the hope Noah will be returned to her, Catriona, is happily preparing to celebrate Sebastian's and James' birthday with family and friends... and then comes a knock on the door.
Claiming Noah is a heartrending story that eventually sees the lives of Catriona and Diana intersect. Though I found some parts of the plot to be a little melodramatic, the situation Catriona and Diana find themselves is thought provoking and confronting.
At its core, Claiming Noah is an examination of the legal, moral and ethical issues related to embryo donation and adoption. Ortlepp admits she became fascinated with the topic when she stumbled across it and her research shows. Claiming Noah explores a kind of 'worst case' scenario which develops into an untenable crisis when tragedy strikes.
By choosing to present the alternating viewpoints of Catriona and Diana, the author encourages the reader to explore the complexities of their individual situations. Both women are sympathetic characters, and there are no easy answers to the dilemma Ortlepp has created. As a mother, the heartache of both Catriona and Diana when faced with the loss of their sons is touching.
A story about motherhood, loss, betrayal and love, Claiming Noah is an emotionally charged novel.
January 6, 2015
This is the story of two couples and the pain and heartbreak they go though to become pregnant and then to raise their babies.
Unable to become pregnant, Catriona and James undergo IVF creating several embryos. After two failed attempts, Catriona becomes pregnant and delivers a healthy boy, Sebastian. Early in the pregnancy they decide to donate their last embryo to another infertile couple (surprisingly not waiting until their child is born before making this decision). Diana and Liam, on the list for embryo adoption, become the happy recipients successfully producing baby Noah a month after Sebastian is born.
What should be the start of two happy families rapidly becomes the story of two dysfunctional families. Catriona develops postnatal depression, which morphs into full blown psychosis requiring several weeks in a psychiatric clinic. Curiously, James, despite wanting a child so much before the pregnancy, doesn’t really engage with Sebastian, trotting happily off to work and failing to notice that his wife is more than just a little depressed. Nevertheless, when Catriona returns home from the clinic she finds Sebastian well cared for and with James taking 6 months paternity leave so she can return to work, she finds that she shakes off her negative feelings and becomes a good and loving mother.
In contrast Diana has taken easily to motherhood and loved taking care of Noah. However, one morning in the supermarket when Noah is only two moths old, she finds herself in the middle of every mother’s worst nightmare when Noah goes missing.
What follows is a compelling story of love and loss and the anguish experienced by two mothers as they fight for the right to raise their son. The author explores many facets of motherhood and the controversies surrounding IVF, adoption and the rights of parents and children. Although a champion of mothers, she does not have a lot of sympathy for the men in this novel. The fathers are weak and shady characters who have little empathy for their wives and their sons. Despite seemingly both desperate for a child before their wives become pregnant, neither seems to make much effort to bond with their sons and their feelings about their sons are never clear to us. James shows little sympathy for his wife's problems and Liam is distant, starting an affair soon after his son disappears. Although the writing is not strong and a little patchy in places in this debut novel, the story is simply told and the moral dilemmas faced by both couples will make you stop and think. 3.5★
With thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for a copy of this novel to read and review.
March 7, 2017
For many couples, getting pregnant and having a child is as simple as making the decision to do so. For couples struggling with infertility, however, the desire to have a child often becomes a reality only with in vitro fertilization. When Catriona Sinclair becomes pregnant, she makes it clear to her husband, James, that she is unwilling to go through it again if she miscarries. They still have one remaining embryo, so they decide to let it be 'adopted' by another couple who long to have a baby. Diane and Liam Simmons are the recipients of the Sinclair's remaining embryo.
Both mothers deliver healthy babies, but while Diane easily adapts to motherhood, Catriona struggles to bond with her baby and is overcome with a terrible case of post-partum depression. While she's in the process of recovery, one of the babies is kidnapped, setting into motion a chain of events that further links these two couples, changing all their lives forever.
Claiming Noah is the first novel written by Australian author Amanda Ortlepp. It's always exciting for me to read a new author, and even more so when it's their first book. It makes me feel like I've discovered a wonderful new author before most people were aware of them—which is a lot of fun for me since I'm used to being the one who discovers those authors and their books long after everyone else has already read them.
There's a great deal I want to say about this book, but I can't even allude to things without the risk of giving away details that would spoil key parts of the story. What I can say is Claiming Noah is a very complex story. I found myself continually changing my mind on how I felt about each of the major characters, and they all surprised me by doing or saying something I least expected. The ending was perfection, though not at all how I expected it would end (which is a very good thing). I'm definitely recommending this book to others, and declaring it a Book Worth Reading.
I received an advance review copy of this book courtesy of Netgalley and Center Street in exchange for an honest review.
Both mothers deliver healthy babies, but while Diane easily adapts to motherhood, Catriona struggles to bond with her baby and is overcome with a terrible case of post-partum depression. While she's in the process of recovery, one of the babies is kidnapped, setting into motion a chain of events that further links these two couples, changing all their lives forever.
Claiming Noah is the first novel written by Australian author Amanda Ortlepp. It's always exciting for me to read a new author, and even more so when it's their first book. It makes me feel like I've discovered a wonderful new author before most people were aware of them—which is a lot of fun for me since I'm used to being the one who discovers those authors and their books long after everyone else has already read them.
There's a great deal I want to say about this book, but I can't even allude to things without the risk of giving away details that would spoil key parts of the story. What I can say is Claiming Noah is a very complex story. I found myself continually changing my mind on how I felt about each of the major characters, and they all surprised me by doing or saying something I least expected. The ending was perfection, though not at all how I expected it would end (which is a very good thing). I'm definitely recommending this book to others, and declaring it a Book Worth Reading.
I received an advance review copy of this book courtesy of Netgalley and Center Street in exchange for an honest review.
August 16, 2017
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
3 stars for Claiming Noah. While I thought the overarching story line of Noah was a good one, I felt like the story took way too long to get to that point. At more than 1/2 way through the book, the author still hadn't gotten to the heart of the story, which is claiming Noah.
I found myself skim reading through most of the book, trying to find the meat of the story. It's in there, but it is hidden by a lot of filler.
Overall, I liked the concept of the story and although it was fairly predictable, I did enjoy it for the most part. But I hate it when a book is too long and takes too long to develop. I typically enjoy family dramas, but this one was just "there" for me.
EDIT: As I have been thinking about this some more, I feel that the story may have worked better if it started out with the custody trial over Noah and through testimony and memories, the reader learns the back story. I think my biggest gripe with this book is there was too much time setting up the backstory and not enough time spent on who would get Noah.
3 stars for Claiming Noah. While I thought the overarching story line of Noah was a good one, I felt like the story took way too long to get to that point. At more than 1/2 way through the book, the author still hadn't gotten to the heart of the story, which is claiming Noah.
I found myself skim reading through most of the book, trying to find the meat of the story. It's in there, but it is hidden by a lot of filler.
Overall, I liked the concept of the story and although it was fairly predictable, I did enjoy it for the most part. But I hate it when a book is too long and takes too long to develop. I typically enjoy family dramas, but this one was just "there" for me.
EDIT: As I have been thinking about this some more, I feel that the story may have worked better if it started out with the custody trial over Noah and through testimony and memories, the reader learns the back story. I think my biggest gripe with this book is there was too much time setting up the backstory and not enough time spent on who would get Noah.
April 18, 2022
This one of those stories with a great beginning, but then it went downhill towards the end. This is because each of the characters are problematic in their own way and the author failed (at least for me) to have that "Oh, my, I totally did not see that coming!" Also, there are moments wherein these characters felt flat. How I wished things turned differently and maybe I could have enjoyed this book more.
October 6, 2016
I picked up this book based on the premise of two couples fighting over who are the rightful parents of a young boy who was adopted as an embryo. The write up had a very Picoult-esque vibe to it so I was expecting an emotional legal drama with some twists (and possibly tears) thrown in for good measure.
The book is told from the points of view of the two mothers, Catriona, the embryo donor and Diana, the woman who adopted her son as an embryo and carried him to term. Readers are privy to the inner thoughts of these woman (and a lot of back stories) but unfortunately the men in the book didn't fare so well. They were given hardly any page time except to show the bulk of them as shallow, insensitive and even nefarious.
I loved the premise of the book but there is a overly long and unnecessary build-up to the main issue which isn't addressed until very late in the story arc. I was in it for the suspense but I got a very different kind of read. That said, I applaud the author for bringing various issues including the legal and ethical issues surrounding embryonic adoption, legal rights of adoptive vs biological parents, kidnapping, postpartum psychosis, infertility etc to her readers in varying degrees of depth.
Yet, even with this plethora of important issues the plot remained predictable and the writing lighter and not as engaging as I had expected. It shouldn't be touted as psychological suspense since there is no twits or suspense to be had. Instead, it reads more like a lighter Women's Fiction read with the ending being overly sweet and tied up much too neatly to be believable.
Overall, this was a decent read but not nearly what I had expected in terms of suspense and twists. But if you're looking for a lighter read that delves into some big issues you may enjoy this quick read.
Disclaimer: My sincere thanks to Center Street Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary e-book copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
The book is told from the points of view of the two mothers, Catriona, the embryo donor and Diana, the woman who adopted her son as an embryo and carried him to term. Readers are privy to the inner thoughts of these woman (and a lot of back stories) but unfortunately the men in the book didn't fare so well. They were given hardly any page time except to show the bulk of them as shallow, insensitive and even nefarious.
I loved the premise of the book but there is a overly long and unnecessary build-up to the main issue which isn't addressed until very late in the story arc. I was in it for the suspense but I got a very different kind of read. That said, I applaud the author for bringing various issues including the legal and ethical issues surrounding embryonic adoption, legal rights of adoptive vs biological parents, kidnapping, postpartum psychosis, infertility etc to her readers in varying degrees of depth.
Yet, even with this plethora of important issues the plot remained predictable and the writing lighter and not as engaging as I had expected. It shouldn't be touted as psychological suspense since there is no twits or suspense to be had. Instead, it reads more like a lighter Women's Fiction read with the ending being overly sweet and tied up much too neatly to be believable.
Overall, this was a decent read but not nearly what I had expected in terms of suspense and twists. But if you're looking for a lighter read that delves into some big issues you may enjoy this quick read.
Disclaimer: My sincere thanks to Center Street Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with a complimentary e-book copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
February 26, 2015
Fertility and fertility treatments are subjects fraught with emotion. Sanity is sometimes swept aside without us realising.
It’s brave then, that former marketing professional Amanda Ortlepp delves into the tricky and fertile (sorry!!!) world of embryo adoption in her debut novel, Claiming Noah.
Two babies born only a month apart and with no other players introduced into the mix, it’s not hard to jump to conclusions when one is snatched from his pram.
What follows however, is far from predictable or formulaic. Rather we’re presented with a complex ethical problem. Of sorts. I mean, in my little mind it was mostly a no-brainer… but I can understand the predicament of all involved and it’s obvious there will be no winners.
Complicating things for readers are of course the players themselves.
It’s almost impossible—while reading this novel— not to have an opinion. Or three. On one hand we have the legal system and its version of right and wrong. Then, led by our hearts and emotions, we feel a strong sense of compassion. And finally (well in my case) there’s our gut and what we WANT to happen.
It’s a thought-provoking debut by Ortlepp. (3.5 stars)
Read the (far more exciting) full review on my blog: http://www.debbish.com/books-literatu...
It’s brave then, that former marketing professional Amanda Ortlepp delves into the tricky and fertile (sorry!!!) world of embryo adoption in her debut novel, Claiming Noah.
Two babies born only a month apart and with no other players introduced into the mix, it’s not hard to jump to conclusions when one is snatched from his pram.
What follows however, is far from predictable or formulaic. Rather we’re presented with a complex ethical problem. Of sorts. I mean, in my little mind it was mostly a no-brainer… but I can understand the predicament of all involved and it’s obvious there will be no winners.
Complicating things for readers are of course the players themselves.
It’s almost impossible—while reading this novel— not to have an opinion. Or three. On one hand we have the legal system and its version of right and wrong. Then, led by our hearts and emotions, we feel a strong sense of compassion. And finally (well in my case) there’s our gut and what we WANT to happen.
It’s a thought-provoking debut by Ortlepp. (3.5 stars)
Read the (far more exciting) full review on my blog: http://www.debbish.com/books-literatu...
August 16, 2019
What makes a parent? Is it blood? Or something else? Can an adopted parent be as much a parent as a blood parent?
This book touches on so many issues; betrayal, crime, adoption, custody, forgiveness and the terrible effects of postpartum depression.
James and Catriona are desperate to have children as are Diana and Liam. And finally, through modern science, it happens for both couples. But then tragedy strikes one of the couples and what follows is devastating. An impossible situation. Two couples. One little boy.
How far would you go to get what you want? How far would you go to protect the ones you love? How much should you be expected to forgive?
I could not stop reading. It was so heart wrenching but so engrossing. While my normal favourite genre to read in the last while has been psychological thrillers, I forgot how much I love to read dramatic fiction like this. It kept me spellbound until the very end. It is gut wrenching but such a fantastic read. While I didn’t agree with everything the characters did and a few characters I disliked intently, it didn’t take anything away from the enjoyment of the story.
This was the author’s debut from several years ago, I will be hunting down other works by her.
Thank you to net galley and the publisher for allowing me the privilege of reading and reviewing this book by sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
This book touches on so many issues; betrayal, crime, adoption, custody, forgiveness and the terrible effects of postpartum depression.
James and Catriona are desperate to have children as are Diana and Liam. And finally, through modern science, it happens for both couples. But then tragedy strikes one of the couples and what follows is devastating. An impossible situation. Two couples. One little boy.
How far would you go to get what you want? How far would you go to protect the ones you love? How much should you be expected to forgive?
I could not stop reading. It was so heart wrenching but so engrossing. While my normal favourite genre to read in the last while has been psychological thrillers, I forgot how much I love to read dramatic fiction like this. It kept me spellbound until the very end. It is gut wrenching but such a fantastic read. While I didn’t agree with everything the characters did and a few characters I disliked intently, it didn’t take anything away from the enjoyment of the story.
This was the author’s debut from several years ago, I will be hunting down other works by her.
Thank you to net galley and the publisher for allowing me the privilege of reading and reviewing this book by sending me a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
July 21, 2016
I selected Claiming Noah for review because it had an interesting description, and because NetGalley (where I get most of the books I review) said it was published by Faithwords/Center Street, who also publish authors such as Ted Dekker and Joyce Meyer. Sure, some of their titles are aimed at the general market rather than the Christian market, but I still figured that if Claiming Noah would therefore be written from a Christian perspective even if it was aimed at the general market.
My mistake.
Claiming Noah opened with a quote from The Prophet, which was an indication that it wasn’t Christian fiction. This was soon confirmed by some of the character histories: none of the characters attended church or had any faith to speak of (although they were all Roman Catholic), Catriona and James started trying to get pregnant as soon as they got engaged, James was on probation following a drug conviction, and two of the characters went on to have extra-marital affairs (although there were no on-the-page sex scenes, thank goodness).
But the premise was fascinating.
And I was interested enough in that premise that I still wanted to read Claiming Noah even knowing it wasn’t going to be Christian fiction. As an aside, it also turned out to be that awkward brand of general market fiction where they feature caricatures of Christian characters, in this case, a Roman Catholic priest who seemed to exist only to lecture Diana and Liam on their choice to adopt an embryo. Yes, I understand this is the official position of the Catholic church, but the ethics of embryo adoption wasn’t actually the story so this lecture wasn’t necessary.
Instead of being about the ethics of IVF, embryo adoption or even surrogacy, Claiming Noah was more reminiscent of the biblical story of Solomon and the two babies. Here’s the book description I read on NetGalley:
This riveting debut novel of psychological suspense explores the dilemmas that arise when motherhood and science collide.
Catriona Sinclair has always had a well-developed sense of independence--in fact the one sore point in her otherwise happy marriage is her husband James's desire to take care of her. As she's often tried to explain to him, she took care of herself before she met him, and did a good job of it. But James has been especially attentive lately as they struggle to have a baby. They succeed at last through in vitro fertilization, but unwilling to risk the heartbreak of another miscarriage, they decide to make their "spare" frozen embryo available to another family.
Diana and Liam Simmons are desperate for a child. Unable to conceive, they are overjoyed to learn that as the closest genetic match to the Sinclairs they are the recipients of the embryo donation. Diana's only concern is her mother's disapproval of IVF, but any doubts raised are quickly eclipsed by Diana's joy of being pregnant.
As Diana is finding delight in every aspect of motherhood, Catriona keeps waiting for the rush of adoration she knows she is supposed to feel, but instead slips into a deep depression. Just as Catriona begins to find her way back to normalcy, one of the babies is kidnapped. Suddenly, all of their lives begin to unravel and intertwine, and none of them will ever be the same.
And here’s the description from Amazon:
Catriona and James are desperate for children, and embark on an IVF program. After a gruelling round of treatments, Catriona finally falls pregnant, and they donate their remaining embryo anonymously.
Diana and Liam are on a waiting list to receive an embryo. Sooner than expected, they are thrilled to discover one is available.
After a difficult pregnancy, Catriona gives birth to Sebastian. But severe postnatal depression affects her badly, and quickly turns into deadly psychosis. For her protection and her baby’s, she’s admitted into psychiatric care. When she comes home, she again struggles to bond with her baby, but gradually life finds its own rhythm.
Meanwhile, Diana has given birth to a beautiful little boy, Noah. But when he is two months old Noah is abducted … and Diana and Liam’s nightmare begins.
Where is Noah?
The NetGalley book description should have given me one big clue about the book, a clue that’s only emphasized by the adverb-laden Amazon description:
The writing isn’t up to the standard I expect from major publishers.
Claiming Noah is full of interior monologue and back story, most of which is telling the reader about something that happened instead of showing us in real time. The characterization is patchy: while Catriona (the biological mother) and Diana (the adoptive mother) are both solid characters, the minor characters need work, especially the men. The only male characters who don’t come across as self-absorbed and shallow were the gay couple. In Catriona’s case, I would have liked to have better understood her descent into postpartum psychosis.
My other issue with the writing was around the setting:
Claiming Noah is set in Sydney, yet there is nothing uniquely Australian about it—it could be set in any English-speaking city near a beach. I’m not sure who is responsible for this: I’ve now found out it was published by Simon & Schuster Australia in 2015, while the version I read is the 2016 American release. Did the Australian version have mom and takeout? Or fish and French fries on the beach? Or have those been changed for the American audience?
And the plot got predictable.
The biggest surprise was Noah’s kidnapping, which wouldn't be a surprise at all if you'd read the book description (I'd read it, but forgotten). The answer to "Where is Noah?" was even more obvious. The main plot points were all in the right places and while everything seemed to make sense, there were a couple of instances where the novel went back in time as it switched between Diana and Catriona’s points of view. This was both a little confusing, and ruined the suspense.
Overall, while Claiming Noah had great potential to be a psychological thriller along the lines of Jodi Picoult, the pedestrian writing and predictable plot elements meant it was merely okay, at least for me.
Thanks to NetGalley and Center Street for providing a free ebook for review.
My mistake.
Claiming Noah opened with a quote from The Prophet, which was an indication that it wasn’t Christian fiction. This was soon confirmed by some of the character histories: none of the characters attended church or had any faith to speak of (although they were all Roman Catholic), Catriona and James started trying to get pregnant as soon as they got engaged, James was on probation following a drug conviction, and two of the characters went on to have extra-marital affairs (although there were no on-the-page sex scenes, thank goodness).
But the premise was fascinating.
And I was interested enough in that premise that I still wanted to read Claiming Noah even knowing it wasn’t going to be Christian fiction. As an aside, it also turned out to be that awkward brand of general market fiction where they feature caricatures of Christian characters, in this case, a Roman Catholic priest who seemed to exist only to lecture Diana and Liam on their choice to adopt an embryo. Yes, I understand this is the official position of the Catholic church, but the ethics of embryo adoption wasn’t actually the story so this lecture wasn’t necessary.
Instead of being about the ethics of IVF, embryo adoption or even surrogacy, Claiming Noah was more reminiscent of the biblical story of Solomon and the two babies. Here’s the book description I read on NetGalley:
This riveting debut novel of psychological suspense explores the dilemmas that arise when motherhood and science collide.
Catriona Sinclair has always had a well-developed sense of independence--in fact the one sore point in her otherwise happy marriage is her husband James's desire to take care of her. As she's often tried to explain to him, she took care of herself before she met him, and did a good job of it. But James has been especially attentive lately as they struggle to have a baby. They succeed at last through in vitro fertilization, but unwilling to risk the heartbreak of another miscarriage, they decide to make their "spare" frozen embryo available to another family.
Diana and Liam Simmons are desperate for a child. Unable to conceive, they are overjoyed to learn that as the closest genetic match to the Sinclairs they are the recipients of the embryo donation. Diana's only concern is her mother's disapproval of IVF, but any doubts raised are quickly eclipsed by Diana's joy of being pregnant.
As Diana is finding delight in every aspect of motherhood, Catriona keeps waiting for the rush of adoration she knows she is supposed to feel, but instead slips into a deep depression. Just as Catriona begins to find her way back to normalcy, one of the babies is kidnapped. Suddenly, all of their lives begin to unravel and intertwine, and none of them will ever be the same.
And here’s the description from Amazon:
Catriona and James are desperate for children, and embark on an IVF program. After a gruelling round of treatments, Catriona finally falls pregnant, and they donate their remaining embryo anonymously.
Diana and Liam are on a waiting list to receive an embryo. Sooner than expected, they are thrilled to discover one is available.
After a difficult pregnancy, Catriona gives birth to Sebastian. But severe postnatal depression affects her badly, and quickly turns into deadly psychosis. For her protection and her baby’s, she’s admitted into psychiatric care. When she comes home, she again struggles to bond with her baby, but gradually life finds its own rhythm.
Meanwhile, Diana has given birth to a beautiful little boy, Noah. But when he is two months old Noah is abducted … and Diana and Liam’s nightmare begins.
Where is Noah?
The NetGalley book description should have given me one big clue about the book, a clue that’s only emphasized by the adverb-laden Amazon description:
The writing isn’t up to the standard I expect from major publishers.
Claiming Noah is full of interior monologue and back story, most of which is telling the reader about something that happened instead of showing us in real time. The characterization is patchy: while Catriona (the biological mother) and Diana (the adoptive mother) are both solid characters, the minor characters need work, especially the men. The only male characters who don’t come across as self-absorbed and shallow were the gay couple. In Catriona’s case, I would have liked to have better understood her descent into postpartum psychosis.
My other issue with the writing was around the setting:
Claiming Noah is set in Sydney, yet there is nothing uniquely Australian about it—it could be set in any English-speaking city near a beach. I’m not sure who is responsible for this: I’ve now found out it was published by Simon & Schuster Australia in 2015, while the version I read is the 2016 American release. Did the Australian version have mom and takeout? Or fish and French fries on the beach? Or have those been changed for the American audience?
And the plot got predictable.
The biggest surprise was Noah’s kidnapping, which wouldn't be a surprise at all if you'd read the book description (I'd read it, but forgotten). The answer to "Where is Noah?" was even more obvious. The main plot points were all in the right places and while everything seemed to make sense, there were a couple of instances where the novel went back in time as it switched between Diana and Catriona’s points of view. This was both a little confusing, and ruined the suspense.
Overall, while Claiming Noah had great potential to be a psychological thriller along the lines of Jodi Picoult, the pedestrian writing and predictable plot elements meant it was merely okay, at least for me.
Thanks to NetGalley and Center Street for providing a free ebook for review.
August 30, 2016
This review, and many more, was originally posted on 125pages.com
Claiming Noah by Amanda Ortlepp is an interesting look at adoption. It focuses on embryo adoption which I have heard of but is a totally new book plot line for me. We meet Catriona and James who have just undergone IVF. Faced with the decision of what to do with the remaining frozen embryos, they decide on adoption. Diana and Liam, who are desperate for a child, then find out about this way of starting a family and end up with the remaining embryo. Life is blissful for both couples until a medical issue and then a kidnapping occur. Both families are left in shock and their lives will be forever altered.
I enjoyed the plot of Claiming Noah as I found it very unique. It weaved postpartum depression, embryo adoption, kidnapping and more into one clear tale. The writing of Amanda Ortlepp really made this story, as it could have been very convoluted with all of the different plot points. It was instead well paced and was very emotionally nuanced. I did not love any of the characters fully, as I found them somewhat over the top, but I still enjoyed their actions. There were a few bits at the very end that turned me off as I could not justify the decisions made, but that is just my personal take.
Claiming Noah was a very interesting read. It tackled a fresh topic and contained enough twists to be very engaging. This was Amanda Ortlepp's debut and I was very impressed with it. I loved the way she was able to merge so many different aspects and make them feel like one cohesive story. I polished this off in two sittings and while I knew what was going on for the most part, there were enough surprises to keep me on my toes.
Favorite lines - You don’t have a child. You don’t know what it feels like to have someone steal your heart. You don’t spend every waking moment wondering whether the person you care most about in the world is even alive.
Biggest cliché - A baby will make everything perfect.
Have you read Claiming Noah, or added it to your TBR?
Enter to win my ARC from BEA of Claiming Noah. Giveaway is open till 11:59 pm MST August 15, 2016 US only.
a Rafflecopter giveaway
This book was most likely received free from the publisher/author in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Claiming Noah by Amanda Ortlepp is an interesting look at adoption. It focuses on embryo adoption which I have heard of but is a totally new book plot line for me. We meet Catriona and James who have just undergone IVF. Faced with the decision of what to do with the remaining frozen embryos, they decide on adoption. Diana and Liam, who are desperate for a child, then find out about this way of starting a family and end up with the remaining embryo. Life is blissful for both couples until a medical issue and then a kidnapping occur. Both families are left in shock and their lives will be forever altered.I enjoyed the plot of Claiming Noah as I found it very unique. It weaved postpartum depression, embryo adoption, kidnapping and more into one clear tale. The writing of Amanda Ortlepp really made this story, as it could have been very convoluted with all of the different plot points. It was instead well paced and was very emotionally nuanced. I did not love any of the characters fully, as I found them somewhat over the top, but I still enjoyed their actions. There were a few bits at the very end that turned me off as I could not justify the decisions made, but that is just my personal take.
Claiming Noah was a very interesting read. It tackled a fresh topic and contained enough twists to be very engaging. This was Amanda Ortlepp's debut and I was very impressed with it. I loved the way she was able to merge so many different aspects and make them feel like one cohesive story. I polished this off in two sittings and while I knew what was going on for the most part, there were enough surprises to keep me on my toes.
Favorite lines - You don’t have a child. You don’t know what it feels like to have someone steal your heart. You don’t spend every waking moment wondering whether the person you care most about in the world is even alive.
Biggest cliché - A baby will make everything perfect.
Have you read Claiming Noah, or added it to your TBR?
Enter to win my ARC from BEA of Claiming Noah. Giveaway is open till 11:59 pm MST August 15, 2016 US only.
a Rafflecopter giveaway
This book was most likely received free from the publisher/author in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
February 27, 2015
In Claiming Noah, Ortlepp creates a very Solomon-esque story in a contemporary setting, and teases it out to a tense and satisfying conclusion. Her point-of-view characters are Catriona, the donor mum, and Diana, who adopts Catriona’s embryo; both are sympathetic characters who go through a very rough time and deserve better. They have problems with husbands, newborns and adjusting to dramatic changes in their life circumstances; both suffer tragedy and deception which cause them heartache and take them to the brink.
At times when reading I found myself pulled out of the story thinking, She wouldn’t do that. Why doesn’t she…? But it’s a credit to Ortlepp that she is able to bring her characters to life so well that I began think I knew them!
Claiming Noah is billed as a thriller, but I think it’s more mainstream than that: I wouldn’t put the “thrills” at much more than you’d find in suspense (which is fine by me). There’s nothing externally life-threatening in this story; the life challenges, when they come, stem from the characters’ inner worlds, and the impact of external events on their psychological and mental health, which is only ever really severely tested for Catriona.
I read the novel over a few days and it kept me engaged – rather than “hooked” – for that time. (Considering I also had a lot going on with my own release, that’s no mean feat.) The moral dilemmas the novel presents are interesting, even if the references to the Catholic church’s influence seem a little dated. The ethical issues the story raises deserve to be explored. And what better way to explore them than in entertaining fiction?
A longer version of this review appeared on my blog.
At times when reading I found myself pulled out of the story thinking, She wouldn’t do that. Why doesn’t she…? But it’s a credit to Ortlepp that she is able to bring her characters to life so well that I began think I knew them!
Claiming Noah is billed as a thriller, but I think it’s more mainstream than that: I wouldn’t put the “thrills” at much more than you’d find in suspense (which is fine by me). There’s nothing externally life-threatening in this story; the life challenges, when they come, stem from the characters’ inner worlds, and the impact of external events on their psychological and mental health, which is only ever really severely tested for Catriona.
I read the novel over a few days and it kept me engaged – rather than “hooked” – for that time. (Considering I also had a lot going on with my own release, that’s no mean feat.) The moral dilemmas the novel presents are interesting, even if the references to the Catholic church’s influence seem a little dated. The ethical issues the story raises deserve to be explored. And what better way to explore them than in entertaining fiction?
A longer version of this review appeared on my blog.
July 26, 2016
Many here have already given enough detail. The only purpose to my adding a review is to comment that in my opinion you shouldn't even bother. I have a 100 page rule. If the book has not interested me by 100 pages I put it away and call it a day. This one held my interest enough but never really got to the "meat" of the story until about two thirds of the way into it.
The concept of adopting an embryo was the "hook" for me.
That wasn't enough though to give it more than a "3" rating. Suggestion is to move on to another title and not waste your time.
The concept of adopting an embryo was the "hook" for me.
That wasn't enough though to give it more than a "3" rating. Suggestion is to move on to another title and not waste your time.
April 10, 2019
Another entertaining read. It's a cross between a chick-lit and a thriller that brings out the psychological / ethical/ moral dilemma. So it feels like reading the lighter version of Jodi Picoult's books. It was impossible to put down!
January 16, 2019
A thought provoking and sad but engrossing story. It's hard to put down - I read it in one day.
January 5, 2022
Empty characters
September 2, 2023
If I could do half stars on here, this would be 4.5 stars. I really liked this book.
Told in third person, the story focuses on two women struggling to conceive and start their families with the chapters generally alternating between the two of them. Catriona and her husband, James, have used IVF and created four embryos. When the third one takes, they opt to donate the fourth - to the benefit of Diana and Liam, also struggling to conceive but unable to have their own embryos created. Both pregnancies are successful, and both families look set for happy futures - until one mother encounters .
The remainder of this review will be spoiler-heavy, so I will say as a general that I loved both of these mothers and it made the ending difficult - though no option would have been easy. By the time I reached the final few chapters, I couldn't help but think of the Baby M case and its impact on surrogacy. I did like the epilogue and the message it had about families and non-traditional and non-biological aspects of those relationships.
Told in third person, the story focuses on two women struggling to conceive and start their families with the chapters generally alternating between the two of them. Catriona and her husband, James, have used IVF and created four embryos. When the third one takes, they opt to donate the fourth - to the benefit of Diana and Liam, also struggling to conceive but unable to have their own embryos created. Both pregnancies are successful, and both families look set for happy futures - until one mother encounters .
The remainder of this review will be spoiler-heavy, so I will say as a general that I loved both of these mothers and it made the ending difficult - though no option would have been easy. By the time I reached the final few chapters, I couldn't help but think of the Baby M case and its impact on surrogacy. I did like the epilogue and the message it had about families and non-traditional and non-biological aspects of those relationships.
May 27, 2020
The rise in popularity of IVF has resulted in hundreds of thousands of excess embryos stored in cryogenic units around the world. The parents of these embryos have to decide at some point whether to donate the embryos to another couple, allow them to be used for scientific research, destroy them, or keep them frozen until they eventually become unviable. What would you do if you were faced with this decision? This is the quandary around which Noah’s narrative is constructed. Reminiscent of the ancient Solomonic judgment between two prostitutes in 1 Kings 3:16-28, Claiming Noah brings to court the definition of motherhood, in which the reader is the judge:
“My name is Catriona Sinclair. I filed the application for custody of Noah Edmond Simmons because I feel I’m the best person to provide him with the love and care he deserves...I have a successful and stable career that provides me with the means to be able to provide Noah with a comfortable life, and I have the support of my family and friends to help me raise him in a loving environment...I am Noah’s mother, and the most appropriate home for him is with me.”
“My husband and I were thrilled when we found out we were pregnant. And even though the pregnancy was a result of an embryo donation rather than a natural conception we never felt that the baby was any less our own child than if we had been able to become pregnant naturally. We fell in love with Noah well before he was born and then even more so once he arrived...I am Noah’s mother. I legally adopted him as an embryo, I carried him inside me, I gave birth to him and I love him more than I can possibly describe to you. My husband and I are good people, and good parents, and we deserve to be able to live the happy family life that we were denied for so long.”
“It’s rare to see a case such as this one where both parties appear to be loving, capable and responsible parents, and I would feel confident to leave the child with either party. But a decision has to be made, as unenviable as it may be.”
Claiming Noah is a tale of two mothers Catriona, Noah’s biological mother who struggles with postpartum puerperal psychosis and ends up in a mental facility after nearly drowning their son, and Dianna, Noah’s birth mother, who nearly loses her mind with grief while pursuing their son’s kidnapper. It is a tale of two fathers James, who is indicted for kidnapping his genetic son after their first son dies of SIDS, and Liam, who fights for custody of his legal son while controlling and cheating on his wife Dianna. While situated in Sydney, Australia, its ethical dilemmas and emotionally charged themes resonate with the universal maternal heart. Claim your copy of Claiming Noah today.
“My name is Catriona Sinclair. I filed the application for custody of Noah Edmond Simmons because I feel I’m the best person to provide him with the love and care he deserves...I have a successful and stable career that provides me with the means to be able to provide Noah with a comfortable life, and I have the support of my family and friends to help me raise him in a loving environment...I am Noah’s mother, and the most appropriate home for him is with me.”
“My husband and I were thrilled when we found out we were pregnant. And even though the pregnancy was a result of an embryo donation rather than a natural conception we never felt that the baby was any less our own child than if we had been able to become pregnant naturally. We fell in love with Noah well before he was born and then even more so once he arrived...I am Noah’s mother. I legally adopted him as an embryo, I carried him inside me, I gave birth to him and I love him more than I can possibly describe to you. My husband and I are good people, and good parents, and we deserve to be able to live the happy family life that we were denied for so long.”
“It’s rare to see a case such as this one where both parties appear to be loving, capable and responsible parents, and I would feel confident to leave the child with either party. But a decision has to be made, as unenviable as it may be.”
Claiming Noah is a tale of two mothers Catriona, Noah’s biological mother who struggles with postpartum puerperal psychosis and ends up in a mental facility after nearly drowning their son, and Dianna, Noah’s birth mother, who nearly loses her mind with grief while pursuing their son’s kidnapper. It is a tale of two fathers James, who is indicted for kidnapping his genetic son after their first son dies of SIDS, and Liam, who fights for custody of his legal son while controlling and cheating on his wife Dianna. While situated in Sydney, Australia, its ethical dilemmas and emotionally charged themes resonate with the universal maternal heart. Claim your copy of Claiming Noah today.
January 13, 2017
Desire for a child is at the heart of Claiming Noah, and two couples in pursuit of baby love find themselves in a heartbreaking situation.
James and Catriona Sinclair, living in Sydney, Australia, go through IVF to achieve their goal, and after a couple of miscarriages, they finally reach full term with their son Sebastian. An extra embryo has been set aside, and the couple decide to donate it. Neither wants to risk losing the one remaining embryo through miscarriage.
Liam and Diana Simmons have also had no luck in achieving parenthood, and when their doctor suggests implanting a donor embryo, they have some misgivings. But they finally decide to go for it. Diana becomes pregnant and carries to term, giving birth to Noah.
Life does not go well for either couple, though. Catriona suffers from postpartum psychosis and is hospitalized, and upon her return home, she does not readily bond with Sebastian. She thinks he seems different than he was before, although she cannot pinpoint exactly what is troubling her about him. However a couple of months have gone by, so she puts her feelings down to the separation.
Meanwhile, Diana and Liam are having marital difficulties, with their relationship skidding toward even greater challenges. Then one day, as Diana and Noah go shopping, something happens…and their lives are also upended. In the aftermath, Liam expresses a distinctly cruel side, and the two are living parallel lives. Liam blames Diana, and she blames herself.
To avoid spoilers, I will say no more about the plot, except that what actually unfolds might surprise you. I had some of it figured out right away, but I still enjoyed watching it all reach a conclusion…and then was surprised by the epilogue that gave a peek into the future. I enjoyed this book, although the support characters were flat…and sometimes I didn’t really get a sense of who James was, except through occasional glimpses from the perspectives of others. Liam was a bully, but any other characteristics were also hard to see. Catriona and Diana were drawn in greater detail, and I rooted for them both. 4 stars.
James and Catriona Sinclair, living in Sydney, Australia, go through IVF to achieve their goal, and after a couple of miscarriages, they finally reach full term with their son Sebastian. An extra embryo has been set aside, and the couple decide to donate it. Neither wants to risk losing the one remaining embryo through miscarriage.
Liam and Diana Simmons have also had no luck in achieving parenthood, and when their doctor suggests implanting a donor embryo, they have some misgivings. But they finally decide to go for it. Diana becomes pregnant and carries to term, giving birth to Noah.
Life does not go well for either couple, though. Catriona suffers from postpartum psychosis and is hospitalized, and upon her return home, she does not readily bond with Sebastian. She thinks he seems different than he was before, although she cannot pinpoint exactly what is troubling her about him. However a couple of months have gone by, so she puts her feelings down to the separation.
Meanwhile, Diana and Liam are having marital difficulties, with their relationship skidding toward even greater challenges. Then one day, as Diana and Noah go shopping, something happens…and their lives are also upended. In the aftermath, Liam expresses a distinctly cruel side, and the two are living parallel lives. Liam blames Diana, and she blames herself.
To avoid spoilers, I will say no more about the plot, except that what actually unfolds might surprise you. I had some of it figured out right away, but I still enjoyed watching it all reach a conclusion…and then was surprised by the epilogue that gave a peek into the future. I enjoyed this book, although the support characters were flat…and sometimes I didn’t really get a sense of who James was, except through occasional glimpses from the perspectives of others. Liam was a bully, but any other characteristics were also hard to see. Catriona and Diana were drawn in greater detail, and I rooted for them both. 4 stars.
September 7, 2016
I recall years ago, when I was a teenager in the 1970's about the first test-tube baby as it was called then. It was a huge ethical dilemma in that time period. Today, IVF and other similar methods to have a child are commonplace for couples with infertility. Catriona and James find themselves in the throws of infertility while Diana and Liam are also struggling through infertility as well. Postpartum depression turns into postpartum psychosis and Catriona and Sebastian are in danger of her own behaviors. Diana has a baby using a donated egg, but the nightmare of all nightmares occurs when Noah is kidnapped in his stroller while grocery shopping with his mother. Liam blames Diana for not watching Noah closely enough and allowing the kidnapping to take place. The paths of the two couples begin to cross in ways neither of them ever dreamed possible.
I don't want to spoil the book for readers and it would be easy to do if I continue describing the plot. I really was enthralled with this book and just couldn't wait to get back to reading it. One part seemed very farfetched to me concerning Sebastian a few days after his mother entered a psychiatric hospital for treatment of her postpartum psychosis. This book is well-written and does not rely on cursing and sex to sell the book.
I rated this book 5 stars and think readers should check out this debut novel of Amanda Ortlepp.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
I don't want to spoil the book for readers and it would be easy to do if I continue describing the plot. I really was enthralled with this book and just couldn't wait to get back to reading it. One part seemed very farfetched to me concerning Sebastian a few days after his mother entered a psychiatric hospital for treatment of her postpartum psychosis. This book is well-written and does not rely on cursing and sex to sell the book.
I rated this book 5 stars and think readers should check out this debut novel of Amanda Ortlepp.
I received a copy of this book from netgalley in exchange for my honest review.
July 23, 2016
Title: Claiming Noah
Author: Amanda Ortlepp
Publisher: Faithworks/Center Street
Reviewed By: Arlena Dean
Rating: Five
Review:
"Claiming Noah" 'by Amanda Ortlepp
My Thoughts...
First of all I would like to say 'Thank you to NetGalley for providing me an exchange of this book for an honest review.' I will say this was quite a hard read and even though it looks like everything did turn out OK it was still a difficult emotional read for me that dealt with what can happen with embryo donation. This story will involve: 'post natal depression, fertility issues including IVF, embryo adoption, religious issues, with ethical legal and oral issues, death, suicide thoughts, that will be a issue to all of the one's involved.' See, we have two families that will be using this IVF and wow what will happen from the aftermath of their choices they make. Be ready for many 'manipulation, twist and turns, secrets and lies' that will have you shaking your head and saying REALLY...I definitely didn't see that coming!
What we have are two women who will be connected by an embryo, Be ready for some interesting characters [Catriona, James, Diana & Liam] to name a few that will keep you turning the pages till the end. I found it all quite interesting read how this author was able to merge these two couples together with each having their own set of problems. I also loved how this author was able to bring out what a person can go through when suffering through post-partum psychosis.
I don't want to tell too much of this well written and intriguing plot with an exceptional epilogue other than saying please pick up the read and see for yourself how well this novel has been presented to see who will get Noah in the end. I would definitely recommend "Claiming Noah" to you as a good read.
November 7, 2016
I could not stop reading this book. I was riveted from the beginning until the ending. Although, I can tell you that I had this whole story figured out before the dynamics of story changed. Yet, I was not disappointed my how the turn of events played out including the ending. The struggles that Catriona are real. I have never experienced them as I have not had a child but I know that my sister has struggled with post-partum depression; luckily not as severe as Catriona. People need to realized that child birth is not just sunshine and rainbows but does affect a women's chemical hormone balance.
Not, to take anything away from Diana. I applaud her as people who open their hearts and homes to adopt in any form are heroes. Their needs to be more people to do this as their are a lot of children in this world that need love.
Ok, back to the story, I dare you not to have an emotional connection towards Catriona, Diana, and Noah. Claiming Noah is a strong showing for a first novel from author, Amanda Ortlepp. I can't wait to see what she comes out with next.
Not, to take anything away from Diana. I applaud her as people who open their hearts and homes to adopt in any form are heroes. Their needs to be more people to do this as their are a lot of children in this world that need love.
Ok, back to the story, I dare you not to have an emotional connection towards Catriona, Diana, and Noah. Claiming Noah is a strong showing for a first novel from author, Amanda Ortlepp. I can't wait to see what she comes out with next.
March 23, 2015
My View:
An interesting look at post-natal depression, fertility issues including IVF, focussing on embryo adoption and the religious, ethical, legal and moral responsibilities of all parties concerned. Infertility is an issue that is becoming increasing prevalent in our modern society (or is it just becoming better known, I don’t have the research or stats to assess myself but am judging by recent social media attention to the topic) – and it is a very emotional topic. Silence can be isolating. Fertility issues can challenge our perspective of self. And then there is the discussion about the pressure to be a “perfect mother.” I am optimistic that this narrative will open up the kinds of discussions that need to be had.
A thought provoking debut novel.
This read is perfect for book clubs - it is rich in material for debate and discussion and is simultaneously poignant and evocative.
May 20, 2015
Ortlepp writes with touching emotional accuracy about the bond between mother and child, and this is ultimately the question the book poses – what is it that makes a mother?
The ethics of embryo donation will provide interesting fodder for book club discussions but the question of whether a mother is defined by her genetic connection to a child, or her love for it, is perhaps a more interesting one.
While Claiming Noah is written as a piece of realist fiction, some of the contrivances do stretch the bounds of credibility. But I am willing to forgive this because the book made me do something I don’t ordinarily do in book – and that’s – to cry. And isn’t that, after all, what reading is all about – to feel something, deeply?
For the full review - http://bookbirdy.com/2015/05/20/revie...
The ethics of embryo donation will provide interesting fodder for book club discussions but the question of whether a mother is defined by her genetic connection to a child, or her love for it, is perhaps a more interesting one.
While Claiming Noah is written as a piece of realist fiction, some of the contrivances do stretch the bounds of credibility. But I am willing to forgive this because the book made me do something I don’t ordinarily do in book – and that’s – to cry. And isn’t that, after all, what reading is all about – to feel something, deeply?
For the full review - http://bookbirdy.com/2015/05/20/revie...
September 9, 2016
I thank NetGalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. It is so much fun getting a book from a new author and will be definitely looking for more from this author, Amanda Otlepp. This book deals with many issues that women face today when dealing with infertility. It also tells of the struggles of postnatal depression. Two couples in this story are unable to become pregnant. Catriona and James decide on IVF and Diana and Liam decide on an embryo donation. The story unfolds from these decisions. The ethics of embryo donation are addressed and the question of whether a mother is defined by her genetic connection to a child or her love for it is to be questioned and debated. This book tugged at me emotionally. I felt for both Catriona and Diana and the circumstances they find themselves in. I highly recommend this emotionally charged book.
March 26, 2015
For some falling, pregnant and bringing a new life into the world is easy. For others, the daily struggle of gruelling IVF treatments fraught with physical and emotional pain is an overwhelming reality. Claiming Noah tackles the issue of two couples struggles to fall pregnant, two genetically related babies are born 1 month apart, into very different circumstances, this book has many ethical questions. What would you do in the situations that unfold that these families face, how would you react loosing a child, knowing you had a living child who was genetically but not legally yours? This book provokes the thought process. I thoroughly enjoyed it and read it in one day.
August 23, 2016
It was a roller coaster of a ride that kept me up all night. It's told by 2 women who suffer from infertility and use IVF to have children. There are lots of twists and turns and by the time I finished the book it brought tears to my eyes. It's one of those books which will have you thinking what you would have done in their shoes. Adding to my favorites shelf.
September 16, 2016
I was intrigued by the concept of this book, but the execution ended up being poor. This felt like more of a soap opera plot than a well thought out novel, and it lacked character development and complexity. I felt like this was an attempt to emulate Jodi Picoult's style, but fell flat.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 238 reviews