This is my second Amy Cross book and I liked it a lot, but ultimately, I have to rate this one a 4 for me. The other book was The Spider .
I like that The Lighthouse starts out with a very creepy, atmospheric mystery with just enough gruesomeness to tell me I was in the right place reading this one.
The story is a pair of storylines involving the main character, Penny. Penny has just graduated from college in Britain, so she’s finished up at “uni” and she and her housemates are facing the daunting task of making their way into the “real world.” For all of them, it’s a pretty grim prospect. There are loans involved. Jobs are scarce and the courses of study chosen because they would be enlightening aren’t exactly transferrable to job market needs. The housemates are looking at taking more loans in order to live, whilst also living back with their parents while they take unpaid internships (the thought of companies/employers doing this to people makes me see red – grrr) in the hopes of getting their foot in the door. All very daunting and Cross gets that point across quite nice.
But Penny is different. She refuses to follow what has become the norm in all too many cases. She holds out and gets a “real” job that pays her money. There’s a personal situation or two that helps drive that decision, but I’m not going to give it away. But she gets hired to work as a lighthouse keeper. It sounds like a grand adventure. And I must confess, there is a part of that that does most certainly sound quite intriguing.
Anyway, the two storylines are first the weeks after graduating and leading up to the lighthouse and second, her arrival at the lighthouse, where she meets two teammates, Matthew and Colin. The chapters switch back and forth between the two timelines. Fortunately, there is a tag-line at the start of each chapter and it orients you as to which timeline you are reading. But the post-graduation timeline gets smaller and eventually, toward the climax of the book, the two merge. Quite satisfyingly I must say. But if jumping back and forth in time isn’t your thing, that might bug you here. I personally thought Cross handled that pretty well.
There’s also an unreliable narrator issue with Penny. That might bother some, too, but again, I thought Cross handled that storytelling technique quite well too. And she doesn’t hit you over the head with it or make it over the top. I actually did not find it confusing, if that helps.
I liked the story a lot and the interaction with the three characters. There are twists and turns and little mini-mysteries throughout. The ending was a great turn of events and made it creepy and scary.
However… there were elements in which I thought the ending kind of fell apart. I can’t really say much more without spoilers, but I detected plot holes and issues that, after the climax, left he thinking that there were narrative elements that were implausible and worse, did not give me enough explanation. This probably would have been five stars for me, but for the elements of the ending I found lacking. But that in no way means I didn’t like the book. I did. (My favorite book of all time has an ending that I absolutely do NOT like, so I can look past that if I like the rest of the story. Which I did here.