What do you think?
Rate this book
Rumours & Recklessness: A Pride and Prejudice Variation
Fitzwilliam Darcy is desperate. Finally confronted with a woman who ignites all his hopes, he agonizes over the cruel trick of fate which placed her in a situation beneath his notice. The morning after the Netherfield ball, he resolves to put as much distance between himself and her as possible. That very morning, however, Elizabeth's future is jeopardized by her father's untimely accident. With Mr Bennet unconscious and surrounded by concerned neighbors, Mr Collins presses his suit. Elizabeth's mother frantically demands her acceptance to secure the familiy's welfare. With so many witnesses to his proposal and everyone expecting her to make a practical choice, Elizabeth's reputation hangs in the balance. Without her father to defend her refusal of Mr Collins, there is no one to speak up for her... except the last man in the world she would ever marry.
382 pages, Paperback
First published October 13, 2015
460 people are currently reading
684 people want to read
About the author
Nicole Clarkston
28 books211 followersNicole Clarkston is a book lover and a happily married mom of three. Originally from Idaho, she now lives in Oregon with her own romantic hero, three kids who are taller than she is, and one very fat dog.
Nicole can be reached through Facebook at http://fb.me/NicoleClarkstonAuthor, Twitter @N_Clarkston, her blog at Goodreads.com, or her personal blog and website, NicoleClarkson.com.
Nicole can be reached through Facebook at http://fb.me/NicoleClarkstonAuthor, Twitter @N_Clarkston, her blog at Goodreads.com, or her personal blog and website, NicoleClarkson.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews
October 21, 2017
It's Kindle freebie romance time again, and this one comes in the form of Pride and Prejudice fan fiction. Here we have the plot veering from P&P early in the book, just before Darcy and the Bingleys are about to leave Netherfield. Before they leave, Darcy meets Mr Bennet while they're out riding horses early one morning, and they get to know each other a little better. Mr Bennet can tell that Darcy is fighting feelings for Elizabeth, but doesn't expect anything to come of it.
The tipping point, and where this variation really starts to diverge from the original story: Mr Bennet has a fall from his horse on his way back home. While he's lying in bed at home, in a coma, family and neighbors gather to wring their hands (in some cases) and offer help (in others), including Mr Collins, Darcy and Bingley. Collins takes advantage of the situation by publicly offering marriage to Lizzy. She rejects him in horror, but with her mother and Collins putting pressure on her to accept and her father not able to counteract them, the situation is getting fraught. Darcy surprises himself, not to mention astounding everyone in the room (and the whole town, once word spreads), by insisting that Lizzy can't marry Collins because ... she's already engaged to him. Jaws practically bounce off the floor.
The problem: Lizzy, at this point in their relationship, really doesn't like Darcy. His private explanation to her later (echoing an actual scene in P&P) does absolutely nothing to help his case.
So parts of this novel were really engaging, if you're into P&P fanfic at all. There's some worthwhile dialogue and developments that vary enough from the original story to make it enjoyable reading, if a little slow at times.
The problems are that (like so much other Austen fanfic and Regency romances generally) the author is either unaware of or ignores Regency manners and ways when it suits her. **Going to get slightly spoilerish now; you've been warned** Darcy is head over heels for Lizzy very early on - the guy is just whipped - which I thought lessened him as an interesting hero. Once the romance heats up, the prose, it is HIGHLY purple. Very unRegencylike makeout scenes ensue.
I was still basically enjoying it, on a definitely brain candy kind of level, when there's a development regarding Lady Catherine de Bourgh and her daughter Anne that ... well, let's just say the book jumped the shark for me right there.
R&R is still a freebie as of the time I'm writing this, but I recommend it only for non-critical romance readers. It's sappy, clean romance reading, but kind of fun in its way.
The tipping point, and where this variation really starts to diverge from the original story: Mr Bennet has a fall from his horse on his way back home. While he's lying in bed at home, in a coma, family and neighbors gather to wring their hands (in some cases) and offer help (in others), including Mr Collins, Darcy and Bingley. Collins takes advantage of the situation by publicly offering marriage to Lizzy. She rejects him in horror, but with her mother and Collins putting pressure on her to accept and her father not able to counteract them, the situation is getting fraught. Darcy surprises himself, not to mention astounding everyone in the room (and the whole town, once word spreads), by insisting that Lizzy can't marry Collins because ... she's already engaged to him. Jaws practically bounce off the floor.
The problem: Lizzy, at this point in their relationship, really doesn't like Darcy. His private explanation to her later (echoing an actual scene in P&P) does absolutely nothing to help his case.
So parts of this novel were really engaging, if you're into P&P fanfic at all. There's some worthwhile dialogue and developments that vary enough from the original story to make it enjoyable reading, if a little slow at times.
The problems are that (like so much other Austen fanfic and Regency romances generally) the author is either unaware of or ignores Regency manners and ways when it suits her. **Going to get slightly spoilerish now; you've been warned** Darcy is head over heels for Lizzy very early on - the guy is just whipped - which I thought lessened him as an interesting hero. Once the romance heats up, the prose, it is HIGHLY purple. Very unRegencylike makeout scenes ensue.
I was still basically enjoying it, on a definitely brain candy kind of level, when there's a development regarding Lady Catherine de Bourgh and her daughter Anne that ... well, let's just say the book jumped the shark for me right there.
R&R is still a freebie as of the time I'm writing this, but I recommend it only for non-critical romance readers. It's sappy, clean romance reading, but kind of fun in its way.
February 22, 2017
Dear reader,
If you are in the mood for a beautifully worded,utterly romantic,humorous,sigh inducing story featuring our beloved characters,then look no further than this fantastic book!
We begin our journey with Mr Darcy's early morning trek thorough the Hertfordshire countryside.In a vain attempt to exorcise the very beguiling image of Ms Elizabeth Bennet from his mind,he encounters none other than Mr Bennet. Both being land owners they slowly become familiar with each other as they converse on matters agricultural.
Shortly afterwards Mr B suffers a fall from his horse and is rendered unconscious.
Mr Jones,the apothecary,fearing for the immediate future of the Bennets under the direction of their sycophantic cousin,Mr Collins,calls on the gentlemen in Netherfield,as the Bennets' nearest neighbours,to step into the breach and offer help and support to them in their hour of need.
Enter stage left,said Mr Darcy and Mr Bingley,whose plans to return to London suddenly disappear,at this sudden call to arms!
Mr Collins,the heir apparent,seems to believe it his duty to propose to his fair cousin Elizabeth,and in an effort to thwart such a proposition and gift Lizzy a marriage partner that she loves and respects,Darcy promptly announces that they are indeed betrothed!!
To say that Lizzy reacts in a furious and somewhat violent way,is an understatement!
Indeed,the scene at the back of the house, near the river,where Darcy encounters her shortly afterwards,left me wondering how,if ever,these two spirited,hot tempered,deeply passionate people would reconcile to their fates,would allow the other to see the real them and finally realise that they were the perfect foil for the other.
What of Lady Catherine,I hear you ask?? To say this lady was devious,is to fail to do justice to her plans for matrimonial happiness for her dear Anne!
Knowing the full facts as she did,the mind boggles as to how she believed it possible that a union could exist between Darcy and Anne!
However,I must admit to loving the plot line involving Lady C,Richard's scheme to delay her inevitable arrival in Hertfordshire,the servants' 'as you wish,your ladyship' replies to her various demands and of course her
'heart to heart' with Elizabeth!!!
Let us not forget Caroline and her desire to usurp Lizzy's place in Darcy's affections.
I really admired how she finally accepted that wishing for the Darcy name,in the fashion of a certain lady of the higher circles,would likely result in her walking the same path as this lady,imitating her dastardly behaviour,and was simply not worth the price demanded!
Wickham too had his share in the conversation but thankfully was successfully defeated in his various money making schemes!
I loved this story and greatly admire the author's evident devotion to Darcy and Elizabeth.
Her inherent ability to pen such a warm, funny,highly entertaining and fundamentally heartwarming story bestows on the reader an opportunity to spend many a happy hour among such august company.
To read of the slow, awkward path tread by Darcy and Elizabeth,towards mutual understanding, appreciation,acceptance,and finally love,couched in such prosaic language left me totally enraptured until story's end!
Treat yourself to this wonderful story,you won't be disappointed!
If you are in the mood for a beautifully worded,utterly romantic,humorous,sigh inducing story featuring our beloved characters,then look no further than this fantastic book!
We begin our journey with Mr Darcy's early morning trek thorough the Hertfordshire countryside.In a vain attempt to exorcise the very beguiling image of Ms Elizabeth Bennet from his mind,he encounters none other than Mr Bennet. Both being land owners they slowly become familiar with each other as they converse on matters agricultural.
Shortly afterwards Mr B suffers a fall from his horse and is rendered unconscious.
Mr Jones,the apothecary,fearing for the immediate future of the Bennets under the direction of their sycophantic cousin,Mr Collins,calls on the gentlemen in Netherfield,as the Bennets' nearest neighbours,to step into the breach and offer help and support to them in their hour of need.
Enter stage left,said Mr Darcy and Mr Bingley,whose plans to return to London suddenly disappear,at this sudden call to arms!
Mr Collins,the heir apparent,seems to believe it his duty to propose to his fair cousin Elizabeth,and in an effort to thwart such a proposition and gift Lizzy a marriage partner that she loves and respects,Darcy promptly announces that they are indeed betrothed!!
To say that Lizzy reacts in a furious and somewhat violent way,is an understatement!
Indeed,the scene at the back of the house, near the river,where Darcy encounters her shortly afterwards,left me wondering how,if ever,these two spirited,hot tempered,deeply passionate people would reconcile to their fates,would allow the other to see the real them and finally realise that they were the perfect foil for the other.
What of Lady Catherine,I hear you ask?? To say this lady was devious,is to fail to do justice to her plans for matrimonial happiness for her dear Anne!
Knowing the full facts as she did,the mind boggles as to how she believed it possible that a union could exist between Darcy and Anne!
However,I must admit to loving the plot line involving Lady C,Richard's scheme to delay her inevitable arrival in Hertfordshire,the servants' 'as you wish,your ladyship' replies to her various demands and of course her
'heart to heart' with Elizabeth!!!
Let us not forget Caroline and her desire to usurp Lizzy's place in Darcy's affections.
I really admired how she finally accepted that wishing for the Darcy name,in the fashion of a certain lady of the higher circles,would likely result in her walking the same path as this lady,imitating her dastardly behaviour,and was simply not worth the price demanded!
Wickham too had his share in the conversation but thankfully was successfully defeated in his various money making schemes!
I loved this story and greatly admire the author's evident devotion to Darcy and Elizabeth.
Her inherent ability to pen such a warm, funny,highly entertaining and fundamentally heartwarming story bestows on the reader an opportunity to spend many a happy hour among such august company.
To read of the slow, awkward path tread by Darcy and Elizabeth,towards mutual understanding, appreciation,acceptance,and finally love,couched in such prosaic language left me totally enraptured until story's end!
Treat yourself to this wonderful story,you won't be disappointed!
June 2, 2018
4.5 stars rounded up to 5 stars
The main premise here is that with Mr. Bennet incapacitated and unconscious for who-knows-how-long due to a fall from his horse, Mr. Collins (working under the assumption that Mr. Bennet may never recover or may be mentally impaired if he awakens at all) steps up his plan to have Elizabeth as his bride and announces that she is his choice of wife and he will manage Longbourn in the stead of his predecessor. BUT, his biggest mistake is that he does this in the presence of Mr. Darcy. There are others there as witnesses, the rest of the Bennet family, Bingley, servants, etc.; they may be shocked but will do little to object to this. And we know Mrs. Bennet will only grab on to this assurance that, if her husband does not recover or recover fully, the family will not be thrown out into the hedgerows if Elizabeth is married to Mr. Collins.
To backtrack just a little: this scene is the day after the Netherfield Ball and both Darcy and Bingley are on their way to London. They are approached by the apothecary bringing to their notice what has happened to Mr. Bennet and "suggesting" that as a close neighbor Mr. Bingley might want to help with advising the Bennet family while Mr. Bennet is bed ridden. Thus Bingley's and Darcy's presence at the onset of this misfortune is explained.
We have had a look into Darcy’s thoughts. You know those of which he pondered after meeting Elizabeth and witnessing her sisters’ behaviors and her mother’s matchmaking efforts while learning of their poor prospects with little to speak of in the way of dowries. So he has realized towards whom his heart is leaning but has had all those misgivings. But to have thrown in his face the possibility that “this cretin” might touch Elizabeth, that she would bear Collins’ children, forces Darcy to make a bold move, an unexpected move, one which has all the makings of a forced engagement. Elizabeth is sputtering, a wet hen, hissing and coiling in her anger. About half this book is about that relationship. Then guess who comes up with a very wise decision about how to sort out and bring to fruition what Darcy has set in motion? OK, you’ll never guess so I’ll tell you, “Bingley”. Yes, Bingley sends for Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana.
So much of this book is reading of how ODC sorts out this rocky start. Darcy loves Elizabeth but she is anything but in love with him. (The Hunsford proposal is brought to mind.) Then there are matters to address in the management of the estate and here we read of this pair working in unison to a wise conclusion. Wickham is part of the story but is dealt with to the applause of the readers in a solid and permanent manner at the end. Lady Catherine has her say but it is her daughter who has some new surprises for us. Some readers have said they can’t quite accept this turn but with variations we do at times have to let the author have her twists and turns. It may be a surprise but Anne herself has a backbone and you will be cheering for her part in this tale, despite some of her personal history. The Colonel, as usual, plays a supportive role but he has some feelings to deal with, which are handled briefly in the epilogue as another review mentioned. Georgiana has much more of a role in this novel than in canon. She develops relationships with several of the Bennet sisters but at the same time continues to conceal the Ramsgate matter.
There are no scenes for mature audiences only but Darcy does have his moments of wishing the wedding was imminent and there is some kissing, etc. But I remember nothing which would offend.
This was an enjoyable book but I was forced to spread it out over several days as I read it before and after the Christmas holiday. I did note some of the errata spoken of in other reviews. But those didn’t lessen my enjoyment of a good read. I noticed that this author also wrote a variation of North and South and, as that is one of my favorites, I will buy and read that as I found this book so delightful.
The main premise here is that with Mr. Bennet incapacitated and unconscious for who-knows-how-long due to a fall from his horse, Mr. Collins (working under the assumption that Mr. Bennet may never recover or may be mentally impaired if he awakens at all) steps up his plan to have Elizabeth as his bride and announces that she is his choice of wife and he will manage Longbourn in the stead of his predecessor. BUT, his biggest mistake is that he does this in the presence of Mr. Darcy. There are others there as witnesses, the rest of the Bennet family, Bingley, servants, etc.; they may be shocked but will do little to object to this. And we know Mrs. Bennet will only grab on to this assurance that, if her husband does not recover or recover fully, the family will not be thrown out into the hedgerows if Elizabeth is married to Mr. Collins.
To backtrack just a little: this scene is the day after the Netherfield Ball and both Darcy and Bingley are on their way to London. They are approached by the apothecary bringing to their notice what has happened to Mr. Bennet and "suggesting" that as a close neighbor Mr. Bingley might want to help with advising the Bennet family while Mr. Bennet is bed ridden. Thus Bingley's and Darcy's presence at the onset of this misfortune is explained.
We have had a look into Darcy’s thoughts. You know those of which he pondered after meeting Elizabeth and witnessing her sisters’ behaviors and her mother’s matchmaking efforts while learning of their poor prospects with little to speak of in the way of dowries. So he has realized towards whom his heart is leaning but has had all those misgivings. But to have thrown in his face the possibility that “this cretin” might touch Elizabeth, that she would bear Collins’ children, forces Darcy to make a bold move, an unexpected move, one which has all the makings of a forced engagement. Elizabeth is sputtering, a wet hen, hissing and coiling in her anger. About half this book is about that relationship. Then guess who comes up with a very wise decision about how to sort out and bring to fruition what Darcy has set in motion? OK, you’ll never guess so I’ll tell you, “Bingley”. Yes, Bingley sends for Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana.
So much of this book is reading of how ODC sorts out this rocky start. Darcy loves Elizabeth but she is anything but in love with him. (The Hunsford proposal is brought to mind.) Then there are matters to address in the management of the estate and here we read of this pair working in unison to a wise conclusion. Wickham is part of the story but is dealt with to the applause of the readers in a solid and permanent manner at the end. Lady Catherine has her say but it is her daughter who has some new surprises for us. Some readers have said they can’t quite accept this turn but with variations we do at times have to let the author have her twists and turns. It may be a surprise but Anne herself has a backbone and you will be cheering for her part in this tale, despite some of her personal history. The Colonel, as usual, plays a supportive role but he has some feelings to deal with, which are handled briefly in the epilogue as another review mentioned. Georgiana has much more of a role in this novel than in canon. She develops relationships with several of the Bennet sisters but at the same time continues to conceal the Ramsgate matter.
There are no scenes for mature audiences only but Darcy does have his moments of wishing the wedding was imminent and there is some kissing, etc. But I remember nothing which would offend.
This was an enjoyable book but I was forced to spread it out over several days as I read it before and after the Christmas holiday. I did note some of the errata spoken of in other reviews. But those didn’t lessen my enjoyment of a good read. I noticed that this author also wrote a variation of North and South and, as that is one of my favorites, I will buy and read that as I found this book so delightful.
March 12, 2017
A deeply engaging and entertaining tale. If you would like to find Mr Darcy giving in to his feelings much sooner than expected, in the face of extreme provocation, then look no further. And extreme provocation it is indeed for him to learn that the woman he loves – a lady of Elizabeth Bennet’s calibre – is likely to become the wife of a pompous fool like Mr Collins. At a drop of a hat he declares it an impossibility, because Elizabeth is engaged to him. This is news to everybody and no less to Elizabeth herself. Needless to say, she does not appreciate high-handedness, nor being taken for granted. Mr Darcy has to try really hard indeed to win her trust and her heart and, to our delight, he does. Luckily for him he has staunch allies in the process: Colonel Fitzwilliam of course, who is as wonderful in this variation as we’d wish him to be; also, a Mr Bingley with a backbone, a number of resourceful servants and a delightful Georgiana. There are villains too – Lady Catherine more villainous than usual, and Wickham, and Miss Bingley, the snotty lady we love to hate. You’ll have to read this roller-coaster of a tale to see how everyone gets their just deserts and follow our beloved couple to their happily ever after. You won’t regret it, I’m sure you’ll love every word!
November 13, 2016
Rumours & Recklessness was a creative variation on Jane Austen's P&P when a series of small actions change the course of the original story. What if Darcy encountered Mr. Bennet just before he makes the decision to leave behind the temptation of a woman he feels he cannot have? What if Mr. Bennet takes a fall from his horse and is rendered unconscious and slips into a coma? What if Mr. Collins is more greedy and sleazy and makes his move while Mr. Bennet is not there to defend his daughters? What if Wickham is more wicked than canon? What if Lady Catherine holds a secret that takes a gothic bend? And what if Mr. Darcy takes the biggest, most reckless gamble of his life to save Elizabeth?
I enjoyed exploring each and every one of those what ifs and seeing where it took Darcy, Elizabeth, and the rest of the cast of characters that involve known and new characters to love and hate in their turn.
The story is gently paced and takes it's time once the opening events transpire. Though it lags in spots, those scenes are important for establishing the transitions for what is to come and I appreciated especially seeing the steady courtship between Darcy and Elizabeth after the rush to save her and her fury in the beginning.
There is a vast deal of humor sprinkled throughout the story to balance the drama taking place. I thought Colonel Fitzwilliam's antics with keeping Lady Catherine at bay and also the over the top bombasity of Lady C quite amusing.
The flavor of the gothic with Wickham's evil rumour-mongering, Collins' grungy greed, and the big dark secret in Darcy's family wonderful sources for conflict.
Elizabeth started out as a heroine I struggled to like because she was so determined to be put upon and stubborn when she didn't have all the facts and didn't want to believe them at first because it went contrary to her views. She also tends to be more of a tease than I was prepared for so I had to adjust my expectations. She also grew and became the lady just suited to a dour and broody Darcy and she stood true and strong through some trying circumstances. Darcy gets his comeuppance, but he really is the solid and supportive hero of the piece- not just to Elizabeth, but to everyone around him.
This is a longer story, but that is because the focus is not narrowed in to just Darcy and Lizzy's romance. This is Georgiana's story, the whole Bennet family, the Bingleys, and Darcy's family. So many plot threads are going on here. I enjoyed each one and it was fun when they all converged for the big scenes near the end.
I experienced this story in the audio version and was rather taken with narrator Stevie Zimmerman. She was in touch with the tone and pace and emotion of the story and she had a huge cast of characters to distinguish from one another. I was impressed. Her Darcy voice was scratchy, but I adjusted. I would definitely listen to more of her work.
All in all, this was a fantastic P&P variation that I would definitely recommend to other Austenesque lovers and also to sweet historical romance fans.
I enjoyed exploring each and every one of those what ifs and seeing where it took Darcy, Elizabeth, and the rest of the cast of characters that involve known and new characters to love and hate in their turn.
The story is gently paced and takes it's time once the opening events transpire. Though it lags in spots, those scenes are important for establishing the transitions for what is to come and I appreciated especially seeing the steady courtship between Darcy and Elizabeth after the rush to save her and her fury in the beginning.
There is a vast deal of humor sprinkled throughout the story to balance the drama taking place. I thought Colonel Fitzwilliam's antics with keeping Lady Catherine at bay and also the over the top bombasity of Lady C quite amusing.
The flavor of the gothic with Wickham's evil rumour-mongering, Collins' grungy greed, and the big dark secret in Darcy's family wonderful sources for conflict.
Elizabeth started out as a heroine I struggled to like because she was so determined to be put upon and stubborn when she didn't have all the facts and didn't want to believe them at first because it went contrary to her views. She also tends to be more of a tease than I was prepared for so I had to adjust my expectations. She also grew and became the lady just suited to a dour and broody Darcy and she stood true and strong through some trying circumstances. Darcy gets his comeuppance, but he really is the solid and supportive hero of the piece- not just to Elizabeth, but to everyone around him.
This is a longer story, but that is because the focus is not narrowed in to just Darcy and Lizzy's romance. This is Georgiana's story, the whole Bennet family, the Bingleys, and Darcy's family. So many plot threads are going on here. I enjoyed each one and it was fun when they all converged for the big scenes near the end.
I experienced this story in the audio version and was rather taken with narrator Stevie Zimmerman. She was in touch with the tone and pace and emotion of the story and she had a huge cast of characters to distinguish from one another. I was impressed. Her Darcy voice was scratchy, but I adjusted. I would definitely listen to more of her work.
All in all, this was a fantastic P&P variation that I would definitely recommend to other Austenesque lovers and also to sweet historical romance fans.
October 2, 2016
Daring, touching, shocking, hilarious, OMG reveal, love rewarded
I just want to say… read the reviews… they were great in helping me decide if I wanted this book or not. Before writing this review, I also read the book… twice. I wanted to see if my original thoughts were true and second to simply enjoy the story again.
The journey to love is not a straight line, especially with P&P characters. There are a lot of bumps in the road to happiness. This work is no different. Some will argue that it was too long or too slow in development. I think we are becoming too accustomed to the current craze of the novellas and short stories regarding JAFF. Now days, an author can have a wild thought, can write it down, doesn’t have to develop the complete story and can have it published. That is fine if you like that sort of thing and shouldn’t take away from those who write a full novel.
I enjoyed the emotional journey Elizabeth took when her world was shaken. First, her father was seriously injured; second, her toad of a cousin embarrassed her by declaring her his fiancée before a room full of people; thirdly, Mr. Darcy, with whom she did not have an agreement, declared that she was his fiancée. We watched as she struggled and came to grips with her situation. Over time, she discovered that Mr. Darcy was not the evil incarnate that Wickham had painted and that Wickham was in fact a complete villain and the opposite of the gentleman that he portrayed to her and to society.
Elizabeth’s world as she knew it was shaken to the ground. She felt she could no longer trust her own instincts. This was a hard blow for our beloved heroine, since she always prided herself on knowing people and could make out their character. It was interesting to watch her understanding change; her emotions and finally her feelings for Darcy evolve over time into love. There was none of this jumping from hate into ardent love as most novellas/ short stories try to foist on readers.
Darcy is so caught up in the web of his own creation that he could not escape. It was NOT his intention to become engaged to Elizabeth. He and the Bingley party were in fact leaving Hertfordshire for London never to return. Darcy simply lost it when Collins cornered Elizabeth with his declaration, and watched as Elizabeth tried valiantly to refuse her cousin. He couldn’t bear hearing Mrs. Bennet screeching at Elizabeth as she tried to force her to accept her cousin’s hand. He watched with horror as Elizabeth, with tears in her eyes, started to panic knowing her injured father was not there to support and back her in her refusal. Darcy simply could not allow it to go on any longer and acted through impulse and love. This is why the world loves Mr. Darcy… it is simply who he is.
Colonel Fitzwilliam: I loved this version of our dear Colonel. He is AWESOME, powerful, smart, crafty, and everything wonderful. What a man, what a brother/ friend to Darcy and so important in his life.
The Earl of Matlock and Lady Matlock: Darcy’s uncle and aunt are generous, wise people that recognized the love Darcy had for Elizabeth and though she was beneath his station, they accepted her as the future Mistress of Pemberley.
Mr. Collins: even more of a toad than canon…if that is possible. He is sprinkled throughout the story wherever Lady C is located. His future condescension from that quarter; however, is in serious jeopardy.
Lady Catherine was in rare form… she was superb in her regal villainous ways, simply awful…delicious. I loved the creative ways in which Darcy’s staff handled her… delightful. It was hilarious watching her thwarted in every endeavor. The author was creative as she sprinkled subtle hints and signs throughout the story that alluded to the madness engulfing Lady C. The big reveal is so massive that you will not believe it. I’ve never see it and the author was so creative. Well done, horror that it was. Just like Lady C.
Caroline Bingley: held out to the very end in her self-importance and thinking that she was best suited for Darcy. She still believed that she could wrestle Darcy from the grips of Elizabeth Bennet. She and her brother Bingley locked horns on more than one occasions due to her behavior toward Darcy and toward his staff. She was awful. It wasn’t until she was in the grips of Lady Catherine that she was able to see how her behavior looked to others.
Charles Bingley: At last… he listened, watched and learned as Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam handled the many problems presented to our group. He put on his big boy britches and was finally able to conduct business with the grownups. I liked how he evolved throughout the story. He and Jane will do fine.
Jane was the strong influence wherever she went. Everyone loved Jane.
Georgiana: I would have liked to see her evolve more than she did. Yes, we saw some change and we needed to see that change process; however, it could have been taken a bit further. After Darcy commented on her release her anger and passion by slapping Elizabeth…there should have been more progress with her development after the dam broke… so to speak. She still reacted too violently where Wickham was concerned. At some point she should progress beyond that initial fright and hold her head high, not quiver in her boots and hide her face in tears. That drew way too much attention to her.
Lydia Bennet: did not change in the story. Everyone, except her mother, saw her for what she was…a spoiled silly girl. Once her father gets on his feet, her life will take a dramatic change. Now THAT is a story I would love to read. The taming of Lydia…how her father manages to wrangle her into becoming a young lady.
Kitty and Mary were able to change somewhat…Mary more so than Kitty. There is hope for them yet. If Elizabeth can separate Kitty from Lydia’s influence, she will improve.
Mrs. Bennet: subdued somewhat by the presence of prestigious guests visiting Longbourn, fooled no one by her quiet demeanor.
Mr. and Mrs. Gardiner played a heavier role in this version and were well liked and respected by everyone they met… including Darcy’s noble relatives. Uncle Gardiner filled in nicely for Mr. Bennet. He was wise, cared for his nieces, and was willing to do whatever was necessary to protect the family, the family honor and name.
NOTE: when they mentioned Mary King’s uncle…there was a subtle hint that he was not a man to cross. That would be a story. We should have heard more about him coming to the rescue of his niece. Even if it had only been a meeting with Darcy, it would have been powerful.
There were minimal errors, already mentioned in other reviews, no need for me to repeat them.
**** SPOILER **** **** End Spoiler ****
I just want to say… read the reviews… they were great in helping me decide if I wanted this book or not. Before writing this review, I also read the book… twice. I wanted to see if my original thoughts were true and second to simply enjoy the story again.
The journey to love is not a straight line, especially with P&P characters. There are a lot of bumps in the road to happiness. This work is no different. Some will argue that it was too long or too slow in development. I think we are becoming too accustomed to the current craze of the novellas and short stories regarding JAFF. Now days, an author can have a wild thought, can write it down, doesn’t have to develop the complete story and can have it published. That is fine if you like that sort of thing and shouldn’t take away from those who write a full novel.
I enjoyed the emotional journey Elizabeth took when her world was shaken. First, her father was seriously injured; second, her toad of a cousin embarrassed her by declaring her his fiancée before a room full of people; thirdly, Mr. Darcy, with whom she did not have an agreement, declared that she was his fiancée. We watched as she struggled and came to grips with her situation. Over time, she discovered that Mr. Darcy was not the evil incarnate that Wickham had painted and that Wickham was in fact a complete villain and the opposite of the gentleman that he portrayed to her and to society.
Elizabeth’s world as she knew it was shaken to the ground. She felt she could no longer trust her own instincts. This was a hard blow for our beloved heroine, since she always prided herself on knowing people and could make out their character. It was interesting to watch her understanding change; her emotions and finally her feelings for Darcy evolve over time into love. There was none of this jumping from hate into ardent love as most novellas/ short stories try to foist on readers.
Darcy is so caught up in the web of his own creation that he could not escape. It was NOT his intention to become engaged to Elizabeth. He and the Bingley party were in fact leaving Hertfordshire for London never to return. Darcy simply lost it when Collins cornered Elizabeth with his declaration, and watched as Elizabeth tried valiantly to refuse her cousin. He couldn’t bear hearing Mrs. Bennet screeching at Elizabeth as she tried to force her to accept her cousin’s hand. He watched with horror as Elizabeth, with tears in her eyes, started to panic knowing her injured father was not there to support and back her in her refusal. Darcy simply could not allow it to go on any longer and acted through impulse and love. This is why the world loves Mr. Darcy… it is simply who he is.
Colonel Fitzwilliam: I loved this version of our dear Colonel. He is AWESOME, powerful, smart, crafty, and everything wonderful. What a man, what a brother/ friend to Darcy and so important in his life.
The Earl of Matlock and Lady Matlock: Darcy’s uncle and aunt are generous, wise people that recognized the love Darcy had for Elizabeth and though she was beneath his station, they accepted her as the future Mistress of Pemberley.
Mr. Collins: even more of a toad than canon…if that is possible. He is sprinkled throughout the story wherever Lady C is located. His future condescension from that quarter; however, is in serious jeopardy.
Lady Catherine was in rare form… she was superb in her regal villainous ways, simply awful…delicious. I loved the creative ways in which Darcy’s staff handled her… delightful. It was hilarious watching her thwarted in every endeavor. The author was creative as she sprinkled subtle hints and signs throughout the story that alluded to the madness engulfing Lady C. The big reveal is so massive that you will not believe it. I’ve never see it and the author was so creative. Well done, horror that it was. Just like Lady C.
Caroline Bingley: held out to the very end in her self-importance and thinking that she was best suited for Darcy. She still believed that she could wrestle Darcy from the grips of Elizabeth Bennet. She and her brother Bingley locked horns on more than one occasions due to her behavior toward Darcy and toward his staff. She was awful. It wasn’t until she was in the grips of Lady Catherine that she was able to see how her behavior looked to others.
Charles Bingley: At last… he listened, watched and learned as Darcy and Colonel Fitzwilliam handled the many problems presented to our group. He put on his big boy britches and was finally able to conduct business with the grownups. I liked how he evolved throughout the story. He and Jane will do fine.
Jane was the strong influence wherever she went. Everyone loved Jane.
Georgiana: I would have liked to see her evolve more than she did. Yes, we saw some change and we needed to see that change process; however, it could have been taken a bit further. After Darcy commented on her release her anger and passion by slapping Elizabeth…there should have been more progress with her development after the dam broke… so to speak. She still reacted too violently where Wickham was concerned. At some point she should progress beyond that initial fright and hold her head high, not quiver in her boots and hide her face in tears. That drew way too much attention to her.
Lydia Bennet: did not change in the story. Everyone, except her mother, saw her for what she was…a spoiled silly girl. Once her father gets on his feet, her life will take a dramatic change. Now THAT is a story I would love to read. The taming of Lydia…how her father manages to wrangle her into becoming a young lady.
Kitty and Mary were able to change somewhat…Mary more so than Kitty. There is hope for them yet. If Elizabeth can separate Kitty from Lydia’s influence, she will improve.
Mrs. Bennet: subdued somewhat by the presence of prestigious guests visiting Longbourn, fooled no one by her quiet demeanor.
Mr. and Mrs. Gardiner played a heavier role in this version and were well liked and respected by everyone they met… including Darcy’s noble relatives. Uncle Gardiner filled in nicely for Mr. Bennet. He was wise, cared for his nieces, and was willing to do whatever was necessary to protect the family, the family honor and name.
NOTE: when they mentioned Mary King’s uncle…there was a subtle hint that he was not a man to cross. That would be a story. We should have heard more about him coming to the rescue of his niece. Even if it had only been a meeting with Darcy, it would have been powerful.
There were minimal errors, already mentioned in other reviews, no need for me to repeat them.
**** SPOILER **** **** End Spoiler ****
December 21, 2022
Excellent Read
Reviewed in Canada on May 29, 2020
I read this book a while back, and just reread it because I realized I’d never given it a review. My bad. Nicole Clarkston is a favorite author for Pride and Prejudice variations. This one doesn’t disappoint. The forced marriage scenario is always a good plot in my opinion, as in this story. Of course, Elizabeth is strongly opposed, and we enjoy reading how Darcy helps her come around to accepting him. The author is a champion of great dialogue, which is a must to a great book for me. The usual P&P characters also make themselves known in the story. I highly recommend this book.
December 24-25, 2020 - Audiobook review
An excellent story and outstanding narration, by Nicole Clarkston and Stevie Zimmerman respectively. My third read and first listen, this superior Pride and Prejudice variation never gets old for me. The writing is brilliant, with marvelous dialogue. The teasing banter of Mr. Bennet, and between Darcy and Elizabeth is always entertaining. The narration first-rate with clear delineation among all the characters. You always know when the character dialogues have changed with the excellent narration by Ms. Zimmerman. I highly recommend both the book and the audiobook.
December 10-11, 2022 - Audiobook, second listen. Drunk Darcy is so diverting perfectly performed by Stevie Zimmerman.
Reviewed in Canada on May 29, 2020
I read this book a while back, and just reread it because I realized I’d never given it a review. My bad. Nicole Clarkston is a favorite author for Pride and Prejudice variations. This one doesn’t disappoint. The forced marriage scenario is always a good plot in my opinion, as in this story. Of course, Elizabeth is strongly opposed, and we enjoy reading how Darcy helps her come around to accepting him. The author is a champion of great dialogue, which is a must to a great book for me. The usual P&P characters also make themselves known in the story. I highly recommend this book.
December 24-25, 2020 - Audiobook review
An excellent story and outstanding narration, by Nicole Clarkston and Stevie Zimmerman respectively. My third read and first listen, this superior Pride and Prejudice variation never gets old for me. The writing is brilliant, with marvelous dialogue. The teasing banter of Mr. Bennet, and between Darcy and Elizabeth is always entertaining. The narration first-rate with clear delineation among all the characters. You always know when the character dialogues have changed with the excellent narration by Ms. Zimmerman. I highly recommend both the book and the audiobook.
December 10-11, 2022 - Audiobook, second listen. Drunk Darcy is so diverting perfectly performed by Stevie Zimmerman.
April 25, 2021
Finished this one yesterday. Loved it so much I want more!!
Reread: One of the more perfect JAFF reads. I want to look up to see if she has written more by now. This is a definite keeper and one to cherish.
Reread: Terrific!
Reread: What is not to love?!
Reread: One of the more perfect JAFF reads. I want to look up to see if she has written more by now. This is a definite keeper and one to cherish.
Reread: Terrific!
Reread: What is not to love?!
December 19, 2015
I will admit the book has some flaws and probably should have about 4-and-a-half stars, but it hooked me so completely I had to lean upwards to 5 stars for my review.
This is filled with well-rounded characterizations that seem very consistent with those in the original P&P. Elizabeth and Darcy are given ample opportunity to interact with some entertaining back-and-forth volleys. The usual scheming villains get in on the action (Wickham, Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine) as do the annoying ones (Mr. Collins, Mrs. Bennet, Lydia). Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana have larger roles in this obstacle course on the way to HEA and the good Colonel's storyline has the most surprising final resolution, though a secret involving the de Bourghs is a jaw-dropper. The book is jam-packed with a variety of different conflicts, the initial event driving this action being Mr. Bennet's accident. He remains deathly ill while events swirl around the main characters, particularly Elizabeth and, to a lesser extent, Georgiana. The book builds to its climax when Mr. Bennet's medical crisis finally resolves. (You can look to other reviews for spoilers regarding whether he survives or not; I'm not telling.)
I agree with other reviewers that the book is too long. There were stretches that delved more into the individual characters' thoughts than was necessary that could easily have been pared down or omitted altogether. I did notice a few typos and occasionally awkward phrasing, but not enough of either to irritate me. Most of the time, I was immersed in the author's prose and felt that she told her story well. I'm not a stickler for authentic Regency period behavior, so I didn't really notice or care if there were inconsistencies there.
I'm all about the story, plot construction, believable character development, and the overall quality of the writing. It's always satisfying to find a book that delivers the goods in all those areas, and I believe Rumours & Recklessness does so. Most JAFF enthusiasts should really enjoy this one as much as I did.
This is filled with well-rounded characterizations that seem very consistent with those in the original P&P. Elizabeth and Darcy are given ample opportunity to interact with some entertaining back-and-forth volleys. The usual scheming villains get in on the action (Wickham, Caroline Bingley, Lady Catherine) as do the annoying ones (Mr. Collins, Mrs. Bennet, Lydia). Colonel Fitzwilliam and Georgiana have larger roles in this obstacle course on the way to HEA and the good Colonel's storyline has the most surprising final resolution, though a secret involving the de Bourghs is a jaw-dropper. The book is jam-packed with a variety of different conflicts, the initial event driving this action being Mr. Bennet's accident. He remains deathly ill while events swirl around the main characters, particularly Elizabeth and, to a lesser extent, Georgiana. The book builds to its climax when Mr. Bennet's medical crisis finally resolves. (You can look to other reviews for spoilers regarding whether he survives or not; I'm not telling.)
I agree with other reviewers that the book is too long. There were stretches that delved more into the individual characters' thoughts than was necessary that could easily have been pared down or omitted altogether. I did notice a few typos and occasionally awkward phrasing, but not enough of either to irritate me. Most of the time, I was immersed in the author's prose and felt that she told her story well. I'm not a stickler for authentic Regency period behavior, so I didn't really notice or care if there were inconsistencies there.
I'm all about the story, plot construction, believable character development, and the overall quality of the writing. It's always satisfying to find a book that delivers the goods in all those areas, and I believe Rumours & Recklessness does so. Most JAFF enthusiasts should really enjoy this one as much as I did.
October 24, 2018
This is a crazy fun P&P What if...
What if Mr. Bennet actually talked to Darcy, then had an accident and lost consciousness, then Darcy & Bingley didn't go to London, then Darcy announced that he and Lizzy were engaged. And then more crazy time compressed stuff happens.
This book bounces from crisis to crisis to emergency to misunderstanding to mistake to crisis.... All of your favorites make an appearance
What if Mr. Bennet actually talked to Darcy, then had an accident and lost consciousness, then Darcy & Bingley didn't go to London, then Darcy announced that he and Lizzy were engaged. And then more crazy time compressed stuff happens.
This book bounces from crisis to crisis to emergency to misunderstanding to mistake to crisis.... All of your favorites make an appearance
September 22, 2016
I say Obstinance!
Oh my. Just loved loved this variation.
In this story it starts out at very near the beginning of Pride & Prejudice, right after the Netherfield Ball. Darcy is taking a ride and encounters Mr Bennet also out for a ride early in the am. They have a genial conversation and they go there separate ways. Unfortunately Mr Bennet has an accident and a head injury. He is unconscious and the house is in an uproar! Mr Collins try's to take advantage of this situation and infers in front of Mr Darcy that Elizabeth is his betroth. Elizabeth outraged tells Mr Collins that he has not asked nor received an answer. Mr Darcy try's to come to the rescue and all hell breaks out. What happens next is very diverting and the journey Darcy and Elizabeth have to make to come to an understand is well worth reading. Incredible alternative and definitely recommend to all JAFF readers.
There's only one thing near the end that I wasn't to fond of. Love Charlotte and truly want to see her happy but was to pat for my liking. Needed more time for that conclusion.
Oh my. Just loved loved this variation.
In this story it starts out at very near the beginning of Pride & Prejudice, right after the Netherfield Ball. Darcy is taking a ride and encounters Mr Bennet also out for a ride early in the am. They have a genial conversation and they go there separate ways. Unfortunately Mr Bennet has an accident and a head injury. He is unconscious and the house is in an uproar! Mr Collins try's to take advantage of this situation and infers in front of Mr Darcy that Elizabeth is his betroth. Elizabeth outraged tells Mr Collins that he has not asked nor received an answer. Mr Darcy try's to come to the rescue and all hell breaks out. What happens next is very diverting and the journey Darcy and Elizabeth have to make to come to an understand is well worth reading. Incredible alternative and definitely recommend to all JAFF readers.
There's only one thing near the end that I wasn't to fond of. Love Charlotte and truly want to see her happy but was to pat for my liking. Needed more time for that conclusion.
May 27, 2021
Had a rough week? Fictional angst got you down?
I've got just the R&R: Rumours & Recklessness will afford you a mental vacation if you are in the market for a long-long- saccharine read.
Synopsis:
We open on a strong note: Mr Bennet wrestling with symptoms of IBS. By the by, before I get accused of pulling this out of my tuchus- pun intended- this information is found on the first page, no cap!
Mr Bennet, knowing sleep with elude him- as long as his farts continue to as well- goes off on his bargain bin horse and ends up running into Mr Darcy. They have a nice bromance moment after which Mr B’s dubious horse proves his worth being easily startled by woodland creature and he falls off, slipping into a coma.
Darcy & Charles are stalled from their London flight by the news of Mr Bennet’s collapse. When they arrive at Longbourn, Lizzy is being pressured into an engagement with Mr Collins. Darcy, noting no one else is standing up for her, and very much in a loosing battle with his heart, rashly declares that she cannot marry Collins as they already have an understanding. Publicly declaring himself thus- in front of servants & the infamously loose lipped Bennets- this is short order becomes a, “Say I do, or kiss your respectability goodbye & live your days out a spinster, dragging your sisters down with you,” classic dilemma.
Lizzy is understandably upset at his presumption which robbed her of autonomy, and gives him a deserved set down. Darcy is urged by Georgiana & Col. Fitz to properly court Lizzy and show her there is more to him than his taciturn veneer.
Charles comes into his own and starts exerting himself as master, brother, and friend- which is always cathartic to read. The usual suspects can all be relied upon to stir their trademark trouble with their hackneyed ploys, fueled by their typical motives.
What Charmed:
♡Premiss
♡The backstory to Darcy’s reticence was dope:
♡ODC have chemistry, though their puppy-love, mutual infatuation, bordered on annoying. I rolled my eyes & groaned several times.
What Marred:
✗ How dragged out & ultimately plot hollow the story is. Formula of this story: Something occurs and then we are privy to half a dozen conversations dissecting the events significance. Tis reminiscent of watching the news, say ‘Situation Room with Wolf Blitzer' or its ilk, ‘This just in: Darcy has offered for Lizzy, but Lizzy hates his guts; we are joined by several experts who will weigh in on what this could mean for inter-county trade relations. Charlotte Lucas, local spinster, joining us now.” I echo the other reviewers that this needed a more decisive editor, desperately, ardently so.
✗Lizzy is an irresistible to mortal men 'Mary Sue' and not even one of the more fun, charming ones I can get on board with for the occasional guilty pleasure. Long optional rant follows- and yes the irony of it's length after dragging weak editing does not escape me:
✗Some ODC scenes cute, some were cringe: I.e.
➳Our overly verbose wingman, Colonel Fitz, whilst trying help Darcy’s suit with Lizzy, mentions Darcy & Fitzwilliam family have been inbreeding for 5 generations... Weird flex, but ok.
The Brass Tacks:
➭A precarious 3. As some other reviewers aptly noted it has nice scenes but far more redundant ones; it would have been more palatable were it truncated in length or beefed up on plot. The superfluousness bleeds into & exacerbates all the issues this novel had. Overall it is a cute and respectable JAFF, but lacks thematic depth and is toothache inducing levels of saccharine.
I've got just the R&R: Rumours & Recklessness will afford you a mental vacation if you are in the market for a long-long- saccharine read.
Synopsis:
We open on a strong note: Mr Bennet wrestling with symptoms of IBS. By the by, before I get accused of pulling this out of my tuchus- pun intended- this information is found on the first page, no cap!
Mr Bennet, knowing sleep with elude him- as long as his farts continue to as well- goes off on his bargain bin horse and ends up running into Mr Darcy. They have a nice bromance moment after which Mr B’s dubious horse proves his worth being easily startled by woodland creature and he falls off, slipping into a coma.
Darcy & Charles are stalled from their London flight by the news of Mr Bennet’s collapse. When they arrive at Longbourn, Lizzy is being pressured into an engagement with Mr Collins. Darcy, noting no one else is standing up for her, and very much in a loosing battle with his heart, rashly declares that she cannot marry Collins as they already have an understanding. Publicly declaring himself thus- in front of servants & the infamously loose lipped Bennets- this is short order becomes a, “Say I do, or kiss your respectability goodbye & live your days out a spinster, dragging your sisters down with you,” classic dilemma.
Lizzy is understandably upset at his presumption which robbed her of autonomy, and gives him a deserved set down. Darcy is urged by Georgiana & Col. Fitz to properly court Lizzy and show her there is more to him than his taciturn veneer.
Charles comes into his own and starts exerting himself as master, brother, and friend- which is always cathartic to read. The usual suspects can all be relied upon to stir their trademark trouble with their hackneyed ploys, fueled by their typical motives.
What Charmed:
♡Premiss
♡The backstory to Darcy’s reticence was dope:
♡ODC have chemistry, though their puppy-love, mutual infatuation, bordered on annoying. I rolled my eyes & groaned several times.
What Marred:
✗ How dragged out & ultimately plot hollow the story is. Formula of this story: Something occurs and then we are privy to half a dozen conversations dissecting the events significance. Tis reminiscent of watching the news, say ‘Situation Room with Wolf Blitzer' or its ilk, ‘This just in: Darcy has offered for Lizzy, but Lizzy hates his guts; we are joined by several experts who will weigh in on what this could mean for inter-county trade relations. Charlotte Lucas, local spinster, joining us now.” I echo the other reviewers that this needed a more decisive editor, desperately, ardently so.
✗Lizzy is an irresistible to mortal men 'Mary Sue' and not even one of the more fun, charming ones I can get on board with for the occasional guilty pleasure. Long optional rant follows- and yes the irony of it's length after dragging weak editing does not escape me:
✗Some ODC scenes cute, some were cringe: I.e.
➳Our overly verbose wingman, Colonel Fitz, whilst trying help Darcy’s suit with Lizzy, mentions Darcy & Fitzwilliam family have been inbreeding for 5 generations... Weird flex, but ok.
The Brass Tacks:
➭A precarious 3. As some other reviewers aptly noted it has nice scenes but far more redundant ones; it would have been more palatable were it truncated in length or beefed up on plot. The superfluousness bleeds into & exacerbates all the issues this novel had. Overall it is a cute and respectable JAFF, but lacks thematic depth and is toothache inducing levels of saccharine.
May 15, 2022
After reading 'These Dreams' by the same author, I was excited about reading this book. It could not be more different but is as equally brilliant. Mr Collins announces to everyone that he has chosen Elizabeth as his future wife, without asking her. Elizabeth protests, her mother insists and Mr Darcy announces that Elizabeth cannot marry Collins as she is engaged to him. This seems to take everyone by surprise, including Darcy himself! This all occurs at a time Mr Bennet is in a coma having had an accident.
This is a low angst story, with Darcy and Elizabeth working things out relatively easily. However, there is still plenty of interest, brilliant humour and fantastic characters.
So why only 4 stars?? Well, there is a storyline involving Anne De Bourgh towards the end of the book which made no sense to me. It made Lady Catherine appear positively weird as opposed to greedy, crazy or fixated. I didn't like it. Also, a lot of the plot revolved around Mr Bennets recovery and I felt that he was in a coma, then fully recovered with his injury frequently being of significance yet seemingly overlooked towards the end. The rest of the book was amazing, but the last 20% had a few things about it that I just struggled with and detracted from the story rather than adding to it.
Despite this, overall I really loved this book and the opportunity to read something with low angst, lots of interaction between Darcy and Elizabeth and a resolution that is satisfying without feeling too easy.
This is a low angst story, with Darcy and Elizabeth working things out relatively easily. However, there is still plenty of interest, brilliant humour and fantastic characters.
So why only 4 stars?? Well, there is a storyline involving Anne De Bourgh towards the end of the book which made no sense to me. It made Lady Catherine appear positively weird as opposed to greedy, crazy or fixated. I didn't like it. Also, a lot of the plot revolved around Mr Bennets recovery and I felt that he was in a coma, then fully recovered with his injury frequently being of significance yet seemingly overlooked towards the end. The rest of the book was amazing, but the last 20% had a few things about it that I just struggled with and detracted from the story rather than adding to it.
Despite this, overall I really loved this book and the opportunity to read something with low angst, lots of interaction between Darcy and Elizabeth and a resolution that is satisfying without feeling too easy.
April 10, 2022
The audiobook was well done. How could it not be narrated by Stevie Zimmerman.
An engaging story, with some twists and turns. Fairly low angst, with several couples finding HEA.
Darcy tries to save Elizabeth from a forced betrothal to Collins while her father is ill. However, that creates a forced betrothal to him, but she doesn't actually like him! So he will do everything he can to get her to fall in love with him, as much as he loves her.
The collection of multiple characters rounding out all the action taking place at Longbourn balances the love story of ODC very well.
An engaging story, with some twists and turns. Fairly low angst, with several couples finding HEA.
Darcy tries to save Elizabeth from a forced betrothal to Collins while her father is ill. However, that creates a forced betrothal to him, but she doesn't actually like him! So he will do everything he can to get her to fall in love with him, as much as he loves her.
The collection of multiple characters rounding out all the action taking place at Longbourn balances the love story of ODC very well.
August 10, 2024
Great story with many turns and twists. At the beginning Darcy got a couple of Elizabeth's tongue lashings, but after both of them learnt their lessons, their relationship developed pretty quickly. Their private moments were sweet and swoon worthy. I loved both their characters, they shine in this book.
Jane and Bingley were both great. Charles found his back bone, and Jane showed her best qualities. Caroline was her usual disdainful and haughty self, but had to make up for it. Lady Catherine was even more scheming and deranged than usual. I loved good outcomes for Colonel Fitzwilliam, Ann and Charlotte. Wickham got his just.deserts.
Jane and Bingley were both great. Charles found his back bone, and Jane showed her best qualities. Caroline was her usual disdainful and haughty self, but had to make up for it. Lady Catherine was even more scheming and deranged than usual. I loved good outcomes for Colonel Fitzwilliam, Ann and Charlotte. Wickham got his just.deserts.
September 18, 2019
In my top 5 P&P variation books
There is nothing to dislike about this book. It even has information about persimmon trees (they like the cold)
A must have book.
This is my favorite book by the author.
There is nothing to dislike about this book. It even has information about persimmon trees (they like the cold)
A must have book.
This is my favorite book by the author.
May 30, 2017
The story is quite nice, but the book is unnecessary long. I liked the relationship between Darcy and Elizabeth, but the revelations sounded too forced and out of place in my opinion.
October 23, 2017
A wonderful variation of Austen's Pride and Prejudice, Rumours and Recklessness starts with a tragic accident at Longbourn that changes the situation of all of the Bennet family on the morning after the Netherfield Ball. This alteration causes the party at Netherfield to not leave, as occurred in Austen's novel, and Elizabeth, practically forced into a marriage she does not want, rebels at the highhandedness of the men who visit her at Longbourn during this difficult time. Will Fitzwilliam Darcy be able to win her heart and hand after all that's happened?
I thoroughly enjoyed this variation of P&P. In fact, I don't usually give 5's to books that are not classics in their own right, but this book was practically un-put-downable. I had to force myself to hide my Kindle out of sight so that I could devote time that I would rather be reading to actually teaching my online classes.
And as I read the author biography at the end, I was thrilled to discover that she is also a homeschooling mom and is also an ardent admirer of Elizabeth Gaskell as well as Jane Austen...just as I am!
So Rumours and Recklessness provides a wonderful excursion back to the Regency era, allowing us readers to revisit our favorite (and not-so-favorite) characters from Austen's most popular novel and enjoy the humor and romance that makes us adore Austen's books and characters so greatly. Read and enjoy!!
And now re-reading this book just a year later, I loved it just as much, if not more. A brilliant book!!
I thoroughly enjoyed this variation of P&P. In fact, I don't usually give 5's to books that are not classics in their own right, but this book was practically un-put-downable. I had to force myself to hide my Kindle out of sight so that I could devote time that I would rather be reading to actually teaching my online classes.
And as I read the author biography at the end, I was thrilled to discover that she is also a homeschooling mom and is also an ardent admirer of Elizabeth Gaskell as well as Jane Austen...just as I am!
So Rumours and Recklessness provides a wonderful excursion back to the Regency era, allowing us readers to revisit our favorite (and not-so-favorite) characters from Austen's most popular novel and enjoy the humor and romance that makes us adore Austen's books and characters so greatly. Read and enjoy!!
And now re-reading this book just a year later, I loved it just as much, if not more. A brilliant book!!
October 12, 2017
Re-read #3 10/11/17
Upgrading my rating from 4 stars to 5 stars, because this another one of those books that's grown to be a particular favorite. The audiobook narrator (Stevie Zimmerman) is fabulous, so that definitely adds to my enjoyment. This time around, it struck me that I really appreciate Caroline Bingley's piece of the story. She's more complex here than she is often portrayed.
Also, I somehow keep forgetting that this is the one where This is the only story where I've seen that, and I think it was a creative twist.
Original review
This is another of those variations where I think Elizabeth changed her mind about Darcy far too quickly; however, it compensated for that somewhat by also having a more assertive Bingley, which I greatly enjoyed. I loved the machinations of Bingley, Colonel Fitzwilliam, Georgiana, and even Darcy's servants to bring Elizabeth and Darcy together and thwart Lady Catherine at every turn. Very entertaining, even if sometimes a little out of character. The change in Wickham's plot was creative. Secondary characters that could have dropped out of sight somehow managed to stay on screen and be interesting--even Mary, which was a nice change.
Upgrading my rating from 4 stars to 5 stars, because this another one of those books that's grown to be a particular favorite. The audiobook narrator (Stevie Zimmerman) is fabulous, so that definitely adds to my enjoyment. This time around, it struck me that I really appreciate Caroline Bingley's piece of the story. She's more complex here than she is often portrayed.
Also, I somehow keep forgetting that this is the one where This is the only story where I've seen that, and I think it was a creative twist.
Original review
This is another of those variations where I think Elizabeth changed her mind about Darcy far too quickly; however, it compensated for that somewhat by also having a more assertive Bingley, which I greatly enjoyed. I loved the machinations of Bingley, Colonel Fitzwilliam, Georgiana, and even Darcy's servants to bring Elizabeth and Darcy together and thwart Lady Catherine at every turn. Very entertaining, even if sometimes a little out of character. The change in Wickham's plot was creative. Secondary characters that could have dropped out of sight somehow managed to stay on screen and be interesting--even Mary, which was a nice change.
January 24, 2018
Funny, thrilling and engaging read. Angst free but with a lot of tension and suspense.
Mr Bennet is out on an early morning ride when he encounter Mr Darcy traversing the fields in break-neck speed. Unfortunately, Mr Bennet is unseated after they part and are found by Elizabeth. The apothecary is sent for and he desides to ask their Netherfield neighbours for help until their uncle are able to come from town because of the questionable behaviour of Mr Collins. Bingley and Darcy are received in the Longbourne drawing room when Mr Collins announces his bethrotal to Elizabeth. An incensed Elizabeth is trying to make the parson understand her refusal when Darcy steps up, announcing that Elizabeth is already engage to him. Elizabeth does not look kindly on his interference and gives him a hard time on changing her perception of him. Add the interference of Caroline, Wickham and lady Catherine, their road to happiness will have some obstacles... Fortunately the colonel are at hand to help, along with Georgiana, whose both helpful and unhelpful...
The story has a new twist to the Lydia/Wickham debacle, a new HEA for Charlotte and a twist to Anne de Borough . The colonels HEA seemed a bit rushed though.
Thoroughly enjoyed this book!
Mr Bennet is out on an early morning ride when he encounter Mr Darcy traversing the fields in break-neck speed. Unfortunately, Mr Bennet is unseated after they part and are found by Elizabeth. The apothecary is sent for and he desides to ask their Netherfield neighbours for help until their uncle are able to come from town because of the questionable behaviour of Mr Collins. Bingley and Darcy are received in the Longbourne drawing room when Mr Collins announces his bethrotal to Elizabeth. An incensed Elizabeth is trying to make the parson understand her refusal when Darcy steps up, announcing that Elizabeth is already engage to him. Elizabeth does not look kindly on his interference and gives him a hard time on changing her perception of him. Add the interference of Caroline, Wickham and lady Catherine, their road to happiness will have some obstacles... Fortunately the colonel are at hand to help, along with Georgiana, whose both helpful and unhelpful...
The story has a new twist to the Lydia/Wickham debacle, a new HEA for Charlotte and a twist to Anne de Borough . The colonels HEA seemed a bit rushed though.
Thoroughly enjoyed this book!
November 8, 2015
I believe the characters in this latest Pride and Prejudice variation keep very true to the original characters. Yes there were some moments were the characters don't keep to Miss Austen's characters, but with the situations they are placed in can you blame them? I can see Elizabeth yelling at Darcy and refusing him after the situation he points them in. It was to save her from Mr Collins but I would yell at him too. During everything that happens Mr Bennet is unconscious but he wakes up briefly a few times and what he says are hilarious.
I have to say that I enjoyed Miss Clarkston's first attempt into JAFF. I especially enjoyed her foray into North and South as well. If you enjoyed her first book you will definitely enjoy this one as well. I recommend this book to everyone.
Rating: 4½ stars out of 5
I have to say that I enjoyed Miss Clarkston's first attempt into JAFF. I especially enjoyed her foray into North and South as well. If you enjoyed her first book you will definitely enjoy this one as well. I recommend this book to everyone.
Rating: 4½ stars out of 5
October 22, 2015
An enjoyable read!
This book was well written and everything lovely. Darcy's love for Elizabeth is so wonderful and heartwarming. I said "awwww!!" a lot!
More things I loved: Collins is his obnoxious self, and Wickham's perfectly evil. There's more to Lady Catherine and Anne's story as well.
What I wasn't as fond of: Elizabeth is just too mean to Darcy for the longest time. I wish she had warmed faster to Darcy. She was just cruel, and said some things that were so judgmental and rude. I think this was just overdone. I also wish she had gone more into Lady Catherine's story in the end. I feel like she's too easily forgiven. Finally I wish the colonel ended up with the woman he loves first. Not with who he did.
But I highly recommend this variation!!!
This book was well written and everything lovely. Darcy's love for Elizabeth is so wonderful and heartwarming. I said "awwww!!" a lot!
More things I loved: Collins is his obnoxious self, and Wickham's perfectly evil. There's more to Lady Catherine and Anne's story as well.
What I wasn't as fond of: Elizabeth is just too mean to Darcy for the longest time. I wish she had warmed faster to Darcy. She was just cruel, and said some things that were so judgmental and rude. I think this was just overdone. I also wish she had gone more into Lady Catherine's story in the end. I feel like she's too easily forgiven. Finally I wish the colonel ended up with the woman he loves first. Not with who he did.
But I highly recommend this variation!!!
January 15, 2024
On the morning after the Netherfield just when the Bingley party had intended to leave for London, Mr. Bennet is injured. Bingley and Darcy are asked to help the Bennet household, and not just because of the visit of Mr. Collins. But everything again changes when Collins offers for Elizabeth in public.
We also have the usual bad characters of Wickham, Caroline and Lady Catherine.
An enjoyable tale with the added benefit of the more involved characters of Miss Darcy and especially Colonel Fitzwilliam.
We also have the usual bad characters of Wickham, Caroline and Lady Catherine.
An enjoyable tale with the added benefit of the more involved characters of Miss Darcy and especially Colonel Fitzwilliam.
December 12, 2017
I will start with praises.
I think Nicole Clarkston feels Austen's world (at least from P&P) quite perfectly. I have read a few P&P variations, and I had not found an author who would create so believable story. First of all, Clarkston was very loyal to the original characters of P&P (at least for the most part - more below). Darcy was Darcy [I honestly think that even drunk Darcy was believable, and I loved this scene], Mr. Collins was Mr. Collins, Jane was Jane and so on. And I really mean it. There are so many P&P variations whose authors didn't bother with much loyalty. And I want to stress it out: Nicole Clarkston did a really good job here.
Next, what is also very important, she invented very smartly how to retell the story. I think that most writers choose the moment after the first proposal. Here, the novel started after the Netherfield ball and I really liked how Elizabeth and Darcy worked on with their misunderstandings and prejudices.
Now we touch the weak points of the book.
Elizabeth and Darcy were finding their love and understanding really slow. I loved their encounters but between them, I sometimes drowned in their thoughts, and I mean it in the wrong way. I was sometimes simply bored. Mrs. Clarkston caught their minds perfectly but she shouldn't have written so much of them, especially that they were repeating themselves.
Unfortunately, near the end of the book, there were plot twists (what became of Anne de Bourgh, Caroline Bingley and Charlotte Lucas) and scenes (e.g. the kissing), that I found less believable.
So, I started to read it with small expectations, then I thought I had found a gem, but with time, there appeared smaller and bigger flaws. Therefore the paragraphs of the last chapters I was often skipping.
This book had a potential for a five-star variation of P&P. But it should have been shorter and some plots should have been rethought.
I think Nicole Clarkston feels Austen's world (at least from P&P) quite perfectly. I have read a few P&P variations, and I had not found an author who would create so believable story. First of all, Clarkston was very loyal to the original characters of P&P (at least for the most part - more below). Darcy was Darcy [I honestly think that even drunk Darcy was believable, and I loved this scene], Mr. Collins was Mr. Collins, Jane was Jane and so on. And I really mean it. There are so many P&P variations whose authors didn't bother with much loyalty. And I want to stress it out: Nicole Clarkston did a really good job here.
Next, what is also very important, she invented very smartly how to retell the story. I think that most writers choose the moment after the first proposal. Here, the novel started after the Netherfield ball and I really liked how Elizabeth and Darcy worked on with their misunderstandings and prejudices.
Now we touch the weak points of the book.
Elizabeth and Darcy were finding their love and understanding really slow. I loved their encounters but between them, I sometimes drowned in their thoughts, and I mean it in the wrong way. I was sometimes simply bored. Mrs. Clarkston caught their minds perfectly but she shouldn't have written so much of them, especially that they were repeating themselves.
Unfortunately, near the end of the book, there were plot twists (what became of Anne de Bourgh, Caroline Bingley and Charlotte Lucas) and scenes (e.g. the kissing), that I found less believable.
So, I started to read it with small expectations, then I thought I had found a gem, but with time, there appeared smaller and bigger flaws. Therefore the paragraphs of the last chapters I was often skipping.
This book had a potential for a five-star variation of P&P. But it should have been shorter and some plots should have been rethought.
October 23, 2020
Was this Nicole Clarkston's first book? Because it reminds me of mine. It's full of head-hopping, non-Regency words, and the odd misused word, yet the book is so darn good, I can't believe it. (Aside: I cringe when I read the errors in my first book, yet the fans often say it's their fave, and I also look at it and say "That came out of me?") Minus half a star.
In any case, I loved this book. The writing was tight, the story didn't go off on tangents, there was a decent amount of natural conflict, the twists were realistic and not contrived feeling, the characterizations made sense for the story at hand, the humour was great, the amorous scenes were handled with a delicate hand (no sexytimes, though), the prose was delightful, the scene-setting was vivid, the development of the romance was natural: all in all, well done.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author and my reviews could be considered to be a conflict of interest. I was a reader first, so my reviews are honest and impartial. I am a friend of Nicole Clarkston but I have not let that influence my review.
In any case, I loved this book. The writing was tight, the story didn't go off on tangents, there was a decent amount of natural conflict, the twists were realistic and not contrived feeling, the characterizations made sense for the story at hand, the humour was great, the amorous scenes were handled with a delicate hand (no sexytimes, though), the prose was delightful, the scene-setting was vivid, the development of the romance was natural: all in all, well done.
Disclaimer: I am a JAFF author and my reviews could be considered to be a conflict of interest. I was a reader first, so my reviews are honest and impartial. I am a friend of Nicole Clarkston but I have not let that influence my review.
August 5, 2024
Not more than 4 stars I think.
To be honest, after a third listen I haven‘t changed my first opinion on Elizabeth.. I don‘t like her that much for the first few chapters. She does improve though. Gladly.
As always brilliantly narrated by Stevie Zimmerman.
To be honest, after a third listen I haven‘t changed my first opinion on Elizabeth.. I don‘t like her that much for the first few chapters. She does improve though. Gladly.
As always brilliantly narrated by Stevie Zimmerman.
August 3, 2024
Rereading and enjoying it a lot. I had forgotten what happens. Mr. Bennet is injured and Mr. Collins takes advantage of the situation and attempts to pressure Elizabeth into marriage. Darcy won't have it and announces their engagement. Elizabeth finds it presumptuous too but it becomes rather public knowledge and he is a sight better than Collins... In the meantime, Caroline and Lady Catherine try to interfere Wickham has a plan that for once has very little to do with Lydia. Georgiana and the Colonel are in Hertfordshire.
Steam level: Kissing, caressing and intentions.
Steam level: Kissing, caressing and intentions.
June 24, 2025
4.5 stars rounded up.
Very enjoyable read. A bit fantastical. Nearly every ridiculous possibility is crammed into one book. But, the story is enjoyable and E and D are charming. I enjoyed watching D try to win her over.
2nd reading was via audible. very enjoyable to listen to.
Highly recommend to those that enjoy JAFF.
Very enjoyable read. A bit fantastical. Nearly every ridiculous possibility is crammed into one book. But, the story is enjoyable and E and D are charming. I enjoyed watching D try to win her over.
2nd reading was via audible. very enjoyable to listen to.
Highly recommend to those that enjoy JAFF.
Read
July 5, 2025DNF no star rating. I’m on chapter 12 and it feels like I’ve already read 800 pages. Slow. I can’t stay interested.
I see this is available as an audio book with Stevie Zimmerman narrating! I might just have to give this another try!
I see this is available as an audio book with Stevie Zimmerman narrating! I might just have to give this another try!
Read
April 17, 2024Don’t judge me. I can’t help myself
Displaying 1 - 30 of 177 reviews