Combining his trademark humour with his eye for the ridiculous, Radio 1's Mark Radcliffe recalls his less-than-glittering rock career in a succession of bands. Interwoven with the musical disasters is the rites-of-passage story of a middle-class grammar school boy.
Enjoyable and funny read about all the bands the author has played in over the years. With the exception of the final chapter about the Shirehorses which is a great ending, I felt the second half of the book - post-university era - lost its way a little bit.
Never re read a book you originally found hilarious - you'll never appreciate it as much the second time. If you've never read it before then read it for a fantastic account of Mark Radcliffe's early complete failure to make it in the music business. It loses pace near the end when talking about the author's experience with the Shirehorses (in the company of the Boy Lard aka Marc Riley) - possibly because they actually achieve success, albeit with an updated version of the Barron Knights formula (ie, re record contemporary tunes with "humourous" lyrics), thus going against the book's central premise.
Yeh pretty good. In this memoir, each chapter covers his time in a different band that went nowhere and wasn't very good. Each encompassing whatever musical trend had appeared at that particular moment. Part of his desire makes you want to think that he is doing it for passiona and desire and the want to be successful at it, but the way he presents it makes you think he was just taking the piss and wanted to be some sort of Tenacious D-esque mockery of a genre. This is a shame because his style of writing is quite good and his demeanor and personality here (as on the radio) is warm and infectious. Great little music memoir though for anyone in a failed band with lofty ambitions of stardom.
Brilliant - if you have ever listened to Mark Radcliffe on the radio you will read it with his tone of voice going through your head, which makes it more hilarious! An easy read which made me laugh on the tube, remembering listening to the Shirehorses on the radio show - am now going to give it to my 18 year old son to read!
No business like... I was vaguely aware of Mark Radcliffe through his engaging and enthusiastic commentary on the BBC's Glastonbury festival coverage, and picked this book up wondering whether he writes as well as he speaks (like his radio colleague Stewart Maconie, whose Cider With Roadies I greatly enjoyed).
He tells the story of every band he's ever played in since the age of fourteen, his bandmates, and the highs and (mostly) lows of his musical career. In keeping with the book's subtitle, the style is relentlessly self-mocking, which can be funny, but I think the writing lacks the light touch which is required to keep things moving along (e.g. p65: "I'd managed to complete an academic record remarkable only for its lack of remarkability with three unremarkable A-level grades [...]"). The details about the personal habits of his bandmates - while intended to be amusing - also became tiresome after a while, since I think he was rather too successful in showing them in an unflattering light.
Matters improved towards the end of the book as he found some degree of success in the spoof band Shirehorses and, apart from that, the parts I liked best were his intermittent accounts of seeing bands that made a difference to him (such as Dr Feelgood, David Bowie and Madness); perhaps a book which was more focused on that sort of thing (like his Reelin' in the Years) would be more to my taste. Time will tell.
I don't often laugh out loud when reading but with this autobiographical tale of life in a series of unsuccessful bands it's hard not to.
It charts musical mishaps including guitarists who can't play, singers who can't sing and bassists who lack, what is generally considered to be a prerequisite for the job, a bass. Add fashion faux pas, ill-judged stage acts and transport traumas, it's enough to put anyone off ever wanting to play music in public. However, it's written with wit and warmth, plus a well-judged turn of phrase that makes it a hard book to dislike.