Traitor

Traitor #1

by Sandra Grey, David L. Walker (Narrator)

With war raging in Europe, the only way Marie can be with Felix is to join the Allied forces. However, as Marie parachutes into France to join the Resistance, she not only lands into the arms of her fiance', but also drops into the hands of the enemy.

Major Rolf Schulmann has been struggling between personal convictions and his duty to the German Fatherland. Now he must decide what to do with the captured fiance' of the man who gave him a new chance at life--a man he once loved as a brother. The Gestapo will do whatever it takes to dispose of Marie. If Rolf helps her escape he will have enemies on all sides--is it a sacrifice he is willing to make? Can Marie possibly trust her life to a man torn between two masters?

Genres: Historical Fiction, Lds Fiction, Romance, Lds, Fiction, Christian Fiction, Book Club

372 pages, Paperback

First published January 1, 2008

Reviews

[Kathie · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this book and thought that she did a good job with her research and using that along with her story line.
This book kept me very interested. I didn't want to put it down because I had to know what was happening next. I love the way the relationship between Marie and Rolf evolved.
I personally know the author and so when I got to the end and she left us hanging, I called her up and visited with her about it. She did give a Prologue for her next book but I thought she still left us hanging. Her new book Tribunal will be out on Jan. 5, 2009.

[Michelle · Rating 4 out of 5]

Great book. A LDS romance novel set during World War II. I really like Sandra Grey's style of writing. She is able to describe tastes and feelings and weather and so many other thigs so well that you can really imagine them. I want to read more of her books.

[Roberta · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have to give this book a mixed review. The story itself is worthy of plaudits. The way the author constantly inserted lengthy Mormon prayers to an unknown audience was not. On the back cover of the book there was no reference whatsoever to the fact that this book had LDS overtones. If it had, I probably would not have purchased it.

The story goes back to World World II, just prior to the Allied invasion. A French/American lady (a Mormon), trained to be a coder, parachutes into southern France to join her fiance, a Resistance fighter, protesting the occupation of their country by the Germans. She's also instructed to test a new communications code the British developed for the French Resistance.

Her fiance is killed & she falls in love with a German officer (also a Mormon), a widower & father of a young son. The officer previously knew her fiance & was also devastated when he was killed. The book details their numerous escapades of being repeatedly captured by the Gestapo & escaping with the help of other Mormons they meet while participating in secret Mormon sacraments. She eventually lands in a brutal prison camp, while he is characterized & imprisoned as a traitor, due to his sympathy for the Resistance.

The ending left the reader hanging, with many questions unanswered. The author needs to work more on closing all situations involving the main characters in future books.

[Christinapstanley · Rating 2 out of 5]

This is an LDS work of commercial fiction, that requires an enormous dose of suspended belief. While the actions of the main characters are laudable, I found them cliche--what you'd expect from the LDS suspense genre. The story is gripping--I read it in less than 2 days--but whole paragraphs could be skipped for all their unnecessary detail. The historical information was based almost entirely on one book and was used simply to propel the plot, rather than develop meaning. The closest it came to contributing anything of literary value was in presenting the conflict of religion versus duty. Otherwise, the purpose of the book was to convey a plot, which leaves you hanging at the end with the beginning of the sequel.

[Michele Blake · Rating 4 out of 5]

Good book. I'm always fascinated with this time in history. I didn't want to stop reading. You need to read all 3 books to get full story.

[Casey · Rating 3 out of 5]

Traitor was a pretty good read. I learned a lot about the war in France, the resistance, and the Gestapo by reading this book. I also thought it was cool how Grey included historical notes at the end of the book for each chapter to give you additional information about the true events she mentions in the book. I do have to admit though that it took me a couple of chapters to get into the story, but once I did I was hooked. However, that's probably only because Sandra Grey puts a lot of factual information into her fictitious stories and my brain is only 10% history driven and 90% romance driven. I just want to get to the romance! You can see the problem here can't you!?
I really did like the story though and was shocked on three different occasions when the story took on twists I wasn't expecting. So as not to be a major plot spoiler I won't come right out and tell you what those shockers were, but I'm including page numbers that these shockers occur on so if you've read the book or if you end up reading it you can tell me what you think.



Shocker # 1: (pg. 38 last sentence in paragraph) Definitely didn't see that one coming. I had her capture pictured completely different!

Shocker # 2: (pg. 334-337) No No No! Very brave Rolf, but not the heroics I was expecting. You're suppose to make things better not worse!

Shocker # 3: And the plot thickens. Yeah, I really don't know what to think of this one.

[Verona · Rating 4 out of 5]

I started reading this book because a friend loaned me the book. At first I couldn't get into the story because I got bogged down in the war details. I found I wasn't as familiar with World War II as I should have been. But after I got into the story, I was really enjoying it. Another friend told me that she had the audio version of the book, and that way my husband and I could enjoy it together, so we started listening together. I learned a lot about the intrigue of war, and I enjoyed the relationship between Rolf and Marie as it developed. I also was curious about the way the Mormons were treated by Dresner particularly and others as well. I wonder how accurately that portrays how the Mormons were treated during the war. I am anxious now to read the 2nd book in this series, and I hear there's a 3rd as well. I would recommend this book to anyone.

[Luann · Rating 5 out of 5]

I absolutely loved this book. It doesn't hurt that I know the author, but even without that connection, I would love this book.

Marie Jacobson parachutes into France during WWII to help train Résistance leaders on a new code system - and to spend time with her fiancé, Félix, who is a member of the Résistance. Marie could not have predicted the outcome of this decision, or the changes it would mean in her life.

Although this is LDS fiction, anyone who enjoys gripping historical fiction set in France and Germany during WWII with realistic characters you really care about would enjoy this book. I highly recommend it!

[Karen · Rating 3 out of 5]

1944 Nazi occupying Europe was a very dangerous time, not only for the Jews but for all people that disagreed with Hitler. Rulf being a Nazi officer and a Mormon finds conflict within himself when asked to carry out the plans of the Fuhrer. He encounters a spy Maria from America (the typical BYU Mormon). The two are intertwined because of circumstance, war, love and a SS officer you love to hate.

Although I found that this book was typical Mormon Literature, and predicable, it was still worth reading. It would have been better to have a little more history, but being a love story I guess not.

[Tiffeny · Rating 2 out of 5]

Took me about 100 pages to really get into this book. I didn't love it, but liked it well enough. Not a real exciting read and kind of hard for me to get through. My plans were to give it 3 Stars, though until I got to the very end.

POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT: I don't know if this book is one in a series or if the author just wanted you to use your own imagination as to how it was going to end, but she really just left you hanging. Quite lame after you'd hung in there with her for through 300 freaking pages of not super-exciting story-telling.

Probably won't be reading anymore by this author.

[Christy · Rating 5 out of 5]

So I usually avoid books from this Historical Event (World War 2). I find it extremely heart breaking to read about the struggles and deaths of so many innocent people. However, I really enjoyed the view point of this book and the struggle of a soldier that fought for an injust cause only to save the lives to the people he loved. The moral dilemma and the faith that drove him to save the lives of hundreds of innocent people. A very good book and I will anxiously await for the release of the second book in the series.

[Ann · Rating 2 out of 5]

This was a bookclub book. The book had to work too hard to add Mormon ideas into the plot. I found the entire book hard to believe. I found the main female character to be shallow and superficial and predictable.

The book does raise good issues of reconciling belief during times of war.

Ann

[Connie · Rating 3 out of 5]

I would have given this book a 4 instead of a 3 except that it took until about page 40 to get into it, plus the ending was too abrupt, and it left you kind of hanging.

[Lenna • Sugar Dusted Pages · Rating 4 out of 5]

Still good. I need more WWII books

[Shannon · Rating 3 out of 5]

When I was a youthful reader, I used to wonder why no member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day-Saints was a mainstream writer. I believe I have it figured out, at least in part; it is because to write a book that is true to our beliefs, one must express our values and faith while trying to explain why we believe those things and commit to them so firmly. This is extremely hard to incorporate into the typical mainstream format which, while it allows for personal morals, is not inclusive of formalized religion, of any nature and especially not of what is popularly referred to as "Mormonism." Also, as devout members of the church, we have been blessed with an optimistic outlook on life, even at its most bleak and despairing. This attitude, of course, flies in the face of the fundamental premises of fiction which are: man vs. man, man vs. nature & man vs. himself. Our religion, due to its positive nature of love, always pre-empts conflict and destruction.
I hasten to note that there now exist some Church member authors who are extremely mainstream and have a worldwide popularity. I submit, however, that none of them is able to incorporate by name and title any of the specific points of doctrine, scripture or beliefs that are the foundation of our religion. Any values, attitudes or concepts considered in those popular works of fiction are purposely generic.
Anyway, I said all that to make the point that this book is proof that my reasoning, concerning why fiction that is motivated by core beliefs of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day-Saints will not enter the mainstream, is correct. That doesn't make it any less frustrating that the world in general is not ready to accept these fervent ideals and uplifting spiritual applications as real-life choices. It is sad that this fact-based WWII story will be relegated to relatively few readers when so many more could enjoy and benefit from it.
Sandra Grey does a pretty good job with this book, although it starts off rather slowly and incoherently as the reader tries to put together the random pieces of Marie's secret mission, her fiance's lack of enthusiasm, and the fluctuating state of various French governments and resistance agendas. Once Marie is taken into Gestapo custody, the plot settles down and advances fairly well, except for getting bogged down in too many sidetracks, such as the visit to Felix's mother. Her style is quite strong, but uneven, and when it breaks down, it sounds like an unemotional police report. There is a glaring example of this flaw on page 254, when Rolf uses force on the Nazi orderly to get him to divulge the Gestapo's whereabouts.
I agree with most other reviewers who felt the ending was too abrupt. in fact, the last twenty-five pages seemed extremely rushed in dealing with what should have been one of the most dramatic highlights of the plot. Then it screeches to an unwieldy halt and readers are definitely left hanging with a very preachy and saccharine let down.

[Wendy Jensen · Rating 5 out of 5]

#5Stars - This rating and review is for the full World War II Trilogy: Traitor; Tribunal; Trespass

Excellent research providing a genuine look into post WWII in France, Germany and Russia make this a remarkable study of history. The End Notes for each book are a must and provide good understanding of the harrowing conditions of the people.

At the same time believable and well-defined characters make this collection a great fictional read. Too often writers “Americanize” the experiences of their characters with little understanding of times and circumstances quite different from our own. Not so with this collection. The writing is engaging. The Audio Books with superb narration are available as individual books.

My heart was at times stretched. It is painful to face our own inabilities to wipe away all tears as our hearts reach out to others who suffer. With the realities faced by men and women under overwhelmingly difficult circumstances, I was led to consider my own efforts to live according to the light and truth I have. I found myself once again grateful for the profound privilege it is to live free not only as an American but also with the precious knowledge that there is a Plan of Happiness. There is great purpose in life and the promises to receive all we are willing to receive are sure. The Savior paid the price of all inequities and will carry each and every one who seeks a heavenly home.

As with all good reads, I find myself desiring to be better and live true. I find greater capacity to genuinely care for and pray for my brothers and sisters throughout the world who are facing desperate times. I find myself seeking whatever small part I can do to make a difference for good.

Well Done Sandra Grey! This collection ranks up there with "All the Light We Cannot See" by Anthony Doerr: "The Book Thief" by Markus Zusak; "Til the Boys Come Home," by Jerry Borrowman; and "The "Nightingale" by Kirstin Hannah"

[peachrings · Rating 3 out of 5]

A clean, predictable, “comfy” sort of read, despite the setting. I’m ex-Mormon, so I understood all the church stuff, but if you have no familiarity with Mormonism you’ll spend a decent chunk of time confused or bored. It’s the kind of book where the more you ponder it, the more flaws you notice in characters’ actions, the pacing, the premise, etc… but don’t think about it too hard. Like I said, an easy “uplifting” book if you’re into that kind of thing. The ending was abrupt and unresolved, but the sample preview of the sequel confirms what I already suspected - I wouldn't have expected the author to do anything bold or shocking.

[Summitsonthetop · Rating 4 out of 5]

I thought this book was an interesting one because it dealt with corruption in the Philippines. It was interesting from that perspective. It was interesting because you got a look at the different characters and their perspectives, and really did learn that people have different experiences, and their experiences shape them. I would recommend the book because it is just an interesting story, but also from the added dimension of understanding the bauty of another culture and people.

[Rachel · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is such a great book! I just reread it for the third time (after not reading it for many years) and was totally caught up in the story. I love how the author weaves a compelling plot line with multifaceted and well written characters into the historical facts of WWII to make a gripping and touching story. I couldn't recommend this book more!

[Chatharina · Rating 4 out of 5]

The only complaint I have regarding this book is I wanted more. I wanted to see Marie fall in love with Alma, more about Hans, Felix, Rolf etc. I quite enjoyed this story, but I think it had more potential.

[Ali~may · Rating 4 out of 5]

I don’t read very many WWll novels, so it was interesting to read something different. But it also reminds me of how horrible war is.
The writing was well done and I enjoyed the relationships and character growth in the story.

[Mindy Williams · Rating 4 out of 5]

Really liked this! It's been a long time since I have read a 'turn off your brain and read' type book, and this one was good! WWII is always such an interesting topic, and this did not disappoint! Definitely a good read.

[Clara · Rating 5 out of 5]

This book was amazing. It was a glorious story filled with faith, love, sacrifice, morals, heroics, and much more.
It showed how no matter where you hailed from and which side of the war you were on, you could be a good person and love God.
It was beautiful.

[Sadie · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 stars. I rounded up to five stars as I really appreciated the author sharing a story that included the perspective of World War II German officers that hated what their government was commanding them to do.

[Kate · Rating 5 out of 5]

Easy to read. Unique perspective on World War II that really got me thinking.

[Tosha · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wish I had read these all in order, but they did all stand alone. Although if you obviously are going to read a series read in order. I liked the good clean read, that wasn't too cheesy.

[Hannah · Rating 5 out of 5]

I loved this book!! It had a great plot line and the characters were amazing. I really enjoyed this love story that included danger and risks! Don’t forget to read book 2

[Pandamonkey · Rating 4 out of 5]

I was slow to get into it. But after a while I was hooked.

[Valerie Spilsbury · Rating 5 out of 5]

My daughter and I both loved this series. Wish you would write more books!!!

[Cassidy R. · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a great novel, with many plot twist and never knowing which way the book is going to turn. I enjoyed reading this and it was hard to put it down at times. Marie is sent to France during the middle of World War 2, and is captured by a Nazi general. She finds out that he is not the man she thought he was. If you like historical fiction and action books this is the book for you to read.