Very romantic stories, and I liked all of them
Warning: This review might contain what some people consider SPOILERS.
"Key to Me" by Jet Mykles - 9/10
PROS:
- This story is mushy and unbelievable but deliciously romantic. Scene after scene after scene had me thinking, “aww…”
- The plot/mystery isn’t really very mysterious (at least, I figured it out very early on in the story, which I’m sure would be the case with most readers), but I still loved it. NOAH doesn’t figure it out, of course, so there are some cute scenes when he’s adorably clueless about the identity of his secret admirer.
- I found the sex scenes to be both super sweet and super hot.
CON:
- When the identity of the secret admirer is finally revealed, Noah is very excited about who it is. But he hasn’t had a single wistful thought about this guy earlier in the story: no “he was hot, too bad Noah couldn’t have him” comments anywhere. So the speed with which Noah proclaims love for the guy felt a LITTLE rushed to me.
"The Gift of Eros" by Kimberly Gardner - 8/10
PROS:
- The story has a bit of a mythological element to it that I found cute and interesting. The element of mystery is maybe a little anemic, but the story doesn’t take itself too seriously, so I really didn’t mind much.
- Some of the sex scenes (later on, when the characters know more than just each other’s first names) are pretty hot: very lightly D/s but heavy on borderline exhibitionism and public places.
CONS:
- The sex starts right away, which I’m not a huge fan of. That first scene is hot and passionate and all that (for the characters, anyway), but it’s also rather on the impersonal side.
- The ending is a little rushed/sudden for me. Val makes a pretty huge decision after not a whole lot of thought.
"Roughly Tied Together” and “Rough Ride" by Laura Baumbach - 8/10
PROS:
- Each of these stories is basically nothing but a single sex scene (with a bit of emotional build-up), and they’re slow and romantic and very loving.
- Neither the excerpt nor the story is very long, but they were long enough to convince me that I liked the characters enough to want to read their novel-length stories. Bram is confident yet gentle with James, and James is shy and tentative and lovely.
CONS:
- I wasn’t LOST per se having not read the novels about these characters, but I was a little disoriented a time or two as to the men’s backgrounds and their history together. “Roughly Tied Together,” since it’s an excerpt from one of the novels, is particularly thin on context (as is to be expected, I know).
- Both stories contain numerous mistakes and typos that seemed to me more careless than ignorant (that is, they’re not tricky misspellings or anything; they’re just things that weren’t read over closely enough).Baumbach also doesn’t shy away from exclamation points, which I don’t have a problem with when they’re used in dialogue, but I think they make regular old sentences in the exposition sound silly: “It was exhilarating unlike anything else!”
"One Good Favor" by J.L. Langley and Dick D. - 8/10
PROS:
- Again, this is a story with an unusual and intriguing plot element. There are hints about the solution to the mystery all over the place, but they didn’t bother me at all because the plot is definitely secondary to the romance.
- The authors do a good job of depicting a believable western world that’s still fairytaleish and at times, really funny: the main character is a rodeo cowboy, and he faces his share of sobering, realistic homophobic characters. But there’s also a scene in a gay honky tonk where he goes into the back room with a guy and notices pegs on the wall for all the cowboys who are getting busy to hang their hats on.
CONS:
- The ending is rushed: there’s a short little climactic scene with the baddies, and once they leave, we get a page and a half of resolution and then 2 pages of epilogue that contain little more than hurried sentences to the effect of “here’s how this worked out” and “here’s how they explained that away.”
- The story’s not very long, and there are multiple instances of needless repetition. There are even a couple of lines of dialogue that the characters repeat almost verbatim in different places in the story.
Overall comments: I think this is one of the best anthology purchases I’ve ever made: I liked every one of the stories, and usually there’s at least one that’s only so-so for me. All 5 of the stories here have fairly graphic sex and are supremely romantic. A couple of them also have rather interesting plots, especially for how short they are. If you’re looking for stories light on angst and heavy on sweetness, I definitely recommend this one.